yes it would have gone both ways. if radahn was one second off with his attack he would've been caught with the lasers. but let's not dwell in the "if"s since they are really comparable.
And he would have, had he done his long distance lightning summon roar that one time after Radan had landed instead of uselessly spinning on the spot, whipping his flimsy tail around, geriatric, dementia contracting, two headed, stone faced freak of nature that he is
When Radahn uses Meteor to hit the first stage of Malenia. If Malenia changes to the second stage in place, she will be killed on the spot. Of course, this is under the condition of scaling in the same area.
@@chaossilvermoon so, Radahn can win only by glitch, because meteor can't one shot second phase of Malenia, especially if she has many HP left in first phase yet.
Still my favorite channel for these Elden Ring battles. Makes me wish I had a computer so I do some of these for myself instead of just having the console version.
out of all elden ring boss vs boss vid i've watched without any stat being altered done Malekith is the only one managed to beat both Malenia form but even that depend on rng
Yea even then its a 9/10 chance for a malenia win and thats including the destined death bug ticking during phase transition. She the top boss v boss souls character and the only soulsborne boss I can think off that might have a chance is demon of hatred. Even then I doubt
@@Toffee-clanit’s 6/10, 6 for Malenia, 2 for Maliketh and 2 draws. He is the only one who can defeat her even though she is OP and has a lot of broken things. The other bosses don't have a chance.
@@Toffee-clan I think Nameless Ring has a video and Malenia won 6/10. But you are right, there is a glitch that causes Destined Death status effect to transfer from Malenia's phase 1 to her phase 2. So in that video, she basically started out phase 2 with like 50% of HP. Also, her grab was not enabled in the video. I figure she probably would win even more if she had her grab on and the glitch was fixed. Also, I wonder how they would perform if we scale Maliketh to Haligtree root tier, just to be more fair.
@RodrickRex And btw the video is nowhere near base maliketh. He starts in phase 2 and has haligtree scaling. This coupled with malenias grab not working and the destined death bug all which still malenia had a 75% win rate proves my point how base maliketh looses 9/10
Radahn vs Malenia is the quintessential battle of overwhelming strength against masterly skill. And as so many animes have shown, skill always triumphs...
Rubbish. Her scarlet aeonia is anything but skill. Radahn defeated her the first time they met, and the scarlet rot exploded, essentially resurrecting her. It happens every time she fights, loses, and blows up the world rather than concede.
@@andyl8055I knew I'd get some nonsense like this. Thankfully I've read almost every item description, so... 1)Each piece of evidence suggests they fought each other to a standstill (Gideon, Millicent, Redmane Knight set) 2)As directly seen in the trailer, Malenia advanced on him and unleashed the Scarlet Aeonia to break said stalemate. She seems to have done this to break free Miquella's fate, which Radahn had chained. 3)Malenia was not then the Goddess of Rot (Scarlet Aeonia description, which is in the future tense). 4)Radahn did not fight the 'Goddess of Rot' as the Tarnished does. He only fought her 'Phase 1', so to speak, to a draw. Malenia couldn't control her powers quite as well back then. 5)If Radahn- a sane Radahn- were to fight the Goddess of Rot, it's implied he would quite firmly have lost, as the Goddess of Rot is the apex of Malenia's powers. 6)Malenia was trained by some sort of Zatoichi who sealed the God of Rot (a scorpion of whom she is the reincarnation), so she's obviously immensely skilled. 7)People treat it with surprise that Radahn was even able to match Malenia in the first place. In particular, Radahn and Jerren swore oaths to give each other honourable deaths if need be before the battle. 8)Yes, the blind triple-amputee must indeed have been VERY skilled to fight off a sorcerer-warlord who had literally every other advantage apart from the Rot- that of size, range, reach, being able to wield magic and, above all, not having the same disabilities.
@@andyl8055 that's literally a part of her skill set. Mind you the Melania Radahn fought was one who had already lost both feet, a leg, and an arm to scarlet rot, so her being hella incapacitated on top of not having eyes yet still putting up that good of a fight is nothing short of impressive. But telling her not to use her aeonia is like telling Radahn not to use gravitational magic or Placidusax to not use his lightning, Malekith his destined death, and Mohg his bleed or Nihil. If you need to handicap someone that bad and then also stop them from using certain skills in their set, their obviously a lot better then their opponent.
@@Count.Saruman👍🏻 And don't forget that Radahn broke Malenia's prosthesis and as a result the golden needle was also no longer able to contain the ROT power so she unleashed the Crimson Aeonia or Scarlet Flower which from what it looks like resembles a flower it's actually a Mushroom!
Morgott is the weakest of these major bosses. Because his damage is too low, mainly Holy damage. Moreover, the toughness and toughness reduction values are not very high, and the HP is not much. He was called "No Victory Legend" by the audience.
man. they did radahn's gear so dirty in this game. he has three different swords and there's not a single unique normal move between the three of them. and they're all colossals! why!! they should be curved greatswords! please!!!
Location sealings. Same units in different locations has different scaling, such like Cleanrot knight in Caelid has scaling(thats common version, not direct like this) base stats*11, when in Halightree base stats*29, some like this
@@Koknius Not quite that simple, but the principle is correct. Every location has a tier assigned to it; for example South Caelid is tier 11 and base HP is multiplied by 3.703. It only goes up to 21 though (base HP x7.422), so I wonder if EldenRingFights has extrapolated somehow.
@@Koknius What kind of unusual scaling is this? There are only 21 levels in the game, from id 7000 (0 lvl) to 7200 (20 lvl) on this principle [7000, 7010, 7020,...,7190, 7200]. Radahn's original scaling has id 7100 (10 lvl) with multipliers: HP = base HP * 3.7 Damage = base * 2.47 Flat defense = base * 1.13 Resistance = base * 2.18 While the original Malenia has the max id 7200 (20): HP = base HP * 7.42 Damage = base * 3.8 Flat defense = base * 1.23 Resistance = base * 2.73 What does 29 mean?
Bro, the fight against Astel seems incredibly natural, like "This is the reason why this guy is called starscourge, my fellas!" Vs Placi: DEAR GOD, I'm dying by epicness!! Vs Malenia: Well... Malenia being Malenia, turning extremely boring all that she touches. Vs Niall: 26:08 "Oh, so you wanna play jump? Let me show you how to jump, noob"
Radahn is supposed to be the “mightiest of all demigods” according to lore. Before any “because rot weakened him he is no longer” comments my man HOLDS UP THE SKY in his rotted maddened state. He’s a whole other beast. They nerfed him so hard he struggles against early bosses now… This is closer to what he should be. Not as high stats but close.
Prime Radhan got stalemated by Pre-Bloom Malenia, so he is obviously nowhere near the mightiest while braindead now, Malenia just became a Goddess later on after all.
In fact, Radana is indeed the most powerful demigod of the times of the schism, the only one who could kill him was Malenia and gods like Radagon, no one else could defeat him. And in the game Radan weakened greatly.@@gunchar06