Тёмный

The Complete Call of Duty Single Player Campaign Critique (For PC) 

Noah Caldwell-Gervais
Подписаться 286 тыс.
Просмотров 721 тыс.
50% 1

This video is a critique and retrospective of all eleven Call of Duty games released for the PC between 2003 and 2014. It's often said that all Call of Duty games are the same-- they're far from it. Journey through the series chronologically and critically with this sprawling retrospective. Major spoilers throughout!
___TABLE OF CONTENTS___
Call of Duty 1-- 0:48
Call of Duty: United Offensive-- 13:55
Call of Duty 2-- 18:10
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare-- 26:14
Call of Duty: World at War-- 36:40
Modern Warfare 2-- 47:11
Black Ops 1-- 58:00
Modern Warfare 3-- 1:08:11
Black Ops 2-- 1:23:50
Call of Duty: Ghosts-- 1:34:29
Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare-- 1:47:43
Special Thanks-- 2:04:40
If you enjoyed this video, please post it where others can find it!
Also, please consider donating to my Patreon to help me produce these sorts of videos.
/ noahcaldwellgervais

Опубликовано:

 

19 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,6 тыс.   
@brendanprettie4067
@brendanprettie4067 7 лет назад
"Everyone dies and nothing is learned, it's the most honest ending to a Call of Duty game in 4 years" Possibly the most scathing intelligent criticism I have ever heard.
@Paranoid1996
@Paranoid1996 7 лет назад
Which game was he talking about with that line? Sorry it's a two-hour long video so i don't remember.
@darkseidafterdark6580
@darkseidafterdark6580 7 лет назад
BO2.
@dylanrobson3802
@dylanrobson3802 5 лет назад
1:33:41
@brunoactis1104
@brunoactis1104 3 года назад
Someone else have to write a comment in 2 years from now.
@RipTheJackR
@RipTheJackR 3 года назад
Ah, but why wait so long ;)
@troyareyes
@troyareyes 3 года назад
It is amazing how enduring the "PRESS F TO PAY RESPECTS" meme has been, Advance Warfare achieved immortality for that alone.
@Don11037
@Don11037 3 года назад
F for ruining cod with supply drops
@Ezekiel_Allium
@Ezekiel_Allium 2 года назад
The funniest part of that is how culturally ubiquitous it's become, while I frequently forget that advance warfare exists
@kieranhurst8543
@kieranhurst8543 2 года назад
Yeah like how in a lot of multiplayer games people will spam F in the chat when someone dies or the game is won or lost
@Handonforehead
@Handonforehead 2 года назад
Its the one meme that never dies
@sunriseparrabellum5505
@sunriseparrabellum5505 2 года назад
@@Handonforehead that fact alone is ironic as hell given the context of its origins
@GamingHistorian
@GamingHistorian 9 лет назад
This was incredible. Thanks for taking me back to my glory days of high school, playing the original Call of Duty at LAN parties with my buddies. You nailed why it was a good game. Excellent video!
@broadcaststsatic
@broadcaststsatic 9 лет назад
Thanks for watching it and putting in the time, man!
@phoenixzappa7366
@phoenixzappa7366 6 лет назад
Look it's the gaming historian. Love your videos dude
@theminer49erz
@theminer49erz 3 года назад
This is an excellent endorsement! Gaming Historian has even taught me things I didn't know even being there at the times deep into the "hobby"! You are both extremely good at your chosen crafts. It is appreciated!
@naquingreen1603
@naquingreen1603 Год назад
@@broadcaststsatic Great video. However i feel/think COD: Black Ops is Overrated and kind of offensive/xenophobic with with its portrayal of the Vietnam War and the Cold War. The omission of South Vietnamese allies and opposing north Vietnamese women and young teenagers (who also fought) and the blatant lie of Russia using chemical weapons in Vietnam (when it was actually America with Agent Orange)
@naquingreen1603
@naquingreen1603 Год назад
@@broadcaststsatic COD:Black Ops even failed at showing the gray morality of the Cold War with America being depicted as the universal "good guys" and Russia being depicted as the generic evil "bad guys" like they are in Hollywood movies. In my opinion CoD: Black Ops Cold War is better than the original Black Ops mainly because it showed the gray side of the Cold War with America/CIA being depicted as being very shady and at times "evil" (brainwashing the main male or female character into working for them) not helped by the character of Adler. The KGB/Soviets are depicted in a similar light but aren't as bad as the Americans/CIA and the game does give you a choice of either siding with america/CIA or the Soviets.
@samuelmccay4092
@samuelmccay4092 7 лет назад
"Without even wiping the Cheeto dust from your chest hairs..." Holy shit, Noah. You bring out the claws when CoD gets to you.
@Minority119
@Minority119 9 лет назад
I always thought that it was pretty weird how they tried making the airport part so powerful and moving with you shooting so many civillians and civillian security forces and then they went and made that damn place a multiplayer map
@Bone8380
@Bone8380 5 лет назад
Well it did end up being one of the best maps in the history of CoD multiplayer, so I'd say its worth it. Besides, the multiplayer should have no bearing on the singleplayer's narrative at all.
@AbstractTraitorHero
@AbstractTraitorHero 4 года назад
@@Bone8380 It kinda does cheapen the feel a little of what happened kinda at least a little.
@parijatha1373
@parijatha1373 4 года назад
This game was s awesome it had awesome storyline
@Guinnessdrnkr1234
@Guinnessdrnkr1234 4 года назад
I always figured No Russian was a pure publicity stunt. So many people wanted to play that game after seeing the outrage it was causing on Fox News. It’s the same reason GTA V is one the most popular games ever. Pissing off a bunch of boomers is great for business.
@demilembias2527
@demilembias2527 3 года назад
its obvious why, that part of the game is fucking stupid and was never intended to be anything different. it was meant to generate controversy and get the game free advertising by way of concerned fox news reports
@allotheabove123
@allotheabove123 9 лет назад
I still LOVE World at War as a game. Many of its levels (namely Stalingrad and the Reichstag) are some of my favorites in any Call of Duty game. But the way you tore it apart was really interesting. I never thought about World at War that way before. This video really makes me want to go and play through the whole series again just so I can come to my own conclusions. Excellent video by the way. Totally subscribing.
@chompyoface
@chompyoface 9 лет назад
***** I like your interpretation. It puts into words the reasons I enjoyed it so much. Of course, it was also my favourite multiplayer in the whole series. Fuck trying to beat it on Veteran though.
@simonjones2395
@simonjones2395 9 лет назад
chompyoface Everyone always talks about how hard it is on Veteran. I didn't believe them. Then I tried it. It was possibly the most frustrating couple of days of my life. I eventually put the playthrough on pause. Not because I sucked, well maybe, but because after trying to beat "Their Land, Their Blood" for about an hour and a half my Xbox froze. Right at the end of the mission. All that work, gone. Then last year I beat all 3 Modern Warfare games on Veteran and it was interesting seeing them get (IMO) easier. After struggling with MW1 (fuck No Fighting in the War Room) I found myself beating MW3 in about 6 hours. Veteran needs to be harder again, just for people to have some reason to go back through the campain. Oh and yeah WAW is my fav in the series also.
@RandomRelay
@RandomRelay 9 лет назад
***** Read about the "Rape of Nanking" and "Unit 731", the scenes of brutality in CoD are quite tame compared to what they historically did. This is a foe that is prepared to disobey orders for the sake of "glory". General Tomoyuki Yamashita ordered his troops to pull out of Manila. In spite of this however they disobeyed orders and without aid of nuclear weapons, killed a hundred thousand civilians in the Manila Massacre "100,000 burned, bayoneted, bombed, shelled and shrapneled dead in the span of 28 days. Unborn babies ripped from their mothers’ wombs provided sport: thrown up in the air and caught, impaled on bayonet tips...Hospitals were set afire after their patients had been strapped to their beds. The corpses of males were mutilated, females of all ages were raped before they were slain, and babies’ eyeballs gouged out and smeared on walls like jelly.” From: globalnation.inquirer.net/99054/february-1945-the-rape-of-manila/#ixzz3WLkI9tnd
@thejourney2point0
@thejourney2point0 9 лет назад
Simon Jones the only reason i found WaW so difficult was the enemy grenade spam, which is lazy difficulty i think. seriously, its a constant barrage of 3-4 enemies throwing grenades one after another
@simonjones2395
@simonjones2395 9 лет назад
Oh I know, "Their Land, Their Blood" was a bitch for that. Tight trenches with dudes around each corner, lobbing grenades at you. Arrrrggh!
@JohnnyElRed
@JohnnyElRed 8 лет назад
I completly disagree with your vision of soviet campaign in "World at War". In the soviet front, Reznov doesn't stop to encourage you, by saying others how much of a good soldier you are. How of a great hero you are. In the other hand, he dismisses Chernov all the time, because he doesn't fires as much, or isn't as comfortable as you killing. He is the one that begs for mercy for the captured german soldiers while you shoot the injured in the floor. He is the one treated as a coward because he keeps a more time writing in his diary than "gloriously" fighting for the mother Russia. He is the one that, as in the first game, tries to enter in the Reichstag with the flag, but gets burned alive after a few steps. Tries to be brave without killing, and fails miserably. Then, when you start the next mission, and you listen to the diary of Chernov, everything makes sense: "When he first spoke of Dimitri, Reznov told tales of a hero, someone we should all aspire to be like. At times, I have seen him show mercy, and at others, complete brutality. I do not understand him. Perhaps heroes need not question their actions." The quote changes depending of your actions, but the point is the same. Chernov doesn't understand how someone being brutal as Dimitri, can be named as a hero. Makes the point clear. It's like talking to the player saying: "Do you think you are a war hero, little monster? For what? For all the people you have killed?" The first level in Stalingrad let's you see the horrible acts of the nazis, so you can compare them to your own acts later. You are not a hero. You act exactly as the nazis would do. You are a monster of the same kind. And the game makes you feel comfortable in that role so you don't question it until the death of Chernov. So he can slap you in the face, by tricking you in doing all of that.
