Тёмный
No video :(

Should an author’s dying wish be honored? 

Drawn to Books
Подписаться 19 тыс.
Просмотров 931 тыс.
50% 1

Terry Pratchett ordered his unfinished novels to be steamrolled when he died. But historically, many authors' death wishes have not been honored. Luckily, in this case, Pratchett's writing assistant carried out the order to a T. Guess we won't be seeing another Discworld book after all. His daughter has even said she won't create any more Discworld books, as it was her Dad's world, not hers.

Опубликовано:

 

5 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,7 тыс.   
@LostElephantInc
@LostElephantInc 2 месяца назад
My dumb ass was wondering how steamrolling notebooks and paper would destroy them, right up to the end😂😂😅
@jackwriter1908
@jackwriter1908 2 месяца назад
Yes! I first thought she was going to say something like _and after they steamrolled them they send it to a publisher and the first book will come out next june, or something like that_ 😂
@mischaminxx
@mischaminxx 2 месяца назад
​@@jackwriter1908 ngl I too thought that was exactly what she was going to say. Glad that's not the case tho.
@wolfishpotato6978
@wolfishpotato6978 2 месяца назад
Same XD
@courtney-ray
@courtney-ray 2 месяца назад
I’m glad I’m not the only one! 😂
@ToudaHell
@ToudaHell 2 месяца назад
Me too. Luddites united
@lukatv9861
@lukatv9861 2 месяца назад
Also, Nabokov said to NOT put a girl on the cover of Lolita. Look up the book . what's on the cover? A young girl. The two prints we have in my family have one with heart shaped glasses and looking over them, the other with a lollipop.
@once.upon.a.time.
@once.upon.a.time. 2 месяца назад
When I wanted to buy the book I specifically found a copy without the sexualized cover, it's so sickening 😒
@tinyfrog881
@tinyfrog881 2 месяца назад
Yep. "I want pure colors, melting clouds, accurately drawn details, a sunburst above a receding road with the light reflected in furrows and ruts, after rain. And no girls."
@AnimatedTerror
@AnimatedTerror 2 месяца назад
I recall man carrying thing did a video on this and how his favorite cover was the one with a regular creepy looking dude on the front. And it works way better for the book.
@cabbage-soup
@cabbage-soup 2 месяца назад
haha yeah and it's all bc of the stanley kubrick movie adaptation. fuck him lol
@MrSmithers
@MrSmithers 2 месяца назад
As it turns out that wasn't out of a wish not to sexualise Dolores or whatever girl may be in the picture but rather because at the time that lolita was published pictures on novels had a negative connotation of being lower quality fiction like pulp detective novels, and Nabokov wanted people to respect Lolita as literature. During his later life he was perfectly fine with the pictures on the covers, in fact there's a video i saw a while back where he talks about how much he likes one particular cover that features a picture of a young girl.
@hamsterdoom360
@hamsterdoom360 2 месяца назад
I learned two things. 1. Terry Pratchett is dead. 😢 2. Terry Pratchett's assistant is a real one. 😎
@azraphon
@azraphon Месяц назад
Rob actually is a super real one. Their relationship was extremely touching and he’s basically family to the Pratchetts to this day.
@FoxDragon
@FoxDragon Месяц назад
Wow, sorry you learned about it this way. He passed in 2015.
@votch2798
@votch2798 Месяц назад
⁠bummer. Just got into Discworld books earlier this year
@johnl6176
@johnl6176 Месяц назад
@@votch2798 Jealous.
@Psylaine64
@Psylaine64 Месяц назад
@@votch2798 its fine you still have plenty of reading material for a while yet
@raidenvakarian9362
@raidenvakarian9362 2 месяца назад
As an author myself, I 100% get why he wanted this. Books are often garbage until they're way in the deep stages of editing, so if you saw his unedited manuscripts, they'd probably be terrible - not at all something he'd want anyone to see. And if someone else was to edit them into a presentable form without his input, then they'd no longer be his.
@ibraheemshuaib8954
@ibraheemshuaib8954 2 месяца назад
Kafka made work about being a better person both mentally and physically, but his unfinished work was written with the interpretation of his sister which made him seem like a literal Nazi, and the Nazis then read the rewritten unfinished work and loved it
@martlettoo
@martlettoo 2 месяца назад
Yeah, same. I might burn the first draft of my first novel because it is EMBARASSING
@runic_raptor
@runic_raptor 2 месяца назад
Yeah, especially the editing thing. Personally, I'd be fine with my unfinished nonsense to be published, but as soon as you start making changes, don't even bother crediting me except as the inspiration. If I can't have my fucked up little world as it is, then go make your own.
@jackiew6598
@jackiew6598 2 месяца назад
@@ibraheemshuaib8954 You must be thinking of Nietzsche.
@ibraheemshuaib8954
@ibraheemshuaib8954 2 месяца назад
@@jackiew6598 I think I am, Probably.
@vevaren8155
@vevaren8155 2 месяца назад
As much as i would have killed to read those last 10 books, it makes me happy to no end to know that his writing assistant was so respectful. A Blink Of The Screen will have to do~
@MercenaryPen
@MercenaryPen 2 месяца назад
There's also "A stroke of the pen" which collects a bunch of short stories believed to be his but published under pseudonyms before he made a name for himself
@gruby970
@gruby970 2 месяца назад
Quality of discworld books deteriorated rapidly in the end. No subtleties, on the nose preaching. Unseen Academicals was borderline trash to the point i didnt bother to buy the railway one that i dgaf to remember the title of. We're better off without those books imo.
@billmilligan7272
@billmilligan7272 2 месяца назад
​@@gruby970You didn't miss anything. The railway one read like really bad fanfic. But the one that came after it, Shepherd's Crown, was actually pretty good, and was a fitting end to it all. It was far from great, but worth reading.
@catwiesel_81
@catwiesel_81 2 месяца назад
there were no books. its an illusion. its only a book once the author publishes it. and lets assume someone takes the notes and makes a book out of it, its not the book you wanted.
@samhartley6154
@samhartley6154 2 месяца назад
@@gruby970 Unseen Academicals is alright, certainly not the pinnacle of his form but I'd honestly put it above one or two of his earlier works (The Last Hero in mind). Snuff & Raising Steam? Those are *rough*, you can clearly tell where several characters are merging into one as Sir Terry simply forgets who does what and the rules for each of them. Vetinari in particular becomes someone else entirely in the final book as Pratchett simply forgets how to write him - it hurts too much to read knowing how much Pratchett fought for his own mind in his latter days. What a marvel of an author he was.
@eat00002
@eat00002 3 месяца назад
Good, rest in peace and atleast someone respected the _last fucking wish of the author_
@mesmichael
@mesmichael 2 месяца назад
I don't actually expect a good answer but, Why? Even using theology I cant come to a path that makes you controlling anything after your dead valid, other then X person is pharaoh and thus a god, so you cant have it, but dead religions are dead so... I really don't get it. I get why HE would want it, pride, vanity, shame, whatever. But why he wishes SHOULD actually be respected? IDK...
@alexisloveschocolate
@alexisloveschocolate 2 месяца назад
@@mesmichael Why shouldn't they? The works were unfinished and the person whose name they would be published under had expressed clearly that he would not want the works to go to publishing as they were. I don't think its always a moral imperative to honor the wishes of the dead but these were people close to him and he asked them for a favor regarding his personal work and clearly they felt that it was honoring their own relationships with him to follow those wishes.
@DukeBarclay
@DukeBarclay 2 месяца назад
​@@mesmichaelWe respect the wishes of the dead for the sake living. You're still alive when you make those requests, and knowing your wishes will be honored can provide comfort. I ask you to destroy my hard drive when I die. If I don't trust you'll do that, it will cause me distress right now while I'm still alive.
