The Big Picture : Section 377 Decriminalised

Подписаться 8 млн

Просмотров 73 тыс.

50% 1

Celebrations broke out 6 September, 2018 as the LGBTQ community and others welcomed the Supreme Court judgment decriminalising consensual gay sex, asserting that the "historic" verdict granted them a basic human right but also acknowledging that complete equality was still some distance away. A five-judge Constitution bench of the Supreme Court unanimously decriminalised part of the 158-year-old colonial law under Section 377 of the IPC, which criminalises consensual unnatural sex, prompting joyous tears, hugs and dancing across the country. Activists, members of the LGBTQ community, authors and politicians welcomed the verdict -- which also said society cannot dictate a sexual relationship between consenting adults -- with many cutting cakes and unfurling the rainbow flag. On this edition of 'The Big Picture' we will analyse the verdict of the Supreme Court on Section 377.
Anchor- Frank Rausan Pereira
Guest- J. Sai Deepak, Advocate, Supreme Court
Satya Prakash, Legal Editor, The Tribune
Menaka Guruswamy, Advocate of Petitioners
Rahul Easwar, Author

Опубликовано:

5 сен 2018

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 276

@dhirajbankar1094 5 лет назад

ms menaka really upset sai deepak at the concluding remarks.She could have talked in a decent manner.But its ok.One thing really needs to mention here.Mr.J sai deepak is true gem of not only legal fraternity but also of our country.He always make me fall in love of his way of expressing,his conviction,his way of thinking.Hope some day India will see him as a CJI. tnx rs tv

@bhumikachaturvedi4446 5 лет назад

This is possible fingers crossed.

@ranvijaysingh3803 5 лет назад

J sai for CJI

@thequranicwisdom744 5 лет назад

At 13:03 Hats off to Mr Frank for being so wise in not allowing hurtful comments to be passed in show he anchors. I really appreciate this aspect of his personality to quickly put water on sparks which potentially can be fire... His parents and friends and even Indian Media is so LUCKY to have such a wonderful anchor in our country... I see his name already in History books of our future...🙂

@sahithyam.a4959 5 лет назад

J Saideepak makes every debate worth watching. Another debate expected on the same issue with different panelists.

@prakashpanday9372 5 лет назад

Sahithya M.A I'm big fan of him...infact, I want to study law due to his influence

@Geetsz1 5 лет назад

The point of a debate is to have all views, opinions and aspects related to the verdict up for discussion. Not just about the verdict and its impact. I think Meneka Guruswamy needs to understand that whatever she had fought for over the years, is exactly what she is denying to other panelists- to be heard, to hold a variant opinion and to be tolerant.

@vikassonwani773 5 лет назад

Absolutely...

@bhaweshthapa4672 5 лет назад

Absolutely correct, they are praising the same supreme Court which had held 377 legal. It's not good to rejoice only when it's in our favor.

@michaelscott3190 5 лет назад

Menaka was totally disappointing. I hope she gets over the ego, respect others opinion & continue to provide people justice.

@vikassonwani773 5 лет назад

And She had pointed to other panelists they that don't talk core issue related to this judgement, But sai deepak clear at the last.. we were touched with the case and talk about the central idea of the case but not like is she...

@AtobaLongkumer 5 лет назад

Very true

@ShubhamKumar-in9fd 5 лет назад

J Sai Deepak responded with full respect and as it needed to be: "We are happy to be educated on other aspects".

@alwinpaulalias657 3 года назад

Who invitedd Rahul Eswar here 🤣🤣

@HK-kv8mm 5 лет назад

And the winner is.....Frank.

@santoshkumarmaurya8976 5 лет назад

It's debate, not argument where no one wins but the debate itself. Nonetheless, Frank has great skill to put it forward, not ending debate it itself. 😊

@beinghappy5924 5 лет назад

Sai Deepak @ 14:35 - 15:00 argument, hats off to you man for such a wonderful oratory skill.

