Тёмный

Tesla Model 3 - Bloody Stupid Idea Removing The Indicator Stalks! (Highland) 

Electric Vehicle Man
Подписаться 81 тыс.
Просмотров 74 тыс.
50% 1

Tesla have removed the indicator stalks for steering wheel mounted buttons on the new Model 3 facelift (highland). An idiotic decision!
2nd Channel: / @drivingohm
Website: www.ev-man.co.uk
Tesla Referral: ts.la/andrew31112
Twitter: / evmanuk
Octopus Referral: share.octopus....
#electriccars #tesla #model3

Опубликовано:

 

8 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,7 тыс.   
@dethier1958
@dethier1958 11 месяцев назад
I’m American. We have a lot of roundabouts in my city too. I hate the idea of removing the stalks. If they had kept the stalks, I’d buy this as soon as it was available. Now I’ll wait until Tesla comes to their senses.
@iBackBeat
@iBackBeat 11 месяцев назад
Great to read this from an American!
@andyarchitect
@andyarchitect 11 месяцев назад
Totally agree. I wouldn't buy a car with basic controls that move. Even accessing heater controls through a screen is super annoying and distracting.
@paulybluenose
@paulybluenose 7 месяцев назад
I love my Tesla but your right.
@andrewuk
@andrewuk 11 месяцев назад
Yep. Agree 100%. Buttons are stupid for indicators.
@nickhickson8738
@nickhickson8738 11 месяцев назад
The Model 3 steering wheel and interior in general has always been a disaster. Everything controlled by a stupid screen, even the glove box lid.
@zes3813
@zes3813 5 месяцев назад
wrong
@QALibrary
@QALibrary 11 месяцев назад
I would not be surprised if there a number of countries around the world that insist on this setup with no stalks is not allowed
@carolinereidartist
@carolinereidartist 11 месяцев назад
I cant imagine Australia approving this
@murphymakesnoise
@murphymakesnoise 11 месяцев назад
@@carolinereidartistI will be honest and say I have ordered a new Model 3 and I am quietly hoping that whatever Australian Gov body decides these things will not approve it and my car will turn up with stalks anyway.
@runeg286
@runeg286 11 месяцев назад
The Model 3 is not the first car with buttons instead of stalks, were they approved?
@murphymakesnoise
@murphymakesnoise 11 месяцев назад
This is the first mass market car to not have stalks. It is clearly a safety issue, so obviously so. Australia has already banned online poker, and is just about to ban vaping. It isn't the kind of country that wouldn't ban Tesla if it wanted to. @@runeg286
@burger9997
@burger9997 9 месяцев назад
@@runeg286Probably not, but hopefully regulators make an example
@savedfaves
@savedfaves 11 месяцев назад
Bad design isn't opinion in this case. These on-wheel turning directions are dangerous.
@FireWalkMusic
@FireWalkMusic 11 месяцев назад
Can't believe this is actually legal in the EU?? Tried it with the new model S a while back. Extremely annoying and dangerous to use, as it forces you to keep looking down at the wheel to figure out where the buttons are, while in the middle of a roundabout. That, or just not using the indicator light at all when changing lanes and exiting. Neither is safe.
@HyperVegitoDBZ
@HyperVegitoDBZ 11 месяцев назад
In EU, which preaches about safety, they allow massive LED screens instead of buttons. Retards from Brussels will agree to anything for a hefty paycheck.@@FireWalkMusic
@fts3865
@fts3865 11 месяцев назад
@@FireWalkMusic yes, you have to constantly look down…the first week. Then you get used to it
@FireWalkMusic
@FireWalkMusic 11 месяцев назад
@@fts3865 That's not my experience. You'll probably get used to it in the US with the grid based roads there, but not in the EU and other places with tight roundabouts everywhere, which will require you to turn the wheel several rotations constantly. In many of cases, you're almost making a 180-degree turn. A lot of people can't get used to this even after using it for months. Some probably never will, simply because you can't train muscle memory for things that constantly change. Muscle memory works by repetition, so it works well for a stalk that is fixed in place and never moves, but not things that constantly change, like the buttons. Even Teslabjorn struggles with the buttons after 2 months of use, as he explains in this video: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-4UOCsbB-KXg.htmlsi=doZsQSwT7l7bu1ua&t=180
@davidlevy706
@davidlevy706 4 месяца назад
@@FireWalkMusic I'm in the US, but I'm unsure of whether I'd be able to get used to it - and entirely uninterested in finding out. This is a shockingly stupid design change.
@markharding44
@markharding44 11 месяцев назад
Totally agree. Removal of both indicator and drive selector stalks is a terrible idea. This button removal obsession with all car manufacturers is getting stupid.
@KeyhanHadjari
@KeyhanHadjari 11 месяцев назад
It is very strange that strict safety rules allowed this. I bet this will result in accidents.
@FireWalkMusic
@FireWalkMusic 11 месяцев назад
Indeed, I wouldn't be surprised if this is eventually made illegal. At least in the EU. People are just going to stop using their indicator lights now. This forces you to either take your eyes off the road and look down to find out where the button is, or not signaling at all. Neither is safe.
@roberts.wilson1848
@roberts.wilson1848 11 месяцев назад
At least is an easy solve, just by replacing the steering wheel and supporting area. When the recall comes, you can add the new part. The wiring is all there, just needs to be taken to a stalk instead of the wheel. But i smell they won't go away, because this minimalist method is for their desired future of self driving cars and not a driver's car. A person driving around would be like, a rare occasion, so the human driving interaction to be minimal from now, and then removed altogether.
@vasil7410
@vasil7410 11 месяцев назад
It most will likely become illegal. Unlike the US and unlike the niche model S and X, the mass market Model 3 sold all around the world will likely prompt regulators into action. Recalls with retrofits will be required.
@benverdel3073
@benverdel3073 11 месяцев назад
And fines for "absence or faulty use of indicators"
@LunnarisLP
@LunnarisLP 11 месяцев назад
people always seem to assume stuff without data. Tesla is a massively data driven company and safety has always been their top priority. Do you really think they gave that no though? I doubt its less save
@lanceareadbhar
@lanceareadbhar 11 месяцев назад
This feels like the yoke all over again. They don't seem to ever think of situations when the wheel is turned.
@hobo1704
@hobo1704 11 месяцев назад
Yep, tech company, not a car manufacturer.. Clearly shown with this stupid car
@mobtgmjb
@mobtgmjb 11 месяцев назад
Totally agree. Stupid decision. Not having a wiper stalk is also very very annoying!
@FireWalkMusic
@FireWalkMusic 11 месяцев назад
The most used function in my Tesla is by far the wiper button..... It probably wouldn't have been a big deal if Tesla had a dedicated functional rain sensor that just WORKS, like every other car has had for the past 20+ years. They said it would be just as good as a dedicated rain sensor back in 2016, but it still sucks. It only works somewhat satisfactory in optimal light conditions. But at night it's completely useless. Same during light snowfall etc. Driving more or less "blind" through a roundabout, unable to quickly engage the wipers because you're not sure where the button has ended up is not just annoying, it's unsafe. Some guy in Germany crashed his model 3 trying to adjust the wiper settings on the screen a while back. This new design will make everything 10 times worse..
@ncb_uk
@ncb_uk 11 месяцев назад
Tbf not only Tesla has shite auto wipers, the ones on my Nissan Leaf annoy me every time it rains. I believe Audi drivers complain too.
@horitulgi
@horitulgi 11 месяцев назад
Totally agree - the rain sensor on my MY is utterly useless. its basically bi-polar - going like mad when there is no rain and not going at all when there is a fine mist (no visibility). The worst is when you clean your screen in winter on roads that have been gritted/salted. It cleans, but then the wipers carry on wiping well after moisture has been on screen, now it is smudging salt spray all over the windscreen and I cannot see again. In these conditions I cannot use auto windscreen wipers. Seems an answer - however auto windscreen wipers is compulsory when you engage adaptive cruise- Thus in these conditions, I cannot uses either auto windscreen or adaptive cruise!!!!!!!- @@FireWalkMusic
@greghudson9717
@greghudson9717 11 месяцев назад
I have relegated my copilot (wife) to manually altering wiper speed when necessary - that's how bad Tesla auto wipers are ! (I'm a Model Y owner, and a TSLA shareholder, but no-one listens to me 😞)
@nnnmos
@nnnmos 11 месяцев назад
Agree , it’s a really stupid idea and would stop me replacing my Model 3 with a new one.
