Hay dos apuntes que están erroneos, los celtas se expandieron desde la peninsula Ibérica hasta las islas Británicas y no al revés (estudio de Brian Sykes, universidad de Oxford) Segundo, el porcentaje de ADN moro no llega ni al 5% en la península debido a que no se casaban cristianos y musulmanes. Hay incluso más de judío y de nórdico. Estudio de la universidad de Oxford y de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela, autor principal Clare Bycroft. Por otra parte en las distintas glaciaciones la península ibérica ha sido en refugio de Europa con un clima similar al de Dinamarca, frio pero habitable.
Eso les da igual a los anglos, si quieren invirtar que las expansión de los celtas fue al contrario por lo inventan cuentan sobre ese relato y ya está, y si quieren decir que el adn norte africano es el que les da la gana ellos se lo inventan y no hay otra historia, dentro de ese cinco % de población que tiene adn africano apenas el uno o dos % de su genomica es del norte de áfrica, el otro noventa y ocho % no lo es y estamos hablando de un cinco % de la población. En cualquier caso me da igual la candad de adn que tengamos de quién, lo que no me da igual es que se cuenten mentiras, cosa que los anglosajones hacen como una naturalidad sorprendente.
Te pongo otro apunte. Al principio del video, no llega ni a los 20 segundos, es al revés de lo que dice, Galicia tienen más adn norafricano que en Andalucía.
Hay otros dos estudios científicos que confirman el 5% de ADN moro ,el de la Universidad de Granada y la de Harvard.Pueden encontrarlas en Google.Los resultados fueron publicados en la revista científica SCIENCE.
"Há duas notas erradas: os celtas expandiram-se da Península Ibérica para as Ilhas Britânicas e não o contrário (estudo de Brian Sykes, Universidade de Oxford)" Questionável... Esse DNA é de 10k anos, além do neolítico, pois os britânicos vieram da Ibéria a partir daí, muito antes de existir qualquer cultura celta/gália/goidélica/bretã ou que seja... "Em segundo lugar, a percentagem de ADN mouro não chega sequer a 5% na península porque cristãos e muçulmanos não se casaram." A genética desbanca esse teu mito, o DNA norte-africano é muito substancia, tanto na Europa quanto na América Ibérica, e maior que os teus ídolos judeus e nórdicos, vira-lata. "Há ainda mais judeus e nórdicos. " - os judeus deixaram DNA que dá pra considerar, mas não mais que os NA. Nórdicos, pior ainda, deixaram quase 0% impacto. "Estudo da Universidade de Oxford " pare de usar alguns estudos como se fossem conclusivos...
My god that’s completely false @0:14! Why do people push this myth? The people in the south of Spain descend from people from the north, as the Iberians reconquered the peninsula they settled northern Iberians south. Andalusians have no more “Arab” blood than anywhere else in Spain 0-2%.
Right. Lots of christians run from the invaders and mixed in the small christian kingdoms in the north. Centuries later they returned to settle the recovered land as homogeneus people.
Correct. In addition, the largest DNA variation in Iberia happens East to West, with western Andalusians being more similar to the Extremadurans and Leonese than to Eastern Andalusians. This happened as the re-colonization during the Reconquista followed a North-South pattern. There is, however an ancestral genetic connection between Iberia and North Africa, but this ultimately means more that Moroccans are partly Iberians than the other way around.
@@tierraprometida8866 Male R1B haplogroup is higher in the north of Spain than in the south, the percentage is 80% in the north, compared to 50% in the south of Spain, R1B DNA are mainly distributed throughout France, Spain, Ireland, England, Scotland, Denmark, Switzerland, Western Germany, Northern Italy.
@@mannyrodriguez5453Si observas el patio de cualquier colegio andaluz verás que muchos de los niños y niñas pequeños son de piel muy clara y cabello claro o rubio, y ojos claros este % es mucho más alto en cualquier colegio del sur de España que del norte, te pongo como ejemplo los niños porque las personas adultas se pueden teñir el cabello y los niños normalmente no, si insinúas que en el sur la gente es más "africana" estas hablado sin saber ni lo que dices.
He makes it sound like Spaniards are more closely related to Middle Eastern people with a small amount of northern European DNA. I feel like he's totally disregarding the Sardinian component from the Earlier European Farmers and he's emphasizing the 5% of Morrish DNA found in the Spanish genome, which by the way does not represent individuals, it represents the entirety of the population, so there are individuals without any significant portion of Morrish DNA. They might have a half a percentage but I feel like he's emphasizing the Mediterranean component. In fact Spaniards and Portuguese tender cluster between Sardinians and French people, also a unique population is the basques, but I feel like this was a lesson in how they are not Western Europeans when in fact they are probably the most Western Europeans lol
@@Matthew4Justice right. In fact, the iberian peninsula is the second european country with more celtic ancestry after the british islands. And the iberians are said to be descendants of the people that arrived here from the east of Europe. White people with dark hair, not as tall and athletic as the germanics. I read one day that the people from Sardinia are the pure descendants of that people. And 5% of northafrican dna is too high. It is much much lower.
Dude, this is just a RU-vid video, it's just general, if you want Full and COmplete content closer to truth, unfortunately the public and social media aren't stimulating... Search anywhere else, like ... in Graphics? Sci papers?
@@user-xb8il5cg2c5% is the average, complexed. People can have more, people can have less or people can have nill. That's why Statitics is important to be taught and isn't in our Education to represent generalities and particularities.
There was never a mass influx of Italian settlers coming to Spain when it was incorporated into the Roman empire, as you state. Simply put, the vast majority of Hispania was inhabited by its original native, Romanized population.
@@sebastianmaharg 5% of latins/italians, according to scholars. Later, about 5/7% of visigothics and suebis (germanics) . The rest, celts and iberians, plus some greeks and people from the rest of Europe, during the empire and later.
