Тёмный

The Complete RELIGION Tier List for Eu4 

Lemon Cake
Подписаться 25 тыс.
Просмотров 69 тыс.
50% 1

You seemed to like the other Tier List, so today, lets tackle theology.
The Eu4 Discord Server (I host MP games there, and am a member of staff):
/ discord
Catch me on Twitch where I play Eu4 MP:
/ lemoncake101
If you enjoyed, a like and a sub would be very much appreciated.
See you next Video!

Опубликовано:

 

6 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 461   
@OcaenNam
@OcaenNam 9 месяцев назад
one thing you didnt mention are the religion specific tier 5 reforms, all the reformed ones have a really good one, zoroastrian can ignore religion entirely, shinto gets free access to divine, etc.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
I mean that's a fair point, I did honestly forget them from the rankings. Well spotted!
@davidsperoni3107
@davidsperoni3107 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 in this line, norse gets way better since you get to raid costs.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@davidsperoni3107 that's fair, although in earnest I think if anything I put Norse a bit too high up already.
@max-imal8588
@max-imal8588 9 месяцев назад
Petition for LemonCake to make a video rating every province in EU4 and to do it in one take.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
... there's over 3 thousand of them...
@max-imal8588
@max-imal8588 9 месяцев назад
Yeah, which just means that you should do it earlier rather than later so thag it doesnt gets to late. You could do a state rating too after the provinces. Maybe a April first video?
@kvlt1349
@kvlt1349 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101delaying just gives PDX time to add more with each expansion. soon there will be 4 thousand.
@max-imal8588
@max-imal8588 9 месяцев назад
Also you dont even need to do sea tiles in the same take! The impassable terrains should also all get honourable mentions.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@max-imal8588 please have mercy
@legitplayin6977
@legitplayin6977 9 месяцев назад
“The complete religion tier list” Oh this will be good “for eu4” aw
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
In fairness, I didn't clickbait!
@celeridad6972
@celeridad6972 9 месяцев назад
12:30 what do you mean ? seems like an accurate tier list to me
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@celeridad6972 if they didn't want Catholic in S, they shouldn't have made it so good!
@Minkybyl
@Minkybyl 9 месяцев назад
Now do a tier list for in-game religions
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
... wait no
@sasi5841
@sasi5841 9 месяцев назад
Sunday schools and several other decisions are also available to orthodox and coptic iirc. The only ones unique to catholic are embrace the counter reformation and declare restraint of appeals.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Yes, but they are unique to 'Christians', hence the mention. But well spotted!
@bradleyn9360
@bradleyn9360 9 месяцев назад
I personally skipped to the end to see the filled out list
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
I can't blame you, but feel free to skip back if you disagree with a placement to see why I put it there. The religions are all done in alphabetical order.
@callofdutywordatwar
@callofdutywordatwar 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101dont wanna
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@callofdutywordatwar understandable, have a nice day
@Xictlii
@Xictlii 9 месяцев назад
Hindu can get you a free 6/6/6 and has many event buffs you can get from the different icons
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Yeah in hindsight I may have been too harsh on Hindu, I can see the argument to bump it up a rank. The monuments on the spot for example I really undervalued compared to everyone else.
@conormcfire
@conormcfire 9 месяцев назад
​@@LemonCake101they have the best religion based monument in the game (arguably) which has CCR and it stacks WONDERFULLY with the 10% ccr from the icon. With this in mind, and admin ideas, you already have 50% CCR, which is huge! HIndu goes to at least the top of a tier for this reason. I would have never got the three mountains if I didn't abuse CCR stacking
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@conormcfire Oh the CCR is great in SP, and the monuments are something I was a touch harsh towards, but overall within all the contexts (MP/SP) I don't know if I can justify too much of a bump up. I will still concede an increase to Hindu, I was a touch harsh on it in hindsight.
@klodpraisor
@klodpraisor 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101they have -2/5/10% dev monument for MP as well, and the 6/6/6 and monarch improvement events are all great, probably the best non-Christian/Muslim denomination in MP tbh
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@klodpraisor yup, that's fair, I have been overly harsh to them as elaborated in quite a few other comments.
@sasi5841
@sasi5841 9 месяцев назад
Orthodox can easily get like 27% missionary strength and 8 missionaries (from monuments, patriarch authority, ideas and policies) without any wierd shenanigans. Recently did a byzantium world conquest by 1700, and turned it into an one faith world conquest by 1730s.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Oh yeah, Orthodoxy good isn't that much of a disputed claim (I hope)
@sasi5841
@sasi5841 9 месяцев назад
The icons also have specific events associated with them. For example: The st. Michael one gives you 5 PA and a huge percentage of you total man power. The st. Nicholas one give you a lot of money. Etc.
@sasi5841
@sasi5841 9 месяцев назад
​@@LemonCake101I know, but it just gets better
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@sasi5841 Yup, they are great for modifier stacking! Shame they are temporary...
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@sasi5841 Orthodox struggles to disappoint, its literally a gift that keeps on giving sometimes
@nicknew907
@nicknew907 9 месяцев назад
Hindu gives you a 6/6/6 ruler every 100 years, best monuments, lots of development, great positioning in the world with wonderful formables, great bonuses, it's positioning lets it expand into multiple religious groups (in both of it's possible positions) and it doesn't suffer from not being able to make any allies like pagan faiths. Definitely above Sikh with comparable military buffs and overwhelmingly better peace time options. You can switch deity for free very often with the gov reform and privilege. I would honestly give hindu S and put it on par with orthodox, the only religion possibly edging it out is catholic because of the HRE
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Hindu I certainly should have ranked higher in fairness, but yeah while positioning is great its specifically something I tried to avoid ranking, otherwise I am just ranking regions. In hindsight though I can see Hindu at A.
@Jesus-jb6ho
@Jesus-jb6ho 9 месяцев назад
Hindu is S tier. Hindu estates are OP. Deities are very polyvalent. CCR, AE, LOTS of Tolerance, -Autonomy monuments tied to the religion. Paired with Buddha deity no other religion can match it. The religion in itself is broken, what makes the Hindu nations suffer are Indian units pips.@@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@Jesus-jb6ho I would not go as far as S tier, I can concede bumping it up a touch as I was harsh with monuments, but AE, CCR may be great in SP, they are just nice side effects in MP, and in MP there is a lack of military buffs from the religion itself.
@Herpestesichneumon
@Herpestesichneumon 9 месяцев назад
​@@Jesus-jb6hoaren't the estates a culture/tech group thing?
@Jesus-jb6ho
@Jesus-jb6ho 9 месяцев назад
Tech group + Religion. Indian sunni countries for example do not have vaishyas. Whereas Indian Hindu have it.@@Herpestesichneumon
@minhuctrinh1059
@minhuctrinh1059 9 месяцев назад
Norse is like Hindu, but for Europe Also I tried the Norway event chain for norse, which i later found out is actually disabled in the live version, so two viable way of getting norse is 1. Be Scandi, get excommunicated, hope for forest event chain (easy) 2. get to new world, get animist rebels to spawn to homeland, wait for event chain to spawn norse rebels instead (less easy)
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That's fair, but the MTTF on those events are insane, and again, not really worth it in my opinion in any practical sense.
@WhoIsTooME
@WhoIsTooME 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 The MTTH on the animist revolt is very low, you just need to wait for age of reformation to start, get to new world, annex and release a south american tribe, feed them a province in Morocco, then either they should reach a norwegian or danish province (which you may or may not need to return first to annex them to them) or you'll need to feed them one more province in like Frisia or Ireland and then you can do it. Really my favourite part about norse is enabling raiding on non-pirate and without idea restrictions.
@hirolpvideos
@hirolpvideos 9 месяцев назад
I would rate Totemist higher. Once you Reform out of a Tribal Federation and you switch to a republic just rotate rulers asap to get all ancestor buffs you want. In the end you have stacked a lot of good modifiers. Not to mention the custom nation totemist republic getting that done waaay faster. It deserves a spot in A Tier.
@Jesus-jb6ho
@Jesus-jb6ho 9 месяцев назад
Imho Totemist deserves an overall B spot, but paired with Republic it's S.
