Тёмный

Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace - Classic Movie Review 

What The Flick?!
Подписаться 193 тыс.
Просмотров 84 тыс.
50% 1

In preparation for Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens, WhatTheFlick will review ALL 6 Star Wars movies in order before the December 18 release.
Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace starring Natalie Portman, Liam Neeson, and Ewan McGregor is reviewed by Ben Mankiewicz (Turner Classic Movies), Matt Atchity (Rotten Tomatoes), Alonso Duralde (TheWrap and Linoleum Knife podcast) and Christy Lemire (www.ChristyLemi...).
See what other critics are saying: www.rottentomat...
In 1977, George Lucas released Star Wars, the ultimate sci-fi popcorn flick-turned-pop-culture myth machine. It quickly became the biggest money-making film of all time and changed the shape of the film industry. After two successful sequels (1980's The Empire Strikes Back and 1983's Return of the Jedi) that extended the story of the first film, Lucas took some time off to produce movies for others, with mixed success. In 1999, Lucas returned to the Star Wars saga with a new approach -- instead of picking up where Return of the Jedi left off, Star Wars: Episode I -- The Phantom Menace would be the first of a trilogy of stories to trace what happened in the intergalactic saga before the first film began. Here, Obi-Wan Kenobi (Ewan McGregor) is a young apprentice Jedi knight under the tutelage of Qui-Gon Jinn (Liam Neeson); Anakin Skywalker (Jake Lloyd), who will later father Luke Skywalker and become known as Darth Vader, is just a nine-year-old boy. When the Trade Federation cuts off all routes to the planet Naboo, Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan are assigned to settle the matter, but when they arrive on Naboo they are brought to Amidala (Natalie Portman), the Naboo queen, by a friendly but opportunistic Gungan named Jar Jar. Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan plan to escort Amidala to a meeting of Republic leaders in Coruscant, but trouble with their spacecraft strands them on the planet Tatooine, where Qui-Gon meets Anakin, the slave of a scrap dealer. Qui-Gon is soon convinced that the boy could be the leader the Jedis have been searching for, and he begins bargaining for his freedom and teaching the boy the lessons of the Force. The supporting cast includes Pernilla August as Anakin's mother, Terence Stamp as Chancellor Valorum, and Samuel L. Jackson as Jedi master Mace Windu. Jackson told a reporter before The Phantom Menace's release that the best part about doing the film was that he got to say "May the Force be with you" onscreen. ~ Mark Deming, Rovi
Watch more movie reviews: • Reviews of Movies Rele...

Опубликовано:

 

2 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 355   
@nickstoli
@nickstoli 8 лет назад
I give it a 10. Of course, I'm referring to Ben's review.
@sirilidionilirium4857
@sirilidionilirium4857 8 лет назад
+Jay Quintana plinkett's review of the phantom manace was better :)
@Nightstalker314
@Nightstalker314 8 лет назад
+Sirilidion Ilirium he put the most relevant arguments into a few sentences
@Adro_Diablo
@Adro_Diablo 8 лет назад
+Jay Quintana Ben is right 100%. 3 eps of horrible saber fighting...
@chashofclans3212
@chashofclans3212 7 лет назад
Wаaааtсh Stаr Wars: Ерisоооdе I - The Рhаntom Мееnасe оnline hееerе => twitter.com/8b41997f6407b3a94/status/822797024072302594 Star Wаrs Ерррisоdе I Тhе Рhаntоm Меnaсе Clаssiс Моviе Rеview
@marikotrue3488
@marikotrue3488 8 лет назад
I vote for adding all of Ben Mankiewicz's rants to The Phantom Menace dvd extras. I so feel his pain. Hopefully I will heal after December 17.
@DJ-wl5qo
@DJ-wl5qo 8 лет назад
He should do a full commentary track.
@democrazy69
@democrazy69 8 лет назад
+Mariko True Don't get your hopes up. Look at JJ Abraham's Star Treks.
@woooweee
@woooweee 8 лет назад
+Mariko True Just watch the redlettermedia epic reviews, better than the movies by a long shot. /watch?v=FxKtZmQgxrI
@JoshBlanksby
@JoshBlanksby 8 лет назад
+( ͠° ͟ʖ ͡°) look at the buzz coming out of the premiere, not a bad thing to be said.
@democrazy69
@democrazy69 8 лет назад
josh blanksby Buzz is another word for hype. I'll believe it when I see the movie.
@JoaqMan
@JoaqMan 8 лет назад
Wow, Ben's rant about lightsabers is amazing.
@detubeme
@detubeme 8 лет назад
+J Wizard Phoenix I think all 3 movies just sort of blended together for him and by the time he saw them whip out lightsabers for the 19th time, he's was just checked out.
@damianjackson6396
@damianjackson6396 8 лет назад
Christy you're hot. Alonso, you actually look like George Lucas with glasses.
@MrMLGuel
@MrMLGuel 8 лет назад
"It's a movie for shitty kids." -Ben Mankiewicz 2015
@vincentknight27
@vincentknight27 8 лет назад
Lol, Ben ripped this movie to shreds.
