The 4 Horsemen of Meaning | Bishop Barron, John Vervaeke, and Jonathan Pageau | EP 204

Подписаться 8 млн

Просмотров 844 тыс.

50% 1

This episode was recorded on September 10th 2021.
Jordan Peterson, Bishop Barron, John Vervaeke, and Jonathan Pageau have a round table to explore ideas and theories of Meaning. All three guests have been on the podcast before, and all share Jordan’s passion for the universal truths of human experience. This deep discussion explores the roots of Meaning and religious significance.
Bishop Barron is the founder of Word on Fire and the auxiliary bishop of the archdiocese of LA.
John Vervaeke is a colleague of Jordan’s and an associate professor at the University of Toronto since 1994. He teaches courses on reasoning, cognitive development, and higher cognitive processes.
Jonathan Pageau is a symbolic thinker, RU-vidr, and class carver of orthodox icons.
-
Find more Bishop Barron on RU-vid: / wordonfirevideo
And here: wordonfire.org/
Find more John Vervaeke online on his website: johnvervaeke.com
John's RU-vid channel: / @johnvervaeke
Find more Jonathan Pageau on RU-vid: / @jonathanpageau
Jonathan's website: www.pageaucarvings.com
_________
[00:00] Preview
[01:30] Intro
[02:40] Everyone gives their answer to “What is meaning?”
[03:30] “We're using meaning as a metaphor... something similar to the way a sentence works. It has intelligibility to it that connects us to the world... so that we can interact and be informed by it” Jon Vervaeke
[07:22] “Our mental framing is transparent like a pair of glasses, but there are times we need to step back and, by taking the glasses off and examining them, consider our framing structure" JV
[09:10] “When you look at the world there is a central point of focus. When you focus on the point with your eyes it becomes very clear... until we no longer perceive anything by the edge of our vision. It's nothingness, it's just not there" Jordan Peterson
[13:56] Bishop Barron's view on meaning and religion
[14:23] “I would say that meaning is to be in a purposeful relationship to a value" Bishop Robert Barron
[17:55] “So I'm talking to you, which I believe is a good, but it's nested in a higher good and a still higher good, so finally I want not just this particular good but good itself-that's a religious relationship" BRB
[18:20] Pageau’s opening thoughts on meaning and religion
[19:56] “The reason we perceive hierarchy is because we are always judging... or trying to evaluate whether something’s good" Pageau
[20:31] Jordan’s brief foray into “mini-celebrations”
[21:53] The idea of revelation
[24:46] “It isn't obvious to me that we see objects-we see patterns" JP
[27:40] “Like a Rolling Stone-it wasn't the first song I liked, but it was the first that rocked my world and rearranged my mind, and I think that's where real value is" BRB
[28:42] Underlying causes of the crisis of meaning
[30:10] “Something that starts with Scotus... and goes into the heart of the scientific revolution is that there’s no such thing as levels-reality just is" JV
[31:00] Science around the hierarchy of intelligibility and connectedness
[33:00] What is science?
[39:00] “There’s an epistemic hierarchy and science does not belong on the top" BRB
[42:00] “As scientists, we are motivated by a narrative we don't understand scientifically… The whole enterprise is driven by a dream whose reality can't be encapsulated within the process itself" JP
[44:00] The ignorance in assuming science OR religion are correct
[44:40] Eminationist ontologies
[55:30] Religious experiences
[01:07:30] The book of Revelations as a psychedelic experience.
[01:17:30] The Psychedelic problem and why psychedelics are useful in communal experiences.
[01:26:00] Jordan’s biblical lectures
[01:32:00] What are the guests working on?
[01:36:00] Beauty in churches
[01:38:00] Growing up Christian
[01:44:00] Possibility is real
[01:50:00] Joining religion and science
[01:58:04] Wrapping up
#Meaning #Psychology #Religion
// SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL //
Newsletter: linktr.ee/DrJordanBPeterson
Donations: jordanbpeterson.com/donate
// COURSES //
Discovering Personality: jordanbpeterson.com/personality
Self Authoring Suite: selfauthoring.com
Understand Myself (personality test): understandmyself.com
// BOOKS //
Beyond Order: 12 More Rules for Life:
jordanbpeterson.com/Beyond-Order
12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos:
jordanbpeterson.com/12-rules-...
Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief:
jordanbpeterson.com/maps-of-m...
// LINKS //
Website: jordanbpeterson.com
Events: jordanbpeterson.com/events
Podcast: jordanbpeterson.com/podcast
// SOCIAL //
Twitter: / jordanbpeterson
Instagram: / jordan.b.peterson
Facebook: / drjordanpeterson
// SPONSORS //
For Advertising Inquiries, visit www.advertisecast.com/TheJord...

Опубликовано:

15 июн 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 4,1 тыс.

@danielcanales2811 2 года назад

I’m 80 years old. I recall, years ago, a cartoon in a major magazine that showed a group of scientists reaching the summit of the mountain of knowledge only to find a group of mystics already there sitting by a campfire.

@BODSTREAM 2 года назад

Love this

@prettycatlick4373 Год назад

It's a Robert Jastrow quote. One of my favorites: For the scientist who has lived by his faith in the power of reason, the story ends like a bad dream. He has scaled the mountains of ignorance, he is about to conquer the highest peak; as he pulls himself over the final rock, he is greeted by a band of theologians who have been sitting there for centuries.

@StrategicWealthLLC Год назад

“The scientist and philosopher want to learn what the farmer and fisherman already know.” I read that in a Louis L’amour western when I was about 13…and have never forgotten it.

@XOXO-mb2vh Год назад

So what is the lesson>

@daisyviluck7932 Год назад

They’d never publish that today

@bretwells3610 2 года назад

So a psychologist, psychiatrist, catholic bishop, and an orthodox Christian walk into a bar... stay tuned to what happens next!

@americanmambi 2 года назад

It was a fantastic time, roughly speaking...

@americanmambi 2 года назад

And they all saved the father from the belly of the whale 🐋🐋🐋

@GetUnlabeled 2 года назад

Lol, irl

@Spiritual_Alchemy 2 года назад

Hilarious comment hope they pin it 😂

@niallmartin9063 2 года назад

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 brilliant

@Hoi4o 2 года назад

I was raised in an orthodox home, but since my teens to my 30s I was a convinced atheist. Jordan Peterson through his biblical lectures helped me understand christianity in a way that no one else could. They were the bridge between science and theology that I needed in order to actually begin understanding faith and the deep and meaningful connection between humans and God. Of course, they weren't the only thing that brought me back to faith, but they were one of the key elements that transformed my understanding and my belief system. I am now a practicing orthodox christian and I can only express my gratitude for that to doctor Peterson. God bless you and your whole family!

@justanothernick3984 2 года назад

I also do not consider myself an atheist anymore. That isn't because there is a God or anything of that description, but people use mind tricks and self deceptions to find all kinds of meaning and happiness. Even though they are mere tricks, they need to be felt as real in order to have the desired effect and that displays itself through actions all across the world with real impact. So there isn't anything supernatural but people acting in that way is pretty much the same as real and I think the only way to experience the reality I am experiencing, is through the interconnectedness between people. So no God but still not atheist.

@liquidusblue 2 года назад

Not quite the same but similar to you. I used to be a fundamentalist atheist. Probably guilty of the "Scientism" they talked about. I still don't really believe in God. But I these days I see the good religions and their believers do and accept there is so more to the human experience than plain science.

@heatedpants8437 2 года назад

I relate to this.

@hristijankjosevski 2 года назад

Same here orthodox, and I think that drifting or pulling out of the faith is induced by popular anti-God culture emerging in the west of we're all influenced by.

@MW-ic7lr 2 года назад

Jung and Peterson helped me feel connected to something spiritual. I was a hardcore atheist for many years. I still don't believe God exists. But I'm open to it.

@John.Christopher Год назад

Bishop Barron is leagues ahead in both coherency and bringing structure to abstraction in this conversation. Master communicator. People really ought to listen to him more.

@margokupelian344 Месяц назад

I hope the other participants are not offended by your comment. It’s kind of subtle to be so straightforward about your thoughts on this discussion. I have expressed my praise and admiration for Bishop Barron every time I listen to him, and I listen to him a lot, but I would be more careful in my assessment when others are involved. I LOVE this group!