@emib6599
@emib6599 9 месяцев назад
I tried the repubblic version and i never get a good buff. I think there is an anti player bias modifier.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
It's still somewhat RNG dependent unless you are prepared to bird for it, and the fact it is a native religion does hold it back quite a bit. But yes, you can build around it to be better with Republic, but the real A tiers help you build your country, not demand you build around them in my opinion.
@justinianflavius9571
@justinianflavius9571 9 месяцев назад
Buddha Diety allows you to use a lot of Eastern monuments too. My favorite is stacking Hue Palace and the Golden Temple plus the Economic Hegemony and other autonomy buffs, pretty much just removes autonomy in territories out of the story.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That's fair, and as I mentioned in a couple other comments, I can see the Hindu placement being higher, I was quite harsh to it in hindsight given the monuments and events.
@Mugistan
@Mugistan 9 месяцев назад
Let's go minmaxing religion! "for EU4" oh
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Yeah I feel like flipping religions in real life tends to be a bit more involved...
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
This was a fun one, in the future however I really should not do these in one take, especially if I want to make an 'all Tags in Eu4' Tierlist...
@max-imal8588
@max-imal8588 9 месяцев назад
Do it, also do an all provinces rating.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@max-imal8588 ... no
@TocsTheWanderer
@TocsTheWanderer 9 месяцев назад
Surprised you didn't factor in religion specific monuments for Confucianism. I feel like the sheer number of monuments (all Confucian, Shinto, and Buddhist monuments) you can get while being Confucian makes it a low A-tier religion.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
The monument count for them is somewhat impressive, but its nowhere near as full as the Catholic/Sunni ones, but I can see the argument for a higher placement from that.
@banana-vd7jm
@banana-vd7jm 9 месяцев назад
you should try stack as many colonists as possible for a future video
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Interesting, I will consider it!
@danshakuimo
@danshakuimo 8 месяцев назад
Coptic actually got indirectly buffed recently with the Domination patch with added the special tier 4 government reform "Support Monastic Schools" that buffs your clerical ministers privilege with a -5% tech cost (along with +5 loyalty for every controlled holy site). Probably not enough to bump it up a tier especially since other religions got their new tier 4 reforms too, but it's definitely unique among them and as someone who frequently plays coptic nations it's a nice touch.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 8 месяцев назад
Fair enough, and well spotted: I wasn't aware of it, but good to know!
@Madokaexe
@Madokaexe 9 месяцев назад
Animist should be higher, their icon looks cooler than the buddhist one
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Icon looks did not go into the rankings I am afraid :(
@TocsTheWanderer
@TocsTheWanderer 9 месяцев назад
There are 3 Buddhist faiths, so which one?
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@TocsTheWanderer Well, all 3 most likely. In fairness, I think the icons are cool.
@syarifagathon4809
@syarifagathon4809 9 месяцев назад
for me i'll put hindu on A tier, since with religion aspect + monument you can get -20% ccr and -15% ae impact
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
In fairness the Hindu monuments are really good and I can certainly see the argument for a grade bump, and I honestly looking back I didn't consider them enough. Outside the Muslim/Catholic Monument group, I would say the Hindu ones are just barely behind.
@kyberboi
@kyberboi 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 tengri get all the hindu monument buffs if synced and +4 tolerance of heathens and mandate of heaven cb on china :) for me its a ten out of tengri
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@kyberboi certainly options, and you can choose which monument set you want to adopt, but yeah I have to hold off due to the lack of real military buffs, and even in SP there are religions that help you expand more.
@stuartwatson7524
@stuartwatson7524 9 месяцев назад
Confusian is great, just loved my ming and manchu runs. You're right it does kick you when you are down but that makes it a bit different, with low harmony and meritocracy you don't have a hope of mandate. Just made me play the game in a different way which was great
@houstonhagler3392
@houstonhagler3392 9 месяцев назад
For me, Confusian is a high A to low S. Being able to one faith so easily and have pretty much 0 unrest is super strong. My Korean game owning almost all of Asia had pretty much no rebels at all, it was glorious and so easy towards the end.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That's fair, its not a weak religion by any means, and it certainly deserves a higher spot if we consider purely SP.
@sasi5841
@sasi5841 9 месяцев назад
Eastern Roman empire, carolingian empire, and sassanid empire approves of your tier list.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Those guys never get along!
@OcaenNam
@OcaenNam 9 месяцев назад
one of the good things about ibadi is that it has access to both the military schools from shia and the economic and diplomatic schools from sunni without the mysticism requirement
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
There is a reason I put it near top of A.
@dakapo8985
@dakapo8985 6 месяцев назад
"So then we move on to Confusion" Long ass paus. Making ME confused if i accidentally paused the video. Well played sir.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 6 месяцев назад
Yay finally someone spotted that!
@hanneswiggenhorn2023
@hanneswiggenhorn2023 4 месяца назад
12:31 one thing you missed is that early game, because of the many minor HRE nations, catholic has probably the strongest defender of the faith buffs (maybe after sunni), which gives you 5% army morale, a bit of war exhaustion reduction and a huge 20% manpower bonus, which is kind of insane early game
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 4 месяца назад
You mean full defender of Faith? Pretty sure Muslims open with those too, and then that kind of gets into the 'allows/disallows DoF' category as well.
@hanneswiggenhorn2023
@hanneswiggenhorn2023 4 месяца назад
@@LemonCake101 true, but I'm not sure about all muslims, but if I remember correctly only Sunni and Catholic start with full defender of the faith, Orthodox for example struggles to even keep its defender of the faith in 2nd rank, so they got much better buffs compared to others
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 4 месяца назад
@@hanneswiggenhorn2023 that's fair!
@hirolpvideos
@hirolpvideos 9 месяцев назад
I think the modifier stacking with confucian with harmonization and leting you use almost all monuments in the world make it at least A Tier.
@justusmorton6555
@justusmorton6555 9 месяцев назад
Harmonisation doesnt allow you to use all monuments unfortunately. It needs to specifically state harmonisation and not just sycretic faith.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That's a fair though, but even when you get every possible one harmonized, compared to some other modifiers, the buffs aren't great, and they require a lot of work. Furthermore, if Zoroastrian ends up converted by the time you get there, goodbye 10% goods produced!
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Also it doesn't auto unlock all monuments unfortunately, as pointed out by @justusmorton6555
@niluscvp
@niluscvp 9 месяцев назад
you need a correct religion in the province with monument though, which is sometimes painful. Like ankor wat isnt the correct religion at start and several indian ones arent either.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That can certainly be fiddly, yes.
@afridge8608
@afridge8608 9 месяцев назад
I recently played with the thought in anbennar (gnomish religion thats pretty much confucian) and honestly its really underrated. The gnomes have a colonialist game going on and the religion pairs very well with that. You ingore reformation pretty much and you collect religions for buffs plus you get tons of tolerance of the true faith which applies to all harmonized religions. I think the main problem with confucian in base eu4 is the location of china and chinese gameplay in general. First 3 religions you get are probably animist, budhist 1 and budhist 2 and then you can start collecting religions. If you had this in england for example you could harmonize christian and immediately get to collecting
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Well, being an Anbennar enjoyer I would like to say that the Thought is significantly stronger then Confucian, so I don't think its the ideal comparison.
@jacobschmidt8441
@jacobschmidt8441 8 месяцев назад
Hussite has a reform for +1 defender dice roll. You can’t be Poland or Prussia with it though.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 8 месяцев назад
Fair enough, but I find it a bit too out of the way to increase the ranking substantially
@andrew2715
@andrew2715 9 месяцев назад
You get native religion reforms for free if you flip to them as a non native tech group. Of course you have to switch via failed war or bankruptcy which is annoying if you’re a decent size and don’t have cleansing of heretics cb.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Oh interesting, I wasn't aware of that. Good to know! I only ever tested/flipped into them as another native.