@smallmj2886
@smallmj2886 Год назад
Steering wheel controls are fine for tertiary functions like audio control (volume, next track, etc), because you shouldn't be messing with them while you are navigating a complex turn anyway. Turn signals are more important than that, and using wheel buttons is just a bad idea.
@keithnewton8981
@keithnewton8981 11 месяцев назад
Oh please this is not the first we had cars with indicator stalk. We had buttons before i6sceasyvto get use to for drivers
@stepheng8779
@stepheng8779 11 месяцев назад
​@@keithnewton8981 It's not that easy to use the buttons on your phone, is it? 😂
@davidvestey6014
@davidvestey6014 11 месяцев назад
Perhaps they don’t have corners in the US?
@hishamg
@hishamg 11 месяцев назад
@@davidvestey6014they don’t have many roundabouts. They prefer traffic lights and giant intersections.
@fanfeck2844
@fanfeck2844 11 месяцев назад
BMWs have managed without indicators for years
@FireWalkMusic
@FireWalkMusic 11 месяцев назад
Removing the stalks was a huge mistake. It will affect sales negatively. Turn signal buttons on the wheel, that keeps moving around when turning the wheel is extremely frustrating to use in the EU and other places where we use mainly roundabouts. I decided not to get a new model S because of this. Can't stand those buttons. I had to constantly choose between looking down at the wheel or not indicating at all. After nearly crashing a few times when exiting roundabouts because I accidentally pressed the wrong button or didn't signal at all, I decided I was done and started looking at other brands instead. It's a shame that the refreshed model 3 is getting this as well, because the car looks like a big upgrade in many other ways. Stupid move by tesla! It's not safe to use and I'm actually surprised this is even legal in the EU. They should have kept the stalks, added a HUD or instrument cluster for the driver, and redesigned the back so that it became a true hatchback. That would have made the car far more desirable. By removing the stalks they achieve the opposite. Sure, most people could probably get used to it, eventually. But a lot just won't bother. The problem is that a lot of average people who are considering buying a tesla for the first time will be upset by this when they test drive the car, and end up going for another brand instead. I know a guy who wanted to buy the current model 3, but decided against it simply because he thought the camera-based auto wipers were so bad (and they are). Imagine how many people these new turn signal buttons will upset.. They take the car for a test drive, going through a few roundabouts and they will either fail to indicate at all, push the wrong button, or nearly crash because they're looking down at the wheel instead of looking at the road. Other people might be honking at them too for driving like an idiot and or not signaling. Not a great first experience. I can imagine a lot of people would rather just go buy something they're familiar with, rather than committing to "unlearning" 20 years of muscle memory.. So yeah, I totally agree. It's just plain stupid! Cost cutting taken to the extreme at the expense of usability and safety. This will come back and bite them in the ass for sure.
@iBackBeat
@iBackBeat 11 месяцев назад
Yes! Excellently written!
@pauld3327
@pauld3327 10 месяцев назад
Agree. Sales will take a big hit in Europe because of removal of the stalks.
@matthiasstuer
@matthiasstuer 11 месяцев назад
I've driven almost 20k kilometers in the M3 in the last 6 months. No indicator stalks would drive me insane especially in the Netherlands with record number of roundabouts. I really really hope they bring them back or offer it as an option, otherwise they'll definitely lose sales.
@clansome
@clansome 11 месяцев назад
You won't see Kia/Hyundai removing the stalks and the execs there will be rubbing their hands with glee.
@jonevansauthor
@jonevansauthor 11 месяцев назад
@@clansome they're likely to go bust because they aren't doing any of this sort of work to improve production though. Not that it's a good idea, but it also means they aren't improving line speed, reducing costs and building more EVs. Lots of the other companies make a loss on their EVs because they're terrible at engineering.
@fr3238
@fr3238 11 месяцев назад
Hello from Norway. I'm now on my second Tesla. The first was a M3P and the current is a MYLR. I've really liked those two cars, but one of the things I don't like is the lack of stalk for the windshield wipers. After 3 years I'm used to it, but it still disrupts my natural driving flow. Now they've removed two more stalks, and I'm probably done with Tesla for this reason alone. What a shame, since Teslas are otherwise amazing cars. You say it perfectly and I totally agree with you, this is an incredible stupid idea by Tesla. Tesla, bring back the stalks!
@greghudson9717
@greghudson9717 11 месяцев назад
I'm sure you are aware that the wipers can be activated briefly by pressing in the button on the left stalk ?
@fr3238
@fr3238 11 месяцев назад
@@greghudson9717 Yes, I am indeed aware of that, using it all the time living in a rainy town. As of late it's also possible to configure the left steering wheel scroll button to set wiper speed instead of having to press the little menu that pops up on the display when pressing the stalk button. Which is good. On the Highland the stalk button is moved to the steering wheel.
@markyates5744
@markyates5744 11 месяцев назад
If you don't think it's dangerous ... the number of times i've hit volume up instead of volume down when the steering wheel is upside down. Not only do you have to move your hands to press the button - you also have to remember the buttons are upside down!
@nkpenn
@nkpenn 11 месяцев назад
When you need to turn the steering wheel upside down, it must be on a relatively low speed surface road. Assuming you have put the blinker on before you make the turn, I cannot think of why you need to touch the button during the turn.
@rubenluiten1813
@rubenluiten1813 11 месяцев назад
@nkpenn ​Ever driven in Europe and used a small roundabout? That's exactly when you'd need to touch the button during the turn to signal out of the roundabout. You'll get a penalty if you don't.
@jonnyroon
@jonnyroon 11 месяцев назад
@@nkpennTesla's Navigation is surprisingly often wrong about the number of exits from a roundabout. When driving on unfamiliar roads listening to the nav and comparing voice instructions to what it actually shows on the screen and ALSO having to watch for and think about the position and arrangement of your indicator is a brilliant recipe for driver error!
@Sweetw4ter
@Sweetw4ter 10 месяцев назад
@@rubenluiten1813 These cars are designed for american (californian) roads and it really shows.
@TsLeng
@TsLeng 10 месяцев назад
​@@nkpennthanks for confirming you have never driven on a roundabout. 😂
@twox16r
@twox16r 11 месяцев назад
You're absolutely right! I don't understand why other media outlets aren't critically addressing this issue. Isn't this idea in direct contrast to what Elon Musk himself referred to as the 'first principle'? It's just change for the sake of change, fundamentally not a smart idea at all.
@greghudson9717
@greghudson9717 11 месяцев назад
It's not being done just because they can, it is a cost cutting exercise.
@andymacrae1093
@andymacrae1093 Год назад
It would totally put me off changing my current model 3 for a New one without the stalks . I’d rather keep the old one
@GizmoMaltese
@GizmoMaltese 3 месяца назад
I just bought a Model Y P. I was worried about the new Juniper refresh but if it's no stalk then I'm glad I got the old one.
@nicholassale4046
@nicholassale4046 11 месяцев назад
I looked at the Model 3 before buying an i4, I didn't like the lack of driver display behind the steering wheel and having to do everything through the touchscreen. Even so it was a serious option, class leading efficiency and range. But this is the nail in the coffin, I will never buy a car without a safe way of indicating. As Andy says in the video, I suspect it will find its way back into the car within 18 months to 2 years.
@marktoby8113
@marktoby8113 11 месяцев назад
I own a current Model 3, and to take remove the stalks is simply ridiculous. I won't be upgrading to the new M3.
@kevintran9321
@kevintran9321 11 месяцев назад
Neither will I. Such a stupid and unnecessary cost-cutting move. They just call it "minimalism" and expect us all to jump for joy.. They must think people are idiots (I suppose some of the extreme fanboys will embrace this, and anything else Elon does, regardless of what it is, but most normal people will hate it) If they had kept the stalks, added a small instrument cluster or a HUD, and a proper hatchback design then this would have been a near-perfect car for far more people. Instead, they've added a rear screen and a light strip. If I want a light in my face when driving at night, it better be the light from a speedometer or something useful.