@calebgonzalez6418
@calebgonzalez6418 8 лет назад
I see what you mean, but the point could've been made stronger. Players more often than not completely ignore that plot point.
@aleksanderolbrych9157
@aleksanderolbrych9157 8 лет назад
Is it the developers' fault that many players ignore the storyline altogether? Usualy if someone's into the story, they focus on the story, if not they dimiss it from the get-go (or very quickly). Anyhow, I fully agree with Johny's view on WaW. Treyarch's games are, in my opinion, probably the most throughtful, subversive and anti-war out of all the CoD tities, but it often goes under the radar because people often focus on what's on their forefront (excess violence and brutality) without caring much with the details (which often change the way you view that violence and brutality in the first place).
@Kelis98
@Kelis98 8 лет назад
Completely agree.
@nathaneskin3572
@nathaneskin3572 8 лет назад
+purplexenno Actually the German foot soldiers were kept in check and not permitted to do things like that. The SS did terrible things to civilians, but the regular soldiers were heavily discouraged from doing so.
@purplexenno
@purplexenno 8 лет назад
Nathan Eskin yes, that whole "discouraged" buisness. Wish real life worked that way (please note, I have talked to people who were there. My wife's family is from Kiev and i've heard what happened from the people who went through it. Things aren't always the way governments or armies say they are)
@DehOtherGuy
@DehOtherGuy 9 лет назад
It's really interesting to see a very well thought out, in depth analysis of a series where any possible depth is ignored by most people today. I enjoy the fact that you have a very, "Hold on, let's really think about this," attitude towards what you see as the positives and negatives of something when others might simply jump on the loudest bandwagon. Great video, you really deserve more subscribers. On another note, could you possibly consider doing a video on the Battlefield series, or the recently released Pillars of Eternity?
@DamianOchramowicz
@DamianOchramowicz 3 года назад
I'm afraid, that multiplayer games are not really Noah's thing... But on the other hand, Battlefield games tend to have really terrible singleplayer campaigns, so there might be a lot to unpack by Noah, and I would totally love to hear him rambling.
@connorp3764
@connorp3764 3 года назад
I know this is a really old comment, but if you want more of this, I'd suggest checking out face full of eyes, he does some good analysis of the aesthetics and themes of World at War and Modern Warfare.
@Beeney1984
@Beeney1984 9 лет назад
There is no other upload I greet with more joy than yours. Always the best stuff.
@woodentable4765
@woodentable4765 9 лет назад
i agree
@afterburner7847
@afterburner7847 9 лет назад
wooden table How can you do anything? You are just a wooden table.
@TheRotfox
@TheRotfox 9 лет назад
Watched this beginning to end in one sitting. Concise and on point throughout its entirety. I can only hope there will be more of these to come. Bravo and well done.
@broadcaststsatic
@broadcaststsatic 9 лет назад
I've been doing them for a couple years-- be sure to check out my previous videos if you enjoyed this one!
@misterscienceguy
@misterscienceguy 8 лет назад
I suppose my problem with Russian campaigns is that they often perpetrate bizarre myths about russian human waves (including the myth about soldiers not getting a rifle). This concept arose as an explanation amongst the Heer/Wehrmacht as the reason for their defeats was due to being outnumbered rather than being outmanoeuvred or beaten due to poor hardware (German hardware was notoriously unreliable in the late war, especially their more advanced tanks). You do note this point in the video, though it seems like popular culture continues to perpetuate this myth.
@Mortablunt
@Mortablunt 7 лет назад
Enemy At The Gates is trash. The Russians have made their own films about it. WW1 was when not everyone could have a gun. By WW2, they didn't have that problem. Human wave attacks also weren't a thing. Charges supported by tanks and artillery, yes. Just swarming with infantry? No.
@PSspecialist
@PSspecialist 4 года назад
@Daddy George ok boomer
@adrianshephard378
@adrianshephard378 4 года назад
a lot of germans had ptsd from killing unarmed russian soldiers
@UntoTheBreach24
@UntoTheBreach24 4 года назад
@Daddy George fun history fact - all Nazis were issued a gallon of piss to chug each day; whole legions of dog-brained vile fucking losers, just going to fucking _town_ on a hot jug of piss every day until they all died like a pile of earthworms getting run over by a cement mixer Today they are succeeded by some embarrassing shit-assed teenagers and grifters who carry on their proud piss-guzzling legacy of making the world worse on purpose, smugly
@burtbiggum499
@burtbiggum499 4 года назад
You need to do some reading. Russian leadership was garbage in the early days of the war due to the purges. They bought their skills with gallons of blood.
@EldritchAugur
@EldritchAugur 9 лет назад
Well... Two hours later and I'm now thinking about Call of Duty games from a political and artistic perspective. THE FUCK JUST HAPPENED?!
@daltonsiler2046
@daltonsiler2046 9 лет назад
I know right? I just assumed CoD was a series not worthy of higher thought.
@EldritchAugur
@EldritchAugur 9 лет назад
Dalton Siler I have a lot of fond memories of the first few games from when I was a kid. I remember playing Call of Duty 4 as a teenager and being blown away by it but was really turned off by Modern Warfare 2's Michael Bay action movie aesthetic the game chose to adapt. So I haven't played any of the Call of Duty games as an adult, now I kind of want to go back and play them again.
@daltonsiler2046
@daltonsiler2046 9 лет назад
+Kolbe Howard I think I may hold off for awhile longer before I decide to go back. I've never cared much for CoD's shooting and it's jingoism in the later titles exausted me. It's nice to see CoD trying to do something interesting recently, though. Hopefully that continues
@eusouocarameuirmao
@eusouocarameuirmao 9 лет назад
Noah happened
@ThePolistiren
@ThePolistiren 9 лет назад
***** Long comment ahead. Seems you've looked at this too much in tunnel vision. Being exposed to hyperbole and "feelings", most likely; the video has too much political bias over cold pragmatism. Case and point, complaining about racism, regarding black people, in a game series with predominantly white villains; or this was just regarding nationalism bias, in witch case the NPCs race should not have been brought up, yet it seems to be so intentionally. Also, this is playing fiction police; I'm not convinced this has any sort of merit. Nevermind the notion calling apathy racist. How do you logically follow from "it doesn't care" therefore "it's racist"? You can't realistically expect political correctness in real life, so why in fiction? That complain felt out of the "firemen have men in the name" or "feminism has female in the name" type of critique. And politics don't work in a critique due to their lack of empiricism. We can calculate and make algorithms when we're dealing with atomic theory, we can't do that with right wing/left wing/fascism/libertarianism/etc. What's to objectively say about whether or not to allow freedom for neo-Nazi views or ban them for the sake of alleged cultural progress? I'd like to think we were better in the past, before politics and activism came in. Those cause alienation, conflict, paranoia and conspiracy theories. Back in the day we praised The Longest Journey, now we call Life is Strange tumblr shit; back then we laughed at Postal, now we call for Hatred to be burned at the stake; those pair of games are really not that different, the cultural . Being Romanian, so eastern European, I can confirm the extreme Russian nationalism from MW2 is not that far off the beaten path. Being a society grown in communism and being cut off the rest of the world does strengthen national pride to fanatical levels. Plenty of people here are still rather critical of democracy, social and financial freedoms, etc. and demonizing United States as a result; my grandfather does think they are run by Masons and he's not senile or anything. Though the real problems with that story are logistics in nature, bending the space-time-continuum, actually. And how did they know that what's his face was a CIA agent or that he didn't try to stop Makarov? CoD is designed through marketing parameters and presented as such. The games themselves are rather useless, with the exception of 2-3 games, to have such an approach in their regards. I mean look at the video itself: 1) World at War was oversaturated violence; 2) MW2 and 3 was marketing with shocking biteless scenes; one was an airport with no children cause political ethics were a thing in its development (fun fact: notice how the overly controversial Hatred does the same thing; ), the other smokes stuff out of your view; 3) Ghost is popcorn material; Critiquing symptoms rather than causes, or in some cases things that simply aren't there is rather useless and misguided. This armchair philosophy does become an issue in parts of this video and videogame discussions nowadays in general. I think Matthewmatosis put it best in his Bioshock Infinite Critique; people want to justify their existence, so they'll add meaning and blow things out of proportion giving the impression there is something to be said when there really isn't; look above, I've summed up 4 games in a few sentences. If you still don't believe me, ask yourself this: what choices can you now make in the real world, with real predictable consequences? That's the only way I see value been given to any sort of analysis, something even Tolkien took into consideration when writing LotR (and why it does not have any allegory in it, yet people still claim the contrary; another example as to why you shouldn't read too much into things). On a more, perhaps, aggreable note, war games that feel real could be created. Brothers in Arms were really good in that regards. Maybe with game mechanics from Bohemia Interactive shooters they would truly feel real.
@Furetchen
@Furetchen Год назад
Saw someone, a veteran of the post-MW CoDs, go back and stream his experiences of CoD 1 and 2. Every so often a moment would hit and he'd sit back and say something like "Man... people *did* this." And I think that illustrates your points perfectly. Great games, great fun... and if you have any perspective at all, they'll give you a moment of reflection.
