The Andrew Garfield Amazing Spider-Man Movies - Reviewed 

After seeing Andrew Garfield performance as The Amazing Spider Man again in No Way Home, I definitely wanna see The Amazing Spider Man 3. Maybe have Tom Hardy's Venom as the villain since Andrew wants to fight an alien.

Andrew Garfield in general is a very under rated actor and he brought so much charisma to the role

I like Andrew’s Peter Parker. He acts like a real person and reacts how someone that’s getting bullies would normally act instead of just being a punching bag. I hate how people try to say he’s bad cause of that or claim he’s not comic book accurate without taking in consideration there numerous versions of Peter Parker and some of them literally act like Andrew.

My thing with skateboarding, it’s a solo sport. Peter never would join a school sports team and seemed like a social outcast. Growing up in the earlier 2000’s peter definitely grew up with X-games and the Tony Hawk and Skate games. It’s one of those sports where you can just do outside In your driveway and not have to talk to anyone else. This “cool” Parker maybe just picked it up cause math

I'm so glad people are starting to appreciate these movies, I grew up with spiderman 3 and tasm 1 and 2 coming out, so I grew up enjoying all the movies

I think Andrew is great and he actually makes me laugh out loud in some scenes

I grew up with the Tobey movies loved all 3 as a kid and when I grew into a teenager around the age spider-man was at around 15 when this came out it was my first introduction on what a reboot was and kept up with set pics and loved the suit and everything. That first movie in 2012 amplified my love for Peter and spider-man even more since I connected with this version so much more. Andrew and crew deserved better, Avi and Sony screwed this up big time. Hope they'll continue this version in the future.

Andrew and Emma as Peter and Gwen were so fucking good. It's easily the best adaption of any comic relationship.

Amazing spiderman is one of my favourite spiderman movies, love andrews portrayal and lizard is really scary. I love nwh too but they didn’t do lizard justice he was too different from his portrayal in tasm

Andrew Garfield quips are more Spider-Man Tom Holland quips are just more pop culture references

I prefer Andrew Garfield’s Spider-Man over the other two. He was my childhood hero growing up.

The Websuit in the first TASM is honestly my favorite for how different it is to most. Also it reminds me of the 2099 suit.

I've always loved the Andrew Garfield take on Spidey,I felt he was too cool as Peter,but he nailed it perfectly with Spidey,his comedic timing was awesome as Spidey,and the Stan Lee cameo in Amazing Spiderman is my all-time favorite Stan Lee Cameo,glad ppl loved him on No Way Home...maybe we can finally make The Amazing Spiderman a Trilogy now...

Let's be honest he was a great spider-man ( The best IMO) The scrip without Andrew was not the best but it is not the horrid movie that people make it to be they focused on Peters humanity and not just him being spider-man this is one of my favorite superhero movies to watch everyone in the movie had good acting they made things in the movie awkward because that's what real people

I used to love this, then hate it and now I appreciate it's strength and acknowledge it's flaws. Either way let's agree that we live Andrew Garfield :)

I really hope they eventually make a third one

I never really liked the suit from the first Amazing Spider-Man movie and since then I'm still not a fan of it but I appreciate them trying something different. When the Amazing Spider-Man 2 was shooting back in 2013 and his new suit was revealed, I liked it a lot more and I was so glad to see Andrew wearing it again in No Way Home.

One thing all Spider-Man fans can agree on. Tasm Gwen is the best live action love intrest

I’m so glad someone else appreciates the ASM 1 suit. I absolutely have loved the suit over the other 2 SM suits. There’s just something about when the ASM 1 suit is in the dark scenes of the movie that just make that suit look insane! I love the dark red and blue with gold. 🔥

Both of the Amazing Spider-Man movies are my favorite Spider-Man movies. The first movie, is great. The characters are the best they've fever been in Spider-Man movies. You can't tell me any characters from the Rami movies it when than May and Tobey compare to the complexity of Andrew, Uncle Ben, this Aunt May, Gwen, and so on. The cinematography is also, amazing. The Amazing Spider-Man movies have always been visually stunning and they are. Especially the second one. No matter what you feel about TASM2, you have to admit it's visually stunning. The OST for both films are great, the Spider-Man theme and the Electro theme are some amazing pieces of music. Gwen is literally the best live action love interest for Spider-Man yet. They handled her arc extremely well. Both movies have great writing, and Andrew Garfield is an amazing actor for Spider-Man. These movies are my favorite Spider-Man movies eight after No Way Home. I hope Sony does more things with Andrew.

