It's not everyday that you'll hear Taeyeon singing other artist's songs. This will forever be iconic. She didn't just try to sing it like the original but did it her style. I think Sunny made her do that performance though lol. They we're obviously just having fun. Obviously they haven't practiced on this song a lot too. And I guess it's right for the occasion.
To those bashing Taeyeon: Imagine if Hyorin covered Taeyeon? It wouldn't sound right, too, eh? It's because Taeyeon is Taeyeon. Hyorin is Hyorin. One can't replace the other.
yeesss that's right!! just imagine hyorin covered Taeyeon's "I",it wouldn't be as beautiful as Taeyeon,because hyorin voice is too rough and powerful to sing such a emotional song just like "I"
As both a Sistar and SNSD fan, i can honestly say I loved this. The point of a song cover is not always to sing it exactly as originally sung, but to bring your own twist into it. Stop getting butthurt because they didnt sound exactly like Hyorin and Bora, and appreciate that they did a cover and their vocals are amazing (:
To the people who say they cant sing.....uh tbh taeyeon and sunny werent in their performance mode. And they danced because sunny just wanted to. Im going to be honest and say that hyorin is definately better for this song because of her high sexy voice. Taeyeon has a very soft and emotional voice, which gives this song a different feel.
True sones should know that Sunny is made for fan service so it doesn't matter if she sang it right or not . And she entrusts Taeyeon to take on the singing . Moreover most older generation kpop groups nowadays don't take covers seriously like most rookies . They enjoy the moment . Idk about other groups but GG does . And based on Sunny's character , she's the type who enjoys giving fanservice . So I can see why she sounded quite horrible there . (Already waiting for people to attack me by saying that im defending them whoops but thumbs up if you kinda agree to what I say ;-) .)
elmoolover123 i actually agree with this 100% rookies take these kinds of things more serious but we all know gg as the dorky group who like to play around on stage when they get the chance, and the gg girls have unique voices that dont fit in every song that well, but they still kill it no matter what
they didnt take this really serious-.- u can see sunny and taeyeon laughing becuz they were singing for fun or to make this event a little funny if they take it serious and sing i know thay can make a great job -.- they are SNSD
Look at Taeyeon’s position now. She is on top of everybody no matter how much haters hate her. So keep hating she still shines and of course making a lot of money 😂😂😂
LMAO haters gonna hate, Sunny and Taeyeon are very busy this was probably something Sunny cooked up in 1 day and she just asked Taeyeon as a favor to be with her on stage, you can see on how Tae laughed when Sunny stood up and started dancing a lot of this was probably ad-libbed. Obv it would be better if they had practiced a lot more beforehand but honestly this is just fan service and seeing Tae and Sunny singing if they just did Karaoke the fans will still love it. I can't understand people who say they don't know how to sing, esp. to Taeyeon wtf why don't you see the MR removed version of I or Mr Mr every member of GG can sing well.
2 years late but You Yourself Are Making An Excuse so If It's Not A 'Clean/Crisp' Version Why Am I Hating? Taeyeon is My 3rd Fav Singer behind Hyorin, and UJi she CAN sing but This isn't a good cover AND Sunny being cute or not was Bad. SiStar fan, but I Respect Talent.... so No Need To Hate. They Do What I Can't.
Bora and hyorin actually had some backtrack when doing this song. If you look at their live performances, the ma boy wasn’t even sang by them. Plus bora wasn’t that confident in singing and had heavy mr over her singing. Taeyeon and sunny did very well. Also I’m not bashing sistar19. Super talentef
It's just a cover its not like they're trying to beat sistar19😐 this is the reason why idols these days don't do as many covers anymore they always get compared by " know it all" fans when they don't even want to be. Just go support your group and bias and SONES will support theirs...
as a fan of both sistar & snsd i think that this performance really shows just how amazing hyorin really is. taeyeon is undoubtedly an amazing singer, but she just doesn't cut it when it comes to this song. its like this song was MADE for hyorin and hyorin only (sorry and bora too but you know what i mean)
Taeyeon's voice is heavier than Hyorin's. Maybe they should have let Sunny sing Hyorin's part but it would be too nasal so yeah I agree, this song was made for Hyorin. It's like letting Lady Gaga (TY) cover Demi Lovato's song.
I saw this again. I never thought people would bash? Like, taeyeon is hitting them high notes with so much power, sunny is rapping showing dynamics. HATERS CAN VANISH.
I don't think taeyeon looks awkward because she can't reach the high note. I enjoyed taeng's voice through out the song. Why? because She looks awkwardly cute because this song is a sexy song and she is performing happily. Hyorin's high note is different with taeng since they don't have the same voice range and tempo. Taeng's voice is flexible and you can see here that She's using her full voice which I love.
Taeyeon is so pretty like really pretty 😍 Her voice is so soothing especially when she add adlibs at the end 🎵🎶 my goodness 💞 and she looks really skinny here Her thigh gaps though 😱
I love Taeyeon's voice so much.. It may not suit the song but to me whatever she sings her voice will always sounds wonderful to me. So far she is the only female singer that has the voice that I truly admire and envy. I wish I have voice like her.. Cannot describe why I like it so much ...
Come on guys hey was just having fun that's why sunny started to dance to get the crowd going. It was a playful fun onstage duet. I got for fun out of it when sunny started dancing, she just wanted to make the crowd happy and act a fool sometimes it's just how sunny is and I love her for that!
No haters, I'm a STAR1. SNSD and SISTAR are good friends. They did this just for fun, and for those who's saying that SISTAR19 is better of course it's their song. Let's just be happy that SNSD did cover a SISTAR song. It's a great sign of friendship between the two groups.
sunny just can't hold her laughed when saw a fan screamed on her because tried to be sexy there....Doesn't mean that she can't this song properly! just too hard to hold it x3
It may not be the perfect version of the song, but it's so lovely when there're singers who sing another singer song in the comfy situation, not a serious ones
![[SNSD] Taeyeon & Sunny - Ma Boy(SISTAR 19), 태연&써니 - 마보이, For Guys Only 20150214](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