@Mortablunt
@Mortablunt 8 лет назад
You completely failed to understand WAW. World at War was meant to make war look like absolute fucking hell. And in case you didn't notice, *YOU* can do things that are just as brutal as the enemy, like murder prisoners, kill fleeing people, essentially give no quarter, just like the Japanese and Germans do in it. Things like the bayonet minigames were meant to put you right up into the brutality to experience the horror. The sniper duel was meant to be fucking terrifying. The Soviet campaign was meant to show that everyone does some truly horrible things, even if they are on the side vindicated by history. The portrayal of the Japanese in WaW is actually pretty goddamn accurate. The ending of World at War told the truth, that all the horrible, brutal, hellish fun you'd just had, actually happened to people just like you, and it was the most destructive, monstrous, deadly war in human history. That seems very fucking anti war to me.
@4T3hM4kr0n
@4T3hM4kr0n 8 лет назад
In my opinion treyarch should have done that tone with a WWI shooter. WWI was the most brutal of all, stalemate,illness, poisin gas, starvation.
@gwen3504
@gwen3504 8 лет назад
It's just a retread of stuff the series already did with more ham acting and nihilism. There's no point to miss if the game as a whole is pointless.
@Kelis98
@Kelis98 8 лет назад
+Triscuitable, except it's not (a retread pointless, etc.)
@Kelis98
@Kelis98 8 лет назад
Completely agree.
@gwen3504
@gwen3504 8 лет назад
Yosef Yonin Nothing's wrong with me. I said "retread". Read more closely next time.
@matman000000
@matman000000 9 лет назад
I really enjoyed your video, but I disagree with your criticism of World at War. It might have seemed strange and like a betrayal of the previous installments, but it retrospect after Black Ops, it's obvious that Treyarch always wanted to go for a different, more pulpy take, instead of just copying the style of Infinity Ward. I didn't find the violence self-indulgent and sadistic, quite the opposite. WaW was the first CoD where it felt like I was shooting actual people rather than moving targets. Shooting a hundred Germans in CoD 1 or a hundred Arabs in MW felt like target practice, but tearing a few enemies to pieces with MG in WaW was a pretty shocking experience. WaW focused on the blood and dirt of war that was missing in previous installments. It just didn't try to make the violence simply disgusting or moralizing and you could still enjoy it in a similar way as the violence in The Wild Bunch. I also don't find the game racist. Japanese military commited multiple war crimes corparable with Nazis, sometimes even worse. The rape of Nanking or Japanese human experiments are some of the most disgusting examples of cruelty by any cultural standard, yet these are often completely overlooked or excused because of a different culture. So how come that German Nazis can be constantly portrayed as the most evil and worthless part of the history of mankind, yet portraying WW2 Japanese as enemies using questionable tactics is racist?
@fuzzydunlop7928
@fuzzydunlop7928 5 лет назад
This is a truthful depiction of the historicity of the war - what you lack is the understanding that Call of Duty isn't actually based on the history it pretends to portray - it's based on media. It's based on film and television. You would never have Peleliu and Okinawa levels without the Pacific - you would never have the violence without the fact that The Pacific cranked up the violence and degradation and the viscera beyond what had been shown in the plucky Band of Brothers sister-series in order to be more truthful to the setting - there would be no Stalingrad fountain sequence without a Stalingrad fountain sequence in Enemy at the Gates - no desperate house-to-house fighting without desperate house-to-house fighting in 1992's Stalingrad. No Berlin destruction without the depiction in Downfall. Call of Duty's greatest lie is that it attempts to portray history when it absolutely does not - it portrays a derivative facsimile of a place and time that once was real, its violence isn't a reflection of real-world violence it's a reflection of its source material being violent - without The Pacific, there is no World at War - don't let this game fool you into thinking it has a lofty purpose or goal. It doesn't. The violence in the game, is just violence - any justice it does to history is as accidental as its equal amount of historical farbs. "The first man takes the rifle..."
@Desmond9100
@Desmond9100 4 года назад
@Fuzzy Dunlop The Pacific came out in 2010. World at War came out in 2008. I believe the game isn´t trying to show how it really happend just trying to be a fun shooter while getting players interested in history, to get players to study it for themselves. I enjoy learning about WW2 I also enjoy playing WW2 games and watching WW2 movies/TV shows knowing fullwell that there are many inaccuracies.
@majik5194
@majik5194 4 года назад
Yea he kinda dropped the ball at that point in the video for me.
@4thdimension526
@4thdimension526 4 года назад
No
@SaberRexZealot
@SaberRexZealot Год назад
The virgin MW2 airport level VS The chad Max Payne 3 airport level
@themocaw
@themocaw 3 года назад
"He gave you that arm. It's your killin' arm. "Give it back." That gave me chills. And it's about a silly Call of Duty game.
@jengwong
@jengwong 6 лет назад
You by far one of the most articulate, intellectual, and interesting video game/personality on this entire platform. Every thing on this channel is a blast. Thank you for making these amazing videos.
@FNsquirrelhatesyou
@FNsquirrelhatesyou 9 лет назад
finally I found a person analyzes beyond games the graphics and gameplay. Who critiques games the same way people critique other forms of art. great video. You made me completely re-think idea about the story of COD: advanced warfare other than being a completely predictable story. Looking forward to future videos.
@venaretro5444
@venaretro5444 8 лет назад
+FNsquirrelhatesyou Then you havent shearched that much.
@PinkFloydrulez
@PinkFloydrulez 8 лет назад
+FNsquirrelhatesyou you might like Errant Signal or Game Maker's Toolkit
@venaretro5444
@venaretro5444 8 лет назад
PinkFloydrulez Check out "Games as Lit(erature)"
@ShallowContrarian
@ShallowContrarian 8 лет назад
+FNsquirrelhatesyou MatthewMatosis and MrBTongue are really good, check em' out.
@venaretro5444
@venaretro5444 8 лет назад
Bob Lobos Sorry man,English is my third language.
@goncalolourenco9804
@goncalolourenco9804 2 года назад
I love how immortal all these videos are. Thank you for your contribution to the world
@aspizak
@aspizak 8 лет назад
kudos for work you're doing here, it feels like documentaries about (what many of us love so much) video games. Your videos almost make me feel like i'm not appreciating some games enough. I try actively promote your content wherever i can, fantastic work. hats off.
@HeadsFullOfEyeballs
@HeadsFullOfEyeballs 8 лет назад
The US invasion segments of MW2 are kind of strange to play as a non-American. Like, I can *tell* they expect me to be moved or at least impressed by the imagery. Except to a German, an American plywood suburb or strip mall is just as much a foreign, seen-on-TV setting as a favela. So it all falls weirdly flat -- seeing the White House on fire has about the same impact on me as the obligatory shot of the Taj Mahal getting blown up in a disaster movie. It's one of those touristy national symbols you see in movies a lot, nothing more. I'm also surprised none of the WWII Call of Duties have a German campaign, looking back. You'd think having the player fight a losing battle for a dying ideology they may or may not ever have believed in would be right up their street, tonally. You could even have the other nations' campaigns bracketed by a German one -- at the start you invade Poland or France or whatever, and the early victories tempt the player to feel good about their success and identify with the German war. And then towards the end, you play some poor Volkssturm fucker with a hastily soldered-together pipe rifle trying to surivive while their hometown is being firebombed by the Americans or shelled by the Russians.
@decem_sagittae
@decem_sagittae 5 лет назад
True.
@emprsnm9903
@emprsnm9903 5 лет назад
Good idea on the German campaign. Fighting against all odds despite the bleak probable outcome, would be right up their alley. Done well, it would tell a deep story on the price of ideology, whichever the ideology might be, no matter which side you are fighting on and for. Sadly, in these times where people are afraid to offend anyone over anything, and pander to whoever has the cash to buy the game; I doubt we'll see such a campaign in a major game franchise. An indie studio would be the only ones to take the chance with their perception to the general public. We know publications would have a field day crying outrage over, even portraying the third reich as anything other than pure monsters. Though everyone in WWII had an ideology, and was willing to fight to death for it. Human wars are funny that way, ideology and greed make them happen, nobody really wins, nobody really learns. Just like a fist to the face never changes anyones mind about something.
@SOMEGUY7893
@SOMEGUY7893 4 года назад
@@emprsnm9903 "Just like a fist to the face never changes anyones mind about something." This along with some of the other stuff you said kinda makes me think you want a game where you can play as Nazi German soldier for different reasons than you're implying.
@emprsnm9903
@emprsnm9903 4 года назад
@@SOMEGUY7893 Do you truely believe that beating a person into submission makes the world a better place? Even in these times of anti-bullying? I think education trumps force every time. Either I failed to express my point of view properly, or your operating under a number of preconceptions. To be direct, I indentify with Mahatma Gandhi's actions and beliefs, and not national socialism. If that doesn't make my pov crystal clear, nothing will. What I expressed, was the same ideological struggle humanity fought for in 'The Lord of the Rings', as well as the rebels in 'Star Wars'. Is it 'wrong think' to play as Sauron, or 'The Empire' for a change? I can seperate my personal views from a video game, or movie to be entertained by a narritive. Where the stuggle itself is worth exploring, the humanity of that stuggle, the failings of humanity in that narritive. Learn the 'why's' and 'how's' of history and humanity, not just the labels and facts. Thats how you truely don't repeat mistakes of the past. Additionally, some of the most moving stories are of when one realizes they were fighting for 'the wrong and evil' side, personally I love a well crafted redemption arc. It worked for Darth Vader :)
@elroyscout
@elroyscout 4 года назад
This sounds like something I could get behind playing... but I doubt a company would be crazy enough to try it. Building it would be an INCREDIBLY wobbly tightrope of tone and message, and even if they get it right, FOX news and its ilk would be on the developers ass like white on rice. Still, if someone had enough brass in their system to try it, would like a playable version of the 1993 German Stalingrad movie
@TempusFugit78
@TempusFugit78 8 лет назад
I've never played any of the CoD games and I found this fascinating.
