No, there isn't really... just atomic structure and carbon content. The nanocarbon structures are equally negligible and the level of heavy metals present are comparable. And that is ignoring the fact that something with such a tightly knit atomic structure couldn't be used to filter, and the lack of fullerenes would have no effect on particulates or microbes
You should also study black mica and watch how the Chinese clean a dirty pond with it also study the effects of counter and clockwise spin of bacteria viruses and metals and the effect of shunigte or black mica. Also carbon pills are acceable in many stores here in the Netherlands against stomic pain from eating bad foods.
Carbon pills helping with stomach pain is PROFOUNDLY different from shungite filtering heavy metals (when they actually do the exact opposite). You could crush up limestone and it would do the same thing. That's the nature of carbonate minerals. You are misunderstanding the mechanisms. There are dozens of minerals that are microporous that do that. That is literally the nature of about 40 different zeolite minerals alone. That doesn't mean we mixed them with drinking water. They are used as industrial filters in mechanisms, they aren't being mixed with drinking water and then consumed
So carbon can react with the chlorine in the water? I wonder what is in all pitcher and refrigerator water filters….charcoal. Might be some carbon in charcoal. Are you going to do a fear mongering video about Brita water filters next? While you’re at it, make a video on the dangers of ingesting the known neurotoxin, fluoride
@@evoltap in the time it took you to write this, you reckon you could have spent that checking whether or not that carbon is treated activated carbon lol
@evoltap Also, and I REALLY want to make this clear, whether something is a "neurotoxin" is contingent on dose. There is cyanide in apples. That doesn't make them dangerous. I also, really cannot stress how basic this is either. If this wasn't the case, you'd keel over evey time you ate a vegetable. Fluoride is used for hundreds of things that you encounter daily, and is only dangerous in DOSES that are dangerous. Which is true for basically every poison you've ever heard of.
People need to understand that in chemistry, the dose makes the poison. Generally, people who understand very little about physiology and chemistry make noise about particular elements that in most situations naturally occur in vegetables. They do the same with vaccines because they don't understand basic science. There is pottasium cyanide in apples. Bananas are technically radioactive... these are both true, but it isn't an issue because these are trace amounts. They are utterly meaningless What most people do to combat this highly exaggerated drinking water hyperbole is to filter their water. All that does is remove the mineral content from the water and make it less valuable. Almost all of the fear mongering (with exception for very isolated examples that in no way occur on a national scale) is propagated by people on the Internet who are only pretending to understand subjects they clearly dont. Sometimes, I wonder what people assume a liver or kidneys are for? Fear mongering about tap water generally gets tracked back to companies selling bottled water. Funny that. Same as most climate change conspiracies originate from fossil fuel companies. They play the general public like fiddles to profit off ignorance
@@luketimberlake4223 Does this mean that taking small amounts of poison every day is completely okay, even if these amounts are broken down in the body more slowly than when taken quantitatively? How many japps did you get since 2020?
@@luketimberlake4223 are you defending tap water? It's no fear mongering that chlorine and it's byproducts are cancerous. Period. And most exceed the safety recommendations. What's dangerous is you are sitting here defending all the BS going on. There's poisons and toxins in the air food and water. You must not live in America and you must not know the amount of corruption going on in the amount of poisons and toxins in our food and water and air. I'm so tired of RU-vid videos with just nobody's making videos trying to tell us what everything is. From my experience, drinking tap water that only has chlorine in it, causes massive stomach disturbances and I've also puked from drinking tap water too much due to the chlorine in the byproducts it creates when the chlorine reacts with the other dissolved substances and minerals that are naturally in our water. Sodium fluoride is is putting a lot of water all over the US. The source of sodium fluoride comes from chemical plants and sodium chloride being a byproduct of what they're producing in the factories. You're going after a rock while there is much much bigger problems going on especially the government's allowing corporations to use all sorts of highly toxic and poisonous chemicals from food growing to production of toxic products like plastics and so many other things. Your comment right here totally bypasses a lot of truths and forces people to listen to the pure BS that you're trying to focus on when there's much bigger problems in this world.