@trevorbromley-palmer
@trevorbromley-palmer 11 месяцев назад
Same here, my M3LR that is due to go back in March won’t be replaced with another Tesla.
@billyreeves169
@billyreeves169 11 месяцев назад
Good, you call all go back to the caves where you all came from.
@Soordhin
@Soordhin 11 месяцев назад
Same. I come from a very safety conscious industry, so safety is literally my job. Aviation. And there are very good reasons, founded on decades of human resources, performance and limitation research, that primary controls, not only flight controls (side stick, yoke) are always in the same place, but also primary autopilot controls. And even more, they have different shapes so you can actually differentiate between them by feel alone.
@trevorbromley-palmer
@trevorbromley-palmer 11 месяцев назад
I wonder if driving examiners will be failing a lot more people when they take their DVLA test and fail to indicate when leaving a roundabout because they can’t work out where the indicator button is or they indicate the wrong way because it is upside down on the wrong side.
@gregturner_awod
@gregturner_awod 11 месяцев назад
I’m in far away Australia. I’ve just purchased my first Tesla, a Model 3 long range. I chose to get it now because I don’t want the new indicator arrangement on the updated Model 3. I’d have to think twice about a Model 3 if the only purchasing option was the updated version. Your comments and example of how impractical this change is were the basis of my thoughts to buy now, and not in 2024.
@SunsetHaze
@SunsetHaze Год назад
Its worrying how many people I've seen (internet commentary not reviewers) claiming this will improve people's driving by forcing 9 and 3 hand position. Clearly these people have never correctly used a roundabout.
@FireWalkMusic
@FireWalkMusic 11 месяцев назад
People saying that are clearly Americans. The grid-based roads they have, with intersections instead of roundabouts makes this design pretty easy to use because the wheel will be more or less straight most of the time, and you indicate before you start turning it. That's not the case in the EU and most of the rest of the world which uses roundabouts instead.
@jonpetter8921
@jonpetter8921 11 месяцев назад
Probably american who never drive trough roundabout, but again Tesla is american brand.
@jonevansauthor
@jonevansauthor 11 месяцев назад
There's no driving instructor whose ever taught that your hands are supposed to be there.... all the time. Wouldn't surprise me to meet a driver who thinks that though, and has forgotten the bit about feeding the wheel through your hands so you retain control.
@jonevansauthor
@jonevansauthor 11 месяцев назад
@@FireWalkMusic they've still got about 9,000 roundabouts in the US and they're gaining popularity everywhere where planners have a brain because they're infinitely superior to not having them. The only people who dislike them also like trams and the new design for the Coke bottle cap that's attached to the neck.
@1dstockton
@1dstockton 11 месяцев назад
I’ve ordered the “old” model 3 now purely for indicator stalks AND the drive selector! No one wants to faff around with the screen when doing a 3-point turn!
@iBackBeat
@iBackBeat 11 месяцев назад
Exactly👍!!! Happy to read someone mention this. The shift stalk is as useful as the turn indicator stalk.
@theelectricmonk3909
@theelectricmonk3909 11 месяцев назад
As others have said.... I'm sure you can adapt quickly enough.... But muscle memory is a powerful thing. For many years, I drove older Lexus LS400s, which had the indicator stalk on the "Japanese" side (opposite to US/EU/UK side). Weirdly, I got used to this in just a few hours; but when I went to a newer Lexus, which moved the stalk to the conventional side, it took *weeks* to learn not to indicate with my windscreen wipers! If you ONLY ever drive a Tesla with buttons, then I guess you'll get used to it; but if you drive 2-3 different cars - or maybe you drive a works van during the day & your Tesla at night, or whatever; then I predict it's going to be chaos. If only in your own head! However, I'm extremely glad you've done this video & alerted us non-Telsa drivers to the situation... I shall now be ignoring what any Tesla is signalling on a roundabout, just in case they've pressed the wrong button!
@narrowboatlongpod4176
@narrowboatlongpod4176 11 месяцев назад
I think the stalk on the r/h side was normal in the UK (it was on my old mini) and was there because, if you drive on the left, you can indicate and change gear at the same time. We now mostly drive European cars who standardised the other way.
@hishamg
@hishamg 11 месяцев назад
I drove a car with a manual “stick shift” for 35 years before buying my first ever automatic last year. I still keep trying to put the car in first gear every time the lights go green, that’s muscle memory for you!
@chriswatt2702
@chriswatt2702 11 месяцев назад
​@@hishamgStill occasionally smack my Zoe into neutral instead of 4th after 9 months.
@FireWalkMusic
@FireWalkMusic 11 месяцев назад
I know people who has had this on the new S for months already, and are still not getting used to it. Besides, imagine a potential new tesla buyer test driving the car for the very first time. In the first roundabout, they will have to look down at the wheel to figure out where the buttons are, or not signaling at all. Neither is safe, and other people would likely honk at them. In either case, they would feel pretty stressed. Not a great first impression, and as the saying goes: You never get a second chance to make a good first impression. I'm pretty sure a lot of people will consider other cars because of this. Especially potential first time tesla buyers. Why should they want to unlearn 20 years of muscle memory when they can just get something else that just "works" for them right away? Some guy where I work was going to buy the model 3, but he decided against it for one reason: He thought the auto wipers were so terrible compared to other cars he had tried. Imagine how many will be put off by these buttons on the wheel. I'm sure this won't be a huge deal breaker for a lot of people in the US, with the grid based roads and intersections which allows you to press the button before turning the wheel. But here in the EU, and most of the rest of the world that uses roundabouts instead of intersections, this will be very frustrating to use and I have no doubt it will be a deal breaker for some. Very strange move by Tesla, considering that the whole point with the highland was to make the car more appealing to more buyers. This new design achieves the exact opposite.
@UmbraWeiss
@UmbraWeiss 8 месяцев назад
This is not an adaptation problem, this is a problem where you can't press the button when you are in a turn or the wheel is not straight, it's just a stupid implementation, no easy of use and access to it in any position is just bad design, anyone who thought this is a good idea is a stupid idiot to be honest.
@gregpeirce6121
@gregpeirce6121 11 месяцев назад
I agree that the removal of the indicator and gear selector stalks is crazy - speaking from the UK perspective of constant roundabouts and left right or right left linked turn signal requirements. I want a Tesla, I really like them and have test driven them. No way will I ever buy a Tesla without stalks or a proper steering wheel. I have been waiting for the new compact hatch but will not buy it without stalks, I would then consider a second hand model 3 or Y instead. This is another example of one part too many removed, so put the stalks back.
@user-kq4ux3fr2q
@user-kq4ux3fr2q 11 месяцев назад
Absolutely bonkers idea! It will certainly put me off buying a Tesla without the stalk to indicate. Really pleased you raise the issue and as your X (Twitter) poll confirms - you are right!
@HiruS22
@HiruS22 11 месяцев назад
Absolutely 100% agree, an utterly stupid idea. And you’re right, it has lost them sales. I’ve been hanging on to see if the facelift would make the Model 3’s looks vaguely palatable, and it has (just), but I will not buy one because of this issue and will go ahead with buying an Ioniq 6. Just baffling how a designer could sign this off.
@greghudson9717
@greghudson9717 11 месяцев назад
I'm hoping this has been sorted out before I order a Model Q/2. In the meantime, I'm not upgrading my Y to a stalk-less anything.
@mohdodat2
@mohdodat2 9 месяцев назад
There’s absolutely no way an engineer would have signed off on this without extreme pressure from Elon.
@andrew9466
@andrew9466 11 месяцев назад
I agree with new ideas/technology, but this is a bad idea. Having to take your eyes off the road to look where the buttons are, is surely a safety issue 😮
@Denserr
@Denserr 11 месяцев назад
Fully agree .. i have the new model S and the indicators (and the horn) are extremely annoying!!!! Such a fantastic car mismanaged by such a small but extremely annoying faulty design!!! How stupid can they be!
@lukehebb
@lukehebb Год назад
Got a model y a couple of months ago so i'll be looking to upgrade in a few years time. If they still don't have stalks I can confidently say it won't be replaced by another tesla. I use roundabouts every day as leaving where i live requires me to use one at minimum (if i use a different route its about 4), and so silly things like this will make a meaningful impact to me
@MrMurphyable
@MrMurphyable 11 месяцев назад
As a 2 time Tesla owner, I’d never buy another one that doesn’t have indicator stalks, doesn’t have a gear selector, and doesn’t have effective parking sensors (either real sensors or video that works). You’re absolutely right, it’s a moronic change they’ve made.