@pankajkasana 5 лет назад

Brilliant debate, as is the case when Sai Deepak is on panel. However, Ms. Menaka needs to tone down the rhetoric and acerbic language. This is not Times Now. Excellent points by Satya as well. Congratulations Frank for such a beautiful debate..

@ruchimistry7113 5 лет назад

Pankaj Kasana Yeah... Satya's points are... 👍

@sayanbera8330 5 лет назад

I need to study more about the issue ...to find out the locus of the case and judgment . There r many aspects (equality, dignity, freedom, fraternity ,privacy and along with science , stats, culture, morality, and in core constitutionality) . But which one is prime mover of this case !!

@sannithreddy5499 5 лет назад

Sathya prakash sir.. Though spoke less has given perfect view

@tracknorth8394 5 лет назад

One of the distinguished judges said, "History owes an apology to LGBT people". Looking at some of the people on this show and reading some of the comments below, my reaction is, "How true"! The blessing of ignorance is heart-numbing.

@Ashhhutosh 5 лет назад

Menaka Guruswami

@surrekhabaskar7632 5 лет назад

Sai Deepak sir.......u beauty ......what a language and clarity of expression..😎

@ssips7860 5 лет назад

Why miss menka so arrogant... And thinks that she's the only one who had done homework properly

@swatisingh4166 5 лет назад

More than right to privacy or equality, the case was about right to dignity. Dignity of an individual's life should be protected by law at any cost.

@gajanankulkarni8972 5 лет назад

What can I can say about Sai Deepak whose way of making argument are appreciated by CJI D M

@cloudygreen809 2 года назад

For miss Guruswamy's words ❤️

@perinaxavier2463 5 лет назад

Frank Sir , I adore the way you moderate the fluctuations propping up throughout the disscussion. Would be great to listen to J Sai Deepak Sir often on the show. Thank you RS TV!

@user-ew1wk5ft1y 5 лет назад

Need a dictionary for understanding statements of Advocate J Sai. 😂😂😂😂😂

@alexmaveli 5 лет назад

Don't invite Rahul Eeswar to this kind of discussions. He comes with a point and never hear what others has to tell.

@rajasekhar7951 5 лет назад

Hopt it's not just a screen that rahul eshwar disappears from.

@satyaprakashmishra7314 5 лет назад

Here a prophecy I make...that come one day, Mr. J Sai Deepak would be delivering verdicts from the bench of the Supreme Court, given the clarity of his thoughts, his commitment to his profession (who subsequently studied law after completing Engineering 😃) and the brilliant power of analysis he has been endowed with. He is a Justice Krishna Iyer in the making! 😊 RSTV...Pls make it a point to invite him to any issue which has a legal angle, because with him, you invite a whole new perspective!

@siddharthavhad6316 Год назад

Losing JSD to the SC/HC would be disastrous. He will be able to express himself more and better otherwise.

@anonymouscaveman8557 Год назад

The courts will box jsai deepak he wont be able to take down wokes

@paridhigiriya4517 5 лет назад

First time, apart from being informative, it also got a little dramatic! But a good work as always in Big Picture!

@SatpalSingh-nk9ix 5 лет назад

It is always great experience to listen to j sai Deepak with great clarity and articulation of thoughts.. Thanks RSTV for this informative debate

@Neha-kl8yz 5 лет назад

That concluding smile by Frank......lively discussion...j sai deepak country is proud to have you...

@monicakarunya793 5 лет назад

19:55 and that's what we call a moment of " victory,"😘Frank , you're gem of a kind.. I don't know how much I love you.

@user-yc6qw1rn7e 5 лет назад

wonderful discussion....thanku RsTV. .😊. coming with such a distinguished panelist ...specially experts like Sai Deepak..... Truelly Rocking...

@peacefullmindleadstogreatl1834 5 лет назад

Mr J Sai Deepak's point to S.C has to give its decision on basis of constitution and don't wait for public positive ness and should have courage to clarify what is wrong and what is right. S.C need to consolidate its position as a guarantor of CONSTITUTION.