@woooweee
@woooweee 8 лет назад
+Vincent Knight that's nothing.. /watch?v=FxKtZmQgxrI
@Nightstalker314
@Nightstalker314 8 лет назад
+wooo weee yes, we all know this one. so there is no more need for other opinions? also 70 mins vs. couple of sentences.
@JoshuaLoftis
@JoshuaLoftis 8 лет назад
It deserves it Phantom Menace sucked all kinds of ass.
@DJ-wl5qo
@DJ-wl5qo 8 лет назад
Jar Jar is the key to all of this.
@dvepps6780
@dvepps6780 8 лет назад
apologist... talk about polishing the cow pie.
@ttvmovies5961
@ttvmovies5961 8 лет назад
+Dylan Paterson It's poetry. It rhymes. Each Stanza rhymes with the previous one.
@thedashboard9562
@thedashboard9562 8 лет назад
+Dylan Paterson It's so dense...
@ttvmovies5961
@ttvmovies5961 8 лет назад
DV Epps ***** He's just quoting Lucas from the behind the scenes materials for Th Phantom Menace.
@phaznac
@phaznac 8 лет назад
+Dylan Paterson It's gonna be great, it's gonna be great.
@richardatthemovies8791
@richardatthemovies8791 8 лет назад
I'm not gonna lie,I thought this movie was better than Attack Of The Clones.
@ObeseYeti
@ObeseYeti 8 лет назад
Agreed
@sofiaa1616
@sofiaa1616 8 лет назад
As much as I dislike Phantom Menace, I have to agree with you.
@Utracia1
@Utracia1 8 лет назад
+Richard At The Movies Because it is better, Episode II is the worst of the lot.
@sofiaa1616
@sofiaa1616 8 лет назад
***** What, you didn't find the great romance for the ages compelling? I can assure you that, as a lady, nothing makes me drop my panties faster that when a man tells me he's a fascist and a mass murderer XD
@classactionsteve
@classactionsteve 8 лет назад
Hero.
@JoaqMan
@JoaqMan 8 лет назад
It's so dense, every single image has so many things going on.
@richardatthemovies8791
@richardatthemovies8791 8 лет назад
I love the trade federation scenes.
@martin43427
@martin43427 8 лет назад
+J Wizard Phoenix Fuck you, Rick Berman. You ruined this, too?
@rbrtchng
@rbrtchng 8 лет назад
+paul rai What is it with Ricks?
@DrewPBalls
@DrewPBalls 8 лет назад
+J Wizard Phoenix where is that comment from? and why is everyone using it? and why does everyone use everything ?
@criticalgeek9187
@criticalgeek9187 8 лет назад
You're the key to all this +J Wizard Phoenix.
@seyma1509
@seyma1509 8 лет назад
I can listen to Ben complainin about Star Wars all day.
@BrendanBeckett
@BrendanBeckett 8 лет назад
I genuinely liked this movie when it came out. I was 14 at the time. It took time and reflection to realize how bad it was.
@2nd3rd1st
@2nd3rd1st 8 лет назад
+Brendan Beckett No, you just grew up. These are movies for kids, as evidenced by yourself.
@JoshBlanksby
@JoshBlanksby 8 лет назад
+2nd3rd1st "these movies are for kids" isn't true, they're for no one, they don't even know who they're for, George put childish elements in them intertwined with the murder of children.
@DADchs13
@DADchs13 8 лет назад
+2nd3rd1st no I saw this movie in theaters at 6 with my parents and like Matt's kid, was bored 20 minutes into it. It is awful for kids as well. It was such a bad experience I remember it vividly and cant watch the movie anymore because of it lol
@daAnT1990
@daAnT1990 8 лет назад
the original Star Wars was for kids as well and you wont find anyone who thinks it is shit now....
@jollyblue
@jollyblue 8 лет назад
It's so funny to see Ben's face throughout this video... thnking to himself, "Why am I even here talking about this movie" LOL.
@tjtoonz
@tjtoonz 8 лет назад
say what u will about the film but the pod race scene and the darth maul fight was well executed.
@ohthepeppers
@ohthepeppers 8 лет назад
+Tj toonz The pod race sequence goes on for WAY too long though.
@martin43427
@martin43427 8 лет назад
"Star Wars: The Phantom Menace" was the most disappointing thing since my son...
@JoshBlanksby
@JoshBlanksby 8 лет назад
Okay even though I know Ben isn't a huge fan of Star Wars he still gets the importance of the original trilogy and is so fucking right about this movie, it's complete trash and hard to watch. Him saying "who fucking likes this movie" at the end killed me.
@Fangtorn
@Fangtorn 8 лет назад
I'm totally with Ben on the lightsaber fights. So many people say of the prequels "well at least the lightsaber duels were better in the prequels". No they weren't! They were sterile and passionless and looked like over-choreographed dance routines fought by characters we never felt at risk. The fights in the originals were not as stylistically impressive, but they were passionate and impactful confrontations between opposing characters, not just flashy action scenes.
@richfaircloth1464
@richfaircloth1464 8 лет назад
Matt: "I got Gabe on the Prequels." Alonso: " I'm calling Child Services.
@jenisedai
@jenisedai 8 лет назад
I refuse to let my kids watch 1-3. We watched Spaceballs instead.
