Тёмный

Talking: Briarlight 

Moonkitti
Подписаться 248 тыс.
Просмотров 327 тыс.
50% 1

hope I didn't forget anything , but It's 9 am goodnight everyone

Опубликовано:

 

17 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,1 тыс.   
@varibunn
@varibunn 2 года назад
I really think Mothflight needs to be talked about. The fact she's basically a teen mom with ADHD and she's set up to fail by the story. Her parents don't support her that much (especially her mom) and she's widowed so soon into her relationship and so young. It's interesting that she was the founder of her role. I really hate how she was turned into just the "creator of the medicine cats having babies" rule and nothing else.
@vilmublues752
@vilmublues752 2 года назад
The series has a habit of turning even nice characters judgemental and mean after they join StarClan. Like what was up with Littlecloud in Squirrelflight's Hope.
@anoushkashenoy692
@anoushkashenoy692 2 года назад
I feel like she gets too much hate. She had very little support to take care of her kits and essentially was pressured to give them up under the premise she couldn’t be a good mother to them. The fandom gets really mad at her even though I feel as though she acts the way she does due to trauma from losing her mate and having to give up her kits so young. It isn’t an excuse for creating the code, but I still feel bad for her. She was super relatable to me when I read the books because of her ADHD.
@vampirekiittii
@vampirekiittii 2 года назад
i really hate how everyone in that book kept telling her stuff like “oh windrunner/star is just overprotective of you… shes your mom…” bc windstar was awful to mothflight and gorsefur did not care about mothflight enough to notice.
@anthares96
@anthares96 2 года назад
what i hate is that moth flight and the other og medicine cats never got given the chance to discover anything on their own. she found the moonstone, sure, but afterwards, starclan word for word told her the clans would have medicine cats, which cat it would be in each clan, when and how to relay any message, and any other major plot point in the book. her relationship with micah and struggle to raise her kits were interesting, but for most of the book she was just starclan's mouthpiece with very little agency.
@SketchUT
@SketchUT 2 года назад
I don’t like how she’s portrayed outside of her book despite her being a favorite of mine (ADHD gang). She’s treated by the writers and the fandom as the mean cat who stood in Leafpool’s way to StarClan (iirc) when she was just doing what she was pressured to believe is right. And because she was raised under this mentality, which absolutely extended through the rest of her off screen life that seems to be forgotten about by the fandom, she holds it true and central to her decision. She was pushed to think that medicine cats shouldn’t have a mate or kits because everyone told her that, and as they founder of the role she didn’t know what affect that would have for future meddies. Not gonna rant any more but Moth Flight beloved, she deserves better treatment especially as the only ND rep we have from what I can recall
@awildsofiappeared
@awildsofiappeared 2 года назад
I’m physically disabled, in a similar situation as Briarlight (I was born with it instead). Her experience, especially with Millie, Greystripe, and Blossomfall, is painfully actuate to my own experiences. Your parents being overbearing or distancing themselves, siblings feeling a painfully jealousy. Not to mention the constant feeling of uselessness that hangs over you. I used to reread Briar’s paragraphs over and over as a kid, since I never knew anyone else who went through what I did. Watching this video, all those memories begin flooding back to me. Thank you.
@firefancy9928
@firefancy9928 2 года назад
I relate to Briarlight's story the same way, I felt bad that I did and worried I was in the wrong for not criticizing Warrior cats, since everyone just loves to argue about Briarlight and how "bad" per parents treated her. I'm glad I'm not alone !
@erismason3441
@erismason3441 2 года назад
It's unfortunately far too real.
@starcycle4308
@starcycle4308 2 года назад
I'm not in the exact situation but something akin, and yeah. My parents are fine but I feel her clanmates and leader are akin to friends and teachers, and the way they treat/talk about her...it's painful, and it's real.
@nevermore5962
@nevermore5962 2 года назад
I don't know how much this comment will mean to you or if you'll see it but I wanted to tell you your loved and so much more useful than you know. Please don't let the 'Millies' and 'Blossomfalls' get to you. You are so useful even just the joy you bring to your friends by being alive and you can accomplish so much if you put your mind and heart to it. You are loved and valid.
@spooderNsage
@spooderNsage 2 года назад
I respect people of all abilities even if they have one they cant use I'm sorry people judge people like you even if it isn't their fault, lots of disabled people are judged and actually have an advantage to some things, people who judge them feel bad inside so keep in mind that you are unique and can still do many things
@lpshorselover1949
@lpshorselover1949 2 года назад
I’d also like to see a video about Deadfoot. I find it really interesting how he is one of the few disabled cats in the series (alongside Brightheart and Crookedstar) who aren’t medicine cats, and also, he was Windclan’s deputy, which I think is super cool!
@sillygoosetaur
@sillygoosetaur 2 года назад
i think the only time warrior cars can write disabled cats is when they completely forget said cat is disabled
@grekoy
@grekoy 2 года назад
Thank you!
@nayanayam
@nayanayam 2 года назад
There was also lilywhisker, the elder in tallstar’s revenge
@lpshorselover1949
@lpshorselover1949 2 года назад
@@nayanayam oh, really? I didn’t know! I never read Tallstar’s Revenge, thanks for letting me know :)
@suburito5370
@suburito5370 2 года назад
OMG YES! He's great
@2devious724
@2devious724 2 года назад
I found it so messed up back in the day when people said that Honeyfern's sacrifice was wasted by Briarlight becoming paralyzed. Similarly to elder characters, a lot of people seemed to want her killed off and I hated that.
@firefancy9928
@firefancy9928 2 года назад
Me too!
@2devious724
@2devious724 2 года назад
@Blueberryfur oh yeah, the fandom was extremely toxic back then.
@TheRibottoStudios
@TheRibottoStudios 2 года назад
"I'm pretty sure I'm worthless if I can't be of service." Fits warrior cats a little too well.
@viccytheimpaler
@viccytheimpaler 2 года назад
Lmao-
@almaszericebean1401
@almaszericebean1401 2 года назад
Especially for briarlight right after her accident
@aestherien
@aestherien 2 года назад
A FLAW OR A CRACK
@pocky-raisin
@pocky-raisin 2 года назад
@@aestherien THE STAW IN THE STACK
@qbbi
@qbbi 2 года назад
@@pocky-raisin THAT BREAKS THE CAMELS BACK
@namelessnavnls8060
@namelessnavnls8060 2 года назад
I think the reason Blossomfall blames the (technically other) victim (Briarlight) and not the abuser (Millie) is because.. That's actually something that happens in real families. The one getting most of the attention can be unfairly seen as the cause of the problems. Blossomfall just thinks that if Briarlight weren't disabled, then Millie would pay more attention to both of them instead of just one of them. It's also similar to how older siblings get jealous of all the attention the younger sibling gets. A sort of "why them and not me?" mindset, because siblings are, in nature, competition for one another and can have a lot of conflict when one feels like they're being neglected. Not all situations like this end up with the resentful, jealous sibling realizing the parents are also to blame for the neglect. Shifting blame is a thing that hurt and neglected kids 1000% do. They might be jealous of a sibling, or even a classmate who seems to be better off. All simply because they are jealous of what they can't/don't have and angrily hold grudges against anyone who makes them jealous in this way. (Also not excusing Blossomfall's behavior in any way. Just giving my two cents on _why_ she acts that way.)
@If-loki-was-a-fox
@If-loki-was-a-fox 2 года назад
As someone who has effectively been in Blossomfall's position before, I second this
@doodlebugdoge
@doodlebugdoge 2 года назад
Yeahhhh I will say as someone who is physically disabled (not paralyzed, but still disabled), it kinda irked me when the fandom decided all of a sudden that the way to fix the books ableism was to... make all of the disabled characters into warriors. Characters like Cinderpelt and Briarlight were the ones that mainly got me, cuz I know they WANTED to be warriors, but a reality of being disabled is that you don't always get to do what you want to. I felt very fond of these characters who found other ways to make their own lives brighter in ways that were different. Tbh, making all the disabled characters into warriors despite it all kinda just loops right back into ableism again; implying that they'll only feel fulfilled or not be discriminated against if they fit into the society's "normal" structure. Just... irks me.
@sillygoosetaur
@sillygoosetaur 2 года назад
thats why i DESPISE cinderheart its so incredibly ableist to take a character which had a perfectly fulfilling life in a different role and then say “okay so because you were disabled your life is worthless so let’s just shove you into a abled body and call it a day”
@amberdaze7892
@amberdaze7892 2 года назад
there was a reason jayfeather was one of my favorites.... i'm not blind but was born with my disability and it stops me from being able to do things i want that everyone else does and as a kid i didn't get to try. but he gets to be salty about it! he has never been the picture-perfect disabled character. he's sarcastic and tired and while he's annoyed with how his disability limits him, he doesn't hate himself and make us pity him. he's a character on his own and like most characters in this series does have morally questionable actions and it's never blamed on him being disabled (disclaimer all of this is what i remember from years ago + i'm very not caught up with anything post bramblestar's storm).
