Тёмный

The Ancient World’s Ingenious Ice Making Air Conditioning System 

Today I Found Out
Подписаться 3,2 млн
Просмотров 447 тыс.
50% 1

Dive into the past to secure our future! Discover how ancient Persians beat the heat without electricity. Witness the revival of wind catchers in modern architecture!
Love content? Check out our other RU-vid Channels:
Higher Learning: / @higherlearningflight
Flick Facts: / @flickfacts
Fact Quikie: / @factquickie
Ancient Marvels: / @ancient-marvels
Origins: / @originsofeverything
Warographics: / @warographics643
MegaProjects: / @megaprojects9649
SideProjects: / @sideprojects
Into The Shadows: / intotheshadows
Highlight History: / @highlighthistory
Brain Blaze: / @brainblaze6526
Casual Criminalist: / thecasualcriminalist
Decoding the Unknown: / @decodingtheunknown2373
Places: / @places302
Astrographics: / @astrographics-ve4yq
→Some of our favorites: • Featured
→Subscribe for new videos every day!
ru-vid.com...

Опубликовано:

 

2 апр 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 865   
@TodayIFoundOut
@TodayIFoundOut Месяц назад
This video brought to you in part by our Patrons over on Patreon. If you’d like to support our efforts here directly, and our continued efforts to improve our videos, as well as do more ultra in-depth long form videos that built in ads and even sponsors don’t always cover fully, check out our Patreon page and perks here: www.patreon.com/TodayIFoundOut And as ever, thanks for watching!
@Bozemanjustin
@Bozemanjustin Месяц назад
It amazes me that people still build above the ground below the ground. It stays the same temperature year round. You'll never deal with a hot summer. You'll never deal with a cold winter. You'll never deal with a tornado. You'll never deal with a hurricane It's not rocket science people
@stephennewberry9815
@stephennewberry9815 Месяц назад
Do you accept submissions for video scrips?
@dainbramage3558
@dainbramage3558 Месяц назад
if i pay you money on patreon will you stop using the flickering screen effect thing on all your archive footage?
@pedrobedoy9574
@pedrobedoy9574 Месяц назад
No computers needed😂🎉
@tommyherring9635
@tommyherring9635 Месяц назад
Interesting topic, but I had to click off early because you’re talking too fast to fully comprehend and process what you’re saying! You’re not alone; many presenters today do the same thing….I guess it’s just the way of the day?! I believe that there could be much gained from letting your audience know that you care enough about your subject (and their understanding of it) to take your time, and make sure that your message is fully heard and received by all who are listening?!
@wortwortwort117
@wortwortwort117 Месяц назад
I learned about this in school for HVAC. Theres alot more ancient methods of air-conditioning that are really neat for those interested
@lijohnyoutube101
@lijohnyoutube101 Месяц назад
Someone is going to get insanely wealthy bringing back a lot of these technologies.
@JohanHultin
@JohanHultin Месяц назад
@@lijohnyoutube101no, evaporative cooling doesnt work well in humud areas, obviously. And most citites where people live, most not all, are in areas where humidity is relativley high. Notice how he only talk about desert areas? The one place these things work well.
@daackmpoy
@daackmpoy Месяц назад
​@JohanHultin by controlling humidity you can control temperature and hear transfer, that's what comfort is. Look for a psychometric chart, it's very interesting
@pan2aja
@pan2aja Месяц назад
any youtube channel to recommend on this HVAC issue ?
@lijohnyoutube101
@lijohnyoutube101 Месяц назад
@@JohanHultin I wasn’t just speaking to evaporation cooling. I mean incorporating more eco ways to heat and cool in general.
@PhantomFilmAustralia
@PhantomFilmAustralia Месяц назад
"Sand, clay, lime, wood ash, goat hair, and egg whites. I think this will work."
@catatonicbug7522
@catatonicbug7522 Месяц назад
I can just see the guy slap the wall with his hand and say, "That's not goin' anywhere!"
@Couchintheclouds
@Couchintheclouds Месяц назад
Just imagine the number of failed experiments they had before they came up with a working mix…..lol
@shawntailor5485
@shawntailor5485 Месяц назад
Must've been ostrich egss
@stevelee5724
@stevelee5724 Месяц назад
Yea I reckon. Chuck it in 😅 home brew's a bit like that.....
@mr.joshua6818
@mr.joshua6818 Месяц назад
I wonder if they tried using other stuff from the goats first...​@@Couchintheclouds
@jonathanwessner3456
@jonathanwessner3456 Месяц назад
I know way back in the 1990's/early 2000's, they built a mall out in Nevada with one of these windcatchers. it could drop the temp of the whole mall to 58 degrees in 90 degree heat
@cameronhermann9400
@cameronhermann9400 Месяц назад
Wow
@kishascape
@kishascape Месяц назад
Yeah if you make an evaporative cooling one that’s basically just a natural swamp cooler instead of just relying on wind. Zion National Park in Utah also has one in the visitor center. Hot 95 degree nights have never felt so cool.
@troyezell5841
@troyezell5841 21 день назад
These are on viable and safe in dry climates; in moist damp climates you run the risk of spreading mold spores throughout the structure.
