It also set up the plot of "A Knight to Remember", so Paige couldn't kill her past life either. I loved that one as well. It helped getting to know Paige better and Leo really started to shine in that episode.
The age of when this is happening is all worng. Perl Russell (fans have always thought that was her name and went along with it. Perl) was 30, 1894-1924. But Phoebe was 24. Born Nov 1975 and ep aired Feb 2000. Error on the writers. The other cousins names. People always thought P. Baxter (Piper's past life) is the same. Piper. P. Bowen (Prue's), we think her name is Phoebe. As when they traveled to the 70's, Patty said "Oh I must've named u after my favorite aunt". Browen must've been really close to Patty to think of her as an auntie.
I was just thinking that. I also realized that the birth and death dates are wrong. According to the dates on tree, Penny would have given birth to Patty at 13. On top of that, according to this tree, Penny died in 1968. Ten years before Patty. And before any of the girls were born. But Patty died before Penny, while her children were younger, and taken care of by Penny.
Not even mentioning that in order to have three magical cousins from the same family, you would have to have three magical syblings one generation before that. Meaning that the Halliwells wouldn't be the first Power of Three.
It makes the most sense that her birth year was 1900, which is consistent with the age Phoebe said and also the birth order (Prue, Piper, Phoebe) and the age gaps between them. The family tree was full of errors
Grams's mother was Piper's past life, which explains why she clearly favored her more than Prue or Phoebe. And they should have given more stories of all Halliwells so we'd know what they were like
The best episode ever👑 Alyssa is great as evil and this is the sign that she will be with Cole again becoming evil. Maybe the most real episode of Charmed because I don't think that past lives are just imagination,I think this is real and I hope that there is also a future life really amazing episode❤ But it would be great for us to remember our past lives I don't understand why we don't remember in this life,we can't fix our mistakes because we don't remember.
@2:23 older gen Prue died in May 1972, but new gen Prue was born (according to resources) October 1970. Another thing I noticed is that in one episode Phoebe said Piper was a Gemini, but she's a Leo here. She's definitely, not a Leo, although like Leo😂. One thing is sure, the prod did not see RU-vid coming.
2:21 I'm confused so penny had patty when she was 13? How come it says penny died in 1963 or 68, like 10ish years before patty died. And it says Victor Jones under Patty's name not Bennett. I'm very confused. Can someone explain that 😂😂😂😂
I had a feeling that Patty was a love child from Penny's teen years. And Penjy didn't die in the 60s, she died in 98 in her golden years. Since her first husband was a hippie, Penny was filled with too much love to offer, that that often included lust for Flower Children. My grandmother would know. And Penny never would've let Patty change her last name to Bennett because she was married. It's clear some mistakes were made on either the family tree timeline or marked graves or whatever. So when Patty was flashbacked to the 70s, she was in her early/mid 20s and since she was still an adolescent when her father was murdered
Ok, so Penny's mother's last name from her father's side is Bennett and Penny's father's is Johnny's, that's why. Penny just changed it back to Halliwell because she wanted her reputation to grow as a demon killer
Leo is very suspicious because it is weird when he says that Piper made a mistake what must take the she made to be with Dan in the past life something doesn't seem right about the Leo character at first I used to be I always glamorize Leo and Piper's relationship because I used to be a fan of Leo and Piper's relationship right now I am not a fan anymore of their relationship I think the relationship is very distinct and there's a lot of age Gap in that relationship 0:01 Put Leo physically he is Young 0:01
@@F.R.F937 I'm not sure if you have noticed Piper and Leo have an age difference he's from a distance timeline so he's been around for many years through out of the centuries this gets very weird about Piper and Leos relationship
