SINDHI in India - Declining? or Thriving? (URDU/HINDI)

Подписаться 9 тыс.

Просмотров 39 тыс.

50% 1

The case of Sindhi Language in India is not a straighforward one. Scholars and Academics say one thing, but the numbers paint a totally different picture. So what is going on with SINDHI in India?
#sindhi #sindhihistory #indiansindhi #sindhilanguage #pakistan #india
Sindhi In Pakistan Video: • Is SINDHI thriving?
Sindhi Resource: learn.sindhila.edu.pk
Implosive Sounds: learn.sindhila.edu.pk/grammar...
Support the Channel:
/ tareekhitales
/ @tareekhitales
Research Sources:
learn.sindhila.edu.pk/grammar...
Iyengar, A., & Parchani, S. (2021). Like Community, Like Language: Seventy-Five Years of Sindhi in Post-Partition India. Journal of Sindhi Studies, 1(1), 1-32. doi.org/10.1163/26670925-bja1...
“The Acculturation of Indian Sindhi to Hindi” by Lachman
Khubchandani.
Sociolinguistic Survey of Indian Sindhi by Chander Daswani and Sundri
Parchani..
“Changes in Sindhi in the Indian Context” by Sundri Parchani.
“Sindhī Multiscriptality, Past and Present” by Arvind Iyengar.

Опубликовано:

2 июл 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 413

@deepakturakhia1954

Si dhi language is dying in India, and the reason is India's first PM Nehru. When Hindu Sindhis migrated from Pakistan in 1947 onwards, Nehru scattered them all over India and most Sindhis lost contact with one another, and that is the reason why Sindhi is dying.

@hitarthchaudhari 21 день назад

How are Marwadi, Bhojpuri, Haryanvi, and Gujarati doing in Pakistan? You guys have killed these languages out of hate and by imposing Urdu on everyone in Sindh.

@hareedoda4025

Madam. Iam sindhi hindu doctor residing in india . Shifted from pakistan 38 years back. Passed MBBS FROM CHANDKA MEDICAL COLLEGE LARKANA. SOME FACTS OF YOURS ARE NOT CORRECT. SINCE I HAVE RESIDE IN SIND AND IN INDIA I KNOW MORE ACTUAL FACTS . EVEN. MY MRS PASSED M. A. DEGREE IN SINDHI FROM. MUMBAI UNIVERSITY

@pawankumarbissa8956

Madam you did a good research, but it's not DEVAN-GARI as you said, it's DEVNAAGARI (دیوناگری).

@The_Cricket_Crazy_

I am from Deccan region aur hamare yaha ek Sindhi bazar hai and i observe one thing about them they mutually intelligible with KUTCHI and GUJARATI languages they people communicate eachother easily and all these three communities highly business minded.

@user-lv3tx8eo8b

ہندوستان میں سندھی زبان کو سرکاری قومی زبان کا درجہ حاصل ہے

@PUNSHIBAROT

I think one biggest point you missed is other tangible languages with Sindhi. Sindhi peoples mostly settled in Gujarat and Maharastra where there was already thriving Gujarati business community. So just like how Urdu speakers can understand and mostly speak Hindi, similarly Sindhi speakers would understand Kutchi, and some Gujarati. So it was natural that those Sindhis who grew up in Kutchi/Gujarati neighborhood their grammar and speaking style became more like these languages. I can say because I met few Pakistani SIndhi people, earlier I thought they were from my district in Kutch but after conversation I came to know they were Pakistani but we hardly had any problem I was speaking Kutchi and they were speaking Sindhi and yet we could understand each other.

@pravirchakravati123

In india sindhi language has constitutional protection.Thereare sindhi schools in india but now a days sindhi people used to speak sindhi among their community.Because English,Hindi and other religious languages have more importance in education and employment

@ScindianLad

Indian Sindhis are proud Sindhis and they try their best to preserve their language. The minor changes into their language was inevitable. Which is fine, as even such differences occur within different dialects of a language, Sindhi also has such differences in its dialects.

@SajidAli-uo6ne 14 дней назад

I am a govt servant from Sindh, Here not only in offices sindhi is spoken but letters applicationa are also written in sindhi whenever anyone wants to lodge complain to higher authorities. Well preserved

@AroonAkash 28 дней назад

I'm Sindhi Hindu banya, proud to be sindhi, جيئي سنڌ

@PK-se2jh

Sindh region today does not even exist in India. While Pakistan is erasing its non-muslim minorities to now 1-2%. How can a language thrive in India when entire region exist outside India. Only English is an exception.

@lish-fb4in 28 дней назад

A very well researched analysis. As a linguist learning about Sindhi Phonetics and Phonology was an amazing experience.

@ashoksmanwani 21 день назад

भारत में सिंधी भाषा को भारत सरकार ने संविधान की आठवी अनुसूची में स्थान दिया 1967 में। मान्यता प्राप्त भारतीय भाषाओं में शामिल है।

@qamarchandio377

اسان جي پنهنجي سنڌي الفابيت آھي جيڪا عربي کان ورتل آھي ۽ اھا ئي رھندي سنڌي ٻولي گھڻي وسيع ۽ آسودي زبان آھي اھا قيامت تائين قائم ۽ دائم رھندي انشااللھ

@pawankumarbissa8956

My ancestors were from Sewani Gatti (Street), Hyderabad ( Sindh) now in Pakistan.

@drwaqarahmed3708

Im sindhi person , madam you have done agreat analysis , your knowledge is super , yes nazalization was and also to some extent is the core part of language which we are losing

@abdulahadpasha5694 21 день назад

a well-spoken girl, the content and topic were interesting but the way she explained things was gradually absorbing into the mind.. which made the viewers to stay and watch the whole video. Her Urdu-lughat is perfect!!!