@mounicasairaj1614 5 лет назад

It's really worth spending half an hour by watching this debate. Firstly, it is for Frank sir. He is the best host ever addressing such debates. Secondly, thank you for inviting Sai Deepak sir and Satya sir. They both have given detailed view of this verdict. At the end we need to respect everyone's view. Thank you RS TV

@professorelixir3351 2 года назад

100 times better than Arnab Goswami's debate lol.

@ch.ajaysingh 5 лет назад

"Let justice be done though the heavens fall." Rightly pointed by Deepak Sai.

@iasmind65 5 лет назад

I am here to hear Sai Deepak’s views. He is 👏

@sureshprajapati3157 5 лет назад

The society should adopt this LGBT community... I think panel missed this point completely.

@nirupamasingh17 5 лет назад

Great listening.# Deepak J sai

@souravsk87 5 лет назад

“Menaka has to be somewhere else”- That’s d class of mr. perera

@gautam161291 5 лет назад

What about SC delivers decision only on the touchstone of constitution disregarding the social morality and then society fails to implement it or concur with it which can lead to social disharmony?

@siddharthgautam159 3 года назад

"say no to homophobia" he said before basing his arguments on homophobia enabling jurisprudence used by the colonial law givers.

@GAURAVKUMAR-np5dr 5 лет назад

I am big fan of Dipak sir and Satya Prakash sir

@sudeepsingh2573 5 лет назад

Sai Deepak rocks🤘🤘🤘

@vikramsinghh3171 5 лет назад

Wow.. simply wow... Just goes on to prove how peacefully and thoughtfully a debate can be conducted... Rstv shud never stop bringing such people on panels..unlike other media houses who r just after trps and care only about profits and pandering to their audiences... Kudos to the rstv team

@Epicurean999 5 лет назад

Big FAN of Sai Sir now...HEARTIEST CONGRATULATIONS FOR MY INDIA'S LGBTQAI community💘

@akashdas3030 3 года назад

Many many thanks

@Gagupathan 5 лет назад

Sai Deepak, as always pleasure listening to you sir. Very knowledgeable and crystal clear points

@rohitagarwal5427 5 лет назад

Menaka Guruswamy is correct. Other panelists have not really read the judgement. Reading down of Sec 377 is much more than privacy issue. It's also about equality and making LGBTs equal citizens like others. A judge said, 'I am what I am and take me as I am'. He is taking about acceptance of variant sexual orientations of people. So it'd not just about sex which was criminalised. People also saw LGBT people through the lens of their sexuality. So this Judgement is much more than what other panelists are saying. (Rahul Easwar is a dumbo, forget about him)

@GAURAVKUMAR-np5dr 5 лет назад

I am a big fan of deepak sir and satya prakash sir

@rohitdeshmukh9043 5 лет назад

Question- as satya prakash stated that sc was waiting for society to be ready, consensus among political parties and people for this decision then isn't it called as populist approach of SC ? As we saw at ayodhya case and binayak sen verdict.

@gauravdarade2490 5 лет назад

Good to see different viewpoints. That's what debates in democracy are all about. And good panelists make it more fruitful. And not to forget the anchor who has got that trick to manage all of them.

@ammushakthi9943 5 лет назад

Have desai deepak in every panel and give him a permanent seat in rstv is my judgement. Bravo desai especially the last point of giving back to menaka 💪 you earned a fan bro

@akshayugale2223 5 лет назад

Rahul easwar is very rightly quoting the real situation in society but...no one's taking him in the right way..... though court has' very rightly ' decriminalised section 377 , our society is still not accepting LGBTQ persons as normal and equal citizens......sc has done it's part....and now the ball is in our(society s) court...... and we have to work for....social acceptance of LGBTQ persons......but if we are approaching the society (with deeply ingrained traditional ethos) with arrogance.....then society will react....with more hatred towards LGBTQ Persons.....so we have to keep in mind all this 'ground situation' and will have to work accordingly......so that LGBTQ persons are gradually accepted by the whole society as equal citizens (which is their birth right) ......this is not end but just the beginning of the war....the war of us with deeply ingrained intolerance in ourselves.....so lets fight it out together.....to give our LGBTQ brothers and sisters the place of dignity in our society which they deserve very rightly 🙂 - Akshay ugale

@nishantsrivastava8199 Год назад

Further going for right may means moving society toward complex problems

@RudraxT Год назад

no one is lgtv since birth

@amankumar7119 5 лет назад

Well brought up.....I loved it.

