To keep the lid from sliding off, I'd add in a 4x2x2 mm rectangular hole/slot on the rear bottom of the lid and also print a 4x2x4 mm key (with the requisite offset subtracted in for your printer) to make a friction fit between the hole and key. The extra 2mm that sticks out of from the hole/slot once you press the key in by hand will add a nice positive stop with the option of prying the key off if you ever needed to fully remove the lid. Great video as usual!
I really appreciate how Kevin takes a simple project like this and unpacks so many valuable lessons and resources from it. Very elegant use of the parametric features and Model Parameters Dialogue. I ALWAYS learn something new and useful from watching his tutorials. Thanks Kevin!
So true. I just did something similar to this and it was a train wreck compared to how he did it. I forgot about offset and shell, and projection is more powerful than I remembered lol. What I really want to learn is to improvise how he does. I do a lot of improvisation but it leads me down these super complex paths that take hours to get where I want, where he just does something that takes a couple of seconds lol.
From all the information about Fusion 360 on the web I've seen so far, your videos are the best. Your way of teaching is calm, patient and elegant, your explanations are clear and easy to understand. I do the exercises along with the video side by side and I'm always learning something more. Congratulations! It's just an idea to prevent the lid from coming off, I put two small pins, one on each side of the front of the box to be printed separately and placed after the lid. The top of the pins can be flush with the thickness of the cover and the pins protrude about 1.0mm into the case. They were virtually invisible and prevented the cap from coming off completely more easily.
Every time I check Kevin's video, no matter how difficult it may look, I have the confidence that I will surely learn and master it. The trust and confidence I got are invaluable. Thank you.
Needed to make a dovetail for a project so came straight here to learn. Glad everything you taught me has meant I was nearly doing this one blind but there was some great refreshers in there. Thank you again for teraching me a new skill from scratch. I have ADHD that makes it hard to focus and get things to "stick" in my mind but your videos are so easy to follow. When I next get paid I promise I'll send over a few £££. Afterall this would have cost loads to learn otherwise.
I love having examples like this because I can use it to learn by, and I have a functional product when I'm done. I'd like to add a tab to snap it shut when closed. I'm going to figure out that solution next. Thanks Kevin for a great series.
So I printed this box and it worked great. I wanted a longer one and with one dimension change in the main box sketch everything was adjusted correctly!! So awesome. Great job explaining this concept.
I can't thank you enough for making this video. I had what I thought would be a simple project become instantly complicated. I don't know what I would have done if I hadn't found your video. You're the man!
Recently subbed. I have unlearned so many bad habits! I love your emphasis on best practice. You have a real knack for creating and presenting educational content. Thank you for all your work.
While it is logical, I didn’t realize that F360 allows parameter changes to the existing model parameters like you demonstrated. Thanks. I’ll definitely implement that!!!!!
Your fusion tutorials are the best! The solution I used to keep the lid from sliding off are slots for 3mm diameter 3mm thickness neodymium magnets. I find the way the components snap together to be very satisfying.
For the lid to be retained, just put a little flexible tab on the inside, rear edge of the lid. Something that can slide one way over the edge of the box but stop it going the other way. Thanks for this video!
Great video. A note on how I would suggest setting the parameters. The outside dimensions probably don't matter for this box, what matters is what needs to go inside it. So I would set the height, width, and depth parameters for the inside dimensions and use formulas with the parameters to drive the outside dimensions, including the offset. So if I know the size of the object I want to put in there I don't have to do any math to figure out what number to put in for those outside dimensions.
just a matter of creating parameters for inside dimensions and using these in the parameters for the outside dimensions. Like: Length = inside_length+wall . Fusion does the math for you.
Great stuff. I learnt how to use Fustion 360 without looking at a single tutorial because most of them were awful. But yours are amazing. And I've also learned some new stuff or things I've never thought of using before.
Very good tutorial :) *Thumbs up* from me for sure. About how to "snap" the lid, I'd embed the magnets inside the lid at the backside and inside the box back side. That way the lid will stay closed without any visible "stops".
Had to subscribe, this idea of creating and printing random stuff is great cause sometimes there is that one thing you need to find out how to do on your design and this type of tutorial might cover that one thing you need help with. Thank you!
Cool tutorial and I'm going to print a few. I changed the design a bit. Rather than a depression for the lid and raised it. In my slicer program, I cut off the raised piece and duplicated. The second one will be glued on the bottom of the lid to act as a stop. Thanks
Update on this. My idea to glue a piece to stop the lid from coming off was a fail. Couldn't figure out how to glue a tiny piece and stick into position accurately.