@ProjectSebastiann
@ProjectSebastiann 2 года назад
I don't think that all the disabled cat's should *have* to be medicine cats, I think they should have a choice- y'know? Depending on the disability, they can still do warrior duties (Cinderpelt very well could've done patrols and such) just fine, so it doesn't make sense as to why they should give up their dreams or current roles because they're disabled.
@torra9979
@torra9979 2 года назад
@@ProjectSebastiannthat is fair, but then I think it’s only so set up for failure as well specifically cause there’s only really two choices. Sometimes you can’t really choose between either choice cause it doesn’t fit you. I think that’s why warriors can sometimes end up with some...really messed narratives. Mainly just the fact there isn’t much of a branching out between warriors and medicine cats (if that makes sense). also, I wouldn’t say characters like cinderpelt actually would’ve been able to do that is the problem. disabilities can be a lot more...well. Disabling than most people would expect. hell, just having coordination that’s off can throw you off your feet. it would *definitely* be hard to even manage to get up with a completely mangled leg.
@ProjectSebastiann
@ProjectSebastiann 2 года назад
@@torra9979 That's when I feel like it's more of an issue with how the clans are structured- there shouldn't just be two choices, Medicine cat or Warrior- the only real breaking of this rule I've seen is Daisy, taking care of the kits.
@angela.i.2364
@angela.i.2364 2 года назад
disabled person here! not paralyzed, but my disability heavily affects my legs to the point they are near-useless. i think briarlight is my favorite character in the series simply because of how well she's portrayed, especially as a newly disabled child who used to be abled and very active. my disability progressed in very much the same way it felt like. i could run and keep up with my friends and do what i wanted, and suddenly i couldn't. having the people around you fret and lose sleep over you is also very much a disabled experience. nobody listens to you when you tell them you don't feel pain, and they insist you're suffering. it deeply affects your sense of self and even your perception of your disability. like, "am i really suffering and just don't know it?" it really hits home for me. especially with how briar doesn't want anyone to worry about her. she's so used to people going into panicked episodes over her health that she would rather let an illness progress to terminality before ever asking for help because she doesn't want to cause more worry over her, because that's basically been her whole life. all in all briar is 10/10 amazing character and surprisingly good representation for warriors. for next cat maybe uhmmm shadowsight? he was my favorite cat in TBC :)
@anoushkashenoy692
@anoushkashenoy692 2 года назад
I’d love to see her talk about Shadowsight! He was also very relatable to me because of his thoughts of worthlessness - the idea that sacrificing himself for the greater good was better than trying to live for himself/for his family.
@siqxyre8473
@siqxyre8473 2 года назад
As someone who's physically disabled (in not as severe of a way though) i'm glad you said something about it not being a good idea for her to race around and fight like a warrior. It's absolutely true that she is in danger if she does what everyone else does. It is not ableist to acknowledge that. It is not ableist to prevent her from doing things that are harmful to only her. Her disability is a part of herself, you can't say she's "just like everyone else" because she's technically not. Her disability effects her, it makes her different. Whats important is to establish different isn't bad, not that differences don't exist. Us disabled people do need different treatment, what is important is that its not treated as a burden.
@sincerely.serendipity
@sincerely.serendipity 2 года назад
THANK YOU- people try to call the authors ablest because of briarlight and it always gets on my nerves.
@firefancy9928
@firefancy9928 2 года назад
I was hoping someone else commented this, i agree with this sentiment too.
@r.i.pmydog7723
@r.i.pmydog7723 2 года назад
@@sincerely.serendipity the author still is ableist tho. it's clear in the text how over and over again they echo the sentiment that having a disability is worse than being dead.
@sincerely.serendipity
@sincerely.serendipity 2 года назад
@@r.i.pmydog7723 ????????? where have they said that?
@erismason3441
@erismason3441 2 года назад
Reminds me of a Tumblr gif I saw years ago: somebody says something along the lines of "disabled people can do anything they want!" - cut to a woman in a wheelchair (the gif's creator) comically hurling herself from her chair in an attempt to walk.
@whisk_
@whisk_ 2 года назад
I'd like to see you talking about Purdy! The old guy doesn't really get the spotlight much, considering just how much he impacts mousefurs life after the death of longtail. He is a great old guy who just wants to tell stories, and I would love if you covered him!
@brainmadeofbubbles4103
@brainmadeofbubbles4103 2 года назад
AGREED
@RockslideTreeClan
@RockslideTreeClan 2 года назад
favorite old cowboy
@Cat-Tea-Nights
@Cat-Tea-Nights 2 года назад
YESSS
@RoseProseFroze
@RoseProseFroze 2 года назад
Remember when they had a survey about what cat we want a super edition on? I picked Purdy.
@whisk_
@whisk_ 2 года назад
@@RoseProseFroze Imagine if he won, I wish we got a backstory for the wandering cowboy, maybe he had a harsh past but managed to stay kind and have faith that good cats will always be out there
@co0kiies920
@co0kiies920 2 года назад
I'd like to see you talk about Mousefur, she's one of the original warriors, and we get to see her become a elder and make friends with Longtail and Purdy (Two characters I also enjoy). She's known to be a bit sassy and gets more of a personality later on. She also loses Longtail and dies in the battle of the dark forest which seems like a fitting ending for a character we see develop but is never the main focus.
@redcow8176
@redcow8176 2 года назад
This is gonna be the top comment, calling it right now
@rowanheart8122
@rowanheart8122 2 года назад
Mousefur! Yes!
@cwappy5348
@cwappy5348 2 года назад
YEs
@birdsbirdsandmorebirds6251
@birdsbirdsandmorebirds6251 2 года назад
YES I NEED MOUSEFUR TO GET MORE ATTENTION. Mah favourite character
@graphitetailgrace3870
@graphitetailgrace3870 2 года назад
Mousefur deserves retribution after she died in a mess her apprentice made.
@Cinemamuffin
@Cinemamuffin 2 года назад
The points you make about graystripe are... really salient, actually. It's bizarre to me that he has so little interaction with his kids with Millie, whereas for his last litter with Silverstream it was seen as incredibly UNUSUAL how involved in his childrens' lives he was. Where did his parental instinct go? Did... did they just forget that he's supposed to be a good dad?
@SLTheOneAndAwesome19
@SLTheOneAndAwesome19 2 года назад
I know that it's mainly because the world wasn't fully built back in Forest of Secrets, but it's implied Graystripe is only as involved with Featherkit and Stormkit was because they didn't have their mother. He also left ThunderClan to be with them and he didn't really have any friends in RiverClan aside from their foster mother. So it makes sense for him to be close with them. So when his litter with Millie is born, it can be perceived as him not being involved because, "that's mom's job" as was stated in Forest of Secrets, or that he didn't feel like they were his only relationships in the clan, so he was free to be distant.
@If-loki-was-a-fox
@If-loki-was-a-fox 2 года назад
Yeah, if we assumed he wasn't supposed to be an especially good warrior cat dad, and assumed he was just the average not very involved father, it would make sense for Blossomfall not to consider him a valid source of attention, but he really should have been more involved...
@roryschoenecker4756
@roryschoenecker4756 Год назад
That was odd to me too, considering how involved he was in Feathertail's life, and how in his super edition, he showered Stormfur with love, yet ignored his other kits with Millie.
@loppie_445
@loppie_445 10 месяцев назад
@@SLTheOneAndAwesome19that and they were the only remnants of Silverstream he had whereas Millie is alive and well after having their kits
@BumbleTus
@BumbleTus 2 года назад
I do understand, from a CHARACTER'S view saying they want to be useful. I am physically disabled, and I struggled with the idea of being of use/being a burden. idk if the authors intended that though, from Briarlight's perspective, but it is something I can connect with. its AWFUL but its something drilled into me from family, doctors, therapists. Briarlight tho, I love. and I think they handled her, specifically, not her family or other characters interacting with her, pretty well. She's a fantastic character who is loved.
@Schnort
@Schnort 2 года назад
I'm able bodied and I can relate to feeling useless if I am not of service at all times. I can't imagine the shit disabled folks go through.
@bitteralmonds2614
@bitteralmonds2614 2 года назад
I’d love to hear you talk about Shrewclaw! I’ve always personally liked him as a character but he’s not talked about much, which is odd because he’s in one of the most liked super editions. He bullied Tallstar as a kit but never had any bad feelings towards him, he was very upset when Talltail wanted to leave and felt bad once he realized what he did hurt Tallstar. Once Tallstar got back he seemed to treat him better and try to mend the relationship.
@mooneatsworms
@mooneatsworms 2 года назад
shrewclaw is such a silly boyo boy!!
@lorelaim1963
@lorelaim1963 2 года назад
His death was so sad, I'm glad him and Tallstar cleared things up.