@nambulgekarnambulgekar8457 5 лет назад

J. Sai Deepak's manner of argument deserve appreciation

@vickyganesh5701 5 лет назад

J sai deepak's way of expressing and his language was so good...

@unknwn0facts 5 лет назад

Frank ji, please held one session on SC&ST ACT whether Supreme Court judgement is really not needed

@anveshdubey7319 5 лет назад

RAHUL easwar nice rattafication

@dipeshbhatt7418 5 лет назад

J sai deepak sr is amazing to watch...his conviction and calm and respected behaviour for other panelist

@satyam436 5 лет назад

It's not all about guts , it's like "making hay while the sun shines" - when it comes to human wisdom . The honorable SC does it so often to prevent the unnecessary chaos in society. After all it's society consensus that needs to be considered. If constitutional touchstones are put forward every now and then there are n number of cases which can be delivered in very short period....

@realindian1187 5 лет назад

Frank the best keep coming with such discussions with such a panelists Satya Prakash showed his maturity in end

@souravsk87 5 лет назад

After watching J Sai Deepak I feel that’s how one should study...

@tracknorth8394 5 лет назад

One of the distinguished judges said, "LGBT people owe an apology..". Looking at some of the people on this show and reading some of the comments below, my reaction is, "How true"!

@ucantbetarun 5 лет назад

did anyone notice J.Sai deepak wore 2 watches in 2 hands (although one is iwatch ):p

@swagh4930 5 лет назад

Rahul easwar comes in debate related to constitutional verdict....but why you dont use good camera....we are living in 21st century but it's looks like you are using 20th century camera...sir you give good points but start using good camera so that ur voice will be more clear.

@manjusha3812 5 лет назад

satya prakash excellently pointed out what ms maneka asserting to....ofcourse satya prakash and sai deepak are fantastic panelist

@IMRANKHAN-zh9vh 5 лет назад

It’s always a treat to watch RS TV debates...so informative..and enlightening...kudos 🙏🙏🙏

@chanakyaniti2883 3 года назад

J sai...always impresses me

@0718amit 5 лет назад

please upload upto 1080p. thank you.

@yogeshjingar1040 5 лет назад

Every news anchor should learn from Frank. He is perfect.

@pandithasmat2363 5 лет назад

Sai Deepak 👍

@asishb6673 5 лет назад

Don't invite Rahul to Rajya Sabha TV discussions. He is always vague.

@deepak-ix3zg 5 лет назад

Asish Anatta not good by natural human

@RahulKumar-ng2gh 5 лет назад

I think he has put a valid point

@michaelscott3190 5 лет назад

M sorry if you did not get his point. His opinion is pretty clear and good. "opinion"

@RahulKumar-ng2gh 5 лет назад

Exactly Arjun, a new perspective, maybe the Supreme Court has not discussed it now, but it can be a future bone of contention between different parties and that's what democracy and this civilised debate is all about. PS: the lawyer was arrogant and not ready to accept any other perspective than her, I hated that

@dhirajbankar1094 5 лет назад

Asish Anatta i dont think so.He always brings some new dimensions to the topic,that too in a very decent manner.Despite disagreement over the verdict,he accepted it gracefully without making any derogatory statement towards other panelists.

@sandipojha5642 5 лет назад

Great work Frank.. Unbiased hosting

@Prelimsupsc2023 5 лет назад

And here a day comes when Frank calls it a wrap with a sigh of relief!