@elcazador3349
@elcazador3349 9 месяцев назад
I play single player, so I usually rate war score cost reduction, diplomatic annexation cost reduction, and core creation cost reduction much more highly than other religious bonuses for a generic nation. I imagine multiplayers prefer military and economic bonuses. With how EU4 works, each nation could have a personalized religious tier list. Creating that seems nightmarish. 🙃
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Oh yeah, I mean in a Tier List is not the best way to rank things in that nature, and when you start adding in player goals etc you end up with each country getting a tier list, but SP - WC, SP - casual game, SP - achievement runs so the subdivision can go on for a while.
@strawbunnyfps
@strawbunnyfps 9 месяцев назад
Confucianism slightly underrated here imo, harmony is incredibly easy to maintain and you get a lot of good monuments. Not sure if it deserves A but definitely a strong B imo
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Yeah, but I said before in other comments, the issue is the lack of Military buffs in MP, which really holds it back in my opinion. For a purely SP list, it would be higher.
@Noldodan
@Noldodan 9 месяцев назад
Music is a bit loud
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Fair, I will keep that in mind, I tried to balance making it hearable but not too loud.
@davidsperoni3107
@davidsperoni3107 9 месяцев назад
just to add, coptic used to be the best because the buffs were stronger and got nerfed :3
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Yeah, its a bit weird, Paradox rarely nerfs intended features.
@xgreedogreed4236
@xgreedogreed4236 9 месяцев назад
I don't agree with the Protestant placement. for Mil it gives you 5 morale land/navy as you said but it also gives you 2.5 discipline + 5% morale dmg, 10% national manpower. For other stuff you have -10% prov warscore cost vs other religions, 15%global settles increase +10% settlers chance,-5% dev cost, -10% Construction cost cost. The fact that you put Protestant in the same tier as Hussite it just feels wrong. It will not put them in S tier (although i do believe that they are better than Catholic in MP) but it's an easy A tier!
@xgreedogreed4236
@xgreedogreed4236 9 месяцев назад
Also i forgot to mention: It is super easy to have 3 active 10 year buffs all the time. Church power is never a problem.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
While that's fair, I feel like the other A tiers are making up for that placement with either insane buffs that are consistent, or other really strong mechanics, and current Protestant is a touch below them in power level: and Hussite has a bunch of unique SP blobbing stuff that has to be considered too, for the argument of objectivity.
@BeanBro66
@BeanBro66 9 месяцев назад
I enjoy the list, I guess the one thing I sort of disagree with is the ranking of Fetishist in particular not including the ability to do single cult or shrine for heirs which means their bonuses can be doubled or diversified respectively. Likewise a power of Ibadi would be having more access to scholar bonuses regardless of policy.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
So I didn't mention it in the video, I am aware of the mechanic, the issue is it makes the religion even less flexible. And while -5 unrest is amazing, if you do that, that is literally ALL you are ever getting from your religion.
@QasqaZhol
@QasqaZhol 5 месяцев назад
With tengri you can get access to any great project by syncretising. And you can culture convert without converting to your religion.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 5 месяцев назад
Not quite 'any' only those that support 'is x religion or has syncretised x religion'. If the condition is 'is x religion' you can't. The culture conversion part is neat though for sure.
@DrowseProductions
@DrowseProductions 9 месяцев назад
The Alcheringa stuff could be fixed by making the cult requirement code not be region specific. Like with trade power it's easy to code out a scope that checks whatever your home trade node power is at no matter where it's located.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
oh yeah, using region scope and similar things would make the religion stronger: the issue is, base game doesn't do that, and hence I have to judge it as Alcheringa on its own.
@ninjasheep7492
@ninjasheep7492 9 месяцев назад
I like Fetishist Buddhism because you can grant the one faith estate in clergy to double your cults effect. 20% dev cost reduction is so fun.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That's fair, once you get to Buddhism as a Fetishist and forgo any other bonus, that becomes useful, but I find in practice there are a lot of limitations with that plan.
@ninjasheep7492
@ninjasheep7492 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 that is definitely a fair point. it's only a great strategy as south and east African fetishists who can no CB sri lanka early. West and Central africa that can take a while.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@ninjasheep7492 fair enough, Sri Lanka is really a weird way to enter into India too, everyone else in the area is so much stronger then them.
@Elvenpath1337
@Elvenpath1337 9 месяцев назад
While Buddhist sucks by default, there's something to be said for its Great Projects. It can get a ton of missionaries/missionary strength and culture conversion cost that makes it basically top tier for One Faith/One Culture. It can also access a -10% Minimum Autonomy in Territories monument. Very strong for wide play, too.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That's fair, but I don't think its enough to get them out of D Tier as a lot of those monuments aren't exactly unique to Buddhist, and hence can be just used by other better religions.
@nikolaitregouet
@nikolaitregouet 9 месяцев назад
You went a bit hard on Coptic imo. The CCR is nice. And the discipline and manpower do add up, and Ethiopia and Karabakh/Armenia can buff Coptic to ridiculous levels from their missions…
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
I just believe there are better options out there in fairness, for me Coptic really shows its age with the scale of its buffs.
@abrvalg321
@abrvalg321 8 месяцев назад
23:32 the actual nice thing is that it allows you to have great projects from 2 religious groups, which is very powerful. And maximum tolerance of heathens can be achieved without Buddha, yes.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 8 месяцев назад
That is fair, and should have gotten a mention, the extra monuments can certainly be quite nice.
@albinosbruh4713
@albinosbruh4713 9 месяцев назад
In my campaigns as Ming Qing and Shun I could stay at 100 harmony constantly even while harmonising other religions and the fact that you get permanent cb agains heretics / heathens (even harmonised) if you complete humanist makes Confucian really powerful plus the list of monuments you can get when you harmonise is pretty good. It only lacks in military buffs apart from 10% infantry combat ability but who needs them in singleplayer anyways. Top A tier religion for me
@vartosu11
@vartosu11 9 месяцев назад
IKR, he completely glossed over one of the most powerful things recently added to Confucianism, the fact that it allows you to go humanist instead of religious and STILL be able to declare "holy wars", blobbing like an animal with fewer rebels to contend with. With other religions, you're more or less forced to pick religious for the CB, and after imperialism comes available you'd have to ditch the whole idea group to pick something else. Humanist, however, sticks around for the long run. On the monument front, it's a shame that more than half of the "harmonized" monuments are rubbish for confucians, since you don't benefit almost at all from them, since you don't care about missionaries and missionary strength. There are still some that give you interesting abilities though. Also, for the region, it's pretty important to have an eastern religion (or pagan I guess) to be able to blob into China faster, using the mandate cb.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
I mean that's fair, and in a purely SP context I have to mark it higher, but since MP is involved, the lack of Military buffs REALLY hold you back, and in MP no one is letting you blob in a way that Confucian does well with.
@albinosbruh4713
@albinosbruh4713 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 for MP Confucian is really dogwater yeah that’s also fair but SP is definitely high A tier. Also video suggestion: Form Mughals convert to Confucian and assimilate everyone then profit. Happy new year btw 🫡
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@albinosbruh4713 That would be an interesting run, but Mughals are bit too easy imo, you can chill WC by 1700, and I got a 1705 one faith like 3 years back with them when I was much worse at the game... we will see!
@purple4395
@purple4395 8 месяцев назад
For me Confucianism in SP is easily S tier. It has very good monuments, if you go for a wc you also get a lot of the nice, altough not op, bonuses and in modern patches you can sustain 100 harmony while harmonizing something thanks to the 2 great monuments that give yearly harmony.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 8 месяцев назад
I have discussed this before in other comments, but yeah the requirements to actually assimilate for your bonuses, the lack of military bonuses and honestly lackluster bonuses even when assimilated, combined with the fact that it is one of the few religions in the game that can give you a negative at 'low' Harmony: these where the reasons for the lower ranking.
@Theplaymaker57
@Theplaymaker57 9 месяцев назад
I want a ranking based on just modifiers though 😂
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
... sorry, I will go do better :P
@alfonsopalacios2725
@alfonsopalacios2725 6 месяцев назад
Ngl, ever sincs they buffed Catholic, ive stopped converting to protestant when playing in europe, its just so good now with all the possible buffs
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 6 месяцев назад
Yeah I mean I think there can be some reasons to flip Protestant if you need it for say Prussia or some achievement, but Catholic is very strong to honestly just 'remain'.