@hlessiavedon
@hlessiavedon 10 дней назад
​@troyezell5841 dry air spreads mold spores too. You are constantly surrounded by mold and it's spores
@troyezell5841
@troyezell5841 10 дней назад
@@hlessiavedon I certainly agree but not near as much and because those climates tend to be exposed to longer duration ultraviolet rays, mold does not propagate as well.
@leej.a.7810
@leej.a.7810 Месяц назад
2:48 'The taller the shaft, the more pronounced the effect.' Doth, she said thusly!
@Jasmohan
@Jasmohan Месяц назад
Verily, Michael Scott wouldst beam with pride.
@matthewmorgan5068
@matthewmorgan5068 Месяц назад
🤣🤣🤣🤣
@peterswires8439
@peterswires8439 8 дней назад
In the UK we'd say, "...as the actress said to the bishop".
@tyramasters-heinrichs921
@tyramasters-heinrichs921 Месяц назад
There was a lady who lived in an 1800s house in Georgia; her house was well maintained, and did not have air conditioning, yet was cool. You see there used to be a central tower design that was blocked off in winter (is it really winter when they rarely get snow? I live in Canada, lol) Each room has has 'window' atop the tall door, in the overly high rooms, and there is under house cooling; plus large verandas; the place never became too hot in summer, and once shifted to 'winter' was efficient to heat thanks to modern wood stove designs. I've been in older homes here in Manitoba, Canada, and I'm always amazed at the care and thinking that went into everything from where the house is placed, windows, roofs, tree plantings, everything for efficiency...funny how we lost that.
@jussikankinen9409
@jussikankinen9409 Месяц назад
Plastic houses dont last 50 years
@will7its
@will7its Месяц назад
@@jussikankinen9409 Junk.....
@will7its
@will7its Месяц назад
Not funny maybe......
@donutchan8114
@donutchan8114 Месяц назад
I imagine in the short term its cheaper to slap a ton of cookie cutter homes with "modern technology" rather than looking back and using what worked thousands of years before.
@NurmaBP
@NurmaBP 19 дней назад
Sadly it's expensive to build house like that now, since the house prices is crazy in US. A tiny proper fabricated mobile home in average cost 200k, not including land
@patrickdurham8393
@patrickdurham8393 Месяц назад
Evaporative cooling does not work in the Southern United States when the air is so thick with moisture you have to cut it with a knife before you can breathe it.
@beth8775
@beth8775 13 дней назад
Evaporative cooling no, but the subterranean cooling can.
@annekabrimhall1059
@annekabrimhall1059 11 дней назад
It’s perfect in the southwest
@SB-cm9jh
@SB-cm9jh 10 дней назад
...this video isn't about the southern U.S., nor similar climates.
@harryverner6218
@harryverner6218 10 дней назад
The water from air would turn to water in basement & go into the earth
@Dante.-
@Dante.- 9 дней назад
@@SB-cm9jhit partly is 😂 It used the United States as its example of why we need better cooling systems
@nolakillabeast
@nolakillabeast Месяц назад
You know you are getting older when this is the highlight of your daily media consumption
@jtb3797
@jtb3797 Месяц назад
Not older, wiser and more curious!!
@unskinnedskeleton
@unskinnedskeleton Месяц назад
this is accurate. if I may add, you know you're getting old when you want to iterate that getting older is okay.
@Loralanthalas
@Loralanthalas Месяц назад
Nope. Just a dork. I was just as excited to eatch documentaries before the History channel decided our entire history is aliens.
@nolakillabeast
@nolakillabeast Месяц назад
Guys, we are ok, we are ok.
@chrisheitstuman6360
@chrisheitstuman6360 Месяц назад
I don't know about older, but it's content that isn't either imbicilic or depressing, like the news.
@ScottPlude
@ScottPlude Месяц назад
I live in the desert. The amount of energy used to stay alive and comfortable is mind numbing. I constantly worry about power outages and equipment failure. Either of these events is life threatening. This video makes the light bulb turn on over my head!
@Deyas786
@Deyas786 Месяц назад
That sucks, why don't you move??
@ScottPlude
@ScottPlude Месяц назад
@@Deyas786family, job.
@justincase3230
@justincase3230 Месяц назад
Should look up oljas. Bare fired clay water jugs, the water seeping through and evaporating off the clay cools the whole water dish. Gets it somewhere between room temp and fresh out the fridge. Farming communities used to cut huge chunks of ice out of lakes in winter and pack them into a fuckton of packed sawdust then dig out the ice to use periodically through summer. You can do similar with a broken down chest freezer and a bunch of 2 litre soda bottles full of ice. Couple minutes a week to swap out bottles and you should be good for a while if the power goes out. A full freezer is more efficient too so keeping spare room filled with ice bottles is always good. Another one is a couple solar powered PC fans, a hunk of ice and some holes cut in a drink cooler can make a pretty great portable aircon. There's tutorials all over the place for building them. I live in Australia, not quite as bad as desert living but God damn summer gets brutal and I'm a broke bitch lol.
@EmmanuelBrito
@EmmanuelBrito Месяц назад
Thanks for the info
@Abby_Liu
@Abby_Liu Месяц назад
​@@Deyas786because every person has the resources and ability to move to wherever they want to, of course, and otherwise where they current live is perfect.
