Тёмный

Spyderco, Benchmade or Cold Steel? Essential EDC Knife Showdown: Mini Recon 1 v Mini Grip v Native 5 

Cedric & Ada Gear and Outdoors
Подписаться 73 тыс.
Просмотров 38 тыс.
50% 1

cedric-ada-store.creator-spri...
Good gravy its bricky on things
Subscribe and hit the bell! Hit like and all that good stuff.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/... - Full steel testing list for my cut test videos, free to all.
/ cedricada - support me on patreon if you like, helps me do the expensive stuff!

Наука

Опубликовано:

 

7 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 108   
@traceyoung5592
@traceyoung5592 5 лет назад
I own each of these and thought I would never say it but the Cold Steel for this comparison is hands down the best because of the incredible price point. You won’t find a Spyderco or Benchmade with G10 and comparable steel for anywhere close to what this Cold Steel costs.
@claymcculloch2729
@claymcculloch2729 5 лет назад
@Semper Skeptical is that a big deal? The g10 and steel is American, just assembled in Taiwan.
@claymcculloch2729
@claymcculloch2729 5 лет назад
@Semper Skeptical yea good point, I agree with you there!😉 I also try and buy American made where I can, but they're so expensive here in Australia as far as far as materials for the money goes. So my Cold steel American lawman was a bit of a compromise but still having American materials.
@sebastianshaw210
@sebastianshaw210 3 года назад
6u
@Phaminator525
@Phaminator525 2 года назад
And coldsteel wins in quality control aswell
@GigiFenomen
@GigiFenomen 2 года назад
or the same build quality, the other knives are flimsy compared to the CS
@guillermolorente2020
@guillermolorente2020 Год назад
If Your life depends on the knife, take with You The Recon 1 the other two are more decorative knives.
@ArikGST
@ArikGST 8 лет назад
If you baton with your folding knives that Tri-Ad lock really comes in handy xD
@FearNoSteel
@FearNoSteel 8 лет назад
you can baton with the other knives too, just keep the locks disengaged heck id do the same on the cold steel, you dont wont wear out the lock and make it loose
@FactFinderGeneral
@FactFinderGeneral 7 лет назад
Plus, pocket knives of this size are not meant for batoning (honestly, 99.9% of knives aren't). If you want to baton, go bigger and fixed blade if possible.
@oggyloc
@oggyloc 5 лет назад
Full size Recon 1 for me..
@ohreally1021
@ohreally1021 6 лет назад
Cheers! Would you say that the Native is the sturdiest
@bobfrombrisbane1831
@bobfrombrisbane1831 8 лет назад
Nice comparison video, I found it informative. I would agree with your thoughts on the Benchmade Mini Grip.
@coldhart79
@coldhart79 6 лет назад
Needless to say; Cold Steel will be the blade everyone should get one inside their pocket. Good metal, razor sharp out of the box, even its black but having the DLC coating which need not worry any scratches with hard use of it and the infamous Tri Ad Lock, the strongest mechanism in the folding knives industries! Many people dislike Cold Steel just becos they dislike how they (Cold Steel) market their product like cutting of pigs, chicken and the arrogant boss of Cold Steel..but we are getting good knives, nothing to do with people whom produce/design the knife. Cold Steel definitely is the blade without any thoughts
@MickMcMahon
@MickMcMahon 8 лет назад
Great review
@Faileduserattempt
@Faileduserattempt 7 лет назад
Why would a 3" blade be unfit for self defence? If you slice someones chest open, it doesn't matter if the blade is 3" or 4".. It'll create one heck of a gash either way.
@brassnblades5211
@brassnblades5211 7 лет назад
PsychopathMisfit if you are carrying a knife as you're primary defensive weapon then you want all the reach you can get 3inch is better than nothing but very small for a defensive blade when you consider cloths bone and muscle a 3inch cutting edge is def on the small side thats why most "tactical" blades are 4inch and above. not an expert by any means just my two cents.
@asdfgidji879
@asdfgidji879 6 лет назад
its bad for self defense cause its a knife. it might be good if you tie it to the end of a stick though
@luisarellanorn3309
@luisarellanorn3309 6 лет назад
ASDFGidji You obviously have no training. Blade length in the hands of someone experienced is the point of fact. One more inch is insignificant in close quarter hand to hand range.
@Acre00
@Acre00 6 лет назад
The way I was taught to use a knife in a fight is to strike at the arm of my assailant, primarily the wrist, then go for more lethal strikes in needed. In this form, an extra inch is negligible.
@KIWIMADNEZ
@KIWIMADNEZ 5 лет назад