@codecixteen
@codecixteen 9 месяцев назад
I have a really hard time hearing you because the music is the same volume as your voice, and your master volume is low, so when I turn you up in RU-vid and my speakers, the noise gets turned up to and makes it hard to discern what you are saying. As a general rule, your backing audio should be no more than 20-30% of the decibel volume of your speaking track. Additionally, you always want to record "loudly" (which is actually just clearly). Your audience can always turn down the volume if they think you are too loud, but if you make them turn up the volume to hear you, you are also making them turn up the volume on any noise/artifacts in the track and that can make it even harder to pick out words. I hope this advice is helpful for your future video productions. Thanks for posting this very helpful guide to EU4 religions! I can tell you worked hard on it. That's why I wanted to give you the detailed advice. :) Have a wonderful day!
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for the writeup, that's good to know. Another issue I found personally is the music I use when I import it from the game files (since I pretty exclusively use the ingame Eu4 music) all the files there are different volumes so I tend to adjust them 'by ear' and I find after hearing my own voice I end up over adjusting the music. I like to think I got better at it over time, but clearly by the couple dozen comments there is still more then enough room for improvement. But good to know for the future, it is easier said then done, especially since my microphone isn't the highest quality thing out there. I also wasn't aware of the 20/30% of decibel rule, so that's good to know! But yes, the planning for the video took a while, thank you very much for the kind words, and I do appreciate the advice. I hope you have a lovely day too!
@nicones1285
@nicones1285 9 месяцев назад
Petition for a DLC Tier list👆🤓
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That would be an interesting one, but I have to admit, I have them all, so DLC vs non-DLC features I tend to forget.
@t.h.8400
@t.h.8400 9 месяцев назад
Alcheringa is better on C tier, as someone who has played quite a lot in Australia chasing the rainbow serpent is too much effort -4 Unrest on Fetishist alone ought to give it a B rank, -5 after taking the Encourage Divination decision (I think you forgot about the estate privilege that doubles the bonus of your cult, in addition to removing stab loss from monarch death) I think that you have to take the Estates unique to the religion into account All Pagan faiths also get +1.5 yearly prestige, -1 unrest and -10% stab cost (after taking stab penalties from the other decisions into account) I spat out my drink when you put Norse into B rank, HARD disagree on it being better than Hindu, Protestant, Hussite & Confucian. They also don't get religion-exclusive monuments and don't really have any events. With Muslim rankings, again, with the estates taken into account (in this case the Dhimmi), easy S tier, at least for Ibadi. Putting Buddhist faiths below faiths that need extra effort to work well/religions that need to be reformed feels wrong. The micromanagement is not THAT bad, I'd say Norse with Tyr god is still worse than any of the three branches. You forgot that Totemist countries never get rulers with bad traits. You seem have limited experience on some of the faiths and that your tiering considerations partially rely on hearsay (cough cough Totemist). That's all and well though, I hope you post an updated one. Maybe when a new religion or a rework rolls around?
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
The estate privilege's does exist, my issue with it is it removes even more flexibility, and -5 unrest is great, but I would like my religion to do more then just -5 unrest. The Norse one high placement has to be considered in isolation but in hindsight I think Hindu has to be higher, but yeah Protestant/Hussite and Confusion struggle for me as their flat modifiers aren't as great. In practice Norse is bottom of D tier due to how hard it is to get in practice. The estates including Dhimmi is what is keeping Muslim in A tier from me personally, but when you get really high up the list, it becomes a lot more subjective I am afraid, so your not wrong, but I also think that A is high enough. Buddhist for me really don't do well in terms of their buffs, even if you assume Karma to be constant which is already a big if since I don't like religions hitting me while I am down, their total list of buffs is quite disappointing. As for limited experience with religions, that's fair, the issue is I would love to have more time to play Eu4, but there are only 24 hours in a day, so I end up having to talk to a lot of people that DO play Eu4 24/7 as well. At the end of the day I can only aim for the most informed opinion, not the objective truth. Otherwise good write up, thanks for the feedback!
@t.h.8400
@t.h.8400 9 месяцев назад
The mechanics of Hussite, Protestant (and Coptic) should keep them above Norse for sure. Norse is pretty barebones. It is the modifiers of your deity with the +10% force limit and nothing else. No events, no mechanics, no nothing. And naturally, I don't expect you to play EU4 24/7. I also can only play it on weekends or one two hours (which I rather spend playing Meiou & Taxes and other map games). But if you are making something all-encompassing like this, there is an assumption that you have good enough base knowledge of each religion to make well-informed opinions. Thank you for viewing and replying to my comment, I apologize for possibly being too harsh yesterday 😅 Happy New Years 🎉
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@t.h.8400 Happy new years! And don't worry about harshness, tonal communication through RU-vid comments is hard. I personally ranked Norse higher since with all else being equal even if it is barebones, in my opinion having access to the +5% discipline deities, construction cost and the other buffs right away without needing to unlock cults or get the right rulers makes it a touch better. I like to think I have a reasonable amount of experience with the religions, but I have to say I am not exactly putting hundreds of hours into say Alcheringa in the same way as I am playing Catholic tags.
@TheCoyfish9
@TheCoyfish9 3 месяца назад
Recently did an Inca campaign and the inti events are pretty insane imo. I got free temples/Stab or prestige for gold/ perma true faith throughout.
@ElSayyidCampeador
@ElSayyidCampeador 9 месяцев назад
Music was a little loud compared to your voice, but I'm a huge fan of your content, best of luck being noticed by the algorithm
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for the feedback, I will try to balance it more in the future!
@Dorrzo
@Dorrzo 22 дня назад
You don't need to have improve relations modifiers going year around for faster AE down tick. it just needs to be at the years end. So with reformed you can get like 34% or 33% or whatever it is quite easily on every yearly tick. In HRE very little can beat that the same goes for advisor, if i can afford it i'll hire an improve relations advisor just for the year tick then switch him out with whatever else i prefer for the rest of the year if im not concerned about monthly improvements/downticks
@JavadHedayat-gs1vn
@JavadHedayat-gs1vn 9 месяцев назад
I would put confucian higher. A really cool thing about confusian is that if you peak humanist idea you will have acsees to a special cb called external perfectionism wich works just like deus vult. Once I tried to do a world conquest as confusian Mughals to accept every culture and religion. At the end it became boring so I didn't finish it but I didn't fought a single rebel while having so much overextension.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
No fair enough, I find Confucian weird in that while it is thematically interesting, mechanically it is lacking as the buffs you get from it really pale in comparison to some of the other religions available, and hence why I gave it a rather harsh ranking. As for the run you mentioned, yeah I did a bit of a different one a while back, 3 years now, running a Mughal Sunni one faith, and with the use of the monuments and a couple other things I got my Tolerance of True Faith up to +25 ish and hence managed to avoid rebels that way, well until I got bored and started hitting over 2k OE, but I didn't even manage to fight rebels that way since I kind of ran out of world to conquer, and finished the one faith in 1706. If anything I believe its a testament to 'Mughals Strong' then anything else.
@zord1352
@zord1352 9 месяцев назад
Literally yesterday was looking for an actual tier list. So don't deny, you pegasuses my phone 😂 Btw, I think it would be a nice idea to add some visualls, showing the owerall stats you get from a religion so you can compare easier. But might be a huge work, idk.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
I mean if I was doing this full time, I can see it, but making the notes and planning this out already took a while, so editing in visuals is a lot on top of that: for me for example a 10 min modifier stacking video with full editing we are already talking 4/5 hours worth of editing, so visuals in a modifier stack would be a week long project.
@zord1352
@zord1352 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 wow, that sounds crazy! I knowed its a lot of work but that's insane. Nwm, keep up with gr8 constant man!