@thatsn0tverycashm0ney88
@thatsn0tverycashm0ney88 2 года назад
I love Shrewclaw so much
@bitteralmonds2614
@bitteralmonds2614 2 года назад
@@lorelaim1963 I started reading the books having already been involved in the fandom so I knew about most of the deaths, but I didn’t realize he died so his death is the only one I’ve cried over.
@lorelaim1963
@lorelaim1963 2 года назад
@@bitteralmonds2614 his, briarlights and feathertails deaths were so sad omg
@PixylMawthz
@PixylMawthz 2 года назад
Oh, maybe Sunfall/Sunstar for a future video? The circumstances around his leadership were really interested, and for a background character, he's actually got a decent amount going for him, especially in Bluestar's book!
@miragracestudios5104
@miragracestudios5104 2 года назад
This video is insightful and touching. And let me just say that the image at 5:18 is the cutest drawing I’ve seen of these two. Well done, Moon!
@-Aquablue-
@-Aquablue- 2 года назад
I know, I love Jayfeather and Brairlights relationship
@blondeashfur3445
@blondeashfur3445 2 года назад
I don't really see it as a romantic relationship (since not everyone has to date everyone) but I really liked the way Jayfeather always managed to encourage her and take a break from his grumpy nature and actually be caring.
@Wolfie000
@Wolfie000 2 года назад
I like that drawing it's cool I kinda wish that briarlight was his apprentice even if she had her warrior name she can still learn herbs (aka me just wanting them to teach alderpaw together and different techniques to do so,) =) peace.
@sammywammye
@sammywammye 2 года назад
Yes!
@robinfrutchey561
@robinfrutchey561 2 года назад
yeah, Briarlight and Jayfeather are one of my favorite pair of friends in the book.
@starscreamapologist3003
@starscreamapologist3003 2 года назад
I feel like something to keep in mind about Blossomfall is that even though she’s a late teen/young adult when Briarlight is injured, I think the purpose of her character might have been to empathize with younger readers who have sick or disabled siblings. My younger sister was diagnosed with a rare chronic illness when I was 6, and yeah I was a lot younger than Blossomfall, but when I read her confession I actually felt seen. Because yeah, I obviously don’t have it nearly as rough as my sister, and the two of us have always been incredibly close, but I remember being a kid and feeling jealous of all the attention that my parents gave her and feeling like they forgot all about me. Now, I was 6 and Blossomfall is 18+, so obviously there are different circumstances there. I won’t deny that Blossomfall’s arc in OotS was clumsily written at best, but siblings of disabled/sick children are very rarely represented, so I appreciated that warrior cats at least made an attempt
@firefancy9928
@firefancy9928 2 года назад
I've seen another comment similar to yours and I agree with both! I care for both Briarlight and Blossomfall as characters and what the books were trying to say about their situation, as well as the lesson they were trying to teach.
@scarthecar9031
@scarthecar9031 2 года назад
I’d love to hear you talk about Ivypool and her kits. She suffered through so much and still managed to find love with Fernsong and raise 3 kits. And, after all her dark forest trauma, after even losing her sister, after losing her DAUGHTER, she still pulls through. That’s amazing to me and I love her for that.
@Leafy_
@Leafy_ 2 года назад
Yes! She’s so cool!
@scarthecar9031
@scarthecar9031 2 года назад
@@Leafy_ she’s my favorite darling sour sister
@nyabis8044
@nyabis8044 2 года назад
Her greeting Rootspring so warmly in the beginning of River absolutely warmed my heart, especially since both of them were devastated by the loss of Bristlefrost. I’m glad that they found some comfort in each other.
@roryschoenecker4756
@roryschoenecker4756 2 года назад
Fernsong was her cousin. He nagged her into having kits, and Ivypool honestly doesn't seem like a mother to me. She's a badass, who definitely should be deputy, and with someone who would wait for her instead of bargaining.
@lindseylindsey9200
@lindseylindsey9200 Год назад
@@roryschoenecker4756 They’re third cousins, their last shared relative is their great-great grandfather Jake. Do you even know any of your third cousins? I don’t. Besides, who isn’t related in ThunderClan at this point. The Stemleaf/Spotfur kids are their own aunt and uncles. Also, unless I’m forgetting something he asked her once or twice and then waited for whenever she was ready afterwards
@Sploosh-goosh9015
@Sploosh-goosh9015 2 года назад
I think Birchfall would be a good option! He has a whole lot of stuff to talk about! Especially his childhood.
@boipoi_78
@boipoi_78 2 года назад
Exactly! For me he's one of those random background characters I just latched unto
@clover3222
@clover3222 2 года назад
Yes!
@firefancy9928
@firefancy9928 2 года назад
I forget when Birchfall was a kit, he would be back with Ferncloud and Dustpelt in the old forest, when the twolegs are deforesting Thunderclan and Shadowclan. I dont remember how old he was when him and Whitewing (Cloudtail and Brightheart's daughter) earned their warrior names???
@clover3222
@clover3222 2 года назад
Idk why but every time I read about Birchfall, I always think of him as this super young warrior, and then I remember he’s a grandpa and is actually a senior warrior…
@thatoneartkidd
@thatoneartkidd 2 года назад
It would be nice if you talked about Puddleshine, and the discussion on him becoming a medicine cat by force. His relationship with Alderheart is also really interesting, with Puddleshine being literally poisoned by an anxious Squirrelflight clone.
@Gold_Pup
@Gold_Pup 2 года назад
When it comes to smaller characters, I’d love to hear something about Lightning Tail! I feel like he’s super underrated. Thunderstar was his adopted brother and I feel like those two are some of the only cats in the Warriors series who aren’t blood related, but still feel like brothers. In the end, both die together while fighting dogs: Thunderstar comes back to life due to having 9 lives, but Lightning Tail obviously doesn’t since he was only deputy. In my opinion, he deserved to be the second leader of ThunderClan.
@clover3222
@clover3222 2 года назад
This comment needs more likes! I think this is a great idea! Basically all the prequel books characters (forgot the name of the series) need to be talked about. A lot of them are really interesting!
@roryschoenecker4756
@roryschoenecker4756 Год назад
Also they are kinda gay and I like that for them
@Gold_Pup
@Gold_Pup Год назад
@@roryschoenecker4756 Ayo?? I hope you mean for other cats and not for each other lol
@lindseylindsey9200
@lindseylindsey9200 Год назад
@@roryschoenecker4756 They were foster siblings, which would be one thing for Brindleface or Whitestorm where them being foster siblings and them being mates was added after the fact and at different times, or Lilyheart and Snowbush where they’re both background characters, but with Thunderstar and Lightning Tail it was absolutely important to their dynamic that they’re foster siblings
@roryschoenecker4756
@roryschoenecker4756 Год назад
It's just how I interpreted the text. Thunder and Lightning seemed too perfect to ignore.
@iaceds
@iaceds 2 года назад
As a physically disabled person, ambulatory wheelchair, I like how you covered this. It was sad to see she was seen as a character to pity. People with disabilities have the right to live and their lives aren’t anything to pity. In reality, there is an issue of disabled people being seen as worthless. When disabled people are killed by their “caregivers”, society doesn’t care much. I really didn’t like how she was just able to walk again in Starclan. Mainly because people act like death is better than being disabled, or that death is freeing.
@tinycatfriend
@tinycatfriend 2 года назад
hey! i'm physically disabled and i think you covered briarlight wonderfully. you were thorough, thoughtful and called out things that needed to be. you reminded me of stuff i forgot that are important for me to know around my opinion of briarlight. i love briarlight, and honestly i think 70% of the plot threads around her and characters in her life are unfortunately very realistic. millie's appalling behaviour and blossomfall's jealousy are common in families of severely disabled children (minus millie's overt comment about letting briar die). parents panicking and fretting to a harmful extent is something i've witnessed myself. and if we read greystripe maliciously (which most likely wasn't intended), deadbeat dads are very common for disabled kids. briar being babied by her clanmates is something i relate to strongly, and briar's struggle with self-worth hits home so much that on a bad day this discussion could trigger me (i'm good atm, don't worry). the books showing obvious causes for briar feeling this way, and the arguments jayfeather makes against those beliefs is truly comforting to read in a kid's book. there is a lot done wrong in the books, of course. comments from clanmates about her being less whole, or that her life is something to fear resembling are problematic. her death is baffling and seems like just a cheap way to put an emotional punch into the book. her being able-bodied in starclan is total bullshit! so, like i said, 70% good but far from perfect. overall could have been done better, but could have been much worse as well.
@firefancy9928
@firefancy9928 2 года назад
I agree that what happens to her in Starclan is indeed BS. I also took comfort in what Jayfeather said to Briarlight when I was young, too! And i'm glad someone else feels the same way.
