Тёмный

Sonic The Hedgehog Character And Personality Writing: 👍Good VS Bad👎 

ShadowDante
Подписаться 17 тыс.
Просмотров 4,7 тыс.
50% 1

Let’s be honest, Sonic’s writing in the 2010s era for the most part was pretty bad. Sonic Team thought it was a great idea to make Sonic only light hearted, kid friendly and only appeal to younger audiences when really Sonic should appeal to everyone like Mario. In the 2010s era, do we have any dark moments? They tried to in Forces but no. Sad moments? Not really (even during sad moments it didn’t really feel as sad) mature moments? Nope. Cause apparently everything just has to be all kid friendly and goofy because apparently kids can’t handle dark, serious and mature things. Yeah they really need to fix the writing in Sonic games. Not that I didn’t enjoy the games of the 2010s era, I actually did I think Colours, Lost World and Generations are great. I think Forces was alright. But the writing just wasn’t that good. So here is a video showing you five examples of bad writing for Sonic’s character and five examples of good writing for Sonic’s character. All of the good writing clips were from games in the 2000s era not the 2010s because the 2000s was back then when the characters weren’t ruined. I don’t mind humorous moments and there were definitely some moments I enjoyed in the 2010s meta era but when there is too much humour it’s just annoying, cringe and unfunny and needs to stop. Sonic already perfectly appealed to kids back then I don’t get why they’re doing this now. Anyway, I hope you guys really enjoyed. Thanks for watching and let me know if you agree with me! Hopefully the next Sonic game has good writing.

Игры

Опубликовано:

 

12 сен 2021

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 127   
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 2 года назад
Let’s be honest, Sonic’s writing in the 2010s era for the most part was pretty bad. Sonic Team thought it was a great idea to make Sonic only light hearted, kid friendly and only appeal to younger audiences when really Sonic should appeal to everyone like Mario. In the 2010s era, do we have any dark moments? They tried to in Forces but no. Sad moments? Not really (even during sad moments it didn’t really feel as sad) mature moments? Nope. Cause apparently everything just has to be all kid friendly and goofy because apparently kids can’t handle dark, serious and mature things. Yeah they really need to fix the writing in Sonic games. Not that I didn’t enjoy the games of the 2010s era, I actually did I think Colours, Lost World and Generations are great. I think Forces was alright. But the writing just wasn’t that good. So here is a video showing you five examples of bad writing for Sonic’s character and five examples of good writing for Sonic’s character. All of the good writing clips were from games in the 2000s era not the 2010s because the 2000s was back then when the characters weren’t ruined. I don’t mind humorous moments and there were definitely some moments I enjoyed in the 2010s meta era but when there is too much humour it’s just annoying, cringe and unfunny and needs to stop. Sonic already perfectly appealed to kids back then I don’t get why they’re doing this now. Anyway, I hope you guys really enjoyed. Thanks for watching and let me know if you agree with me! Hopefully the next Sonic game has good writing.
@shucaybkarie1389
@shucaybkarie1389 2 года назад
Ian Flynn who wrote Sonic Frontiers and comics
@therussshow
@therussshow Год назад
Hopefully 2020 sonic can be darker
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
@@therussshow I agree
@raysonicfan1.207
@raysonicfan1.207 Год назад
The jokes were so cringe
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
@@raysonicfan1.207 ikr?
@dwainsimmons3447
@dwainsimmons3447 5 месяцев назад
If 4kids had better writing than the 2010s writers, then you know it really, really horrendous!
@TheDatabaseNetwork
@TheDatabaseNetwork Год назад
For Sonic '06, I would've also chosen the scene where Sonic gives Elise a lessoned advice where he says "Nothing starts until you take action. If you have time to worry, then run." Which I think is a good lesson of taking initiative of the problems head on. For Sonic case, its running towards the problems he faces.
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
Oh yeah that was a great one!