@riverpubby
@riverpubby 2 месяца назад
⁠@@mesmichaelbecause terry pratchett was a fucking incredible human being, and he deserves to be respected in death as such. And as the person above me mentioned, his unfinished works were unfinished - if they were in a state he wanted them to be seen in he would have published them himself. Why would you want anything other than an author’s best work that they were proud of and wanted to share?
@am_Nein
@am_Nein 2 месяца назад
​@@mesmichael because it's rude not to honour a dead persons wishes, given that it doesn't involve harming others.
@887frodo
@887frodo 3 месяца назад
This is a very polarizing issue. This year alone, we had “En Agosto Nos Vemos”-the final book Marquez wrote, now published posthumously. A project even Rushdie expressed concerns about because Marquez himself did not wanted for it to see the light of day. On account of his own sons, during the final years of his life, Marquez mental state had deteriorated so badly, he would read a book, praise its writing and claim he wanted to write something like it, only to reach the end and see his own picture on the sleeve. At which point he would get happy and confused and start the book again to see what he had written. Rinse and repeat… Yet the book was published unfinished with the go-ahead from Marquez’ editor.
@DrawntoBooks
@DrawntoBooks 3 месяца назад
It happens way too much. It sucks because you know if the author had a chance to finish it it would be a masterpiece, instead they are choosing to publish rough drafts.
@oz_jones
@oz_jones 2 месяца назад
That sounds like a scene from Hundred Years of Solitide
@887frodo
@887frodo 2 месяца назад
@@oz_jones it does, doesn’t it!? Much like Aurelio’s father, I like to think that Marquez once just ventured his feeble mind too far into one of his own books and couldn’t find his way back home.
@simonvelar
@simonvelar 2 месяца назад
Well, who knows, it says till august, and might magically vanish in September, like the cheating woman it's about 😮
@somewhatpixels6814
@somewhatpixels6814 2 месяца назад
do you mean by account of his sons? on account sounds like they've done something to him
@starseeker1334
@starseeker1334 2 месяца назад
Publishing letters someone asked to be private is fucking vile Edit: thanks for 4k likes, i saw a big debate below
@adorabell4253
@adorabell4253 2 месяца назад
On thé one hand yes. On thé other have you read Joyce’s letters to his wife? I just wish we had her replies.
@SwampyBoy476
@SwampyBoy476 2 месяца назад
@@adorabell4253that doesn’t make it any less bad
@Sepi-chu_loves_moths
@Sepi-chu_loves_moths 2 месяца назад
To anyone who's going to say they're already dead: true, but their friends and family might not be
@Sepi-chu_loves_moths
@Sepi-chu_loves_moths 2 месяца назад
​@@SwampyBoy476also haiiii rain world person :D
@SwampyBoy476
@SwampyBoy476 2 месяца назад
@@Sepi-chu_loves_moths hi cherry
@ldystardust
@ldystardust 2 месяца назад
Victor Hugo specified that his poetry should never be made into songs, but never imagined nobody would turn not one but two of his *novels* into musicals (les miserables and the hunchback of Notre Dame)
@ohauss
@ohauss 2 месяца назад
Well, the Hunchback didn't precisely turn his novel into a musical, it used the characters and a handful of selected plotpoints to turn it into something that had little to do with Hugo's actual narrative, let alone the point he was making...
@ldystardust
@ldystardust 2 месяца назад
@@ohauss true, which might have made him even more disappointed if he'd lived to see it 😁
@satsujin-shathewitchkingof6185
@satsujin-shathewitchkingof6185 2 месяца назад
Sounds like a loophole to me. Kinda based,honestly
@BeckyRRR
@BeckyRRR 2 месяца назад
He did write songs into Les Miserables, one or two
@LordVader1094
@LordVader1094 2 месяца назад
@@ohauss Which is likely why he didn't want them to be made into musicals.
@victoriadiesattheend.8478
@victoriadiesattheend.8478 3 месяца назад
Fans who had read Sir Terry's books for the last 20 years could see from "Unseen Academicals" and onward that his dementia was finally affecting his writing. He was no longer what he had been, and he had the same feelings about that that I do....which is he never wanted to be remembered that way. I don't think the last five novels he wrote would have been publishable without the help of Rhianna, his daughter and his assistant. Honoring his wishes showed how much they truly loved him by doing what he wanted, but it was also protecting what Sir Terry had created. Why put out lesser quality work that he had created while he was suffering from an illness that cruelly took from him the greatest gift he had, his mind & writing ability? Why hurt the Discworld for others and harm what Sir Terry in his right mind created with such love and care? In this case, it was the right thing to do.
@roboticzamat
@roboticzamat 2 месяца назад
Thank you writing this. I 100000000% love that you've spoken my mind.
@maxximumb
@maxximumb 2 месяца назад
I agree. For me it was Making Money where I felt the change in his work. I don't know if this is because of the illness or he had help with the writing process but it was the first of his books I could put down and not pick up again for long periods of time. I also wonder how much help he had to finish Raising Steam. I started to read the novel but it seemed like such a different voice I had to abandon it. I'm was torn about reading The Shepard's Crown. I love the Tiffany books and where it ended with I Shall Wear Midnight would be fine. But I have to know what happens to Tiff. From what I have read of the Shepard's Crown so far still feels like Sir Terry's voice. I don't want to spoil the book for anyone but I had to take a break from reading it as chapter four hits very hard. I do wonder if the Tiffany books were written earlier and the publications delayed by the publishers. As they don't seem to have suffered the same fate as Making Money, UA, Snuff and Raising Steam. I miss Sir Terry's writing and I can't believe he's been gone almost ten years now. I think I will go and reread Interesting Times or Thief of Time, two of my favourites.
@SatanRomps
@SatanRomps 2 месяца назад
I'm just here in the corner, liking his last few books just as much as the first few. 😭😭😭
@bisma1352
@bisma1352 2 месяца назад
This makes me wonder if this distespect of last wishes makes it difficult for other authors suffering from mental deterioration from indulging in their hobby of writing FOR THEMSELVES. Like publishing and having an audience isn't all writings about it's also creative expression. Making someone already struggling with illness and end of life that someone will air their creative outlet to criticisms of the world is soooo cruel.
@amoose8439
@amoose8439 2 месяца назад
I enjoyed Unseen but 100% agree with what youre saying.
@caleightilson8030
@caleightilson8030 2 месяца назад
An artist i followed died several years back and a journal company took her art and put out journals with her art on the covers and insisted that it was ok because that had started talking to her about it before her sudden death. There was a screen shot of text messages that showed they were contacting her about it, but there was no confirmation from her that she wanted to participate at all. I pissed me off so muc, because it wasnt even a week after shed died
@samevans1289
@samevans1289 Месяц назад
Is it Qinni? Edit: wrote the name wrong
@grobble_
@grobble_ Месяц назад
qinni art... i think about her all the time. it's so sad. she made such beautiful art and she was taken from the world way too soon. what that company did was pure evil. may she rest in peace
@rabbitguts2518
@rabbitguts2518 Месяц назад
It was also stolen and sold as NFTs and the crypto bros just say it was alright because she was dead so it was somehow fair game and public property 🤢 like no the rights still belongs to her family and even without that's shits gross and legally and ethically wrong
@BinturongGirl
@BinturongGirl Месяц назад
It hurts my heart to know those stories will remain unfinished, because I feel such a connection to his characters. They lived, independently. They didn't die when he did, but they are now in limbo forever, their lives frozen, their plots unresolved, unable to rest, and that makes me very sad. But it was absolutely the right thing to do to honour his wishes, and not allow anything he didn't approve to be published. We were so lucky to have him, and his work. We will always want more, but it's not our right to take it. We must be grateful for what was given, and say goodbye with respect.
