@@acecha05 Who exposed it? Firstly, they said that they were straight in 2001)) There are many early interviews in which this image was discussed. In Russia, absolutely everyone knew that they were not lesbians). The group collapsed when its main creator, the ideological inspirer Shapovalov, got thoroughly hooked on drugs. And the girls left him. Yulia also completely lost her voice. In general, the band broke up for objective reasons.
@@Leading23 Yeah, I heard of the drugs. Only thing I disagree with you here is nobody knew they were not lesbians, maybe in Russia, here in the states they did not know. Everyone I knew felt duped when it became common knowledge that it was just an act. I do not know who outed them, maybe they outed themselves. I just know for a bit there the fans were angry as hell. My niece straight broke their CD in half lol.
@@acecha05 The fact is that the girls have been saying from the very first day that they are not lesbians. But no one listened to them. It's been 21 years, people are still surprised that they are not lesbians)) I feel sorry for the girls, they are constantly negative, also from the fans. They didn't deserve it. Yulia has a daughter aged 18)) I.e. her daughter is already 4 years older than her mother when she starred in the video . Yulia was 14 years old at the time of shooting the video)
Mama, Papa Forgive me Out of sight Out of mind Out of time To decide Do we run? Should I hide? For the rest Of my life Can we fly? Do I stay? We could lose We could fail In the moment It takes To make plans Or mistakes 30 minutes, a blink of an eye 30 minutes, to alter our lives 30 minutes, to make up my mind 30 minutes, to finally decide 30 minutes, to whisper your name 30 minutes, to shoulder the blame 30 minutes, of bliss, thirty lies 30 minutes, to finally decide Carousels In the sky That we shape With our eyes Under shade Silhouettes Casting shade Crying rain Can we fly? Do I stay? We could lose We could fail Either way Options change Chances fail Trains derail 30 minutes, a blink of an eye 30 minutes, to alter our lives 30 minutes, to make up my mind 30 minutes, to finally decide 30 minutes, to whisper your name 30 minutes, to shoulder the blame 30 minutes, of bliss, thirty lies 30 minutes, to finally decide To decide To decide, to decide, to decide To decide To decide, to decide, to decide To decide
It was a time when we in Poland wanted to learn Russian for their music. Any guy want girl like Lena or Julia. Today Russia threatens us with nuclear weapons. We destroy it with sanctions. We have anti-LGBT zone in both our countries. The world has fucked up. This is literaly 200km per hour in wrong way
Нет ни чего хуже человеческой эгоистичной любви если это вообще любовью можно назвать желание обладать кем то или чем то если не могу то пускай не достанется не кому и это болезнь большей половины ЧЕЛОВЕЧЕСТВА
I always thought the song was about only having 30 min to decide if the girl was going to run away with her lover or not, but this video makes the song way darker than I'd ever imagined.
Нет и не может быть ни чего важнее нашей юности , времени , что как сказка волшебно , что вне времени и вне всей сущности мироздания , вне этого материала бытия , что невероятно бодрит и волнует как чудесный плод иллюзии , как желаемое возможное и необратимое - молодость ..........нет ни чего прекраснее чем ТЫ . памяти минувших лет посвящается этот нежный поцелуй ....я растворяюсь и скорблю .
What are you talking about? I thought the girl was being cheated, that's why she set a bomb. or are you assume she's lesbian because she has short hair?
@@goliaththetrap8489 the black hair girl is girlfriend of the girl with red hair (or at least that's the concept of the band and many music videos). The user isn't assuming that she is a lesbian for having short hair
Recuerdo q por el 2010 tenía 7 años y en esas páginas para descargar MP3, en la barrita de artistas me llamó la atención el nombre tATu y me puse a escuchar sus canciones, recuedo q está era la q más me gustaba y la ponía todo el dia Mi mamá un día busco el vídeo y me prohibió volver a escuchar tATu, al final a ella también le termino gustado y ahora la escucha conmigo
For this song, it’s implied that Julia's character was in a relationship with one of the lovers on the carousel and committed murder-suicide as a result of Lena's or the boy's infidelity, although it could also have been unrequited love for either of them.
Gracias afecto por tu manito y no me lo siento mucho mejor con cuidado de que descanse Saludso y no he podido ver si claro es que haces ñtasruo de una gran pareja estas dos veces por la misma pareja estas personas son muy buenas🖤💗🖤💕💝
The title 30 minutes has an even deeper meaning, especially considering where the world is heading nowdays. 30 minutes is how long an intercontinental ballistic missile takes to get from Russia to the United States. 30 minutes to contemplate your life, the world, and how they both are about to end....Follow the english lyrics, it's eerie when you include this possibility. Out of sight Out of mind Out of time To decide Do we run? Should I hide? For the rest Of my life Can we fly? Do I stay? We could lose We could fail In the moment It takes To make plans Or mistakes [Chorus] 30 minutes a blink of an eye 30 minutes to alter our lives 30 minutes to make up my mind 30 minutes to finally decide 30 minutes to whisper your name 30 minutes to shoulder the blame 30 minutes of bliss, thirty lies 30 minutes to finally decide [Verse 2] Carousels In the sky That we shape With our eyes Under shade Silhouettes Casting shade Crying rain Can we fly? Do I stay? We could lose We could fail Either way Options change Chances fail Trains derail [Chorus] 30 minutes a blink of an eye 30 minutes to alter our lives 30 minutes to make up my mind 30 minutes to finally decide 30 minutes to whisper your name 30 minutes to shoulder the blame 30 minutes of bliss, thirty lies 30 minutes to finally decide To decide To decide, to decide, to decide To decide To decide To decide To decide To decide To decide
The scene where the carousel exploded reminding me of 9/11, I watched the MTV report, the scene was made in 2001 and a few months later in New York twin buildings got exploded
I used to dislike this song for the quiet ambience, I personally like the Hard-Drum Mix and the 119 Club Vocal Extension over the album mix. But I'm at a point in my life where I feel just like this. I always had many goals that I wanted to achieve, but it all changed over time. Where there used to be many colours and positivity, now there's only silence and a decision to take.
I hear you bro, we are in a time where the future looks dark and uncertain. Sometimes I ask myself why I still going to work when I feel and know that our world is at it's end. We are destroying ourselfs, the hard part is that the new generation has no clue of it cause they are to busy making videos on tiktok and instagram and such. We are sadly in the endtimes
I came home after school. I read the title "30 minutes". But the CD drive showed that it was only 3 minutes long. I thought it was a joke or a mistake. Yes, that was a mistake. It's been 20 years and the song doesn't want to end.