@ianbrown7913 2 года назад

This conversation with these four gentlemen is basically my Super Bowl 😂 I’m hyped!

@finneganmcbride6224 2 года назад

Couldn’t relate more 😂

@douglascummins4213 2 года назад

Same!

@jordylamslag5903 2 года назад

Same!

@martinpaveymusic309 2 года назад

Amen to this. 🙏 Was so fabulous!

@michael7144 2 года назад

Yep!

@RandaEd 2 года назад

I feel like this needs to happen about a thousand more times. This group could stand to talk weekly.

@MariaPerez-uv8mm 2 года назад

Me too!!!!

@NitwitMN 2 года назад

I wrote essentially the same proposal about 2.5 hours after you did. Reminded again that I’m not an original thinker. Of course you’re correct.

@alaricgoldkuhl155 2 года назад

Nah dude. You can have too much of a good thing. Maybe once every month or two. People make the same mistake with psychedelics when they experience them for the first time. "That was awesome! Let's do it again real soon!" When you touch the depths of meaning, going back to the same well too often cheapens it, makes it less special and remarkable. These great minds need to go away and let this stuff percolate awhile and come back with renewed energy and perspective. Maybe some one-on-ones between them to unpack stuff might be helpful, but if they come back and do this again too soon, you'll likely find them rehashing the same points until they are beating a dead horse. The value in such deep insights and discussions is that they are rare and therefore precious and sacred. Speaking for myself, I have enough to digest and unpack to last me for a good few months. Maybe wait a week and watch it again and see if you pick up something new. I understand your enthusiasm (can hardly wait for the next one myself), but it's a trap I've fallen into before, and my instinct here is to want to protect this most valuable source of profundity.

@NitwitMN 2 года назад

@@alaricgoldkuhl155 Like many things, serving size and frequency are key. Nutrition value is difficult to dispute, however. Good for those who partake

@RandaEd 2 года назад

@@alaricgoldkuhl155 I'd be quite content with bi-yearly, but honestly, I just hope they do it again someday.

@johnbrion4565 2 года назад

For years I suffered from horrible anxiety on a daily basis to the point where I was having panic attacks at work breaking out in sweats at my desk. I was questioning the point and purpose of my life. My psychologist said I needed to ground myself in something. This didn’t make sense to me as how could I find solid ground in the words of another man or woman. Then I came to find God first through the writings of Aquinas Augustine and other church fathers. Then through the videos of people like bishop Barron which led me to the letters of Paul then the Gospels. And finally I figured out what the psychologist meant. Even though I don’t think he expected me to ground myself in God as he wasn’t religious. My anxiety attacks stopped and my depression and despair greatly improved. I’m sure some atheists would argue I am weak and taking the opiate of the masses. But maybe there’s something to be said about the power of turning toward a higher power. And this is coming from someone who turned toward Dawkins and hitchens and Harris before turning to God so I know most the arguments against religion. Ultimately for me it came down to believing that if there truly is ultimate meaning it is found in love. And then reading the Bible it’s right there, God is love, infinite unconditional self sacrificial love. Well it all made sense. I’m thankful for people like Bishop Barron and now Jordan Peterson who helped me and I know are helping many others in their journey through life. Thank you and God bless.

@clairejagels9598 Год назад

Feeling safe in the loving arms of God is the best truest and most long lasting antitode to anxiety. I know because I’ve tried the other things too. Being God’s child is not weak, it’s how he designed us!

@user-nj9ru4ef2w 4 месяца назад

how is god love if he is letting all of these bad things happen? I wouldn't say you're "weak", but I do think you're escaping. I definitely believe that there's some higher purpose/meaning than the four horsemen of arrogance; their arguments essentially amount to "I'm very smart, so if even I can't conceptually prove the existence of objective morality then it must not exist". It's very much akin to someone 5000 years ago saying bacteria must not exist because I can't see it and you have no way to show me they exist. It's the arrogance of belief in our rationality and intelligence and that nothing must be beyond its bounds.

@johnbrion4565 4 месяца назад

@@user-nj9ru4ef2w if there is life after death then the bad things that we see happen really are of no significance if we are destined for eternal glory. God allows bad to happen sometimes so a greater good can come about. I wouldn’t call it escaping. I’d call it being aware that either there is no meaning at all or there is ultimate meaning. And I choose to have faith that there is a loving God based on the evidence. It can’t be proved either way but it’s like Pascal’s wager, believing could mean infinite glory and if I’m wrong well I’m in the same place as the non believers at the end anyways. But there have been many intelligent people who have believed throughout the ages and I don’t think they are escaping. I think they just see evidence for God and choose to have faith.

@user-nj9ru4ef2w 4 месяца назад

@@johnbrion4565 the idea that you need bad to exist for some greater good is silly if god is all powerful. God could have created it so that the concept of bad doesn't exist at all. You're escaping not because you choose to believe in meaning; like I said, I do too. But you've chosen to escape to an answer that is obviously logically false. Like meaning is hard, searching for it is an arduous task that may cause huge amounts of depression and despair; I have suffered through that and am still suffering through it. But because it is literally the only thing that matters, I will continue to suffer through it til the end of my life and I'm not going to reach a false conclusion just to stop suffering.

@user-nj9ru4ef2w 4 месяца назад

@@johnbrion4565 Also the choices aren't a binary of nihilism and christianity. Like, there are thousands of religions out there. Why christianity? Why does the answer have to already exist in human knowledge? Can't it be something we haven't discovered yet?

@trentcoalson415 2 года назад

When Bishop Barron said Aquinas called God “IPSUM ESSE”: “to be itself” I was absolutely floored. I think viewers would get more value from the podcast videos if it were always multicam view. I would have loved to see the looks on Jordan’s, John’s, and Jonathan’s faces when he dropped that line, but the video cut to the solo shot of Bishop Barron. There have been so many staggeringly meaningful moments on this podcast, it would be great to have those reaction shots. It is a rare moment in podcasts where the entire screen needs to be utilized for one party during a conversation.

@cindyrobertson3798 2 года назад

Agreed .I think Jordan P had a very sore throat as well.

@josephtravers777 2 года назад

'I AM' is His name

@r.lizarraga693 2 года назад

The notion of God being Being itself is a very ancient Christian belief that existed long before Aquinas. It's a basic tenant of Orthodox theology that Jonathan has talked about many times, so I don't think he would have been that surprised (though I'm sure he was happy to hear it mentioned!). For modern people in the West it might seem like a new idea, but it's a fairly common belief in Eastern Christianity.

@xDELFYonceagain 2 года назад

@@r.lizarraga693 Even older than that, the idea was articulated by the likes of Plato though Aquinas drew more from Aristotle’s ‘causes’.

@trentcoalson415 2 года назад

@@r.lizarraga693 That’s fascinating! I attended Christian evangelical and baptists church services all throughout my early life and had never encountered that idea stated so succinctly and explicitly. I’ve only heard and seen Jonathan through Jordan. Do you have a recommendation on where to begin with regard to Jonathan‘s work, or perhaps Eastern Christianity in general?

@MrsYasha1984 2 года назад

Bishop Baron mentioned that Jordan pulls a lot of people back to the bible, back to christianity. That happened to me. It took me some time, but I'm proud to say that after years of fighting against the wisdom in the bible, I've found my way cautiously back to the catholic church. That would not have happened this way without Jordans lectures. And to my delight I must say, our community and pastor are amazing. I still have ways to go to heal myself, but I'm certain I'll find healing in church. So thank you Jordan! Thank you very much!

@publiusovidius7386 2 года назад

So enjoy the antigay bigotry and misogyny of the Church. Really poisonous crap that isn't real.

@Abigailwark 2 года назад

Same!!!

@debras3806 2 года назад

Welcome Manuela, may your pursuit of knowing Jesus proceed steadily! Remember it is Him, whether found in the Catholic or Orthodox or Protestant Church... Who is the goal, and nothing other.

@XmarkedMySpot 2 года назад

@@publiusovidius7386 hehe get a life dude

@galadine12 2 года назад

@@publiusovidius7386 I'm not catholic, but between your post and his, I'm guessing he's not the one with the problem.