A manix2 saved my life once so I'm sure your good with a 3" blade.
@LisaInTheSkyMU
@LisaInTheSkyMU 8 лет назад
Nice little graphic you made for the channel avatar 😊
@CedricAda
@CedricAda 8 лет назад
Yeah the other one had been around for ages! Im fully pro now, should be on 99999 subs tomorrow morning *sits up all night wide awake*
@dalecarpenter8828
@dalecarpenter8828 4 года назад
the reco 1 is the strongest but a lot of reviewers play that down but at the same time don't bring up the littles part that break on the (g) lock ( axis ) and on none triad back locks ! I have broken back locks on buck 110 and broken spring on axis locks ( replaced with better (G) lock springs )! I have never ever broken any part of a recon 1 ! so lock strength and lock part strength is an issue ! when I customize the recon 1's they work easy and become fidget knives ! I have both of these knives and if I could only have one it would be the recon 1 because it is the strongest and most reliable ! that does count even in a small knife ! the spiderco isn't in the same class with the benchmade or the cold steel accept in size !
@SRVandDtrouble
@SRVandDtrouble 3 года назад
What mods did you do to your Recon 1? I have several Cold Steel and love to hear others custom work. Thanks
@Intoxacajun
@Intoxacajun 9 месяцев назад
Same question, have the recon 1 and it is a bugger to unlock to close!!@@SRVandDtrouble
@artemkanarchist
@artemkanarchist 3 года назад
Love them all, need them all
@mrc2205
@mrc2205 Год назад
The Benchmade is my favourite. And I love the colour on that one. And it fits my hand well.
@Rivy_ID
@Rivy_ID 7 лет назад
I wonder if the results would be different if you used a standard version of the mini grip. I think that version is better, but you also pay for it. The standard version is closer in price to those other two knives.
@Intoxacajun
@Intoxacajun 9 месяцев назад
Did you add the scales to the griptillian and if so what brand are they? I have the griptillian and just do not like the handle feel, and probably love it if I could upgrade the handles. Good video!! For the value Cold Steel knives are hard to beat!!
@ElonaldTrusk
@ElonaldTrusk Месяц назад
I carry the native 5 lw and a cold steel verdict g10. Both light and tough.
@ccooper8040
@ccooper8040 7 лет назад
A better comparison would have been the Native 5 with G10 D s35v steel.
@chrisventer3060
@chrisventer3060 3 года назад
I have code 4 love it
@blkbyrd
@blkbyrd 6 лет назад
I can't figure out how he ended up with the Spydie being anywhere close to the price of the Benchmade. When I look it up the Benchmade is like $50 more and the Spydie is only about $20 more then the Cold Steel. Also S110 I actually haven't found to be that bad to sharpen with a decent set up (I use a Hapstone Pro). 3rd he should've compared either the 154CM model of Griptilian or gone up in class with the Spydie and Cold Steel to make it a legit comparison.
@lukuscarter3563
@lukuscarter3563 Год назад
Nice video man.
@sputumtube
@sputumtube 7 лет назад
If you think S110v is hard to sharpen, have a go at ZDP189 - it took me weeks of honing and stropping. It's sharper than volcanic glass now though. I'm almost scared to use it....!!
@CedricAda
@CedricAda 7 лет назад
paul greenwood I look at those rockstead knives at 67 Hrc ZDP and almost cut myself
@sputumtube
@sputumtube 7 лет назад
CedricAda Gear and Outdoors I've seen 'em. Mad innit? And just look at the feckin' prices! You'd never dare use 'em for anything other than showing yer mates. And if you want even madder prices, have a look at Jim Skelton's channel. All custom stuff but oooh, so beautiful...;)
@user-uc1vd7kr5n
@user-uc1vd7kr5n 8 лет назад
What is your favorite one?
@CedricAda
@CedricAda 8 лет назад
the mini grip :)
@mistersmith3986
@mistersmith3986 Год назад
Hands down Recon 1
@1809vishal
@1809vishal 7 лет назад
plz help me choose between coldsteel recon1 (spear point) & American lawman (spear point)... this will be my first edc knife🔪
@CedricAda
@CedricAda 7 лет назад
+Vishal Dighe American Lawman, definitely
@1809vishal
@1809vishal 7 лет назад
CedricAda Gear and Outdoors thanks alot man! Even i was more inclined towards lawman... also thanks for video,keep uploading more nd more videos👍
@jmuk3571
@jmuk3571 7 лет назад
Vishal Dighe. Lawman all the way.
@Xyrium
@Xyrium 6 лет назад
If one can get past that terrible gap on it when folded. :)
@catz2006
@catz2006 6 лет назад
get lawman or recon 1 if you have strong fingers, the tri ad lock is so hard to disengage. for similar amount of money you will be better off with a spyderco manix 2/ endura 4/ para 2...
@getfucked2164
@getfucked2164 7 лет назад