@hellothisisayoutubeaccount
@hellothisisayoutubeaccount Год назад
Nahh That one sucked, that's just telling you to run away from your problems, it doesn't solve anything its just you cowering from it
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 7 месяцев назад
​@@hellothisisayoutubeaccountYou didn't understand anything... Sonic means running TOWARDS the problems, not fleeing them! That's exactly what the "Nothing starts until you take action" sentence means! Amateur...
@RealHyperHedgehog
@RealHyperHedgehog 2 года назад
I miss the real Sonic. But with recent information, I think we will have him back soon. Edit: I knew it! Sonic is back!
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 2 года назад
I sure hope so
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
It's confirmed, Frontiers brought the real Sonic back.
@eggynuts7735
@eggynuts7735 Год назад
Just personality, I agree, but story and gameplay are shit Bosses and character development were good tho
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
@@eggynuts7735 Story ? Shit ? LOL. You're kidding. Frontiers story is excellent. It was really emotional, Sonic literally suffered for saving his friends at the cost of his life, he died temporarily, his friends sacrified themselves for him, the plot twists with Sage and The End were excellent, the history of Ancients were great, the link between Sage and Eggman were exceptionally moving. Shit ? My god, you can't be serious. And the gameplay is good.
@eggynuts7735
@eggynuts7735 Год назад
@@maryafantalia8614 no way, it doesn't equate to sonic adventure one bit, it's a bad story, and that my dear is a fact, since I said so if I say something is true then it's true The plot felt very predictable and vague and it felt like a side quest just to learn more about the chaos emeralds and the end, all u had to do was get memory tokens, talk to some people, beat bad guys and move stay on that BORING cycle, Ian Flynn literally wrote IDW Comics many times better than Frontiers could EVER BE!!!!!!
@Azurald55
@Azurald55 Год назад
With the new Knuckles prologue, it seems like Sega is finally respecting their characters again. Not only does Knuckles act like himself again, they also acknowledge the past and the lore of the world. I'm so glad that this is their direction for frontiers and I'm really looking forward to playing it not only for the gameplay but also the story!
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
Ikr? I’m so happy with the prologue
@Azurald55
@Azurald55 Год назад
@@ShadowDante7 yessir
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
Same here ! I want to play for the story !
@Azurald55
@Azurald55 Год назад
@@maryafantalia8614 same here 👍
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
@@Azurald55 😊
@CartoonLowStudios
@CartoonLowStudios Год назад
Kids are not stupid. Sometimes, they're even smarter than the adults. They CAN understand dark topics like death or betrayals. Sonic in the 2010s shouldn't have looked at what Mario did. He should have looked at what Disney or even Pixar did. Their stories are lighthearted but have serious moments and the scripts have jokes that are well-timed and actually funny. I think they accomplished it with Unleashed. It felt like a Pixar or even a Dreamworks movie (the good movies like HTTYD, Shrek or Kung Fu Panda) Hopefully, Frontiers will do great thx to Ian Flynn writing the script. I don't want Ian to copy Shiro Maekawa's style or be joke-crazy like Pontac-Graff. He needs to have its own style that can stand up in the right way!
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
EXACTLY! THANK YOU! I really hope Frontiers does justice and brings back a more serious tone to the franchise
@CartoonLowStudios
@CartoonLowStudios Год назад
@@ShadowDante7 By looking at the cutscenes that surfaced from Gamescom, the script is good 👍
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
@@CartoonLowStudios I hope SEGA has surely learnt their lesson by now, and I have hope for Frontiers
@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516
@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516 Год назад
They should look at Imagi Studios, not Disney! Imagi Studios doesn't make anything SJW.
@CartoonLowStudios
@CartoonLowStudios Год назад
@@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516 IMAGI's reputation is not the best
@LuigiXP
@LuigiXP 2 года назад
classic sonic’s writing is so good i liked it when he said …
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 2 года назад
Lol. I mean…nothing is still better than the kind of writing we are getting now lol
@traviscunningham7062
@traviscunningham7062 11 месяцев назад
Mario even has better writing than Meta Sonic.@@ShadowDante7
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 7 месяцев назад
Classic Sonic has no writing! And the peak writing was in 2000s and came back in Frontiers.
