Smash Rules Suck So We Made Our Own... 

Funniest part is I’m the one who turns peoples microphones on and off but Peter is COPPING it in the comments 😂

I'm just glad to see Captain Grim becoming a mainstay of the channel. Truly one of the Underdogs meme characters of all time

I can confidently say I’d watch a full video for all of these modes

For tag, maybe you could do 10hp for the runners and the tagger tries to kill them, with a time limit so the runners have a way to win

24:50 I love how every time someone buries Cogger, they completely fail to take into account the fact that he just does mash, and it completely ruins the follow-up they are trying for.

I wonder if they will bring back the assassin game mode where they all had a target.

I'd like to see a Banana Smashdown where you have to come up with a justification for each character you choose being banana-related.

16:02 poppt saying I’ll give it a two genuinely had me cracking up

The fact that the blue shell killed and changed the winner right at the end is so Mario kart 👌🏼

Peter not turning on his mic has to be one of the biggest twist since Score Display On

It's good that Peter is a naturally loud speaker, if it was Jackson whose mic went out we wouldn't have heard a peep from him for the first few minutes

9:20 I see they added Ganon's Dead Man's Volley to Smash, finally.

4:34 Zack:”should we go high” “Nah” Jordan: Visible disappointment*

The cops and robbers one should definitely be a full video. Just add a timer for 3 minutes and have the runners have 10 hp. The seeker has to kill all three runners to win, while the runners have to outlast the timer. I think TC Nick had a video like this before actually and it was pretty fun to watch.

As representative of the bananas, I humbly request a full video of banana smash. Truly the greatest game mode of all time

For the Death note language thing that Poppt1 was referring to in the show "death note" the death note itself has instructions that were written in english as it was the most common language and when dropped into the world would be easiest to use for the majority of the world. This is not changed no matter the language to my knowledge

Of course Peter would win on the Mario kart rule set lmao

I think the sheer lore behind Australia, boomerangs, crocodiles, no guns, but still crowns (because of the Commonwealth); and then the arresting adding to it, made it the best. "Banana Smash was my favourite" - because of how dominant Poppt was.

17:45 The only way to make this work is the stage with strongest downwards wind

I can't wait for 28 minutes of ideas that are too good. oh and edit as a massive underdog fan I think all of them should be a full video each

Lmao it's honestly too funny seeing Peter try and lie about cheating and using the gun after being called out on it as thought he's on the primary schoolyard as opposed to on camera footage that we all watched 💀

I feel like the grim reaper would speak Latin considering it's literally a dead language.

We NEED a Banana Smash video

Bro pinball smash and banana smash went crazy

Shouldve added the bunny ears for Australian smash to represent the kangaroos

For tag, give everyone 5 stocks with 10hp on great cave. If someone dies, they become the new chaser

Loved the mario kart and Grimm modes. Banana smash was obviously the best :P

9:19 literally Dead Man’s Volley (Zelda reference)

I appreciate y’all posting so much around the holidays. Just takes my darkness away for a bit

This was actually one of my favourite Underdogs videos. Fantastic job!

As a British person, I can confirm that we are not aware of other languages and ask that you stop this foreign propaganda.

I honestly really like Hopcats rule sets, he was trying different things instead of just regular smash with a certain item

I'd love to see all of these in their own video! :)) Here are some suggestions to make these videos even better: For Grim Smash: the desth scythe has an execution effect on ftilt too. For Rubber Banding Smash: the blue shell still works in stock mode, but I think time mode is actually better for this experience. For Austrailian Smash: the boomerang gets more powerful the more you throw it, so having items on low might make the boomerangs more impactful as you can keep track of them. For Mine Smash: if you want duck hunt without the tree, hazardless wily castle is an alternative. For a stage with platforms I recommend Cloud Sea of Alrest.

Okay, Jordan played out of his mind in banana smash. That was so hype to watch.

god the complaining from Little Z after the first DK Banana smash was hard on the ears

Its nice to hear you guys actually having fun lmao

The fact that you 4 can still come up with multiple fun, chaotic and creative modes is outstanding to me that I might try them out. W video👍 For the tag one, I recommend playing with a time limit on custom stages shaped like mazes that can also have obstacles. I think it would be a fantastic video idea ;)

Doubles with yet another freaking twist

I absolutely would love for the metal-angled smash shenanigans to return in any capicity

I also never knew about the platforms affecting each other

Honestly really liked both the Heavy Metal Smash and Tag. I think some adjustments could be made for tag but both were good, and the Heavy Metal was really funny.

Tbh if they did a full video any of these I'd prolly watch it :0

This is a very good video! Many funny moments, would love to see more of these silly game modes

the pinball smash was actually hype holy shit

My friends and I do tag. Everyone plays as either Zero suit or Kirby. One person chases and can only tag with neutral B. Set a timer, last person it when time runs out is the loser

If the rubber banding mode ever becomes its own video, it can work with stock. AFAIK it goes for whoever has the most stocks and least %

Been a hot minute since I watched these four goofs. Glad to be back!