@alangravy27
@alangravy27 11 месяцев назад
You did a great job of demonstrating why it is not a good idea I was put off a Model Y because of the driver info and other controls. You should be able to just get into a car and drive it. You shouldn't have to get used to it. If you need to get used to it, the designer didn't do a good job. Telsas are like this to make them cheaper.
@glennbloke1965
@glennbloke1965 11 месяцев назад
In answer to your question “Would it put you off buying a model 3”, YES absolutely. When I heard, a number of months ago, of the stalk removal being a likely thing, I opted to not wait for this rumoured refreshed and updated model 3. I couldn’t handle the buttons to indicate for exactly the reasons you stated in your video. I’d watched a couple of videos by Mr Nyland who also hated roundabouts in his stalkless model S. The way I look at it is yes in time you would get used to it. I thought I could put a little red sticker by the left indicator button that way it’d be more obvious where the button was when I needed to indicate my exit in a roundabout especially when the button was now on the other side and upside down. The thing I think though is even when and if you get totally used to this stupid idea, it’s still a relatively small button that will be constantly on the move, a small moving target so yes you might be totally aware of where that little button is but you’ve got to safely touch that tiny MOVING button. Good luck with that. I bought my model 3 four months ago rather than having no stalks. Maybe if you’re right and Tesla in the future were to offer the option of an indicator stalk, I would possibly upgrade but as of right now no way I’d buy the highland. (Also here in New Zealand I still get parking sensors, yay!!!) I will say though that the indicators in my model 3 are the worst indicators I’ve ever used, solely for roundabouts. Having to double click for my exit BUT this is still way way better than no stalks what so ever. I have started using my model 3 for RideShare. I often tell people that I don’t regret my model 3 purchase and would buy it all over again but I have found the indicators, auto wipers and creaky and squeaky build quality not up to scratch. As I say though, I would still buy it again, in MY opinion there are some great EV’s out there but Tesla with its charging infrastructure and timely software updates still wins out BUT not with this stupid new indicator buttons it doesn’t. Fingers crossed you’re right as of love to buy a highland with better build quality and nice functioning indicator stalks. Yes please. Waffle/rant over.
@graeradt
@graeradt 11 месяцев назад
I agree that it is a crazy idea. Not only will it affect whether some people will buy the car for themselves, but what about loan cars and courtesy cars. That would be even worse. It is one thing to have your own car and learn to deal with the missing stalks, but for someone who is just using the car for a short period, learning to handle the moving indicator switches and wiper buttons will be a nightmare.
@dabulls1g
@dabulls1g 11 месяцев назад
@@ismetoit’s illuminated lol
@jacobheinz8236
@jacobheinz8236 11 месяцев назад
Guess what car rentals business and insurance companies will cope with accidents caused by lack of stalks. No laughing matter .
@alexcumbers
@alexcumbers 11 месяцев назад
Good point!
@ians3328
@ians3328 11 месяцев назад
Yes standardisation of the indicator stalk came in years ago as some markets had teh stalk on the other side. Which was a pain. No buttons is bad enough but this is another step too far. More money savings which are not passed on to users.
@alexcumbers
@alexcumbers 11 месяцев назад
@@ians3328 Maybe they will be forced to revise the button positions at least, but hard to see a decent workaround. Musk does not always think!
@dalroth10
@dalroth10 11 месяцев назад
I completely agree with your point and think Tesla have taken minimalist design to a silly level. I had got the model 3 on my shortlist for when I replace my Kona next spring. When I found out that Tesla had decided to remove the parking sensors I thought ... why? They aren't expensive and give drivers an easy way to gauge how close they are to a stationary object rather than having to gauge it from a camera view. When I realised they had decided to remove the steering wheel stalks I couldn't fathom why. The adage "if it aint broke ......" sprang to mind. I'm now thinking the Model 3 isn't for me.
@kennguyen1594
@kennguyen1594 11 месяцев назад
I totally agree. I have the S with that stupid yoke and it is totally worthless. Fumbling to signal is a daily thing and honking is non-existant. I have no idea why they're planning to remove the stalks on all models. Such a dumb idea.
@handsofdoubt31
@handsofdoubt31 11 месяцев назад
Yep. Removal of the stalks is a step too far imo. I understand their desire to reduce cost, complexity and resource usage....which is great. But I really do find this a bad idea. I would avoid any car without easy, intuitive and safe to use indicators.
@angrypom
@angrypom 11 месяцев назад
Back in about 2006 Vauxhall decided that they were going to solve the "problem" of indicators by fitting the Vectra with touch sensitive indicator stalks. I drove one for a few months and it was so infuriating that I would often just not indicate at all. This seems even worse than that was and is just not a good idea by any measure.
@davidquinn5906
@davidquinn5906 11 месяцев назад
It was a little before that. I had a 2003 Vectra with those stupid things and I'm still angry about it.
@ysarn
@ysarn 11 месяцев назад
Yes, remember those infuriating Vectra indicators. It was a light touch for a 3 blips and a harder touch to stay on. Quite difficult to get it right though, and drivers behind must of thought that I was drunk or something with repeated indicating or the indicators being left on when I only wanted them to be on for a short time.
@davidquinn5906
@davidquinn5906 11 месяцев назад
The infuriating thing was the 3 blips was impossible to cancel. Flick the the other way and you just got 3 blips on the other side as you drove down the road wildly indicating left and right just trying to make it stop.
@jibx3439
@jibx3439 11 месяцев назад
Totally agree! It makes no sense at all. Designed for US roads, yet launched in Europe! 🙄 How did they not market research this? If they had, we would have stalks and a hatch! Could be marketing. I'm now thinking of getting the Y instead, for it's stalks.
@Wol747
@Wol747 11 месяцев назад
Doesn’t the Y have those buttons too?
@pauld3327
@pauld3327 10 месяцев назад
​@@Wol747No only S, X and now 3
@charlesbridgford254
@charlesbridgford254 7 месяцев назад
Would have considered 3, but no hatch. Now no stalks? Definitely nope.
@be-golf8374
@be-golf8374 11 месяцев назад
I'm in the US and we do have some roundabouts here. What is rare, however, is any use of turn indicators in those roundabouts. I make it a point to properly signal in them but I am in the VAST minority here. We own an ID4 and a Model Y and I would absolutely NOT consider a new Tesla if it did not have the stalks on it. Period, end of discussion, never going to change my mine on that one. So yes, as you say, it is indeed costing Tesla sales.
@davidstewart1153
@davidstewart1153 11 месяцев назад
Exactly. Turn signals in a roundabout mean the driver probably accidentally hit them while reaching for a loose phone.
@pauld3327
@pauld3327 11 месяцев назад
I'm from Europe and I wanted to buy the new Model 3 but the deleting of the stalks put me off. I instead bought the 'old' Model 3 last week. I'm happy to see that some people in the US also think the deleting of the stalks is a bad move.
@Astrophysikus
@Astrophysikus 11 месяцев назад
I could not agree more. One further reason to keep my 2021 LR for hopefully many years to come. I could accept getting rid of the shifter stalk, as you do not use it that much in reality. But the indicators? This is not only stupid and uncomfortable, it is also outright dangerous!
@Sam-tx1tn
@Sam-tx1tn 11 месяцев назад
Agreed. No stalks, not interested.
@bobabout256
@bobabout256 11 месяцев назад
100% agree. What a ridiculous idea to remove indicator storks.
@alan2804
@alan2804 Год назад
That put me off buying one. I agree it’s done to cut costs and increase profit. Plenty other better EVs out there now anyway.
@thomasegeland1847
@thomasegeland1847 11 месяцев назад
This is the best take I have seen yet on the missing indicator stalk. We also have lots of roundabouts in Norway, and when going left in a roundabout you should blink left, then shift to right blink before you enter the exit you're going through. In those situations the steering wheel will always be turned to some degree.
@ColinRichardson
@ColinRichardson 11 месяцев назад
Can't we just get the government to step in and say it's a regulatory requirement to have indicator stalks?