This is a great review. Appreciate the thought that went into this. Usually people just pan these movies because Peter is 'too cool', but you actually look deeper.

Really like your humor in this! Keep it up

I remember watching the first Andrew Garfield movie in theaters. I enjoyed the darker tone. Thought Andrew Garfield was a great Spiderman.

Great video Jay! I never watched the Tobey Maguire version of this video because I just thought I was secure in my thoughts of how good those films were, however I absolutely love the ASM movies so I just had to see someone's opinion on it. This video was great so I'm definitely gonna go watch the Sam Raimi movie era video!

great video! Andrew deserved more respect than what he got but given the times, I understand it. Can't wait for the next trilogy analysis

Can't wait till the 100k play video

Great job man

Captain Stacy in TASM1 at the dinner scene is to bring Peter into perspective. Peter was just hunting down criminals that look like his uncle’s killer for his own vendetta, he wasn’t actually trying to protect anyone. He wasn’t actually being a hero. The cops also weren’t incompetent at catching the criminals, it was a strategic move to find the leaders of the gangs. A plan that they were following for months. So really Peter was actually messing them up. We as an audience know that Peter is the protagonist, so we are (supposed to be) on his side, but from an outsider’s perspective, a random masked figure starts hunting down people, potentially endangering bystanders, and messing up an established plan you had set up. Peter actually needed that talk to tell him what he was doing wasn’t the right thing. Stacy also didn’t ignore the Lizard. When Peter came to the Police station to tell him about it, after Peter left, he actually looked into it, and a whole team started hunting down the Lizard, as you can see in the scene where the Lizard gets shot up. They were trying to stop both the Spider-Man AND the Lizard. Many seem to forget this.

I really think Andrew Garfield has become loved over the years and it’s really good to see cause he smashed as spider-man.

I'm still mad that they pushed Harry in the second movie out of nowhere without giving any backstory as to when these 2 meet. Harry fell flat for me because I don't know this version of Harry Osborne personally he should have been the villain in tasm 3 which unfortunately wasn't the case

electro's theme is awesome

I'm glad i'm not alone in loving the TASM suit. First one and second

I very much enjoy the plot with his parents introducing the concept that they were shield agents hiding information on the super soldier serum which furthers the plot

As a huge spider-man fan the really sad part is that what sony had in mind with the tasm series if done well could've been really cool...a sort of micro-mcu based around spidey and his villains. If they had let those stories be organically fleshed out in multiple movies without messing with the creative process like they did I think it could've been a pretty great franchise...Andrew deserved a better chance at this character and I'm happy he got some redemption at least in no way home, he's a great actor and you can tell he really loves and cares about spidey

Recently watched all the Spiderman movies again, and I gotta be honest, TASM2 is one of my favorites.

Happy to hear that someone else likes the amazing spider-man 2 movie too

I’m so happy to see someone who genuinely likes these movies and gives them a fair shot, I’m sick of people shitting on it so harshly

12:13, the opening is a metaphor for the entire film, peter searching for his father, he prioritizes searching for his biological parents and ends up working with a father like figure (doctor connors). the day ben dies hes prioritizes working with that father like figure instead of picking up the call with ben, he loses the father he then loses the father he took for granted (ben) and connors turns himself into a perversion of science, captain stacy talks sense into peter during the dinner scene (this is the point of the film where he finally becomes spider-man) he then saves a kid on the bridge and reunites him with his father, a moment that he'll never have and then Gwen's father dies, so for me at least even though he had very little screen time, that silent scream peters lets out is everything

I used to get roasted before for saying that i really liked andrew as spideman and even rate the 1st movie quite highly. Now the same people are singing hymns for andrew.