@aq5426
@aq5426 Месяц назад
My mom did something similar to this when I was little--she'd open the upstairs windows early in the morning on days when there was a stiff breeze, and let it cool the house before closing the windows on the side opposite the wind so that cool air would come up from the basement.
@JustinRevis
@JustinRevis Месяц назад
My dad does the same things. Crazy how that worked.
@origGooglieWooglie
@origGooglieWooglie Месяц назад
We still do that!
@NothingXemnas
@NothingXemnas Месяц назад
Even though I live in a single floor house, the idea of heat battery works marvelously well by sleeping with all windows open and keeping an electric fan pointed towards one of the house's windows if there is no wind. Airflow is low, but over several hours, it does cool the house until around 8AM. Then I close all windows, keeping the heat out. Living without an AC sucks, but this makes it manageable.
@larsonfamilyhouse
@larsonfamilyhouse 14 дней назад
Using a fan to blow out the hot air sucks in the cool air even better!
@ZeroGamersX
@ZeroGamersX 14 дней назад
@@NothingXemnas try making the fan a bit away from the window, look up bernouli’s principle it might remove the hot air in the house even faster!
@swj719
@swj719 Месяц назад
Evaporative cooling really only works in low humidity environments. The drier the air, the faster/more efficiently the water will evaporate, so the more efficiently heat will get pulled out of the air. This means, sadly, that they don't work very well in places like the southeastern United States, where summer is also very, very humid. They work, but not nearly are well. There's a whole formula that will tell you how much cooling you can get per unit of air moved over a wet/damp membrane.
@keith38able
@keith38able Месяц назад
Evap. cooling didn't/doesn't work at all for me in Oklahoma.
@Skywatcher16
@Skywatcher16 Месяц назад
@@keith38able pheonix and las vegas could probably benifit from incorporation of these ideas though. as could a good chunk of socal
@TonkarzOfSolSystem
@TonkarzOfSolSystem Месяц назад
These systems also use radiative cooling which will work anywhere regardless of humidity (though clouds and rain will overshadow radiative cooling effects. Radiative cooling uses large shallow pools of water. At night when the sky is clear the water will radiate a significant amount of heat. This can cause it to freeze even on nights where the ambient temperature is above zero. Before dawn workers cut up the ice sheet and store the ice in an ice house. With modern insulation materials an even more pronounced drop in temperature is possible.
@johnsyler8580
@johnsyler8580 Месяц назад
I lived in western Oklahoma in the 80s. Evaporative coolers were common then. Later we lived in El Paso TX while stationed at Ft Bliss and had Evaporative cooling in our housing. I like it better than freon air conditioning. ​@keith38able
@rb-pk8ds
@rb-pk8ds Месяц назад
We have a fan forced evaporative cooler on our roof in Australia - when its hot & dry we run it with water dripping over the intake vents ... when its hot & steamy we turn off the water & use the humidity. It works a treat & costs very little to run.
@Bunker278
@Bunker278 Месяц назад
Me, in Utah: "Wind catchers would definitely work here." Simon: *Mentions a visitor's center in Southern Utah using one.*
@kishascape
@kishascape Месяц назад
Those aren’t wind catchers though they are evaporative cooling towers and even the ancient Arabian ones used water evaporation as well instead of just wind alone. Fad boy really missed the mark on this one.
@piccalillipit9211
@piccalillipit9211 Месяц назад
*I LIVE IN A COMMI BLOCK* in Bulgaria - it has a wind catcher on the roof for passive cooling in the 40c summers - its VERY effective. A giant scoop catches the wind and funnels it down to the bottom of the building, it then cools and comes up the service riser with the cold water pipes and out a vent in the centre of the apartment. Large metal plates over greats outside regulate the pressure - too much wint they lift up. This is not normal for commi blocks - I think it was experimental. BUT IT WORKS ---> Our apartment block has 90 apartments maybe 15 have AC units - most blocks that would be 70 with AC units.
@buisnessclass9520
@buisnessclass9520 21 день назад
Evaporative cooling works in dry climates. Not effective in humid air found in tropical countries
@bobwolfley2449
@bobwolfley2449 Месяц назад
Im in Florida and due to high humidity evaporated cooling does not work here
@floridaboiwoody
@floridaboiwoody Месяц назад
Exactly. I see guys with the old "swamp coolers" on their classic cars at shows here and although it looks nostalgic evaporative coolers just don't work in Florida lol.
@marktg98
@marktg98 Месяц назад
Still, if this could be implemented everywhere where the humidity is below a certain average, it could save huge amounts of power.
@swj719
@swj719 Месяц назад
​@@marktg98sadly, in the US you're limited to basically the states to the east or the Rockies, and the southwest. Which happens to be most of our lower population states.
@user-ri5fe7ti6i
@user-ri5fe7ti6i Месяц назад
And your governor is practically making alternative energy generation illegal while removing all mention of climate change from all government departments.
@DESTRUCTOR122
@DESTRUCTOR122 Месяц назад
They don’t work in coastal Virginia either. We sit around 90% humidity during the spring and summer
@jimmy21584
@jimmy21584 Месяц назад
The physics behind ancient radiative sky cooling is fascinating - using space as a massive heat sink to make ice in the desert.