@jamesmicheal4814 5 лет назад

"politician is tied on opinion of his constituents But supreme court not " Excellent quotation by deepak Sir

@pankajpatil5459 5 лет назад

Well played..frank

@kushaal596 5 лет назад

18:25 to 18:43 perfect for the conclusion part of the answer :) or for ending of any essay

@zekeyaeger3018 5 лет назад

@@NAENRA That is the most heartbreaking curse I have read so far in RU-vid. Lol😂😂

@Vishal-my7rc 5 лет назад

J Sai Deepak rocks once again.

@abhigaurav 5 лет назад

I liked the discussion due to varying viewpoints.

@sheratype 5 лет назад

Great debate.

@jishnu3031 5 лет назад

how come rahul eswar in this platform

@Sisyphus999 3 года назад

j sai deepak raised the real issue..of non interference of state into pvt affairs.

@hariomgandhi4758 5 лет назад

Exact but too late on decision by SC is exact Q that has raised by Satya prakshji but saying that to seek apologize of SC for this is condemnable....

@darshansoni1668 5 лет назад

j sai deepak veiws are good

@atulmichael4723 5 лет назад

Easwar was making really good points, why did they cut him off????

@shouryasachdeva8195 5 лет назад

Sai Deepak nailed it.

@prashantkaushik7035 5 лет назад

Please invite J. SAI DEEPAK more often. He is a modern day Ambedkar , in the way he presents his thoughts in a logical and conclusive manner.

@vamshidhar8648 Год назад

His ideologies are totally against Ambedkar

@abhishektiwari5132 3 года назад

Seen first unbaised panelist . Bravoo.. mr. Frank

@shwetajoshi8829 5 лет назад

Mr.Frank Rausan Pereira is one of the best anchor in our country ... Rahul easwar 18.25 to 18.43 is the perfect conclusion for this issue...

@royalera512 5 лет назад

Sai deepak feeled sad at last comment

@theangrybirdreturns6956 5 лет назад

Frank is awesome

@avinash9776 5 лет назад

The recent supreme court judgements expose the legislative lethargy in our democratic system. The naction of the parliament in such issues have forced the people to resort to judicial activism to get rid of ills of society. This could have been done by legislative action but politicians will play safe to vote banks and leave important legislative actions to the courts who are not bound by public opinion.

@saurabh7241 5 лет назад

J Sai Deepak excellent

@AtobaLongkumer 5 лет назад

Best Anchor in India.

@AnuragYadav-nf6ut 5 лет назад

frank and deepak , thumbs up

@avneeshkumar5754 5 лет назад

Wao what a anchor this men is!all pannalist are too good.

@miseera2589 5 лет назад

Why Maneka is irked when others are expressing their views ? This is what they were invited for. Thanks to Frank you saved a verbal tussle. XD

@pmvidz4262 5 лет назад

#Respect for SUPREME JUDGEMENT of the supreme court

@DevyaniPatil333 5 лет назад

Sai Deepak has always been so clear with his views ! I respect him even more since CJI Misra has praised him for making a point in Sabarimala case !

@vinodsrinivasan9077 5 лет назад

What was the point that Mr. Sai Deepak made pertaining to sabarimala case.?

@DevyaniPatil333 5 лет назад

He’s arguing from the side of the deity. He said that the deity (ayyappa) is a jurist person and he has certain rights like being brahmachari

@vinodsrinivasan9077 5 лет назад

@@DevyaniPatil333 Do you have any chance of having whole transcript regarding Sai's argument in regards to sabarimala case.? I couldn't find in web.

@DevyaniPatil333 5 лет назад

Even i would like to go through it once. Can’t find! Would post the link if i get it. I read his take in one of the news articles

@DevyaniPatil333 5 лет назад

Hello, I found one of his old videos ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-W91BB0QtcnQ.html

@forpeaceandcalm4649 3 года назад

Not by nurture,Rahulji

@kuldeeptanwar7654 5 лет назад

Rahul ishwar is hypocrite and delusional

@rotsanctum 5 лет назад

You know you're in for a rollercoaster ride once you've got Mr. J Sai Deepak on the panel with his stark clarity and insights into the matter. Always a music to ears.