I surprisingly really like the first amazing Spider-Man the second one has its flaws but I still love Andrew Garfield

I have always liked Andrew as Spider-Man. I don't think he was too "cool" as Peter Parker because in the start of TASM he got a basketball landed on his head, a girl went up to him and he thought she was going to ask him out but ended up asking her to take pictures of her boyfriend's car, he acts like a weirdo when he's taking pictures of his crush, he tries to stand up for a kid that was getting bullied but ended up getting beat up in front of everyone, and every time he talks to someone he seems to have serious social anxiety. Also, I don't think him skateboarding was a bad thing because it just makes him relatable to modern teenagers and it's not like he was the captain of the football team, he didn't play any sports in school. And he is a science geek because he was at oscorp and looking up to people like the lizard who was a known scientist. That's just my defense on his take as Peter and I'm tired of people saying negative comments about his take.

Awesome

I loved the amazing Spider-Man suit personally. It’s nice to hear that I’m not the only one 🙂

Someone who likes the TASM suit?? New year looking good already.

Harry Osborn should have been the villain for TASM3. He should have been introduced in TASM2 with similar storyline.

The TASM movies are underrated even the second one Edit: Jay: I have a crush on Emma Stone His wife: you fucking what mate?

His suit from TASM 1 is honestly my favorite spidey suit of all time atleast from the movies.

I remember when the movies came out I was in high school and I actually liked it. The writing in both movies is what messed up Andrew & everyone wasn’t ready to not see anyone but Tobey be Spider-Man but he did a great job in my opinion. Though the writing wasn’t as good in the first one the 2nd movie followed up with an excellent performance by Jamie Foxx as Electro which you could argue made the movie. So for Andrew he never got his due to me but I’m glad people are being more open to seeing him as Spider man and you can tell he really enjoyed playing Spidey.

I personally wasn't a fan of andrew garfield spider-man movies but I am glad you enjoy these movies more then I did.

I love TASM, cause the characters feel more grounded. Andrew’s TASM Suit looks sick. It looks far more athletic and Andrew’s Spidy is visually in the way he swings. It could also be just the way it was shot. Which the different swinging shots are top tier. 20:37 Yh I think they should have separated Harry’s transformation into Hobgoblin / Gwen’s death into another movie. They could have sprinkled some scenes of Harry throughout in TASM2 to get us familiar with him as a character so that his transformation would have been so much more horrifying to see. 26:03 Yeah man, I was typing this in advance but yh, like that scene where Harry and his dad were talking could have been a post credit scene; to setup another movie. The whole bloodline aspect I skipped over ( didn’t really register / process ) the first time watching, but it’s true what people said and I agree. If it wasn’t rushed there would have been an “Amazing” story arch across the movies. I’ve seen NWH and yh . . . #MakeTASM3

I just watched this movie for the first time the other day and man I was missing out. I much prefer Toby Maguire as Spider-Man but Andrew does a very good job.

The Amazing Spiderman suits are the best live action suits I have ever seen in my life especially the first suit I absolutely love that suit

I always loved The Amazing Spider-man duology, i never understood why people hate on it so much, now with No Way Home, since i loved these films, the movie hits so much harder

I won't throw shade at people who dissed these movies with their mind and soul, but rather I want to say "welcome to the family". I hate how it took this most recent movie just to see his potential. But as a fan since day one of Andrew, I'm glad people are actually seeing how much of an "amazing" Peter Parker that he proved to be. I never hated on Tom or Tobey but I love them in their own way, and hopefully people think like me now more than ever.

I don't agree with everything you think here (especially Captain Stacy, who just seemed like a regular cop dad that took his job seriously). I'm shocked that you think Andrew is MORE awkward than Tobey tbh lol (one of my problems with those movies is that Peter felt like a weird dork and not just a bitter nerd like he was in the comics). I think the personality of Peter in the first half of TASM1 is very accurate to the original comics, where he says something that a school shooter would say lmao. Despite their flaws, I love both of these movies and think they captured the characters and stories from the comics I've been reading for so many years the best compared to Raimi, while MCU Spidey is a close second. I wish we could get an extended cut of TASM2 since there are so many good scenes that were cut out, that would improve the movie and its plot.

You used the 60fps AI version of the Lizard School fight lmao

I wish they kept the same overall design from the tasm 1 suit in tasm 2, but with minor upgrades as seen in the concept art. The actual tasm suit is amazing, but doesn't feel unique from the rami suit

Is this suit included in the PS4 version of Spider-Man?