@Dreadpirateflappy
@Dreadpirateflappy 11 месяцев назад
sadly it would take years.
@ColinRichardson
@ColinRichardson 11 месяцев назад
@@Dreadpirateflappy wonder what M.O.T's say on the matter regarding the lack of indicator stalks..
@cafl9844
@cafl9844 11 месяцев назад
They sadly already turned a blind eye to the new Model S with the same indicator configuration....
@Dreadpirateflappy
@Dreadpirateflappy 11 месяцев назад
@@cafl9844 it's clearly legal. but Model s is nowhere near as mainstream as the model 3 though. far more people will see how awful it is having button indicators soon. (normal people not MOT testers)
@Dreadpirateflappy
@Dreadpirateflappy 11 месяцев назад
@@ColinRichardson it's clearly legal as other cars have done it in the past. A few citroens did it (although the steering wheel didn't move so it was far safer) and many sports cars including Ferrari do it. Law needs to be changed though. I think Manual windscreen wipers should be a legal requirement too. if sensors fail then you're fucked if you only have auto ones like a tesla
@iPeel
@iPeel 11 месяцев назад
We were holding off a new Model3 to replace our Freemont special '20 plate until Highland arrived. We're now reconsidering directly as a result of the indicator stalk removal.
@bellshooter
@bellshooter Год назад
In UK/EU City/Town driving this is positively dangerous, just to go to my local supermarket I have to traverse 6 roundabouts/mini-roundabouts on the return journey, people in Milton Keynes will be driven insane! This would stop me buying a facelifted Tesla. Would not get 3 anyway as no hatchback, but considering a Y.
@iBackBeat
@iBackBeat 11 месяцев назад
Get a Y until it’s too late.
@oatcrisp
@oatcrisp 11 месяцев назад
Spot on, I won't buy any vehicle without signal stalks!
@armandsimonis7992
@armandsimonis7992 11 месяцев назад
I agree fully 100%, I had exactly the same thought when I heard/saw Tesla wants to remove the stalks with the Highland upgrade. I own a Tesla Model 3 LR AWD for more than 4 years now and I was thinking about to purchase a new Model 3 somewhere next year. But as long as the stalks don't return (permanent or as an option, I don't care) I will not do it. I will continue to drive my current Model 3 or I will buy another EV (an EV6 perhaps). A month ago I would never have considered this but now with that stupid stalk-stuff I do. BTW the new button-indicators have another disadvantage. Lots of time I like to drive with my hands on the 10-before-2 position on the stearing wheel. No problem to use the stalk indicator with one finger in that case. But with buttons I have to move my hands - or at least my left hand - to the 9-3 position or even a bit lower than that because I need my thumb on the buttons. ARGGHH. idiots those who "invented" this at Tesla.
@edbot456
@edbot456 11 месяцев назад
You are spot on with the problem of stalk deletion. What a bloody stupid idea whoever thought that up. Ok, I know they want to improve their margins, but this is a cut too far. It’s a definite deal breaker for me.
@iBackBeat
@iBackBeat 11 месяцев назад
Absolutely!
@pocoheywood4007
@pocoheywood4007 11 месяцев назад
I think this is also an accessibility issue. With stalks, it’s often possible for people who have something less than a fully developed/functional left hand to knock a stalk into position. With the buttons, the driver pretty much has to have a full range of hand/thumb motion in order to be able to signal. Not helpful.
@gavjlewis
@gavjlewis 11 месяцев назад
Well I guess Tesla could add an accessibility menu to the car and activate indicators by voice. "Ok Tesla indicate left" ect.
@DeltaOps111
@DeltaOps111 11 месяцев назад
@@gavjlewisYou’re kidding right
@Wol747
@Wol747 11 месяцев назад
@@gavjlewisI assume this is a joke? IF the voice commands worked 99.99% of the time it would still be potentially unsafe. My S recognises voice commands correctly perhaps half the time - and even then actually does something totally unrelated half the time.
@gavjlewis
@gavjlewis 11 месяцев назад
@@Wol747 Well kind of. The point was it would be easy for Tesla to implement. Your current system is looking to work out exactly what you are saying from any numbers of words available. They could set it with this mode on so when it hears the key word then it only has to choose the word it thinks you have said from "Left" or "Right" which is far easier. As for if it worked 99.99% of the time then that's still many times more than people manually bother indicating.
@Wol747
@Wol747 11 месяцев назад
As someone who had a stroke 12 months ago and went through operations, rehab, wait time then driving test with an examiner plus an occupational therapist in the back seat to regain my licence I fully concur. My left hand can find the stalk - although sometimes it’s the autopilot/cruise control one - but those haptic buttons would just be impossible.
@grahamastor4194
@grahamastor4194 11 месяцев назад
UK Performance Model 3 owner; comppletely agree, indicator stalks need to be used. Hopefully the "new" Model Y will have them.
@iBackBeat
@iBackBeat 11 месяцев назад
.. and the gearshift stalk!
@stephenholder7314
@stephenholder7314 11 месяцев назад
I had a Tesla model 3 performance for 18 months, and liked a lot of things , not everything. Moved job and car went back. I'd been waiting on the highland version to see if I might consider it, but the lack of indicator stalk is a deal breaker. I'm ordering an i4 instead, but I'm happy as its a much better car (more expensive to buy, but cheaper to lease!). I'm actually glad that in Europe this move will probably increase market share of non Tesla car sales.
@kiwijonowilson
@kiwijonowilson 11 месяцев назад
I'm in NZ and, like the UK, we have plenty of roundabouts and weird tight intersections. I was thinking about upgrading to the Highland (particularly like the idea of reduced noise on our coarse chip tarmac, a bit more efficiency and a better looking car) but I don't like the idea of losing the indicator stalk. It probably not a big deal in the USA where most of the driving is on freeways with gentle on / off ramps. I feel I might get used to the lack of the indicator stalk with time but I think it will remain a somewhat degraded experience with potential safety implications. While I could live without the shift selector, I'm a bit sorry to see that go too, as its very convenient to use. In any case I'm holding fire to see if the indicator stalk comes back as an option - really my existing Model 3 is a great car already (albeit a bit noisier that I would like on rough surfaces).
@iBackBeat
@iBackBeat 11 месяцев назад
I would miss the shift or gearselector as well. On maneuvering in parking lots or changing direction on narrow (too narrow for a u-turn) streets, intuitive gear selection is a must! BRING BACK THE STALKS @Tesla!!!
@Brian-om2hh
@Brian-om2hh 11 месяцев назад
It's a terrible idea. As you said EVM, roundabouts and sharp corners will reveal it's flaws and shortcomings.....it will create confusion, annoyance and frustration.
@somewaresim
@somewaresim 11 месяцев назад
Insane. A stalk is essential for driving outside the US. Indicating on roundabouts will be impossible and dangerous with indicator buttons in the steering wheel. It seems, as demonstrated by the new Model S, Tesla believe we should also drive from left hand side of the car too.
@toad008
@toad008 Год назад
I would not buy a car without stalks. It works, leave it alone.
@JohnR31415
@JohnR31415 11 месяцев назад
Stalks plural? Are all the features on stalks necessarily best on a stalk? I agree that indicators are very naturally stalk based (though many seem to think that’s so you can hit them as you turn the wheel). Do you need wiper speed controls on a stalk for instance?
@Dreadpirateflappy
@Dreadpirateflappy 11 месяцев назад
@@JohnR31415 yes... purely automatic wiper controls are proven to be terrible, Tesla forums are full of people asking for proper controls. So is hunting for a button when you suddenly get a splashed windscreen.
@JohnR31415
@JohnR31415 11 месяцев назад
@@Dreadpirateflappy does it *have* to be on a stalk? Could it be a thumb button, or a foot operated control? There is, as the saying goes, more than one way to skin a cat. I’m convinced that having directional indicators change direction as you need them is stupid - but a “wipe now” button on the wheel doesn’t have the same issue. I’m not saying they shouldn’t be - I’m asking the question… is it really best place? Because the amount of times I’ve put wipers on instead of indicating, and vice versa, when switching between cars is quite high.
@toad008
@toad008 11 месяцев назад
@@JohnR31415 Yes, most cars have two stalks, so I suppose that is plural.