@mitchcohn1800 2 года назад

Mind blowing!! Great input from all !!because of Bishop Barron 7 years ago I became a Catholic from being Jewish 🙏

@berwynsigns4115 8 месяцев назад

Glory be to Jesus Christ.

@mk05022 6 месяцев назад

Why?

@bobmcswigan6415 4 месяца назад

Praise God for Bishop Barron. He's helped me to get back into my Catholic faith.

@bestgameralive1 2 года назад

Its truly a blessing to see color in Jordan's face, I've been worried and praying for his recovery and this video has only made me absolutely ecstatic. Bless you four

@sirvaliantvillianjr5403 2 года назад

Well it could be deep fake? Even real time 5g

@Mj-pf6by 2 года назад

Beautiful discussion... As a Muslim, I am happy Christian thought is becoming more mainstream, and will hopefully become established in the West again as a bulwark against the unfortunate absence of meaning and a connection to the divine. Everyone is better off with a transcendent aim!

@11antun 2 года назад

Well, i pray with you. A chatolic Women! Thank you!

@tourist1313 2 года назад

Amen. This is a beautiful sentiment.

@tatsumakisempyukaku 2 года назад

Well said

@michaelterrell5061 2 года назад

Beautifully put.

@masterofnone6620 2 года назад

Very well said.

@charlescoult 2 года назад

15:00 - When Bishop Barron says, "Good to be with all of you", as a habituated Catholic, I couldn't help but feel the need to say, "and also with you." XD

@pieteytrenton2747 2 года назад

We lift him up to the most highest

@xDELFYonceagain 2 года назад

And with your spirit!

@timanderson6896 2 года назад

Cool bro

@charlescoult 2 года назад

@Nick Williams I was just poking fun at how habituated I had become to certain customs of Catholicism. I wasn't making any comment on my beliefs whatsoever. That said, I think religion helps to provide a framework for understanding those things which we are demonstrably true but (currently) unprovable. Correct me if I misunderstood your comment.

@charlescoult 2 года назад

@Nick Williams demonstrable doesn't necessarily mean 'provable'. It means it's 'able to be demonstrated'. Correlation vs causation. It can be demonstrated that living life according to certain principles leads to a certain result, however it can't, currently, be proven that it does. And if we're being nit picky about semantics, you meant to say 'accept' in your first comment, not 'except'.

@EUPThatsMe 2 года назад

As a teen I realized that it is not humanly possible to know everything about everything and so I settled for learning something about everything and how/where to find out more about anything as needed.

@boss180888 2 года назад

Good approach

@Lyonessi 2 года назад

That's exactly the thought I had at 14/15 years that brought about my search for enlightenment lol

@the2ndcoming135 2 года назад

Oh okay😎

@robfield2302 2 года назад

@@the2ndcoming135 lol

@MarvinAMarcelino Год назад

At teen i have so many questions, after questions they were not all answered that even now I am still finding answers to understand many things i observed around me. I want my own kids to ask, to question and make it their journey the rest aspect of life will just go secondary of importance.

@matthewsheek8306 2 года назад

The inclusion of an artist in such a conversation has been a long time coming. Happy to have Jonathan’s input

@hypertips 2 года назад

Marvel: "Endgame is the most ambitious crossover ever made." Jordan: "Hold my Grail."

@milkman2266 2 года назад

“Hold my sparkling water”

@bryanmatthews3797 2 года назад

"Hold my spiked wine."

@jorritjorik 2 года назад

you gave me a good laugh :-)

@angureyna 2 года назад

Hold my steak

@MTD4dz 2 года назад

Marvel is such Satanic trash. Never watching that shit again!

@garrettvandenberg2031 2 года назад

Can we please get a round two of this? This is like my favorite thing to happen on this channel. Feels like the council of elders meeting, or like in lord of the rings were Gandolf and Saruman and Galadriel and Elrond meet together to discuss the state of things. What a fun time

@MrTTnTT 2 года назад

I just hope none of them is going to turn out to be Saruman... :P

@lawdogattorneyatlaw4886 2 года назад

@Back to the Future 2021 sounds like a you problem

@anchy0301 2 года назад

Agreed!

@Sopranohooper 2 года назад

Speaking of wizards, is he *ever* gonna interview John Michael Greer?

@46positivity 2 года назад

One thing that stood out in particular in this episode was the seemingly effortless flow of the conversation from one participant to the next. They seemed to each speak for about the same amount of time, which is one of the things you hope for in these multi-guest episodes. Among his many other talents, Dr. Peterson is a very gifted interviewer.

@candyholyoak 2 года назад

Loved this conversation, as with all of yours, Dr. Peterson. I can be one more example of someone who has had a transformative and transcendent experience through prayer and meditation without drugs. I have never taken any drugs or alcohol in my life, except what has ever been prescribed by doctors. When I was pregnant with my second child, I had suffered from depression and anxiety for the six prior years. I did as much inner work as I could to try and rid myself of this torment. I journaled, I found tapping/EFT. One of the last things I learned was meditation. Although I was a novice in it, there was one day when I prayed and meditated very intently when I felt myself slipping into the depression ‘hole’ again. The only way I can describe what unfolded in my mind during this meditative prayer was a vision - it was like a movie on a screen that gave me different perspective of my experience. The content of the vision was something I have never conceived of before. I have no idea where the concepts came from, but the meaning was definitely rational, and gave me an entirely new perspective (I won’t go into details here). In the vision I was told that my depression was healed and the only way I would fall into depression from that point on is if I chose to. Well my second son that I was pregnant with at the time is now 13 years old and I can say that the experience has held true. I have never experienced depression once since that moment. It just completely vanished. And it hasn’t been until hearing some of your and other’s podcast more recently that describe the use of psychedelics to attain similar experiences, that I realized that maybe what happened to me was like what happens to those who undergo a psychedelic experience. Anyway, I just wanted to share my experience of a life-transforming experience without the use of drugs, only prayer/meditation. Thank you for sharing your work and thoughts and introducing me to such amazing guests as well. You all have changed my life!

@JordanBPeterson 2 года назад

Thanks for this. Very interesting.

@evillano 2 года назад

Indeed, very interesting! thank you for sharing and you got a reply from the doc himself!

@J.Mulleno 2 года назад

Greetings, Your description of your anxiety and your transformative experience was exciting to me. I have had anxiety with intensity for years. I could not take tranquilizers in a while because I have been getting treatment for pain.. Despite all this, I had something spiritual that happened about a couple of years back. It caused me a real shift in how to view anxiety.. That perhaps some of the anxiety was actually something else that might be helpful to me.. It is hard to share here, and I am still meditating on it. I do think that it is more now than a "hyped state of intensity". I think it has spiritual meaning, value... I still need to continue to understand, and meditate on this.. I hope you work out the meaning it has for you, and I wish you the best with yours too. (Smile) Take care. 🖖⚘🌿

@lornadoone8887 2 года назад

I can relate to this experience somewhat. I reached a point of spiritual urgency and sense of need such that I reached out to God (as a Christian in an Evangelical context) with every fiber of my mind and being with the crux of my question (having to do with God in His nature as Love). The response was a stunning instantaneous insight that was outside any concept I had ever encountered before. It rocked my world. It led eventually to my entering the Orthodox Church where I had discovered this concept in an essay entitled “The River of Fire” by Alexandre Kalomiros, and further based in insights like those of St. Isaac the Syrian. I think this may be an instance of the synergy of the “emergent” (my need) meeting “emanation” (insight from above) in John V’s terms that is where transformation occurs.

@samanthaduggan9002 2 года назад

The sciences "ever more precise accounts of the cave" - love this quote from Bishop Barron.

@easyemu1511 2 года назад

That for sure is a mouthful and worth thinking about.

@erravi 2 года назад

That’s so amazing

@dannymaciejewski 2 года назад

I missed what the ”cave” signifies. Can someone please explain?

@samanthaduggan9002 2 года назад

@@dannymaciejewski With apologies to anyone who could do this much better to me....it refers to Plato's cave. Plato described physical reality in the world as "the cave" but believed outside the cave, in the world of Forms, was where true reality lay. You might call it this life and eternity. Science can only describe material existence and thus misses the greater truth.