So I liked Andrew Garfield as Spider-Man and also as Peter Parker and I know someone will disagree with me. I loved how these movies focused on the relationship between Peter and Gwen like that’s done perfectly. The first Amazing Spider-Man movie is great. I understand it’s not the best Spider-Man movie but it’s still a good movie and I liked how in that movie how Peter had to build his own web shooters and how the movie showed how intelligent Peter Parker because that’s part of his character. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is really good too I just wished they should’ve shown more of Gwen Stacy like the first one did. My biggest issue with the second movie is that yes, they teased the Sinister Six but they sort of rushed into it and then they just abandoned it and that really irritated me. I love Spider-Man he’s got some of the best villains. Like you said in the video it would’ve been better to tease the Green Goblin in a post credits scene. Or they could’ve had Harry become the Green Goblin earlier in the film and have a confrontation with Spider-Man before Gwen’s death. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 isn’t a bad movie I just feel like it could’ve been better and I think in order for a Spider-Man movie to tease the Sinister Six that you need more time to set that up and not have it rushed into the movie.

4:40 can we talk about how fast he did that? Wtf??

Yes the suits are awesome I love them I like the yellow eyes like at school we had to make ornaments at school so I made spider man with a Santa hat with yellow eyes I love the suit but my favorite is the Symbiot suit from spider man 3 and part is nostalgia

Jay is gargling on the amazing spiderman 2 and I kinda like it

I hate when everyone hates the Yellow Lens, they're supposed to be from a Sunglass Lens, AND they're actually dark yellow, Closer to black than yellow.

I've never hated the ASM movies. But they are aren't the best. Also, 100k here we come !

After seeing no way home hope we get a amazing Spider-Man 3

instant like when you said you liked dane dehaan in a cure for wellness.

I really like this universe more than the rami verse mostly because to me the rami trilogy felt like a spider man soape Opera and these movies feel like a modernized spider man imo. I really sympathize with Andrew especially since he was such a massive fan of the character and was fired for something that he can’t control. The history behind these movies really brings a frown to my face (some of it Sonys fault some of it not). After no way home and the leaks I really hope Andrew gets a second chance, weather that means spider man has a universe with no avengers or with avengers (probably without). I’ve loved this movies since forever and I really liked it, and I’m glad TASM 3 didn’t happen because of Sony’s plans for it.

I like to make an argument on captain Stacy because in the movie he does say to Peter that Spider-Man ruined an operation to catch 1 car thief that could’ve lead the cops to catch an entire operation of car thiefs that they were trying to catch, also his point to Peter was how Spider-Man is inexperienced an amateur and doesn’t know anything about crime fighting, keep in mind this was during peter’s blood lusted revenge which captain Stacy points out saying Spider-Man is only catching a guys who looks similar to each other like he has a “vendetta”, I personally say captain Stacy was needed to help Peter understand he could do or be more as Spider-Man rather than just going on a revenge spree

5:40 LMFAOOO😭

It's not just the TASM2's propensity for trying to set up a Sinister Six movie that absolutely no one wanted, it's the tone. I loved the first TASM, and have said so openly since. TASM2 didn't even feel like it belonged in the same franchise, let alone the same cinematic universe. And no matter what thematic elements they could play with with this version of Harry Osborn, it can't substitute for the fact that he wasn't set up in the first film AT ALL and is just dropped on us in this one in a manner that is completely unbelievable, at least to me. EVERY redeeming feature of the film either comes from Garfield or Stone rising above the material they were handed.

my big problem is the silly scenes and the lizards plan in tasm 1

I think the movies are really good my personal opinion Spider-Man 2 with doc ock never was special to me it was good tho but I love andrews performance Emma stone and just the franchise in general

Yeah I liked both amazing Spider-Man movies too.

I'm probably one of the few people who grew up with the Sam Raimi Spider-Man movies that actually liked the Andrew Garfield Spider-Man more than Tobey Maguire Spider-Man, it's definitely mainly due to the Gwen and Peter relationship was just better than MJ and Peter but also because I was more into the Ultimate Spider-Man which this version was definitely more inspired from. I do think what they should have is Spider-Man and Captain Stacy a good relationship that would have made his death more impactful, seeing in the comics his death was 1 of the 3 that really effected his character, the other two obviously Uncle Ben mad Gwen.