@jussikankinen9409
@jussikankinen9409 Месяц назад
Maybe pyramids were ice houses
@fredrichenning1367
@fredrichenning1367 Месяц назад
Drawing outside air down underground and then up in the house for cooling is a system also used on the island of Madeira.
@falleruen
@falleruen 14 дней назад
I just hope local municipal governments will allow zoning for these new/ancient technology
@justsoicanfingcomment5814
@justsoicanfingcomment5814 День назад
They do. You just have to pay more in taxes.
@ColinMcMahon1337
@ColinMcMahon1337 Месяц назад
Idk if I'm getting slower or your speech is getting faster :/
@ruidadgmailcanada8508
@ruidadgmailcanada8508 24 дня назад
Same. I usually watch everything at 1.5x speed and up. Not this video. 😅
@mr.yellowstrat3352
@mr.yellowstrat3352 24 дня назад
After years of reading scripts that someone else wrote he's probably just trying to get through them all as fast as possible at this point
@_Solaris
@_Solaris 23 дня назад
The editing cuts are _way_ too short, with no natural breathing pauses. Too many channels are doing this now. Gotta say, it's getting annoying.
@Brunos2Costa
@Brunos2Costa 23 дня назад
Had to go back many times to keep up.
@celticstephenhill
@celticstephenhill 22 дня назад
Yeah. Ditto. Can't watch on ff anymore, even 1.5 is WAY too fast to understand.
@XSR_RUGGER
@XSR_RUGGER Месяц назад
My home was built in 1940 and it has a whole house fan. Being originally from Michigan, I'd never even heard of one as summers rarely required more than a window fan to keep cool or at least cool enough to be relatively comfortable. Our hvac unit went out the second year after we bought the home and I grew up heating our home with wood. The house has 2 fireplaces and so I made a fire in each and thought, "I'll use the W.H. fan to draw heat into the middle of the home. Well, it drew more than heat as all the smoke from the fires can't back down the chimneys and into the house😂. It also pulled any unlatched door open or closed depending on the direction it swung. I didn't realize it moved that much air! It wasn't viable for heating but that summer in SC I opened the basement door (which I found out is a rarity here apparently) and turned the fan on and man it kept us cool enough. At night I'd open the windows and let it run. Was it as cool as AC? No. It was cool enough to keep us from sweating our butts off or potentially having dangerously high temps in the home.
@sernathadd
@sernathadd Месяц назад
HVAC back then was crazy
@yeti4269
@yeti4269 Месяц назад
I'm just trying to imagine what an ancient Persian owner of an HVAC company would look like 🤣
@BMichaelGalloway
@BMichaelGalloway Месяц назад
😂😂😂
@will7its
@will7its Месяц назад
Was it really crazy ?
@simondymond8479
@simondymond8479 Месяц назад
I sometimes go to Turkey on holiday. One place has a dining hall using a similar principle and it is quite incredible how effective it is.
@ihaveabanana482
@ihaveabanana482 9 дней назад
Could you name the place maybe ?
@ericbartol
@ericbartol Месяц назад
This is where Frank Herbert got the idea for the Fremen 'wind traps' in his novel, "Dune." This is my first contact with this concept, but the "Dune" reference is unmistakable. The novel is filled with many historical references just slightly tweaked and brought together very well. No wonder it won a Hugo Award.
@brycemooreguitar
@brycemooreguitar Месяц назад
Right I was thinking the same thing!
@ericbartol
@ericbartol Месяц назад
@@brycemooreguitar It is a tremendously long novel, but I will have to re-read it again this year, I think. It has so many facets that it is almost always fascinating.
@brycemooreguitar
@brycemooreguitar Месяц назад
@@ericbartol it's absolutely worth a re read, I'm on my second time through the entire series, although I listen on audible so it makes it alot easier as I can listen while I work, and drive. But it's definitely one of my favorite science fiction series. I realize another layer to the stories the second time through.
@wow1371
@wow1371 12 дней назад
A lot of elements in Dune even outside of the Fremen and the planet dune is taken from Iranian ideology. Mahdi is almost exclusively Persian islam as it is a concept exclusive to 12 imam Shia muslims which is a sect that was born in Iran and is the biggest shia sect. The emperor's title is Padishah which is a persian word meaning great king. Lisan al gaib is arabic for "hidden tongue". This specific title I have not seen given to anyone else in the world except Hafiz who was an Iranian Poet from Shiraz whose poems are revered as a part of Iranian mysticism. And funnily enough people consider his poems prophetic and read his peoms as a sort of prophecy to their specific questions. Like I would ask "is it wise to pursue this specific endeavour" and randomly open the book and read the poem that comes up and that poem would be my answer. Or words like selamalik which is a word with origin in Arabic but almost exclusively used in Persian and Turkish speaking countries for hello. The name for Chani's tribe's Soldiers. Fadayikin is made up of a persian and an english word. Fadayi means the thing to be sacrificed, in this case a person. Fun fact, in 20th century there were two terrorist parties called Fadayian as they focused on assassinations of government officials, one was communist, the other muslim fundamentalist. The flag of Fremen is an eagle with outstretched wings, very similar to the Achaemenid eagle flag. There is also a good chunk of influences from Turkish language. It is very interesting in general.