@depressedvillainobsession2771
@depressedvillainobsession2771 2 года назад
Hi, I’m also physically disabled and I agree with everything you are saying. Briarlight was a really important character to me, and it broke my heart to just have her killed off like that
@goldenfloof5469
@goldenfloof5469 2 года назад
Her being able-bodied in star clan is following the precedent they set when they introduced Jayfeather. Nobody will argue that blindness isn't a disability, and since he was born blind his happiest moments were definitely when he was blind. But, despite being born blind, he can still see while dreaming, and more importantly in this case he can see perfectly fine while he's in starclan. So your physical disabilities not carrying over into your afterlife just *is* how things are in warriors, and if that wasn't the case for Briarlight then it would've been a massive plothole. Now whether you think the way it works is bullcrap or not, I don't care, not my place to judge. But saying Briarlights case is bullcrap while disregarding Jayfeathers situation just doesn't make sense.
@tinycatfriend
@tinycatfriend 2 года назад
@@goldenfloof5469 the books are extremely inconsistent about starclan lore. nothing is set in stone, because the lore changes whenever the authors feel like it. so, the authors can do whatever they want (they already do, in fact! that's why lore is a jumbled mess). i'm going to judge them for this decision, because the inconsistency of the lore makes it easy for them to keep briarlight disabled after death, and they chose not to do that. human people made those decisions, in a book series notorious for NOT having a lore bible. i'm personally not gonna accept the "ah! but the lore dictates this!" as an excuse for the authors ableist undertones. that's my opinion, anyway.
@melanopygus
@melanopygus Год назад
I honestly think the authors forgot about Graystripe / forgot he was her dad for awhile lmao
@KZFathom
@KZFathom 2 года назад
ok get this: what if briarlight still can't use her back legs in starclan, but that's because she literally just has no reason to? Starclan has no earthly problems like thorns, and you can't get infections in starclan. She can interact with all her loved ones, spy on all the gatherings she wants, do all the activities like play with kits/help others with medicine cat tasks like she did while alive, and if she really wants to hunt because it might be fun, well, prey is easy to catch in starclan, and she can experiment with all different hunting types from all clans. Her not being able to use her back legs in starclan shouldn't affect how happy she is there. (although of course her wanting to have use of her backlegs is her choice in starclan, the experience of running on all fours isn't unparalelled, and I just don't like how if your form in starclan is how you were happiest in implies that she was never as happy as she was again as an apprentice.)
@samfinnell6070
@samfinnell6070 2 года назад
Jayfeather and Briarlight are one of my favorite relationships platonically or otherwise! I love so many of their interactions and it was really nice to see that side of Jayfeather!
@slashercat8649
@slashercat8649 2 года назад
I think the fact that both Jayfeather, another disabled character, and Briarlight were able to form such a close bond showed great solidarity between the two. Probably influenced how great Jayfeather was in helping her see her self-worth as something other than usefulness. Though I agree Blossomfall is obviously in the wrong with her blaming Briarlight, the whole jealousy over siblings' things is extremely common as parents tend to neglect the other kids. As someone whose sister had a disability that required frequent checkups as a kid, I was always really jealous of the attention my mom spent with her so I could understand Blossomfall feel a similar way. Even if it isn't rational, she probably would rather Milie give her attention even if it's doting and overbearing because she resents not having that.
@xXEclipse_studiosXx
@xXEclipse_studiosXx Год назад
Right! I wonder if blossom fall training in the dark forest was more or less for attention, like she wanted Millie to pay attention to her because she was training in the dark forest
@RLane-xz5cj
@RLane-xz5cj 2 года назад
I can't speak on the disability aspect of their relationship, but Blossomfall and Briarlight are definitely a surprisingly realistic representation of how parental abuse or neglect can affect siblings. Blossomfall very much reads as an adult whose ability to empathize with others was damaged by her parents ignoring her. She doesn't see the KIND of attention her sister gets, only that it's attention. She doesn't blame her mother, because it's really hard to recognize and deal with knowing that your parents are failing you. We all want to be loved by our parents, and if you don't know what love looks like, the negative attention Briarlight was getting from Millie probably looks like it. Doesn't excuse Blossomfall's flaws, just makes them more real, which I can appreciate. I think it also implies Millie is an even WORSE mother than the writers probably intended.
@cinnamonsnowcones5516
@cinnamonsnowcones5516 2 года назад
Please do Frostfur next! She is a really interesting character who i think has been developed enough for a more complex reading to be done of her. I feel like she is underappreciated, and i think she deserves and episode :>
@catxborsuq1
@catxborsuq1 2 года назад
I hope that now that we have an in-book confirmation that Lionheart was the father of her kits (finally) we'll get a novella centered around either her or him, not even any big story, I would be legitimately interested in just knowing how they got together, I don't think they even interact in Into the Wild or Bluestar's Prophecy xD
@kneelessnightcat9164
@kneelessnightcat9164 2 года назад
11:41 To answer your question, because kids don't like to accept the fact their parent might not love them, or that their parents are in the wrong. It's easier to blame external factors for relationships not working instead of just accepting there's something wrong with the other person, or even yourself in some cases. She's in denial to put it simply. Why this wasn't followed up on and reached the conclusion it should have, Blossomfall accepting her mother is the problem, and fixing her relationship with Briarlight is why most conflicts in Warriors don't get resolved well. The Erins are great at set up, but suck at payoff.
@firefancy9928
@firefancy9928 2 года назад
This makes sense!
@corvidkhaos
@corvidkhaos 2 года назад
crookedstar/rainflower vid! i’d love to see you cover one of the only explicit instances of parental abuse within the clans (and one of the only instances of cat divorce) and also cause crookedstar has such an interesting backstory
@Cage-CatYT
@Cage-CatYT 2 года назад
I'd love to see a vid on Crookedstar! Rainforest would also be super interesting
@tomewifecollector9608
@tomewifecollector9608 2 года назад
Idk, Brokenstar's abuse from his own "mother" (Lizardstripe) was kind of explicit. Actively neglecting him of basic needs such as food and encouraging/manipulating her biologic children to antagonize him. But yeah, as someone who had an abusive mom, Crookedstar is seriously my favorite character.
@rubixcube3774
@rubixcube3774 2 года назад
Yes!! Most of the super editions/novellas were mediocre at best, but I loved Crookedstars Promise
@GweenOfTea
@GweenOfTea 2 года назад
Would you talk about Jagged Peak or Turtle Tail next! Jagged Peak was bullied hard for his disability both intentionally by Clear Sky and kinda unintentionally by Gray Wing, and Turtle Tail is so bold and different from all the other girls
@legrandliseurtri7495
@legrandliseurtri7495 2 года назад
Which made it weird when Jagged Peak suddendly bullied Gray Wing for his breathing problems in a forest divided.
@maplefoxxo
@maplefoxxo 2 года назад
YES. JAGGED PEAK. Like. Wow
@birdsbirdsandmorebirds6251
@birdsbirdsandmorebirds6251 2 года назад
I'm NoT lIkE oThEr GiRlS
@maplefoxxo
@maplefoxxo 2 года назад
@@legrandliseurtri7495 yeah
@Cat-Tea-Nights
@Cat-Tea-Nights 2 года назад
I'm only just in the middle of The Sun Trail, and Jagged Peak is such a cute boy. Agreed
@viral4983
@viral4983 2 года назад
I would love to you to speak on Ivypool and Fernsong, or just Fernsong, I find their relationship to be one of the least toxic in the current few arcs and quite interesting of a match yet very fitting for Ivypool. Fernsong is just so understanding, and supportive and actually LISTENS and communicates with his mate, and meet each other in the middle on things like wanting kits. Fernsong being in the nursery so Ivypool could still be a warrior, is probably one of the best romantic shows of love, and affection in a healthy relationship, in maybe even any arc (yes ofc ravenpaw and barley are good and tallstar and jake, but im more so meaning “confirmed” relationships)
@sevdge5
@sevdge5 2 года назад
I think Fernsong and Ivypool are definitely the one of the best couples (top three or five). I just have to keep trying to forget that theyre cousins, like what the heck ERINS?
@viral4983
@viral4983 2 года назад
@@sevdge5 yeah its a downside however they /are/ cats in a clan thats nearly all related in some way or another so pickings are slim to choose between for ships
@sevdge5
@sevdge5 2 года назад
@@viral4983 at this point they'll have to start dating the horses at the horseplace or whatever they call it.
@songbird6414
@songbird6414 2 года назад
@@viral4983 I just find it annoying because there’s an entire prophecy about how she’s related to his dad. This ONE TIME you’d think they could avoid a direct incest scenario but I guess not.