TASM and TASM 2 are underrated.

7:16 I kinda feel like Mary-jane in the Sam Raima movies is a loose intaganist

#makeTASM3

That moment when you're the only person in the comments who grew up with the TASM films....

I Pretty much grew up all of the Spider man movies and Animated Shows. He's my favorite Super Hero. Venom is my favorite Anti-Hero and Carnage is my favorite Villain. Honestly Andrew has always been my favorite Peter Parker and Spider-man. Even though he's not as nerdy or geeky as Tobey he still has some awkwardness and in the second where he's college age I think he seemed like adult Peter. As Spidey he has the prefect comedy & charisma, he helped everyone including Jorge(the kid with the turbine) and he feels like an actual Spider-MAN. which Tom Holland (until the most recent movie) didn't feel right to me.

I have very bad social anxiety to

Best Spider-Man my opinion

Everyone was conflicted that Spider-Man 4 wasn’t gonna happen but everything happens for a reason eventually we see the endgame. I mean No Way Home was worth the wait of Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield

Sounds like you matured alot

Always loved Andrews Spider-Man and I still wish he would have been Spider-Man of the MCU

I feel bad for the people that didn’t appreciate Andrews performance and the good parts of his movies, now they want a 3rd movie just bc they saw nwh. Good that they are realizing though

i love TASM2. it is my favourite superhero/comocbook-movie next to Batman returns and Dark knight. TASM2 ´xs pacing is brilliant. Great action with drama and emotional heavyness. On the other hand I can not get behind any of the MCU-movies (not just the Spiderman-MCU movies). Am I out of touch for liking Tasm2? No, it is the rest of the world that s wrong! i really think I live in bizarro world.

Garfield was simply a self imposed outcast/wall flower. Nothing more nothing less. Very true to Parker’s character in the original 60’s comics

Andrew Garfield is my favorite spiderman out of the lot I understand how you feel about being too harsh on a film I didn't like the mcu spidey because I wanted Amazing spiderman 3 but also because it didn't feel like spiderman to me

The reason Peter skateboards is because Andrew saw this video from Willaim Spencer skateboarding and said this is Spiderman skateboarding and that is why the skateboarding scene exist and how William became his stunt double

The amazing Spider-Man is amazing

#MakeTASM3

#maketasm3

Heres the problem I have with the community. After seeing andrew in NWH now everybody is like GIVE US TASM3, and im like wat where was this love 4 andrew back then.

i also liked Gwen Stacy in this movies too

I'm sure the reason why Andrew and Emma's chemistry in these films was the standout is because Marc Webb is no stranger to directing on screen couples in a quirky and loveable relationship and that carried over to this franchise as a result

Among the three actors who played spiderman. Andrew Garfield actually had by far the best performance, its just the bad writing messed him up.

Fun fact: the school fight with the lizard is complete cgi till Spider-Man throws Gwen out the window

Seeing amazing spiderman 1 for the first time i thought it was just ok and nothing more and later got to enjoy a bit more. TASM2 however nah i cant. That film was not enjoyable for me at all. I would like to see TASM 3 though. Andrew Garfield fantastic actor and although i prefer tom holland's version more andrew is the more solid actor out of the three.

I generally dislike the first amazing spider-man film. I feel Peter as a character is portrayed poorly. He is kind of jerk to almost everyone. Including Aunt May when he comes home with bruises. Also, I don’t think they gave Lizard enough screen time to develop which kind of made him meh. I actually really like The Amazing Spider-Man 2 aside from probably the villains. Maybe it’s just me but Garfield era villains are pretty forgettable. Anyways, I think they nailed Peter’s character. I personally think the amazing spider-man 2 has the some of best fights/action scenes and web swinging out of all the live action Spider-Man films.

I remember the first ever SpiderMan movie I saw was TASM in a drive in movie theater when I was like 9 or 10. My friend and I almost cried when we saw the lizard cuz we were so scared 😂. These movies aren’t the best but they hold a special place in my heart and their my favorite SpiderMan movies