@BaronSengir1008
@BaronSengir1008 Месяц назад
If you haven't already, read the last Discworld book, The Shepherd's Crown... It's probably the best way the series could have ended...
@crd2815
@crd2815 2 месяца назад
It is honestly infuriating that people will disregard the last wishes of the dead because they want to make money off them.
@GaioSonase
@GaioSonase 2 месяца назад
Honestly, I think it;s not very good to honour these kind of wishes though. It's part of the world's heritage. Those novels ought to have been saved and properly archived.
@Lleanlleawrg
@Lleanlleawrg 2 месяца назад
​@@GaioSonase im glad he got his wish, and i'm a discworld fan.
@angreagach
@angreagach 2 месяца назад
If Chopin's last wishes were honored, we'd have been deprived of some lovely pieces (the Fantaisie Impromptu, for example).
@Lleanlleawrg
@Lleanlleawrg 2 месяца назад
@@angreagach ...and? We would be unaware and it would be fine. Anything can be of artistic or historical value to someone. Does that mean when we die, everything we leave behind ought to be made publicly accessible - no matter how little the person who made it wished it'd be made public? If you think so - do you think we should start while they're alive? Because suppose he wrote some more great music he burned while alive - was that an equally awful thing? If so, we should mandate everyone archive their entire life for the public and make it instantly accessible to everyone. Yes, im taking it to an extreme, but its because i think its effective to examine edge cases in discussions about principles.
@GaioSonase
@GaioSonase 2 месяца назад
@@Lleanlleawrg what a person does while alive is their own matter, as much of a shame as it may be. Once the person is dead, they cease to exist and frankly so do any of their wishes.
@user-ko8qx3db5g
@user-ko8qx3db5g 3 месяца назад
Virgil ordered the Aeneid be destroyed from his deathbed, but upon his death Augustus Caesar overruled him.
@einplaysbad
@einplaysbad 3 месяца назад
I WAS JUST ABOUT TO COMMENT THIS LOL
@adrasthe314
@adrasthe314 2 месяца назад
Oh oops I commented the same before seeing this 😂😂😂
@Kfroguar
@Kfroguar 2 месяца назад
The man wanted the propaganda he'd paid for, can't really blame him for that.
@alltradesjack502
@alltradesjack502 2 месяца назад
Look at y'all, using your classics education for good
@afrophoenix3111
@afrophoenix3111 2 месяца назад
Imperial Domain
@theforestofoak
@theforestofoak 2 месяца назад
and his one of his other dying wishes, that Good Omens gets an adaptation, came true too
@torbjornlekberg7756
@torbjornlekberg7756 2 месяца назад
While Neil Gaimans writing never really spoke to me, as a fellow human being he have earned my respect.
@LorenScott-ub2qb
@LorenScott-ub2qb 2 месяца назад
A wish that he directly gave to neil gaiman no less.
@theforestofoak
@theforestofoak 2 месяца назад
@@LorenScott-ub2qb and which Neil Gaiman made sure he carried out
@3choblast3r4
@3choblast3r4 2 месяца назад
I wish Neil didn't completely ruin the show in its second season. It was fantastic. Until they had to "push the message" and suddenly the main characters are romantically involved and every other character is an acronym gang member
@theforestofoak
@theforestofoak 2 месяца назад
@@3choblast3r4 ooh someone's a little mad that the book had romantic tension but the first season downplayed it and you were okay with that because you could ignore it but then they address it and suddenly everything's gay? boohoo
@stevenhedge2850
@stevenhedge2850 2 месяца назад
It helps that sir terrys executor was his daughter rhianna who had a good relationship with her father and cares about his legacy so shewould follow through with it
@CrocvsGator
@CrocvsGator Месяц назад
And also because BBC decided to just undermine the show he'd been working on and sell the rights to BBC america.
@triplestaff
@triplestaff 2 месяца назад
The only writings published posthumously I support is J.R.R Tolkien's, since it was done by his son Christopher, who's a major reason J.R.R came up with middle earth in the first place, and who knew that world just as well as his dad.
@LuminousArc92
@LuminousArc92 2 месяца назад
What about Wheel of Time? Robert Jordan asked his widow Harriet to choose someone to finish it, and she selected Brandon Sanderson
@triplestaff
@triplestaff 2 месяца назад
@@LuminousArc92 did he just edit what was already written though? Cuz writing new things is something I'm more okay with oddly enough. Haven't read wot so can't speak about it more than that
@LuminousArc92
@LuminousArc92 2 месяца назад
@triplestaff unclear. Jordan had some scenes already written out (some were earlier scenes some were later scenes they werent in an order) and I think they were left in tact save for any editing, which Harriet was Jordan's editor and wife. Otherwise he'd left notes of the plot and character beats to be hit
@triplestaff
@triplestaff 2 месяца назад
@@LuminousArc92 so his actual writing wasn't really changed, which seems a lot like the J.R.R and Christopher situation, so that's fine in my opinion. As for Sandersons writing I'm assuming that's just fleshing out the already made story beats, which seems somewhat reasonable to me. Though personally I still prefer how Christopher Tolkien didn't flesh out things more than what was already written by his dad.
@stevenhedge2850
@stevenhedge2850 2 месяца назад
I don’t know I always felt Christopher was just selling out the notes to keep control of the legacy
@Ax-xo4ux
@Ax-xo4ux 3 месяца назад
Honestly- as a gigantic fan- I’m extraordinarily ecstatic that his last wish was honored.
@Finckelstein
@Finckelstein 2 месяца назад
It's bittersweet. I would LOVE more Pratchett novels. But on the other hand....I've read his later novels. They certainly show his mental decline. Which is why I think this is for the best. Not just because his wish was honoured, but also because it might've sullied his legacy.
@tinamathews3379
@tinamathews3379 2 месяца назад
As an author, I feel that their wishes should be honored.
@madmachanicest9955
@madmachanicest9955 2 месяца назад
One of the reasons he wanted his last books destroyed was that his mental health and cognitive dysfunction had been in severe decline for years. With out the help of his douther he couldn't have finish the last few discworld novels I got. So it likely there nothing but rambles on that hard drive
@ashrowan2143
@ashrowan2143 2 месяца назад
Yeah that probably played a large part in it, he was very aware that his cognitive function was in the decline and he did his best to work around that. He apparently got very involved in the modding of a specific video game(that I can't recall the name of) because the community had made mods that could remind him of things he was meant to be doing so he could continue to enjoy playing it.
@dreadlindwyrm
@dreadlindwyrm 2 месяца назад
@@ashrowan2143 Oblivion I think. One of the mod authors had created a function on their character that could be asked to lead the player out of dungeons - and maybe even to specific towns.
@jinchronic6683
@jinchronic6683 2 месяца назад
Rihanna never helped Terry write his books, it was Rob, the assistant, who typed and Philippa Dickinson, his editor and friend, who helped tie the scenes together in a sensible manner.
@catrinmelldansen
@catrinmelldansen 2 месяца назад
God bless his assistant. She was NOT stopping until those books were dust
@c.johnson8981
@c.johnson8981 2 месяца назад
His assistant, Rob Wilkins, is to the best of my knowledge a man.
@fnsmike
@fnsmike 2 месяца назад
@@c.johnson8981 They're probably thinking of Rhianna, who also had a strong hand in making sure her father's wishes were honored.