@viral4983
@viral4983 2 года назад
@@songbird6414 yep thats fair too but they do change their writers around so much they probably didnt even know what happened in the previous books 😔
@_something64_59
@_something64_59 2 года назад
I feel that Millie was just a shit mother. The way Blossomfall acts is how someone with a neglectful if not abusive parent acts and it isn't much better with Briarlight or Bumblestripe. It sounds to me like Millie saw 'a good life' as fighting and having kits, never reassuring Briarlight that she is worth more than that and can live life her own way. Also, the way all three act is as if they were being guilt tripped and held hostage (Bumblestripe seeing that behavior as normal and trying to do that to Dovewing, Briarlight, the cat who lets no one get her down, immediately blames herself for her mother's overreaction, and Blossomfall, who bottles her own emotions because she is scared to have them) and for me, the doubt they all have that them just being happy is enough for Millie is a pretty big red flag. It's kinda telling when 2/3 end up fucked up and the third beats herself up constantly for being disabled. Just my take, I'm probably over analyzing. To everyone seeing this, you matter. You don't have to stand for abusive family and no matter what, you are enough. Millie = Karen
@StinginqNettle
@StinginqNettle 2 года назад
I’d love to hear your opinion on Shadowsight! After the end of the broken code i’m glad that he’s left with something that will keep him fairly relevant, and i think he’s interesting and funny. I like the plot point where be was demoted and treated like a child by Mothwing.
@littlelady8835
@littlelady8835 2 года назад
I'd love to hear you talk about Snowfur. Snowfur wasn't mentioned all throughout the original series- only in Bluestar's Prophecy. Her relationship with Bluefur is almost like Ivypool and Dovewing, except Thistleclaw is in the Clan. I think her story is interesting, and very unlike the rest with her tragic death. I would love to here your thoughts on Snowfur!
@saltybisexual2653
@saltybisexual2653 2 года назад
I agree Snowfur would be so interesting to have a video on!
@huntersly782
@huntersly782 2 года назад
I'm going to say this again, I would like you to do Alderheart, because during his childhood sparkpelt was more desired as a hunter and combat then all the sudden he was changed and more, during his journey he suffered the loss of sandstorm and is reminded of that situation ever since. That's why I would want him to be talked about. And plus he's one of my favorite characters
@chicade5449
@chicade5449 2 года назад
I think Bluestar would be very interesting. She's a character that gets misinterpreted by the fandom a lot, or at last used to. You mentioned in one of your videos on Frecklewish that people used to think she was meant to be read as an unreliable narrator when she's actually correct in most moment that were supposed to prove it.
@misskittyfantastico3473
@misskittyfantastico3473 2 года назад
Thank you for this I am so tired of people acting like Millie was a good mom to Briarlight, I wrote an AU where Briarlight moves to Riverclan to be with a forbidden love interest (Grasspelt) and get away from Millie’s ableism and got attacked because that kind of ableism is “normal” and “just the way things are” since Briarlight’s disability is just sooooo hard for Millie. This fandom is incredibly hostile towards disabled people, I know multiple disabled people, mostly kids, who have been harassed due to speaking up about these things.
@meeplol145
@meeplol145 Год назад
I keep seeing people say “Millie is such a good mom! People should ignore that she didn’t pay attention to Blossomfall because she’s an adult!” But I never see anyone bring up the way for treated Briarlight. And I don’t blame Bossonfall for being jealous, she was a young warrior.
@anarchist..archer
@anarchist..archer 2 года назад
I know he’s not very popular, but I really think you should talk about Thrushpelt! Other than being in love with Bluefur(star), he’s a sweet boy who deserved more screen time! I think it’s ridiculous that more bad cats are way more popular than this sweet underrated warrior!
@failingradish2010
@failingradish2010 2 года назад
Thrushpelt is one of the univerally most liked characters tho?
@anarchist..archer
@anarchist..archer 2 года назад
@@failingradish2010 that’s odd, I don’t ever see anything for him. I guess what I’m saying is that his traits are under appreciated by the writing team now.
@failingradish2010
@failingradish2010 2 года назад
@@anarchist..archer you haven't seen the 'she wants me (to be loved)' amv for thrushpelt?
@anarchist..archer
@anarchist..archer 2 года назад
@@failingradish2010 no, I have, I just consider his character underrated compared to the popular villains
@angrygremlin
@angrygremlin 2 года назад
As your local Mousefur Stan, I'd love to see a video on Mousefur! She actually dealt with a large amount of guilt in her life, especially over the deaths of other cats, at least it was more than the average warrior. Of course there are the canon examples Longtail and Honeyfern, but she was on the same patrol with Runningwind (her brother) when he died, and although it's a bit of my head-canon ish, Redtail, since she ran away from the battle he died in (worse is the fact that he was deputy). Also kind of briarlight, because she ran in to save Longtail, who wouldn't have even gone back into camp if Mousefur hadn't complained. She dies as soon as she meets up with Longtail again in the battle with the dark forest, by an unnamed dark forest warrior (which kind of sucks since she was an original arc 1 warrior, she deserved at least a named killer). She was also a part of (in my opinion) the best group of elders with Longtail and Purdy.
@yakketyyak6414
@yakketyyak6414 2 года назад
Love to see brightheart next! The series I grew up with when I was little was power of three and even though she’s not treated very nicely I absolutely loved her character.
@therobynintheoak7817
@therobynintheoak7817 2 года назад
maybe sol? (correct me if i’m wrong! i haven’t read power of three in a long time!) he was abandoned by his neglectful mother as a kit, kidnapped leafstar’s kits in order to frame it to make it seem he saved them rather than stole them in order to join skyclan, manipulated blackstar to have his clan drop their entire religion, and used his words rather than his claws to achieve power. i think it’d be really interesting to see your opinions!
@Tato.of.Scotland
@Tato.of.Scotland 2 года назад
Used to have a dog who had her back legs broken and they never properly healed this made me love briarlights charecter even more
@mayzcantdraw
@mayzcantdraw 2 года назад
I would like a video about Stormfur! He's a pretty underdeveloped character, and I would love to see people talking about him! ^^
@starcycle4308
@starcycle4308 2 года назад
I'm not (usually) paralyzed, but I am physically disabled, and I think you did a great job with this one! It was honestly very relieving to see an able-bodied person talk about disability in such a way, and for so long, since in my experience either nobody talks about it, or they're ableist. This is definitely a breath of fresh air from all that. You also helped point out things that I hadn't remembered, or hadn't originally clocked as ableism due to my own internalized ableism (gotta love it). Thank you for bringing up the point about making Briar a warrior! It helped me realize and (mostly) solve some of my internal issues about not doing everything everyone else was, and I'm in a much better mental state because of it. Sorry for the dramatic ramble lol.
@superflyghtheart
@superflyghtheart 2 года назад
I'd love to see you talk about Daisy!! Maybe her kits too if you need to fill time? She's such a unique character, being so much more cowardly and timid than other cats, and I wish we'd gotten a little more about her perspective as an outsider to Thunderclan, especially since she was preforming a duty that not many other cats in the clans did due to her not fitting in with clan life so well. We got a novella, which is fantastic!!! I'm very glad to see her perspective on her losses and her relationship with Smokey, but there were weird things too with how the Erins handled her characterization, especially that contrived drama with Brightheart and Cloudtail...
@TitaniumShortcake
@TitaniumShortcake 2 года назад
I stopped keeping up with the books some time before they killed Briarlight off, and finding out that they had hurt. She was a very easy character to root for, as someone who has also had to overcome difficulties caused by a disability. And her dynamics both with Millie, the parent who struggles to accept and adapt to her child's new normal and with Jayfeather, one of the only other cats in ThunderClan who will understand her struggle and frustrations, felt very familiar and natural. She's arguably one of the most complex and relatable characters the series has ever produced, and she's certainly one of the ones that I remember most fondly.
@aspen1713
@aspen1713 2 года назад
Haven’t read the books in years, haven’t even read most of the books Briarlight exists in, but here I am watching a 40 min video and crying over a fictional cat. ; ___ ; I’d heard Briarlight died, but the excerpts Moonkitti read ripped my heart out.
@nerdygal6133
@nerdygal6133 2 года назад
Thank you so much for this video Moon. My mom is physically disabled and Briarlight is a very meaningful character to me because of that. I’d really enjoy hearing you dive deep into Mothwing and her atheism, I’ve always found it extremely interesting and very relatable. How bad experiences can affect you’re relationship with religion/any higher power one was raised to believe. Plus I’d love to hear you’re thoughts on her and Leafpool’s relationship and the (intentional or not) queer undertones they have to it. ♥️
@AlchemicalLeopard
@AlchemicalLeopard 2 года назад
Think you could talk about Tigerheart or Dovewing? Their relationship still confuses me because of how they get together, then they don't, then they do again? And I know you like Dovewing so I'd imagine you would enjoy talking about her.