@LordCHull
@LordCHull 9 лет назад
I like your video, but I would have to disagree with you on WaW being a pro war game. It does not revel in its violence. If anything it revolts you with it. In reality war is a brutal thing. It is the most disgusting act of humanity. The previous WW2 CoD games were built around comradery of Hollywood blockbusters where as Treyarch's approach in WaW was to display war for all of it's savagery. The reason you don't understand the nuance of the Japanese cultural difference is that you are too busy blowing off their heads, and that can be fairly reflective of the reality. If anything WaW was the first CoD . . . hell the first shooter I actually considered the people I was shooting as you know . . . a person (granted a simulation of one). The horrifying use of the flamethrower, and don't even get me started on the Russian campaign. I had to turn the game off for a few days after the scene in Berlin where you are given the choice to burn or shoot the surrendering Germans. By this point already feeling worse and worse I chose to shoot them, but they are still lit aflame anyway. It wasn't until Spec Ops the Line I got such a reaction from playing first person shooters, and although WaW definitely wasn't anyway near on the sheer horror that Spec Ops the Line is, it still had an effect
@viettrungtran4500
@viettrungtran4500 9 лет назад
Chandler Hull Same here bro. WaW first, then The Line. After that... come Black Ops 2, the first CoD where you only want to get the bad end because you love the Bad Guy.
@kireta21
@kireta21 9 лет назад
My guess is, he didn't get to watch The Pacific, which was for World at World what Band of Brothers was for first Call of Duty games
@LordCHull
@LordCHull 9 лет назад
kireta21 He'll knowing history it was a cruel fucked up conflict. Also judging war crimes on culture is a cop out. Japanese war crimes were still atrocious even if their Emperor ordered it.
@TheXenuite
@TheXenuite 9 лет назад
Chandler Hull Yeah, this was where he lost me on the more 'social' commentary he was throwing into the overall review. What he, and others, perceived as 'jingoistic' elements were historically accurate (though modified heavily) and it seemed a big disgusting that he would excuse their actions for no particular reason, especially since Japanese war crimes are often ignored and forgotten, making World at War somewhat important in reintroducing the concept to the current generation.
@KironVB
@KironVB 9 лет назад
+Chandler Hull Its racist and jingoistic in a similar way CoH2 is towards Soviets, it only shows the atrocities, one after another, it only presents the Japanese as cartoon villain baby eaters, there is nothing showing the Japanese mindset or that in reality the Japanese army as well was made up of mostly conscripts forced into a "holy war", which is why he brought up Letters from Iwo Jima, to show that the Japanese were humans as well and had their own nuanced cultural justifications for what they did. Also another scene of note shows the Soviets as evil as well, the burning of PoWs. This scene is actually from a Soviet movie, Come and See, but the difference is that the Soviets decide to just shoot the Nazis
@ARSP333
@ARSP333 9 лет назад
Noah, you earn every single like you get.
@coldberserk
@coldberserk 9 лет назад
Indeed.In every single video of him you can see how much effort and care he put in. For someone who doesn't do YT fulltime that is really impressive.
@RedlegsBluelegs
@RedlegsBluelegs 2 года назад
The Funeral in Advanced Warfare could have worked if it didn't actually ask anything of the player but rather just let them explore the scene, talk to the other mourners, give them a couple of meaningful interactive objects and leave when they were ready to leave. The problem is the button prompt is so garish, so obvious and sincere in its need to hold the players hand, and tell them exactly what the character is doing when the visual language of the scene has already told the player anyway.
@drifter402
@drifter402 2 месяца назад
It's more first person cutscenes. It's stupid
@timothymclean
@timothymclean Месяц назад
Take away the button prompt and the funeral could have been unremarkable. Maybe it makes for a worse cutscene and a worse game, but I'm glad it's there.
@SirBlacknoiseIII
@SirBlacknoiseIII 8 месяцев назад
That's a very poor reading of world at war. I don't see how "glory and honor" in the previous CoDs is wholly anti war while having a savage and painful depiction of the horrors of the pacific front and barbarossa is fetishising it. Ask a chinese, indonesian, korean, indian or any allied PoW how they were treated and you will have your "non-western standards"
@kieranhurst8543
@kieranhurst8543 7 месяцев назад
because combined with the music and aesthetics, it's trying to be cool.
@brandon8045
@brandon8045 15 дней назад
The problem isn’t with the depiction of pacific front barbarism the problem is the badass distorted guitars and overly edgy tone of the whole thing
@archnacho7581
@archnacho7581 9 лет назад
I really enjoyed not only the obvious effort that had to have gone into this incredible analysis, but your own personal style of clear speaking and thinking that so expertly conveyed a wealth of information spanning history, politics, and even film. Very nicely done, will look forward to more of this in your future
@dejureclaims8214
@dejureclaims8214 9 лет назад
Fifteen minutes in and this is really astoundingly good. Concise, trenchant, and genuinely enlightening. I'm reminded that this series had really strong roots. I raise my ginger tea to you, sir.
@TheDominitri
@TheDominitri 9 лет назад
***** You have been enlightened by a Call of Duty review, alright pal calm down
@dejureclaims8214
@dejureclaims8214 9 лет назад
TheDominitri _enlighten_ verb [WITH OBJECT] Give (someone) greater knowledge and understanding about a subject or situation. -Oxford Dictionaries
@Tudorgeable
@Tudorgeable 9 лет назад
+ for ginger tea
@Weenmeen
@Weenmeen 9 лет назад
Yah calm down with those big words hot shot. Your gunna give me a headache.
@thewayfarer8849
@thewayfarer8849 9 лет назад
***** + for "trenchant, - for "ginger tea" ;)
@robcain8865
@robcain8865 9 лет назад
I've never seen a critique as deep and comprehensive as yours. You made me (and probably many others) think about the Call of Duty series in a way we never thought possible. Suffice to say, you deserve far more recognition and views for your excellent work!
@awalloftext
@awalloftext 9 лет назад
Seriously amazing stuff - so glad I found this channel. I've actually been a pretty avid player of the CoD campaigns, at least up until the last two years or so. I loved the tone of this video; touching on the transition from "morally ambiguous war approximation" to "pulpy shlock adventure" is something that I really appreciate. Personally, while not the most clever of the series, MW2 has ended up as my enduring favorite - carefully straddling the line between harrowing war portrayal and silly action movie romp (perhaps a little more toward the latter) in a way that I haven't found in any recent game.
@I_Want_Peace_World_Peace
@I_Want_Peace_World_Peace Год назад
World at War was done so dirty in this video, I think Face Full of Eyes video of the games aesthetics really dismantles a lot of the arguments within this video. I love Noah's content, but the scathing and dismissive nature he approached WaW in particular rubs me the wrong way.
@mayorofbagtown9097
@mayorofbagtown9097 11 месяцев назад
Same. Its the only time that I haven't been anywhere near the same page as Noah on a review. His take on WaW kinda lives in my head rent free, not gonna lie. Like, everything about it is wrong. Its like he played it with blinders on or something, i don't even know.
@OCMOOO
@OCMOOO 9 лет назад
Hohohoho! A new Noah video, bring out the tea!
@cacharadon7460
@cacharadon7460 9 лет назад
El Mooo Gonna need refills for this video
@minimme
@minimme 9 лет назад
This video is excellent! Great job
@chilldude30
@chilldude30 2 месяца назад
Minime in the wild! Love your videos mate
@muchfunnysuchcomedy
@muchfunnysuchcomedy 6 лет назад
I never got a pro war vibe from WaW, though I was relatively young at the time I originally played it, so that may have to do with it. I remember being incredibly disgusted by all the gore when I played it. Still personally one of my favorites of the series, beneath CoD 2 and CoD 4, but I still genuinely really enjoyed it.
@trombonegamer14
@trombonegamer14 3 года назад
Same. Plus multi-player and zombies in that game was incredibly fun
@SylentVoidkeeper
@SylentVoidkeeper 3 года назад
@@trombonegamer14 So many fond memories of me and my brother playing split screen, constantly hiding in buildings with bouncing betties and just having a good old time
@stephensmith7327
@stephensmith7327 3 года назад
He does also ignore how imoral the Japan army was at the time. I mean, while portraying them as being "genetically pre desposed to barbarism" is fucking sickening, I doubt the government that funded unit 731 is all that concerned with the Sanctity of Human Life.
@stephensmith7327
@stephensmith7327 3 года назад
@IntrepidFinch well, they where uniquely cruel during that time, mostly because the imperial Japanese congress didn't ratify the Geneva Convention, wich is what led to Unit 731's creation. This is also why the Pacific theater of War had the highest percentage of prisoner death of W.W.2. But the U.S. isn't the bigger man during this, we granted those scientists immunity in exchange for exclusive access to the data they acquired. The U.S. also bombed boats carrying U.S. Prisoners. Japan was also not the only country to sign but not ratify the Geneva Convention, the USSR also did not ratify it.
@joshburns969
@joshburns969 3 года назад
@IntrepidFinch During the Rape of Nanking two Japanese officers had a contest to see how many chinese heads they could cut of in a minute. Thats not propaganda or hyperbole, that is a true verifiable fact. The japanese army during ww2 was cruel to a point rivaling the worst of the Nazis
@GreedAndSelfishness
@GreedAndSelfishness 5 лет назад
I dont get how you see WaW as pro-war. It shows wars cruelty and its ugliness better than any other WWII game. I dont see how gory=pro-war in your mind. As for the whole guitar rocking in the background, I think its to portray the mindset of the soldiers, you have to think violently when in this setting. You do become a killer in this environment. The russian campaign especially shows how merciless war truly is.