@TrogdorBurnin8or
@TrogdorBurnin8or Месяц назад
This didn't make a whole lot of sense when I first came across the topic ten or fifteen years ago on Wikipedia. The Iran-focused people didn't grasp the thermodynamics and the engineering-focused people didn't grasp Iran's historical application. I think the problem is that we forget we're discussing a half dozen fundamentally different passive HVAC systems that do very different things with temperature, humidity, airflow, and thermal mass. There are qanats that act as swamp coolers, there are municipal ice houses that act like seasonal iceboxes and may not even have any airflow, there are windcatchers that just equalize day-night average temperature (which can be extremely effective in deserts) or summer-winter average temperature.
@ClaytonDeeringC3D
@ClaytonDeeringC3D Месяц назад
That’s how they had cold beer in ww2.
@maverick7291
@maverick7291 Месяц назад
That is a pretty cool innovation from the Persians.
@dexterwilliams4289
@dexterwilliams4289 14 дней назад
It’s on our blood
@Adolphsson
@Adolphsson Месяц назад
I wonder if there is a connection between windcatchers and why we call the attic for wind in Scandinavia. The longhouses from the medieval warm period had an opening just below the roof called "vindöga". A literal translation would be wind eye (the word later became window in English). I've read that the opening was used to let the sunlight in or let the smoke from a fire out, but it's a curious connection.
@jussikankinen9409
@jussikankinen9409 Месяц назад
Sun is eye
@amacot656
@amacot656 Месяц назад
We are so quick to ignore and forget the olds ways of things... Yet they solved similar issues without the same level of technology
@markbroad119
@markbroad119 Месяц назад
People are more in tune with mother Earth and nature then. We need to get back to it.
@Skywatcher16
@Skywatcher16 Месяц назад
@@markbroad119 id argue that its more neccessity being the mother of invention. very similar to how early programming tricks were used to make use of the much lower storage/processing capacity. you can only use what resources you have, so you find tricks and short cuts to maximize those resources. conversely, today, things that programmers past might have squeezed into mere kilobytes of storage, take up megabytes because well, they have terrabytes to work with. why bother making things efficient when sheer data capacity and raw processing power can brute force any inefficiency into better performance than the 1980s could have ever dreamed? same goes for this. when you have "abundant" power, and cheap modern machinery, why bother with the effort and time to improve efficency when you can use that same brute force and abundance to make up for any loss in the move away from traditional techniques? you can even see the argument in why suddenly the attention on these things is back. suddenly, that power and machinery isnt so "cheap" or "abundant" anymore. theres more value to be had again in finding ways to make what one has go further. and so, once again, that effort in taking advantage of these natural principles is worth peoples time and energy.
@ZeroHourProductions407
@ZeroHourProductions407 Месяц назад
This aint going to work in an apartment complex. Or when it gets hot enough that your phone will shut down, whinging about overheating.
@Skywatcher16
@Skywatcher16 Месяц назад
@@ZeroHourProductions407 and why wont it work for apartments, my good HVAC tech?
@ZeroHourProductions407
@ZeroHourProductions407 Месяц назад
@@Skywatcher16 for one, nobody has built an apartment complex with a basement since ever. Secondly, everyone or nobody can vent to get the benefits.
@zackmassey8258
@zackmassey8258 4 дня назад
Damn. Great work. That was some of the best fighting choreography I've seen. Be proud of yourselves. You all knocked it out of the park.
@korinogaro
@korinogaro Месяц назад
Companies will make sure to make any such solution so expensive it will be comparable in price with "traditional" electric systems.
@KimiAvary
@KimiAvary 4 дня назад
I learn something new every time I listen to you! Thank you for sharing your interests with the world!!!
@ocsrc
@ocsrc Месяц назад
The desert dwellers dug tunnels and used them for cooling and to keep cool in the summer The temperature underground is 60 degrees in the summer
@Striker9
@Striker9 Месяц назад
You're telling me, i didnt have to suffer as a kid when dad wouldnt turn on the air conditioner until it hit 100 degrees?! I just needed ancient technologies?! And wind!? 😅
@ericbartol
@ericbartol Месяц назад
If you pause at 1:26, I find that architectural accent at the entrance absolutely astounding!
@raymondmartin6737
@raymondmartin6737 Месяц назад
I remember living in Phoenix AZ in 1976 where the older houses had an earlier form of AC called Swamp Coolers. 😊
@chrisbarriere101
@chrisbarriere101 Месяц назад
Hey, so I am an HVACR / AC inspector, Thanks for highlighting this issue. Yaktchals and Wind Catchers have been an inspiration to me for years. You would be surprised to learn that Catalonian Architecture has absorbed this design. However many found here in Santa Barbara have been made as entirely stylistic. Very strange…
@jon9103
@jon9103 Месяц назад
I suspect most of the arictect designing those structures don't know what the original function was, let alone how to design it to be functional.
@GregMerritt-ws8tq
@GregMerritt-ws8tq Месяц назад
I imagine, with recent advances in engineering, we'll be able to figure out how make maintenance of windcatches easier fairly soon.
@Itchyknee88
@Itchyknee88 Месяц назад
This is awesome! I love learning about ancient technologies that are genuinely impressive, even by today standards.
@Blitzcomin
@Blitzcomin 18 дней назад
There is 1 problem with attempting to introduce this into everyone's homes.... the middle of city's have 0 wind cause all the outer rings block it. As a city expands the new ones nullify the old ones by blocking the wind.