@thebeardedastronomer
@thebeardedastronomer Месяц назад
@@fnsmike I didn't know Terry was Rhianna's dad. They definitely don't look a lot alike
@steventhomas2856
@steventhomas2856 Месяц назад
​@@thebeardedastronomerDon't give up the day job. Unless the day job is "self - deluding 'comedian' ", in which case, FOR GOD'S SAKE, PLEASE GIVE UP THE DAY JOB.
@giorgospapoutsakis5271
@giorgospapoutsakis5271 10 дней назад
Sounds like book burning to me
@Feralfoundry
@Feralfoundry 2 месяца назад
Every word on that harddrive was STP's property. It was his estate. He owed us NOT ONE MORE WORD. Do i have infinate anger at the loss of him? Yes. But he published over 60 books. I know i wanted a goodbye letter. There couldn't be enough- our time with STP ended and now we students were told to leave this place and go have lives??!!! Discworld was home. It still is home. However, STP did not OWE us one more word. His life, his death, and his decisions about every aspect of his life belong to him. There's no denying the grief, but he was not selfish.
@EpicWinNoob
@EpicWinNoob 2 месяца назад
Nah I'm pretty sure "If I die destroy everything so it's not possible to innovate on my work or help my family flourish further after my death" is a pretty selfish thing to do
@Feralfoundry
@Feralfoundry 2 месяца назад
@@EpicWinNoob That's an enormous sense of entitlement you have about other people's work, their time, their estate, their legacy. He owed us NOTHING yet he gave us entire worlds. And you have the audacity to call him selfish? Are you a family member or colleague of his that feels slighted in some way?
@dylanswift5185
@dylanswift5185 2 месяца назад
@@FeralfoundryHe didn’t give, he sold. There was no charity involved
@Feralfoundry
@Feralfoundry 2 месяца назад
@@dylanswift5185 Should he have lived in a barrel and begged for the honor of having his work appropriated? You paid to be entertained by those books he wrote. If you are not entertained, move on. You paid for a story he wrote, not his body, mind or legacy. You do not own any part of his life beyond the words on those pages. Artists share moments, thoughts. Words, songs etc- they do not owe anyone their life.
@Feralfoundry
@Feralfoundry 2 месяца назад
@@dylanswift5185 Then you paid for what you got. Be content or don't, but he doesn't owe you forever and everything because you bought copies of the books he wrote.
@simonnading
@simonnading 2 месяца назад
Additionally amazing is how close this came to not being the case. The man in charge of the hard drive, Rob Wilkins, was busy talking to Neil Gaiman about the Good Omens adaptation. The steam roller was part of a fair, and had a scheduled time slot, so it was a now or never sort of moment. Wilkins admitted he was debating not going through with it, and had Neil (who was unaware of what was going on at that moment) not wrapped up the call in time, the hard drive would have likely not been destroyed. Fortunately, Mr. Gaiman spoke quickly enough, and Pterry's wishes were honored.
@Covah86
@Covah86 2 месяца назад
I guess he thought it was worth doing. All the negative comments are just proving him right. "It's not worth doing something unless someone, somewhere, would much rather you weren't doing it." - Terry Pratchett
@dylanswift5185
@dylanswift5185 2 месяца назад
Contrarianism ftw
@madsfiedler3884
@madsfiedler3884 2 месяца назад
the perks of being late to a post is that all i see are people agreeing with the decision uwu
@Dusty_B
@Dusty_B 2 месяца назад
So are you saying they shouldn’t have honored his wishes? Because that seems to fit that quote there.
@Kuchenwurst
@Kuchenwurst 2 месяца назад
@@Dusty_B I guess what OP is saying is "Sir Terry was damn right to order the posthumous destruction of the hard drives. Show them buggers who's boss."
@disgruntleddude6105
@disgruntleddude6105 2 месяца назад
He gave us a lot. We have enough. Rest In Peace Terry.
@fabulousphoenixboy
@fabulousphoenixboy 2 месяца назад
as a writer and artist, I'm horrified by the amount of commenters who feel entitled to a creator's work regardless of said creator's last wishes. I have no doubt there'll be oodles of unreleased writing & visual art left behind when I am gone. I'd be fine, happy even, for a lot of it to be shared, even unfinished, for anyone who might be interested in a closer look at my creative process. but there's also a lot of stuff that is far too personal for public consumption. and I sure as hell hope my loved ones respect me enough to honour my last wishes re. which is which.
@propagandalf123
@propagandalf123 2 месяца назад
This is my personal opinion so feel free to disagree, but I think above a certain skill level your work doesnt belong to you anymore, it becomes a treasure for all of humanity. Imagine if Da Vinci, Monet or Mozart ordered all their work to be destroyed in their last will. It would be a incredible loss to humanity. Also there are last wishes that cannot be respected, like "kill my wife if she marries again" or something alike, where the rights of others are touched, and this is exactly what I think is the work of some world class authors, poets, composers etc. Their work has inspired so many others that I think it is kind of theft to not have it publicised
@fabulousphoenixboy
@fabulousphoenixboy 2 месяца назад
@@propagandalf123 absolutely agree to disagree I'm afraid. There's a huge difference, like a wide gaping chasm, between "commit murder in my memory" and "please destroy/do not release my unpublished work after I die." besides which, who would even get to decide what this hypothetical "skill level" looks like, and where/when/according to what criteria?
@ghost656metal8
@ghost656metal8 2 месяца назад
@@fabulousphoenixboy If it was me, and know that I'm dying soon, I would just take all of my unfinished work and destroy it my self
@KasumiRINA
@KasumiRINA 2 месяца назад
I am horrified by people who would destroy Kafka's work, giving up to his depression. It's almost as if mentally insane, demented or otherwise disturbed people are literally self-destructive.
@fabulousphoenixboy
@fabulousphoenixboy 2 месяца назад
​@@KasumiRINAas a writer struggling with depression and other mental health conditions, your ableism is showing. A mentally ill artist still has legal and moral ownership of their work. If I die, my unpublished work doesn't suddenly belong to everyone & their uncle just because of my mental health struggles, jfc
@patrickkaleja9581
@patrickkaleja9581 2 месяца назад
i cryed for two days when he died. tear up right now. i love this Storys
@vinzo0913
@vinzo0913 2 месяца назад
Sir Terry was a unique case; he raised his family to be good people, and was a shining example of what a real hero is. To not honour his last wishes would have been more than just a betrayal, it would be to mock his very way of life.
@IamMeHere2See
@IamMeHere2See 2 месяца назад
I'm sad we won't get anymore Discworlds, even posthumous ones, but if that was his wish, then I'm glad it was honored.
@celticwolff5429
@celticwolff5429 2 месяца назад
In case you didn't know, Rhianna Pratchett wrote "Tiffany Aching's Guide to Being a Witch."
@joliebokeh1958
@joliebokeh1958 2 месяца назад
Exactly. Amen to this.
@Hanmacx
@Hanmacx 2 месяца назад
There was a Watch TV Series With Questionable Quality 😅
@IamMeHere2See
@IamMeHere2See 2 месяца назад
@@Hanmacx I did see it. I also kinda enjoyed it, but only by treating it as its own thing. It sadly wasn't that remarkable.
@Hanmacx
@Hanmacx 2 месяца назад
@@IamMeHere2See i would loved to have a City Watch TV series It doesn't even need to follow one of the books, it just needed to feel in the right setting But they needed to put "politics" into the show 🙄 😒
@rolebo1
@rolebo1 2 месяца назад
As a discworld fan who has read all of them, I can tell that there is a definite drop in quality in the last 3 books. The last one, the shepherds crown, even felt unfinished. If those other books got published I don't think I would even want to read them, it would spoil the memory.