@wilsoch
@wilsoch 11 месяцев назад
Thank you for posting this --- all of the reviews so far of the Highland gloss over this issue, but it disqualifies this car for me (and I'm actually in the market right now). This is such an incredibly stupid decision by Tesla and it makes driving less safe. I rented a Model S for 3 weeks late last year, and I never "got used" to those buttons. I hit the wrong signal sometimes, I missed altogether others, but in nearly all events I ended up looking down at the wheel (even if momentarily) to hit the button. And I also found that I just skipped using the signal sometimes. This makes driving less safe. What's next? Get rid of the pedal and brake and put them in the touch screen?
@gregpeirce6121
@gregpeirce6121 11 месяцев назад
Bjorn Nyland pointed this out as stupid during his test ride.
@martinottosson6583
@martinottosson6583 11 месяцев назад
I will not buy the new M3 either just because of the missing stalks either but I am pretty sure that someone will offer a aftermarket stalk kit for the car very shortly. But still utterly stupid.
@iBackBeat
@iBackBeat 11 месяцев назад
Get yourself a Model Y, as long, as it exists with stalks. Next will be the removed accelerator pedal. You’ll have to access it through the keyboard on the screen 🫣. Cursor keys.
@no-oneman.4140
@no-oneman.4140 11 месяцев назад
Totally agree. Many roundabouts require us to indicate right followed by a quick change to indicate left to then come off. Impossible without the stalks. Dear Elon - If it ain't busted - Fix it is just nuts.
@stevenmoran4060
@stevenmoran4060 11 месяцев назад
You should read the Highway Code for the correct routine.
@no-oneman.4140
@no-oneman.4140 11 месяцев назад
Ok smart arse, tell me where I'm wrong !
@nigelparry4911
@nigelparry4911 11 месяцев назад
yes I notice how many drivers not indicating while on the roundabout so confusing other drivers not knowing if you staying on it or exiting
@GoGreenAutos
@GoGreenAutos 11 месяцев назад
I completely agree. A backward step for a bit of cost saving will cost them sales. They did the same when they removed parking sensors before they had a software alternative and still that doesn't work as well as sensors. They've tried to make the Highland M3 more premium, with double glazed glass, more insulation, rear screen etc, but at the same time remove stalks which make it less premium.
@robwalker864
@robwalker864 Год назад
I've had a model Y for about a year and consider myself a bit of a fan boy. I embrace change and never let a new way of doing things put me off.. But I totally agree. This is madness. There is no way this is better or even as good. Completely impractical and dangerous on European roads. I think your point on it being good publicity is an interesting one. You could be right - they could be taking marketing ideas from the Ryan Air playbook.
@markwilson7013
@markwilson7013 11 месяцев назад
"Tesla, indicate left!" 😅
@rcajavus8141
@rcajavus8141 11 месяцев назад
GOOD DESIGN NEEDS NO EXPLANATION - its the fact of making things since first humanoid (or otter) grabbed first rock to smash a walnut(or crustacian). GOOD DESIGN IS ORGANIC, LOGICAL, PRACTICAL, all Tesla morons cant understand and NO I WILL NOT GET USED TO A HALF ASSED SOLUTION TO A PROBLEM THAT NEVER WAS!!!!!
@overdriver99
@overdriver99 11 месяцев назад
@@markwilson7013 please, send your opinion to Tesla!
@0PureEvil0
@0PureEvil0 11 месяцев назад
@@markwilson7013 why have buttons when you can just have voice commands? 🤣
@keithhobbs1
@keithhobbs1 11 месяцев назад
If it ain't broke don't fix it.
@raleedy
@raleedy 11 месяцев назад
Buttons on the wheel are marked with an arrow to show their function. Turn the wheel and the arrow no longer points the right way.
@konrad3
@konrad3 11 месяцев назад
Maybe the car recognizes the position of the steering wheel and indicates accordingly😂
11 месяцев назад
​@@konrad3unfortunately no
@konrad3
@konrad3 11 месяцев назад
@ It isn't really a solution because then you have to know when exactly the car switches the buttons around. But it would be funny😀
@ElectricCarAustralia
@ElectricCarAustralia Год назад
Agree! Fixing something which wasn't a problem. Understand it was obviously done as a cost saving but is not intuitive and potentially unsafe is some scenarios. Will be interesting to see if any safety regulators have some feedback on this. Can see this as a no deal for some buyers. Likely to end up like the yoke.
@dabulls1g
@dabulls1g 11 месяцев назад
The point with this was reducing the number of components of the car to drop cost right? this has always been a major tesla design philosophy. People will adapt or find ways around it…or just not signal like most people do anyways WITH stalks lol. This problem is a minor annoyance at best.
@erwindewit4073
@erwindewit4073 11 месяцев назад
I'm also in the Bloody Stupid camp. And it actually did put me off. So I'm probably going for a MG4 Performance instead. The Yoke steering wheel felt idiotic and now this..
@seapeeshaw
@seapeeshaw 11 месяцев назад
Totally agree, seems to make driving a whole lot more difficult & potentially more dangerous - daft! If it ain't broke don't fix
@markyates5744
@markyates5744 11 месяцев назад
As a current model 3 owner (2021 version) I am glad Elon's done it - it will keep the used market price of my car nice and high!!! Few people in the UK will want one without stalks! My mate is already searching for a pre Oct2022 model 3 so he can have parking sensors!!
@proximaone1350
@proximaone1350 11 месяцев назад
I have just bought the previous model 3 2023 it still has parking sensors.🌝 In Australia
@hanzohanzo1639
@hanzohanzo1639 11 месяцев назад
Please stay in your moms basement.
@finnwolffkaysfeld7000
@finnwolffkaysfeld7000 11 месяцев назад
Yes, I am totally against the stalk removal, and it is the only thing I don't like about the refresh. It definitely keeps me from buying this car. But maybe if they lovers the price even further, I have to live with this stupid idea, but then Tesla would not have saved anything, and we all drive more unsafe.
@rossadamdixon
@rossadamdixon 11 месяцев назад
The comopany that does SEXY buttons is making a stalk. Personally I dont see the issue. I'll need to try it but I have mimicked the button presses on my current car and really dont see an issue.
@FireWalkMusic
@FireWalkMusic 11 месяцев назад
I was going to buy a new model S a few months ago. I have been extremely happy with the one I had, but I decided against it mainly because of these new indicator buttons on the wheel. They were impossible to use in roundabouts. They forced me to either take my eyes off the road to look down at the wheel, or not signaling at all. Neither is safe. I sometimes also pressed the wrong button and I started feeling anxious when approaching roundabouts. That's when I decided that I wouldn't buy a new model S. I'm sad to see this coming to the new model 3 as well. I'm sure I could have kind of gotten used to it after half a year or something, but why should I bother unlearning 20 years of muscle memory when I can just buy something else that works for me right away? I can imagine a lot of potential new tesla buyers being put off by this after a test drive. All it takes is one roundabout, and they're everywhere here in the EU.
@rossadamdixon
@rossadamdixon 11 месяцев назад
@@FireWalkMusic LHD in the UK is far more dangerous than no stalks. On a roundabout in the UK the indicator will be near the top at 12-3 o'clock whereas in Europe it will be at the bottom. I really do not see a problem. If you do don't buy it. This will not hurt Tesla's sales at all. They will continue to sell all the cars they can make.
@FireWalkMusic
@FireWalkMusic 11 месяцев назад
​@@rossadamdixonWell I certainly won't be buying it, and if you look at the majority of comments under this video, and the poll, that seems to be the case for a lot of other people as well..
@Slugsie1
@Slugsie1 11 месяцев назад
Yes, this would absolutely put me off buying a new Model 3. Same with the yolk on the S, same with the Falcon doors on the X. They are deal breakers to me. I'm also guessing that when the Y gets refreshed it'll probably have no stalks as well.
@trevorcrook2565
@trevorcrook2565 11 месяцев назад
Tesla have clearly never employed or consulted an ergonomics engineer. Sadly, neither have EuroNCAP, if they had then this would be marked down in their tests, as would other screen based controls (not just by Tesla). As you say, Tesla do sometimes listen to consumers, eg supplying Model Y's with a parcel shelf, so there is hope.
