SMG4: Who Let The Chomp Out? ORIGINAL VS REMASTERED64 (Comparison) 

I dont care if i get copyright claim on this video (the music), this is a certified classic and I wanted to compare the 2!!! This song deserves to be NOT claimed and be used in funny videos such as these. But anyways. Sorry if it’s not synced up properly I tried the best I can! Thanks for watching!!! Check out my Reaction video also! ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-4kAOAx-YypM.html

So the main differences are: 1. More usage of GMod models than the original N64 models 2. SMG4 has his lines voiced over as opposed to being either silent or a random voice clip 3. Most of the swearing is censored And 4. The music being swapped for a copyright friendly cover instead of the original.

The remastered version is a example of copyright being a bicth

I love how the Chain chomp has more expressions

The OG is why i know SMG4, not because of TADC or MD, it was because of a video of Mario and Blue Mario being chased by a Chain Chomp

Changes: who let the dogs out was changed Various swears were censored “Retard” was changed to “Idiot.” Smg4 has voice acting Various N64 models were replaced with gmod models

The old version was good up until the middle, but I appreciate how smoothly the remaster progressed in the latter half and how the chain chomp's expressions became more diverse. I would like to say that the remaster is about 90% of the original.

Don’t know if I prefer the original or remake just yet, but I will give major points to the latter for both adding additional emotion to the Chomp while having it retain the N64 graphics much more than the OG.

The original will still be the goat to me

WHO LET THE TOADS OUT?! 2:04

I prefer the original over the remastered one, not because of the song or the uncensored jokes or even out of nostalgia, simply for the experience and how the jokes land. The remastered just feels too oversatured in every scene, like it must be filled with sound effects every second and be over-animated like a cinematic and that every character must constantly move or have an expression and that the jokes need to take an extra second or two for it to land and even when they arrive its taped with added sound effects. Basically think of a chocolate chip cookie; people love them and the chocolate makes it great, but it's now given so many chips that it's too gooey, sweet, there's almost no dough and reeks of chocolate, thats about the equivalent of the sound effects and animated scenes used in the videos, every time someone walks or a joke needs to be made, it doesn't need a sound effect or be made like a cinematic for it to be funny

2:04

It's been a while since I laughed at the current SMG4 like this xd

1:55 I love how you can still hear the cussing, even with the remastered censored

the very definition of less is more there is a reason why the og who let the chomps out has over 60m+ views, and time is not the only factor

Here before people start saying how The New One is Bad and The Old Obe is better and how People should Never Improve on thier Craft.

If you like both of them please like this comment

The main issue with modern SMG4 at least in my opinion is that he relies *waaaaaaay* too much on Garry's Mod. The characters being taken almost exclusively from Mario 64 was basically his trademark. It's sad to see how that trademark is basically no longer there.

Ahh the meatloaf!!!!

The remastered video definitely has higher detail and quality. I just don’t prefer the over reliance on using Gmod models over the SM64 hacks. The scene with the goombas swarming is much better in the old version. The biggest upgraded joke from the remastered one is the “they took his dog” parts, since that’s an example where the hacks aren’t as comedic. So I do feel I like the remastered one more. I still think the video itself is overrated, but it’s a classic. I actually prefer the Toad rendition over the actual song too 😂.

Not only the original was best. But more memorable. :)

ngl, the Chain Chomp Animations on Remastered is Awesome! All the things from remastered is good, except the copyright music that was taken out. But the OG has the Nostalgia!

5:23 SMG4: Why did you allow him to do this? Mario: well he is my bro he’s got nothing to do and he was up for it! SMG4: I guess that makes sense.

Funny how there was already a remake of Who let the chomp out before Remastered64

One of my biggest gripes with the remake is smg4 being voice acted, now if there are other voice acted characters in the modern videos it makes sense but in the remake where he is the only one who is voice acted and everyone is speaking in voice clips then it stand out

The Remastered Chain Chomp have a Revolver Gun but in the Original Chain Chomp have a Pistol Gun!

I didnt remembered the original well because its been 10 years.

Love the remastered bob-omb buddies scene

Remastered 64 🤝 original

Kids in 2020 and 2024 will never understand that the original was better then the remaster

I was confused why you didn't play the old intro but then i realized "oh wait you can't say the R word anymore"

Nice! I also did the same video!