Okay, and which peer reviews specifically did you draw from? Because usually when the average person says "I did my own study" if turns out that means "I googled it"
This video is a lie I know shungite water works wonders there is a war on consciousness and don't let them win with mis intelligence @@luketimberlake4223
How come PH levels get higher after putting shungite in water? Also if you were to get pure shungite then you wouldn’t have to worry about other contaminants?
I can not even put into words how basic this is in terms of minerology. I'll tell you what: tell me... what specific tests do you conduct on the shungite you put in your drinking water to assertine its composition? Be super specific. Because minerals don't form in a vacuum. Let me know how you test for arsenic, aluminium, cadmium, or any of the heavy elements that form alongside shungite? How do you know there isn't arsenopyrite in it? How much copper did you assume was safe? What about galena or any other lead based minerals? Tell me... how did YOU PERSONALLY check?
You think that more than one thing forms in the ground at once is "hearsay," lol. Okay, go to literally any academic filter and look at the x ray diffraction of shungite. Or look at the articles about this in the Russian journal of chemistry. Or literally any book that discusses basic minerology or perhaps look at the years' worth or educational content we have created on minerology - given that's what I do FOR A LIVING
There are 3 types of Shungite. What you have there is NOT elite noble shungite. You have type 2 or 3. 1. Elite or Noble Shungite is the highest quality Shungite. It contains over 90% of carbon. It is a rare black stone with a silvery shiny appearance, and it's very fragile. Due to its high carbon content, this type of Shungite has the most powerful benefits in healing and EMF protection. 2. Black Shungite or Petrovsky Shungite contains 75-50% carbon; it has a deep black color, similar to coal. Black Shungite is industrially mined, and due to its composition - carbon, other minerals, and chemical elements - can be cut in various shapes and polished. 3. Gray Shungite contains only 50-30% carbon, it has a dark gray color. It can be cut and polished in any shape. A wide variety of products are made from Black or Gray Shungite including Shungite bowls, plates, pyramids, spheres, cubes, towers, phone stands, flat pocket stones, skincare products, and jewelry.
But it isn't actually all that necessary to look all that hard, because in minerology its common sense, because shungite will often form alongside things like arsenopyrite which is an arsenic laden mineral. The whole shungite thing comes from very loose research that was thrust into the mainstream by hacks like Judy Hall, who with respect, is the only person in the world who would describe themselves as an expert... because she literally has no qualifications whatsoever in minerology, geology... or any science whatsoever for that matter. Half of what that woman said (author of crystal bible) was dangerous. She used to say that crystals laden with mercury lowered blood pressure, and all manor of absurd and baseless things. Putting shungite in drinking water makes no sense and would do more harm than good
@@luketimberlake4223 I have Shungite from Karelia from source. They have this in pharmacies and use it as a filter. How? They wash it good for 2 weeks and keep it water after that every day. Then is put in a glass receipient but not on the buttom, in the middle of in hanging for 12h. I do not use it in water but only around routers.
I can honestly say I have been drinking Shungite water made with ( Elite Noble Shungite) for close to 2 years without any ill effects... I have a Shungite mat for bathing, wear Shungite jewelry, pyramids for my home/electronics, cellphone...
its hilarious how poorly received this was, because it was well made and straight to the point. you know what though? the only people watching this are people searching for confirmation bias content, to reaffirm their existing woo woo bs. thanks for fighting the good fight......................... rationality is dying
Nope, im trying to find what the fuck it is because my friends are putting this shit into baby water and giving it to their toddlers. Im about to call fucking CPS. The fuck are people thinking putting some stones dug up in Russia , peddled by Chinese and their healthy standards into their DRINKING WATER.