@jeremyrobbins9064
@jeremyrobbins9064 Месяц назад
Would like to see the wind catcher method modified with fans and or other tech to see what can be done.
@MisterFaucker
@MisterFaucker Месяц назад
That rapid exchange of air also reduces air born pathogen infection rates
@markstevenson6635
@markstevenson6635 Месяц назад
Less good for airborne allergens
@KokkiePiet
@KokkiePiet Месяц назад
I have solar panels and air conditioning. When it’s hot in summer there is loads of sunlight. I really don’t get why people don’t get this. Cost Price of a photovoltaic kWh is about 0,06 - 0,08 euro in Germany. Since I have a battery as well I produce about 85% of my electricity myself. And this is in not so sunny Northern Europe
@floridaboiwoody
@floridaboiwoody Месяц назад
Yeah but how long will your batteries last before needing replaced? The costs of buying and maintaining solar at that small of scale is too high for me. Wood gasification is a better solution for me, but I am in a rural area with many acres.
@KokkiePiet
@KokkiePiet Месяц назад
@@floridaboiwoody 12-15 years estimate
@sagetmaster4
@sagetmaster4 Месяц назад
​@@KokkiePietthat's just when they will reach an arbitrary 70 or 80% efficiency compared to when they were first bought, you can use them for MANY years after that with reduced effectiveness
@swj719
@swj719 Месяц назад
​@@sagetmaster4assuming you could afford at time of installation to have excess capacity.
@KokkiePiet
@KokkiePiet Месяц назад
@@sagetmaster4 true
@MacTX
@MacTX Месяц назад
It wasn't a mystery to me why wind capture faded with the advent of modern air conditioning, passive vs active. With wind capture, you're at the whim of nature while air conditioning wasn't, and instead you're at the whim of electricity availability.
@MichaelWinter-ss6lx
@MichaelWinter-ss6lx Месяц назад
And this functions so much superiour, especialy when the electricity is turned ON for two hours each day. This is still true for most villages and even some small towns in all regions of this video topic.
@MichaelEilers
@MichaelEilers Месяц назад
Great presentation on this one thanks for not lazily using Midjourney for everything
@Indra_P
@Indra_P Месяц назад
The problem is the wind catcher need the houses to be more spaced between each other, have a lot of unused space and have the wind catcher taller than any nearby building. In a big city, this is almost impossible.
@jussikankinen9409
@jussikankinen9409 Месяц назад
Did u learn in high school
@phlanxsmurf
@phlanxsmurf Месяц назад
Hey Simon! You should do an episode on raidative cooling paint. Ceracool is the one I know about, sends heat out to space! Super cool. Literally. :-)
@WilsonPendarvis-tn3wm
@WilsonPendarvis-tn3wm Месяц назад
Keeping ice as long as possible is more truthful
@marvelaturraz5405
@marvelaturraz5405 7 дней назад
Wow! This video was very good, but the aspect of it which impresses me the most is how this guy can talk! His veritable torrent of verbiage remains perfectly clear throughout and, IMO, stands out as the most effective and efficient example of communication via spoken language that I've ever heard from any human! I'm stunned. The man has awesome talent!
@steampunkster2023
@steampunkster2023 21 день назад
Probably incorrect, I read somewhere that they can't make ice, they can only import ice from Europe. The Yakhchāl is only good for storing it all throughout the summer. If I'm wrong, show me a demo on how can water turn to ice if sent inside the Yakhchāl.
@jasont80
@jasont80 Месяц назад
To really work, we'll also need to go back to making our buildings with much more thermal mass.
@mr.dalerobinson
@mr.dalerobinson Месяц назад
They’ve used architectural principles like this in Federation square in Melbourne, Straya. It cools an event space room with the cool air from the river.
@YeahItsRico
@YeahItsRico 13 дней назад
Less than a minute in and he spit straight facts about the Air Conditioner industry nobody talks about.
@rogerpenske2411
@rogerpenske2411 Месяц назад
The only way to cool effectively is A/C. Swamp cooling was popular here in Phoenix for decades, but A/C is much preferred.
@jussikankinen9409
@jussikankinen9409 Месяц назад
But can use solar panel and not needed in night
@UrbanGardeningWithD.A.Hanks14
@UrbanGardeningWithD.A.Hanks14 Месяц назад
How many channels are you on?
@690Lighthouse
@690Lighthouse Месяц назад
Thanks Simon, I was discussing this topic with my brother only last week so this was very helpful.
@C.Fecteau-AU-MJ13
@C.Fecteau-AU-MJ13 Месяц назад
How did these ancient people figure this out?... It must have been aliens - The History Channel.
@ralphcroker4889
@ralphcroker4889 Месяц назад
I think that's where all this is gonna end up. They just don't want us to panic.
@violettracey
@violettracey 12 дней назад
Thank you for sharing about this! It is cool!
@whimpypatrol5503
@whimpypatrol5503 Месяц назад
Swamp coolers, which are inexpensive to buy and operate, work for dry climates on similar principles. If only a device existed to do the opposite and remove moisture from the air to inexpensively cool in humid climates.