@azeemharithbinfaireezmoe
@azeemharithbinfaireezmoe 4 месяца назад
L​@@maryafantalia8614prepare yourself for some woooosh comments...
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 4 месяца назад
@@azeemharithbinfaireezmoe Why would people reproach me to say an absolute truth?
@SonixSprite
@SonixSprite 8 месяцев назад
It’s only good writing when Sonic is actually taking situations seriously.
@thekeybladeninjaturtle7380
@thekeybladeninjaturtle7380 10 месяцев назад
I remember watching a DidYouKnowGaming video on Sonic Generations saying how the writers of 2010s Sonic games, Pontac and Graff, knew nothing about Sonic and would watch cutscenes to get an idea of the characters and their personalities. I'm so glad SEGA replaced them with Ian Flynn to fix the mess they made
@MegaSonic1999
@MegaSonic1999 10 месяцев назад
Thankfully, this has changed in Sonic Frontiers.
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 10 месяцев назад
Yep and I’m glad
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 7 месяцев назад
Youhou!
@2Qwuik
@2Qwuik Год назад
The real sonic is back! Sonic Frontiers writing was great!
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
Ikr? I’m so happy!
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
YEAHHHHHHHHH !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
Seriously, even in Shadow the Hedgehog, a game where Sonic's not the main character, he was better written than in the whole Meta Era ! Just look in the endings where Shadow is against him when he says "Shadow... I can't let you go ! Not like this !" or when he loses : "Shadow... Why ? Why are you siding with them ?" Or the true ending, when he is very serious and especially when he admits Shadow is the only hope of the planet : "You're our only hope now !" Just that was better than Meta Era. Meta Era hasn't that. And don't forget Jason Griffith's talents helped for that ! He has the tone in his voice which can that somehow sounds like a scream of Sonic's personality, a thing no other voice actor can replicate (especially in Black Knight. Man, THIS game is the golden game of Jason Griffith). Roger Craig Smith has the enthusiast tone but not this scream of the WHOLE personality. But Frontiers will fix that, with Ian Flynn and the direction, this Sonic we loved will be back.
@Werten25
@Werten25 2 года назад
You know what? If I ever make a fanmade Sonic game, maybe I could make the story deliberately nonsensical and full with awful jokes in a way that mocks the games’ poor writing.
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 2 года назад
Lol that would be great
@therussshow
@therussshow Год назад
Sonic: I play by my own rules Also sonic: think of the children
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
Lol true
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
You must correct that in : *Maekawa* Sonic : I play by my own rules *Pontaff* Sonic : Think of the children
@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516
@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516 Год назад
@@maryafantalia8614 *Imagi Studios* Sonic : [speaks some philosophical poems in a way that fits with *Maekawa* Sonic]
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
@@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516 Who is Imagi Studios ?
@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516
@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516 Год назад
@@maryafantalia8614 Look here... en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imagi_Animation_Studios *Imagi Studios* theatrical films are... *TMNT* (2007) *Tusker* (2008)* *TMNT 2* (2009)* *Astro Boy* (2009) *The Legend of Zelda* (2010)* *Gatchaman* (2011)* *TMNT 3* (2011)* *T28* (2012)* *Cat Tale* (2013)* *Astro Boy 2* (2013)* *Astro Boy 3* (2017)* *This project is dead...
@bryanblueblurhedgehog8899
@bryanblueblurhedgehog8899 Год назад
Which I thought in 2010 stories are meant to make taken a little bit seriously before lighthearted towards children but no, they prefer towards everything at children like nothing else to do, sometimes there's lot of things like Sad, Happy and Cool moments such as generations and lost world. But in forces was alright after all the sudden feels forced by having dark moments includes infinite itself. Not to mention, Sonic frontiers story feels incredible at this point, it should be better than 2010's stories of meta era
@patrickdixon7202
@patrickdixon7202 Год назад
Sonic Frontiers' story is awful.