I think watching you guys play overcooked would be really funny :)

Banana smash was my favourite because I loved the way that poppt targeted everyone from best to worst with best last.

What a fun way to end the year. Gosh I wish I had friends I could play such fun modes with. But you guys are my friends so I'm still happy.

Banana smash is one of my favorite new game modes I cant lie

I am laughing so hard at the k rool Australian bit

9:19 oh hey it's the actual ganondorf fight from ocarina of time

I genuinely really enjoyed heavy metal smash. Idk if it would work for a whole video but that was really funny to watch.

The scythe is consistent. F-tilt kills at 120% and f-smash kills at 80%. Only the blade hitbox will kill. While an attack is in progress, enemies in attack range that would be killed are surrounded in an aura. If they avoid the hit, they can still survive.

We gotta see a full video of Banana Smash

My rating is worst first best last. 1. Heavy Metal Smash 2. Cops and Robbers (will be improved with timer) 3. Australian Smash 4. Grim Smash 5. Mine Smash 6. Blue Shell Smash 7. Pin Ball Smash 8. Banana Smash

Most of these were great, but if there’s one I’d really love to see a full video for it’d be blue shell smash.

Love To see A full Rubberband smash video

Banana smash deserves its own video

Great to see Jordan appreicate death note

I think Slingshot is the best one, you just need to put the shells on low so they don't interfere too much.

Idea infection everyone starts at 0 on a 3 min timer and one is the tagger and try’s to get the others on 100 if thy get to 100 then they are a part of the taggers team. If the person gets killed before 100 they restart at 0. You can see who lasts the longest or wins (the timer goes to zero.

I'd watch 24 hours of banana smash no questions asked

i think there should be a whole video dedicated to targeting best to worst but u dont know the order...

Love your vids again xD Vids 28 and 21 I think of asking for assassin and launchrate smash

9:40 Really disappointed that 'Stralian smash wasn't on hazards on Spear Pillar for the chance for the stage to flip upside down. Missed opportunity

thank you UNDERDOGS for the COOL VIDEOS i look forward to watching them OFTEN. THANK YOU.

I'd love to see them play Lethal Company

Jordan absolutely murdering Zach in banana smash is the funniest thing ever😂

I'd love to see a video of Pinball smash, with just the soccer balls and bumpers. Even better if you guys make a custom stage using the bumpers!

My favourite was probably Grim Smash, although it took ages to get to 100%, so you could start at a 50% handicap or something

Good Death Note reference Jordan. If I remember correctly the shinigami themselves don't speak English but the Death note instructions are written in English because its the most common language.

I wanna give my spin on the cops and robbers mode: Basically a spin on boss smash where the player starting as cop must catch (kill) all other 3 robbers, and upon their respawn they become cops until all robbers are captured thus making a win for the starting cop. Then next round next player starts as cop. It’s similar to spirits boss smash and stuff. For the rule set I recommend hp with the cop being at 50hp and robbers at 10hp. Defending oneself is allowed and test it to see if 2 minutes or even just 1 minute is best. Everyone has two stocks. The first stock of robbers they must flee but upon being killed once and respawn on last stock they are cops now too and gotta help… if they want. Friendly twist of throwing deliberate is nice cause I know Zack will shit talk Cogger not doing shit to help while Jordan is likely to friendly kill lol Anyways, that’s my recommendation that I think can work. And of course, massive stages works best.

clearly the only answer is a twelve hour stream of banana smash

Bannana smash had me in tears i cant believe that the c word came out there and not the Australian mode

Cops vs Robbers: Cops DK with bananas, robbers are king K rule. Basically Doubles... with a twist!

Y'all should do Explosive smash, were you put all explosives on high, pick characters with a lot of fire moves, and play on standard Brinstar.

Okay guys, COPS AND ROBBERS, I really genuinely want to see you guys try this again but it should be once you tag them they go into the corner or "jail" and the other two that aren't tagged have to get to them to set them free. If the cop tags everybody and gets everyone in jail at the same time then you win. If the jail is completely in the corner maybe they get a couple seconds immunity to get out. Please try this again it would be so hilarious.

9:19 Imagine: Mario and Luigi edit here

Banana smash is golden

Where did the podcast go?

Leave it to the underdogs to release the best video of the year on the last day of the year

These guys never run out of content because they work at the content factory

I’m just imagining what carnage hero with whack would do in grim smash.

Pinball smash should include the star that blasts you off in a certain direction

That seems pretty good.

I love how at 9:17 they just play Ocarina of Time.

It’s nice to see Captain Grim get some honor on this channel with that rule set

Bats and beastballs. So much fun

Best video ever, Cogger is amazing

The grim scythes only kill above 100%, but it's guaranteed with an f-smash at that point

australian smash had me cackling

They always find a way to make the weirdest rule set so intense

They didn’t notice that Cogger got the K Rool up smash spike

I want to see angle heavy metal smash in a full video

It’s canon for Peter to have won the blue shell rule set lol

I REALLY liked the rubber banding gamemode. Can we get more of that with perhaps a 6 minute timer?

Idk why I thought this was beefy smash doods

Grim Smash is peak gameplay