some of it is artificial because most of these guys likely also know hindi and bits of Sanskrit, so they are checking the new language against both Hindi and Sanskrit vocabulary in addition to their native language
@@adibhau7178u mean our dharmic granthas are wrong u mean the country mentioned as Nepal in our Hinduism is wrong why did u named your country as Hindustan If u become so greedy that u don't even acknowledge your religion and Nepal (mentioned in even Mahabharat and Gita) even other purans why are u so greedy for your land , Nepal is our country it was never indian just because of a treaty we loose land and people of north east speak Nepali language doesn't mean it is an Indian language please correct yourself to maintain peace
@@alani3992 Most of northeast cultures are certainly related. Assam and Tripura are indo-aryan. The tibetans of arunachal and the Meiteis/Manipuris are heavily influenced by indian culture. Only the Nagas, Kukis, Donyi-Polo, Garo Khasi can be considered as having relatively less Indian influence before the Republic of India.
I'm from Darjeeling which is now a part of India .I'm from Nepali speaking Indian community so I used to see so many times marathi and Gujarati people commenting why Nepali song is sounding like Marathi or Gujarati and I have to reply the history of Nepali Language. Now finally we got video for same❤
@@mamatapandey6073Hehe Nepali people of India and Nepali people of Nepal speaks different dialects of Nepali Language so both community speaks Hindi differently.In fact Nepali too have many Dialects.
Im from east maharashtra and i can understand little of bengali as we have itty-bitty population of bengali here ... and bengali language and culture is pretty similar like marathi, Gujarati , bengali people can easily vibe on durga puja ashtami 😊 in harmony 😊
This is such a good & relaxing video. But this will NOT get too many views bcoz there is Nothing sensational or Controversial in this. Nowadays unfortunately people like only stuff that is Controversial & sensational. People don't appreciate good stuff like this. Show these guys & this channel some love.
I find it fascinating and mind-blowing that the word "today" in Indian languages here is like many European languages, specifically Romance, hojê (Portuguese), oggi (Italian), heute (German), azi (Romanian)... they may seem different but by sound is very alike No wonder it is indo European language family 😀
Thanks Bahadur I'm really interested in Indo European languages so this was definitely interesting. Greetings to Indian,Nepali, Pakistani and Bangli friends from Iran 🦁👑☀️💚🤍❤️🤝🇮🇳🇵🇰🇧🇩🇳🇵
Sindhi, Bengali, Marathi and Nepali are also spoken in India as they are part of our 22 Officials Languages because we have all these communities exist in our Country. Appreciate for taking keen interest in Indo-European languages of Indian Subcontinent. Greetings to Iran from India. 😊
@@sauravkumarchand9691 Nepali is also a recognised official language in West Bengal. Offcour se the Nepali speaking people are wanting to separate, i think they can consider having the West Bengal capital shifted to Darjeeling during summer in case that brings the two communities together and helps foster better understanding and if that does not work go for a separation. I like Nepali and all other Himalayan cultures, people and environment quite a bit and I would not like a separation unless that's absolutely necessary to the hill people. Also ,if they have reservations on the type of people going into hill places through west bengal i think thats a genuine concern and they should be allowed to regulate entry of people into the hills themselves. I have faith in their goodness and I think they will be fair in their judgements. Of course there are problematic elements in every community abd I had noticed that in them too but I.also believe every community must have control over their future unless they will misuse their liberty to.start harming others
It is good to see speakers understanding each others languages in the group! 🎉 There are many similarities in languages especially Bengali and Marathi with Indo Arayan origin with Sanskrit base...😊
Good composition, I felt the marathi lines were just too long for other people. As a marathi speaker myself it could have made shorter and simpler ...still a great overall :) A suggestion would be to add word to word translation below the lines to make it more easy for viewers to understand the meaning of each word.
Hi Bahador can you do a video on the languages spoken in Pakistan such as Urdu, Pashto, Punjabi, Sindhi and Balochi and how all these languages have a lot in common. Urdu, Punjabi and Sindhi are all Indo Aryan languages whilst Pashto and Balochi are both Indo-Iranian languages. You previously did a video on Indian languages such as both Indo Aryan and Dravidian languages and compared them to one and another.