@astupiddvdcase
@astupiddvdcase 8 лет назад
Your analysis was pretty good til World at war. You say that WAW had no political message and treyarch made the game gorey just because it was a shooting game but anyone who played it knew it was part of the consistent with the tone of the game. WaW was probably one of the first WWII media to shift from the "good war" to show the unrelenting brutality of WWII. The entire game was trying to smack home that point, there is a reason why Treyarch chose the Pacific theatre and the eastern front because those two theatres were the most brutal in WWII. The brutality done unto the americans by the japanese and the germans unto the russians and vice versa as a response is well documented and to make a "clean game" a "sympathetic game" would be a betrayal to the overall tone of the game as well as the attempt to show that sometimes, there is no subtle nuance to the brutality of war. You say the game is racist against the Japanese, and you would probably like it to be more sympathetic explaining the reasons for the indoctrination of japanese but that is beyond the point i feel. portraying the japanese in a "sympathetic light" showing them as victims of a few elites can be a Historical plausibility isnt historical reality. Its akin to "Generation WAr" painting all these germans as morally conflicted when in reality most Germans in the eastern front were highly indoctrinated and probably enjoyed committing genocide on slavs and jews,You wouldnt call Reznov a bad person but he had no problem torturing or murdering german POWs, hell he probably enjoyed it and slept quiet well after doing it which brings to the point that, The people who raped, murdered and committed large scale genocide at most times enjoyed it and went home to live a perfectly normal life.
@genkispt
@genkispt 8 лет назад
+astupiddvdcase thank you, the further i got into the WaW part the more I had an itch to write some text to the same point. completely agree
@4T3hM4kr0n
@4T3hM4kr0n 8 лет назад
I honestly think that the point would have been drivin home better if they did the first world war than WWII
@Kelis98
@Kelis98 8 лет назад
Completely agree.
@astupiddvdcase
@astupiddvdcase 8 лет назад
WWI was a different beast to WWII, although WWI had death on an industrial scale (somme, verdun etc), it still very much rested on old empire values, valour, service to empire etc. It was the war in which British sangfroid got crushed by the reality of industrial total war and modern weaponry. Generals couldn't merely believe in the superiority of the fighting man to get the job done, it wasn't like the Napoleonic war anymore where pitched battles was won by the discipline and bravery in the face of danger in musket to musket battles. There was simply no way for these outdated beliefs to realistically counter automatic machine guns and dug in infantry combined with deadly artillery. Whilst WWI was more and old world war between empires, WWII although about empires as well was also an ideological war, fascism vs communism vs democracy etc. This meant that there was also that extra step in ideological leap where war was racially motivated. The germans were there to take over slavic land and enslave the german population, the Japanese were superior to the Chinese and the Japanese were demonized by the Americans after news of their treatment of prisoners etc. But watever, wrote too much
@ilo3456
@ilo3456 5 лет назад
Also I mean as a soldier in the ground you don't really have the time or care to be non racist or even caring about the enemy, you are a soldier, you are told go fight those people, and you do, to be honest I am sure that many soldiers during the war did think quite poorly of how the japanese fought, the use of suicide bombers to ambush american GIs, the torture of prisoners, the fanatic zeal, to a soldier in the pacific I doubt they cared much about why the japanese threw themselves at the enemy, they just knew they did and fought them, I think it is a more realistic aspect of war, than if we over complicated the story with showing the Japanese perspective. In the end you are no more than one soldier in the larger war trying to survive one of the most brutal theatre's of war from WW2, fighting against an enemy who uses both conventional and unconventional tactics.
@PedanticGaming
@PedanticGaming 2 года назад
I feel a little bit like the comments regarding the Japanese portrayal in World at War are bordering on revisionist. I'm not going to claim the game is in particular good taste, but in terms of what the Japanese did and how American soldiers experienced it... I'd say it's actually fairly accurate. I get disagreeing with the tone, but I think it gets the blow by blow events fairly right. The whole 'we need to look at the deeper reasons' argument, and the fact that we can judge the Nazis because we hold the same moral framework does not exculpate these actions. The fact it's portrayed like a wartime propaganda piece is, I think unintentionally, a quite accurate way to view it, because this WAS how we viewed it at the time and your argument appears, at least to me, to try and give the Japanese a bit too much of the benefit of the doubt. I appreciate there were reasons for this, the historian Mark Felton made an excellent video essay on the subject and he deals with it a hell of a lot better than I am in this comment. I just think it is not an inaccurate way of portraying the war, even if it is inappropriate to modern sensibilities, and I appreciate that those do apply to a work written in the 21st Century and not intended as an accurate role-play of a WW2 era marine. I just think you might've gone a bit far in the opposite direction in trying to correct the, admittedly tone deaf giving it as much credit as I can (and I agree that I don't think it earns that credit), presentation, especially when taken into the broader context of the general Japanese refusal, at the very least on a national level, to apologise or sometimes even recognise their atrocities in the Second World War.
@BlxckBaron
@BlxckBaron 2 года назад
That section screams white guilt to me. I don’t remember Japanese people having a problem with how they were depicted in the game.
@MyH3ntaiGirl
@MyH3ntaiGirl 8 месяцев назад
I don't get it? This is exactly feel like american civil revisionism These new Yanks generation ignore the brutality of the evil Japanese Empire and painted them as "just following order" I refuse to believe that bullshjt with many evil action the Japanese people themselves justify
@nicholasferlazzo3021
@nicholasferlazzo3021 4 года назад
I think it’s unfair to excuse the Japanese atrocities just because they were from a different culture. They had modern science and technology, philosophy and ethics, they weren’t a backwater. They had moral agency just like any other culture. Should the Hutus of Rwanda be forgiven just because they’re not from Western culture? And depicting the war in the pacific accurately without addressing the hated and prejudice between the Japanese and Americans would just be dishonest in a game going for realism like World at War
@ripdito
@ripdito 4 месяца назад
3yrs late but he never excused them?
@rusi6219
@rusi6219 12 дней назад
Yet you excuse the atrocities against Baghuz, Mosul, Raqqah, Diyala, Fallujah,...
@pyramideddie7813
@pyramideddie7813 9 лет назад
So, you do realise that next to Campster and SuperBunnyHop you are the very best youtube gaming ever got in terms of competent artistic/academic critique, right? Holy hell the fact you aren't at least in the top 100 most subscribed channels is a crime in an of itself. Please, keep on doing what you're doing, 'cause you're great at it.
@podto0426
@podto0426 9 лет назад
***** For a few months i've been hunting for somewhat insightful and smart video producing channels (you can probably erase the "Somewhat" part on this channel IMO) but there are A LOT of channels that put up near, same or better quality content all of them get 1% of what a channel like AngryJoe or TotalBiscuit get with the exception of a small few. Not to say that those 2 do not posses the qualities i attributed to this channel, but my point (and yours kinda too) is: It is a crying shame that these valuable channels don't get more eyes on them...
@idnyftw
@idnyftw 9 лет назад
***** it's in his dry "documentary narration" way of doing things, as opposed to the "post-Nerd" school of raging at The Man for churning out shitty games
@Learned_English_Dog
@Learned_English_Dog 9 лет назад
***** Not just the best 'youtube gaming' ever got, but in some ways the best games writing we've got, in general. Excluding some corners of academia, of course, but that stuff often isn't penetrable to the average reader. And I think the importance of these video essays is that they're quite digestible to anyone who treats games as more than mere toys. Hopefully these dudes will help to curb the tendency towards anti-intellectualism that I've noted in the wake of recent.... cultural rifts.
@Jprime777
@Jprime777 7 лет назад
I'm generally one of those people who finds the CoD series pretty dull for singleplayer, but the nuke scene in CoD4 is one of the best scenes I've seen in a game. From the almost blood red burnt sky, with fallout thick in the air, how your character laboriously limps, to the mushroom cloud in all its horrific glory, it's just good god damn moment. A lot of games would try and copy this sort of thing after CoD4 made it popular, but I've never seen any nail it like this.
@UnchainedEruption
@UnchainedEruption 2 года назад
Mostly it's other COD games that tried to recreate that feeling. Death of a beloved friendly soldier character near end of movie? Check. Shocking scene that gets the plot going? Check. It becomes so formulaic after a while.
@Jamez928
@Jamez928 4 года назад
"When i say Somalia you say" Me: "jump, wait what" "If you didn't say pirate good for you" Im not sure whether i should be proud or disappointed with my brain
@satanicpizza6666
@satanicpizza6666 2 месяца назад
You didn’t even say how high? You just said jump lol?
@salokin3087
@salokin3087 9 лет назад
This is absolutely fantastic! I've never come across a single video this thorough in a particular subject. Kudos to you and all the hard work, made me think, contemplate on topics i usually don't pay much attention too. Very interesting, very well scripted and wonderfully done, thank you for doing this. Will look forward to new content from you, regardless of what it is!
@LikeTheBirb
@LikeTheBirb Год назад
It certainly speaks to your skill and verbiage as a narrator and critic to make me listen to multi-hour videos about games that I never played
@frood801
@frood801 8 лет назад
The Paris scene in CoD;MW3 seems a little distasteful now....