@Thunderstormworld
@Thunderstormworld Месяц назад
I have bought solar powered fans and coolers , they all have a solar panel and a battery , the coolers suck air through a wick which evaporate water cooling the air or a mist unit . They might not go extremely cold but make it livable . Plus is my electricity bill dropped a lot in summer with a plus point that when we have loadsheding (no power) in South Africa I can still cool the house .
@detromaniac
@detromaniac Месяц назад
The most ingenious design is the one that routes air underneath the house and forces air out the scoop. For effective cooling, you want to leverage the air pressure, not work against it. It's why attic exhaust fans are so damn effective.
@--Paws--
@--Paws-- Месяц назад
I remember coming across a show or even a video in RU-vid talking about how in India they also have pools in certain locations of a palace that serve as an air conditioning function. The palace had certain areas where the air would flow from one side of the building to pass through the pools which evaporates the water to cool that area of the palace. Fountains and pools in general are placed in certain areas to be away from excessive evaporation but evaporate enough to cool the area.
@boyraceruk
@boyraceruk Месяц назад
Utah's wind catcher also has a water spray system if I remember correctly, allowing for even better performance.
@1Bearsfan
@1Bearsfan День назад
These buildings can be built by Persian cultures in CK3, there's even events lamenting the lack of the cold noodle desserts, lol. Their attention to detail is awesome.
@pj7362
@pj7362 25 дней назад
Fantastic. What a great piece, you and your team knocked it out of the park. I thoroughly enjoyed this . Thanks
@rkadowns
@rkadowns 19 дней назад
I wonder how many realize the relationship between power generation and technology and human development? Conserve energy yes, but make more please. Lots more.
@coldnhot369
@coldnhot369 Месяц назад
I love the idea of wind catchers so much. I wonder if it’s possible to install them in America
@flareinc7413
@flareinc7413 Месяц назад
Such amazing tech!! :O Thank you for this information!
@spardzy1
@spardzy1 Месяц назад
Once again, I've found another channel with Simon Whistler
@UnicornsPoopRainbows
@UnicornsPoopRainbows Месяц назад
You mean the *original* channel with Simon Whistler
@arckmage5218
@arckmage5218 Месяц назад
Yea lol, this is the original one. But I do like some of his new ones.
@MakerBoyOldBoy
@MakerBoyOldBoy Месяц назад
Temperature change is a universal to accommodate human temperature limits has been a universal issue. Passive technical usage seems to be the solution. The common expectation to run around your home in your underwear while snow piles up around your house seems to be a losing sustainable practice. My own solution is to build a detached roof over a home which also has an overhang allowing cool shaded air into the building. A definite passive cooling concept.
@jussikankinen9409
@jussikankinen9409 Месяц назад
Eskimos use insulation
@AudioThrift
@AudioThrift Месяц назад
“No pleasure, no rapture, no exquisite sin greater… than central air.”
@vladimus9749
@vladimus9749 11 дней назад
Only 12% energy usage for residential AND commercial cooling isn't bad at all. Air con isn't a big environmental problem and saves many lives.
@jonjohnson2844
@jonjohnson2844 Месяц назад
The biggest paradox ever - I don't have AC but for the last few British Summers I really wish I did.
@davidjams2596
@davidjams2596 Месяц назад
very good job, sir
@TrineDaely
@TrineDaely Месяц назад
Ancient cities figured out how termite mounds work. Got it.
@devanshugaur6490
@devanshugaur6490 12 дней назад
Very well made research, thankyou guys for this info.
@puntabachata
@puntabachata 22 дня назад
Great for a dry desert climate. Try it in a HUMID climate.
@SmokingDabs
@SmokingDabs 11 дней назад
They also used screens over window openings, shoved grass and leaves in between the screens then poured water over the leaves. To cool the air coming into the home
@dainbramage3558
@dainbramage3558 Месяц назад
why do u make the screen flicker in the archive footage? its so distracting
@bghiggy
@bghiggy Месяц назад
For the vibes of course
@tripsaplenty1227
@tripsaplenty1227 Месяц назад
You kids have the attention span of a goldfish
@mattwolf7698
@mattwolf7698 Месяц назад
I didn't even notice it
@TheRealDrJoey
@TheRealDrJoey Месяц назад
I have to say that, as a former motion picture projectionist, I'm really annoyed by fake fire-roller scratches, and specks of dust on videos.
@dainbramage3558
@dainbramage3558 Месяц назад
@@TheRealDrJoey it just looks bad and i see no point in it, it makes me think my monitor is broken :D
@MycoloG2H
@MycoloG2H 10 дней назад
I've been doing HVAC for almost 9 years, and I'm down for wind capture technology
@iainburgess8577
@iainburgess8577 Месяц назад
Yes. Modern life NEEDS to reintroduce passive systems. These particular ones are excellent, but not universal; they require cold nights to work well, for example. I live in Australia; these examples aren't sufficient for our summers, where regular week to months of heatwave mean no cool nights. We Ised to have locally developed designs. Fly large breezeway verandahs, ventilated roof spaces, stilts where floods are common. But that mostly fell out of favour from the 70s on. Now, we have the same cookie cutter homes as US, UK, etc. Except more brick & tile...and less insulation (none except in roofs) Brick veneer is durable & cheaper upkeep. Tile roof is simply a fad; sheet metal was traditional... not Modern. We have 1 foot eaves, and don't even string shadecloth off them. We have created summer ovens w air conditioners to keep them cool. And we have the same majority concrete/asphalt/stone/brick cities creating heat island effect in a hot climate.