@thieleaf_the_shelf_dragon
@thieleaf_the_shelf_dragon 2 года назад
disabled person here! along with all the things already brought up here (which i wholeheartedly agree with) , a thing that really gets under my skin is the words the narration uses to describe her, not the characters but basic descriptions of things she never is allowed to "come" over, to "rush" to "wander" even just to "get" anywhere, she is only ever allowed to "drag herself" or "haul herself". that scene where she jokes about leafpool getting slower, the book describes her movement as "hauling her useless hind legs behind her" which. while yeah, sure, she does have to pull her legs along without the use of her leg muscles, but the language goes out of its way, all the time, to imply that she is suffering. even when doing things that she doesnt have any trouble with. and it just. it all adds up into feeling like the narration wants you to believe that her mobility is a huge horrible terrible upsetting loss, something to feel sorry for they also do a similar thing to her as they do with jayfeather, where they describe her doing normal everyday things for her "despite" her back legs. (they sure love to say "her useless hind legs" a lot). it simultaneously is suggesting that shes oh so wonderful and inspirational for ~overcoming her challenges~ while also reinforcing that she is missing something. they even say so so many times that she is one of the most cheerful in the clan *despite* her paralysed hind legs. and it just. sucks. she was one of the happiest members of the clan before that!
@bluejay4560
@bluejay4560 2 года назад
I’ve always loved Briarlight and Jayfeather’s dynamic. I’ve also got a suggestion for another character. What about Shrewpaw? He’s pretty interesting and I wish we got to see him in Starclan, especially after the whole incident that just went down.
@thatsn0tverycashm0ney88
@thatsn0tverycashm0ney88 2 года назад
I think that the reason Blossomfall blamed everything on Briarlight was it was easier. It was easier to be mad at her sister than admit that this was and issue between her and Mille. By the time she stopped blaming Briar, she felt that too much time had passed to try and fix things with her mother. Maybe Thornclaw had been the one to point out that she wasn't really mad at Briar
@SpaceInvader42359
@SpaceInvader42359 2 года назад
There's an unpleasant undertone whenever Briarlight's downplaying her own needs, pretending not to be sick, not eating, etc. What it's suggesting is that, while Briarlight has a right to have her needs met, the fact that she /doesn't/ assert her own needs makes her a better person. It's unfortunately common in fiction written about disabilities. It's not for Briarlight to assert, or demand, her right to life. That's for the able-bodied cats to do on her behalf.
@eve123princess9
@eve123princess9 2 года назад
Unfortunately it’s also pretty realistic as well when you think about it.
@rebeccaloe
@rebeccaloe 2 года назад
I think a video about Goldenflower would be interesting! She’s one of my favorite characters and I feel like people don’t talk about her enough :)
@Krill_Phil
@Krill_Phil 2 года назад
_(This is copy-pasted from the Longtail video.)_ I’d personally like to see you cover Fern Leaf from DOTC. She was an abuse victim of Slash and was eventually taken in by Tall Shadow’s group via encouragement from Gray Wing a little while after she met him. She gets close to Wind Runner over time then joins her group when Wind Runner splits off from Tall Shadow’s. Even after leaving Slash’s group she still cared about her friends there. She thought one of them; Bee, was finally coming around only to be pressed to return and attacked when she refused. I just find Fern Leaf’s character so interesting and would love a proper video on her.
@legrandliseurtri7495
@legrandliseurtri7495 2 года назад
Yes, she was a great character from the second half of the arc!
@nyxskip
@nyxskip 2 года назад
i dont remember this character at all (i havent read dotc since it came out) but youve described her so well that now i want to reread all of dotc just so i can see her
@true_lovers_knot
@true_lovers_knot 2 года назад
OH MY GOD YES I FORGOT ABOUT HERR
@Krill_Phil
@Krill_Phil 2 года назад
@@nyxskip Yes, for sure do that! DOTC is my favourite Warriors arc and it has so many amazing characters. Rereading it is always a great time and I guarantee you won’t regret it!
@nyxskip
@nyxskip 2 года назад
@@Krill_Phil i did it! fern leaf is definitely one of my favorite characters, i love her friendship with gray wing. somewhat unrelated but i feel like dotc has way more solid black cats than any other arc lol
@pieisgood3287
@pieisgood3287 2 года назад
What about snowtuft. I know recently he’s been talked about a lot but I think it would interesting to hear all about how your opinion on the the snowkit snowtuft theory and if I’m if you think he deserved to be in starclan.
@firstmoon2400
@firstmoon2400 2 года назад
I hated Snowtuft, I'm sorry but he is confusing
@Turvold
@Turvold 2 года назад
I only cares about snow tuft because he was a back round dark forest character who was just kinda their so they had basically a blank slate for him, I think they did alright with him overall in Broken Code
@starstorm1267
@starstorm1267 2 года назад
I do agree that Blossomfall’s behavior towards Briarlight is in no way justifiable. Unfortunately, her behavior is very realistic for a lot of siblings who have disabled siblings. And I’m saying this as someone who’s not physically disabled but is mentally disabled and has an abled sister who gets easily jealous and angry at me because my mom gives me “special treatment” because of my disability
@Olimick98
@Olimick98 2 года назад
I’m really glad they showed the harm Millie’s reaction did. Because it’s a very common response for parents of disabled children. There’s being sad about the hardship your child has to face, and then there’s implying your child would be better off dead than disabled. It’s sad that Millie’s character goes this way, but I think it shows even more how Jayfeather helps Briarlight and how she overcomes her mother’s words and finds happiness.
@danascully7997
@danascully7997 2 года назад
I know you probably can’t talk about the new protagonists in River yet since we only have a preview, but could you maybe talk about the cats in their lives? Like Flamepaw has a lot of interesting dynamics with Sparkpelt and Baypaw, and even Lilyheart! And Sunbeam has interactions Lightleap a lot, and Blazefire. The only character I liked in Frostpaw’s chapter, besides Mothwing, was Whistlepaw.
@joltyflare
@joltyflare 2 года назад
As a disabled person myself, I can say her struggles are surprisingly realistic. I'm not paralyzed but I suffer from chronic migraines, which is debilitating enough for me to be at home a lot so I can rest immediately and take medication if an episode occurs. Millie's complaints about her daughter being disabled and acting like her life is over is similar to what my mother did once. In both Warriors and in real life, it feels like a lot of the time people only care about a person's ability to make money and socialize. Because of that, it really does feel hard to accept oneself because we are indeed treated as "being broken." I'm honestly fine with my life and I can work around my disability but there are always Millies out there who will not be able to accept that you can have a disability and be content. It's honestly tiring and Briarlight's struggles are something I relate well to. I eventually learned that my personality is where my worth lies and that it's fine to try just living as comfortably as I can and be content with it regardless of whether or not people think is "normal." Also, my suggestion: I think Heathertail would be a neat cat to talk about. Her character is interesting and I'm actually shocked she hasn't had her own novella yet, considering the importance she has in the lives of Lionblaze and Breezepelt.
@evahagen9131
@evahagen9131 2 года назад
I actually have to disagree on blossomfall. In Germany, we would call her a "shadowchild" - Someone who feels left on the side by their parents because of the terminal illness of a sibling. That often leads to misplaced grudge towards that sibling + guild for feeling that way. The way I read it, it never seemed like she wanted the same treatment from Millie towards briarlight, but just that she wanted A relationship with her mother AT ALL. I mean, come on - she comes home with a bloody head and Millie doesn't even care. That's why the argument "but she had so many other people around her!" doesn't work for me - they are not her mother. I'm an adult too, but if my mother would stop caring about me at all I would be hurt too, no matter how many good friends I have. I'm not saying blossomfall is perfect. The obvious solution to her problem would have been to just TALK to both briarlight and Millie. But this is warrior cats and none talks to anyone, specially when you are a sidecharacter, so the authors never resolved it.
@firefancy9928
@firefancy9928 2 года назад
Thank you for pointing this out. I was hoping someone mentioned this.
@Moonkitti
@Moonkitti 2 года назад
Are you saying that as an adult, you would blame your disabled sibling if your mother stopped caring for you? Because that's what Blossomfall did. I didn't say she shouldn't be upset. I'm saying she shouldn't be upset with her sister over her mother.
@evahagen9131
@evahagen9131 2 года назад
​@@Moonkitti No, of course not and that's not what I said. I said having a mother that doesn't care about you is upsetting for anyone at any age. Blossomfall acknowledged that none of this is briarlights fold. She seems to feel genuine sorry for her sister's condition. But she also feels bitterness that her mother stopped caring for her, and that started with briarlights injury. While she says she is angry with briarlight, she also says she is sorry that she has to go through all that, and she acknowledged that she should not feel that way towards her sister - she also NEVER lets her emotion out on her, as far as we know briarlight never even knew she felt that way. The person she seems to actually be mad at is her mother. It honestly reads like blossomfall is more angry at briarlight INJURY and Millies treatment towards herself than her actual sister as a person. And again, these are emotions that a lot of people with disabled family members feel. These people are not horrible people for simply having those emotions, as long as they don't let them out on the disabled family member, which again, SHE DOESN'T DO. Nobody HAS to like Blossomfall, I agree with you that she is a classic mean girl. But I do feel empathy for her situation, and I think her emotions are more complicated than "Well she just mean!".