@pr01etar1at
@pr01etar1at 9 лет назад
This is probably one of the best game critiques I've ever seen. You really put a great deal of care in to this and it shows. I particularly love how you look at games as a complete package - often times "games critics" segment mechanics from narrative too distinctly. You have a great understanding of how these two aspects of a game cannot be divorced from one another and that inherent contradictions between the two [i.e. a criticism of war told via the FPS mechanic] does not necessarily mean the point is superseded by the action [i.e. the fun of killing as a mechanic does not de facto override the narrative about warfare]. A number of criticisms of CoD I have seen take this blanket approach which you are wise to avoid. I think it's great that you're being realistic in acknowldging what a game can actually accomplish. A number of emerging critics are coming from a games utopia standpoint whereby they feel games are in a way a superior medium for storytelling. They're not - they're just a different media format. Like literature, film, or the visual arts, games have strong and weak points as an expressive means and I think it's great that you're keeping this in mind as it allows you to be fair in your reading of a game. There are just some things the medium has an inherent difficulty with that the more author controlled nature of literature and film have a better grasp of - i.e. balancing the mechanics vs. narrative when the two conflict. This is great and I hope you make more videos as it's rare to come across a critique as nuanced as this, especially when discussing such a large AAA franchise which many simply equate to Michael Bay-esque cinema of spectacle.
@leka34
@leka34 Год назад
Just going through the backlog years after, and I find your conclusions on World at War extremely strange. Yes, the game is violent. Probably the most graphic Call of Duty even to this day. But I've played it through maybe five times, and never felt the violence was glorified. It throws you into the mud and blood, and by the time you're through, you're numb. Its nature reflects biographical accounts, like E.B. Sledge's "With The Old Breed", better than any other game I've played. You could argue that CoD's more casual style of gameplay is not the best medium for that, but that alone does not make it glorification. I also find the accusations of racism go equally perplexing. The American characters might be racist, that does not mean the game is. And as far as depicting the Japanese as extremely violent and cruel goes, that's what they were. In some aspects, even more so than the Nazis. The magnitude of the atrocities they committed in the Sino-Japanese war and during their conquests on the Philippines are maybe not as well known in the west, but that doesn't make them any less real. Could they have depicted the Japanese perspective in the game? I suppose. But none of the earlier Call of Duty games do that for other nations, nor have you criticized the earlier games for the omission, so I find that piece of criticism effectively invalid.
@YCCCm7
@YCCCm7 7 лет назад
Black Ops 2's "Choice" moment shooting the hooded guy was very poorly framed. You can't shoot the guy next to you, you can't shoot the guards, and hence, you feel like it's not really a choice. The secret is to shoot him in the leg. You're under the impression that you can only shoot him, so it feels like a non choice and never makes you think of where you're placing the shot. Waiting, equally, does nothing. I only learned of the choice by googling it.
@haydentravis3348
@haydentravis3348 5 лет назад
How do you google something you don't know exists?
@winup9417
@winup9417 5 лет назад
@@haydentravis3348 video game guides
@VioPLayable
@VioPLayable 5 лет назад
YCCCm7 I figured the choice out myself. Shot his leg to see what would happen.
@linusdn2777
@linusdn2777 4 года назад
I think i shot him in the knees ans that worked.
@raditzhoneyham
@raditzhoneyham 2 года назад
While you can't shoot the others sure, to the game's credit he's wearing mason's clothes.. Not only that, if you had been doing the optional objectives and paying attention to the game when you scope mason it says stuff "they've got a mole.. they are framing the CIA" or whatever so it does try to push you into making questions
@BrainSeepsOut
@BrainSeepsOut 9 лет назад
When it's the Japanese, it's racist but when it's the Germans it's fiiiiiine! Wow, dude. Wow.
@rusi6219
@rusi6219 12 дней назад
He's a Jew
@TheSupermuffin12
@TheSupermuffin12 7 лет назад
Great video the world at war part kinda sounds like the ramblings of a insane man who has no idea what he is talking about but this is still the first video I saw from this channel and i still re watch it often.
@tpiom
@tpiom 9 лет назад
Myself, I find World at War more interesting than the other games... from a gameplay perspective it is just awesome: the "enemy at the Gates" recreation in in Stalingrad, storming the Reichstag felt good - like making a final step toward the end, then when you think it's over: you get shot, but is saved by a fellow soldier: reminding you what the war was really about for them: the comradery. I find the Pacific campaign... interesting as well, mainly because of the environment and different feeling from the rest of Call of Duty games. It is intense, in that aspect the developers did really well. And then, I can't help but to admire Modern Warfare 2. It is self aware and doesn't hold back: the spectacle is a whole another level. It is what makes that game. But I salute you for these series! LA Noire, Warcraft and now this...? I... Just thank you.
@broadcaststsatic
@broadcaststsatic 9 лет назад
If you've been enjoying my videos, be sure to check out my back catalog on my channel page-- I've done sixteen major videos so far.
@jonslamlee6539
@jonslamlee6539 9 лет назад
Noah Caldwell-Gervais i would like to see your opinion on the metal gear solid series. admittedly it is a confusing and hard series to get into but I think it is a great series overall. even though I think that metal gear solid 4 was easily the weakest in the series.
@Malgon3DR
@Malgon3DR 7 лет назад
Just finished watching this and I have to say I was seriously impressed with it, as you can clearly see the amount of time and effort that was put in, along with a lot of thought about the themes and ideas which gives a different perspective on the series that you otherwise wouldn't consider. Subscription well earned.
@WolfhoundMercenary
@WolfhoundMercenary 8 лет назад
Pretty good material but your World at War analysis is waaaay off, unfortunately. I suggest you read up more on the war in Pacific because it was frankly painful watching the WaW part of your video.
@fooman530
@fooman530 6 лет назад
Agreed
@MrGutty117
@MrGutty117 6 лет назад
I agree wholeheartedly with basically the entirety of this video. Well thought out, well put together and coherent arguments. But I would actually disagree with your assessment of World at War. I don't believe it glorifies war, and I don't think it does anything different from the other games in portraying the "bad guys". For me, having recently played 1, 2, 3, 4, and 6, WaW is not the most fun of those games. The mechanics are solid, as you said, but I don't really get a dopamine rush or enjoyment that much from the killing. It's very much reminiscent of Spec Ops: The Line, where killing isn't that great because it's not SUPPOSED to glorify war. The gore, at least for me, is a deterrent to seeing it as "fun to shoot people". And from having played it recently, I would have to disagree with your statement on the world building; it's dark and gritty but I don't see it as just for the sake of being dark and gritty. It's dark and gritty and as such, it merely has a different feel to the older games -- a different focus. Whereas the older games focused on comradery and the unity of soldiers with a more hopeful message, WaW is dark and depressing (with both color palate and aesthetic) because war itself is hell. Read any book from the writers of the Lost Generation after WWI and you'll get in the mindset more. Your points are mostly spot on, but for me I think subjectively WaW was not the start of the unfeeling hollywood shitshow that CoD became in the later years.
@GoldenGyroBalls
@GoldenGyroBalls 6 лет назад
World at War is a children's game in comparison to Spec Ops.
@drogoz4042
@drogoz4042 2 года назад
@@GoldenGyroBalls only children play videogames, go read a book
@Slowsilv
@Slowsilv 2 года назад
I suggest reading With the Old Breed by E.B. Sledge. one of the things the book points out over and over again was the animalistic hatred the Americans and Japanese had for each other. The mutilation of corpses on both sides is something that is hard to believe.
@Tronathon242
@Tronathon242 9 лет назад
The problem with Ghosts, in my eyes, was that it couldn't pick a line to go with. It felt like a semi trying to be in three lanes at once on a highway. You had a massive continental war, an ultra Navy Seal story, and future tech. It handles each one badly. I would have liked the first two scenarios to be put into separate games. Have the continental, weakened America bit and ignore the future tech and the Ghosts bit. Or you could have the Ghosts bit and not have the Federation. Pick a fucking lane Infinity Ward! Also, I think Advanced Warfare had a thoroughly mediocre campaign that wasted its set up.
@redline841
@redline841 Год назад
7 years late but keep in mind that Ghosts was a product of a gutted Infinity Ward, after MW3 IW was shattered as the majority of their staff went off to make Respawn. i have heard rumors that Ghosts was supposed to be MW4, but personally I think Ghost's issues was that of the tight 2 year development cycle because the support it got post launch was second to none. PC port was solid and there was so much DLC and experimental game modes that it stands as a sleeper hit on what Infinity Ward can do even during their slumps
@GermanPeter
@GermanPeter 8 лет назад
1:29:36 "It's an explosion. ...of emotion!" That line cracked me up :D Just how you pronounced it, in this condescending tone! And the one at 2:03:12: "He gave you that arm. Your killing arm. Give it back."
@BoneMarrowBro
@BoneMarrowBro 9 лет назад
I play these videos and listen to your soothing voice while I do graphics design for games and practice my skills in drawing. 10/10 for you man, you are awesome.
@engine4403
@engine4403 3 года назад
Watching the recent Face Full Of Eyes video made on World at War was quite the different experience when compared to Noah's own views towards the game
@baller42061
@baller42061 3 года назад
I just watched the entire video, definitely worth my time. Thanks for the video man
@yosefyonin6824
@yosefyonin6824 8 лет назад
holy shit. the World at War review in this video is a goddamn disaster! nihilism? the game showed what war really was. bloody, horrifying and merciless. a place were brutality and and evil are a common place! this is not nihilism! because this is what war looked like! the review of the pacific campagin was especially terrible. it wasn't trying to be bad-ass! especially how difficult and unforgiving the game was. there was no way to feel badass after dying for the 20th time! the game showed how the american troops actually behaved towards the japanese. they hated them. they wanted to kill them with the most painful ways possible. because they deserved it. "cultural difference" IS NOT A WAY TO EXCUSE ATROCITIES!!! the japanese were demonized because thats what they exactly were like. and no "cultural difference" is going to make them any less demonic.
