I heard, sometimes ago, Dalai Lama said that he is against “Tibet independence”. We just had Juneteenth, the slave emancipation date (like Passover). And I heard Tibet slavery emancipation date is March 28th. Ain’t that something.
The three poisons, US is using them as much as they can... I don't get why the USA don't focus on their own people and the internal issues they have, they are getting eaten up from the inside, people suffer and die for their politicians vanity and self interests instead of helping the country become better. An USA is attempting and to some extent has already got several European countries to do the same that in the end helps the dollar and US foreign interests.
@livinlavidaluke It seems you are paid agent of Chinese Commi Gang. You talk about Tibets History without historic proof. Even Chinese Commi Gang can't prove it's claim. You talked about bunch of Americans history and in middle of that you again claim that even Dalai lama said '' Tibet is part of China'' what proof you have to claim that. Dalai Lama said that historically Tibet is Independent country, but he said that he will not seeking Independent for Tibet. He wants autonomy for Tibet given by constitution of People's republic of China that's all. But after drafting constitution and given priveledge to minorities for their right than Chinese Commi Gang started to show their real agenda and face. They smashed Tibetan cultural structures and systems. Begin to loot trillion of valuable minerals from Tibet. Even cuts down tree in massive way that they can't export, so they throw in Yantse River collected from mainland China. It is like looted trillions and invested quarter of millions to developed Tibet that too aims to build Tibet a tourist spot and earn money from tourist. If you don't believe me you can personally go there and see yourself. Even most of big shops and office are captured by Han Chinese. Also they migrated millions of Han Chinese and given them best treatment over native Tibetan. Force Tibetan language as second class language and building boarding school particular for Tibetan children to brain wash. Again I called you paid agent of Chinese Commi Gang. If you are not prove me wrong.
China should begin helping Native American Indians reclaim the West from the United states. Under all the modern laws and rules, and the known fact Genocide and land theft was committed and that damage has never been undone, the US West should start to be returned to the Native American tribes. China and other nations should begin to raise the causes for this and see how the US likes it?
China must do that , because it is the truth . But that doesn't change the truth that Tibet was never a part of china , till Mao sent its army to invade
@@iWantPeace838 principles! The only principle china has is to eat live , even during territorial encroachment they salivate thinking of salami slices .
Don't forget the Philippines, which was under American control for half a century and is still a satellite nation. The US would like to make Tibet a satellite too, but even more so, like Taiwan.
If these warmongers so eager and righteous to help other places to become independence. Why don't they start with Texas in their own country? They should start with that to make a good example.
@@hengongchua6250Always were always is whole world Belongs to Bharat and Will always BE . No ones Belong to others than Bharat Akhand Bharat Mahabharat Aryavarta Bharatavarsha Pangeia Gondwana Laurasia Agartala Shambala Shangrila all parts Belong to Akhand Aryavarta Mahabharat Alone Bharatavarsham
"Why is the US getting involved" As if US ever cared about having a reason. 🤣🤣🤣 Free Hawaii, Free Alaska, Free Puerto Rico, Free Texas, Free New Mexico, Free California, Free Guam, Free Gaza.
Same theory: Once you understand why some countries cannot find genocide in Gaza, then you immediately understand why they can find genocide in Xinjiang.
I can not relate to this. Other countries turned a blind eye to the genocide in Gaza. Those who turned a blind eye on Gaza are the same group who fabricated lies about genocide in Xinjiang. Same as Tibet, Xinjiang was not left behind in development and those applying for education are given extra points.
nie jest to takie proste 1 . tybet to królestwo wiec rządził nim król i arystokracja jak wszędzie ale najsilniejsza instytucja w nim był klasztor gelugpa - bardzo to podobne do np Cesarstwa rzymskiego czy tez sutemu władzy w krajach komunistycznych gdzie formalnie krajem zarządzał rzad, ale najsilniejszą instytucją byla partia komunistyczna - problem tybetu była słaba gospodarka wynikająca zamknięcia sie kraju na świat ( podobnie było z chinami ) mi przestrzały system polityczna, społeczno, administracyjno gospodarczy na co nałożyła sie geopolityczna strategia USA - które poprzez kontrole na tybet ( zródło trzech rzek azji) chciały sparować władze nad chinami i reszta azjiprzez co chiny nie miały wyscia i musiał inkorporowac tybet do swojego obszaru
Is crazy people wants to go back to elite, slaver, slaves status. Idk who these separatists are but they aren't for the well being of the Tibetans today. China freed these people from such misery, bring them forward to a more modern state. Don't forget China was not a wealthy rich country back then, they still have their own problems to solve. While these malicious foreign powers keep using greed, temptation to seduce the elites in reuniting with their old power and continue to undermine China's effort while pushing their own agenda through out the world.