I am Uruguayan, and I descend from Spanish settlers Andalusians, Extremadura, Canarians and Castellanos, I also descend from recent immigrants, my great-great-grandparents were Galician, Basque, Catalan and Asturian
You don't have Canaries It's north Africans especially morrocans who conquered Spain for 1000 years Canaries just small tribe of berbers called guanche most of them emigrated to north Africa or killed by Spaniards finally Your ammosal dna dosent reflect ur actual ancestry I'm Semitic although I have 13% middle east Check halagroup to figure out
@@JUVENTUS299 Yes, I do not rely on a DNA test, but on a genealogical minarbol, it is the most numerous genetics that I have (from a political point of view), they already came mixed with Spaniards from the south and southwest, but native Guanches appear...so yeah....
@@BORN-to-Run. En España si son blancos. En mi familia tenemos incluso pelirrojos pecosos y de ojos claros, se ve que no has estado nunca en España y hablas sin conocer.
@@egutiguti3337 Sí, es verdad que nunca he estado en España, pero he visto a muchos españoles, pero sólo algunos eran blancos. Pero no me refiero a cómo "lucen", sino a sus "antecedentes ancestrales". Los españoles (y los portugueses) no son originarios de Europa, son originarios de pueblos del Mediterráneo y de Oriente Medio. Lo sabemos por su larga y extensa historia documentada por todo el Mediterráneo y Oriente Medio. Esos son ellos.
@@BORN-to-Run por lo que dice, no tiene absolutamente ni idea. Mejor estudie, culturícese porque por sus palabras veo un total analfabetismo histórico. Y a parte de paso, vea y consulte vídeos de genética en España y en Europa, la ciencia no miente.
@@g-ps Yes, but I'm talking about WHERE THEY ORIGINATE FROM. That's the point. The Spanish, & Portuguese ORIGINATE from the Mediterranean peoples, "NOT" from up in Europe where White people come from. And the Mediterranean peoples, all the Islanders, south Italians, Greeks, and North Africans (not the black ones) are connected and find their roots in the Middle Eastern peoples. None of these people originate in Europe.
The Celts lived all over Iberia and it is actually thought that the Iberians were actually Celts - the Visigoths started the Christian reconquest and resettlement with Catholics from western and central Europe - not to mention the re-population of southern Spain with catholic colonists from central Europe in places like La Carolina in Andalucia. Modern Spanish culture has its origins in the Romanized Visigothic culture there are a lot of lies told about Spain because people don't know the history of the North African moors who were expelled. Spain is one of the only countries in Europe that had to put up a fight to remain European and Christian.
@Mathl7979 claro, pero no es menos cierto que ni siquiera los celtas europeos eran étnicamente homogéneos. Recuerdo haber leído que se da ese nombre, más cultural que étnico a un conjunto de pueblos que habitaron Europa occidental y que eran el resultado de la mezcla de primeros grupos autóctonos con recién llegados del norte o el este de Europa. También los iberos tenían diferencias entre los distintos grupos existentes.
"Iberians were actually Celts" not really, the samples don't show any Steppes in the early stages. "there are a lot of lies told about Spain because people don't know the history of the North African moors " including yours, there were never a Reconquest, but a Christian conquest, it was more complicated than there. People most changed religion.
I am PuertoRican and my grandparents on my dad 's side we came from the Canary Islands. And I have proved it with records of my ancestors. Of course it all started thru DNA test. I was always love history and genealogy. I knew because of all different groups that came into Spain is why we are mix and more now was that spread to the West but "I love your break down" in this video. Thank you!
@@luisvelez5695HOLA, HERMANO HISPANO. NO TODOS LOS PORTORRIQUEÑOS HISPANOS SON DESCENDIENTES DE CANARIOS. A DIA DE HOY, HAY PORTORRIQUEÑOS HISPANOS CUYOS ORIGENES SON DE OTRAS REGIONES DE UN ESTADO ANTERIOR, EN EL TIEMPO, QUE SE CONOCIO COMO MONARQUIA HISPANICA Y QUE PUDIERON TRASLADARSE A PUERTO RICO, SIN IMPEDIMENTO LEGAL ALGUNO. QUIERO DECIR QUE, EN TERMINOS GEOGRAFICOS ACTUALES PUDIERON LLEGAR CANARIOS, ANDALUCES, EXTREMEÑOS, CASTELLANOS, VASCOS, CATALANES, GALLEGOS,MURCIANOS, ASTURIANOS, CANTABROS,NAVARROS, Y AUN MAS PROVINIENTES DE LA PENINSULA IBERICA COMO PORTUGUESES, O, DE EUROPA COMO ITALIANOS, HOLANDESES, BELGAS, LUXENBURGESES, ALEMANES, IRLANDESES, O, DE ASIA COMO FILIPINAS, FORMOSA, O, DEL PACIFICO COMO GOA, ISLA MARQUESAS, ISLAS CAROLINAS, O, DE AMERICA DEL SUR COMO ARGENTINA, CHILE, PERU, URUGUAY, PARAGUAY, BOLIVIA, ECUADOR, COLOMBIA, VENEZUELA, O, DE AMERICA CENTRAL COMO PANAMA, COSTA RICA, NICARAGUA, HONDURAS, EL SALVADOR, GUATEMALA, O, DEL CARIBE COMO DOMINICANA, CUBA, O, DE AMERICA DEL NORTE COMO MEXICO Y MUCHOS ESTADOS DE E.E.U.U.( CALIFORNIA, OREGON, NEVADA, UTAH, COLORADO, KANSAS, ARIZONA, NUEVO MEJICO, TEXAS, FLORIDA Y PARTE DEL RIO MISSISSIPPI CON LA LUISIANA). ESTE BASTO TERRITORIO, Y TRESCIENTOS O CUATROCIENTOS AÑOS SIN RESTRICCIONES DE TRANSITO DE CIUDADANOS Y MERCANCIAS ENTRE ELLOS, PRODUJO UN MESTIZAJE ENTRE NATURALES DEL PAIS Y GENTE QUE TRANSITARON POR EL, PARA QUEDARSE O PARA LLEGAR A OTRO PUNTO DE LA EXTENSA MONARQUIA HISPANICA. POR TANTO, CON TODO RESPETO Y HUMILDAD, LE COMENTO QUE NO TODOS LOS HISPANO-PORTORIQUEÑOS EN SU ANCESTRIA GENETICA SON DESCENDIENTES DE CANARIOS, PUEDE HABER MUCHISIMAS ANCESTRIAS DE DIFERENTES ORIGENES. UN SALUDO AMIGO HISPANO.