@mikutai6395
@mikutai6395 8 лет назад
But the game did it poorly. World at war's campaign was more of a wolfenstein style "rush in with a 50 cal machine gun and blow them away!"
@yosefyonin6824
@yosefyonin6824 8 лет назад
what? unless you play 'RECRUIT" difficulty there is no fucking way you can go guns blazing! didn't you read about how brutally hard and unforgiving the game is? trying to go guns blazing will result in dying 20 times in a row. hell, this game is notorious for being the hardest CoD ever made (although i argue that united offensive is harder
@mikutai6395
@mikutai6395 8 лет назад
Yosef Yonin I played on regular and harden difficulty and I was still able to rush in and do that
@yosefyonin6824
@yosefyonin6824 8 лет назад
your skills must be godlike or you are straight up lying. World at War is wildly famous for being the hardest CoD ever made.www.xboxachievements.com/forum/showthread.php?t=351344 there is no way you could just rush your way through the bunkers and buildings like you described, without dying like 20 times in a row
@Wintd1
@Wintd1 8 лет назад
World at War is the hardest CoD ever? You didn't play the first game on Veteran then. WaW was infamous for being hard on veteran because of the insane amount of grenade spam that resulted in plenty of cheap deaths. From a gunplay perspective it wouldn't really be any harder than most Call of Duty's if the grenades weren't always constantly forcing you out of cover and then dying without even being given a chance to fall back.
@TheBlackDeath3
@TheBlackDeath3 9 лет назад
A fantastic look at one of the biggest game franchises ever with an insightful, penetrating, critical eye. Very nicely done!
@ThisisKyle
@ThisisKyle 2 года назад
No not be Western standards, by objective standards of morality what the Japanese did during WW2 was cruel. You should judge them just as harshly as you would the Nazis. Their cultural difference is never an excuse
@AydarBMSTU
@AydarBMSTU 9 лет назад
That's how I see Call Of Duty: Infinity Ward before key members left - the only studio that can make a brilliant COD game (which was proven by it several times); Treyarch - bunch of hacks who only get to make COD games because Bobby Kotick wants COD game each year; Infinity Ward without the key members - fucking abysmal to the point of being hilarious (everyone remembers dog jokes, right?). Man, it's sad to see COD games today and compare them to the glory days of the franchise. It's even worse to see that games still sell well, general audience doesn't really care about the quality of the product - it's COD, it's cool to play, so they play it and choose to ignore the degrading franchise. Can't wait to see COD die and Kotick retire
@disorderrgv
@disorderrgv 9 лет назад
Treyatch still uses real things in its ridiculous over the top fun narrative (mk ultra project blue bird the dangers in the advancement of technology etc.)
@TheBeird
@TheBeird 9 лет назад
Good work as always Noah. I'm so glad someone gave voice to a grievance I've had with the 'elites' of the gaming community. Namely this kind of entertainment eugenics view point that the blue collar people who get a kick out of COD are the reason a lot of games suck. They are not. I don't like a lot of Call of Duty. I hate the Transformers films. And Fifty Shades of Grey gets me Fifty Shades of Grim. But I'm sick of the snooty attitude that's crept into geekdom. You don't like it, feel free to critique it. But shove your view up your ass if you think you know what people SHOULD enjoy. Look forward to your next vid!
@noway9320
@noway9320 9 лет назад
You know in World At War the random "choose what to do" bits actually have a small effect, right? Chernov's journal entry changes depending on what you do in the game.
@oh-not-the-bees7872
@oh-not-the-bees7872 3 года назад
Ooooh bou
@Don11037
@Don11037 3 года назад
Your a little late
@Regularguy220
@Regularguy220 3 года назад
Your not forced to commit a war crime but he talks about it like you are
@antonyduhamel1166
@antonyduhamel1166 2 года назад
@@Regularguy220 You are forced to commit a war crime. The Nazi soldiers you can kill either quick or slow (at the subway entrance) have surrendered. Killing soldiers who have surrendered is a war crime, even if you attempt to do so "mercifully."
@Regularguy220
@Regularguy220 2 года назад
@@antonyduhamel1166 you dont have to shoot them. Chernov in his monologue looks up to dimitri if you dont and reznov admonishes you if you dont as well. Your still there and they will still kill them but whether you kill them yourself is your choice
@swempytimes
@swempytimes 3 года назад
I really truly love listening to your perspective You have made me appreciate more a series I already loved since 2005. I would love to hear your intake on the more current Call of duty's if you would like to. You are awesome keep making videos I love these 😁
@faenihelvete6144
@faenihelvete6144 7 лет назад
Your videos are an amazing gift to game-history. Way more interesting analysis of games than commercial game journalism or even larger youtubers.
@gootubesucks9390
@gootubesucks9390 3 года назад
you missed the nail with world at war but the rest is amazing
@Megan-ii4gf
@Megan-ii4gf 2 года назад
Absolutely agreed on that one.
@MikeWhite7620
@MikeWhite7620 8 лет назад
Bravo on this. Your commentary actually carried the bulk of the game and made the contents very entertaining. This was an enjoyable two hours of my time well spent. And I should thank you for that alone.
@antonsoderman4124
@antonsoderman4124 9 лет назад
This video take me back, I remember getting Call of Duty for Xmes, the deluxe edition with United offensive included, and decided to play on hard which was hard since I was not that used to fps back then. I remember being terrified holding the Pegasus bridge, knowing that every hit could kill me. Years later I visited the same bridge, recognizing it and the area around. Things like that really stick with you, and as you said, it was the catalyst for wanting to learn more about what actually happened. Like for example, just by looking at the games, you would imagine that the battle of Stalingrad was actually won in the city, not by the encirclement of the Russians, but that does not make as just so epic set pieces. The second game I remember playing the demo with the the battle in the desert town, being amazed by the graphics and in particular the smoke grenades; looking back I don’t see it the same way even thou it is still fun to play. Two levels I remember in particular fondly was the second of the American campaign, having you retreat back to the point, desperately holding one. And the level after that gave you a town to secure, but with a degree of freedom in which order you wanted to capture it, I wished that they had done more of it. I think the fact that Call of Duty 2 was released as a launch title for the Xbox 360, as the best game at launch, really helped it establish itself and started the steps towards a console focus. Just look at Call of Duty 3 which really is mostly a multiplayer game, even thou its single player got some interesting ideas like a Polish tank crew. However I think without these steps, Modern Warfare would not had the effect it had. The first game established itself and the second and third game expanded it to the console market. I really like the fourth game, it isn’t perfect, but as you say, it served a purpose at the time and it tells a story that is relatively believable, in the same way as a Tom Clancy novel it believable. What I remember with it is that you could really see the connection with the first game, exposition between levels, and secret mission between enemy lines with alarms going on. I actually never thought about the balance between secret ops and the grunt on the ground, thanks for helping me realize it. World at war I did not play until years later and at that point it was fun having a modern world war two shooter. While I don’t got much to add to what you said, I do think that the campaign really drove home the point of just how global the conflict was, with you fighting in both the pacific and east German, with maps showing of the distant between the two. Modern Warfare 2 was also allot of fun, but allot was different. The plot was stupid and despite it, hard to keep track on. Also the entire Russian invasion plot was stupid, glad to have you point out that it was mostly because they had to make to with plot points from the first modern warfare game. Modern Warfare was the last call of duty game I played, I got tired of paying full price for a game when I was only interested in the campaign, something that clearly was not the focus. I am glad to hear that I have not missed much, even thou I might play Black Ops if it goes on sale and it seems like Advance warfare might be work a look. And as always, awesome work, you if anyone on RU-vid deserves to be successful when you put this much work into your videos. I will keep watching your videos and spread the word to anyone that will listen!
@nickchaffins8524
@nickchaffins8524 5 лет назад
Jesus Christ, a two hour analysis of a video game series. This is the type of thing I love. Thank you for making your videos. You are great.
@zesty2023
@zesty2023 9 лет назад
"Captain McTavish was run over." That's the best game over message ever! XD I'm laughing my ass off. I didn't even know you could do that!
@famalam943
@famalam943 2 года назад
WaW racist? I don't think you know enough about Japanese brutality. The game didn't go far enough honestly
@AJadedLizard
@AJadedLizard 9 лет назад
37:13 You know not a single solitary thing about the Pacific and Eastern theaters if you think WaW isn't historically accurate, in tone and the simple cruelty visible on all sides. IW, back when IW actually could write, captures the "lesser of two evils" way the USSR really conducted WWII is accurate, but the off-handed, callous way the Russians and Germans treated each other is on full display in both WaW and Black Ops, and that's what I've always loved about Treyarch. IW makes games based on Hollywood movies (albeit how they think Hollywood movies should go; thus every single American character is killed in their remake of Black Hawk Down and overall the American campaigns have fuck all to do with the overall game and are narrative black holes). Treyarch shows war the way it actually was, on these darkest of battlefields, as anyone who was a veteran on these fronts will tell you. For crying out loud, the player character in WaW spouts quotes from Robert Leckie's famous With the Old Breed (which serves as the partial basis for The Pacific...a good few years before that series existed). You can't ask for more historical accuracy than that.
@HeartlessGorre
@HeartlessGorre 9 лет назад
at 1:22:30 you say that its the first time you play as price but actually in all ghillied up in cod 4 you play as price.
@nessabethany7068
@nessabethany7068 3 года назад
Watching this as a channel fan five years after release for the first time, was about to go to the comments to make a joking jab about this, glad I wasn't the only one who noticed, ha.