@jenningscunningham642
@jenningscunningham642 Месяц назад
It was nice of those aliens to build that for them way back then
@amysilva1547
@amysilva1547 Месяц назад
Thanks, your best yet!!!
@troyhavok8605
@troyhavok8605 11 дней назад
What event caused the "Common Era" to begin and ended "B.C.E?"
@Applemangh
@Applemangh 16 дней назад
Passive cooling is so neat. It feels like when humans learned to control fire, but in reverse. You might even say it's... cool 😎.
@Greatblue56
@Greatblue56 Месяц назад
A+ video. Well done. Thank you.
@intignia
@intignia 6 дней назад
Fascinating and so clever.
@s.e.n3264
@s.e.n3264 9 дней назад
Fascinating!
@FrithonaHrududu02127
@FrithonaHrududu02127 Месяц назад
I suspect that they were inspired by the ants and termite Hills in Africa because that is essentially how they cool the are in what otherwise would be ovens. They build completely efficient AC systems by instinct. Im a sheet metal worker so a good portion of our work is forced air. The thing is if we started using some of the ancient methods in conjunction with forced air wed have even more work. Simon i have estimated that you make 27 hours of content per day. Another great one.
@cameronhermann9400
@cameronhermann9400 Месяц назад
Amazing, we need to to look into this not only to use less energy, but could be interesting for artwork
@markhatch1267
@markhatch1267 Месяц назад
The ancients knew how to make ice! Who would have thought? Learned something new today!
@teppo9585
@teppo9585 Месяц назад
Hmm.. yea at night when the outside temps go down to below freezing. I´m not able to feel impressed by this feat honestly.
@casperyourfriendlyghost7552
@casperyourfriendlyghost7552 2 дня назад
For every one saying evaporative cooling doesn’t work in humid regions your wrong. It just requires a fan.
@narwahlssb
@narwahlssb 6 дней назад
From the day I found out about wind catches and qanats I've wanted to build a house with this style of cooling. One day I will build a house with it.
@gilgarza2903
@gilgarza2903 11 дней назад
One of my aunt's in Mexico has an old adobe house on her property. In the summer time it is fresh and cool in there. I spent a night at my other aunt's house in Monterrey, Mexico. It was an oven! You could of cooked a Thanksgiving meal in there. To top it off, the only fan was a cheap oscillating fan which made the room into a convection oven. Needless to say, I was "done" but 7 am. 🍗
@handyhippie6548
@handyhippie6548 22 дня назад
this is why victorian homes had 10'(3m) walls, and floor to ceiling double hung windows. you dropped the upper sash about 4"(10cm) and raised the lower sash about the same. the warm air at the ceiling would flow out the upper sash, while cooler air came in the lower in a simple convection flow, no air mover(fan, blower, air handler, ect.) needed. i remember my grandmother doing this in her old house before they moved to a house with electric service good enough to run AC.
@warlockpaladin2261
@warlockpaladin2261 Месяц назад
"Air conditioning is man's triumph over nature." -- Capt. Katsuragi
@doctorgoose7
@doctorgoose7 13 дней назад
Truly passive systems like wind catchers are not just reducing electrical demand by replacing HVAC, that electrical energy would have ended up in the atmosphere as heat!
@inocent007
@inocent007 17 дней назад
I remember going to a river surrounded by rocks we had to climb down to. It was a water hole, and half cave. That water was freezing in 90 degree weather.
@cjxgraphics
@cjxgraphics Месяц назад
I wonder how effective these would be in humid climates. Probably not very. Although I have worked in arenas where we had the opposite effect. Open some doors, and open the windows at the top of the arena, and we would have a very nice cool breeze to work in. Management didn't like that, so they nailed the windows shut.
@tolson57
@tolson57 Месяц назад
I have been in the building in Zion National Park with the wind catchers and the vent at the bottom has a stone bench that you can sit on in front of the vent. It gets really cool! The towers are more like swamp coolers in that they have pads at the top that are sprayed with water and as the air flows thru the pads is it cooled and drops down the shaft which in turn pulls more air in. it can be quite breezy at the bottom.
@fly.god.infinite1626
@fly.god.infinite1626 12 дней назад
Architecture is truly a reflection of of consciousness
Далее
Air Conditioning isn't free... but we're close.
25:45
Просмотров 856 тыс.
How Japanese Masters Turn Sand Into Swords
25:27
Просмотров 9 млн
How to cool our homes (even without ACs)
13:00
Просмотров 2,4 млн
Wirtz pumps are really clever
12:05
Просмотров 12 млн
Energy Free Cooling through Physics
11:36
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Unlimited Fresh Water: Can MIT's Breakthrough Save Us?
15:17
Leonardo Da Vinci's Bad Ideas
11:53
Просмотров 149 тыс.
What's Inside the Egyptian Pyramids?
21:22
Просмотров 228 тыс.
Fool’s Gold Might Be Better Than the Real Thing
7:28
5 Ancient Mysteries We Still Haven't Solved
16:15
Просмотров 7 млн
Making Opals for Free Air Conditioning
48:24
Просмотров 746 тыс.