Bengali and Nepali are gender neutral that means verb not change one gender. While other Indian language are gender bias like I am drinking in bengali either male or female it will ami jol khachhi.
Not sure where is the Sindhi speaker from ? The people in Mumbai/ Ulhasnagar have a different accent and some from South Mumbai / Bandra Khar speak English. The person speaks English like people from Mumbai but Sindhi is different. Would be interested to know.
Finally , I was wondering when you'd make this video. I also liked how you chose one language for the cardinal direction it is spoken in. Nepali:north Bangla:East Sindhi:west Marathi :south* *Technically maharashtra is west, but marathi is spoken in parts of Karnataka, TN , Telangana and even kerala by descents of the Maratha empire soldiers .
@@kimayakane4523 that is what I meant in my original comment 🙄. Marathi is not a "southern" language, but in India it is the southern most spoken Sanskritic language.
Actually Bengali, Assamese, Nepali are all influenced by Magadh, so they a lot in common. Konkani is spoken in areas South, but can you guess the southernmost Aryan language in the world ?
Very interesting.... Bahadur... I would like to let you know that I would be more than happy to take part in your video that involves Tamil. Besides, I can speak Telugu, Hindi and Malayalam too
That Sindhi guy is from india, he doesn't know much of Sindhi for example the word "faqat" is not usually used by Sindhis in Sindh, only if anyone has to put more emphasis or importance on one thing. Otherwise, commonly, we use words like rugo, thalo, and sirf. Also meeh is pure Sindhi word, not Punjabi, IDK why would he say its Punjabi as Punjabis never use it.
@@tanishmandhani2601 but in Pakistani Punjab side they say barish or barsat, never meenh. And even if Punjabis use it, then the word is definitely not Punjabi, but it's rather Sindhi origin word, as Sindhi language is much much much older than Punjabi In fact, I believe Punjabi is one of the dialects of the Sindhi language.
Yes punjabi has so many words of sindhi but sindhi is older than punjabi.. when i listen to punabi i understand it not because its similar with Urdu but because of its similarities with sindhi ..
@@selfpossessed3940 you are absolutely right. Punjabi, Gujarati, and Rajasthani are all children of the Sindhi language. Sindhi is the oldest language of Pakistan for sure, Punjabi is basically a corrupted version of Sindhi and Hindi.
Second Sindhi sentence is written incorrectly. The marathi girl guessed the meaning of the sentence incorrectly and the person representing Sindhi agreed with the incorrect translation. He later goes on to speak irrelevant words. I feel totally disappointed with the way Sindhi was represented in this video.
Please make one video of nepali origin languages like Newari,Tamang,Magar,Tharu,Maithili, Sherpa,Gurung etc. If you will make this video i am sure most of Nepalese will subscribed your channel. ❤🇳🇵
There are much more similarities in Aryan Languages. Nepali, Bengali, Gujarati and to some extent Marathi, Sindhi are close to Nepali language. These languages are part of BHARAPELI Language = ( Bharati+ Europeli)- Kudos to the youngsters for this project.- Love from Nepal
Person representing Sindhi does not know any thing about Sindhi language and Sindh. There are several Sindhi sattelite channels watched by people in Sindh. He simply pronounced Sindhi sentences too poorly to be understood by non-natives.
This Nepali guy selected simple sentences. Also Marathi and Bengali were quite easy to guess as they have more Sanskrit but spoken Nepali might not be as easy. Sindhi was more similar to Urdu I guess.
Hi Bahador can you please do a video of all the languages spoken in Pakistan such as Urdu, Punjabi, Pashto, Balochi and Sindhi and how they have a lot in common since Urdu, Punjabi and Sindhi are Indo-Aryan languages and Pashto and Balochi are both Iranic languages. I think in your previous video you did a video on Indian languages such Indo Aryan and Dravidian languages and compared to one and another.