me too Mainly Spain( Asturias, Catalunya, Canary Island), small percent English, Irish, Scandinavian, native American, some Western African, Ashkenazi Jewish
Moroccans & Spaniards have the same Gino As I said all the time We are brothers you like it or no After almost eight hundreds years Livy together for sure nobody can denied it For that reason we are obligated to cooperate all together for ever plus the portugais too Two brothers or threes plus Portugal No shame about we still love those countries Beside that we are the closest neighbours Got it accept it live with it & be friend
I'm hispanic, have Mexican mom and my dad's parents are but I honestly dunno if my ancestors were from France or Spain. Might've been both, but they are white so they def came from somewhere in europe.
@@justinaccount9920 Yes I agree all the strips north and north east La Galicia and & the north until the frontier of French north northwest ( ex head quarter of the ETA) One time during 1975 the Spaniards obligated me to take the autopista Lucky the French side was open I just run to French side and given my passeport without paying Because they stopped me near a Granada and I was just behind two trucks They said I did cross over the continuous ligne & it was true They gave a big ticket & I didn’t had enough So they escorted me to la Caja national Where I charge my travel checks & pay cash I did ask for the prouve of my payment They just answered via that time they had a problem with France 🇫🇷 where my car 🚙 was immatriculâted The police was corrupted to the bones The reason I didn’t pay 💰 the highway
@justinaccount9920 take a DNA test via Ancestry. You'll find a wide mixture. Most Mexicans and those of Mexican descent have Spanish, Portuguese, North African, Native American, Basque, Celtic (listed as Irish), and West African from slavery. This last is typically a trace, 3 to 5%. Some of us have traces of Asian from Filipino ancestor due to the Spanish trade route and conquest of The Philippines.
@@dianalugo8327 I agrée that Bilbao Santanderre Bsyon all the Bascos and Galicia were not dominated par the moorish But most richer Andalusian went North to Escape torture & supplicies against them Most ré immigrated to England 🏴 one of them was the lateQueen Elizabeth way be in peace with her never got involved in religion The proof a lot of Andalusians are back to practice their muslims beliefs as their grad great father & mothers used to fallow Anyway the Moroccans used to be soldiers warriors keeping the law & orders Few Moroccans were involved in mixed mariage They were going & coming every six months Most or them having their families in Morocco 🇲🇦 Got Mejicanos my trees Amigos ola
@@MrGreenfiveHechos : España en 2023 tenía casi un millón de musulmanes y Reino Unido tenía en 2021 tres millones novecientos mil ,casi cuatro millones ; si tenemos en cuenta que este dato es de 2021 , en 2024 deben tener muchos más de esos cuatro millones. Por si le interesa busque en Google los datos ,son EXACTOS. ¿Quiere más pruebas ??????.
he honestly should have , but either way everything he said for Spanish genes also applies for Portuguese, Spanish and Portuguese genetics are virtually identical
Mexican here and my ancestors came mainly from extremadura , la mancha , andalusia from my moms side my dad is from northern mexico most of his ancestors were basque , asturias cantabria and other parts of north castile and andalusian .. found a few ancestors from both sides that are from murcia , valencia , aragon , portugal and some with french last names and some with sephardic last names and even italian last names but they dont make up the majority and are only a small fraction compared to the rest of my ancestors .
Check your halagroup you might be berber ot arab The atomsal dna isn't revealing the ancestry of your antespassados But analyzing your biological features or blood
The Spanish Christians rarely ever mixed with their Muslim invaders. 1-2% max DNA from N Africa. Thats it. Incredible to think considering the Iberians were occupied by the moors for HUNDREDS of years until La Reconquista of Spain was finished in 1492 in Granada. Talk about a tough and resilient people.
12 thousand Moors did not make an impact on 14 million iberians. They were a tiny minority with most of them eventually being white iberians that converted
@@user-cm9pt8bo3l the mountains of Asturias was never conquered by Moors .. that's why there's a famous saying Asturias is Spain the rest is just conquered territory. All the people from Asturias have no Middle Eastern or black blood in their DNA results .. many of them look like germans, swedes, austrians, add dark irish. You will never see someone who looks like Pedro almodovar in the North
Im of Italo-Ibero descent with my dad being from Argentina and mom from Italy I did 23andMe im 70.5% Italian 24.1% Spanish and Portuguese 1.8% Coptic Egyptian 1.4% broadly Northwestern European 0.8% Broadly Southern European 0.4% indigenous America 0.4% broadly Arab Egyptian and Levantine 0.3% Ethiopian and Eritrean 0.3% Levantine My Italian ancestry is primarily from Campania also with ancestry from Molise Piemonte and Sicily My Spanish ancestry is from Valencia and Andalucia (I also have Spanish colonial ancestry from Argentina so I probably have ancestors from all over Spain but Valencia and Andalucia are recent from my great great grandparents) My Argentine ancestry is from corrientes
Todo el mundo debe saber, que en cada país cuentan la historia de forma diferente, esta es la historia que supongo que enseñan en los paises anglosajones que es diferente ha la historia que se estudia en España y diferente a la historia que se aprenden en Marruecos, por poner un ejemplo en Marruecos aprenden en los colegios que España es suya por que fueron espulsados de allí y estubieron en España durante 8 siglos.