@bryanblueblurhedgehog8899
@bryanblueblurhedgehog8899 Год назад
@@patrickdixon7202 that's your opinion, not mine
@bryanblueblurhedgehog8899
@bryanblueblurhedgehog8899 Год назад
@@patrickdixon7202 also you didn't play frontiers just because you hate the story doesn't mean that you have to like meta era stories are trash
@patrickdixon7202
@patrickdixon7202 Год назад
@@bryanblueblurhedgehog8899 You're so daft. I did play Sonic Frontiers and I watched every cutscene. Nowhere did I say that I like Meta era stories.
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
​@@patrickdixon7202 The only daft guy here is you. Frontiers' story, awful? HAHAHA!😂 You live in a cave, do you? Or you do an April Fool, because if you saw EVERY Frontiers cutscene and call that "awful", which is TOTALLY wrong, you're bugging out. Or you're just a hateful guy, because I don't see anything "awful" in Frontiers. What is awful? Characters (no)? Universe (no)? Rythm (no)? Nothing! At the limit you can say it's not your kind, but "awful"? Do you know what "awful" means? Sorry but a bad story is by definition boring, uninteresting and inconsistent. And Frontiers has none of those flaws. You can tell me any argument, I will contradict them, just go ahead.
@dwainsimmons3447
@dwainsimmons3447 Год назад
If 4kids can make a better script than Pontaff and Graff, that’s really really bad!
@RenoKyrie
@RenoKyrie Год назад
Will you make a sequel with Pontac Vs Sonic Team + Ian Flynn?
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
It will be fun !
@Alolino1605
@Alolino1605 7 месяцев назад
Sonic secret rings and black knight are both decent games, but the writing each of them are FANTASTIC imo.
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 7 месяцев назад
I love Secret Rings and Black Knight! And I also agree that the writing is awesome!
@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516
@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516 Год назад
With all honesty, blunt or no, *Baldy Nosehair* was funny IMO (although compared to butt machine guns [a hilarious line from a dark-dramatic movie, Astro Boy], it's nothing], but *Baldy McNosehair* is abysmally unfunny/cringy (compared to *Baldy McNosehair* [I choke on my own spit saying that], *Baldy Nosehair* is a masterpiece).
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
I guess so. I found it really funny when I was younger
@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516
@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516 Год назад
⁠@@ShadowDante7And another thing, if IMAGI Sonic existed, Sonic's real name would be Ogilvie Maurice, and Black Knight Sonic would be called Knave. As for Secret Rings Sonic, his real name is unknown.
@therussshow
@therussshow Год назад
To be honest, sonic forces was actually pretty dark and mature for a sonic game. They definitely took a HUGE step up from lost world. Especially when infinite transformed and became more powerful and evil.
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
I can agree on that. But they could’ve done more, since the tone of the game still didn’t feel dark enough with how much the characters still joke around in a literal world war.
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 7 месяцев назад
Forces seems dark and mature only in appearance and expectations. But in reality, it's nothing of that.
@hazzatgames2776
@hazzatgames2776 2 года назад
Cool
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 2 года назад
Thanks
@hazzatgames2776
@hazzatgames2776 2 года назад
@@ShadowDante7 no worries
@supersonicjulio8691
@supersonicjulio8691 7 месяцев назад
So basically when Sonic was voiced by Jason Griffith sonic was good I agree 👍
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 7 месяцев назад
Frontiers?
@ALegendaryBlueHedge
@ALegendaryBlueHedge 6 месяцев назад
That's some mad cope right there
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 6 месяцев назад
@@ALegendaryBlueHedge You speak to who?
@ALegendaryBlueHedge
@ALegendaryBlueHedge 6 месяцев назад
@@maryafantalia8614 The other guy
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 6 месяцев назад
@@ALegendaryBlueHedge Oh.