What if I live in Canada and I dont have to carry childrens knives like what u got. I carry a new 2016 recon 1 with a 4 inch blade. As far as carrying in a sheath there's no restriction in size. Lol. UK and Australia are so restricted it's a joke.
@getfucked2164
@getfucked2164 7 лет назад
Love Australia tho no question same with UK.
@GorillaBikeRider
@GorillaBikeRider 7 лет назад
It isn't about being children's knives, some of it is the practicality of how much bulk and weight you want in your pocket. I live in Michigan and I could carry my full Recon 1 if I desired but it's just ridiculous for EDC, for my needs anyway.
@Adam666...
@Adam666... 6 лет назад
Bench made contigo, it's a beast but carries well in your pocket
@asdfgidji879
@asdfgidji879 6 лет назад
i live in texas i could legit carry a long sword but i still dont like anything bigger than my dragonfly
@lovemyamunition
@lovemyamunition 6 лет назад
get fucked how's that sweeping knife control legislation going in Canada 😂
@bassraptor4085
@bassraptor4085 8 лет назад
If the benchmade had a full flat grind it would be better
@CedricAda
@CedricAda 8 лет назад
I agree. FFG is the best grind for smaller blades. Bigger blades can be taller so they can handle other grinds better, like the Cold Steel American Lawman and its hollow grind for example. A great cutter and slicer, on that one.
@antoinedoinell
@antoinedoinell 5 лет назад
I agree. FFG is my personal fav for edc. Ritter designed a grip (came in mini too) with a leaf shape blade and a much higher grind. Been lookin on ebay to swoop one.
@menacewithaknife4045
@menacewithaknife4045 5 лет назад
I only buy USA made knives so I will never buy a Cold Steel knife. Until recently I was leaning towards the Benchmade now undecided. Great review thanks 🐱
@FearNoSteel
@FearNoSteel 8 лет назад
im a big spydie guy but id get the mini grip hands down so expensive for aussies thats dedication
@cycloneoutdoors7781
@cycloneoutdoors7781 8 лет назад
I think if I had to rank them, I'd put the mini grip first, spyderco second and the cold steel third. I've just never been fond of the way cold steel does handles, on a lot of their knives, the handles are so that they pretty much make you hold it in a certain way with finger choils and such.
@jimyocum9556
@jimyocum9556 6 лет назад
I really like my mini griptillian but Benchmade has serious issues with quality control..I have a native5 that came flawless as well as a mini ak47..love all three but the grip took three trys to get one that after a few hours of work getting the edge straightened out is now on par with the others..
@Xyrium
@Xyrium 6 лет назад
I'm not buying the propogated QC rumors. I just picked up a 484 and it was flawless. Every manufacturer, especially in mass produced units, makes a few lemons. However, I will say, Cold Steel and ZT are probably the most consistently good products at this time, IMO, when the product design itself isn't a problem. I wish Sypdie would give up on those crappy FRN handles though, in all price ranges.
@jimyocum9556
@jimyocum9556 6 лет назад
P Hanley when it's actually happening to you it's not rumor... buying Benchmade sight unseen and soon enough you'll find out...
@Xyrium
@Xyrium 6 лет назад
Jim, I totally understand the misfortune of mass market knives and I don't mean to dismiss your experience and apologize if I conveyed it as such, but I have three BMs now, and all were excellent out of the box (good fortune perhaps). I'm also the furthest thing from a BM fanboy...I prefer ZT over them any day, mostly, by design. :)
@richardsaunders5717
@richardsaunders5717 7 лет назад
Your like my daughter, the blue did it
@jameshinrichsen9238
@jameshinrichsen9238 8 лет назад
Good vid and il I've your new user picture
@CedricAda
@CedricAda 8 лет назад
Thanks! I suck at that sort of thing so it took me ages
@tindra98765
@tindra98765 5 лет назад
firs of all SPYDERCO...spYDer-COW _____sounds better. (their designers have probably got hooked on Opium (or something). CREATIVITY !!!!!
@stuardoloy1104
@stuardoloy1104 7 лет назад
My heart will always go for spyderco ... but benchmade runs very close
@jimyocum9556
@jimyocum9556 6 лет назад
I use to be the same way but then I went to the dark side of cold steel and never looked back!!..I find more value for the money with CS.. although my 940,mini grip,and crooked River along with a few Spydercos will never leave my collection..
@ronaldo77782
@ronaldo77782 Год назад
Any knife is a fighting knife
@205jab4
@205jab4 6 лет назад
Not needing a strong lock just sounds stupid. The stronger the better. You may not need it every day but if you ever do then you have it.