The new schools in Morocco are lying to themselves. Spain was never theirs. They are not even a European or Iberian people put from some other continent. The average Spaniard does not look like the average Moroccan
Pero en Marruecos no recojan muestras de ADN, ni siquiera de Historia: ¿Quienes habían antes de llegar ellos a España? seguro que no lo tienen en cuenta
I’m Cuban American and let me tell you that it seems to match the things you just mentioned,besides Spain I got Portuguese,basque,Irish and southern Italian with North Africa
I am moorish Amazighan & i know that’s most Spanish got Moroccan ADN and I travelled a lot throughout Spain 🇪🇸 If you are coming from Spain 🇪🇸 to Morocco 🇲🇦 for the first time you think you are still In Spain & vis versa Every things look the same the white houses the people White brown blonde or black hair with black eyes large one Even the blonde have black big eyes until passed Madrid to the North It is hard to think about but As I said all the times The same blood 🩸 brothers You like it or not Beside the architecture the churches looks like mosques 🕌 just the cross or Jesus added Got myself drunk in Morocco 🇲🇦 & take my to Spain I am still in Morocco Brothers separated by a few miles from Tarifa in the evening you can see Tangiers & vis versa It is going to be fabulous & fantastic to build this Tunnel and the it will be no borders Ps: we are neighbours brothers from long long time ago and still we do
I was born in Spain to Spanish parents. I can trace my family tree back to over six generations in the Castilla and Leon region. My surnames include Juarez, Moreno, Salvador, Valles, Bravo, Pozo, Alvarez, Marcos, De Rodrigo, De Villares, Montero, Rodriguez, Montalban and De Sanfrancisco. My ancestry DNA has the following results: 98% Spain 1% Basque 1% North African.
I’m Puerto Rican and mostly Spanish / Portugues / Native Taino / and other European (mostly Western, some Eastern) and Middle Eastern and various African nations. Basically we are mutts.
me too Mainly Spain( Asturias, Catalunya, Canary Island), small percent English, Irish, Scandinavian, native American, some Western African,Ashkenazi Jewish.
Interesting, I understand now why I got 5 % Scotland dna on my ancestry dna test results. I was born in Cuba and migrated with my parents to the US long time ago. To the best of my knowledge I have ancestors from Galicia and the Canary Islands. My ancestry dna test results were : 58 % Spain. 20 % Portugal. 6 % Indigenous Cuban. 5 % Scotland. 3 % Northern Italy. 3 % Northern Africa. 2 % Middle East. 2 % Sub Sahara Africa. 1 % Sardinia.
I’m Galician and have 35% hunter gather DNA on primitive testing. 55% Neolithic farmer. 10% steppe. I have tested negative for North African, Jewish, and Levantine autosomal DNA. I have 18% Irish DNA possibly Celtic related.
@@asturiasceltic3183precisamente la zona de Galicia, parte de León y parte de Portugal, el índice de ADN norteafricano es el mayor de la península. Entre un 10/15 % mientras que en el resto de la península la media es del 7%. Consúltalo, existen cientos de estudios europeos al respecto.
"we don't." there isn't a broad study to you affirm that, but the biggest 'till now says you have big north african DNA, the biggest after Portugal in Iberia @@asturiasceltic3183 🤷♂ There is genetic convergence to Portugal and Andaluzia as well, this last one high romanized, so...
Ufff, it is a little bit more complicated. Firts: is true about hunter gatherners and anatolian but the first influence of indoeuropeans came 4500 years ago in the first wave of these people (arround 95% of Y chromosome is R1B among spanish men). After that came another waves of proto celtic and celtic peoples. Second: Roman influence is true, myself have more than a 20% of etruscan origins. Germanic invasions also true: aboiut 5 %. Moorish is very residual cause the islamic people from Spain was the original pople converted to Islam and the north african armies in this age were pretty small. The north african influence was minimal. Also, during Middle Age was common to bring colons from other parts of Europe.
Right. Such a dry place like Arabia could never had that many people to occupe and substitute the people of the ancient Roman empire. There are too many myths around this issue.
I'm Iberian 57%, Celtic-Irish 21%, French 10%, English 5%, Italian 4%, Broad Western Europe 1%, Askenazi Jewish 0.9%, Sephardic Jewish 0.6% Others 0.5%. approx... No North African genetic trace in me.
Irish does not mean Celtic. What are people meaning when they state Celtic? Also are you going by a dna test instead of genealogy in stating what you have. Depending on the dna test you can get different results so I wouldn't use a dna test as stating real ancestry.
I love your videos. However, I have a request. I am Egyptian and I loved the video that you made about Egypt. I would love and appreciate if you made a long video about the Egyptian race/ ethnicity. There is a systematic attack on Egyptians where African Americans accuse us (Egyptians) of stealing their land and that we are invaders and intruders and that our civilization does not belong to us. This is all fueled by the Afrocentric ideology and the pseudo-historians like (Cheikh Anta Diop). This ideology clams that all of the North African civilizations belongs to the Blacks (the sub-Saharan Africans). They claim that we are not Africans because we do not fit to the sub-Saharan facial features. Jada Pinket smith who is an afrocentrist made a movie depicting Cleopatra as African with sub-Saharan features. African Americans see the world in such binary view. Egyptians are not white and not sub-Saharan black either. Even Egyptians with the darkest of tones don't share the same facial features with sub-Saharan Africans. There is a spectrum of skin tones in Egypt that ranges from Mediterranean light skin to champagne and olive skin tones to that reddish brown (that was depicted on the temples) to the dark brown. My father was brown (and can be considered as black in the American eyes) and my mother is light skinned like the Mediterranean people. The sad reality is that the Afrocentric movement is claiming all the North African civilizations to be black. Not just Egypt. Egypt, Libya, Tunisia, Algeria and Morrocco are black civilizations. And the people who live in those counties now are thieves and intruders. This Ideology spread like wildfire by those fake historians and a lot of African Americans and Sub-Saharan west Africans now believe in it. It's insane. They claim that we pushed them out of the country and that the whole ancient Egyptian civilization is not ours. It would be great if you made a video about Afrocentrism and this topic. Thanks again for your videos. Wish you the best.