@kristaatare9688
@kristaatare9688 2 года назад
@@Moonkitti honestly psyhology wise its just normal for blossomfall to get mad at her sister aswell, the same thing would probs happen with a human child/teenager, im not saying its good im saying it would take a special tipe of self realisation to realise that ur only blaming your disabled sister becouse of your mothers actions, over all that anger ur not able to think straight, and if it happens constantly then u wont ever be able to think straight. Only thearapy could fix that
@lucilucid
@lucilucid 2 года назад
@@Moonkitti Emotions and feelings can be stupid and irrational at times. I can have a strong feeling about something and know it is stupid and incorrect. Though that doesn't make it go away and it can be easier to give into it at the end of the day. Not defending her but I can kind of understand the feelings behind it. I struggle with my brain a lot and I know I need professional help since I can't do it alone.
@Twuwu
@Twuwu 2 года назад
40 minutes of Moonkitti Talking? Awesome!
@clover284
@clover284 2 года назад
*I genuinely love Briarlight so much. She’s a great cat and I love her relationships with other cats (like Jayfeather and Alderheart as you mentioned.) and her entire personality in general. Probably one of my favorite cats in the series. She’s really sweet if I’m being honest. She helps both Jayfeather and Alderheart with their own problems even with having to deal with her own from Millie’s overprotection.* *also I LOVE THE CUTE INTERACTIONS SHE HAS. Really makes me happy.*
@amberbydreamsart5467
@amberbydreamsart5467 2 года назад
I would love to hear about Russetfur! Her origins as a rogue/implied bloodclan cat and rising to shadowclan deputy I find really interesting, and she's been a popular semi-background character for a while.
@Laze_n_Daze
@Laze_n_Daze Год назад
Briarlight's experiences are so accurate to my own. Some people becoming overbearingly "helpful", some people distancing themselves because you or what happened to you makes them uncomfortable, even Blossomfall's painful jealousy. I definitely read that as her feeling incredibly guilty and not blaming Briar at all. And of course she wouldn't talk to anyone about it, she feels like it makes her unforgivable, she certainly never forgives herself for those feelings. I think the reactions are all very well written, very real reactions, ablism included. Briarlight constantly minimising herself and her needs is also frighteningly accurate, especially the "I'm not useful, so I don't deserve to eat." mentality. 😅 I adore Briarlight for so many reasons. Longtail was one of my favourite characters and his death was so hard for me and when Briarlight died I was a mess. Completely and utterly devastated.
@pawprintseekers5323
@pawprintseekers5323 2 года назад
I think you should talk about deadfoot, he is Crowfeather’s dad, tallstar’s apprentice. Plus he is one of the disabled cats that is not made to be a medicine cat or elder, instead he is a deputy! Like the one cat I can think of that got something better than him was Crookedstar, but the reason I’m not talking about Crookedstar is because he is popular and deadfoot is not, I think he is good novella Material tbh
@timidDot
@timidDot 2 года назад
i'm physically disabled (not paralyzed, but still) and i remember briarlight being pretty important to me as a kid reading omen of the stars, i fell off of the series after that (couldn't get into the dawn of the clans) but i liked her a lot. i didn't know i was disabled back then but i do now and i really relate to so much about briarlight, especially with the cruelty from her mother, and i appreciate all the points you made in this video. remembering some of the things jayfeather said to her genuinely made me cry because he was so kind to her and that exchange about her not deserving to eat because she can't hunt is so similar to conversations i've had with my partner about my disability and how it affects my ability to work. i just really appreciate you talking about this and i know i'm being really emotional in the warrior cats video comment section but i just wanted to thank you. :•)
@wisterias6484
@wisterias6484 2 года назад
I’M NOT GIVING UP Since you did Poppyfrost, I’d love to see one on her siblings. Honeyfern, Cinderheart, Lilyheart, and maybe even Seedpaw would be cool to see (Molepaw skipped because he existed for a book or two before they give him Greencough and killed him).
@mykie5287
@mykie5287 2 года назад
I’d love to see you talk about Daisy! She’s so interesting to me
@Mx_Mc
@Mx_Mc 2 года назад
I’m so excited for BriarLight! She is such a good character
@ParadoxusSquid
@ParadoxusSquid 2 года назад
I'd love to hear you talk about Needletail! I personally think she is one of the most engaging characters Warriors has ever had, but I know how divisive she is in the fandom lol
@BravestarBDB
@BravestarBDB 2 года назад
I would love to hear you talk about Rowanclaw. He went from a pretty feisty (she)cat to a leader that let everyone walk all over him. Also him and Tawnypelt don’t appear to have much chemistry and were together. Also his granddaughter getting his name is . . . interesting.
@firstmoon2400
@firstmoon2400 2 года назад
But Rowanclaw is not a female
@luvulfurz_64
@luvulfurz_64 2 года назад
Could you talk about Berrynose? He’s had a very interesting life, being one of the apprentices that grew up with lionblaze, and we got to explore him a bit. Now that he’s dead we have nothing more to explore and we can fully dive deep into his character
@catxborsuq1
@catxborsuq1 2 года назад
Never really liked him (well, since Power of Three, when he was a kit he was cool), but he didn't deserve what happened to him in The Broken Code :/
@InkSans_FandomSoda
@InkSans_FandomSoda 2 года назад
Next discussion on Moth Flight, maybe? She’s very interesting and you can discuss a lot about her.
@monster.student
@monster.student Год назад
I am not a physically disabled person (yet suspect neurodivergency) but I think Briarlight's trauma with her ableist mother is great represented. I relate to how parents deny the disability and victimize, and even ignore their child and I know how painful that is and how it affects you later on, the useless feeling and the eventual need to h@rm yourself thinking that you deserve it.
@Hadeshy
@Hadeshy 2 года назад
Haven't finished the video yet, might watch it in multiple take. But I wanted to pause because I now imagine Tigerstar and Hawkfrast surrounded by butterflies in the dark forest. Also, as someone with a disability, the scene where Briarlight want to be useful and Jayfeather says she doesn't need to be is really something, at least to me. It's like Briarlight is voicing the worries I sometimes have. Cause even knowing that it's just a stupid concept, sometimes, it's hard not to think about it, especially when everyone around you is working AND taking care of you and you feel so powerless and guilty. Idk if it was the intention of the authors, but it made Brialight felt real and close to me.
@kaydentaylor1862
@kaydentaylor1862 2 года назад
As a kid, my older brother was diagnosed with ADHD. Immediately he was getting so much more attention from my parents. I didn’t feel like it was fair. I had naturally good grades then, even envying him because “If I had grades like him, my parents wouldn’t expect any better from me.” Looking back I realize this is more my parents fault than his. Now I’ve been diagnosed with it as well ironically, and I didn’t get any extra attention like he did but I realized- I didn’t really WANT any. I was a kid, who saw my brother getting so much more attention than me and felt jealous and unloved. I don’t really hold anything over my brother anymore, meaningless envy for years gone. I can understand Blossomfall. Although I believe she should’ve tried harder to really understand what Briarlight was going through, in the warrior cat universe where people don’t really even tell each other things I cant blame her. If her mother had given her as much attention as Briarlight this wouldn’t be an issue. So of course it’s Millies fault, and not her sisters but Millie is her mother. I used to wish something happened to me like breaking my arm as a kid, just for some attention. I would lie a lot just to get reactions. I wonder if I would be able to make more friends if I wasn’t so jealous and lonely in the past I obviously know better now, but I still regret those years.
@Canineblood05
@Canineblood05 2 года назад
Id love to hear about sol!! i feel he was severely underused for a villain and he could have been more interesting. the fandom doesnt talk about him enough in my opinion. any of the athiest cats are really cool and interesting story wise, because they are directly denying after evidence. and hes just cool lol. Great vid on briarlight, too!! love to see her getting more attention
@oddbloochicken
@oddbloochicken 2 года назад
I think moth flight is an interesting character to talk about. I think its implied she had basically cat ADHD. And ive been rereading dotc and her super edition lately. Seeing the way cats treat her and get so frustrated at her made me sad and kinda relate to her myself as i recently got diagnosed with ADHD myself. She also is basically the equivalent of a teen mum studying to be a doctor and expecting to look after all her kits with little to no help
@moonli8123
@moonli8123 2 года назад
Please talk about Leafstar and Skyclan!!! They're the most logical and seemingly moral clan and have some of my favorite characters.
@jelly_4_brainz
@jelly_4_brainz 2 года назад
6:11 I just have to say that is the ❤️cutest❤️ picture of Briarlight and Jayfeather I have ever seen, not in a shippy way but it just shows off their dynamic in the best way and it perfectly encapsulates what you're talking about when you're talking about it. Also I love bright eyed Briarlight!
@ABTW
@ABTW 2 года назад
A similar thing to Briarlight’s incident happened to my mother’s friend. She and her husband were surveying their property after a storm to see if anything was damaged. A large branch on one of their trees was, in fact, heavily damaged and fell on my mother’s friend. Her back was injured and her legs have been paralyzed for five years now, I think. She started walking around again with a walker like a year ago, and her recovery is awesome.