@Cerealcasual 2 года назад

@@dannymaciejewski It's a classical story where these men live in a cave for all of their life having never seen the outside world and believe the cave is the world. Eventually one of the men leaves the cave and discovers there is a whole world outside of the cave. So in the case of the lecture I assume it's inferring that the sciences understanding of our world (Earth and outer space) is still vastly limited.

@tanyadecastella4770 2 года назад

As a Catholic convert from fundamentalist Christian upbringing, to becoming a beginner Iconographer / secondary teacher of the history of Christian Art and a mother of ten with seven boys who brought me to Jordan Peterson, this episode touched me on every level. Thank-you

@juliac9080 2 года назад

Strange to realize when is discovered JP a few years ago, he wasn't a means to an end. Through him I met so many other thinkers and thought leaders.

@conornagle9528 2 года назад

I've revisited this dialogue again for a second time now after listening in full to Jordan's Biblical series, John Vervaeke's Awakening From The Meaning Crisis lecture series, and listening to more of Jonathan and Bishop Barren's salient and impactful work. The gratitude could not be more Graciously given. All 4 of you have transformed and blessed my life and I hope to be of relevant service to those around. Participation and Love 🙏🏻

@benjamin-senpai9564 2 года назад

One of the best talks with guests on this channel! This, "The 4 horsemen of meaning" should be it's own podcast, which comes out every 3 or 4 mounths.

@TheReunizer 2 года назад

agree

@ikennaoparandu9029 2 года назад

Totally agree

@Lerian_V 2 года назад

Yes!

@renaud_gagne 2 года назад

Yup, this should keep happening. To hell with the "tours" to sell books ;-)

@shakbhaji 2 года назад

I’d love to see a meeting of the remaining 3 original horsemen with these 4 and watch that conversation. Perhaps too many people for a rich exchange of ideas in proper depth.

@PaulVanderKlay 2 года назад

The Protestant reformation happened for a reason. The Protest must end, and is ending, but it's helpful to see the role it has played for all parties concerned.

@sillygoose4472 2 года назад

Hey Paul, do you have a video about what the Protest is? Like a good introduction for someone who has no clue what it is? Asking for a friend 🤣

@CesarScur 2 года назад

The Church is anxious to have you back integrally. 😍

@DerekJFiedler 2 года назад

Would be helpful to include you in one of these group talks.

@mattspintosmith5285 2 года назад

Not forgetting the protests about the protests....

@MrSofuskroghlarsen 2 года назад

Where in the lecture do they talk about the protestant reformation? :)

@szabolcshursan761 2 года назад

It's astonishing how much authority has Barron as a Bishop of the Church in these conversations. When he speaks, you can feel the weight of his words and the deep silence and attention from the other three, as they would be his disciples. Fantastic

@brittclausson3221 2 года назад

It's not the authority of the Church. It is a great mind well schooled in the Church's tradition of philisophy and theology

@brycebensing 2 года назад

@@brittclausson3221 as a Bishop, he has the fullness of the sacrament of holy orders, responsible for teaching doctrine, governing Catholics in his jurisdiction, sanctifying the World and representing the Church. He does speak with the authority of the Church. As a bishop he is considered a direct spiritual descendant of the apostles through the unbroken laying of hands of the Apostolic Succession.

@JeremyStMartin 2 года назад

It is the grace of Holy Orders at work. People don't know about that. The Church has grace.

@ms.leclaire9017 2 года назад

The respect they all shared is beautiful to witness!

@benpitman9134 2 года назад

That was excellent. I am a Pentecostal minister and I was so thoroughly encouraged by the dialogue. Thank you.

@Renigade16 2 года назад

This is the kinda conversation that make me want to educate myself more, just so I can keep up with what's being said.

@Michalfx 2 года назад

You won't regret the journey of doing so :D It'll only add depth and from that a beauty to your life and your appreciation of it

@zanec9108 2 года назад

Check out Jonathan Pageaus video Jordan Peterson re-posted. He does a great job of setting up this particular podcast.

@bertvsrob 2 года назад

get your hands on a first year philosophy reading list if you can

@KJ-lb4tj 2 года назад

@@Michalfx or depression or an existential crisis....

@Michalfx 2 года назад

@@KJ-lb4tj Hahaha you’re not wrong. Although I found that to only be temporary for me. It was almost a cleansing out of previous held ideas beliefs that stood on weak foundations in the real world. It revealed to me that the life and journey I thought I should be pursuing was one devoid of meaning and a connection to what was truly real. whilst it showed the bleak reality around me it consequently showed me where to go or look to learn more. Almost like seeing a light house in dark stormy seas. And since then I must say life has rearranged itself that even struggles and anxieties don’t throw me back into that dark place. I realise I’m talking in metaphors but it is really hard to summaries 2-3 years of events any other way 😅

@chucksdad 2 года назад

Bishop Barron's acknowledgement that the modern Catholic seminaries, architecture and pandering to the world view has led to a real void in connecting man to God was a mea culpa I wish the whole Church would to see. Jonathan Pageau has opened my eyes to the Orthodox. I pray for a reunification of the Apostolic Churches which are separated by so little

@Lerian_V 2 года назад

I truly believed a unification would have happened if Benedict XVI is still in charge.

@G-MIP 2 года назад

@@Lerian_V Accept that it didn’t happen under Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI- it is God’s will that he was replaced by Pope Francis.

@bryant475 2 года назад

Many Catholics are now becoming born again Christians, and it's great to see. It's about a real relationship with Jesus, and not merely religion!

@drdonnad 2 года назад

There are 23 Eastern Catholic Churches - Orthodox by tradition, of various rites, yet in communion withe the Bishop of Rome. Each of these Churches their own canon law and hierarchy. The largest of these Sui Uris Churches is the UkrainianGreco Catholic Church - which is not just for Ukrainians (the Church in Ukraine distinguishes itself from the Roman Catholic and thus the name translation). It’s liturgical tradition is in the Byzantine rite and very Orthodox in living the teachings of the early church fathers. Yet, the UGCC is Catholic. It is an example of unity in the one holy catholic and apostolic church. If there is one near you, encourage going to check it out. There are also monasteries in the USA (not sure about Canada) that can be visited. Keep praying for full communion in the Church (katholique = whole).

@michellestamper5527 2 года назад

And it seems many pagan societies aren't fairing much better for similar reasons. Honestly many religious and spiritual organizations are drowning in the massive influx of people joining and this push to betray one's convictions is really strong.

@DOBEAGAIN 2 года назад

". . .in front of the Blessed Sacrament with my Rosary. . ." Bishop Barron got it in one!

@weproject3125 Год назад

Wonderful! Thanks to all, especially Bishop Barron for representing the Catholic community as a true leader. 🙏🏼

@christiangadfly24 2 года назад

It's time people admitted that there is nothing "intelligent" about mocking metaphysics. So glad these conversations are happening.

@paulfrederick1568 2 года назад

Listen more

@merlepatterson 2 года назад

There is also no "Ignorance" for paying only cursory or little attention to metaphysics as well.

@lancewalker2595 2 года назад

That depends. It was pretty goddamn intelligent the way Nietzsche did it.

@calummacritchie7840 2 года назад

Metaphysics alongside logic, morality, Aesthetic Judgement and truth are all immaterial realities that cannot be touched, seen, tasted, smelled or heard but they are essential to our reality.

@lancewalker2595 2 года назад

@@calummacritchie7840 Metaphysics is the language of imagination, it cannot be formalized.

@Milestonemonger 2 года назад

No psychedelics involved, I had an emotional religious experience last month while visiting a 600 year old church in Romania. For an atheist, this took me completely by surprise. This experience changed me.

@Brus963 2 года назад

This was mindblowingly amazing. Thank you, all four of you, for giving us the opportunity to listen to such a deep conversation.

@jmethos 2 года назад

Most of this is over my head and far deeper than I've ever delved into religion and the meaning of life but I still enjoyed listening. I'm so pleased there are people out there that are able to have these conversations!

@not-much 2 года назад

Jonathan is my fav. He’s always smiling.

@martinliehs2513 2 года назад

He exudes such positive energy, regardless of the topic.

@Illlium 2 года назад

@@martinliehs2513 I honestly wish I could be like that guy.

@brien1513 2 года назад

I like when he chuckles

@catholic_based534 2 года назад

And laughing. Amazing guy man.