@Michael_Afton40
@Michael_Afton40 10 месяцев назад
Glad Pontac and Graff are gone
@tendayimichaelchinyerere1843
sonic colors writing was not that bad there was that moment in sonic colours were they realize what eggmans plan is that scene was actauly good
@ALegendaryBlueHedge
@ALegendaryBlueHedge 6 месяцев назад
I bet if it was Jason Griffith saying all these cringe lines, y'all would be singing a whole different tune
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 6 месяцев назад
Never said it was Roger Craig Smith’s fault. He’s a good voice actor. It’s the terrible character writing that Sonic had during that time period.
@ALegendaryBlueHedge
@ALegendaryBlueHedge 6 месяцев назад
@@ShadowDante7 Yeah I get that, I'm just referring to the nostalgia blind 2000's fanboys who act like Sonic had bad writing in the 2010's just because Jason Griffith left
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 6 месяцев назад
@@ALegendaryBlueHedge oh fair enough. Yeah I agree with you. I do think Roger deserves to be given a chance by fans (I mean he’s a great voice actor and Frontiers did both Sonic and him justice) we shouldn’t be blaming the voice actors for Sonic’s writing.
@ALegendaryBlueHedge
@ALegendaryBlueHedge 6 месяцев назад
@@ShadowDante7 True
@therussshow
@therussshow 2 года назад
Cough cough Sonic Colors
@AdamSelvig
@AdamSelvig 3 месяца назад
4kids games did better
@therussshow
@therussshow Год назад
It’s like kids nowadays like sonic and adults are infuriated. And with Mario everyone like it
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
Yeah exactly
@therussshow
@therussshow Год назад
It’s like sonic is restricted to 7 and under when Mario is 0+
@therussshow
@therussshow Год назад
I mean sonic should be family not just kids lol.
@therussshow
@therussshow Год назад
Especially colors
@jonathanjuarez5544
@jonathanjuarez5544 Год назад
Because Mario didn't go through a period of games where he cracks jokes only eight year olds find funny, or have his friends become the writer's punching bags for quick jokes.
@jesuspernia8031
@jesuspernia8031 Год назад
Thank god Frontiers exists
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
Yep
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
Yeah!
@patrickdixon7202
@patrickdixon7202 Год назад
@@maryafantalia8614 Overrated.
@sawwt.hedgehog
@sawwt.hedgehog Год назад
It's embarrassing how the game that sucks badly has better writing than actual good games (besides Forces)
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
Well personally I like some of these games but yeah I agree
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
Black Knight, Unleashed and Secret Rings were good games.
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 Год назад
@@maryafantalia8614 agreed
@maryafantalia8614
@maryafantalia8614 Год назад
@@ShadowDante7 :)
@jesuspernia8031
@jesuspernia8031 Год назад
@@maryafantalia8614 Secret Rings is growing on me. I really enjoyed Black Knight even before. Unleashed is spectacular but that’s obvious.
@Crybaby0ttant0tt0
@Crybaby0ttant0tt0 29 дней назад
What kind of essay is this. You can't just play cutscenes and edit in the words Good Writing and Bad Writing. You need to elaborate.
@ShadowDante7
@ShadowDante7 29 дней назад
It’s not supposed to be an essay though. I simply just wanted to show clips of what I think is good vs bad writing. Since Sonic fans would agree (at the very least most of them) I do not really need to elaborate in this video. The clips in comparison say enough. If I wanted to write an essay, I would’ve.
Далее
How Remakes Could Change Sonic Forever
10:33
Просмотров 2,4 тыс.
SSBB J P Sonic Solo vs Tabuu Intense (No Deaths)
6:09
Просмотров 661 тыс.
Same voice actor
0:29
Просмотров 34 тыс.
Sonic the Hedgehog: A Perfect Character (Video Essay)
12:01
Is Sonic Frontiers Writing Bad?
6:30
Просмотров 2,6 тыс.
E.G.G.M.A.N.
3:24
Просмотров 1,8 млн
Shadow the Hedgehog - All Endings [1080p HD]
11:29
Просмотров 510 тыс.
The Great Confrontation (Sonic IDW 50) - COMIC DUB
23:24
The VARIED Voices of Sonic
21:03
Просмотров 63 тыс.
Let's Fix the Deadly Six! (Sonic Lost World Rewritten)
22:18