@BIGTENFanatic
@BIGTENFanatic 8 лет назад
You're a great parent
@Singgen
@Singgen 8 лет назад
+Thessarabian You are bad parent. There are many ones who loved PT. And OT looks outdated now. They ain't gonna like it for sure. The magic of OT was that it was 1st. Now, there are many products same as OT.
@Chillguy99
@Chillguy99 8 лет назад
+WolverinesNation92 I'm getting really damn tired of this attitude. Since when has it become socially illegal to enjoy a piece of entertainment!? I love this movie. I've been defending the damn thing for over a decade and I will keep defending it. I've hated Jar Jar Binks since the first time I saw him but the positive aspects of this film far outweigh the negatives. The trailers for The Force Awakens didn't impress me at all (and this is coming from a guy whose favorite film is Return of the Jedi). I don't praise the Phantom Menace just to be contrarian, I really think it's a fun movie and I agree with Witson1991 you're a lousy parent for not letting your kids watch the prequels. God forbid they disagree with you and enjoy them.
@jenisedai
@jenisedai 8 лет назад
Witson1991 Bite me. You don't know me or how I parent. OT was groundbreaking. PT was "the search for more money" done to pander to an audience he thought was out there- but failed to take the original audience into account. Millennials love PT because it's part of their childhood, but Gen Xers were adults when it came out and can't stand them. Plus Jar Jar was racist as anything, which turns me off even more. My kids have seen clips of the prequels and thought they looked stupid, so I never bothered. They love Spaceballs and are looking forward to the planned sequel. When it comes down to it, we all have our own opinions and that's fine. If you like it, that's great-,if it's what brought you to Star Wars then I'm happy the films exist. I don't happen to like them, and that's my choice. And it's my choice not to expose my kids to them. They're old enough now that if they had any interest in them then they could ask. If they had asked I would have shown them- but they've never asked.
@Singgen
@Singgen 8 лет назад
Thessarabian FROM MY POINT OF VEIW YOU ARE BAD PARENT!!!! Ahah. Sorry. Could not resist. Sure. My comment about your bad parenting was mostly about my intention to be opposite to "WolverineNation92". And your sentence implied to me as first thought that you refused your children to watch PT, when they had a chance and you gone all nuts, like "Nope, I won't let you see it. Cause I hate it. You never gonna watch it. Not until I alive and shit. You gonna watch Spaceball and not this atrocity. I said NO!". Well, now you cleared to me that you just ain't gonna promote SW PT to them. Well. *clap*clap*. Thought there is Internet and ep 7. So eventually they will watch PT if they ever liked SW saga. Sure. OT was groundbreaking and all in it's own time. And what? PT is just about "the search for more money"? Let's forget that every product is about making money(it's only way how a person can measure the product to benefit creator). But just no. PT enhanced SW universe. It showed to us that SW is not just fairy tale with outdated design, it showed us interesting era. When Jedi weren't hunted down. It showed us what is Star Wars. It wasn't just one sandy Tatooine, that it has Coruscant. Now we have an idea how simple folk lives in this universe. It became something bigger. It introduced Jedi Temple and it's organization and so much more about other factors. If not for enhanced universe SW could never compete with LOTR, Warhammer or Warcraft and etc universes. Because it showed us that it have some background. I doubt that we could imagine The Old Republic if not for PT. That's why I love PT more that OT. Even those characters from OT. I don't buy them. I saw and read miriads about same characters. That's why I loved Qui-Gon Jin and Obi-Wan. They had a more complex character to me. More than just a Hero, a Rogue and Princess. p.s. srsly? clips of PT? Considering how everybody just hate them and enforce this opinion on others? There were things that I didn't like and practically knew nothing about because everybody hated them. But my opinion was totally different once I could watch it and judje it myself rather the nlisten to others. p.s.s. And what? I kinda LOLed for good here. Millennials and Gen Xers? Never heard about these err... names? Whose stupid idea it was to name generations? There are new generation and old. That's all to it. It sounds to me like someone tried to bring some pathos to himself. Like, look at me I am from Gen X/Millenial. Uff. Well. Maybe I am wrong and it had some deep meaning and all. Beats me.
@nikosvault
@nikosvault 8 лет назад
The least awful prequel. I stand by that. Shot on film. Enough real locations in places like Tunisia and Italy. Great villian (with no Lucas dialogue). Two good action scenes. And a dull but inoffensive lead performance by Liam Neeson. Give me that over Hayden and Natalie eating CGI fruit any day of the week.
@hiimanhuman
@hiimanhuman 8 лет назад
shot on film dosent make a movie good
@Frahamen
@Frahamen 8 лет назад
+datboi forthere No, but it does make it a film...
@sofiaa1616
@sofiaa1616 8 лет назад
+nikosvault Honestly, as much as I dislike Phantom Menace, I have to agree with you. I think by far the worst one is Attack of the Clones. Unlike that movie, Phantom Menace at least looks like it was trying to be an actual movie and had what tried to pass for charm (even if it failed). People just claim this one to be the worst one because it's the first in the prequel trilogy (and thus was the most hyped and subsequently disappointing one at the time of its release) and because it has the most Jar Jar. But I would honestly take Jar Jar over that grating Anakin/Padme romance any day.
