Star Wars NOVEL Reveals Why Yoda FORBADE Obi-Wan From Training Luke As a Child - Star Wars Explained 

Space will do that 😎

No. He still wasn't quite there yet. After all even on his death bed he wanted Luke to kill Vader

@@markcarpenter6020 Very good point! Yes, Yoda improved a lot in exile but not enough to have the open mind and heart Luke proved to have.

​@@markcarpenter6020Yoda still thought Anakin was beyond redemption.

Luke should have listened to Yoda. He didn't help his friends by rushing off. They had to go back and rescue him.

@@jeffreyconner2937I don’t remember what happened in the movie but it was definitely necessary for him to go face vader

@@grantfuller6123 Only one time but not twice.

The clone wars arc about it in S6 is awesome.

Thank you!

Jedi are against Obsession and Obsession leads to the Dark side. Anakin developed an obsessive nature due to his lost of his mother.

My thoughts exactly

Obi wan had believed he killed Anakin, then separated his kids later probably under Yodas orders. Guessing Yoda didn't explain everything to Obi Wan as the council had the habit of keeping secrets/hiding things they don't want discovered, but I barely started the video so... Yea.

They'd still have to hide them from Sidious, tbf. It always struck me as odd that Kenobi didn't know Anakin lived anyway. Surely he'd have felt if the chosen one, and his best friend, had died.

Lol but who is counting?

And I've answered you several times !!! It's already been covered on another channel ,search bar is your friend!!!!

@@strongislandzfinest23 the holocron you speak of was created by a different force user and thus does not contain the knowledge I seek. And thus my quest continues for I am one with the Force and the Force is with me. May the Force be with you...always

He's not going to do it

Day 298! Thats some Dedication!

Via force power he would. Yoda is overrated in light Saber combat

Given that Anakin was able to defeat Count Dooku, the ROTS novel shows that he was able to overpower the Sith even before Sidious provoked him to use the Dark Side, he was definitely nearing his and Yoda's level, and at the age of 23. Had he had another 2-3 years he may well have been able to utterly best Sidious

@@user-tx3ho6fl3s he also did a few times in the clone wars almost killed him too

@@user-tx3ho6fl3s One of the reasons tha Jedi do value self control and wisdom a great deal. Anakin has the assertiveness to be an excellent Jedi Guardian but the downside is that He is impulsive as hell. Anakin has plenty of flaws that Sidious exploited. Yeah you are right that if Anakin had the patience for that. Dooku is a Top tiered Sith Lord and Anakin matched him

@@DeathScepter It also shows Sidious' genius that he chose to turn Anakin after he became one of the most powerful Jedi, at least in the top 5, but before he he could address his faults

You can blame the Clone Wars show for this, more than the prequel trilogy

@@harrambou9468 why should i blame either? This is from ep3's novelization - my point stands.

What's really messed up is the Jedi grabbed people as kids but the sith actually didn't like training children because of their lack of life experience...of it wasn't for being constantly told the sith are evil there would be times it would be really hard to tell which ones are the good guys.