@@massculiniThey have done DNA studies on Ancient Egyptians, 10% Sub-Saharan African, with modern Egyptians being 20% Sub-Saharan African because of the Muslim slave trade. Egyptians usually controlled northern Nubia, North of the first cataract and hired Nubia mercenaries as guards and soldiers. So there were usually some Sub-Saharan Africans in Egypt during Ancient Egypt.
There is not a 10% admixture with north Africans: about 5% of the Spanish male lineages have north African origin, but that doesn't equate to 5% north African DNA either (which could be almost nil in fact, since less common DNA tends to dissapear after several generations). You are going to find more Iberian ancestry in north Africa than north African ancestry in Spain as well, because Iberian Muslims fled or were expelled to north Africa during and after the reconquista. Btw, Andalusians have LESS north African male y-haplogroups than Galicia, a region that after the Canaries has the higher percentage in Spain. There is nothing you can call "Celtic" DNA either, the Indo-European invasion of Spain predates that non existent "Celtic" migration you cited by two thousand years. The Spanish DNA is basically Basques (Neolithic 45%, Indo-European 40%, hunter gatherer 15%) plus a little of Mediterranean admixture (mainly Italian). Other migrations didn't affect the whole DNA makeup of the Spanish very much. And lastly, you have to take in consideration PHENOTYPES in order to understand how populations appearance varies in different latitudes, it's not just DNA.
The North African admixture seems to be rather 5/6%, that's true. Actually, the highest average is in Galicia at 11%, so 10% is indeed higher than the actual average. But maybe he's counting Canarians in there, which usually are excluded when it comes to Peninsular Spaniard dna for obvious reasons.
Thank you for this comment it summaries everything I’ve studied about the reconquista. I never understood how Spain could have kept North African DNA from the moors/Berber’s or Arabs considering other occupations such as Roman’s controlling Britain for hundreds of years or Arabs taking over Persia when both of those groups don’t claim to have their oppressors DNA left behind. Very lazy reading of history considering the reconquista was a race war fought with the sword to expel Arab rule the Jews fought along with the Christian’s.
@@Mr1329932, The Jews allied themselves with one or another depending on the historical period. At first the majority was with the Muslim invaders, then in the end they opted for the Christians, who dominated, since the beginning of the 13th century, the bulk of the Iberian Peninsula.
@@Mr1329932 Arabs rules just in the Umayyad era, Jews were living peacefully among Muslims and doing all they want, Spaniards forced them along with Muslims to convert to Christianity and some of them were killed and other were rescued by the Ottomans and others ran to Morocco.
There was some Visigoth expansion west in the later Roman period due to pressure from warring Mongol hordes. The Visigoth were from places around Dacia and Romania and present day Bulgaria (the Eastern Provinces of the Western Roman Empire). I have heard some linguistic similarities between Castilian Spanish and Slavic Bulgarian. Uno Edno, Dos Dve, Tres Tri, Quatro Chetiri, in the number system as a quick example.
The visigoths were not a “ pure race group “ they were simply a confederation hodgepodge of peoples from different areas the base being germanic and the rest being sarmatians , dacians , thracians , prussians , slavs , baltic peoples etc. its even documented that roman slaves and other roman natives joined them . they were joined by many other nearby tribes where they settled next to and eventually assimilated them into their gothic group and culture. You can see some evidence on this online the slavs carry haplogroup r1a which is found in eastern europe mainly but is found in pockets throughout the iberian peninsula especially where the goths took refuge the most . And haplogroup r1a prior to the goths was not native to the Iberian peninsula.
The woman you put on your advertising ain't spanish descent, she appears to be mixed indian or Amerindian but no a Spanish person has that complexion and facial features
you should have included the Portuguese, as they share a common DNA story with the Spanish. like, the entire Iberian peninsula shares the same DNA story
No, los portugueses tienen entre un 10/20% de ADN norteafricano. Más o menos como la media en Italia centro y sur. Mientras que en España la media del ADN norteafricano es del 7%, de norte a sur, este y oeste.
@@g-ps hasta épocas recientes, esas ciudades estaban pobladas por españoles de origen y eran muy pocos los marroquíes que vivían allí. Incluso las mujeres marroquíes cruzaban diariamente la frontera para trabajar en Ceuta, como empleadas del hogar la mayoria, esto hasta los años 80 era así, pero después con la llegada masiva de inmigrantes se establecieron muchos de ellos en las dos ciudades, pero antes era diferente y la mayoría de sus pobladores eran españoles de origen, de los que llegaron de la península, eran andaluces la mayoría y también muchos venían de familias militares de toda la península.ya que allí se concentraban muchos cuarteles, porque había mucho ejército.
As a spaniard (Galician) i thought i was going to have more north african DNA since everyone is so keen on thinking we are extremely related. But my dna test showed im 60% iberian, 15% german, 15% irish Scottish and from whale's, 8% from the balkans and 2% north african. It also surprised me not having any italian dna for the same reason.
Are you really from Galicia? It's because people from this area along with the educated people know that the Northwest has absolutely no Middle Eastern DNA and were never conquered by Moors. Historians, scientists, anthropologist know this. Are you talking about the little millennials from Latin America and Andalusia on RU-vid that are jealous of Northwest Spain's Celtic DNA and the fact they were never conquered by Moors. So they come on RU-vid trying to make false rumors that the uneducated, gullible believe
I’m Puerto Rican, the biggest mix in me is Portugues then Spanish, North and Central African, and like 15 other mixes. Total mutt, I look very Mediterranean, my mom white looking, Dad more African, native indigenous look.