@MrFishDishWish
@MrFishDishWish 8 лет назад
+nikosvault Darth Maul is basically just a cool-looking bad guy with no characterisation at all, he's hardly a "great villain".
@nikosvault
@nikosvault 8 лет назад
I am the Table Compared to any other villian in the prequel he is. And I have no problem with the mysterious silent-killer type.
@Tall_Order
@Tall_Order 8 лет назад
Jar Jar Binks is still around but these days he's going by his new post-op name Sarah Palin.
@basquat76
@basquat76 8 лет назад
Yeah that poor kid, he was sold from the get go. Kid actors are a 100% reliant on their director guiding them through it. You get a director who just sits on his ass and drinks coffee the kid doesn't have prayer of a chance.
@Phi1618033
@Phi1618033 8 лет назад
I highly recommend RedLetterMedia's review of the Phantom Menace if you really want to know exactly what's wrong with this film.
@Liesmith424
@Liesmith424 8 лет назад
I love Ben's review. I want his quote as a blurb on the back of the box: "It's a movie for shitty kids."
@choklatechuck
@choklatechuck 8 лет назад
What is enjoyable about the pod race? So kid Vader is gonna win a race against a terrible looking CG animal. Why am I supposed to give a shit about this race? It's so long and boring. Literally more boring than Battlefield Earth.
@sofiaa1616
@sofiaa1616 8 лет назад
IKR? I don't get why everyone loves that scene so much. It goes on for wayyyyy too long and uses the exact same angles at all times.
@hanburgundy4317
@hanburgundy4317 7 лет назад
What's NOT to like about the Boonta Eve race? It's a high-speed high-stakes Ben Hur style chariot race through vast deserts and twisting canyons with the twist that the chariots are pulled by jet engines that roar like muscle cars. It's visceral in a way that few other scenes in cinema have ever achieved.
@MrJethroha
@MrJethroha 8 лет назад
Ben's right about the light saber thing, and it applies to pretty much all jedi related things in the prequels as well. They're over-used and they're over powered. The Jedi should've been on the brink of extinction during the prequels, that last remnant of a more elegant time. They should be inferior to the technology of the time, they should be like monks, hidden away, mostly keeping to themselves, but still fight for the good of the universe when Sith reappear.
@edgeninja
@edgeninja 8 лет назад
+MrJethroha The Jedi were on the brink of extinction in the period between the prequel and original trilogies. And also, I believe, around the time of the Old Republic.
@MrJethroha
@MrJethroha 8 лет назад
edgeninja extinction due to the fact that they're out dated, not because they were all unbelievably slaughtered by the clones. Why would monks ever be so numerous or tied into the government? They should be more like Japanese warrior monks, unaligned, and devoted to they're way of life. Instead they're warriors generals diplomats politicians cops spies and everything in between except wise and meditative like Yoda and Obi-wan or passionately good like Luke.
@Brutananadlewski
@Brutananadlewski 8 лет назад
+MrJethroha because they arent fucking monks.
@RevolutionCPT
@RevolutionCPT 8 лет назад
+MrJethroha With respect, then you want a different movie. What you're asking for is akin to saying that Harry Potter books and movies should focus on the Muggle Prime Minister, and how he deals with day to day, and Wizards coming in from the side. George Lucas wanted to tell the story of the Jedi and the Force with Star Wars. It makes sense that they are at the forefront.
@twiedenfeld
@twiedenfeld 2 года назад
Your version is a million times better and is something more akin to what I was expecting from these movies. Don't listen to these asshats who just want to see things go bang.
@Mutex50
@Mutex50 8 лет назад
I didn't realize this was a bad movie until the second time I saw it. I guess I was in denial the first time because I was just so excited to see a new Star Wars movie.
@fiable262626
@fiable262626 8 лет назад
My favorite star wars film, its just full of cool bits
@carinalastimosa
@carinalastimosa 7 лет назад
Re-watching these reviews after Rogue One and Ben's reaction to the overuse of light sabers is everything! I so agree. Thank you What The Flick for reviewing all of the Star Wars movies.
@NAETEMUSIC
@NAETEMUSIC 7 лет назад
I know this is unpopular, but I am at the age where the prequels came out when I was in 1st grade and I was absolutely enthralled by all three of them, and love them to death. Maybe because I saw them as a kid, but I fucking love them all. Sorry.
@notabot835
@notabot835 8 лет назад
ben, there is only *ONE* lightsaber battle in the phantom menace, calm down
@notabot835
@notabot835 8 лет назад
well sure, if you want to count the one where they clash blades for like 1 second before Liam Neeson jumps onto the ship and flies away *****
@basquat76
@basquat76 8 лет назад
+doody magoob I think he's talking about the lightsaber battles in all 3 prequels.
@vespertinnee
@vespertinnee 8 лет назад
Matt is blury af
@ohthepeppers
@ohthepeppers 8 лет назад
+strk Thank fuck it's not just me seeing that- I thought I was having a stroke :P
@mrjibran421
@mrjibran421 8 лет назад
Haha to all the people who say "You just hate the prequels cause of the original trilogy nostalgia", listen to what Ben Mankiewicz has to say!