Old one is the most popular smg4 video

You should have included the fan remake on top of the official remake

I'm going to give an opinion, I really think that the new one is better but almost better than the original, this happens especially and it is noticeable when you manage to put a higher quality in the production, settings and even angles and scenes that could not be done because they did not have the possibility before, I mean he looks and feels better, but he doesn't do it well, one of the problems is that he feels overloaded, although I think he's right, I know that if he removes an old joke people will get angry, and if he doesn't put anything in, they will say: "the veil is not worth it", and that is why it continues like this, we all know copyright, although it is a minor problem, along with censorship, and a certain joke that was better in the new one, like others that were better in the original, in my opinion is 55/45, but realistically for others it's 50/50, I don't see the need to argue about which one is better, especially since they are both fun in their own way.

In the first half of videos the OG was 100% better but as it got to the second half the remake took the cake imo.

thx with 2 versons 😁

Nostalgia be like

I think in the new version he uses the GMOD models for mario and smg4 to often instead of the N64 model

Nothing is better than the original

It’s from “Rugrats in Paris: The Movie” (2000)!

Smg4 has no idea that you can still use that old music but not remastered to make it super strange

I personally prefer the original version sorry

Now that's 4K!

You have to admire how he used his limited resources at the Remakes not to bad either

Nice comparison video, but the synchronization needs to be improved!😄

The remake video looks better than original

I love the old one 2014 smg4

How come the original feels better then the remastered, The original is better paced, nothing is drawn out, and the expressions are just better, no relying on gmod squash and stretch faces, the sm64 models gave it charm and helped make jokes better, The new one, everyone feels so lifeless, constantly being wiggled around in gmod, there is also the lack of image editing in the new one, which makes it feel so dead, everything looks so bland, everyone moves so awkwardly in the new one, and because new smg4 hates using images to make characters have different expressions and relies on gmod to make their faces, it always gives them the same face, a squashed and stretched face with cross eyes, and the added animation with lip sinc is so... Unnecessary. The old videos, due to sm64 mario not having a mouth, had them move alot more, and had alot of eye expressions, which made them feel more alive, and honestly, the characters in the old one actually felt like they were in a room together,

Both are good

Can’t beat the classics

1:10 biggest down grade of all time 😞

So very Evolution 😎😎

The original video looks better than remake

Sorry youtube, but it would be better if uncensored version was monetized

3:44 and U gotta help us

1:58,2:04😂😂😂😂😂

ORIGINAL 1:15

Remastered: victim of 2024 RU-vid and its copyright rules Original: good ol days 2014 RU-vid

I Like the original

2:39

I prefere old version so much

Maybe old version is better ❤

old vs new

Who let the dogs out

0:43 in the original is like a meme like. A day normal in Ohio:

I like the remake but it's not better than the og the one thing I really don't like is the who let the toads out because it is so awkward as hell without any instrumental playing I get why he did that but he couldn't chose an entirely different chase music not everything has to be extremely faithful he proved that by using only gmod models more often as oppose to SM64 ones with the only ones being the pink bomb ombs and chain chomp

The original is way better

Can you fix it because the video it delayed

0:40 the original is way funnier

What happend with smg4 voice?

Only sometime the old looks better

There both good but i prefer the remaster more I don't mind if someone like the original more than the remastered. But calling it better then the remastered it's straight up nostalgia biased. And you can't change my mind, unless you be more specific, that is what part in the original is better than remastered. I can only agree on who's let's the dog original been better.

I kinda wanted Smg4's new design in the remake.

It would be better if you left the audio of only one video

The remastered seems like an average lower Quality version than the originals

Original Is much better

The original is the best

yatatatatatatatata original is better

I dont know the remastered version just look awful for me, the voice of smg4, the 3d character, is not the same like the original

Me gusta la original la Remastered 64 esta muy feo cada vez lo hacr un poco más subido pero el original ese tiene buena chista pero la Remastered 64 no tiene bueno chiste yo elijo la original por que me da risa la cara de pricesa pech su cara todo muerto es la original xd😂😂😂😂

176th comment Beans.

“It’s not bad ur just blinded by nostalgia” nah his stuff is just eh now. Like it’s good animation and stuff props to their skills but it takes away the crappy homemade charm. All the new expressive animations make the use of goofy gmod ragdolls feel unneeded to me, like are you a shitpost Mario video or a children’s cartoon pick a side. Like the animation is good and if you like the remake better that’s fine but I just think smg4 feels more corporatized and sanitary now

>:(

I am the 600th person to like.

OG One is Better, Use Copyright Song & Uncensored Swear.

woah, the remaster sucks

I just hate all the censoring, I cant watch the remaster

I like the original more

Remake is better because smg4 speaks

STOP. Stop this, unless you know how to make these videos be compared INSYNC with one another.. JUST STOP IT!!

Og better bc the who let the dogs out ok copyright but Its what also made funny remake made good art but that's all (and voice acting

2:01

2:08

2:38