Some of IFK (famous Russia`s alternative band) musicians - t.A.T.u support band in 2002-2004. Me (Peter "PJ" Zhavoronkov) on drums, Denis "Pit" Petukhov - bass, Max Galstyan - guitar, Vlad "Moskva" Antonenko - keyboards.
2021. Когда они появились, у меня не было и мысли их слушать, на фоне Земфиры они казались детсадом)) А сейчас как что-то новое для меня зашло на ура))
bro that was a stellar performance. How the heck could people just sit and watch there 🤣I couldn't help but headbang the entire time, imagine hearing that live.
They are not lip syncing, if you had any amount of a musical ear it would be obvious, especially at the beginning. And they are really singing on all their recordings - no pitch correction gimmickry. And Julia is a pretty good pianist. At some point during their early career in their live shows they did use an off-stage female singer to supplement the harmonies that are on the album songs, and the off-stage singer would also sing unison with Julia or Lena when Julia or Lena were singing a solo part of a song, you can hear the off-stage singer at certain parts of this performance. Many bands/artists also do this for their live shows, and not just off-stage singers, off-stage musicians as well, usually a keyboardist.
@@MarkRaymondLuce They are singing. But the high tones are playback. Yulia is fighting all the time to arrive it (she tries as good as she can), but when it is impossible (because of her operation voice), than became music voice. Lena is singing all the time. I think that they see eachother because Yulia wants to sing all and Lena support her. They made part of my childhood/teen!! I love the feeling :)
@@miriamv9 That could be, but if it is in fact a playback of her voice, that means someone such as the on stage keyboard player or someone off stage is pressing a specific note on a keyboard that plays a sample of her voice singing that particular vocal phrase which would why the drummer is wearing headphones - this is also common in many live performances of different bands/solo singers with backing band. Aerosmith does this live where Steven Tyler is singing lead vocals live but there are also Steven Tyler backing vocal parts because a keyboard player offstage is playing sampled Steven Tyler vocal parts - watch any live version of Love In An Elevator - I saw them live twice and Steve Tyler's harmony vocals were being played off stage by a keyboard player; the other alternative would be that Julia & Lena are singing live over a pre-recorded stereo mix - maybe the CD itself and the band is not really playing live - but the drummer is playing live along to the pre-recorded stereo mix, which is also possible but highly risky for ethical reasons and critics would not like it and expose it; but that doesn't seem to be the case here, the band seems to be playing live - the drummer definitely is and he's wearing headphones and the only reason for a drummer wearing headphones live is because they are receiving a metronome click track because other parts are being played via samples from a keyboard which is what is going on here, because certain parts of this song live has three different guitar parts just like the album studio version, but there is only one guitar player on stage. But like I said above, there is only one reason for a drummer to be wearing headphones during a live performance, that is because they are receiving a metronome click track for syncing to samples that will be played at various sections in the song. There is a live video of t.A.T.u where there is another female singer standing next to the drummer singing with Julia & Lena - it is an outdoor daytime concert I think in Moscow, I saw this video a few years ago.
Son tan lindas verlas cantar juntas y nadie les puede igualar son únicas julia y lena x dios lena canta con julia que te cuesta creo que nada olvida todo lo malo sabes 🔥🔥😘
Yulia had a vocal cyst and she gave a girl three months before it, she had real serious vocal problems, cause of the high notes she did when she recorded demos, and 2 albums, and in gigs, in all of the songs of their two first albums she sang with high notes except for 30 Minutes/Polchasa, Stars/Zachem Ya, Doschitai Do Sta, Ya Tvoi Vrag and Robot, she sang with high notes in two songs incluided on t.A.T.u. Remixes CD called Ne Ver', Ne Boisya, Ne Prosi and Prostye Dvizheniya
I know it's an 11 year old comment but not true for gigs. Tatu never sung live until their Eurovision performance in 2003. I don't buy the whole screaming thing causing her voice problems as she only screamed on a few from both albums and never sung again till Eurovision. I think it's more to do with not having a strong voice in the first place and her smoking since the age of 12.
@@redplague Well. I carefully watched all of their performances and in the 200 Po Vstrechnoy Tour (2001-2002) they sang over the track in various performances except for a few televised ones in shows, awards, then in 2003 after Eurovision they sang fully live for the first time, also in festivals with their live band with backing track on chorus/harmonies, but they still lip synced in some TV shows, others not. Then in Dangerous and Moving era, the same, in the promo tour they lip synced in some TV performances only but in other live events with the band they sang live, then in the D&M Tour they sang 90% live, also in their small 2008 Waste Managenent/Upravleniye Otbrosami Tour and 2013/14 small comeback appareances performances were live. Julia had several cyst removal surgeries between 2003-2005 and since late 2006 her voice improved a lot. But then after their split in their solo careers, late 2012 she undergone a surgery to remove thyroid cancer where they accidentally touched her vocal chords and since then damage was irreversible, she improved from time to time, but then again she lost her voice sometimes. And she has chorists and uses pre recorded vocals a lot
@@krayewskikevin Not in the screaming sections she didn't. I've seen most of the performances from 2001-2002 that are available in youtube and she certainly didn't scream in any of those I saw. Also there is an established link between smoking and cysts and other problems with vocal chords.
@@redplague you need to go back and listen better. She said herself that singing too high and too loud was damaging her voice, and around 2006 you can hear the results.
Yulia is singing on playback in chorus, but the verses not... :) Lena all of it live... :D I can understand her, her voice couldn't manage so high notes at that time... after 2005 they singed all live! :)
Despite them being a producer created pop band and the cookie-cutter band I have to say they did this pretty good. The odd octaved singing was pretty cool as well.
13 year old comment but anyway, yeah as someone that lives from making music its incredible how charming they were, even if theyre not "true artists" or whatever. Great song and duo.
I say shotgun, you say wedding not really, Yulia (dark haired one) started to struggle with her voice, because her manager made her sing really high notes, he basically made her scream, her voice used to be really high and now is hoarse, she isn’t married anymore, and at first she needed to get a surgery because she had a cyst so that’s why she couldn’t sing that song anymore or not gonna get us, just the ones that didn’t require that much power
@@AlexAndra-wb4cc its the vocal problems she had as you can hear in the lower notes she sounds fine but as soon as she attempts a high note it just cracks
not all of them. yulia attempted 1/3 of them but her vocal strings are broken and would not comply. she had a vocal cyst. she sang some of the lower high notes, also.
Светленькая девушка слишком много лажает, все-таки. А темненькая - вполне так сносно поет. Просто может и глупо от поп исполнителей наших требовать уровень, но такие оплошности - это перебор. Ну а сыграли - отлично. Что и говорить. Молодцы ТАТУ )))))))))))
this is the first time I see yulia singing alive... she was singing alive , but in the tv , they made it like playback it always happens in the show she sang alive , but in the tv , she was doing playback
But Now: vogue is gone, but show - became more proffesional! Compare! Maybe vocal became level up too! :))) But maybe it`s smart equipment...:))) But! Main point! - Great energy! Nevermind about vocal lessons! Sex Pistols never thought about it! :))) And many others greats too.
Cada que las escucho me imagino la escena de la película Desde Pool 2 donde hace la simulación de dos tijeras con los dedos dándose placer... No sé por qué?🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
One of the weirdest presentations ever: those girls were trying to sing with playback and live at the same time, the drums were so awful plus the people were sitting like watching a movie!