@persebra
@persebra 8 лет назад
Everyone seems to have lost the ENTIRE POINT of the first three movies: Queen/Senator Amidala's wardrobe. One of the most amazing line of customs in all of Cinema.
@arad7613
@arad7613 8 лет назад
For me this is the best of the prequels. Here are my reasons: 1. This is the only prequel where I didn't know what was going to happen. 2. The CGI stuff was groundbreaking and looked very cool at the time. It opened the way to things like Lord of the Rings. 3. I really liked the princess. This was the first time I saw Natalie Portman and I was enamored. She's completely ruined in the next two. 4. The pod racing was the most exciting sequence in all the prequels. 5. Watto is funny. 6. Darth Maul is cool. 7. No Hayden Christensen. There are of course many problems, but I disagree with some of the complaints. The fact that you can measure the Force in a blood test? It's the same as saying "the Force is strong with him". The amount of Force you have in you is just a potential - you still have to develop it. The claims about "racism" are nonsense: these are aliens, and whatever racial identities you ascribe to them is just your own prejudices. Jar Jar Binks? A regular comical sidekick. I find him less annoying than C3PO.
@TopFlightSecurity415
@TopFlightSecurity415 8 лет назад
+arad7613 number 7 is the best reason
@agreatlotrfan6178
@agreatlotrfan6178 8 лет назад
+arad7613 Jake Lloyd was worse than Hayden Christensen in my opinion.
@DADchs13
@DADchs13 8 лет назад
This movie is an easy 5/7 perfect score.
@Stablemable2
@Stablemable2 8 лет назад
Am I the only one that watch this film more than once and still enjoyed it?
@Hypno_BPM
@Hypno_BPM 8 лет назад
Ben is right about the light sabers, too many people had them in the prequels and i personally feel like the end battle with maul was too "clean" and choreographed IMO.
@dvepps6780
@dvepps6780 8 лет назад
dunno if "classic movie review" is apt. drop the first word maybe :)
@DJ-wl5qo
@DJ-wl5qo 8 лет назад
What about "classic disappointment review"?
@TrunkMonkey3000
@TrunkMonkey3000 8 лет назад
+DV “Eppish” Epps These guys were probably paid by Disney to do movie reviews of all these old movies to build up hype.
@DJ-wl5qo
@DJ-wl5qo 8 лет назад
+TrunkMonkey3000 These men are hack frauds.
@nickstoli
@nickstoli 8 лет назад
I 'll never forget watching this on opening night. Before lights went out, the theater was at a fever pitch -- honestly, it was like being at a rock concert -- after the movie was over, it felt like all the life was sucked out. But we all rationalized the movie and said it was good. Only one guy had the cajones to admit it was a turd.
@MyTubeIsBetter20
@MyTubeIsBetter20 8 лет назад
Christie's impression of Jar Jar offended me more than Jar Jar's actual characterization.
@r3d0c
@r3d0c 8 лет назад
I love Ben just hate movies, sucks he has to torture himself like this.
@democrazy69
@democrazy69 8 лет назад
I agree. If Anakin had been a teenager, and then a fatter older guy in ep. 3, and if Jar Jar had died in the first scene, it might not have sucked.
@TheSpiritOfTheTimes
@TheSpiritOfTheTimes 8 лет назад
When I was 9, 10 and this movie came out I loved it. These movies are for kids, get fucking over it.
@AnthonyLewis1981
@AnthonyLewis1981 8 лет назад
Kids love trade negotiations!!!!
@TheSpiritOfTheTimes
@TheSpiritOfTheTimes 8 лет назад
+Anthony Lewis Only adults notice that part and only adults get bored by it- the kids see freaking CGI aliens talking.
@DJ-wl5qo
@DJ-wl5qo 8 лет назад
+TheSpiritOfTheTimes Nice try George.
@4kfrank276
@4kfrank276 8 лет назад
The worst thing Lucas did was put Jar Jar at the end of Jedi in the DVD releases.
@DJ-wl5qo
@DJ-wl5qo 8 лет назад
YAY! MEESA FREEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!
@Frahamen
@Frahamen 8 лет назад
+FilmFan Frank Two words: Despecialized Version.
@csjcsj2906
@csjcsj2906 8 лет назад
+Dylan Paterson *WEESA
@DJ-wl5qo
@DJ-wl5qo 8 лет назад
+So Jin Choi Well, exxxcccccuuuuusssse me, princess.
@csjcsj2906
@csjcsj2906 8 лет назад
Dylan Paterson (Tobias Funke style) ...excuse me.
@MyTubeIsBetter20
@MyTubeIsBetter20 8 лет назад
is it me, or does Matt look blurry and no one else does. it's like he was filmed in 420p and everyone else is in 1080p.
@xxWickedLifexx
@xxWickedLifexx 8 лет назад
+MyTubeIsBetter20 It's not just you. I wonder if it's the focus on camera one, maybe because he's sitting closer to it than everyone else?
@Airicks1
@Airicks1 8 лет назад
I saw this movie in 2000, I was 10, and I loved it.. Now when I watch it I can see the plot mistakes and the cheesy acting, but I still can't bring myself to hate it.