@cshaffrey3438
@cshaffrey3438 2 месяца назад
His biography (which TP contributed to when he was alive, but was 90% written by his assistant) is incredibly sad. Near the end he could write good scenes, like Xs death in Shepherds Crown, but his brain couldn't hold them all in his head and join them up into a story like it used to. So his assistant ended up "suggesting" how to join scenes together etc, which made the books coherent, but it also meant they never quite felt like proper Pratchett
@adorabell4253
@adorabell4253 2 месяца назад
@@cshaffrey3438that’s probably a big reason why they followed his wishes. A lot do times things are published because they flesh out a creator’s work. Publishing disjointed scenes would just be to the detriment of the whole canon and not do anything for Pratchett’s legacy.
@Tuaron
@Tuaron 2 месяца назад
I quite liked Snuff and Raising Steam. Actually, I thought his watch books became stronger as they continued, became more sure of what they wanted to be as something unto themselves, rather than thinly veiled parody.
@kierstencarr2590
@kierstencarr2590 Месяц назад
I actually loved The Shepherd's Crown. It did feel different; it was a send-off in more ways than one. 🥲
@BooksandBuns
@BooksandBuns 3 месяца назад
It's so common to disrespect a dying person's death wish, not just among authors. A famous doctor was discovered to be a transman because his dying wish, for no one to undress him, was disrespected & he was found out to have female anatomy. It's horrible that things like that even happen
@hellobees3320
@hellobees3320 2 месяца назад
Would this be James Barry? Unfortunately, he isn't alone in this. It is often that historical trans people are only known about because their last wishes were disrespected. Often they are post-humously sensationalized and misgendered (I've especially seen a trend with historical trans men to be counted among female figures, even if said people expressed publically and privately that they were not, but this might just be on account of myself being transmasc and having biases in what I research), which is really sad to see.
@BooksandBuns
@BooksandBuns 2 месяца назад
@@hellobees3320 yes! I'm unfortunately very bad with names, but Dr Barry's story breaks my heart. I especially hate when so called 'feminists' coopt historical transmen as being 'feminist icons' or 'lesbian icons', because they can't fathom a world in which a woman might want to be a man for the sake of being a man, & not because of privilege. The fear that comes with being a closeted trans person is no privilege, & these people aren't 'feminist icons' because you never would have known that they were born female if not for the gross negligence of the coronary staff!
@uhoh6092
@uhoh6092 2 месяца назад
Hey, this is very nitpicky and I am sorry for being like this, but some people view “transman” or “transwoman” as bad to say as it sounds like you aren’t calling them a real man or woman. A lot of TERFs don’t add a space either. Many people prefer trans man cause it’s just a label to describe a man
@BooksandBuns
@BooksandBuns 2 месяца назад
@@uhoh6092 I am a transman. I won't call you that if you don't want to, but I AM a transman myself, & I don't take kindly to people constantly correcting me on my OWN IDENTITY.
@pleasesnapmyneckmommy3048
@pleasesnapmyneckmommy3048 2 месяца назад
Hey, another trans man here, @booksandbuns! I separate the two words because that's just basic grammar. You wouldn't say "bluerug". Also, considering that Dr. Barry wished to not be outed as trans, I would assume that he wouldn't take kindly to someone minimizing (in the eyes of many, including me) his identity as a man by tacking on "trans" all the time. Trans is an adjective, a word to describe something. In the phrase trans man, the adjective "trans" is describing a characteristic of the noun "man"
@dragonsflame3777
@dragonsflame3777 2 месяца назад
Fun fact. Virgil, writer of the Aeneid, one of the more famous classical written works from the Roman period demanded on his deathbed that the Aeneid be destroyed and never published, before dying of sunstroke. Instead, Augustus had it published by imperial decree
@professorhaystacks6606
@professorhaystacks6606 Месяц назад
And the world would be a poorer place without it. This is why I am so torn on this. On the one hand, you'd like to respect the author's wishes (at least immediately on death... I'm ignoring here works passed into the public domain), but on the other hand, the work could enrich the corpus. TBF in Virgil's case didn't Augustus technically own the work under the law of the time, since he commissioned it?
@generalgrievous2202
@generalgrievous2202 Месяц назад
​@@professorhaystacks6606same thing with Kafka, he wanted everything he had done to be hidden. That wasnt obeyed, and the world is better for it.
@lithiumeater100
@lithiumeater100 Месяц назад
The Aeneid is a poem not a novel
@jeffreygao3956
@jeffreygao3956 Месяц назад
@@generalgrievous2202 Really? Kafka comedy is so insensitive and unfunny. His papers SHOULD’VE NEVER BEEN published!
@gwincondon
@gwincondon 3 месяца назад
The love of money is the root of all disrespectful posthumous publications
@SomebodyPerfectly
@SomebodyPerfectly 3 месяца назад
Probably true in more than 90% of cases. But I think sometimes the work living on is more important than the sentiment of a dead author, or the greed of the bereaved. For example....I don't think that Anne Frank would have ever shared her diary had she survived Auschwitz
@Pumpkinshire
@Pumpkinshire 2 месяца назад
And it’s the root of evil to don’t forget that
@riverpubby
@riverpubby 2 месяца назад
@@SomebodyPerfectlyto be fair, most people wouldn’t want their diaries shared. She had so much personal stuff in there. Imagine if she had been alive when it was shared, she would have been so upset.
@balladsnowfox7714
@balladsnowfox7714 2 месяца назад
Kafka was a bit of an edge case since he did have a ridiculous amount of anxiety and depressive signs in both how he lived, how he viewed his own work and the work itself So his was less a moment thing more he thought they were awful buy they really weren't
@oz_jones
@oz_jones 2 месяца назад
​@balladsnowfox7714 irrelevant
@piperbird7193
@piperbird7193 2 месяца назад
I am a huge Pratchett fan and would have loved to had dozens more stories. But I'm glad these were never published. Terry was fading. His last couple of books didn't feel the same, the characters acted so differently. It breaks my heart we'll never see young Sam or Tiffany grow up, we'll never see how Ankh Morpork grows and changes, never see the Feegles steal something again. But I'd rather them all be frozen in amber then know what might have been on those hard drives.
@OptimusPhillip
@OptimusPhillip 3 месяца назад
As a hobbyist writer, I can't imagine asking anyone to ever destroy something I've created, unfinished or otherwise. But I guess that's why these guys are the pros and not me
@lexibeard4404
@lexibeard4404 3 месяца назад
Remember these things are also there jobs, if they are published after their death they aren't gonna be getting any money at all nor it will likely go to any family they want it to go too
@887frodo
@887frodo 3 месяца назад
@@lexibeard4404it’s not the money-it’s the lack of creative control. An edited manuscript can be drastically different from a work in progress or a first draft. If you fear dying before you see the whole project through, you are gonna be vulnerable to staining your legacy with shoddy final books you never truly “wrote”, at least not to completion. Everyone likes the sausage, but not everyone understands the messy process behind it and these final books usually have a lot of pig’s blood so to speak.
@DreamStudio10
@DreamStudio10 2 месяца назад
​@@887frodopig's blood?
@AramatiPaz
@AramatiPaz 2 месяца назад
Yeah, I remember many cases of the family deleting fanfics when the author died. It make me so sad. I have wrote in some places I don't want anything erasured.
@thaddeuscramer2312
@thaddeuscramer2312 2 месяца назад
Honestly, I’m a writer too, and my hope is to find someone I trust to understand my visions and ask them to complete any of my unfinished work if I pass. Hopefully I’d have some knowledge I was dying so I could outline everything beforehand so it could be as close to what I would have written as possible. I get why other writers would feel differently, but I couldn’t bear for my work to die with me like that!