@@A30rathod Lmao you're so ignorant! Sindh literally has a official status in Pakistan since it's inception whereas in India the Sindhi community had to put in blood and sweat just for the government to recognize Sindhi and till this day Sindhi doesn't have a single Indian channel which Indian Sindhis have been demanding since ages! Not to mention the Prejudice Indians have against the Sindhi migrants telling them to go back to Pakistan
16:55 According to me, this sentence would translate into Hindi as "Bhagwaan sab ko alag (aur accha) banata hai. Dosh sirf nazaron ka hota hai." Please correct if wrong
Word to word meaning; Bagwan jo thayal har insan sunhro aahe, doh rugo nazrun jo aahe. Bhagwan ka banaya huwa har insan sundar hai, dosh sirf nazaron ka hai. God's made every human, is beautiful. It's only the fault of one's sight. The word faqat is not commonly used, its a heavy word, no one use it in Sindh. Also the sentence should have been "doh rugo nazrun jo hundo aahe" meaning dosh sirf nazaron ka hota hai.
It's actually surprising because the Sindhi guy in the video is from India. I'm from Pakistan and I've heard Sindhi spoken by Pakistani Sindhis as well as Indian Sindhis. Indian Sindhi sounds very similar to Gujarati while Pakistani Sindhi sounds more like Panjabi-Seraiki languages. But the guy in the video speaks very similar to Pakistani accent.
The accent and choice of vocabulary totally differs from region to region in India, it's difficult for me as well to understand the sindhi speakers from South or Central region.😁
As a Bangladeshi fluent in arabic, had no idea sindhi has so many arabic words in it! especially relating to religion, like insaan, ilaahi (all quranic words) i can understand a fair bit of the nepali guy, but was only got bits and pieces of marathi... surprised the bangali lady understood so much, likely from living in india with exposure to different languages also being able to read the sindhi words from arabic helped with understanding
Sindhi is also originally Indian language. Just because sindh has become part of pakistan now does not change this fact. It does not have any persian/arabic script. There r many sindhis who live in India even now. Also there is no such thing as indo-aryan or dravidian. Its just western theories with no base.
Lol yet still it took ages for Indian constitution to recognize Sindhi, not to mention the prejudice Indians have against Sindhis in India asking them to go back to Pakistan and calling them Gaddar
how come that even though they speak different languages their accent in English sounds very similar? if they all said they're Indian I'd believe them.
To an Indian one can tell when a Bengali or Marathi or a Dravidian-speaker speaks English. To others, it may be like most can't tell the difference between an Aussie & Kiwi accent.
To indians the differences are easily discernible, because we vaguely know the intonations of respective languages. But as a whole the languages themselves are pretty similar, so to an outsider the English accent might sound the same. Australian and Kiwi accents are perfect examples, as @@alani3992 mentioned
Tbh, only Bengalis and Biharis to a certain extent have a very distinct accent while speaking English, all rest of the country have an extremely similar accent while speaking English.
Yes nepali is indo aryan. But not all nepali belongs to indo aryan. Only Brahmin and chettris. Other ethnicity comes underr tibeto burman langauge. They have their own language and culture. Nepali language is just a lingua franca. So youre just representing brahmin nepali and chettris.
@@kishandubey7882 Not really chettri and bhramin combined population is about 28.6% . Out of which around 10-14% chettri or khas are native . And the remaining 72 % are non Aryan and native Nepali population. Nepali or khas bhasa is only spoken by 42-44% of Nepal's population.
@@indiafirst3676yeah it's written in Devanagari in india ( not everyone knows the persian script 😅only a few ) but in Persian-arabic script in pakistan
Nepali is mainly spoken in nepal and some parts of india like sikkim darjeeling area Bangla is widely spoken in bangladesh Sindhi is mainly spoken in sindh region of pakistan Marathi is the only language all of which native speaking regions lie in india
I am from Darjeeling and my mother language is Lepcha but I also speak in Nepali. Lepcha is an aboriginal language in the region but Government still not recognised it.
Person representing Sindhi is not a native speaker. He cannot pronounce implosive consonant /ʄ /. He replaced it in the first word in the first Sindhi sentence with the ʤ. He repeatedly spoke and gave examples from Urdu / Hindi. He does not belong to Sindh, instead he is Indian national.
you should make a video on the similarities on dakni, persian , turkish and iraqi arabic (man hidostaani hastm lakin man pasr zoban yek koyeshe az zobane farsi ast) dorood az hindostan 😄