@sugarcane1234
@sugarcane1234 8 лет назад
Neither can I. I kind of feel the same way.
@alfredocornelio4329
@alfredocornelio4329 8 лет назад
Ben is on FUCKING point on the lightsaber battles. They are the last resorts of Jedis. Using them every freacking time takes meaning away and shits on the prequel and everything Yoda told us.
@adamJKpunk
@adamJKpunk 8 лет назад
Mankiewicz rocking the Verizon kickstand case
@HannahGK
@HannahGK 8 лет назад
Hahaha, Christy is such a dork. I love this gang. :)
@SoulStylistJukeBox
@SoulStylistJukeBox 8 лет назад
Ben's criticisms and observations are borderline incoherent. And most importantly WHY would you invite a guy who disliked the original trilogy along to review three more films in the same fucking series?
@axlehammer
@axlehammer 8 лет назад
Angry Ben is inspirational. His hand movements alone contribute to winning half of an argument.
@Timothy27778
@Timothy27778 6 лет назад
The phantom menace is a masterpiece. Lucas succeeded in making a Star Wars fim where the good guys are overall in control and the evil is in the background. The politics and world building are all great. I came out saying- 'that was awesome!" and everyone else was saying 'that was shit' I was like "WTF!"
@musicmann1967
@musicmann1967 8 лет назад
Wildly gesticulating Ben is funny as shit!
@ABevs
@ABevs 8 лет назад
These have been the most fun I've had watching any of your reviews. Great stuff.
@mexicanexalted1
@mexicanexalted1 8 лет назад
10:00 Darth Ben Mankiewicz
@trexation
@trexation 8 лет назад
Just a head start: I'm old enough to have seen Star Wars without the prequel being released. I watched Episode I in the cinema when it came out - I was a kid then (9-10 yrs) After rewatching all the prequels I have to say that Phantom Menace might be the best one of the three. Why? - real locations - somewhat interesting plot about the dark red faced hooded guy whatever - some kidfriendly racing shit (very star warsy) - a somewhat relatable fate: Anakin leaving his mother behind blaaaaah - the only character with an arc (Jar Jar. Ironic, huh? From an outsider to mega heavy General. That's an arc, sadly) - and yeah that redundant fight at the end blabla The other movies are just less of the practical love and more of the CGI-shittiness. And yes, Episode II ist by far the worst out of the three, but if you compare Menace to Sith... Sith has no sets whatsoever ("We built 70 floors", yeah, fuck you Rick) Sith is completely tone deaf and alienates its audience even more, when Menace was all about "Oh, Star Wars is back" Sith was about "Ugh, let's just finish this" and it shows. Scene after scene is pointless, there is no story and in the end we are watching two dudes fight because one of them choked a girl and murdered children. Back when Menace came out, some of the humanity in Star Wars stayed intact, but was raped by its two sequels.
@edgeninja
@edgeninja 8 лет назад
They hit on all the points when it comes to Ep. I: Awesome pod racing and end battle scenes, terrible everything else. Frankly, George Lucas could've skipped Ep. I entirely and the whole franchise would've been better for it.
@500midnightmary
@500midnightmary 6 лет назад
Jar jar sounded Italian to me.
@JohnnyH1982
@JohnnyH1982 8 лет назад
BEN IS RIGHT! The lightsabres were overdone and sucked in the prequels. Fuck, I had been waiting for SOMEONE on the panel to say this.
@jupiterkansas
@jupiterkansas 8 лет назад
Why do people like Darth Maul? He has zero personality and he looks like a WWF wrestler. Is it simply because he had the Boba Fett fight that Boba never got?
@cine_caro
@cine_caro 8 лет назад
The prequels are boring for the most part. But, that criticism at 10:02 was a bit extreme. Yikes, John Williams' music elevates the fighting sequences to a little more excitement.
@Scrapluv
@Scrapluv 8 лет назад
Zero?!?! It's dull pandering snoozefest, but the Dark Maul-Obi-Qui-Gon duel is worth at least two points!
@commandZee
@commandZee 8 лет назад
The Matrix was the badass movie of that year, it came out two months before Episode I TFM and raised the bar way up for the sci-fi/action genre.
@nicholashylton6857
@nicholashylton6857 7 лет назад
"A shitty kids movie..." *BINGO!!!* I was SUPER pissed off after I saw this movie in theatres. Wooden acting... A BORING premis (A war over a trade dispute? What was so valuable that it was worth starting an interstellar conflict?) Special effects that were distracting and unnecessary to serve the narrative.... Talking, talking, so much talking and I _still_ didn't get any sense of personalities or motivations.
@joelkelly4154
@joelkelly4154 8 лет назад
It always pisses me off when people bring up how much better the prequel lightsaber battles apparently are. There is one kind of awkward but also kind of not that bad fight that lasts about 5 minutes in Star Wars (as in 1977, I refuse to call it "Episode IV" or "A New Hope"). The other fights are taught, and character driven and they have heft and physicality. They're few and far between, making them events, and Jedi training ultimately comes off as less sword and more force and even thought orientated. In the prequel trilogy they're superflous, overly frequent, and too obviously choreographed. Did Qui Gon and Obi Wan even know about Darth Maul before facing him? Did they even care? I am have so many criticisms I could wright a whole essay, but to suffice it to say, I agree with Ben.