Tibet was an authoritarian country with the elite feeding on the produce of the impoverished farmers who could only produce wheat or potatoes once a year. The poor farmers lived in the outskirts of the Potala palace and had the most miserable life one could imagine. The elites were the monks who controlled everything even the gold mine. The land was barren and desolate across, with desperate locals. Everyone was bound by the religion and religious rites, tradition and culture. The progress of modern Tibet is all due to Chinese effort. It would never have been what it is if it weren’t for China.
Tibet has been a part of China for more than 700 years. Before 1950, Tibet was a brutal serfdom under Dalai Lama and had a cast system similar to that of India. The Monastery class were the slave masters and owned 99% of the land in Tibet. As a matter of fact, Dalai Lama was the biggest landlord and slave master and owned more than 6000 slaves. As a result of the brutal treatment of serfs, such as judicial bodily mutilation, Tibetans life expectancy under Dalai Lama was only 32.5 years. Now it has more than doubled.
Has everyone also already forgotten all the photos of the dalai lama with Chairman Mao and other communist leaders. They were happily reunified with China until the Americans started to get in the Dalai Lamas head. His own brother was secretly training soldiers with the CIA for years which they then used for the separatist movement. Whenever there's unrest, you can count on Americans being involved.
@@tenzinchoegyal4067 2000 years ago Tibet according to Tibetan texts was under the Kingdom of Zhanzhung then it was conquered by Songsten Kampoor or TriSong Desten both Tibetans. It was not until 1240 that the Mongolians conquered Tibet. It became part of the Mongolian Empire Just as China had been conquered. On their demise, it became part of the Tibetan Empire. until The Qing took control in 1720. So what is your source that claims it was part of China for 2000 years?
@sotopla1 Well whatever it is Tibet has been part of China for a very very long time and the whole world recognizes this. Why is the USA trying to stir up trouble to separate it from China ?
Those Tibetans who are living outside of Tibet have no say, only Tibetans living inside Tibet have the right to decide for themselves. Those Tibetans who chose to live in the West, be happy of where you are and lets Tibetans living their happy lives in Tibet!
Tibetan who are stying inside Tibet were not happy with Chinese regime. 99% people will follow His Holiness Dalai Lama’s instructions. He is our Guru and everything since 400 years ago.
Won’t you be supporting your family if they are suffering , most of Tibetan living out side of Tibet have relatives inside the Tibet and have great in-depth knowledge of what’s going inside the Tibet as a tibetan living in tibet.so it will mindful if you don’t point out on things which you don’t know fully .
@@RAB-fo3tv Come on, stops the BS, if the Tibetans inside Tibet are not happy, they can leave, why still want to stay, might as well leave and joins the Dai Lama in India? I think it’s the other way round, Tibetans outside Tibet wanted to return seeing Tibetans living a good lives with beautiful houses.
Hello, I am a Tibetan living in Lhasa. I want to say that most Tibetans in Tibet love China very much and hope that China will become better and better.
I know Tibetians. Your are not representing Tibet or it’s people. Your either not actually from there or your being forced to post this. Fact is it is ILLEGAL for anyone in China to watch or comment on youtube. If your there and doing so your working for the government and posting what they tell you to. I have lived there I know how china works. Xiao zhonguo ren
A great brief introduction of Tibet. Don't forget that there are many Tibetans living in neighbouring provinces to Tibet. Show Tibetans, Han, and other ethnic groups living in harmony.
I've written a lot about this, because I'm a Marxist and a Buddhist so it comes up sometimes. (Not that kind of Buddhist though, Tibetan Buddhism is like what Mormonism is to Christianity). Tibet is the US's favorite fallback, after the Xinjiang thing fell apart (and everyone finally found out how bonkers Adrian Zenz is), they were bound to come back to it. If Tibet really became indenpendent again (after the 40 year defacto independence from 1911 to 1951), it would quickly become a theocratic slave state again. The US would be okay with that, we turned Libya into a hellhole and tried to turn Xinjiang into a clone of Afghanistan. But it'll never happen, because this bill is really just a public proclamation that Sinophobia is still cool in the US, no one can actually do anything with it.