@mr.blueshyguy3408 2 года назад

This is beautiful, I'm so thankful to be alive in this era of the internet where I can witness this conversation alongside hundreds of thousands of people, all coming together in search of meaning

@alaricgoldkuhl155 2 года назад

Well said dude. I got that sense too - that I was participating in something much bigger than myself, which ultimately is the goal of metaphysics.

@MrCmon113 2 года назад

@@alaricgoldkuhl155 No. That's not the goal of metaphysics. At least look up the word on wikipedia or sth.

@TheFlash-rh2el 2 года назад

We are animals, we create our own meaning. People who rely on others to tell them how to live life are losers. The four nerds in this video are the very definition of that state of loserdom.

@hakapelika7024 2 года назад

I search for Truth, Good and Beauty. Whether it means anything or not, I long for those things.

@mr.blueshyguy3408 2 года назад

@@TheFlash-rh2el are u trolling lol?

@Lerian_V 2 года назад

A very illuminating conversation. I have to go back and watch "The Forerunners of the Reformation - with Dr. Scott Hahn" lecture one more time.

@stampintoconnect.jcollins 2 года назад

Even though much of the discussion was over my head, I listened. I found the discussion fascinating and interesting. Thank you.

@curtiste3235 Год назад

I feel the same... Very fascinating, mesmerizing, incredible. And yet, I kept hearing myself say, "What?..." Just mind blowing.

@nucknuck4476 2 года назад

Jordan this is so fucking awesome! Nothing excites me more than your Christian discussions, it gives me the church I always wanted man. Please keep this up, this is phenomenal. I've stopped all I was planning to do today and instantly switched to this rockstar conversation. Bless you all.

@RicardoGarcia-ib8ro 2 года назад

That conversation came in the church since St. Augustine. He has a simple but iluminative book: On the master (I think this is the right translation)

@8795153934 2 года назад

God is man-made. You are delusional

@nathanbell6962 2 года назад

If Jordan fails or becomes subverted into a schism how is your world view then?

@DieLazergurken 2 года назад

@@8795153934 God is as man-made as your eye.

@euanharrison7125 2 года назад

@@8795153934 Guess again

@mariog1490 2 года назад

Bishop Barron is so underrated. I’ve been a fan of Jordan for awhile, specifically on pragmatism; but Bishop blows me out of the water every time.

@jeffw7382 2 года назад

He gets so much hate from a lot of tradcaths, but I love what he's doing.

@mariog1490 2 года назад

@@jeffw7382 yeah. I thought he was especially good last podcast arguing against the will-to-power with the will seeking God.

@zi8gzag 2 года назад

Love the comment + pfp combo hahahah

@rushthezeppelin 2 года назад

@@jeffw7382 us trads don't hate him. I mean I'm a recent concert and he did play a role in helping me through RCIA for which I'm thankful. He's solid on a lot of things. That whole dare we hope thing is not good though. Also the catholicism is the privileged way thing. He also has some other modernist tendencies although is not near as bad as others. Most of us just want to see him use the wonderful platform to teach the Catholic faith more boldly. Trying to appease the world does not really draw in converts like his generation of bishops thinks it does. The Tradition is something so beautiful and a refuge from the modern world that it's a travesty to water it down. Bishops Strickland, Schneider and Burke are awesome prelates to follow that don't shy away from speaking hard truth.

@mariog1490 2 года назад

@@zi8gzag 😂 it was a good album.

@semmler3499 2 года назад

Thank you so much for having this conversation publicly so that we may all learn from your gathered wisdom. God bless you.

@cindyrobertson3798 2 года назад

When I was a young teenager I had a transformational experience with the suicide of a friend. And I sought reason , faith ,explanation of which there's no real answer. I never drank,smoked pot, or lived stupidity after that. My dad who was taught by Jesuit s was my best person of council. You do not have to get high to be shaken to the core of the value of life.and set s plan for your eternal life.

@stevecrawford6792 2 года назад

This conversation may become an epoch for the recovery of meaning in the West. Thank you all.

@teenanguyen217 2 года назад

If meaning can be lost, than it is not really meaning. It is merely corruptible arbitrarity that is impermanent.

@youssefsammouh501 2 года назад

@@teenanguyen217 love seeing people typing crap like this on youtube hahahah

@mafia461 2 года назад

@@youssefsammouh501 😆 lol 99% of people don't even speak nor write this way. We should coin this phenomenon "The Jordan Effect". How's that for a cognitive experience😄

@erlendurk 2 года назад

What on earth does that mean? Organized religion has been the number one source of misinformation, cruelty and corruption over the centuries. Please explain, sounds like nonsense to me.

@anilmethipara 2 года назад

Facts

@richarddimitrov6545 2 года назад

That was a wonderful dialogue that left me very hopeful; "Science is not a map but a description of the terrain". Wow. I didn't want the talk to end. Great job!

@joshmcminn5168 2 года назад

@@jonde-cent4897 I'm really struggling to understand which of the observations in this talk you're perceiving to be 'imagined'.

@joshmcminn5168 2 года назад

@@jonde-cent4897 This is exactly the deductionist rhetoric that the entire podcast objects against. God isn't discussed as a contingent being that can be clarified by propositional arguments, but as a logical necessity that is presupposed by all Being and thought, and, as discussed, the Sciences in particular. John talks at length about acknowledging this presupposition, or set of presuppositions, that science depends and yet cannot in and of itself account for, as a feature of rationality itself. The Bible is that presupposition.

@the2ndcoming135 2 года назад

Helps with the whole exploration thing. Stuff I didn’t really look at way back when I started the journey😎

@pela907 2 года назад

Isn't this presupposition a result of the external environments effects on the cave. I suspect a cave may be a bad example because it creates an image of the external being very distant from the observable inside when they very much, are interconnected...take consciousness for example...I suspect the cave has a little hole that allows us to peek through, and so when it rains and the cave begins to fill with water, and small flashes if light show from this tiny hole, we can assume it's raining outside, and rightly so.

@sonicman52 2 года назад

@@jonde-cent4897 Even if you think something is “fictional”, doesn’t mean it’s “untrue”. There’s a difference between reason, and the postmodern, reductionist, materialist rationalism you’re displaying in this comment. You seek to tear down with nothing to replace it. There are deeper metaphysical and spiritual truths to life and the human condition, I truly hope you can realize that someday. Take care.

@sarahb441 2 года назад

This was so nourishing, and as someone who has struggled my whole life with the 'tug and pull' of faith, I find this incredibly positive and I have reformed my relationship with our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, it is an ongoing wrestle with God, but it is so beautiful I don't want it to stop. God bless you all. And please keep these coming. PS. We need you Mr. Peterson, please keep yourself strong, we need you to keep fighting the good fight, the light of the Lord shines through you immensely, I don't think I am the only person who has witnessed this, I hope you can feel him working through you, and if not I pray you do very very soon in Jesus name I pray, Amen.

@jesh879 Год назад

I prayed with you.

@jeffreylewis4708 2 года назад

Thank you so much. This conversation was like a run in the woods with old friends I just met. It was work to keep up, AND it was a salve for my mind and soul. Here is one person feeling less alone.

@sarahgoins93 2 года назад

1:09:03. Omg, the best part was when Jordan Peterson said “I think Revelation is a psychedelic account” and Bishop Barron and Jonathan react like “No, I don’t think so.” 😆

@Lerian_V 2 года назад

@@JAMWITCH True.

@cecilcharlesofficial 2 года назад

@@JAMWITCH and yet you’re describing one now…

@AngelBien 2 года назад

Lol

@bend6799 2 года назад

The bishop is a fool when it comes to psychedelics

@sarahgoins93 2 года назад

@@bend6799 I disagree. While psychedelics can mimic a mystical experience, a true mystical experience is a gift that comes about from a communion with God and that requires the same full attention and cognitive functioning as any normal and healthy relationship among humans, not a drug induced “experience.”

@fallen0851 2 года назад

To use one of Bishop Barron’s favorite Augustine quotes, “Lord, you made us for yourself, so the heart will not rest until it finally rests in thee.”

@sleepystar1638 2 года назад

It’s actually from the bible

@AlexKomnenos 2 года назад

@@sleepystar1638 no it isn’t

@sketchartist1964 2 года назад

Barron holds some beliefs that are not Catholic, like the possibility that in the end everybody might be saved. He also denies that bishops should defend the faith publicly against it's attackers. He says that's a layman's job.