@greghudson9717
@greghudson9717 11 месяцев назад
Parcel shelf? It's an add-on option here in Australia 😞
@dedaloskprs9013
@dedaloskprs9013 11 месяцев назад
Finally someone is daring enough to say in public that this is a really stupid idea and is done by Tesla just to cut down on costs, just like the whole "minimalistic" theme of their cars. Also you forgot to mention that many people drive with one hand and may never bother to indicate at all if they get this car.
@JonathanPalfrey
@JonathanPalfrey Год назад
I just wish they’d add a rain sensor, parking sensors and radar back too. I completely agree, my lease is up next year, probably perfect timing for the updated car however I won’t get one unless they add the stalks. Sadly with some of the updates Tesla have done to 2020 M3 I feel it’s a worse car then when I got it.
@fathippy
@fathippy 11 месяцев назад
They are not going to be adding the stalks back in for you
@sagargadre
@sagargadre 11 месяцев назад
The 45K car doesn't have rain sensors and parking sensors?😮
@_clemens_
@_clemens_ 11 месяцев назад
@@sagargadre rain sensors not sure, tbh in my current cars (not Tesla) they often more bother me than helping me. Of course if you have no stalk to enable the wipers...sigh. Parking sensors are replaced by Tesla vision...So you have cameras and some AI logic, but it is less precise than if it were sensors. But is also not better form an engineering standpoint, combination of both makes more sense, but it more expensive.
@Ughthisagain
@Ughthisagain 11 месяцев назад
They have rain sensor but it’s vision based and sucks. I have just learned to use the manual swipe and good application of rainx
@M0j0
@M0j0 11 месяцев назад
I was super hyped for the refresh...when I had seen the stalks missing..i was immensely disappointed. All the tslas with stalks and parking sensors and heatpumps are the ones to go for!
@MrQuay03
@MrQuay03 11 месяцев назад
Don’t worry, you’ll get used to it in 10 days
@jameschapman4824
@jameschapman4824 11 месяцев назад
IMHO your correct. For me this change is a deal breaker. I currently drive a Model 3 LR however when I come to change this in maybe two years time ( or when another car takes my fancy) I will NOT be going for another one unless this stupid alteration is changed. It may be fine in the USA where they have very few roundabouts because their cities are built on a grid system but as you quite rightly said outside of the USA not such a good idea. Oh well and I really do like my model 3.
@dvader3263
@dvader3263 11 месяцев назад
Yes, fewer roundabouts in the USA compared to Europe. But there are still plenty of them, causing the same problem in the US as in Europe.
@any-car-will-do
@any-car-will-do 11 месяцев назад
Definitely a crazy idea, personally not only removing the stalks is a bad idea but what about the touch screen to work everything? You can’t pickup your mobile phone (rightly so) yet you have a huge screen in front of you to operate the vehicles functions, 1. what’s the difference and 2. what’s the matter with buttons and switches?? you can flick a switch without looking but you can’t operate a touch screen without looking, very distracting I find, just like a mobile phone.
@samwoollard4491
@samwoollard4491 11 месяцев назад
You're 100% correct, Tesla have really sh1t the bed here
@philipcarpenter4671
@philipcarpenter4671 11 месяцев назад
When I learnt to drive most cars had the indicator stalk on the right hand side of the steering column. I remember in the late 1970s more and more cars moved the stalk to the left hand side, presumably so the manufacturers didn't have to produce different layouts for left and right hand drive versions. I used to sometimes drive a car with the stalk on the "wrong" side so occasionally tried to indicate with the wiper stalk. The legislators stepped in and standardised a left hand indicator stalk throughout Europe. I thought this was still the case for cars destined for the European market. Certainly indicators operated by buttons on the steering wheel would be a deal breaker for me. What next? A button for the accelerator and brakes?
@Joe-lb8qn
@Joe-lb8qn 11 месяцев назад
The annoying thing about saving money is OK its removal saves some money but what about adding 3 speakers from 14 to 17 (does anyone care?). Or a whole ass awkwardly placed display screen low down for what are likely infrequent back seat users.BOth of those must be more expensive. I hope you are correct and they retreat from this idiotic move.
@amperformance7998
@amperformance7998 11 месяцев назад
I did a Model Y review some months ago and came to the conclusion that the car was designed to be "impressive". They invest in features that look good on a website, in RU-vid, and in a showroom (more speakers, bigger screen, more apps, etc), and cut features that may be useful, but are not promote-able.
@jonevansauthor
@jonevansauthor 11 месяцев назад
Yes. The price of the car went up not down. They've got a Model 2 coming at some point which will be their new budget car so the Model 3 doesn't need to try so hard to be cheap. These stalks don't save money, since they'd charge you the £25 it cost them to buy an incredibly ancient technology that's actually cheaper than chips because potatoes are worth more, and they can only save minimal time. The back screen is a pointless luxury, for children who will have a tablet or smartphone anyway and would argue over whatever you'd display on it (or maybe it's just to scroll the continuous message, 'No, we are not there yet!').
@greghudson9717
@greghudson9717 11 месяцев назад
@@jonevansauthor IMO the back screen, and even the seats for that matter should be OPTIONAL. We are a retired couple, and no-one ever sits in the back.
@jonevansauthor
@jonevansauthor 11 месяцев назад
@@greghudson9717 yup. I swear if they offered the same car with more boot space and no back seats, people would love it. No need for back doors either. But really I just want a Tesla Smart car.
@Streeknine
@Streeknine 11 месяцев назад
There is a reason stalks have been on vehicles since they got blinkers.. it just makes sense and it's a very simple control. To eliminate those and replace with buttons is madness.
@nobrien1
@nobrien1 11 месяцев назад
I agree completely! Hopefully, this will be like the yoke steering wheel and they will relent.
@chuckles1357
@chuckles1357 11 месяцев назад
Agreed. Hoping they will bring back the indicators as at least an option... with pressure i, too, hope tesla will relent. Like most others here, definitely will not buy without the indicators
@andrewwebster6025
@andrewwebster6025 11 месяцев назад
Definitely a bad idea, one of the best things about indicator stalks is you can get into nearly any vehicle and they will be in the same place so why change it. I suppose if you could indicate using voice control it might be okay but why change a simple standardised control with something more difficult
@jumbo994
@jumbo994 11 месяцев назад
Voice control wont be ok. it's already crap now in cases when, folk have broad accents, poor english, if the windows are open and there is wind noise, if others are talking in the car, if the radio is on / loud music. Cannot be relied upon for such a safety critical application.
@TsLeng
@TsLeng 10 месяцев назад
Voice control for indicators is crazy.
@mbak7801
@mbak7801 11 месяцев назад
Would this be a big enough issue for Tesla to lose type approval and be unable to sell these in the UK?
@greghudson9717
@greghudson9717 11 месяцев назад
Same for Australia I hope.
@didierpuzenat7280
@didierpuzenat7280 11 месяцев назад
My Citroen Visa had to indicator stalks, was it ban in UK ?
@atikurrahman932
@atikurrahman932 11 месяцев назад
Great points, but i also think that the gear shifter in the screen will be a big nuisance - specially doing a 3-point turn...
@iBackBeat
@iBackBeat 11 месяцев назад
Exactly!!
@PaulLemars01
@PaulLemars01 11 месяцев назад
This design process is straight out of the Apple playbook. "You, the consumer don't know what you want and you are highly resistant to change. Therefore we the brilliant engineers and designers will tell you what you want." except this is a safety issue. If the British government had any balls they would ban the sale of the new Tesla on safety grounds and only let the vehicle back in the country when the standard indicator stalk that is on every other vehicle/brand in the country had been returned.
@keepfitbunny9919
@keepfitbunny9919 11 месяцев назад
Totally agree. I own a Model 3 and was excited about the improvements made in Highland. Unless they offer stalks (even just the indicator stalks) as an option I seriously doubt I would be purchasing one. Once sales drop in Europe Tesla may listen.
@leftcoaster67
@leftcoaster67 11 месяцев назад
The funny thing is roundabouts are being popular with city engineers and managers. It reduces accidents, and saves lots of money on traffic lights. So even in parts of the US roundabouts are more and more common.
@stamfordly6463
@stamfordly6463 11 месяцев назад
The concept of "giving way" is rather anathema to Americans, that's why they have to have Stop signs everywhere and why they have problems with roundabouts.