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@zord1352 thanks, appreciate it! Although re-reading I would like to clarify that the 5/6 hour mark is for the whole video, so recording is a part of that and that really takes me a while since I end up doing so many takes (just so we are clear)
@sasi5841
@sasi5841 9 месяцев назад
5:51 since 1.36 deving institutions is kind of irrelevant, since you can just ask for knowledge sharing
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
To some extent, sure, but I find when the world hates me I end up having to
@sasi5841
@sasi5841 9 месяцев назад
​@@LemonCake101really, how come? I usually end up with most tags being friendly or neutral. You gotta work on you rizz bro. You just have to ally a minor, ask for institutions, then break alliance. At most you'll lose 3 diplo mama from extra diplo relations.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@sasi5841 that's fair, but knowledge sharing doesn't help much either when your such a big empire that even when your capital state has the institution, you are still on 3/10, and hence I end up needing to dev it multiple times for it to spread. But that may be just me, and I am taking about my last WC which was a world full state run.
@XeNeXX
@XeNeXX 9 месяцев назад
where is zoro idk the symbol and cba watching 1.2 hrs ty
@bradleyn9360
@bradleyn9360 9 месяцев назад
Very last few minutes
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Its in alphabetical order, its the last one I cover.
@dominikobora5385
@dominikobora5385 9 месяцев назад
1:14:28 for zoro
@Andersl201
@Andersl201 9 месяцев назад
So B tier is the best tier?
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
I like to think of these as Grades and I am an Asian parent: S: Shocking A: Acceptable B: Bad C: Complete Failure D: Don't come back into the house
@Andersl201
@Andersl201 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 I'm just politely disagreeing with your decision. But you made some good points. Now a days I'm deep in Anbennar, I guess you do a full rundown of all your videos to Anbennar next year? :) Btw for an Asian parent grades go I think S is stands for Simple, Double or triple S to impress an asian parent.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@Andersl201 Oh Anbennar, that's certainly one of the topics. See I am tempted to do a cav video on it, its just I don't know if the Anbennar community is ready for a Regent Court Centaur Military Marhold with Sun Elf unit pips...
@Andersl201
@Andersl201 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 nothing my Dak undead goblin horde can't handle! (My current playthrough)
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@Andersl201 undead is certainly an interesting build, that I cannot deny.
@Mkill14
@Mkill14 9 месяцев назад
good list overall and i know we're reviewing religions in a vacuum, but i think you were a bit too harsh on protestant and reformed. Catholicism does have stronger modifiers but unless you're able to be the only catholic in the world, it takes a ton of work (heavily stacking papal influence,curia cost etc) to consistently take advantage of those buffs. whereas protestant and reformed can have almost as good modifiers from the get go pretty much till the end of the game, also prussia requires a non catholic ;D
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
While the Prussia point is true, you can also Prussia as Anglican, Hussite and Reformed anyway, and looking at them in a vacuum as you said I have to be quite harsh on the nature of those buffs to try and maintain a sense of objectivity. However a lot of your points still stand, and while personally as a Catholic I find just getting to 7 cardinals gets you a lot of the way towards Papal Controller, I can see the argument that it does still require work. At least the buffs are insane!
@spencerleifeld7517
@spencerleifeld7517 3 месяца назад
Small note: Hinduism is OK in monarchy, but GREAT in republics, since you can switch the deity out every 3-5 years.
@amilavxilmen5632
@amilavxilmen5632 9 месяцев назад
I'm really glad Zoroastrian is ranked quite high
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Its a good religion!
@alexwang4136
@alexwang4136 5 месяцев назад
Great tier list, although I'm a bit surprised that Norse is even above hindu given that it's got no unique monuments (well except walls of benin but that's in Africa which is quite far from the norse holy site) Also quick question - given that catholic is so extremely powerful, in what circumstance should one actually consider switching to protestant or reformed in a normal blobbing single player campaign except to form prussia or if your entire country is wrecked by centers of reformation (which shouldn't happen in a blobbling campaign)?
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 5 месяцев назад
The honest answer to your first point is looking back I think I was too harsh to Hindu, it should be higher looking back. As for flipping out of Catholic: honestly if you 'want' to, but for blobbing in SP Catholic is just a really good option.
@iggitteggitt3187
@iggitteggitt3187 8 месяцев назад
You forgot the strongest tengri mechanic: When picking a secondary religion you get access to all of their monuments. So you could build the Kaaba without being muslim for example
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 8 месяцев назад
So it does kind of work, but I find the couple extra monuments you get in that fashion not worth moving up a tier: the best on is Shia but even then Shia has a lot more going for it then monuments and hence that ability wasn’t reflected too much on the rankings.
@benabaxter
@benabaxter 7 месяцев назад
Budget Monk just came out with a great video on how to regain Norse as Gotland->Denmark or as Denmark. Reroll your starting heir for a minimum of a 4/4/2, buff him using the Danish missions to make him a 5/5/5, profit.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 7 месяцев назад
Yup, thats one way to make the process at least a bit more achievable, but it is still a pretty insane pain to do so. Also forget this strategy for the most part in MP.
@tomoliop
@tomoliop 4 месяца назад
Keep the lists coming!
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 4 месяца назад
Thanks!
@С.Н0
@С.Н0 9 месяцев назад
Did they fix the totemist "feature"? - I remember when you converted TO tothemist, you could still get > 1 trait on a new ruler. The only downside was you could also get a negative trait unlike "original" Tothemist but it was really good in general. Idk if it's the bug you mentioned.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Oh, converting into bugs? I wasn't aware, but I will have to go take a look...
@joman2729
@joman2729 9 месяцев назад
For Fetishist you forget to mention you can embrace singular cult, giving double the bonus of the cult following. With a mission from Kongo you can also get a cult for your heir. This means you can get 25% dev cost reduction, -5 unrest, 5 merchants or 25% goods produced. Pretty strong
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
I mentioned this in the other comments, I am aware of that estate privilege but I find that it makes Fetishist even less flexible. While you can get -4 (-5 with base) unrest for example, you tend to be pretty much locked into that from that point, and I would prefer my religion to give me a bit more then just -5 unrest. I find the actual best use of it to be the 4 merchants from Zoroastrianism, but that's not exactly guaranteed as Zoroastrianism can get converted before you get there, and again a lot of other religions do much more with less, hence the ranking.
@mehdiaridhi203
@mehdiaridhi203 9 месяцев назад
shia gives up to 15% moral -10% shock damage received AND +10 shock damage and the ability to call on followers piety interaction which scale gives alot of manpower and the dhimmi estate which is one of the most powerful estates IMO
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
I mean yup, its part of the Muslim OP section, and in fairness Ibadi runs around with both Scholars. A tier for sure, at a minimum.
@mehdiaridhi203
@mehdiaridhi203 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 i think it's top A tier better than ibadi and sikh
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@mehdiaridhi203 Ibadi has access to the same schools and more then Shia, and Sikh can get +1 of each mana, among other things, hence the placement.
@nicolestanley5825
@nicolestanley5825 3 месяца назад
I would point out, with Fetishism, there's the clergy privilege to commit to a primary cult, which improves the power of your cult buff. I'm not sure of what it does with all the cults and who exactly gets access to it, but I always do it when I'm playing Butua > Rozwi Empire > Zimbabwe or Mutopa > Zulu with the Mwari cult, and it increases the +2.5% Discipline to +5% Discipline. This is available Nov. 11, 1444.
@nicolestanley5825
@nicolestanley5825 3 месяца назад
With Reformed, I would also argue that the spy network action cost reduction can be a lot more impactful than you give it credit for. Claims are powerful, and if all you're concerned about is getting the CB then sure, it's whatever, but claiming more enemy land makes the later integration that much easier for the low, low cost of a diplomat's time. As claims get more expensive as you claim more land, it can get really annoying and time-cost prohibitive, but this makes it much easier to do en masse.
@5dkuriboh
@5dkuriboh 4 месяца назад
I think you're massively underestimating how powerful the ccr from Maya is. If it was easier to convert to Maya you'd do it basically every world conquest. The main problem with Maya is that to become Maya you have to be small enough that a Mayan nation can force convert your religion. Also if you convert to Maya you get all the reforms for free
@christianwhite8877
@christianwhite8877 3 месяца назад
Do you mean the Mayan branch of Buddhism? (If I spelled it correctly), if so then it's available to Japan with a different method
@RotgerValdes
@RotgerValdes 9 месяцев назад
Normal people: - The religion issue is quite delicate, it's not fair to compare different confessions between each other... EU4 players: - Let's talk about which religion is Gigachad and which is just a trash...
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
In game, ofc.