Great video tutorial, thank you! :) Am a total noob, I couldnt do any fancy geometry fix for the lid, so I just tighten the tolerances from 0,25mm to 0,05mm and the lid is now holding well :) Subscribing and hoping to learn more :)
Fantastic Video!! I was able to quickly design my own version with your help. I put a small ramped catch on the back of the lid that should snap in when assembled. I printed the lid face down to get a smoother texture from the Prusa print sheet. Thanks!!
What I have in mind is to create project on the bottom of the box, remove the side that the opening for the lid is on and make the side a removable dove tail like the lid. On that project create a latch on the inside to hold the side in place. Put a stop on the bottom side of the lid. To assemble put the lid on the box and slide the front side of the box in place to latch in place. The offsets for the lid stop will be up to you. Great videos. I am still a fledgling with Fusion 360.
This is really cool thank you, just a handy tip in the joint limit you can just add your length user pram that way if you do changed the length you will also change the joint limit as well :)
Thank you for this excellent instruction. I managed to reproduce it successfully ! Working further on this topic, I've found another way of doing it, which, if you don't mind I'd like to share with you: Instead of working with offsets on the sketch I tried the following: Box and lid as seperate components, as you do it. Create the box as a hollow, complete cube. Create the lid with triangular profiles on the sides, sketch on the xz plane, extrude along the y axis. Cut the lid from the top shell of the box using combine with the lid as tool and keeping the tool. This creates a box with a slot for the lid, but without any gap, so it won't slide , of course. The use the offset face command on the box's 4 slanted faces where the lid slides in. A value of -0.1 mm works for me (0.20 layers). It gives the same results , but I found it a little bit easier.
Thank you for a great tutorial. I used the basic concept to create a channel and diffuser for LED strip lights for a project I am working. I can adjust the parameters to fit different width of LED strips. I this is my first project I have modeled from start to finish!
Join my Patreon to get all of my demo files ➞ patreon.com/productdesignonline - *TIMESTAMPS* 0:00 - Creating a sliding lid in Fusion 360 0:27 - User Parameters preview 1:08 - Creating the box 1:50 - Making the box hollow 2:43 - Projecting the edge of the box 3:29 - Cutting out the dovetail shape 6:00 - Testing the dimensions 6:23 - Creating the lid of the box 7:45 - Factoring in the clearance 10:15 - Model Parameters into User Parameters 12:45 - Creating the thumb hold on the top 14:13 - Adding a sliding joint to the lid
You have helped a great deal! Thank you so much for making it easy and simple to understand. You really have no idea how hard it was to find something that's simple and gets the job done. I didn't use your design but I took what I needed from it and now I can finally make my GFs damn Christmas present
After seeing how smooth the bottom of the box was, I decided to print the top again, but this time upside down and it came out great, including the finger notch. My heated bed is fairly new and smooth so it made for an excellent finish.
@@ProductDesignOnline Creality Ender 3 - I also took advantage of printing the top upside down to also add a 20mm x 5mm rectangle at the bottom edge (under the finger pull) extruded to .3 mm with filets to act as a friction stop to keep it closed. Thanks again!!
Your videos are awesome! You present things so clearly. Thanks for sharing! I had an idea for keeping the lid on. What about a little embedded hinged flap that would only open 90 degrees? If would fold up flush to the bottom of the lid then swing down to act as a stop. Just a thought.
I didn't use parameters but pretty the same. I make lid stop as a small bump on the lid. If you make two bumps one in front and one in back so it will be open stop and close stop . Nice work and thanks for lessons.
Really good and practical tutorial. I tried a thin bead of superglue about 4-5 mm long on the dovetail right at the outside and it seems to work fine and gives enough friction to keep the lid closed yet still open easily. I actually had to do it twice as the first one wasn't thick enough. As another viewer posted, I had trouble with the coincident constraint and spent an hour trying to repeat exactly what you did. I eventually got it to repeat, but still don't quite understand what we're doing there although I do know without it you can't change dimensions and have the cutout work. I tried w/o the constraint as you did and saw exactly why you need the constraint. I'll go back through a couple of your earlier videos on constraints.
What did you do to get it work? I restarted this project a few times, and must have made at least 5 sketches. Edit: I moved the line from the outside of the box to the inside.
I don't know if you ever resolved the issue of having the Box lid being retained or not, but after watching your video, the idea struck me of having some sort of separately 3D printed Peg or lip or something that you can put on to the lid after you've installed it. It can really be anything, to square pegs, an entire Square lip the length of the lid, a dovetail shaped dowel bet you press fit into the back of the lid. Any of these can be manufactured ahead of time and then put together after assembly. Of course there's going to be a minimum size where a person's fingers won't fit and articulate correctly to press fit the part in, but in many cases I imagine it might do the trick.