@miragedown
@miragedown 2 месяца назад
Terry Pratchett was respected by a lot of people in his passing. That's how good omens came to be.
@gracelynroberts-cn2hu
@gracelynroberts-cn2hu 2 месяца назад
I’m just hung up on “notecard jambalaya.”
@mapletoplibrary
@mapletoplibrary 2 месяца назад
The Shepherd’s Crown (his last book to be published) was very appropriately his last. GNU sir Terry.
@JmonsterNEO
@JmonsterNEO 2 месяца назад
I’m just happy that he managed to finish the Tiffany Aching series before he passed.
@quid435
@quid435 2 месяца назад
Bro someone's art is as personal as their search history lmaooooo
@AdrianColley
@AdrianColley 2 месяца назад
Oh boy we're going to see JK Rowling's search history after she shuffles off the mortal coil, aren't we?
@justaurora01
@justaurora01 2 месяца назад
​@AdrianColley hopefully not.
@Rainears129
@Rainears129 Месяц назад
I'm pretty sure for most people, their search history and their art are very closely linked.
@nishthagupta1357
@nishthagupta1357 2 месяца назад
Finally a loyal assistant 😂❤
@josephshriner2850
@josephshriner2850 2 месяца назад
I had the pleasure of meeting Mr. Pratchett at a signing. Good on the assistant following through. He was a pleasure to meet.
@miguelangelcote9168
@miguelangelcote9168 2 месяца назад
There's a great book by novelist Milan Kundera (himself a brilliant novelist) called the betrayed testaments that deals with the topic of artist of different fields who's last wishes were ignored, not only in regards to their unpublished work but even their final resting places
@wipe3100
@wipe3100 Месяц назад
Last wishes should be honored, whoever made them. You should always chose to side with those who can't defend themselves.
@FreyasArts
@FreyasArts 2 месяца назад
I'm glad they respected Terry's wishes. Writing can be an incredibly personal thing, where you pour your soul into it and maybe some feelings and thoughts that you were not yet ready to share with the world. So i find it really disrespectful when they posthumously publish writing the author wasn't ready for yet and that went against their wishes.
@adhominid3269
@adhominid3269 2 месяца назад
Sir Terry Pratchett is the only celebrity who's death made me cry. I miss that man an awful lot.
@michaelshigetani433
@michaelshigetani433 Месяц назад
I still can't read Shepards Crown. I've opened it, read the dedication, cried and ugh.
@jjOnceAgain
@jjOnceAgain 2 месяца назад
If an author asks for his work to be destroyed in writing, any publishing of said work should be considered as breaking copyright law
@AdrianColley
@AdrianColley 2 месяца назад
That's an astonishingly good point.
@irrelevantcheese8623
@irrelevantcheese8623 2 месяца назад
That’s not how copyright works
@jjOnceAgain
@jjOnceAgain 2 месяца назад
@@irrelevantcheese8623 I know, that's why I used the word "Should"
@dingesskahn
@dingesskahn Месяц назад
The world needs Terry Pratchett more than ever right now
@jessematthews8084
@jessematthews8084 2 месяца назад
Kudos to all those that followed his last wishes, RIP Mr. Pratchett
@comettamer
@comettamer 2 месяца назад
Good. They actually figured out how to honor his wish even the main attempt didn't quite go to plan.
@RamDragon32
@RamDragon32 2 месяца назад
I'm actually glad. I loved the Discworld series, and I have read everything he wrote or helped write, and while I do listen to them on audibles now, I can say I read them and mean it. The Shepherd's Crown was a perfect endcap to Discworld.
@Alverant
@Alverant 2 месяца назад
As much as I may want to read the next Discworld book, no matter what shape it's in. I respect Pratchett more.
@brianvalenti1207
@brianvalenti1207 2 месяца назад
I completely agree.
@Fr.O.G.
@Fr.O.G. 2 месяца назад
Even when the author is alive their wishes aren't honored. Look at Harper Lee.
@RowieSundog
@RowieSundog Месяц назад
I'm glad Pratchett's wishes were respected. I absolutely love his work but the amount of love and respect he has for his characters and the real communities they often represent showed him to be a deeply caring person, and the same respect being afforded to his wishes is very fitting.
@ender691
@ender691 2 месяца назад
idk why it surprised me that it was a hard drive they steamrolled. he died pretty recently, well into the era of writing shit digitally.
@EthanKristopherHartley
@EthanKristopherHartley 2 месяца назад
He also infamously was an early adopter of the home computing fad. I believe that he was also involved in the Discworld PC Game (the reason that I still own my 386). 😁
@Radien
@Radien Месяц назад
Well dang, if Pratchett wanted it that badly, I think it's good to respect his wishes.
@tallulahraccoon3832
@tallulahraccoon3832 2 месяца назад
I despise ppl who not only not respect the dead but also make profits off of them. I applaude Pratchetts assistant for doing the right thing. ❤ Not gonna buy the books you mentioned bc that would be disrespectful. Thank you for the info ❤
@natp8387
@natp8387 Месяц назад
Props to his assistant being thorough. That's a good man there.
@BaronSengir1008
@BaronSengir1008 Месяц назад
*Woman... It was his daughter...
@natp8387
@natp8387 Месяц назад
@@BaronSengir1008 No it wasn't, it was Rob Wilkins, his business manager and former assistant.
@daviddavid5880
@daviddavid5880 2 месяца назад
Yeah, I know he expected me to behave with a few shreds of decency and honor, but hey, there was a few bucks to be made, amiright?
@user-tc2ie3db3z
@user-tc2ie3db3z Месяц назад
That assistant is a good man and a true friend.
@averycheesypotato
@averycheesypotato 2 месяца назад
I’m so glad his final request was honoured, even if it means I don’t get to read a new DiscWorld book. Pratchett gave us so many wonderful books, it would be greedy to demand more GNU Terry Pratchett
@RamblingSailors
@RamblingSailors 23 дня назад
Pratchett had people he could trust. Well done, sir.
@mrgreatbigmoose
@mrgreatbigmoose 2 месяца назад
Kudos to those that actually honoured his wish. Terry Pratchett G.N.U.
@mistygraves6033
@mistygraves6033 Месяц назад
i’m glad they are starting to be respectful of dead authors. It’s disheartening hearing how many death wishes were disregarded 😢
@eszemaszeszed
@eszemaszeszed 2 месяца назад
publishing letters, journals and diaries is disgusting and vile.
@JuMiKu
@JuMiKu 2 месяца назад
Why? Some of the most important historical documents are personal accounts. So I guess you are judging Anne Frank's father for publishing her diary, too?
@POP-nm1ix
@POP-nm1ix 2 месяца назад
​@@JuMiKu If she had asked him or anybody else *NOT* to do it they still did, then yeah its disgusting.
@JuMiKu
@JuMiKu 2 месяца назад
@@POP-nm1ix Do you think any young teen would want the world to read her diary? Have you read that book? Additionally her dad took some things out, but that still means he read it all. Would you have wanted your father to read your most private thoughts at that age? Probably not. However, very likely, if she had survived, she would have recognized the importance of her work years later. The stupidity of destruction is that you can never change your mind and adhering to a nonsensical thought at the end of someone's life means that you think they had always been that way and would never change either.
@michaelmartin9022
@michaelmartin9022 Месяц назад
@@eszemaszeszed Eeh I dunno, depends when it turns from "embarrasing" to "history". People can take anything of mine they like 100 years after I die. Shame it's no use.