When Tibet was already on the map of China thousands years ago. There was still no such country in this world named USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand and Argentina. Even no India too. The country India was gathered up from many different pieces of unknown lands and formed by the colonizer. Before there was no such country.
@@SlimJim3082 , if we look at the indigenous people of the north east 7 sisters state. Their faces, skin colour, cultures, foods they eat are so different from the Indian. They are more like Tibetan, Nepalese, Mongolian and Chinese.
As a failed and failing plot, some folks want to split China into 7 parts: Tibet, Xinjiang, Inner Mongolia, Hong Kong, Taiwan, and the rest of China. :D. China, in itself, is already a hybrid and inclusive ethnic blend. When seen from a racist perspective, they would see many different "races" living together. However, China has practiced mixed or inter-ethnic marriage for thousands of years. There's not "racial segregation" existing here
@@Tashi_delek_10 You must be only know little cut version from Western media The Full history is: - Tibet already part of China in Qing Dynasty 17th Century (Dalai Lamas choosen by Golden Urn which make by Qing) (See Qing Dynasty Map) - Since in Yuan Dynasty 13th Century Tibet part of China, even first Title of Dalai Lama created by Yuan Dynasty (See Yuan Dynasty Map) - The First Unified Tibetan King, Songtsen Gampo are son-in-law of Emperor Taizong Tang Dynasty China 7th Centure (theres twin ancient monument in Xian & Lhasa)
Yes, Tibet is one of the chess pieces US used it against CN. I have seen street show of ethnic groups in New York, representing Chinese is falungong people with political slogan. Hong Kong, Taiwan, Philippines, Xinjiang, Tibet, falungong all are chess pieces. Annual central finance give Xizang 150 billion yuan. Tibet Middle School primary school learns Tibetan language every day. continuous construction and development...US never talk. they made up excuses for trouble. they are Machiavellianism. what a shame
Thank you so much for the video. I have traveled to Tibet myself more than 10 years ago. Indeed they are very religious. A lot of people in the past spent their entire life doing simply one thing - practice buddhism in order to go to heaven. They almost don’t care anything about here and now. Oftentimes we would find a bathroom that stinks the whole block and the next block. And they have lakes and a lot of pipe water. If you ask them why they don’t clean the public toilet, the answer is”what for? Any toilet will become stinky again after you clean it.” We have a middle-aged Tibetan driver who only has one eye. We ask him what happened with his other eye. He answered that he lost it when he was young during a fight after drinking, but the person who hurt his eye is crippled - he chopped it with a machete, so they’re even. That’s what I heard with my own ears. Even Tibet is breathtakingly beautiful, its society would be closer to hell than heaven - dirty, poor, ignorant, savage … if the central Chinese government had not poured so many resources, sent so many people with more advanced technologies, build roads and railways, schools, and hospitals … to make it a more livable and civilized place. Even so, Tibet still has a long way to go. But at the same time every person I met in Tibet are pretty happy with their lives because they do get a lot of support including monetary subsidies from the central government. it’s just very sad and frustrating that the American politicians bombarded the audience with lies upon lies without even stepping into Tibet for one day or talking to a local Tibetan for once.
China should ask the UN to do a study comparing how Tibetans and Uyghurs fare compared to how Australian and N American aborigines(and indigenous Hawaiians) fare in terms of life expectancy, education levels, morbidity, etc. create healthy competition to improve the wellbeing of indigenous peoples!
@@NgawangPhuntsok-vd3oe If there are such self-emulations, I tend to think they are by misguided individuals. Just my guess (since you ask). That said, best to ask them to explain the reasons for their actions; it's hard to understand people's behaviour without knowing the reasons for their behaviour.
Before communist China introduced modern development policies to Tibet, ordinary Tibetans who had been consigned to generations of the slave and farming class were due to continue for generations and there was no foreseeable prospect of that cycle ending. It was a very feudalistic system. Today, ordinary Tibetans have the freedom to pursue businesses or careers of their choice.
President Putin tell President Xi, if you breakup, Russia will be next. President Xi also tells President Putin, if you breakup, China will also be next. So, why not we work together.
I visited Tibet the summer of 1987 when individual travelers were allowed. The people were so friendly and the culture and landscapes are amazing. Having said that it was really poor and infrastructure, especially outside of Lhasa was not good. I have watched a few videos of travelers visiting Lhasa today and the change is like night and day with all the new wealth. We actually took a bus from Ge'ermu, Qinghai on dirt roads to get to Lhasa. Now Chinese and visitors can take a pressurized high speed train.