High levels of North African 😂😂 that’s a joke. The Muslims did not mix with ethnic Spanish that much. Only some people in Spain have a small percentage of arab or North African blood. It is estimated that only 60.000 Muslims came to Spain and they did not mix with the ethnic Europeans as you are saying. Just look at some dna test from Spaniards.
@@adamnesico a qué historia te refieres….. as leído algún libro al respecto? Sabes algo sobre la reconquista cristiana y los tiempos de recuperación de esas tierras, en diferentes etapas y reinos? Pues te aconsejo que lo eches un vistazo, es muy interesante. Y de paso un vistazo a los estudios de ADN en Europa, por supuesto que NO se mezclaron.
@@egutiguti3337 He leído libros, he leído lis tests de ADN. Claro q hubo mezcla, ahí tienes a los andalusies del Magreb con adn ibérico, ahi tienes la lista de líderes islámicos mezclados, incluso algunos cristianos como Mauretato.
@@adamnesico jajaja jajaja, no entiendes nada….. los andalusíes de Marruecos son los moriscos expulsados de la península tras la reconquista y eran de etnia ibérica, lo que demuestra todavía con más rotundidad que no hubo mezcla, porque también ellos tenían de ADN R1b. Celtíbero. Por eso todavía hoy en día se distinguen del resto de marroquíes que son de media ADN R1b1. O no has entendido nada o tu comprensión lectora es mínima. Mejor consulta vídeos de los estudios de ADN en Europa que los hay a cientos y todos dicen lo mismo. Que no hubo mezcla.
@@adamnesico. Pero si precisamente los andalusíes eran ibéricos expulsados tras la reconquista y tenían ADN rb1, precisamente eso es lo que demuestra que no se mezclaron. Más claro el agua.
Mate, you have a serious confusion between the Berbers and the Phoenician. These two people have a very different genetic makeup. While the results you showed clearly show the 10%of berber component in Spanish genetic makeup, which is correct as a gene flow between Iberia and North Africa predated the Islamic expansion. Moreover, the Phoenician had little impact on the population in North Africa and Iberia except Tunisia. Please correct your analysis. FYI, berbers had their own civilisation through Numidia and their preceding kingdoms of Massyl and Massaesyles (present Algeria), which had interaction with the whole Mediterranean world.
In fact its suspected that the jews impacted the genetic pool of iberia more than the phoenicians did since after the expulsion of the jews not all left and many actually converted and stayed or moved to spanish colonies
@@clo8862 the only problem with your statement is there is no such a thing as Jew ethnic group or Jew genetic marker. A Jew is an individual who practices judaisme. Regarding Islamic Spain Jews, the most likely they are of berbers descent
Can you please do a video on French DNA? Breaking down the regions of France just like you have done with this and other videos? If so, that would be amazing! Thanks.
Not true. Obviously the steppe men impact was lower as you get far from the steppes. Current genetic studies show that. Also european population became taller because of those steppe men, while spanish remained short. Another evidence is that the iberian peninsula entered the bronze age in a very gradual way compared to the rest of europe. There is also evidence about previous languages not being replaced by the languages that the steppe men used, the most obvious example of these would be Euskera.
@@carlsderder Child, you don't know nothing about this subject. Better read the study made by Harvard University, Barcelona University, Coimbra University, conducted by David Reich and published in scientific journals like Nature and Science in 2019. You must study more...
Spaniards (as in Spain not simply Spanish speaking people) have, in my opinion, some of the most attractive women in the world. And it's almost definitely because of this mixture of DNA. Generally it seems like the more mixed a population is, the more attractive people are broadly speaking. Don't get me wrong, there are extremely attractive women in every ethnic group just as there are also unattractive. I'm just saying, for my personal preference, Spaniard women...or perhaps Mediterranean women broadly, are the most beautiful women on earth. 😍
I think South American Indian, Spanish mix makes the most beautiful women. EG Colombia. I would not advise anyone visit Colombia as it's dangerous place.
In fact Steppe related ancestry reached in Iberia long before the Celts arrived in there. It was mainly taken there by the Bell Beaker Folk about 4,300 years ago. Celtic migrations arrived much later, about 3,000 years ago and had a much smaller genetic impact.
Exactly. Celtic is jsut a culture, jsut as Mediterranean is just a geographical concept. The Italic Mediterranean poeople were closer to the Celtic than to the Mediterranean people in North Africa. I don't like when they use cultural and gepgrahical terms in a genetic way, because it is missleading and just untrue. You get Spaniards were a mix of Mediterranean and Celtic, yet, their Mediterranean component was closer to the Celtic than to Mediterraneans elsewere in the Mediterranean. I don't know, those lebels don't make any sense to me. Italic were closer to "German" Celts than they were no North African Mediterraneans, yet, here you have both of them being leveled Mediterranean, I just don't get it.
@@MrMiguelForster I don't think so. From a linguistic perspective both Berones and Celtiberians were undoubtely Celtic speakers whereas other poeples like Lusitanians, Gallaeici, Astures or Vaccacei were proto-Celtic who sopke other Indo-Eurpeans languages. So at least two differentiated migrations into Iberia happened during the Bronze Age and carrying different branches of IE languages with them.
For sure... Something weird with the Celtic heritage is that it's usually linked to Northern Spain, whereas the real Celtiberia was in the East. + There has been more genetic impact by the Moros around Valencia than in the South.
@@dionisiodussart5629 Yes, most probably NW Iberian peoples (Gallaeci, Astures, Cantabri, ...) were IE but pre-Celtic speakers, although there seems to have to been some migrations from Celtiberia proper to those areas in a very late period.