@laurap6534
@laurap6534 2 месяца назад
As a big fan, I'm also glad they are abiding by his wishes .
@themelancholyofgay3543
@themelancholyofgay3543 2 месяца назад
Hemmingway got done dirty💀💀💀
@Tallame_Longstory
@Tallame_Longstory 2 месяца назад
I would have loved to read those books, but if Terry didn't want me to, I'm okay with that
@Milkex
@Milkex 2 месяца назад
good! I wouldn't want to have it if he didn't want me to.
@dehro
@dehro 2 месяца назад
I'm both sad and glad that this is how it went down
@elliedonels6606
@elliedonels6606 2 месяца назад
Reminds me of Ralph Ellison who’s book was separated by chapter and after he died his publisher found the individual chapters and shoved them together in a semi understandable story
@unclerat2131
@unclerat2131 19 дней назад
His books always showed how to become a better person by caring more for others.
@deannaabeyta1855
@deannaabeyta1855 2 месяца назад
Why do most of these commenters think they're entilted to disrespect an artist's dying wish, the amount of ppl calling him selfish for not publishing work that he wasnt proud of is insane
@donutreactions
@donutreactions 2 месяца назад
They're right.
@christianpeterson8167
@christianpeterson8167 2 месяца назад
Cause every artist will have a negative opinion of their own work even if it’s objectively good. So what ever he had that was unpublished he may not have liked but it could have been good so wanting it destroyed anyway is ridiculous.
@thatdude9091
@thatdude9091 2 месяца назад
Why do you believe you’re obligated to his works?
@declaringpond2276
@declaringpond2276 2 месяца назад
Art itself is a being, separate from the artist. An artist asking for their art to be destroyed is like a parent asking for their child to be unalived. Just because you created it, doesn't mean you have the right to do anything with it. Yes, the artist has rights that should be respected, but so does the art.
@christianpeterson8167
@christianpeterson8167 2 месяца назад
@@declaringpond2276 exactly man couldn’t have said it better myself.
@avalonperez3806
@avalonperez3806 2 месяца назад
Honestly based, good for Prachett's editor! Respect!
@Delunkleus
@Delunkleus 2 месяца назад
There’s a lot of children in these comments that don’t understand they aren’t entitled to art. I call them children, because they all have anime profile pictures, and if they are adults, they are beyond help. I will repeat, you aren’t entitled to something the author doesn’t want you to see. They understand their work better than you ever will, and to demand posthumous publication for your own entertainment is kind of evil, no? I won’t accept the “to deny humanity of their work” argument either, because art is enjoyed individually, not collectively. You can’t expect an entire populous to enjoy or even consume the same works. Deeply unserious to hide behind ‘humanity’ when what you really mean is “I don’t like that I don’t get more books that I like.” If you’re children, please learn and grow up. If you’re adults, please read the above.
@jakedee4117
@jakedee4117 2 месяца назад
there is more to this than just art. People are entitled to examine the historical record. Once a person is dead they are part of history that also includes their artistic and personal records.
@dhp6687
@dhp6687 2 месяца назад
You are part of the new trend where you sanctimoniously yammer on and whine about things in an echo chamber with people who agree with you and act like you’re God’s gift to the world for enlightening us with the correct view of everything. “I will repeat” you must’ve thought that sounded badass instead of the pathetic one-liner attempt it comes off as. Anyway I’m devastated to have lost the approval of “Delunkleus”, the arbiter of maturity. What will I ever do?
@bestaround3323
@bestaround3323 2 месяца назад
I mean we don't know which works of art will be needed in the future, so it is best to preserve as many of them as we can the best we can. I definitely don't think the unfinished works should be repackaged and soild for a profit.
@thomasgilbert2266
@thomasgilbert2266 2 месяца назад
Wow someone is unnecessarily angry, listen friend, you may think you have a point, you may even think your rant, cause that’s all this really is, is supposed to what? Be this profound bit of wisdom? No no it’s just you being mean and stupid, good day…
@TheDneaves
@TheDneaves 2 месяца назад
Anime is actually more for adults than children, there's nothing wrong with an adult using it for a picture. Maybe you should just shut up and get over yourself.
@kassassin_brahgawk
@kassassin_brahgawk 2 месяца назад
I adore Pratchett's stories and who he was as a person. I'm happy I got to exist on this planet with the Disc world.
@ShrekGrunge
@ShrekGrunge 2 месяца назад
Im still upset about Sylvia Plaths husband burning her last novel after her death
@justaurora01
@justaurora01 2 месяца назад
Why does it upset you ? (Gen question)
@ladykoiwolfe
@ladykoiwolfe 2 месяца назад
I was fairly sure I remembered hearing they had done this as he requested. And I'm good. When Esme died, I grieved for him as much as for Granny. It felt like he was saying goodbye to us. Maybe I'm wrong, but that's how it felt to me.
@biggestfanof300
@biggestfanof300 2 месяца назад
Don't forget the black paintings, not written work, but still relevant. I love the pieces, especially the devouring of the son; however, I do feel that high wishes should have been honored. Not only were they not meant to be seen, they were the visual representations of a man literally losing his mind. I think he was robbed of some of his final dignity in not having his wishes honored, and to have the unfortunate ending of his life on display. I feel similarly when people unearth old burials; I love history, and it's always fascinating to learn new things from a discovery. However, it severely desecrates the burial practices and beliefs of the fallen; especially if burial/afterlife is an important part of the culture, and/or the death in particular was of particular note.
@justaurora01
@justaurora01 2 месяца назад
Real, The archeologists are all yay look what I found by disturbing this persons resting place until they unearth something they shouldn't have.
@generalgrievous2202
@generalgrievous2202 Месяц назад
​@@justaurora01the curse of ra
@kunaiflicker
@kunaiflicker 2 месяца назад
I love that they respected his wishes
@GardensAndGames
@GardensAndGames 2 месяца назад
Yeah, Pratchett's assistant really seemed like a partner for him. I'm not surprised he followed through.
@LovleyLemonade
@LovleyLemonade 2 месяца назад
It seems like the way to go is for the author to do it themselves or supervise people they hire to do it.
@lonelygovernment4544
@lonelygovernment4544 2 месяца назад
I read "der proceß" by kafka in school which was published after his death. He had finished it but not reworked it and my goodness was it horrible to read and analyse. The next thing we read was "Woyzeck". That one wasn't even done when the author died and they still published the fragments. The scenes didn't even have a specific order so they had to kinda guess and it was pretty much as horrible as "der Proceß". Don't publish dead author's books if it goes against their wishes but if you do that at least don't make us analyse it when half of it is missing Thank you
@JoeEnigma
@JoeEnigma 2 месяца назад
I cried when Terry died, and I still cry sometimes when I think about it.
@Mambo1061
@Mambo1061 2 месяца назад
I hope there’s a website with a list of books published posthumously and nonconsensually so people can know to avoid reading them, like avoiding leaked nudes
@dylanswift5185
@dylanswift5185 2 месяца назад
A significant amounts of influential mathematics and philosophy. That’s a good start
@RuthvenMurgatroyd
@RuthvenMurgatroyd 2 месяца назад
Yeah, I'm still reading the Aenied. Sorry, Virgil 🤷‍♂️
@jakariashafin8685
@jakariashafin8685 Месяц назад
@@dylanswift5185 math and science is one thing but why entertainment it gives us nothing truly beneficial for progress why defile someone's corpse for a few hours of joy
@jakariashafin8685
@jakariashafin8685 Месяц назад
@@dylanswift5185 math and science is one thing but why entertainment it gives us nothing truly beneficial for progress why defile someone's corpse for a few hours of joy
@generalgrievous2202
@generalgrievous2202 Месяц назад
Why would you want to boycott Kafka
@Jihino
@Jihino Месяц назад
The stories of the Discworld. such a amazing ride to have exeperinced
@elberethreviewer5558
@elberethreviewer5558 3 месяца назад
I don't know why artists do that. Maybe they don't want their work turned into something it's not, maybe they don't want others to make money off them, or maybe they have control issues. As an artist, I would like my work to go on after me. I would be honored.