@assasindroid9128
@assasindroid9128 8 месяцев назад
Shinto doesn't have limited monuments. They have access to every Buddhist monument, so they have a decent number
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 8 месяцев назад
While true, I find that list is pretty limited when compared to say Catholic, or Muslim or even Hindu monument lists. But yes its not as tiny as one can think from first inspection.
@manalord4228
@manalord4228 6 месяцев назад
I think Judaism diserves a Low s-tier placement, because the aspect Purim Teachings gives also 75 faith power for every won war, this means, that you can selebrate a festival every 3 month.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 6 месяцев назад
I mean its good, but S tier is full of honest monsters.
@manalord4228
@manalord4228 6 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 But this means, that you can increase your Income by 120%.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 6 месяцев назад
@@manalord4228 not quite how that works...
@manalord4228
@manalord4228 6 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 You get every 3 month 0.3*yearly income and because there are 12 months, so you can get 4*0.3 off your yearly income. But of cause this means that you need one war per month in order too receive such a high reward.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 6 месяцев назад
@@manalord4228 So yes: but no. See you do spawn 0.3 yearly income, yes. But that is generated income, that's not money on your balance sheet, which means you can't take loans against that income. Also things that scale with income, like money you get from selling crownland, gold rush events etc also don't scale with that income.
@josevitor918
@josevitor918 4 месяца назад
The new netherland missions make reformed much better, but is just for netherlands
@edim108
@edim108 9 месяцев назад
Hindu is deffinitely at least an A tier and maybe even S tier religion. Between the variety of strong bonuses it gives, the events it has and the monuments it unlocks it's an A tier already. Then you take in the positioning of it which allows you to juggle multiple religion groups for AE and the ability to regularly pump out 6/6/6 heirs. Hindu is a strong contender for the strongest religion in the game right there with Catholic, Orthodox and Zoroastrian.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
I mean I won't go as far as S tier with Hindu, but I will concede I marked it rather harshly, so I am happy to move it up a tier maybe even two in hindsight.
@jorisschaltegger2131
@jorisschaltegger2131 8 месяцев назад
Confucian countries unlock a CB against other religions when completing humanist ideas, IMO this easily boosts it to A tier or even S tier. Harmonized religions count as true faith provinces for tolerance, which makes it much better at unrest reduction than anything else. It's probably the best religion for preventing rebellions.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 8 месяцев назад
I should have mentioned the CB in the video, its come up quite a few times now, but I don't think that's enough to justify a higher placement imo, especially due to access to better late game CB's like Imperialism, and the fact you can just... bother to fabricate a claim a lot of the time.
@jorisschaltegger2131
@jorisschaltegger2131 8 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 Religious ideas are a frequent pick solely for Deus Vult, at least in single player. It's of course always personal preference, but if you exclude Deus Vult from the equation I find humanist ideas better than religious ideas in almost every regard. I look at it like this: Confucianism elevates the already strong humanist idea group to one of the best idea groups overall.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 8 месяцев назад
@@jorisschaltegger2131 fair enough, I can see the argument, but personally I only really take religious either for the missionaries for a one faith, or for the morale in MP.
@nymasajista9207
@nymasajista9207 9 месяцев назад
Mayan has great bonuses but is annoying to get since you have to stay small to force convert to it or use rebels to force it. As long as you already have feudalism you get the full final version when you convert to it, I've never played as a native country they seem boring. I got it as Ryukyu by the rebels hopping back to my capital to convert me and as Jolof by coverting to fetishist at the start and releasing vassals to get smaller and forcing a mayan country to convert me once I got to them. Free colonist, ccr, unrest reduction, unit maintenence reduction, and infantry combat ability are awesome, its just annoying to get the religion in the first place.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That's fair, the bonuses aren't bad when you do work through the reforms in fairness, but yeah unreformed religions are going to struggle on the list for personal opinion.
@slakinboyz
@slakinboyz 9 месяцев назад
Great video! One thing I want to point out is that your audio mixing is a bit off. It is kinda hard to hear you over the music. Its a little too loud, or youre too quiet.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for the feedback, its a bit awkward to do given that the music files used for this are all different volumes too, but I will put even more attention into it in the future.
@MyUsersDark
@MyUsersDark 9 месяцев назад
Something I noticed while playing a Nahuatl custom nation with the High-American tech group, is that I did not have the doom mechanic. I haven't tested this, but I believe if you start with a "reformed" tech group (not natives, probably) you won't need to reform, though I missed out on the bonuses you get from reforming, so it's a trade-off I guess. Also I like how RU-vid marked the game as CKII lol
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Oh no, it is Ck2? Time to change that. But interesting point regarding the start as Custom Nations.
@MyUsersDark
@MyUsersDark 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 I assume it's because you mentioned CKII *once* during the Norse section, but still funny also during this video I finally realized the icon in the middle of the Mahayana symbol is supposed to be the Buddha. I guess I haven't played in that region enough to notice.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@MyUsersDark Oh that would make sense, I set the game now. But yeah the icons are hard to tell sometimes, especially since in the game there's a lot of other visual information to process too.
@amb8936
@amb8936 9 месяцев назад
good video! I find the music a little loud compared to your voice, but that is my only qualm.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
The music point is fair, I do need to work with that a bit more, its just annoying how a lot of the game soundtracks I use are all also in different base volumes. But thanks for the feedback!
@TheMelnTeam
@TheMelnTeam 9 месяцев назад
Hindu is too low. It can stack enough CCR that some tag changes get to < 10 month coring, and if you do pick up and run Buddha you get access to those monuments too. The fastest coring in SP + ability to swap off that into tons of missionaries from the Buddha monuments for one faith belongs in A at least. It's also rare enough that it's easy to use -score cost vs other religions. For SP, I put Fetish over Alcheringa in same tier, simply because you can pick Waaq for -2 unrest, then take the decision that doubles up the effect and just sit on that -4 unrest all game. Slap on interfaith dialogue and you're at baseline 1 ToH with -4 unrest, before factoring legitimacy or stability. This is one of the few faiths that can straight up ignore religious or humanist, sit at 100% OE, and not get rebels in wrong religion/culture provinces. A fetish nation with 0 fetish province at 100 legitimacy has 75% unity using interfaith, and 85% if you curtail clergy. Similar to Hindu, once you unlock the Buddhist cult you do have the option to drop Waaq, go Buddha cult, and use all their monuments once you're over there. I consider Norse a trap for similar reasons. It's bad at tolerance, bad at conversion, doesn't give nearly enough from monuments or deity choice to make up for it, and can't swap deity to pick up an entire other group's monuments late game. 10% discipline is simply not a competitive SP benefit compared to what other faiths are getting out of their monuments. Zoro might be S tier in MP if allowed to get that going, but no way is it there in SP. This religion doesn't tolerate well, doesn't convert well, and doesn't have the sheer monument count and benefit of the others. It can't even be like Tengri which can sync access into other monuments and hit +3 ToH w/o any idea investment whatsoever (which if you're not a horde, is something Tengri can do pretty easily, and if you ARE a horde you have the game's best government). It's okay, but it doesn't belong next to Catholic and Orthodox.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
So Hindu I think I did judge too harshly in fairness. As for Fetishist, while that's true, I find going for that estate privilege tends to 'lock' you into the same cult removing even more flexibility, and having a religion be -5 unrest isn't bad to be clear, but sometimes I want more from it then that. But yes, it can be improved through the use of the estates, that's for certain. Didn't see the Norse bits: yeah: its not great. For SP for Zoroastrian, that's a fair point, the issue is the 10% discipline is really strong in MP, and hence that does a lot of the heavy lifting, and Zoroastrian directly enables some really OP stuff from the Persia missions, as well as re-kindling the royal fires being quite strong. If the list was pure SP however yes, I would drop it down quite a bit, most likely two tiers.