@sleepystar1638 2 года назад

@@AlexKomnenos Deuteronomy 33, 12; 12, 10 Exodus 33, 14 1 Kings 5, 4 2 Samuel 7, 1 Joshua 21, 44 Psalms 91, 1 You have no idea what you are talking about these aren’t even half of the quotes about the Lord giving us rest for believing in him.

@btrav667 2 года назад

@@sketchartist1964 say what you want about him, but he holds his own here. I also think it is wise of him to meet non-believers and non-catholics "where they are"........he's not perfect but he does a great job with the new atheists. My guess is that some of the Trad-youtuber-types couldn't hang in there with these heavyweights.

@loveoverfear20 2 года назад

well I popped onto RU-vid for some pre Thanksgiving turkey cooking ideas and now I am rescheduling my whole afternoon because I am SO excited about this!!!

@casfoto2 2 года назад

I am amazed at this discovery of spirit/mind/wonder. I have lived around the world and and observed beauty and as a person who has made his life's work photographing the beauty of what God has given...this gathering of the four of you have given me a new definition of beauty that has deeply inspired me. Thank You all.

@bellanegrin3915 2 года назад

This was extremely insightful. I have always been a Christian , but I have only just begun a real and meaningful journey with God, Jesus, and his Holy Spirit. It took an aweful and traumatic experience to see something I had never seen before. I am horribly saddened and yet thankful, in a very strange way for this new, but scary mystical experience.

@markdallaire278 2 года назад

When I saw this video pop up on RU-vid, my immediate reaction was "Woohoo!" I've been following JBP, Pageau, John Vervaeke and Paul VanderKlay since 2017. If I have this correctly, PVK brought Bishop Barron to John's attention by way of a video that was recently posted. Great to see these four deep thinkers, all with very different training, histories and perspectives engaged in dialogos. And imagine my surprise and pleasure when Bishop Barron brought Bernard Lonergan into the conversation. I had the good fortune to study Lonergan's "Insight" at Lonergan University College in Montreal in the winter of 1983. It answered so many questions that I had at the time, and changed my life. These four thinkers are now helping answer a new set of questions. We should all be grateful for their tenacity and courage in doing so.

@markdallaire278 2 года назад

And really looking forward to PVK's unpacking of what has been said. He has a true gift for helping me see what is true in what has been said, but also seeing what is sometimes left out or not fully recognized or acknowledged. And his deep pastoral experience always brings me back to compassion for the poor, broken and marginalized.

@like.a.hairbrush6083 2 года назад

I was only 20 minutes in and had to stop to "google" Lonergan (once I worked my way through a few guesses at the name based on Bishop Barron's quick mentions, haha). This Jesuit is new to me, but based on the Bishop's statements--and particularly on the quote he mentioned that knowing God results in an insatiable desire to to "know everything about everything", I had to find enough to get me started on who the man was and his ideas! I have enough for a beginning!

@masonreynoso3077 2 года назад

Was inordinately pleased to see Vervaeke in this. Please check out his "meaning crisis" series. I think about it every day and it inspires me to pursue my PhD. Edit: I was reminded that the series is called "Awakening from the Meaning Crisis."

@joyzenger6016 2 года назад

I WILL TY

@the300XM8 2 года назад

Go get it brother. God speed

@LC-pr5or 2 года назад

What is the meaning crisis series really? Why is it genius? Convince me to watch!

@laray7228 2 года назад

They’re great and pursue that PhD man!!

@Igor_lvanov 2 года назад

Vervaeke's Awakening from the meaning crisis and Peterson's Personalities and it's transformations are two most profound courses in my life

@evemacdonald8654 2 года назад

Thank you Bishop Barron, John Vervaeke, Jonathan Pageau and Jordan Peterson for this episode!!! Very much enjoyed it 😊

@rosawisteria Год назад

Bishop Barron is so awesome

@streamscounselling9501 2 года назад

John Vervaeke statement " How is science related to meaning and truth?" I think he nailed it right there. Thank you gentlemen for sharing your brains in collectivity. Mind candy for me to ponder on.

@donnmckee4973 2 года назад

Science never once claimed to relate to meaning and truth. Its defined as the intellectual and practical activity encompassing the systematic study of the structure and behaviour of the physical and natural world through observation and experiment. So when someone asks how science is related to meaning and truth they clearly don't know what science is.

@chaplainstudent5689 2 года назад

Science seeks truth. It may not always find it but is seeking it. If not, why qould anyone listen to them?

@donnmckee4973 2 года назад

@@chaplainstudent5689 the problem with the definition of truth is it has a couple different opinions: the quality or state of being true, what you might be talking about and a fact or belief that is accepted as true, which can be used by philosophy, religion, feelings, and prejudice. I think Oxford sums up scientific truth best. Scientific Truth is based on facts. Verified, reproducible facts are the bedrock of scientific truth. Each element of a theory corresponds to some part of nature and, in this sense, scientific theories describe nature. In a sense when science seeks truth it's really seeking verifier facts which is a higher standard compared to the common use of "truth". I understand it's just a use of words but plenty of scientist will be quick to make the distinction clear.

@NitwitMN 2 года назад

Discernment sometimes just arrives gloriously.

@tcl5853 2 года назад

@@donnmckee4973 Hmm, the scientific method cannot by design make claims concerning purpose or meaning. That’s true, but hasn’t prevented more than a few scientists from doing exactly that. It’s become the sole arbiter of truth in western societies. Still, I’m of the opinion that empiricism may be humanities most important invention. Or very close to it. What’s disturbing is how easily people accept philosophically, the materialist view of nature. It’s everywhere, the first thing you encounter in almost any discussion about meaning, purpose, or truth is the following: if you cannot prove your argument scientifically- it’s irrelevant. Without a thought, many in our society bow before the scientific method as the adjudicator of truth. There’s an old fashioned word for that- idolatry. Whether or not God exists, isn’t the point here. The point is that it’s probably never a good idea to handover our decision and thinking ability to - a human invention. Now that, is something to be concerned about.

@michaelraney 2 года назад

Thank you Bishop Barron for being a faithful representative of the Church!

@AngelBien 2 года назад

yassss!

@phillipnecessary6851 2 года назад

Amen, a gem

@mikefaber3567 2 года назад

I so appreciate the wisdom you all shared. And the humility and respect shown when there was some pushback that allowed the conversation to be productive. Also it's pretty obvious that the Bishop is not typical of a pastor or priest of any denomination. He seems to be exceptional in his realm.

@jmanderson84 2 года назад

I don’t think Jordan realizes how much he was the gateway drug to Christ for a lot of people. Wishing him and his family the best.

@unclebob2792 9 месяцев назад

hahah! you could have used a better phrase than gateway drug but i get you. JP is the reason a lot of people (including me) went back to God or strengthened their faith.

@RedBird77 2 года назад

These discussions are like healthy food for the soul. Enjoy them so much. Thanks to all for a fantastic discussion.

@tatsumakisempyukaku 2 года назад

Jesus said: “man should I not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceeds out of the mouth of God” Just as the good foods we eat become a part of us and so capacitate our bodies, so too do the ideas that fill our ears and reach our minds become a part of us. Be careful of what you ingest.

@jakubpogran 2 года назад

There was a question "Where to find the wisdom?".. I would say in the discussion of elders. Thank all of you for letting us to listen!

@NunYaO 2 года назад

AMEN! The world needs alot more of this! ((Even Christ would go to the Temple and LISTEN to Elders debate the Scriptures [e.g. the Educated and Wiser]

@Lerian_V 2 года назад

@@NunYaO Yes, scripture says he grew in wisdom.

@taranmurray7046 2 года назад

This is the council of elders. If the culture gets another few decades of occasional public discussion from the likes of these people, I think there is some cause for optimism. Let us fan the flames!! Also I would personally love it very much if Father Stephen Freeman could participate in something with these gentlemen.

@christopherramos161 2 года назад

Yes! Fr Stephen

@thecreator6480 2 года назад

I would love to see all of you guys weekly doing a podcast about different themes!!! Incredible EYE OPENING conversations, thanks for all this intelligent minds and the respect that each of you have for each other!