8:24 - the only way I was able to get this to work is by making sure that the top two lines were projected along with the trapezoid. So, something in Fusion 360 has changed.
You could create small nubs near the front of the lid and offset a spherical shape so it locks into place when the lid is fully in, you'd definitely want a good handle for that method. Alternatively, you could create a pin hole within the box edge where a securing pin could be inserted into the lid to hold it in place, changes to the lid style would yield better results for that method however. Also i find Curved lids are less likely to fall out easily because of the curvature, it depends on the shape, e.g. if the lid was slightly angle downwards towards the back end gravity would help keep it in place as opposed to a "perfectly level" slide track letting friction be the only pull force on the lid. creativity's the limit.
the same way you added the divet, you can add a locking divet. A notch running lenght of lid will ensure it clears, but locks once its pushed all way in. Done it many times.
I think for preventing the lid out of box, you can add two symmetrical shallow cut at each side of the sliding rail then extrude two short pins at bottom of trapezoid, so when lid fully slide out, the pin will stop it off from box.
K another great project thanks for sharing. If you drilled a small hole and threaded it, then a allen screw could be inserted to be used as a stop. A 3d printed key & keyway would also work thanks again
Great video =D. Have you thought of making a tutorial about japanese joinery? It is traditionally used for wood working but as 3D prints have anisotropic properties similar to those of wood, i think that the techniques and geometries involved would be highly compatible, resulting in very strong joints for 3D printed parts. wdy think?
Hi, Santiago. I've used a lot of woodworking joinery techniques for some personal 3D printing projects. Great idea - I'll try to make some videos on them :)
Keven- My eyes aren't what they used to be, so following the "bouncing ball" (Keystrokes/Pointer tracking) ..is another parameter of learning obstacle only you have medicine for. Could you add an opaque circle to the pointer, and maybe a keystroke indicator? ...( sorry I don't have the vancular). Thank you ! I ask this of you because your tutorials are the " Best Example " of how to present any given topic. Good Job !!!
Lid stopper idea: make 2 or 1 small hook(s) ( like a fishing hook )on the beginning of the lid. once inserted with a litlle force ( pla is a little bit flexibel) you wont be able to remove the lid “ >” > insertion only lifting up with a knife to overcome the highest part of the hook
To stop it from sliding out, add a snap latch to the bottom of the lid. Just add 2-3 layer slit above the latch (below whilst printing, has to be printed upside down) to allow plastic to deform while inserting and spring back once in place. Printed flat, there should be no issue as it's just simple bridge over the latch.
Add 2 limited-cycle living springs to the underside (2 makes it not twist around) of the lid near the edge. Wedge/ramp one side and square off the other or maybe not as sloped as to make it removable but with more force. Have it recess enough to be flush into the underside of the lid as it slides on past the wall. This would be a cool tutorial.
If you make a little nub on the back bottom of the lid, it won't slide out on its own, but you can still pull it out with a little bit of force. Plastic has enough flex for that. 😁
I wonder if you shell the outside it would be easier too determine the required parameters for example you could then use the size of pack of cards too be the size
As Jorge J commented below, a flange will keep the lid from coming out, but it would also prevent it going in! If you end the dovetail at the same length that the flange begins, you can put it in. Or, a little trickier, add a hinged stop, sunk into the lid, that swings down when closed. Then you can hold it out of the way to remove or replace the lid .
Lid stopper idea: Extrude a guiderail in the joint from the back forward. Then add a small pin in the lid joint that slides along this inner guiderail of the box. A separate front face of the box needs to cover the guiderail and needs to be printed separately. The pin then stops at this front face. The front face needs to be attached after the lid is in place.
4:40 I have the problem that I constraint Horizontal/Vertical not working, ("Error: Failed to solve. Please try reworking dimensions or constraints."). I did it exactly like in the video. I would be happy if I got an answer Thanks for the video, I learned a lot from it! 👍
To stop the lid from coming off, I would think you could just put either an additional track on each side of the sliding parts, and then little "wings" at the end that stick out and run along the track. Various ways to do this, and difficult to explain in comments though.
I reduced the tolerance from .2 to .15 and the lid was still loose. So, then I printed off just the lid with a .05 tolerance and with a very light sanding I got a very satisfying friction fit. Hope this helps.
I loved the content and followed the video a few times, i just cant get my constraints to work when I modify the size of the box the rest doesn't go with it.
The easiest way I can think of is to design two small hooks like stuff in the face of the open part, two holes on the back part of the lid to catch on those hooks when it fully open, the lid drop and the hooks catch the lid to maintain fully open.
Hi, can you make a tutorial for intermediate users on how to improve their modelling skills, meaning some tips to improve the method and for doing it more organised