@EbonySaints
@EbonySaints 9 месяцев назад
While Zoroastrian definitely has monument and missionary issues, at least with Eranshanr/Iran, you can unlock religion trade propagation and actually have it convert Abrahamic religions as well, which sound stupidly powerful if and when you set upa trade company in Europe. I'm still early in my run, so I don't know how well that will play out, but it could be the case where you can easily take CoTs from a co-beligerant, get >50% trade share, slap on a merchant, and effectively preconvert all of their provinces, tanking their religious unity, making them have to fight constant rebels if they don't have Dhimmi or tolerance and making the next war against them not only simpler, but making overextension less of an issue with a decent ToTF. Also, there's a reform that removes tolerance problems from heathen provinces. It's like Coptic, where the religion is potentially stupidly OP, but only in the hands of one nation and their mission rewards, namely Ethiopia for Coptic with the bonus that makes it Orthodox but with the additional Coptic buffs and Eranshahr for Zoroastrian which gives it stupid buffs like free one monarch point per month as well as DoTF, removing all the balancing penalties that the religion has, and a bunch of other things that utterly make it silly. Any other nation taking those religions are just gimping themselves. Also, I concur with Fetishist with Buddha. You have access to a lot of monuments that more than make up for any shortcomings the religion has. The problem I had with my Zimbabwe run was that they're an economic powerhouse, but have near zero military ideas, so you need to actually pick a couple up unless you want to throw 40 width stacks at everything.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@EbonySaints Yeah the consistency issue is a real one, namely that I considered how OP Persia is with Zoroastrian but not how good Coptic can be with Ethiopia. I can still argue how there are Coptics outside of Ethiopia, and how they don't really benefit from those mechanics, meanwhile 99% of all Zoroastrian runs end up going Persia since that's the only province, but your point still very much stands. Great write up!
@OcaenNam
@OcaenNam 9 месяцев назад
i find it very easy to balance karma with the buddhist religions, just take the karma accelerator from clergy privilege and from government reform then you basically never need to micro it again
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That's fair, but it is still something you have to bare in mind, and even assuming 100% central karma, it really isn't great buff wise.
@Tudsamfa
@Tudsamfa 9 месяцев назад
I'll be honest: You need a bit more [[Charisma]] before I'm willing to watch an hour of content here. Dont fret, the shorter yet in Depth videos are still interesting and well written/improvised. But it's still a no for me dog, I'll be back in the updated version in 2026 or until you wear the funny suit and hat that increase [[Charisma]] by 3. Dialogue Options: > "A bit pretentious, are we?" > "Screw you" > "[[Bargaining]] Couldn't you simply watch it in 1.5x?"
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
In fairness, its a tier list video, and they are in alphabetical order, so feel free to skip around to the section you want. From a personal consumption point of view, I find these ones are great when you have a big meal/are trying to fall asleep. I can also make a version with Subway Surfers gameplay below it if that would help?
@dmitriysmirnoff8636
@dmitriysmirnoff8636 5 месяцев назад
Agreed, Ibadi definitely rocks. You play Kilwa? Go Ibadi and have tons of goods. You want to form Andalucia - go Ibadi Mzab -> Morocco -> Andalucia with inno+divine+espionage+offence fortbuster combo wich nets +25% fire damage reduced and +25% gp combined with Ibadi and Andalucian ideas.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 5 месяцев назад
Pretty underrated to be honest
@Noric.Morava
@Noric.Morava 9 месяцев назад
Great video - i would love to see one on Ante Bellum´s exlusive religions.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Might be an interesting one, but I have to admit that compared to say Anbennar my Ante Bellum experience is very limited.
@sasi5841
@sasi5841 9 месяцев назад
You have to do videos on max reform progress and max manpower recovery and max manpower. You still haven't done max diplo rep, have you?
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Dip Rep no, again, the list is long, and I want to try other things outside modifier stacking too. Like tier lists, and a couple projects already in the works ;)
@gothia1715
@gothia1715 9 месяцев назад
I dont see any point in going Protestant or Reformed since Catholic got buffed big time. Imo those three should be on an equal level of power to make it a choice. Right now i always stay Catholic cause the other two would just be nerfing my own country.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That's fair, and I honestly feel like that most of the time, I find myself only really flipping when I blink and the centers of reformation converted 3/4 of my country.
@ziggytheassassin5835
@ziggytheassassin5835 6 месяцев назад
You didnt mention the Zoroastrian government reform that adds a government mechanic that lets you get +1 of every mana point per month with some other buffs.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 6 месяцев назад
I believe that is a Persia specific though, but yeah either way its not exactly buffing it up a tier.
@ziggytheassassin5835
@ziggytheassassin5835 6 месяцев назад
@LemonCake101 persia gets it from their unique tier 1 government but any zoroastrian nation can get it in the zoroastrian equivalent of the "more power to the clergy" reform. I got it as khorasan.
@jacoblinde7486
@jacoblinde7486 8 месяцев назад
I think the religions like Hindu or Fetishist should get a rework. The mechanic where you get to pick one or two tiny buffs for your monarch's lifespan isn't that interesting in my opinion, especially when one deity/cult is clearly better than the others.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 8 месяцев назад
In the ideal world I would agree, but I think that they have more pressing issues to address in my opinion.
@OcaenNam
@OcaenNam 9 месяцев назад
did you completely forget to mention that you have to give up 1% missionary strength per guru for sikh? you talked a lot about religions giving you debuffs before, and i feel like giving up a total of 6% missionary strength feels really bad
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
I mean that's a fair point, but given the list of buffs you can get instead, I find you are either in conversion mode where you care about that, or in a 'I have finished converting what I care about' in which case you stop converting. Its also pretty playable as a State Religion only with nothing else converted if you build around it, but yes, that is technically true.
@sadettinarslan5324
@sadettinarslan5324 9 месяцев назад
buddha deity is far more useful than you think and of course as a country buff for example khmer. it basically grant the country the option to build dharmic great projects in india as well as eastern great projects. super useful.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
No fair, as I discussed in other comments I was a bit too harsh on Hindu and I can see them going up a tier at least in hindsight.
@christianwhite8877
@christianwhite8877 3 месяца назад
Without any dlc that improves Catholic (golden century), do you think protestant is worth it as Italy? (I don't have the dlc that adds monuments. The nation I started as is Milan (I got an incredibly unlikely start so far. Austria for once has no interest in Italy (it's like the first time that happened in any play through I've tried in Italy). I managed to stabilize the Ambrosian republic before I could have gone bankrupt. I was able to kick Genoa out of Italy (I took there capital and there other province in mainland Italy while releasing a one province nation from Genoa that happened to occupy there last province in Italy) and subjugated luka (or whatever that Tuscan opm was called) in the same war without any coalition because they were only allied to Genoa. Catholic reform desire is very close to 50 even though it's almost time for shadow kingdom to occur, and France (even though rivals with a couple of my allies) became friendly with milan (unfortunately I don't really have a spare diplomatic relation available and neither does France) and it's only really Aragon and castle trying to meddle in the affairs of Italy) also in the long run I'm trying to form rome with one of the best republic's (I'll decide later if I keep the reform or switch to the Roman republic) in Italy (I looked into enough to know how to get the most absolutism I can as a republic for when the time comes, depending on how things go I might attempt a wc/one Faith)
@elcazador3349
@elcazador3349 9 месяцев назад
Animist (and friends) have the advantage of more easily changing to other religious groups if desired.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That's true, but making a religion higher on the list because it is better to switch to literally anything else isn't exactly the positives I have in mind for a strong religion.
@Nerazmus
@Nerazmus 9 месяцев назад
Alcheringa - While Australia itself is not the best region, Indonesia is right next to it and that is one of the best region. So the area restriction is not so bad. Confucian - The negative Harmony is not a thing in practice. Keeping high harmony is not challenging at all. Shinto - Is better. The bonuses are really good. And let's not forget about the amazing events
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
1. I believe the ability to play in Indonesia I reflected with a relatively high B placement, but yes. 2. While not a 'thing' in normal SP, I don't want a religion to kick me while I am down, and in cases like MP where you are not always winning, that does matter I am afraid. 3. I don't think the events make up for its lack of normal buffs, and a lot of the events I think people associate with Shinto are actually Japan specific.