@the300XM8 2 года назад

As a huge fan of all 4 of them, philosophy graduate, catholic interested in orthodox tradition and a Jung reader. This is a dream come true. Thank you God

@erlendurk 2 года назад

I would thank Jordan Peterson. At least give the video thumbs up. God had nothing to do with it..

@TheClassicWorld 2 года назад

@@erlendurk To be fair, he also thanks Jordan and most likely did give the video a thumbs up (at least, you cannot assume that he didn't)...

@erlendurk 2 года назад

@@TheClassicWorld fair point.

@casandra0 2 года назад

@@erlendurk Thank God for Jordan Peterson, who has brought these three men to talk together on his channel 👀

@erlendurk 2 года назад

@@casandra0 Good one and I agree :) I'm an atheist but also thankful for JP.

@DerekJFiedler 2 года назад

This is a seminar panel that would normally cost $$$. So grateful that you all shared it with us as a free gift. Happy Thanksgiving.

@ToxicallyMasculinelol Год назад

Very interesting conversation, and I appreciate their bringing Bishop Barron on to challenge the symbolistic narratives. As a former consumer of psychedelics, I really feel for the bishop struggling to deal with this modern obsession with turning mundane neurological noise into an encounter with God. Not only is there no good evidence that psychedelic experiences are anything other than a temporary neurological handicap, but I think the very impulse to find divinity in them speaks (in harsh and disappointed tone) to our near-complete loss of supernatural language. We struggle to even conceive of the divine, the mystic, or the supernatural, in terms other than the materialistic, the reductionistic, the psychobabble. At best, we reduce it to a sublime psychological state characterized by elevated recognition of meaningful-but not supernatural-patterns. That may be satisfying to some people, but it leaves us in the same darkness, hurtling through the cosmos, as any other scientistic/naturalistic worldview. Frankly, the best antidote to this kind of medicalizing of God is to go study some miracle accounts. Whatever God is, he's certainly not a psychedelic experience, since there are well-documented people who could not walk, who could not see, or who would not even be alive, if God was just a psychedelic experience.

@jesh879 Год назад

Increases in neuroplasticity with psychedelics are well documented.

@mialmastaposeia 2 года назад

‘Part of what I see my task is to take the very best of science and answer all those challenges in a way that restores confidence in the hierarchies of intelligibility and the phenomenology of connectedness’ John you are in another dimension!

@kaellito 2 года назад

Jordan, a request. You can gather these 3 great minds 1 time a month, or 1 time every 2, 3 months. This debate was sensational. Thank you very much.

@kaellito 2 года назад

@@JAMWITCH Yeah sure. But no.

@ZeroSmoke. 2 года назад

@@JAMWITCH I can understand his mindset. A lot of churches are just garbage.

@Lerian_V 2 года назад

@@JAMWITCH Right. As the saying goes - I heard that from Bishop Barron - "an open mind is like an open mouth, it wants to bite down on something."

@kaellito 2 года назад

@@Lerian_V The funniest presumption is believing you know what I think is best. And Baron for me is the least interesting in this conversation.

@Lerian_V 2 года назад

@@kaellito It's funny that you presume that I presume to know what you think I best. I quoted Bishop Barron's speech ONLY for its relevance to what I was responding to, not for any other reason.

@conormartin2477 2 года назад

Would love Jordan to talk to John Lennox, would be a brilliant conversation!!

@146_kevinmathew5 2 года назад

Hoping for it soon...both great people

@jimboi2318 2 года назад

Yes Please! Just what I was thinking.

@isaiahfronning5157 2 года назад

Yes, and my second choice would be Douglas Wilson.

@WillEhrendreich 2 года назад

Oh I'm so on board with that!

@WillEhrendreich 2 года назад

@@brando3342 no doubt, Dr Peterson and Dr Craig were talking past each other on stage the last time. They are exceedingly different thinkers, and JP took what wlc was saying incorrectly I think.

@leo_olive 2 года назад

This was really good stuff. Growing a lot in my appreciation of Pageau.

@jeanlanz2344 2 года назад

Thank you, Bishop Barron, Jonathan, John and Jordan. Keep working together for truth. Integrating what is true, good, and beautiful benefits us all. God bless you.

@Jefrejtor 2 года назад

Weren't I prone on my couch upon seeing this notification, I would've been knocked flat on my ass. Jordan, you're a wonderful man, but you've made this podcast into something far greater than yourself.

@msg1192 2 года назад

This reminds me of something CS Lewis Williams, Barfield and Tolkien would have loved. Although not rooted in fiction, the depth and content of the conversation is something that the inklings would have gladly indulged in.

@benjamMin278 Год назад

Wow. Good thought! 😊

@ChrisOgunlowo 2 года назад

A terrific conversation. One must first acknowledge Jordan's remarkable ability to moderate high level conversations. One almost assumes that, given the differences in their backgrounds and approaches towards truth/meaning, things might get daunting or tedious at some point. But they've been far illuminating and enjoyable than one could imagine. And Jordan meanders through it all with such effortlessness. It's a gift, Jordan, a charming gift. As I write this, my mind conjures Rapheal's fresco - The School of Athens. This seems like its modern incarnation, of brilliant minds taking on some of the hard themes of life - and simplifying them. We don't know how all of these would eventually play out, or the extent of the impact. The four of you - as in the other horsemen of atheism, are yinging-and-yanging, choasing-and-ordering, in ways that ennoble our human experience and our understanding of reality and Being. For me, without necessarily comparing, the horsemen of meaning take the cake for coming to the discussion table with such grace, humility, fidelity to truth and love! Thank you, gentlemen.

@psychsoulogy8018 2 года назад

Dear Sir Jordan I might not know what had happened to you, but I am very sure that your chance of life right now is more meaningful and purposeful. You are here to inspire more of us humans who wanted to know TRUTH I will be indebted. I do really admire you by being not bias and having real grounds that made your feet really attached on it and how you are so focused and a very well composed person! I Love you Sir. You deserved to be loved in return!!! More Health, More Life, More Wisdom for you Sir and to all your love one's..

@NitwitMN 2 года назад

You fellas have to get together OVER AND OVER! You manage to make one another at the top of each of your perspectives. This conversation sparkled. Gonna prolly replay several times. Grateful

@martinjoseferreyra1961 2 года назад

absolutely!!

@haydenlukas7447 2 года назад

This is a dab on all the 2008 era atheists. Love it guys. Thank you all so much. Especially Jonathan. Grateful to God for you.

@wrenlinwhitelight3007 2 года назад

In my country, all our churches are empty and turned into homeless shelters. Atheism is strong in many parts of the world.

@sonicnarutoTDpg 2 года назад

@@wrenlinwhitelight3007 you haven’t been paying attention

@pritam452 2 года назад

@@wrenlinwhitelight3007 Which country are you from?

@haydenlukas7447 2 года назад

@@wrenlinwhitelight3007sounds terrible. I hope you guys can figure yourselves out.

@mapaz555 2 года назад

Bishop Barron is like a cascade of knowledge and inspiration to me & Jordan Peterson is someone searching and seeking that I hope reaches higher & higher each time. I wish for him the warmth and peacefulness of resting on the arms of God as his child. Cherished, I hope you feel cherished.

@edybrasfield1345 5 месяцев назад

I am immensely grateful for tuning into your conversation today. Thanks for make your wisdom available to us. With all my admiration respect , and gratitude 🙏 ❤ thank you.

@funkyboy_22 2 года назад

This is such a wonderful early Christmas present given to us by Dr. Peterson! I cannot believe a discussion as juicy as this has actually occurred. I’m really going to enjoy this one, thank you!

@Remy.- 2 года назад

mate its november

@ashleynikolenko 2 года назад

@@Remy.- and it’s the Christmas season! Advent began days ago! 😉

@renx81 2 года назад

@@ashleynikolenko Ugh, cringe

@funkyboy_22 2 года назад

@@Remy.- Mate, its literally 6 days away from December. Learn how to use a calendar.

@funkyboy_22 2 года назад

@@renx81 Why are you such a buzzkill?

@milesmungo 2 года назад

This feels like a movie premiere... LET'S GOOOOOOO!!!

@EfrainOrtega-Tio 2 года назад

In my own opinion, Jonathan and Bishop Barron were more calm with this Discussion Sharing. Thanks God for this great minds !