@epcalderhead
@epcalderhead 11 месяцев назад
@@stamfordly6463 Giving way is seen in this example of America vs Europe. Witnessed this first hand. There were two ATMs (forget where it Europe) side by side. The Europeans made one queue for both AMTs. That makes the most sense. Americans would have formed a line for each ATM.
@carlarrowsmith
@carlarrowsmith 11 месяцев назад
Single lane roundabouts are proven to reduce accidents but multilane ones are no better.
@AnonYmous-rw6un
@AnonYmous-rw6un 11 месяцев назад
​​@@stamfordly6463A number of yields where I live. Even the odd surprising one. Roundabouts have also more than doubled near me in the 16 years I've been here. 0 to 2 in my city, and from 2 to 4 in near the next one.
@dabulls1g
@dabulls1g 11 месяцев назад
@@epcalderheadthat’s an absolutely retarded analogy, you’re an idiot. Americans (being one myself) are notoriously impatient and would never wait longer in one line behind someone else when another ATM is opened right next to that queue. Also, why would any rational being wait longer for no reason whatsoever? You’re an absolute imbecile.
@MrSimonRoffey
@MrSimonRoffey 11 месяцев назад
I’ve had my first M3 for 4 weeks now and I’m glad I didn’t get the refresh model without the stalks, hopefully by the time I come to replace it Elon will see sense and put them back as it will seriously affect my decision on what I get next.
@Basih
@Basih 8 месяцев назад
More likely that new EU regulation would force him to go back to stalks.
@stevecrabb1
@stevecrabb1 11 месяцев назад
I was seriously considering a Highland but the thought of the withering looks I would get from my better half when she tried to navigate the first roundabout made it just too depressing. I plumped for a Model Y instead.
@silverghini2629
@silverghini2629 11 месяцев назад
Absolutely, my wife would kill me if I bought a car without indicator stalks!
@donaldduck5731
@donaldduck5731 11 месяцев назад
Totally agree, will get a Polestar2 most likely, it's a safety issue, it's simply not possible to drive/steer correctly, indicate correctly and be in full control. But lets be honest, it's not just the indicators, not having a driver display in front of the driver, no gear select and having to take your eyes off the road to use a touch screen. Also I'm not so sure about one pedal driving, your conditioning/training yourself to lift your foot off a pedal to stop in a subconscious response situation/ emergency situation.
@greghudson9717
@greghudson9717 11 месяцев назад
One pedal driving is like a video game where you gauge when is exactly the right moment to lift off the go fast pedal, and roll to a stop right on a stop sign line. On the other hand, if there is an actual emergency (or regen isn't working for whatever reason - and there are plenty) then you can do what I do, and use my LEFT FOOT to press the brake pedal. Have a look at some car racing vids on YT where they film what is happening in the footwell - particularly when there are THREE pedals. It's like watching a symphony - and it's how I was taught in racing school... I NEVER use my right foot for braking (unless it is lifting off to activate regen braking).
@tonydoc903
@tonydoc903 11 месяцев назад
Accident waiting to happen.I Like the new seats and the range on the new 3, but the indicator s it’s a big no. Glad I’ve got a 23 model with 8 year battery warranty. Probably keep it that long anyway.👍 Good informative video. Hope the Tesla design team make right handed 3’s with last year’s model stalks.👍
@shockthemonkey7046
@shockthemonkey7046 11 месяцев назад
I think there’s a distinct possibility that this will draw the attention of Government Vehicle safety standards, just because Tesla has shown this as a pre-production spec doesn’t necessarily mean that it will be put into production that way for every market, let’s hope as I was going to order one, now I’m not so sure….
@d4m029
@d4m029 Год назад
This is my biggest issue and it’s making me feel old 😅 to many “touch” somethings!! Infotainment fine touch screen and voice yada yada… but I want indicators, hazards, wipers, and aircon (particularly the widow defog/mist button) should all be a button or knob! Muscle memory without looking away from the road should be the norm for anything that will impact safety of you or other drivers. I can wait till I’m ona clear straight to fiddle with skipping songs, I cannot wait to indicate to come off the roundabout or if my front window suddenly starts to fog up
@birreboi
@birreboi 11 месяцев назад
Agree, the removal of indicator stalks is crazy. This is Elon taking cost cutting way too far.
@ericpisch2732
@ericpisch2732 11 месяцев назад
Totally agree, I will not buy another Tesla, loss of radar, parking sensors, indicator stalk. The loss of the gear selector stalk is just as bad imo. And worst of all still no CarPlay or android auto … so many better choices now
@gregpeirce6121
@gregpeirce6121 11 месяцев назад
Well said
@-A-lm5xb
@-A-lm5xb 11 месяцев назад
Yep, like a petrol car.
@ericpisch2732
@ericpisch2732 11 месяцев назад
@@-A-lm5xb lol… no. I have driven petrol cars, they are terrible to drive compared to EVs. Going back to petrol would be like going from a 93” OLED to a 12” black and white CRT
@-A-lm5xb
@-A-lm5xb 11 месяцев назад
@@ericpisch2732 You must have driven some crap then. I've driven both petrol and EVs, diesel too, wouldn't touch any current EV, no comparison. Likewise with many other people, that's why they're not selling. lol.
@ericpisch2732
@ericpisch2732 11 месяцев назад
@@-A-lm5xb owned from new 2x RS6, 2x RS4, C63, C63S, 2xM3, M4 etc, all shite compared to an EV
@thathairyguy
@thathairyguy 11 месяцев назад
I feel the same about this as when I saw their rectangular steering "wheel". It's over engineering and trying to solve a problem that doesn't exist - while actually causing more problems for the driver. This will hurt Tesla for sure and the stalks will be back for the next revision.
@RichTeer
@RichTeer 11 месяцев назад
Fellow Model 3 owner here, and I agree that removing the stalks is a bloody daft idea! I think the idea, in addition to reducing manufacturing costs, was to somehow pave the way for autonomous driving: if the car is doing the driving, there's no need for stalks. Of course, FSD still seems to be a long way from being ready for general consumption!
@waqasahmed939
@waqasahmed939 11 месяцев назад
It'd be fine if it was fully self autonomous, but even when we're in the interim phase, we should still have the ability to have a stalk to indicate
@PhilT993
@PhilT993 11 месяцев назад
As a 2021 M3LR owner, I totally agree with you AND what about the removal/disabling of radar and ultrasonic sensors? I seriously doubt I will be buying another Tesla, at this point.
@adrianmonk68
@adrianmonk68 11 месяцев назад
I just took delivery of a model 3 as I didn't want to wait for the new Highland without stalks!!! That was the only reason I didn't wait for the Highland
@pauld3327
@pauld3327 11 месяцев назад
I waited for the highland even though I knew the Highland wouldn't have stalks because I thought the highland would have: - steer-by-wire - a better battery I bought the current Model 3 this week 😀
@barriewhite9733
@barriewhite9733 11 месяцев назад
I was going to order the refresh as soon as possible but not with the indicators as they are. Ludicrous idea.
@djgoode
@djgoode 11 месяцев назад
I have been called a Tesla fanboy in many occasions. However no stalk no buy. It’s like LHD nope not buying and don’t like the 3 (boot) or y handles and single screen.
@ade1963
@ade1963 11 месяцев назад
they will probably make indicator stalks an optional extra. when they get away with that it will be brakes next - press the button on the stearing wheel to brake or you can pay extra to have a pedal
Далее
How To Drive An Electric Car Efficiently!
16:48
Просмотров 149 тыс.
Electric Cars - Motorway Speeds (Range Differences)
16:06
Men Vs Women Survive The Wilderness For $500,000
31:48
🛑 ты за кого?
00:11
Просмотров 92 тыс.
BRUTALLY HONEST REVIEW OF THE NEW TESLA MODEL 3
38:49
A true generational leap! - Tesla Model 3 2024
18:13
Просмотров 470 тыс.
My BRAND new 2024 Model 3 is broken AGAIN!
12:05
Просмотров 27 тыс.
Almost EVERYONE is Wasting Money on Dash Cams.
17:32
Tesla, Now Is A Good Time To Buy Used!
17:23
Просмотров 32 тыс.