@gwailotus9154
@gwailotus9154 5 лет назад
lots of dummies in the knife gun world
@csquared4538
@csquared4538 3 года назад
Why does it take 20 minutes to say Cold Steel. Whoever makes the biggest edc is clearly the best knaff co
@raversman
@raversman 7 лет назад
No pm2?
@dalecarpenter8828
@dalecarpenter8828 4 года назад
They are all cnc made knives !
@HWGAFoundation
@HWGAFoundation 8 лет назад
appels and pears.
@CedricAda
@CedricAda 8 лет назад
and oranges!
@CedricAda
@CedricAda 8 лет назад
no lemons thankfully!
@luisarellanorn3309
@luisarellanorn3309 6 лет назад
Any Blade is defensive....do you have any military experience? Thanks
@mr.e9017
@mr.e9017 5 лет назад
All American companies. The one made in USA wins. Go figure.
@Prometheus1111
@Prometheus1111 5 лет назад
if you didn't use a guided sharpener for all three knives and set the edge angle the same with the same grit finish, your cutting test wouldn't be accurate. Even that aside the difference in blade shape would even still present an element of inaccuracy.
@CedricAda
@CedricAda 5 лет назад
i use a guided system, but you are right, there are elements of inaccuracy. Better than doing nothing though, and just leaning on anecdotes and feelings for how I think about performance I figure.
@Prometheus1111
@Prometheus1111 5 лет назад
@@CedricAda right, good to do your own research. I often hear people quote a steels performance based on someone else's observations. I have test a lot of steels myself, my finding differ a lot from what I've read.
@_superjoe
@_superjoe 2 года назад
COLD STEEL
@LightInnDmountain
@LightInnDmountain 2 года назад
Yeah yeah, benchmade is a Flicker fun fun and look at all the colors …………NOT ….recon all the way, NUMBER ONE safety, #2 price and #3 reputation with owners with bad ass jobs and pure reliability. if you want to flick and flick get a gonzo for $20
@thefullyawakened3021
@thefullyawakened3021 6 лет назад
With those 3, I will take the Cold Steel😏
@laloguillen6109
@laloguillen6109 8 лет назад
my mini griptilian #256 first run is a safe queen
@Cujobob
@Cujobob 6 лет назад
You're comparing the best Benchmade vs a budget Spyderco (with the upgraded steel). I'd take a PM3 every day of the week over any of those options though they're all quality knives (Native is one of my least favorite Spyderco knives). The axis lock is severely flawed IMO as the springs will and do fail (same reason I hate assisted opening knives). FRN and FRCP I don't like on medium or larger knives. On the delica I can almost stand it until I hold the G-10 version. Still, any of these options would be fine knives if you could only have just one... minus the axis lock spring issues.
@UdNeedaMiracle
@UdNeedaMiracle 6 лет назад
The griptilian is not the best benchmade. It is part of their lowest "tier" in their lineup of knives.
@Cujobob
@Cujobob 6 лет назад
UdNeedaMiracle this particular griptilian is quite expensive and it's still arguably their best and most popular knife.
@jkerekesh
@jkerekesh 5 лет назад
Obviously a Benchmade Fanboy!
@CedricAda
@CedricAda 5 лет назад
im actually a spyderco fanboy or a cold steel fanboy too depending on which person is watching his first of my videos and just cant help himself in the comments!
@fredgarvin4482
@fredgarvin4482 6 лет назад
cold steel all the way. spdygay handles look so cheap and plastic. tri ad lock is the best.
@diepn83
@diepn83 6 лет назад
Spyderco has that stupid hump and hole on top of all their knives that looks ugly asf.
@mistersmith3986
@mistersmith3986 6 лет назад
And the winner is: Cold Steel Ultimate Hunter.
@calibre45ymas89
@calibre45ymas89 4 года назад
1 Benchmade,2 Spyderco!
@tindra98765
@tindra98765 5 лет назад
i can promise you 100% that my new (green) MORA....Yeh MORA slice better & faster (have you seen the blade on the new MORA Fire-starter (WoW)...AND is cost 1/4....he he (Spydercow).
@Zainsmith26274
@Zainsmith26274 6 лет назад
Biast much
@CedricAda
@CedricAda 6 лет назад
probably a little
@mikecarr1484
@mikecarr1484 4 года назад
The cold steel doesn't belong in this category. It is a cheap ass china knife. Nothing more. Benchmade griptalion all the way..
@kabirh3626
@kabirh3626 4 месяца назад
Recon 1 is a tactical blade 🤦🏽‍♂️ come on dude know your knives
Далее
Send this to an artist… 😉 #shortsart
00:19
Просмотров 3,6 млн
5 Unpopular Opinions about Knives, Gear and EDC
17:23
Cold Steel Mini Recon 1: Tough Little EDC
19:19
Просмотров 61 тыс.
Time To "Revisit" The Cold Steel Recon 1
15:17
Просмотров 96 тыс.
COLD STEEL RECON 1 KNIFE REVIEW GOOD & BAD
14:52
Просмотров 8 тыс.
S-Pen в Samsung достоин Золота #Shorts
0:38
ОБСЛУЖИЛИ САМЫЙ ГРЯЗНЫЙ ПК
1:00