@nkosig4995
@nkosig4995 3 месяца назад
He was probaly in a bad mental state when he was dying and it's very disappointing that they went through with it
@fatcat1414
@fatcat1414 3 месяца назад
One must consider that an unfinished work is exactly that: unfinished. A living author who loves and respects the craft would never publish a work before it's time, and a particularly empassioned author would not want that to happen after their death.
@BooksandBuns
@BooksandBuns 3 месяца назад
You would want your private letters to someone to get published??
@saoirse_miller
@saoirse_miller 3 месяца назад
he had alzheimer's, and his last works were affected by its progression. who would want to be remembered for what they wrote when they were dying from a terrible disease like that? not to mention, even if someone finished writing his works, it wouldn't end how he wanted. imagine dying before finishing a painting, and some person decides to finish it and it turns out completely different than what you intended? what if they entirely misinterpret your intentions and the meaning of the piece? it's the same with writing.
@dangernoodledee111
@dangernoodledee111 2 месяца назад
I think it may be because they just don't want to publish their drafts. I have plenty of first drafts that were okay, but weren’t the type of story I wanted to tell. So I had to delete some of them and go in a completely different direction. The editing stage is very important for a lot of people, and he may not want people to read what he considers "shitty wips" Heck, there are story concepts I'm really proud of, but I'd hate for people to publish my unfinished drafts.
@bunji_beans
@bunji_beans 27 дней назад
I was so sad when he passed. In recent years, I've been struggling to read books despite reading a lot in the past. Just this year I started listening to audio books from the Discworld series, some new to me and some old friends
@charliegoodwin1933
@charliegoodwin1933 2 месяца назад
They destroyed Emily Dickinson’s works after she died, and only selected a few because they didn’t like all of her work and felt it too sensual
@larastroud6644
@larastroud6644 2 месяца назад
They didn’t destroy her poems, just heavily edited them for publication. She also never consented to their publication. While it’s not clear if she asked they be destroyed (she did ask that some correspondence was and it was, but I’ve read conflicting sources on whether she also wanted the rest of her poems destroyed) it is probable she would be very unhappy by the ways her work was edited and people profited off of it.
@charliegoodwin1933
@charliegoodwin1933 2 месяца назад
@@larastroud6644 I would argue that the heavy editing is in fact, destruction of the original. But I suppose I should’ve been more clear. It is accurate that she never expressed any wish for her poems to be published, and that she would probably be pretty disappointed in what was published.
@Its.a_me_
@Its.a_me_ Месяц назад
Virgil also wanted his unfinished manuscript of The Aenied to be burned, but literally everyone even the Emperor, Emperor Augustus stepped in to make sure it didn't get destroyed
@AbstractStew
@AbstractStew 2 месяца назад
Works that are published against the dying wish of their creator are stolen. And they are lesser for it...
@catwiesel_81
@catwiesel_81 2 месяца назад
GNU Terry Pratchett Also. There never was a doubt his wishes will be followed... He was surrounded by loving family and friends and not money hungry business vultures.
@michaelshigetani433
@michaelshigetani433 Месяц назад
GNU Sir Terry Pratchett.
@chocapic2373
@chocapic2373 2 месяца назад
Super happy to see so many fellow fans agreeing with honoring sir Pratchett's last wish.
@bluedaze1191
@bluedaze1191 Месяц назад
We love you Sam!!! I'm so proud of you, I'm So sorry you've had to go through this! Me and my grandma recently celebrated her 10 year anniversary of being cancer free, I can't wait for you and your family to one day be there too! In the meantime, no rush, please be easy on yourself and your new voice :) it will take time, but you'll get there!!! It's incredible that you are already speaking and talking, and I'm sure it's very reassuring to know that your voice sounds the same, even though the words are harder and slower for you to say right now! We believe in you, and are so happy to see you again, and are also happy to patientpy wait whenever you need some more recovery time! We love you always - From your Critter Fans! P.S. If appropriate, is there a P.O. box that we can send you and your family some wonderful gifts too? Thanks! 💕
@CailinRuaAnChead
@CailinRuaAnChead 2 месяца назад
Good. I don't want them. Because they wouldn't really be his. Just based on some of his ideas.
@anthmeisterrrrr3336
@anthmeisterrrrr3336 Месяц назад
I'm holding out hope that they can still sneak the hard drive pieces on a rocket😂
@LancasterHermitCrafter
@LancasterHermitCrafter 2 месяца назад
As someone who has the whole Discworld audiobook series playing on loop every day, I'm torn: I get why sir Terry would want his unfinished works destroyed, he was a perfectionist whose manuscripts had to be pulled out of his hands to be printed, otherwise he wouldn't stop editing them, on the other hand, I'm greedy, I want more! I want to see Havelock and Margolotta share more than a pie, I want to see young Sam grow up, and Sybil as a grandmother, or even how Nobby gets on with his goblin girl... The Disc is a cruel world, but perhaps a little bit less cuel than our own. They at least have their million to one chance.
@ktg3811
@ktg3811 2 месяца назад
Greed is a sin that you must overcome
@LancasterHermitCrafter
@LancasterHermitCrafter 2 месяца назад
@@ktg3811 really, mate? Maybe you would like to check the meaning of "hyperbole". 😄 Besides, what is a sin? I know what evil is - treating people as things, for example 😉 In the eyes of Anoia not having drawers to rattle may be a sin, but Blind Io couldn't care less about your kitchen furniture. 😁
@ilkyway5854
@ilkyway5854 Месяц назад
While I am a HUGE TP fan and have read all Discworld books multiple times I am glad his assistant did as Sir Terry Pratchett asked him to do. His work, his decision .
@SteveTheNam
@SteveTheNam 2 месяца назад
I like the fact that so many people in the replies of comments are mega entitled/selfish when they said art works musnt ve destroyed even if its the creator's wish (c'mon fight me ye cowards)
@jacquelineking5783
@jacquelineking5783 2 месяца назад
I am on the fence personally. I don't think Pratchett was wrong and cool that his wishes were respected but well there is something to be said about preserving art as much as possible. Then there is the personal letters which can serve as a window to a time and place removed from the period of when someone is reading them.
@vikinggoddess2126
@vikinggoddess2126 2 месяца назад
Terry Pratchett had Alzheimer's so he wouldn't have wanted his last book published anyway. It may not have made any sense. The whole reason he "passed" is because he got to the point he couldn't write. Just like he said he would.
Далее
For YEARS She Recorded Everything on TV
0:55
Просмотров 7 млн
ПРИКОЛЫ НАД БРАТОМ #shorts
00:23
Просмотров 760 тыс.
У ГОРДЕЯ ПОЖАР в ОФИСЕ!
01:01
Просмотров 4,5 млн
The Hit Song with Pure Nonsense Lyrics
0:56
Просмотров 8 млн
No one knew this secret 😱
0:59
Просмотров 26 млн
What you didn’t know about Agatha Christie
8:09
Просмотров 1,6 тыс.
Hitchhikers Guide
0:39
Просмотров 4,1 млн
Book series that won't be finished.
0:50
Просмотров 337 тыс.
ПРИКОЛЫ НАД БРАТОМ #shorts
00:23
Просмотров 760 тыс.