@scorpioneldar
@scorpioneldar 9 месяцев назад
I had a really long comment on this but RU-vid ate it. suffice to say that the Abrahamic religions are defined by their name. ABRAHAMIC as in those who worship the god of Abraham. Zoroastrianism worships a different God (and acknowledges 2 rather than only 1) who's key negotiator/prophet was Zoroaster not Abraham. they are so similar because early Judaism and Zoroastrianism were contemporaries and many anthropologists (myself included) believe they influenced each other during their formation. furthermore Zoroastrianism remained a powerful religion when Christianity was born and likely had influence in how some Gnostics and Dualists viewed the spiritual side of the faith.... Islam would kill the major remaining Zoroastrian empire in its early expansion though some people do still follow that faith to this day. Zoroastrians and Abrahamics are more akin to neighbors who lived next to each other for generations with similar traditions who can't agree on who started their many mostly shared but subtly different traditions. and who may or may not have copied who... as well as what version is best... whereas the Abrahamic are cousins who all agree they have a common ancestor but each claim to follow the families true (or at least best) traditions and that the others are doing it wrong or even shouldn't get to claim their common ancestor at all when relations get real bad. its all really weird and techichal. but yeah. Zoroastrains are there own family. not a member of the abrahamic family tree.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
RU-vid does like to eat comments sometimes, happened to me more then once. Great write up, and good to know! To say I have a surface level understanding of those religions would be an understatement, so its always nice to see an opinion from someone qualified!
@chinchillaruby4170
@chinchillaruby4170 9 месяцев назад
I think reformed ought to be higher. More suited towards tall/MP rather than world conquest though.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Honestly with reformed I find it does a lot better if you have access to all the European churches that give it the monthly fervor growth, and without those monuments it struggles, so I find it performs better when going for SP vc style too. As for the Tier placement, for me as discussed in the video there are still enough drawbacks and insufficient buffs for it to make it really go higher then I already placed it from a personal opinion point of view.
@justincronkright5025
@justincronkright5025 8 месяцев назад
I've always hated religion differences in E.U.IV. - always focussed on events rather than having events that allow changes to the history of the game. Not just spreading this religion here or there as the only thing that really changes for them (i.e. which province has which religion).
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 8 месяцев назад
In fairness to the devs, adding a mechanic change/event system is a lot more work then just making a religion give -2 unrest or +10 national tax or something!
@avisdunrandom
@avisdunrandom 9 месяцев назад
I didn't watch the full video ( mostly watch confucian) but I will disagree with the ranking with confusian and should be low A (for his potential) since when you harmonize, as you said, you will consider harmonize faith as a secondary faith wich allow you to get the bonus from faith only monument wich give to much missionary strength, culture conversion, some tech cost reduction, tolerance, loyalty from estate, advisor cost, dev cost, less autonomie,yearly harmonisation, yearly devastation recovery,... (so no military) but are "easily" conquerable since most of them are in Asia. If confusian faith change and I allow to used every "faith lock monument" that you harmonize, it will be amazing with core cost creation (from India, need to be a dharmnic faith group but harmonize don't work), quality from zorastrian unique monument,... Amazing if you can harmonize pagan group faith and have they unique monument. So sure definitely not as strong as catholic or orthodox but definitely not weaker to reformed.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
My issue with it, is that while true requires you to pretty much World Conquest, so its a pretty high barrier to entry, and furthermore for the context of MP, which I have to take both into account, Confucian really struggles due to a lack of military buffs in my opinion, hence the lower ranking. But yes, the potential is there, its just even in the case of full harmonization, there are religions out there with more buffs that take much less effort.
@avisdunrandom
@avisdunrandom 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 well most of the useful one are near ming (Malacca region, India sub continent, Korea, Japan,...) so not that far. Sure the strongest monument will require to be more wild or play WC. But yeah in multi confucian is bad like having the mughal unique government reform that allow you to integrate every culture, bad in MP but amazing in solo.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@avisdunrandom yeah that's fair, and religions that have potential for debuffs I am also personally not a fan off, not because its hard to avoid the debuff, but because I would rather mentally not have to think about them.
@pelinalwhitestrake3367
@pelinalwhitestrake3367 9 месяцев назад
The only bad thing for Orthodox is that it take a lot of time to get to 100 patriarch authority. But yeah, +33% manpower is huge, especially for Russia.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
That's fair, but compared to some of the other things you need to do in other religions to unlock their buffs, getting patriarch authority personally I found not that challenging, given the metropolitans, the frequent events and the estate privelage.
@MyUsersDark
@MyUsersDark 9 месяцев назад
I'm no theologian, but if there's any religion that SHOULD give Morale of armies (apart from Shinto), it's Norse. Vikings went into battle with the mindset of either A), they die and get to go to Valhalla, or B), they survive and become rich with the loot they probably plundered. It doesn't make sense to me how it has 0 morale related buffs, but hey that's just my take.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Oh yeah, but I try to not apply real life logic to Eu4, otherwise we run into bigger problems. On that note, maybe that's a video!
@MyUsersDark
@MyUsersDark 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 yeah, it's just something I think should have been thought of, especially since Paradox are Swedish.. that's off topic though. Nice list!
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
@@MyUsersDark Thanks for the support!
@MyUsersDark
@MyUsersDark 9 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101 oh, and happy New Year :)
@emib6599
@emib6599 9 месяцев назад
Anyway, I'm the one that commented on reddit that "a religion tier list out of context, it's better that abusing the Pope" of you want an awkward Christmas moment.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
Oh hello! Yeah I actually had this video planned for over a week at this point, but feel free to mentally take credit!
@faarsight
@faarsight 6 месяцев назад
It's not controversial to say that Zoroastrianism is not an Abrahamic faith. It is however monotheistic (well you could argue dualistic but that's arguable) faith that's older than Abrahamic faiths and deeply historically and culturally connected to the abrahamic faiths.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 6 месяцев назад
Well, I have seen it placed in the Abrahamic group before, hence the caution.
@faarsight
@faarsight 6 месяцев назад
@@LemonCake101Islam would consider it a "religion of the book" but that's not quite the same thing. A Zoroastrian, Cyrus the Great, is mentioned as a Jewish messiah in the OT. However by definition Abrahamic faith implies that it venerates Abraham or is somehow derived from the religion of Abraham which Zoroastrianism is not.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 6 месяцев назад
@@faarsight I guess by that definition, it is not, but still I have seen it referred to as such.
@CesarLuisAfonsoDias
@CesarLuisAfonsoDias 9 месяцев назад
I strongly disagree on coptic, hindu and shinto. Coptic has 1 extra missionary in Alexandria and the 10% CCR is very juice. Hindu has the 10% CCR monument, the -2 unrest monument, 2 minimum autonomy monuments and is on pair with Christians on missionaries. Shinto is like a Gem, you have access to almost all monuments has Hinduism and also you can have like 10 missionaries with japan. I also think Ibadi and jewish are overrated.
@LemonCake101
@LemonCake101 9 месяцев назад
The +1 Missionary from Coptic is really helping with keeping it out of D tier, lets be clear, but if you are going for pure missionaries, many others do it better, and +1 missionary tends to not be that insane overall I find. Hindu I will concede: that could certainly demand a higher ranking, but Shinto really rides the coat tales of Japan, as for Ibadi and Jewish honestly I've seen more arguments for higher placements then anything, with Ibadi getting all the Muslim mechanics and Jewish getting the aspects of faith mechanic too.
Далее
The Complete TRADE GOOD Tier List for Eu4
58:44
Просмотров 50 тыс.
The Complete END TAG Tier List in Eu4
1:13:45
Просмотров 58 тыс.
Women’s Celebrations + Men’s 😮‍💨
00:20
Going On The EU4 SUBREDDIT Was A MISTAKE
30:07
Просмотров 77 тыс.
How hard is it to build a Factorio MEGABASE?
1:30:00
Просмотров 337 тыс.
The Complete LEADER TRAIT Tier List in Eu4
53:45
Просмотров 9 тыс.
Stellaris 3.12 Traditions Tier List
39:33
Просмотров 251 тыс.
The Complete PERSONALITY Tier List for Eu4
1:11:55
Просмотров 16 тыс.
The Complete LOADING SCREEN TIPS Ranking in Eu4
1:40:33
The Complete SPECIAL UNIT Tier List for Eu4
41:07
Просмотров 37 тыс.