The U.S. has had a long history of supporting and then suddenly abandoning Tibetan freedom fighters during the Cold War. Tibetan exiles are simply used as geo-political tools, it's a very sad fate.
There is a tibetian town that is between the border of China and India. The China part has lights, plumbing, basic utilities. The india side has nothing. The tibetians in india side frequently move the border markers to make their town part of China. It is the chinese not india authorities that keep putting the border back
China should bring that part of Tibet back to China’s control since the Indians stole that part of Tibet from China with the help of the British empire! At least let the local native Tibetan people vote to decide which country they would like to be a part of! That was what Russia did when it came to the faith of Crimea.
The Chagos affair has been so shameful. So sick of the west's hypocrisy. And what happened to the Catalonian referendum? Oh, that's right, the Catalonian politicians were arrested. Pelosi is yet another example of why there needs to be age limits for politicians.
In Mandarin there is a saying “Just like a toad sitting on your foot, it can't bite you, but it will disgust you". That's what the US has been for many many years, a toad...
We Support the Independence of Haweii, Puerto Rico, Guam, Mauritius and America be handed back to the ORIGIN INDIGIOUS VOLKS. FREE USA from the Colonial White Occupation. ✊🇨🇳✊🇷🇺✊🇨🇳
In short, the Tibetan people formed clans (sai, mu, dang, dun, re and zhu) which were then united into the Tubo kingdom where Songtsen Gempo was appointed as king... Over time, Songtsen Gempo's son wanted to marry his son to the Tang royal princess (Jincheng)... all these forms of unification can be seen in the Tang-Tubo alliance monument which is in front of the door of the Jokhang Temple in Lhasa City,,, where the Tibetan kingdom was given autonomous territory to run its kingdom...
Really enjoyed your video, put your perspective across very well. Having the opportunity to talk with some Tibetans and also having some Tibetan friends, I think you are correct. Personally, I remember one conversation which stood out, “if Tibet was free, it would be open to western influences that would destroy the culture, and MacDonalds would set up shop at every tourist site” I perceive the view of those I talked with as saying they the best choice is China.
About this country their govt must know well the history first than said about Tibet. This country history it just little bit over 200yrs only. But Tibet was been part of China which more than 200yrs before pass many many years decades. So this country their govt have " no right " to talk about Tibet at all same as Taiwan too. China History is over 5000yrs ok. So Taiwan is always part of China which history book been wrote black & white that noone allow to change the history at all 🙄.
Everyone (Mainlander or foreigner) needs a special permit to visit Tibet as a special region (like Chinese passports are invalid to visit Hongkong or Taiwan). But everyone (again Mainlander or foreigner) can travel to Xinjiang freely. The Tibet has been treated differently thanks to Dalai Lama being enrolled in the CIA payroll and staged a mutiny in the late 1950's. I think this special permit requirement could be waived very soon.
It's interesting to say the reason for destabilizing or overthrowing another nation or region is to win votes in an election. That means common Americans are to be blamed for the ills of the world? Thank you for presenting your viewpoint on Tibet, Native Americans and Hawaii.
Agreed, excuse for unilateral sanctioning to those regions thus causing destabilisation does seem plausible reason for inclusion of unrelated regions into Tibet province.
Free Assam, free Khalistan Punjab, free Sikkim, free Manipur, free Dravidian Tamil... And the list goes on. And why is the USA not helping these countries to gain freedom from India???
Tibet has never been part of china ,Tibetian people DNA never matched with chinese rather it matched with Indian ladakhi people ,India and Tibed has similarities but china forcefully occupied Tibet in 1950
@@rahul254751Rahul you are right. Tibet was invaded in 1959. Before that own country, Tibetan language, Tibetan Buddhism, Tibetan kings and empire. different places in Tibet has different accents but they all speak and write Tibetans. And when these foreign RU-vidrs talk as if Tibet and China are one. It is very hurtful to a Tibetan. My family is descendant of Tibetan king lang dharma
Regarding the Yuan dynasty, although the name 'China, meaning Middle Kingdom' had been regularly used before the Yuan dynasty, but Kublai Khan was the first sovereign ruler in Chinese history to officially used the term Middle Kingdom (ie China) in official document, which is his letter to the emperor of Japan written in elegant classical Chinese, which you can find on wiki and the Japan National Archives website. Actually the Mongols did not originate in present day Mongolia, they originated from present day north eastern China and were called Shiwei, and during the Tang dynasty were ruled by the governor-general of Yingzhou. They then migrated to present day Mongolian Steppe after the Turks were chased away to the west by the Tang empire in the 10th century.