@@markcarpenter6020 neither r "good guys", both r mutually the worst of opposite ends of the spectrum of forceusers n their guiding philosophies. Jedi n sith both r the extremist version of two leanings while their origin really was centrist n that also as a focus not as coincidencial result. They weren't like that based on hindsight evaluation of their action, they acted above all to b that n evolved teachings n believes for that goal. The jedi perhaps r worse in the way, that almost all later force sekts resulted in a way from the jedi n their light sight extremist stance. Most afterwards resulted from disagreements n splintering factions, light n dark side leaning. Some that existed parralel were remaining disconnected for minor differences that were not really a philosophical divide but seen as such by the jedi which made that hericy - no clearer way to present as extremist than exclude any diversion to the own positions. The sith, though' being extremist darksiders, only are one of many examples that came to b like that n a pretty late one at that. Given the invidability of drifting into exttremism due to that side's believes very nature n with the age of the jedi in mind, it sticks out that for several times more than the sith's entire existence as an order, the jedi have prevented any group to evolve a dark side focussed tradition long enough to even reach sith level of corruption whatever era of sith u wanna pick. Before there exiled jedi met the species, the jedi for nearly 20000 years fought n destroyed every sekt that they deemed corrupted or fallen n stole or destroyed all connected objects they found. It's hard to b any more extreme n that is nostly true in modest times too. The zero tollerance regarding the dark side was never in question at the top n the increasingly dogmatic rules that limited the daily lifes were often excused by preventing things that "can lead to the dark side" but the less propable that was the more of a purely opressive regime they became n by excluding real learning about dark side views academicly, even 4 masters - their was never any competend to help once a student really fell, it was never recogniz time either. Also any genuine attempted help came from ppl that were just as ignorant or naive as the whole order just less easily hostile. Such attempts resulted in backfirering n making the helper into a convict or they ended useless cuz the person was too far gone before even be suspected. Otherwise it could have been met by more proactive jedi who acted rigurously n rather too early than late, causing injustice seen by other members n also causing fear n anger. I think either extreme upon becoming such in the eyes of others would cause a counter extreme by default no matter which was origin to the other. Both r definitly wrong or misguided views that harm or pervert the real thing that their beliefs r about n that means also both r correct about their judgement of each other as such n thx to their mutual viev as priority above all about their beliefs, both r blind to independend perspective or see them as inferior so they are as definitly reappearing as long the other is arround as they r impossibly ever to change closer to a better state cuz that demands internal reform aimed at leser extreme. Any deliberate reform they do was to get more extrem inside their framework or to widen the framework to allow further extremization beyond the current limits cuz extremism also includes a sense of superiority which is the guaranty for it to become hostile to all it doesn't welcome. No extremism can ever truely "tollerate" stuff longer than it has more pressing issues elsewhere to deal with. Some point n it wants to bother those who wanted just to b unbothered n kept for themself. That's quite a lot n rambled on into deeep theory,hm ? ;) Buttomline, both r as wrong as they can b n even twice as far from convincing each other than from being right so both allways pose the most potential for violence by existing but have to exist if the other does. That's why in both prophecies the meaning is that the chosen being will end both orders, just the misunderstood purpose of that makes 'em seem 2 n about 2outcomes implying the other to b false n a proof for the other belief to b false. Both think that the goal is a further purification. One thinks balance point they r helped to reach while being actually the obstacle between. The other think that destruction of both sides is a step to more extremes n don't understand that destruction to b the goal already. To bring a force tradition that is guided as it should the biggest inbalancing factors among forcetraditions must end cuz neither can tollerate the approach of a middleway as it was b4 the jedi began to change it. It won't mean there can't b a reformed version of the orders nor is it reall mythical, more a natural fact to happen caused by the force's will that is the same as a not to heavily inbalanced state. Means such a chosen one will appear that way as soon a treshold is breached but that is slowed by the neutralizing effect that both orders have on each other. Either will cause the chosen one not as help against the opposing side but as "the nuclear option" should they ever get the upperhand n gwet close to totally end the others. That's why vader's fall really was the thing that made him the chosen one_ The prophecy started to b furfilled when he kept personally pressing continued search n destruction of jedi after order 66. Killing sidious was just finalizing te task not the step to become the chosen one as result. It's commonly seen flipped, he doesn't becomes the chosen one as a process that is meant to b a lasting state, he reaches after balancing the force (ending the jedi n sith) like a method with him as the goal - he allways is the chosen one, which isn't a gradual but a single, defined thing. Either it's the one or not. N that one is there to do the thing, which is the goal.

To be fair, if they HAD tried, it might not have turned out as perfect as you’d think then, either. Think about it. Obi-Wan and Yoda, powerful and capable as they may have been, were wanted dead by almost *the entire galaxy* so they probably couldn’t have raised the children THAT well if they wanted to. Sure, the children would’ve learned Jedi values and skills, but the chances of them getting into trouble before it was the time to would’ve gone way up, and that part about familial care-or, essentially, a foundation of support alluded to in the book (and now this video) is just as vital. A physical footing, and also a MENTAL footing, was important. They clearly see this. It’s only made more valid by the fact that the Jedi were on the run. Besides, Obi-Wan and Yoda TRIED to take on Vader and Sidious themselves. They mostly failed.

@@harrambou9468 I'm reminded of what Sidious said to Vader shortly after Yoda started training Luke: "There is a great disturbance in the Force. We have a new enemy....I have no doubt that this boy is the offspring of Anakin Skywalker....He could destroy us....The son of Skywalker must not become a Jedi." So it's possible Yoda decided against training Luke and Leia as children to protect them from being detected by Sidious' far-reaching Force sensibilities, and from being subsequently hunted down and killed by the Empire. But if Sidious is that all-powerful, then why ever train them *at all?* As long as that question remains unanswered, the logic of Yoda's decision remains deserving of scrutiny.

Jedi is naturally against Obsession. Being attach is a part of life. They want their members to be attached to the Jedi Order within reasons of course

Better than the Disney universe

Most people who have read into some of those novels. The Darth Bane novels are fantastic. Give it a try if you like some parts of Star Wars.

The EU is real Star Wars.

Clearly you do lad or you wouldn't have typed about it.

Then leave?? You're allowed to enjoy the parts of the fandom that you want to, but you dont need to shit on the parts that you don't.