*Viva a todos os ibérico e íbero-americanos.* 56% Portuguese (Including the possible North-African and Middle Easterns from Carthaginian, Phoenician, Roman and Muslim times) , the others Native (I'm from Mid-North Brazil) and minor Subsaharan Africa (with 5 major groups - SG, Guinea, WAfrica, C. Africa) Culture is more important than DNA in Countries Post-Imperial, but DNA tells a lot of History and helps understand culture too. Brazil, a big guardian of Iberian Culture, specially Portuguese.
Was told growing up I was half Spanish. Turns out I'm only 6% Spanish, 8% Italian, 3% North African. The rest is a mish-mash from all over the world, but mainly Irish & Indigenous MesoAmerica.
.The Jews of Spain who were thrown out in 1492 had a choice either to convert to Christianity or to leave. I met people who told me in Italy and Spain that they know from their grandmother that they have Jewish blood in their family
It's well known by everybody that southern Spain has the most Middle Eastern DNA and the northern has zero. Just look at their monuments customs music and phenotypes and look how different it is from the North
I am Chicano (Mexican American) 55% Spaniard (Galician, Basque, Castilian, Andalusian, Valladolidian) and 40% Native American. The 5% is a mix of Irish, North African, Sardinian, Greek and Bantu African. On a more refined test, I had 4% North Caucasian connected to the Ossetian and Circassian people. However, I just count that as Spanish because the Alans (Iranian ancestors to Ossetians) settled and created a kingdom in Spain. Other than that, I’m a true product of the Spanish Empire and their mixing with Native American civilizations. I’ve traced lineages back on both sides to mid 1500s Mexico. My Haplogroup is YDNA G-L497. I do have a more refined Haplogroup, but for reasons of privacy I will not disclose. I understand that G are the Anatolian Neolithic Farmers. This goes to show that a lot of us fled to the Iberian peninsula upon the arrival of the Yamanaya people and their annihilation of the male populations throughout Europe.
@@gmssamakyaahlahhopeful144 I have Sephardi Ancestors, many of whom were killed on the Canary Islands during the Inquisition. However, their descendants kept reproducing with non Sephardic Spaniards and the blood died out
OMG. The % of north african genes is very low as they came in very low quantities and as well they did not mix. On the other hand, Galician people have the highest percentage of north african genes in the spanish part of the Iberian peninsula. There is quite a % if Nordic genes in the spanish ancestry.
No, Galicians do NOT have the highest MENA DNA. They don't have any whatsover and are a celtic people. Some jealous Andulucian or Latino (who descended from Andulucians) and put that on Quora and ignorant people just ran with it. Some people resent the Northwest or Celtic territories for being more European than other parts. Typical Galician looks like Emilo Estevez, the south not so much like him.
I am american and i have Mexican indigenous, spanish ,french, jew and north african. But to everyone around me in new mexico im just another Mexican. Lol.
Probably because you have a typical Mexican mix. The normal thing is a mix of European (usually Spanish, although not always) and Amerindian (Native American). The majority usually meet that pattern... in one percentage or another, but that's the point.
@@Brandon-eo6mx I think that the lack of mestizos in Philipines is due to the fact that the Japanese killed them during WW2. Probably Gary knows more about this and can give his opiniom.
The Iberians not exists ? we come from most of them not Romans; not visigoths;; not arabians; etc..thats why the name of the Peninsula is our roots ; the fpreigners you dont know the essential ..
2:05, you are not following the video correctly, he is "moving forward/grouping" the ethnic groups that existed in a particular period of time when adding a new migration. Iberians are descendants of the early european farmers and western hunter gatherers
Soy del sureste de España y toda mi familia afincada aquí por generaciones en Murcia, la Mancha y Valencia son rubios con ojos azules, a mi madre la confunden con una inglesa y todos nuestros apellidos son peninsulares… en un test de adn me salió un alto porcentaje de información genética vinculado a Alemania y los Balcanes… aunque lo mayoritariamente era ibero, y Vasco francés (eso ponía) ¿será por eso que soy 0- ? En definitiva…. No es todo así como dice pero bueno. 😅
25pcnt of Spanish carry Jewish dna (numerous studies have proved this). Makes sense since they were threatened with death if they didn’t convert to Christianity. The genetic study, based on an analysis of Y chromosomes, was conducted by a team of biologists led by Mark Jobling of the University of Leicester in England and Francesc Calafell of the Pompeu Fabra University in Barcelona
Great video! Very interesting! Im of British and Italian decent but im sure you can find more lol! Im trying to figure out your roots lol. You can pass for Lebanese, turk or Iranian 😅 sorry if im wrong, i like guessing people's ethnicity lol. God bless and good job with all your videos.
Please make a detailed video on the Balochs, do Baloch have Median or Parthian connection, which haplogroups do they have. And where do those haplogroups belong to?
Los vascos son más españoles que nadie, está el rollo patatero del RH que no es más que una mutación en los tipos sanguíneos ocurrida hace unos 3000 años Los vascos son básicamente anatolios por el ADN mitocondrial, femenino, que son quienes conservaron el idioma caucásico e indoeuropeos por el lado masculino en un 90%, siendo los que menos porcentaje tienen de oriente medio
España is ADN 🧬 Ibero, Celta , Celtíbero y otros grupos celtas con diferentes nombres, lo demás es aporte. Los Celtas migraron para el norte a lo que es las islas del norte como Inglaterra , Escocia, Irlanda no al revés.
That is right. Galicia and Asturias in Northwest Spain are Ireland's and Scotland's cousins. They are all Celtic territories and related. They're also one of the few places in Spain never conquered by Moors. Long live their Visigothic King Pelayo
Well… In fact, Andalucía and Galicia are the two regions of Spain with more blue eyed people. My family comes from “La Carolina” a region with high rates of central european settlements and my father and his cousins are blond and have blue eyes. I’m blond, very pale and have green eyes so, not tipycal spanish at all 😅
Mi ADN es 80% R1b. Celtíbero. 9% Europa Nor-oeste, 7% Europa Noreste y 4% Italia norte. Tampoco hay rastro genético norteafricano en mi ADN, soy del centro de la península.