British invasions probed as root cause of Tibetan separatism 2008-04-18 Tibet, a region coveted by western nations since the Opium War in the 1840s, has long been an inalienable part of Chinese territory and the Tibetans have been part of the big multi-national Chinese family. The so-called issue of "Tibet Independence," is originally an outcome of aggression by imperialist nations, said a Chinese expert.
Britain launched two invasions into Tibet, in 1888 and during 1903 and 1904, in an attempt to build up an exclusive colonial influence in the region. It also tried to separate Tibet from China and ultimately turn it into a "buffer zone" against British-controlled northern India.
Trust me, even if there’s only 1 out of 1.4 billion people in China wanted Tibet independence, the US would have made it sound like it’s the majority of people in China wanted Tibet to be independent
The local Tibetans have been very closed in their beliefs for thousands of years. After the territory joined the Qing Dynasty and the Republic of China, the central government did not try to change the status quo in Tibet. Tibet is like the Amazon in China. The locals would rather become slaves of the monks for their beliefs, but the CCP changed everything.
A very well infomed focus on Tibet. You obviously came to a similar conclusion to those of us who do our own research and reject biased propaganda from the US. Bottomline is the US is afraid of losin its hegamonic position and will do anything to destabilize and attack China's progress. The evidence is the US has already lost technologically, economiclly increasingly diplomatically and only has a MAYBE military lead. Keep spreading the truth about present Tibetan conditions, including their new high speed rail service.The US has become a destructive force in the world often spearheaded by its NED/CIA support for local terrorist/separatism. Tibet will remain part of China along with Xinjiang as the alternative is US military bases, killing and economic destruction.
Seeing is Believing!!! Before talking, those Politicians need to go to Tibet and speak with the people living there. Life is much easier and everyone can go to School. Especially females, with the Dalai Lama ruling, females were 2nd class. Now, they have schools, hospitals, food,homes to live in, jobs, water, toilets, sewage systems, streets, busses, cars, infrastructure, need I go on?
Dalia Lama himself kept thousands of slaves n asked for a fresh human head to be presented to him on his birthday ! Imagine this happening in Tibet today...
The cry is Free Tibet but was it ever free? When the Dalai Lama left it was a feudal theocracy where over 90 percent of the people were surfs, slaves. The people's revolution saw many of their people in slavery.
Tibet was a sovereign country. Tibet has its own language, people, one governing body, culture. Both utsang, khan and amdo share one language despite the long distance between. No sign of Chinese influence in the history of language, clothing, religion and everything until recent years
Due to Tibet’s geographical isolation. Surrounded by mountains, Himalaya, high altitude , low oxygen. And Tibetans negative view towards foreigners. Tibet as a whole had limited exposure to the outside world. However, during that time many countries were extremely poor even with foreign exposure, countries by the sea etc
@@earthwizz No my friend i am not saying that is right. I am explaining how tibet has ended up in such situation due to isolation from the rest of the world but if you question the openness and willingness to change and transform. Tibet did indeed transform. The tibetan democracy was established in exile in 1960 following the year it was occupied. Dalai continued to take the leadership of spiritual aspect and he has established democracy for tibetans in exile. The willingess to transform and evolve has been answered by this. There were way worse things happening at the time. 6 million jews were murdered by Hitler's Nazi. 6 million is the total estimated population of the tibetans. Under Mao's regime estimated 40-70 million people died. Mauritania abolished slavery only in 1981. WW2 resulted in increasingly inhumane and significantly worsened conditions around many countries. Just because a humble buddhist nation was not at the perfect stage of its transformation at the time does not give another expansionist communist nation to illegally occupy it for its own gains. China does not have democracy right now and continuosly violates human rights. Uyghur concentration camps, inhumane torturing, censorships, media ban, authoritanian regime- does that mean russia or America should illegally occupy it?
Tibetans never had it so good. 70 Years ago, 90% of Tibetans were serfs. The average life expectancy for Tibetans rose from 35.5 years in 1951 to over 67 years by the end of 2010. infant mortality rate dropped from 430 infant deaths per 1,000 in 1951 to 20.69 per 1,000 by the year of 2010. Literacy increased from below 5% to over 90%. There are new schools, hospitals, highways, airports, a high speed rail from Lhasa to Beijing. Tourism is booming, Tibetans live in peace and very rapidly increasing prosperity.