@MysticMetaKnight
@MysticMetaKnight Год назад
Graystripe used up most of his "affection for offspring" on Stormfur and Feathertail, and lost his personality on the way back to the clans 😂
@macgyversmacbook1861
@macgyversmacbook1861 10 месяцев назад
So basically when his overbearing spoiled wife came up 🤣
@honoramongassasins8056
@honoramongassasins8056 2 года назад
38:08 I feel like if you ever include her in a video again, this is a good way to do it. She makes a good straight man, yes, and this can be expanded heavily by this dynamic that exists- she's the optimist in a room full of pessimists, the one who sees Jayfeather and Leafpool wallowing in misery and goes "HEY GUYS I GOT CAT STARBUCKS." Not only that, as you described, she's such a great foil for Jayfeather in particular- seeing him brooding and being there to roll her eyes and laugh at him to cheer him up. Plus, with that snarky, gossipy side, she can make for a very unique and unconventional straight-ER man that's really not so above it all, especially when interacting with kits and apprentices. Loved this video! Even though it's been a while since I've read Warriors, I'm still subscribed to your channel and have been since middle school. I love your perspective on Briarlight especially, since she didn't make the world's biggest impression on me when I was younger. That said, I appreciate her like ten times more after this, so thank you so much!
@kwittenish
@kwittenish 2 года назад
i mean. she probably thinks the way she does about the situation with briarlight and millie because of the dark forest. they did the same thing with dovewing and ivypool, “oh it’s dovewing’s fault she gets all the attention and she’s treated so differently than you! be mad at her instead of the cats who treat her differently and pay more attention to her than they do you!”. it’s most likely the same thing for blossomfall. also it’s easier to emotional manipulate her into thinking she’s a bad person incapable of redemption if she’s angry at her disabled sister instead of her mother. and that’s exactly what blossomfall thinks, she hates herself for feeling jealous of briarlight, and she believes that because of her feelings she going to the dark forest. the dark forest probably turned blossomfall’s jealousy of briarlight into a hatred of her, the same way ivypool’s jealousy turned into a hatred of dovewing.
@Normal_Arkplayer_
@Normal_Arkplayer_ Год назад
At least when Jay'feather visits star clan she'll be waiting for him, Sweet sweet briarlight
@elemental-winter3085
@elemental-winter3085 2 года назад
Thrushpelt needs more love. He did so much for Bluestar and I just love how he was supportive no matter what. Some of the lines about Thrushpelt or from Thrushpelt are my favourite in the entirety of Bluestar's Prophecy.
@s1llyguy
@s1llyguy 2 года назад
i'd ADORE a video about Riverstar/River Ripple. hes both the founder of Riverclan (which seems to have completely changed as time has passed, feeling very distanced from his ideals and motivation) AND made the mentor/apprentice system, an important part of the Warriors universe. it would also be cool to see any of your predictions for his super edition? since we dont know much about him other than a few appearances in moth Flight's Vision, Leopardstar's Honor and DOTC (not much!!!) i feel like the Erins could do ANYTHING with his character.
@nearlynight
@nearlynight Год назад
Briarlight is one of my favourite cats in the series. I was born with a muscle weakness that is slowly but surely making it impossible for me to walk, more over these past years than ever. When I was diagnosed with my physical disabilities, my parents denied it. They took away my braces, I couldn't have a walking cane. The sort of detatchment and panic Millie goes through, and then overbearing attitude, feels incredibly relatable as someone who grew up with a helicopter mother who really, desperately hated the fact I was disabled. The fact Briarlight gets to be.. just, happy, has always encouraged me. I've grown a lot of hatred and trauma regarding my disabilities and part of me feels like she's become a positive influence in the way I see myself, which is hard for me these days. Her portrayal hit me really close to home, especially since I used to do.. so much- I was reckless, I ran and did track, I figure skated, I was always on my feet. Part of me always felt like I did it to myself, though of course that isn't true. Briarlight is an amazing character, and it always made me stew in my own self-worth issues when people would hate her so vehemently back then.
@wildmimic8164
@wildmimic8164 2 года назад
Jayfeather when Hollyleaf dies: Ouch that hurt anyway . . . Jayfeather when Brairlight dies: *deep breath* AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
@fefrezi
@fefrezi 2 года назад
im not physically disabled, but i am a t1 diabetic briarlights death really hurts me bc i almost died the same way, insisting nothing was wrong n that i didnt want to bother people as i was literally dying of ketoacidosis in my deluded state of mind, which i almost dont remember, only from being told by family, all i said was im fine to my parents n paramedics i also struggle with a bunch of self hatred to my worth, thinking im a burden on the money and lives of people that care about me, similar to briarlight briarlights death Destroyed me, to the point i didnt finish avos n didnt start tbc, i want the new arc though
@lunasaurus0802
@lunasaurus0802 2 года назад
‘D love to hear you talk about Mothwing/Alderheart. He’s such a cutie and has always been my favorite medicine cat! I just feel like he diesn’t get much attention in the fandom. And Mothwing is just a bean that I adore and would love to hear you talk about! They both deserve some attention.
@justlikethewizard
@justlikethewizard Год назад
I loved Briarlight so much. She was such a good character for Jayfeather and her chemistry with him is easily the best of any characters in the series. Not even in a ship way, she was just so great for him and I think her place as his foil really helped both characters shine. I'm still so upset about her death, Jay is my favorite character and watching his heart break made it so clear how important she was to him.
@emilymonahan5232
@emilymonahan5232 2 года назад
I'd love to see a video about Icecloud and Foxleap. They're characters who appear in your videos more often that other background cats, and they actually have a little personality. They're pretty funny, I think.
@peepytime
@peepytime 2 года назад
40 minutes of Moonkitti talking about Briarlight? Heck yeah! Thank you , this was super great to watch! Briarlight is up there for one of my favorite warrior cats characters. Hearing that story about Vicky's cousin was absolutely touching, and I had no idea that was the origins of why she survived like she did!
@susiepilled
@susiepilled 2 года назад
DOVEWING. she struggled a lot in her life and went through a lot - responsibility of powers at a young age, some trauma from rippletail's death, her relationship with ivypool, the love triangle/corner with bumblestripe and tigerheart. losing her powers, having to cope with that, and leaving thunderclan. would love to see a video on her! ive always really loved her
@barleysixseventwo6665
@barleysixseventwo6665 Год назад
Anyone else notice this stuff always seems to happen in Thunderclan? We've had a Blind Cat, A Deaf Cat, A Paraplegic Cat, A Cat with a crippled leg, And a cat with half her face mauled. Meanwhile between Windclan, Riverclan, Shadowclan, and Skyclan the only "on-screen" chronic or permanent injury I can recall is...Runningnose's cold?
@thelittlepoppy8970
@thelittlepoppy8970 Год назад
Crookedjaw/star and Deadfoor
@meevins
@meevins Год назад
it's not a case of disabled cats just not existing in other clans but it's because so much of the narrative of warrior cats is focused on thunderclan, it's the clan that gets the most focus and screentime so yeah that makes sense? also p.s i would uh not use the word crippled to describe a disabled character.
@Answeredriddle
@Answeredriddle 2 года назад
Absolutely lovely video tackling a lot of fantastic points for such a fantastic character. Briarlight was such a delightful addition to the series and I miss her presence dearly. Also: go to BED you're causing ME hives with the thought of staying up till asscrack o'clock for a video. REST. HAVE GOOD BIRTHDAY NEXT WEEK. SLEEP. WASH RINSE REPEAT.
@pebblecrust
@pebblecrust 2 года назад
I would like to see a talk about ivypool, this video talks about her for a bit while blossomfall is being discussed but I think she should have a video to herself. I think that her time in the dark forest and her jealousy of dovewing make her a very interesting character. Her relationship with fernsong surprised me and I also think it's a topic worth talking about.
Далее
Talking: Rowanclaw
35:47
Просмотров 160 тыс.
Talking: Moth Flight
35:08
Просмотров 215 тыс.
ROBLOX TRAND AGAIN. Part 7☠️🗿🙋🏻‍♀️
00:16
Spottedleaf's feelings are probably a retcon
26:20
Просмотров 190 тыс.
Cats to END
12:33
Просмотров 758 тыс.
Harpy Hare - Warrior cats, PoT  (AMV)
0:42
Просмотров 38 тыс.
I want Warrior Cats to Change Permanently
17:11
Просмотров 449 тыс.
Gender In Warrior Cats - Sunny's Spiel | Warriors Analysis
1:17:52
The Life of Briarlight
5:30
Просмотров 18 тыс.
WALK WITH ME - GRASSPELT & BRIARLIGHT AU MAP
2:51
Просмотров 73 тыс.
Cat Ages and Sizes
9:44
Просмотров 419 тыс.
Talking: Stormtail
21:17
Просмотров 194 тыс.