@Halderic
@Halderic 8 лет назад
I would give it a 1.5/10. (Exclusively for SOME decent effects) Soul sucking terrible film. I remember this theater experience so vividly. I saw it on the first weekend of release, was so excited, and then about 30 minutes into the film this when a wave of sadness washed over me when I realized this film was total shit and wasn't going to get any better. It didn't. Also, that light saber duel with Darth Maul wasn't very exciting for two reasons. 1. Looked WAY too choreographed. 2. No vested interest in Darth Maul since we knew almost nothing about him.
@DennisFrancispublishing
@DennisFrancispublishing 8 лет назад
Check out the anti cheese edited version of all three prequels. The cuts were much better than expected. The story is still weak but the movies work a lot better.
@james101089
@james101089 8 лет назад
This movie is a steaming pile, BUT......the Darth Maul fight at the end, with Duel of the Fates playing over the top of it, is awesome. I don't know what Ben's talking about there. George shouldn't have killed off Maul in the first prequel, he should have given him a much larger role. Wouldn't have saved the prequels as a whole, but they'd have been more watchable. As it stands, the only one I've rewatched in the last 10 years is RotS (and the Darth Maul fight on several occasions).
@theolamp5312
@theolamp5312 8 лет назад
Glad I never watched any of the "Prequels". That would have been 7 hours of my life I could never get back. Glad I watched "Ex Machina" & "The Martian". Both were great. And, Ex Machina gave me food for thought to think about It afterwards. Oscar Isaac was brilliant in it.
@DangerousTalk
@DangerousTalk 8 лет назад
You guys thought the Phantom Menace was Darth Maul? You totally missed everything this movie was about.
@Stand_By_For_Mind_Control
@Stand_By_For_Mind_Control 8 лет назад
I think this is the only prequel where the problems run deeper than the dialog. Much, much deeper. But in 1999 I didn't give a shit. The film was a fucking feast for the eyes that we'd never seen up to that point. So give it credit for that. I realize that 4 Transformers films later it's difficult to remember there was a time when CGI to the point of visual noise was a thing people actually really wanted to see. Wisest words I've ever heard on this show, though: "Don't start your kids on the prequels". Amen.
@RockNTroll555
@RockNTroll555 8 лет назад
I watched The Phantom Menace just the other day and loved it. Do little Anakin and Jar Jar Binks kinda suck? Sure. But the film still has imaginative locations, bitchin Pod Race scene, awesome light saber battle, fantastic musical score and some hilariously insentive racial stereotypes. "Mind tricks don't work on me, only money." says the hook nosed alien. Love that scene!
@zacharyfarr5044
@zacharyfarr5044 8 лет назад
the next one is worse
@JAContes
@JAContes 8 лет назад
About 1/3 of this movie was decent, the rest was just plain terrible! I will admit that I watched it numerous times back in 1999/2000 for Natalie Portman. She was my first and last celebrity crush...
@grjeremy
@grjeremy 8 лет назад
This is why George Lucas should never be allowed to direct another Star Wars movie. Three strikes, you're out...Six strikes if you count what he did to the originals when he re-released them. George went full Yoko Ono, and you can't put the band back together again!
@bucksdiaryfan
@bucksdiaryfan 2 года назад
The bearded guy brings up a point that I argued even before the prequels were released -- since the original trilogy basically copied World War 2 equipment, I felt it would have been cool if the prequel trilogy copied World War 1 equipment... it would make more sense in the whole technological chronology
@bigideas3
@bigideas3 8 лет назад
I don't think most of them watched the movie recently. Ben probably has not seen it since 1999, 16 years ago. Tons of movies that came out since TPM, especially ones with clones or droid armies, have taken from this movie. Ben doesn't even like the original trilogy. A 0 is completely ridiculous.
@rikumajumder1558
@rikumajumder1558 8 лет назад
The too much Lightsaber is f*cking ridiculous. The prequels may suck but the Lightsaber battles were far better and needed. The sequels were a time when Lightsabers were illegal in the universe and there weren't Jedi's. So obviously the Prequels would have more LightSaber battles. Such a stupid thing to say...
@worldprez6655
@worldprez6655 8 лет назад
Alanso is totally wrong, it's a fantastic kids movie I totally loved it as a kid (including thinking JarJar was hilarious), it's just not a great adult movie. It's ok though. I keep hearing people bitch about tariffs, which is bizarre there's zero tariff debating in the movie
@EasyZee69
@EasyZee69 8 лет назад
The Star Wars prequels are my top 3 worse movies ever made, just so you know where I'm coming from. Having said that; I just thought of something that I have never heard anyone mention, something that would have made the prequels better. The main planet/location of the prequels should have been Alderaan. If we got to see a peaceful, beautiful planet, and get to know it's citizens, then it would have had much more impact when the Empire blows up the planet in the original movie. It would give us a whole new perspective when the planet blows up, we know the characters that lived there, we see their society and relate to it's people. It was a huge missed opportunity to give a lot more emotional connection to an important event in the original movie. Alderaan is only briefly mentioned at the end of the 3rd prequel, just to tie up some lose. Anyway, it boggles my mind how bad the prequels are.
