I have to say I prefer the orginal b&w, but it is interesting to see a more refined Gandy and in color. Gandy is best of all with Sourpuss, making one of cartoondom's best teams. I am not sure about the '38 version's title as I can't find an appropreate adjectival meaning for gandy, what is a gandy goose? I have seen it called Gandy the Goose but that is not his name in the cartoon, it is Willie.