@randumgaming 2 года назад

This was an extremely fascinating and exciting conversation that I'm very happy to be a part of as a viewer, and I genuinely hope this happens again. I really do pray that John Vervaeke is able to get some healing from the terrible experiences of his past, and perhaps by sitting so personally with 2 heavily religious men, and with you Jordan who appears to be traveling rapidly down a beautiful and rich religious path, that he might be starting that healing process by all of the influences here.

@celladoor_uk 2 года назад

When I was a teenager, around 15, and still in high school, I remember repeatedly getting this intrusive thought. It kept telling me that although we lived in material abundance we were living in spiritual poverty. I think this conversation has really helped me to understand exactly what that voice was saying to me back then. Thank you for sharing this conversation with us.

@thesapphire_standard7534 2 года назад

Read Jesus' words to the Laodicean church in the book of Revelation (Rev. 3 14-22). Then I would appreciate if you comment what you thought.

@celladoor_uk 2 года назад

@@thesapphire_standard7534 I have read it and I found it incredibly interesting, as I find most words from the bible, but I honestly don't have much to offer. Maybe I have to think about it a little more. I appreciate you sending me the reference to this passage though. :)

@bryant475 2 года назад

@@celladoor_uk I'm confident that this was God reaching out to you! Please check out lectures by Dr. Frank Turek, Dr. Hugh Ross, Dr. William Lane Craig for more about the evidence for why Christianity is True :)

@cindyrobertson3798 2 года назад

I too had a very early adult view of the value of life the serioseness of our contributions. I never got drunk or smoked po a a result my early revelation s I'm ur my experience was different than you but suicide of a friend in 9 th grade ha a profund afect. God bless you in your life quest.

@celladoor_uk 2 года назад

@@cindyrobertson3798 I smoked, drank, did drugs. I still smoke weed every day but I have been moving away from pretty much all other substances. I think, eventually, I won't smoke weed either. I am still not sure if god cares about these things are not, I know he just wants me to live truthfully, I'm still figuring out what that looks like. I don't want to stop something just because god wants me to, I want to stop something once I understand exactly why god wants me to, otherwise I am just virtue signalling and if I have learned one thing about my god, he does not like virtue signalling.

@tcl5853 2 года назад

As a viewer, I experienced the difference between seeing a horse at a distance, beautiful and pregnant with possibilities. And what it’s like to jump in the saddle and feel the power, the breath, and the risk rider and horse take together. Nothing is gained or lost when you keep your distance, but in the saddle, the possibilities are endless.

@BrotherLaymanPaul 2 года назад

Well put. Four smart men, but two of them seem a bit afraid to jump in the psychedelic saddle (*wink wink*) and try to ride the thing. They also seem to know a lot about what god thinks and wants of us. Never forget: reality does not require our belief in order for it to exist.

@suzangrant7656 2 года назад

Well said TCL. They did didn't they? They ALL got stuck in! Never seen Bishop Barron before, loved his transparency. Their respect for each other was admirable, solid. Am looking forward to another.

@TheLibran1 2 года назад

@@BrotherLaymanPaul As someone who had done meditation, ritual and visionary work entirely apart from any drug use for years (not even casual). I can say that having started spaced out experimentation over past 4 years has shown me directly psychedelics can improve, support, but not replace "intentional mysticism" that is bootstrapped through cognition & internal effort. Inotherwords strictly speaking I dont think its necessary for a religious person to use psychedelics if they use the tried & true methods of mysticism of whatever trad which has self-supporting mechanisms. (A core text, initiations, cyclical practices, a community of practictioners, realizers of the results of the practice) But they may benefit, or may not - its really too variable. Whereas those who use psychedelics or any drugs I CERTAINLY suggest they take up the basics of meditation such as rythymic breathing, thought watching, body awareness, mantra/chanting. (Picking from whatever tradition at will)

@MrCmon113 2 года назад

@@BrotherLaymanPaul >Well put. No, it was extreme cringe. A horse pregnant with possibilities? You know a bad writer by their mixed metaphors.

@tcl5853 2 года назад

@@MrCmon113 Well, I suppose we fall into different categories. Yep, I need to brush up on my writing skills. And you, well, perhaps it’s possible that you may not actually be, an insufferable asshole. Only time will tell, but I’m optimistic - there may be hope for both of us.

@DoctorLazertron Год назад

Pageau and Vervaeke are always intense and speak at such a high level. I love that Bishop Barron can keep up and add a lot to the conversation using mainly normal-people words. His responses kind of help me deduce what the others mean by what they say too.

@rapidlyrap 2 года назад

Mr. Peterson, thank you for this program and bringing together these most influential and purposeful thinkers. We all must find a way to save the hearts and minds and souls of people that have lost their meaning and deep purpose in life.

@marywellssmitharnp-c6667 2 года назад

I am about to begin my third listening of this conversation. I’m thoroughly convinced these are some of the most important public discussions being had in the Western world, and that the next generation-whatever paths they choose-will have to contend with the reality that this caliber of thinking and cordiality of debate was accessible to them.

@classycompositions932 2 года назад

After the last session with John Vervaeke I became a big fan of his, hearing his cognitive science and philosophical explanation of things really takes your understanding to another level. Really interested to see how it combines with Petersons psychological and Jonathan/Barron religios expertise, especially when it comes to meaning making.

@mitchellhahn 2 года назад

I’d like to 2nd the motion of checking out Vervake’s “Awakening From The Meaning Crisis” lecture series

@classycompositions932 2 года назад

@@Joeonline26 I have, just the episode with JP was not nearly enough to understand all of his idea's, it was just the tip of the iceberg.

@classycompositions932 2 года назад

@@Joeonline26 It is indeed a lot of material, and also: althought his ideas are as great as JP's, they are slightly more theoretical or 'dry'. (And of course almost noone has JP's charisma and eloquince.)

@Lerian_V 2 года назад

Isn't it simply amazing that all truths about reality when expertly laid out, they cohere in a beautiful way. One more evidence that all truths about reality come from a single mind, the one eternal mind of God.

@majojok 2 года назад

@@Joeonline26 I think it was this comment that in January got me to start Vervaeke's lecture series, just finished it and wanted to thank you for playing a non-insignificant role in transforming my life for the better.

@timspurr381 2 года назад

Wonderful talk. Thank you all. I think the whole thing is best summed up by JP's line: "Newton wrote more about alchemy than he did about physics."

@irenegewinner8193 2 года назад

I love how Johnathan described the interactive experience of the Mass. The two concepts of the logical understanding of Christ and the actual experience of the Eucharist come together during the Mass.

@brycemannn4847 2 года назад

Man I seriously love everything that bishop Barron does. He seems to understand religious history/theology better than anyone I’ve ever heard. He also sounds like he’s fallen in love with it. You can hear his worship

@bigwig594 2 года назад

Watch Church Militant

@wmhs02dm 2 года назад

A truly unique priest

@ms.leclaire9017 2 года назад

Well said! He is fully in love with sharing what he's learned. His ability to enter any conversation and express the faith is amazing. He takes be not afraid to a new level!

@lcrcastro6966 2 года назад

I could not agree more! Bishop Barron has been a warm light for so many questions.

@the2ndcoming135 2 года назад

🥇

@sams8502 2 года назад

As a graduate of a top university working in tech, the amount of intellectual firepower and just wisdom in this conversation is astounding. The layers to peel and the assumptions challenged. Everything is on the cutting edge, philosophy-religion-science-consciousness and there aren't new ideas but there are new connections that just push wisdom forward.

@sams8502 2 года назад

@Kiwi ConnoisseurMy point is that I’m surrounded by the smartest people and I’m floored by the level of intellect these individuals have.

@dom7590 2 года назад

This video is a great example of what an intellectual discussion should be.

@JSMI Год назад

Thanks to all 4 horsemen who participated in this educational video. I appreciated listening to this episode multiple times. Thank you.

@elporteroful 2 года назад

Finally! Bishop Barron mentioned this conversation TWO MONTHS AGO in one of his videos and I've been waiting for it since!

@RoshiR 2 года назад

This was completely incredible. So proud of Dr. Peterson for leading the wisdom movement. We are all right behind you thinking through these beautifully complex social issues. God bless you all. It's a wonderful day to be alive!