@takanara7
@takanara7 8 лет назад
I would hardly call the Phantom Menace a "Classic". Although on the last episode of _Movie Fights_ (on the ScreenJunkies youtube channel) they randomly chose prequels to defend and Keven Smith had to defend it. Pretty hilarious.
@cuyanartjom8175
@cuyanartjom8175 7 лет назад
Okay, as some people seem to have their problems with the Anakin/Padmé romance and their age difference, I just want to say, in Phantom Menace the character of Anakin Skywalker is 9 years old and the character of Padmé Amidala is 14 years old.
@chinaskibloodline
@chinaskibloodline 8 лет назад
I recently watched a making of video and Jar Jar is even played by a black guy; it was originally in part a guy in a rubber suit that they eventually completely replaced with CGI, but yeah it is a black doing the floppy legged walk saying those lines.... there's also even a bit where Lucas says "I think I might've taken it too far there but we can't do anything about it now"
@underweightHater
@underweightHater 8 лет назад
the lightsaber battles do SUCK in the prequels. originally it was more a 2 handed weapon and the old fights looked linda like kendo. it was treated very seriously, the way you would act if one wrong move could end your life. the prequels have them twirling and cartwheeling around... its supposed to be super cool and badass but they sacrifice all emotional impact and sense of danger.
@TieXiongJi
@TieXiongJi 8 лет назад
The only way to watch the Star Wars series: Episode 4, 5, 2, 3, 6. Luke is built up then brought down by his father, then flashback to see how the father came to this point, then the redemption at the end. Much better than 1-6.
@nickstoli
@nickstoli 8 лет назад
"There's fucking Jar Jar Binks."Alonzo's line is right up there with Matt's, "this movie is shockingly half-assed."
@adronias
@adronias 8 лет назад
Ok Ben, you've somewhat redeemed yourself here. I can forgive your SWOT opinion. You're back in my good graces. Come on, get over here you big furry oaf.
@schmoab
@schmoab 8 лет назад
Ben is reviewing all 3 movies, which collectively sucked ass. This movie was awful but had a couple of great action sequences. I hate 2 & 3 much more than this film.
@coosoorlog
@coosoorlog 8 лет назад
I'm so 100% with Ben that light saber fights are so bad. too many and no soul. just empty choreography that's occasionally cool looking but mostly just tiresome.
@twiedenfeld
@twiedenfeld 2 года назад
Good fight scenes are where you understand each fighters abilities and strategies, and the fight goes back and forth and you know why whoever is winning is winning. It's not 20 minutes of stalemate and then somebody suddenly wins for some unknown reason.
@elisepatterson7869
@elisepatterson7869 8 лет назад
the set pieces looked good?! the CGI looked good? the cg has aged HORRIBLY. and WHAT set pieces?! it wa all green screen!
@bucksdiaryfan
@bucksdiaryfan 2 года назад
I remember when this clunker came out and we all initially tried to convince each other "Oh, it wasn't bad... there were some good parts" but then time passes and you realize it was an awful movie
@calvinthebold99
@calvinthebold99 8 лет назад
He is so right. Every lightsaber fight in the prequels sucks. No tension, so stakes. Always overly choreographed to the point that it is so obvious you are watching a fight practiced over and over and over again
@jorgetag
@jorgetag 8 лет назад
I was starting to dislike Christy for say "beautifully shot" in every review with grat cinematography, but after that impression, how I can?
@oberoth111
@oberoth111 8 лет назад
This movie was shit but how was there too many lightsaber fights? There was a 2 second fight between maul & jinn before jinn jumped on his ship and flew away. then there was the big one at the end. am I missing the other 20 or so fights Ben was talking about?
@chasington89
@chasington89 8 лет назад
The lightsaber battles really do suck, just an overly choreographed dance off. If you were to edit out the lightsabers the scenes wouldn't be any less interesting.
@Littlemisshavoc
@Littlemisshavoc 8 лет назад
I love how Ben doesn't like Star Wars as much as the others on the panel LMAO. His apathy is so funny to watch in contrast to their general enthusiasm in the movie reviews.
@hectarsavoie8166
@hectarsavoie8166 8 лет назад
Whys is Matt Achity out of focus, he looks really blurry :P
@beavispdx
@beavispdx 8 лет назад
I like the Prequels, but this was a fun discussion. I was hoping at least one of the 4 people liked the movie too, to give a dissenting opinion, but no such luck.
@ddunn67
@ddunn67 8 лет назад
7.5 for me...... - Also I hope Ben can get his money back cause he's PISSED the fuck off lmao
Далее
Лиса🦊 УЖЕ НА ВСЕХ ПЛОЩАДКАХ!
00:24
The Worst Movies Of 2017
12:48
Просмотров 37 тыс.
The Hateful Eight - Official Movie Review
14:14
Просмотров 123 тыс.
The Best Movies of 2015!
8:03
Просмотров 64 тыс.
Лиса🦊 УЖЕ НА ВСЕХ ПЛОЩАДКАХ!
00:24