Yes there is, the journal of water and health did extensive studies on heavy metals leaching out from shungite. And that's just one. Similar results were found by the Russian journal of chemistry
A Study of the Antioxidant, Cytotoxic Activity and Adsorption Properties of Karelian Shungite by Physicochemical Methods Liubov Skrypnik,1 Olga Babich,1 Stanislav Sukhikh,1 Olga Shishko,1 Svetlana Ivanova,2,3,* Oleg Mozhei,1 Ivan Kochish,4 and Ilia Nikonov4
Did you actually read the study? Cause it talks about pulverized Shungite into dust which reacts with few chemicals to produce anti oxidant effect. Anti oxidant effect which is 1000 less strong than compounds found in grapes. Also this is not in live organism. The dose to do any good would probably kill you since those nano tubes and nano spheres are actually toxic not only to bacteria, but also to human cells.
Awwwww didums, shall I assume your position on the matter came from a book written by a woman who also referred to herself as a witch? Or would you like me to list the peer reviewed data on this?
Chlorine in tap water bahaha if that's the case you getting fluoride as well foo you cant buy that without a hazmat LC 😂 in it not for teeth and bones bone hed
@lancesudberry209 super basic science: the dose makes the poison. Again...about as basic as you can possibly get in science. There is potassium cyanide in apple, and mercury in cabbage. You don't see those being framed as dangerous. It's just members of the public who don't know the first thing about science are easy to frighten, exactly because they don't understand science. They're also super easy to peddle nonsense to
Tap water in 1st world countries is safe to consume as is (in 90% of places) Tap water with quality filters in less safe regions or in poorer countries. I think Bretta is a pretty solid solution. Ideally there should be activated carbon and other materials in the filter to catch toxic minerals/metals + bacteria.
You use a lot of words to say nothing ... 1.Shungite is not a mineral ! 2. Neither is carbon considered a dangerous compound to come in contact with chlorinated water. 3.Toxins won't leech out of stone into water in any significant amounts. 4. Shungite or carbon 60 as it is called in more serious scientific circles has long proven to filter water better than active carbon a widely used material for this use. 5. It further has been used successfully in cancer therapy over recent years... Thanks for coming to my TED talk
1) Shungite is a mineraloid - the factor that makes it this is the lack of a highly ordered repeatable structure. One of the very things that WILL cause it to break apart in the water (basic mineralogy - I use "mineral" because your average person doesn't understand the term mineraloid (thanks for proving my point) 2) Shungite is almost never just carbon. That's literally the point, and carbon also isn't a compound. That's the literal definition of it being an element, meaning you don't know what compound means either. 3) Both three and four are complete twaddle, so I implaw you to show me the peer reviews, or at least articulate how a carbon filter helped cancer in a carbon-based lifeform. Please know this: out of every comment on every platform this has been posted - yours has the worst understanding of science
There is loads of research on C60 and cancer inhibition and chemo therapy modulation. Anyone interested can do a quick google search and find these Shungites properties will be hard to contest in the near future You are scared of potential toxins in a black rock but probably eat processed foods on a daily basis , just lol. Overspecialisation is one hell of a drug Good luck with your endeavours mate I'd think a bit about my condescending tone No wonder you are stuck at 704 followers... @@luketimberlake4223
Benzen5340, did you concuss your head as you crawled out of some subterranean neanderthal cavern? so you could get data to post this nonsense? or are you also afraid of 5g lol
Nothing saved the Russian soldiers during WW1, ignoring the fact that they lost. The medical conditions during WW1 were one of the catalysts for the very revolution that toppled the government and birthed the Soviet Union. Assuming that there was nothing wrong with drinking carbon laced with measurable amounts of mercury, arsenic, cadmium, aluminium and various kinds of heavy metal... there is nothing about putting carbon in drinking water that would save anyone's life. Out of every nation engaged in WW1 Russias medical care was considered the worst, and that was a fact that quite literally altered the course of history