@Ilshatey
@Ilshatey 3 года назад
@@nessabethany7068 same
@VivaLaNatedog
@VivaLaNatedog 8 лет назад
Great video so far. I'm almost 1.5 hours in but stopped to let you know about an error I spotted. At 1:22:27, you said, "So, for your last mission, you play as Captain Price--at long last--for the first time in franchise history." However, the player plays as Captain Price in COD 4 in the mission "All Gullied Up."
@David-mw5sd
@David-mw5sd 9 лет назад
Holy mother of god... That's one detailed review! That's what I call quality and professionalism. Thank you.
@joaogomes9405
@joaogomes9405 2 года назад
I don't think you could have been further off the mark when it comes to WaW if you genuinely tried.
@frycopy2746
@frycopy2746 2 года назад
yeah i think his entire take on WaW was shit
@mjordan072
@mjordan072 9 лет назад
This was genuinely fascinating! CoD was never really a part of my childhood (my shooters of choice were always sci-fi) so I tend to just write it off as the current pulpy trend. You gave a really thoughtful and unbiased look at the whole series, noting it's development, cultural effect and even it's tonal shift over time. You didn't jump on the bandwagon of condemnation or silly praise. I hope you're able to keep making videos like this for a long time, because they're some of my favorite on RU-vid at the moment!
@galacticrelic258
@galacticrelic258 8 лет назад
I think you completely missed the mark on WaW.
@mayorofbagtown9097
@mayorofbagtown9097 11 месяцев назад
It hurts to hear you call WaW "pro war" and unrealistic. Making the game about brotherhood and honor would have been MORE disshonest than depicting WW2 as it was. That is, brutal and savage. There is a reason the main menu comes across more like a horror game than an action FPS. The japanese in WW2 were NIGHTMARISH AND CRUEL. THAT IS A FACT. I really don't get your take on that game man. Its so frustrating because you are usually so on point but HOLY COW did you miss the mark on WaW. Everything you said about it was wrong. Just... dang, man.
@FunOrange42
@FunOrange42 9 лет назад
just finished watching through this amazingly done
@MrDumbRodent
@MrDumbRodent 9 лет назад
It was very satisfying to hear your opinions on both Black Ops and Advanced Warfare. Especially the latter- enjoying a post-MW1 CoD game's single player campaign that much made me feel like I was beginning to lose my mind.
@Paranoid1996
@Paranoid1996 9 лет назад
Uhm i know this is a hard thing to do but can you add English subtitle to this video? My native language is not English so for a 2-hour video, it's extremely diffcult for me to watch the video and completely understand it, especially when it's a long, complex and thorough analysis video like this. Also thank you for making this. Call of Duty is one of my favourite video game franchises of all time.
@607995
@607995 2 года назад
just discovered your channel. very impressed. cheers, and thank you.
@th3highwayman
@th3highwayman 6 лет назад
I enjoyed it, except for the WaW portion. You seem to think it was a glorification of war because of the gore and brutality, and I think it's the opposite. WaW was trying to convince you that war was hell.
@Jarekthegamingdragon
@Jarekthegamingdragon 9 лет назад
I can not disagree any more about waw. It's not a movie, gameplay should come first, story after. Treyarch has always done a great job with this and is far better than IW because of it. I've pretty much come to the conclusion that you just dislike treyarch. Black ops 1 and 2 is far better than any other COD title and it's not even close. LOL! Did you just say cod is a true esport? Easy to learn, hard to master? You shitting me? It's easy to play, easy to master, has no balance, and isn't even one of the bigger esports. The largest are dota, lol, CS;GO, starcraft, and smash melee. Cod has no place in that.
@mechanicalorchards3961
@mechanicalorchards3961 8 лет назад
I don't think you can justify what the japanease did to the chinese during ww2.
@c.jarmstrong3111
@c.jarmstrong3111 5 лет назад
Yah, Imperial Japan was pretty fucked. The Japanese people hold it as a grand embarrassment within their current culture
@tacodude98
@tacodude98 5 лет назад
Explaining the causes for such atrocities isn't the same as justifying the act.
@LostShipMate
@LostShipMate 5 лет назад
@@c.jarmstrong3111 and yet they've never officially apologized . . .
@c.jarmstrong3111
@c.jarmstrong3111 5 лет назад
@@LostShipMate maybe they will some day, who knows. It took Canada until just a couple years ago to finally make an official appology to our Indigenous peoples
@adrianshephard378
@adrianshephard378 4 года назад
@@tacodude98 You could say the same for germany
@bretteller9420
@bretteller9420 9 лет назад
absolutely brilliant review. shame we dont have more people like you. diamond in the rough
@therealredtales
@therealredtales 4 года назад
On the point of Japanese, they still never made any apologies about their behaviour during the war times/occupation of china/korea unlike germany where they actually learned a lesson and teach about it in schools, japan pretends it never happened.
@clapointe151
@clapointe151 3 года назад
I don't want to be rude buuuuut... War is war. There is no law in war. There is no ethics in war. There's no honor in removing the life of someone else. The moment you are invading, you are already a monster. For me at least, all the rape,murder and genocide that japan did are part of war. Look at it this way, you can't morally kill someone. You can have a motivation that make it... sort of excusable in the extreme, like if the person raped your entire family and plan to kill them. But murder is murder. The act of murder is morally wrong. Only the motivation can be moral.
@soyjakpartyvideoarchive4645
@soyjakpartyvideoarchive4645 7 месяцев назад
​@@clapointe151dumb
@thequirts
@thequirts 9 лет назад
Noah you run one of the best channels on youtube. I don't know if you've played/are interested in the hitman games, but seeing you give a thorough look at where that series started off as and has gone on to become would pretty much make my year.
@SamuraiPie8111
@SamuraiPie8111 9 лет назад
Call of Duty gets a lot of hate, but you know, all of their single player campaigns have been enjoyable I think it's the MLG dudebro online community that ruins it
@DethThrasher1
@DethThrasher1 9 лет назад
SamuraiPie8111 "all of their single player campaigns have been enjoyable" except finest hour and ghosts
@SamuraiPie8111
@SamuraiPie8111 9 лет назад
lam neth did you find finest hour to be spooky? i always thought it was
@RomanHistoryFan476AD
@RomanHistoryFan476AD 6 лет назад
I think of cod as just a simple fun shooting game which lets you be the heroic action hero soldier we as kids always wanted to be. it's multiplayer and the community ruin it though.
@troubleinbound
@troubleinbound 6 лет назад
Agent Bill Wilson this holds true for ww2, even if people hate it I still had good dumb fun with it
@majik5194
@majik5194 4 года назад
*insert hitmarker sound effects and adolescent teens yelling "OOOH! OOOOOH!" Through a shitty mic*
@raphaelhemery152
@raphaelhemery152 2 года назад
I've never cared about call of duty, until I saw this video. They aren't the type of games I'm interested in. I have had for a brief time that snootiness of thinking that call of duty is bad and blablabla. I've since then matured and realized that it definitely has value. It's just not the type of value I look for in games. Great video, I'm glad to understand a little better the roots of such an influential franchise.
@Phobosinadamant
@Phobosinadamant 5 лет назад
Great video, agree with the majority that you're flat out wrong when it came to WaW.
@RunRobots
@RunRobots 9 лет назад
Always have to watch your videos twice! You're doing a great job with these retrospectives, and you should feel great.
@Tax_2000
@Tax_2000 2 года назад
I personally disagree with the your opinion that world at war has a pro war sentiment, and i absolutely loved the modern warfare trilogy of games, 1 and 2 for their story and multiplayer, mw3 just for its story, but other than those things, I enjoyed the video. :D
@chronoflect
@chronoflect 9 лет назад
That was an enjoyable and painstakingly thorough critique of the series. I didn't think that you would hold my attention for the full 2 hour length, but I watched it without pause until the end. It was a very well done video. Thank you.
@witherdrive
@witherdrive Год назад
been working my way through your older vids, and i cannot believe it's taken me this long to find out that the "standard" version of no russian lets you shoot civilians. i used to live in germany which is home to some very strange and strict video censorship laws, and in the version of the game released in germany, shooting a civilian during that mission nets you a game over. funny how that works. keep up the great work!
@crowcade
@crowcade 9 лет назад
Glad to see someone take a critical eye towards the CoD franchise, and I can't think of anyone to do it better justice. MW in particular was my favourite iteration, for both multiplayer and the campaign. My question is overall, who do you think held better philosophies towards the franchise between Treyarch and Infinity Ward? And do you think Activision noticing the success of MW affected the quality of later games (more set piece action sequences, less emphasis on the overall narrative)? Otherwise, this might be my new favourite retrospective of yours, looking forward to the new genre orphans, whenever that may be!
Далее
F.E.A.R.: Itself! (A Franchise Retrospective)
56:27
Просмотров 329 тыс.
A Thorough Look at Wolfenstein
1:14:30
Просмотров 302 тыс.
Ромарио стал Ромой
00:46
Просмотров 56 тыс.
Добрая весть 😂
00:21
Просмотров 590 тыс.
Call of Duty: A Franchise Retrospective and Analysis
3:27:38
Playing Quake for the Story (A Franchise Retrospective)
2:27:29
Every Historical Inaccuracy in Call of Duty
1:04:52
Просмотров 159 тыс.
History of Call of Duty (2003 - 2019)
1:47:55
Просмотров 6 млн
A Thorough Look at Mass Effect
2:29:05
Просмотров 917 тыс.
Fallout 4 - One Year Later
2:32:34
Просмотров 12 млн
The First Call of Duty Veteran is HARD
3:30:23
Просмотров 1,1 млн
A Thorough Look at Red Faction
34:45
Просмотров 228 тыс.
Ромарио стал Ромой
00:46
Просмотров 56 тыс.