I did to myself time ago a DNA test and I was pretty surprised that I didn’t have any “muslim” DNA (I’m from South Spain) and I was añso surprised that I’ve got a 2’5% of italian blood
Fantastic video, though I will say regarding DNA, we're unsure of the Gothic people. Genetically they were likely a separate group from what was to be referred to as Germania (which was a region inhabited by both Celtic and Germanic tribes, though both could be referred to as Germanic). There was some historical confusion that the Goths had originated in Sweden, but few credible scholars hold this position today. They originate in the east and were likely related to, or the descendants of Scythians.
My favorite Scythian history is that the Persians invaded Ukraine to fight them and that Scythian artifacts are found in the mountains north of Eastern Manchuria, China.
@mrbaab5932 My favorite Scynthian history is their connection to the Israelites that migrated North into Europe. Have you heard of the Dariel Pass, A.K.A. The Pass of Israel?
I entered this video because I thought it would contain interesting information, but it didn't. Ignoring all the events derived from these migrations, conquests, wars and derived laws causes the data provided to lose considerable reliability. I have family in the South of Spain and we are talking about areas of thousands of square kilometers that were literally depopulated during the Reconquista, for example. If you want to find someone with African DNA, you should look for a recent immigrant. North African DNA? It's EXACTLY the other way around. It was first the Romans and then the Vandals who crossed the Straits to Africa. In addition to the centuries-long raids to kidnap Europeans on the coast of Spain, Portugal, Italy... In other words, it is in North Africa where there is a trace of European genetics.
When I was teenager I was working a server job and some white and Asian family thought I was Italian 😂 I told them no I’m just Mexican. So I started doing research and I found out that the Roman’s were in Spain and had kids so my Spanish ancestors were descendants of Romans😂 as I got older I started looking like my native ancestors more until I decided to grow my beads
Nope. That has been debunked and that is a false Internet rumor spread by resentful Andulucians and their deep dark brown descendants in Latin America from swarthy, conquistadors from 500 years ago.. Galacians were never conquered by Moors and they have zero Middle Eastern DNA like the rest of North Spain. South Spain has tons of Middle Eastern and that's why they look the way they do including their culture and music. That's why Galacians look very European, fair, light, little lipped. fine features and are often blonde and redheads similar to Swedes ...and in the South are so dark because they were conquered by Moors. The absurdity of what you're saying is almost like saying Canada is more Mexican than Texas. You're going to tell me that there's more Middle Eastern in Galicia that is nowhere near North Africa as opposed to Andalusia that's right there. No One believes that lie including scientists, historians, and academics. Pure internet hoax started by an Andalusian and dark Latin Americans from conquistadors from 500 years ago. Most men in the north look like Emilio Estevez not Petra Almodovar and Antonio Banderas from the south
LIE....... My family from Asturias did a DNA test and had NO MENA in our DNA. Just look at us and look at the rest who look like Antonio Banderas and Pedro Almodovar in the South. Typical face here is like the blondish man in my thumbnail and Emilio Estevez. Both can pass for Swedes.
You just helped explain why Spain was more advanced in other ways when other European countries were not. They helped disperse people out throughout Europe. Simply that. But they were a composite of other groups who decided to invade Spain. So it was gathering all this knowledge of everything all in one spot.
We all are one and it doesn't matter how you arrived but it clearly shows when we walk the path of ancestory, Its us human origins that that has made us what we are today. Also there are more species that contributed to this development of all species
Southern Europeans are not that related to North Africans. Like almost at all. Berbers during the Muslim conquest made up only like 1% if iberian population. Many of them moved back to North African after the reconquista alongside European white Muslims. Most southern Spanish people are Europeans with Greek and Sardinian components alongside other European groups. They are not Berber or Arab. The o oh reason why people think Spanish people specifically in andalusía are Arab or Berber is because it was once Muslim territory. Therefor they think people there are still Muslim or Berber when it’s not even when they conquered Spain. Most of the Muslim population 99.9% were white Iberian natives. They don’t even make 5% of the genome in Spain
I'm Mexican, and have very thick brows (almost a unibrow) that make me look Arabic/Middle Eastern, for a while I didn't know why, but I guess this (1:34) explains it. 🤙🏽
No sabes que más de 10 millones de ciudadanos del antiguo imperio turco (de Oriente Medio, palestinos, libaneses, sirios…)emigraron a Latinoamérica desee el siglo XIX? Tal vez viene de algún antepasado tuyo. Hay muchos personajes famosos que descienden de ellos. El expresidente Medem de Argentina, la propia Sakira, Salma Hayek, un montón, los españoles tenemos muy poco ADN del norte de África o Medio Oriente, tiene más Italianos y griegos, solo hay que consultar el ADN en Europa que lo puedes ver detallado incluso por cada país.
I am 46% Iberian 9% Italian 8% Baltic 26 % MasoAmerican 2% Scandinavian 5% West Asia and Central Asia 3% inuit With a last name Scottish “Galloway” how is that?? 😅 please 🙏 brake it down for me so curious I consider myself Mexican
there are alot of mexican scotts mostly in northern mexico like by chihuaha from around the time of the mexican revolution and war. also some scottish settled mining operations in jalsico and san luis potosi.
Maybe it is true a lot of the Andalusians immigrants want north to England & Scotland The richer ones Some writ that The Queen 🫅 Elizabeth family want to England from the reconquesta Only God know what did the Catholics toward muslims & the Jews most want the Morocco 🇲🇦 specially in the northern Morocco & the rest of the Moroccans others city specially Fes
@@lakbirsbaihi6201, 🤣🤣🤣 No, not at all, that's ridiculous. He is probably American and is a descendant of some Spaniard who emigrated there. Very simple.