The Difference Between Disinvestment,Privatization and Monetization?| Sujit Nair | Akhilesh Bhargava 

Respect Sujit & Akhilesh!! Best of reporting!!

Highly underated chanel .mr Bhargava is very knowledgeable

Hello Mr.Nair, Occasionally you come up with very beautiful and topical issues. Today's topic - Disinvestment,Monetisation and Privatisation - is one. While complementing you for a very objective narration of the topic, I request you to do a show on how public sectors became sick. Particularly, BJP's contribution and responsibility for the sickness of PSUs.

Nice pair A.Bhargava & S. Nair on various discourses. Factual & bold.

Very nice to see you both discussing issues plaguing ordinary indians minds

Excellent information is shared thank you akhilesh sir & sudhir sir

At time 12.25, smile of Akhilesh ji cleared all answer to the question of Nair Sab

very well discussed sir.

Really worth listening

Privatization of Profits - Selling Profit Making PSUs to Ambani and Adani Cheaply. 🤷‍♀️

Very cunning government, why PSUs are not profite making, it is because of the mismanagement of the government. The government does not want to take up challenges in these failed PSUs and want to go only the easy way so what else privatization.

Great episode...

One by one 'temples of modern India' is 'vandalized'.

If Rahul Gandhi actually said that then that's probably the best thing he has said in ages. Thats a very good come back.

This is one of your best videos, Sujit. You two were simply great, one of you reflecting a lay man's concern and the other addressing it very intelligently enlightening us. Thank you.

Thank you HW News.... Thank you Sujit and Thank you Akhilesh for explaining things in such a beautiful and easy manner...!!!

Singapore has public sector that is vibrant. A few years ago, Singapore gave each of it's citizens 100-300 Singapore dollars. Singapore is a good example of how to run a government to govern. It has controlled corruption, which unfortunately is unlimited in India. It covers all sectors.

India may see a huge jump in unemployment figures and pension payments in the next 10 years if the government continues to privatise most if not all government undertaking entities..

And pl make a show with Akhilesh to explain how and when the PSU s like HMT,ITI, IDPL, BSNL, MTNL AirIndia and Banks and Insurance companies. This may help opposition and immature and thick skulled politicians to shut their mouths... Mr.Akhikesh deserves cudos for his objectivity and you for bringing him to us. Shubh chintak

It's said जिस देश मै राजा व्यापारी वहा प्रजा भिखारी।

Interesting

Wonderful explanations... Thank you

The core idea which Private sector follows is that of performance based incentive. Unfortunately our political leaders are only in favour of privatisation but does not believe in performance as the base for increase in salary and benefits. There is no measure taken to cut cost and reduce expense to balance out the ratio of revenue vs expense. All that was followed was borrow today and let someone else pay...

Yes please discuss mismanagement the crux of the problem

As a supporter of this channel, I really love this combination. You should do more discussions like these together. Looking forward to that next episode. Thanks!

If the govt does not have money for various progressive programs then is it NECESSARY TO BUILD A NEW PARLIAMENT( CASTLE) .....

Adani seems to have unlimited money. Is anyone keeping track of where are the funds coming from. Are we creating the next set of NPA because it seems like he is taking loans from PSU banks. Otherwise where is the money come from.

I always try to follow discussion of Mr. Akhilesh Bhargav and I find it very informative, intellectual, practical and thought provoking. According to me he has a good sense of out country's economic situation and gives nice suggestions for improvement. Hope his ideas are lietened to and adopted. Also I think Mr. Sujit also brings up interestingly topics being faced by our country. The above is purely my thought and not meant to hurt anyone's sentiments or otherwise.

Well how can government exit railways? 🤔 Private companies do not have that much capital to run the railways. In Britain private railways failed. In America also they aren't doing any great.

This govt takes up all unwanted things. Real issues are sidelined. BJP govt should explain, how can they resolve highest unemployment problem before disinvestments, privatisation. Then they can go ahead. Without having a roadmap, this uneducated govt does all unwanted things like demonitization and makes more complex.

Privatise profits and socialise losses first appeared in the context of Lehman crisis of 2008 in the USA۔ Private firms collapsed۔ The US government came forward through bailouts۔ It was an attempt to save capitalist system۔ In India, if a private company would fail, the government would come forward with public money۔ Remember Yes Bank bailout۔ Excuse would to save jobs but now the government is selling assets and people turning jobless۔ Both ways, corporates win over law and logic۔

1 Appoint Cronies as Heads of PSU 2 Cronies run the Profit Making PSU into Losses 3 Sell them Cheaply to Party Donors like Ambani and Adani for a Throwaway Price. 🤷‍♀️

This reshaping of economy by monetising national asset is the most difficult challenge for all government and you rightly pointed out the hindrance along the path. Your news agency is the only one who is discussing this issue without getting polarized and providing the valuable gist to viewers.

If government sells Airindia, it should be 100%.

Government has admitted the failure of finding ways to raise the Avenues to Raise the Revenues thus, trying to sell the 'family silver '..

Very nice..👍 a perfect crash course.

Sir IOCL pipeline division future mey Privatisation Disinvestment Kiya jaraha hai kya agar private ho giya to pehle joining Non-executive employees ko kiya effects ya change ayega ya nical Diya jayega job se any service condition kya change ayega....

When both of you are together in a show..it's even more informative... thanks

Nationalizing Losses - Indian Taxpayers Money used to Payoff Loan Defaults by Ambani and Adani. 🤷‍♀️

Excellent discussion! 👍👍

What an interesting discussion. Unless right people are put in running an organisation, we will continue to make losses. It all starts from Govt portfolios.

Privatisation is an excuse for government mismanagement of public sector. Complete privatisation will be a disaster for a large and poor country like India. China is a good example of well managed public and private sector working jointly for national wealth creation.

In one of previous vedio he said about forex fdi no other person explain this well

Ok why private sector make heavy losses and not paying the public sector banks loan and ultimately the government classifying bad loans of private sector as NPA and writes off lakh of crores! So do not glorify private sectors manage properly! The government should rake stringet action on the privatesector to pay the loan on time! All problems are with the CORPORATES!

What happened to Vinod Dua- haven't seen him this week

This Govt is doing every thing it likes because it has absolute majority in Lok Sabha and can manage in Rajya Sabha to get the bills passed.

Why not attach each department to private agencies and give franchise tax collections and remove all ministries and retain and president PM and elect only Cultural members instead of members of parliament . Pl think over

I do not understand why Air India is still in loss, when they are enjoying Air bubble travel agreement and flying full load. I have never seen any Air India flying with empty seats. Where is the leak?

I always wonder, qualifications of the Ministers, How do they become Ministers with such btech, tenth, etc qualifications ? Very much looking forward to the exclusive Administration episode. Akhilesh and Sujith rightly talk about facts and that keeps me glued to such videos.

Engaging conversation. Just think: Most netas are crude, some also uneducated & ever hungry for wealth, power & fame They live super luxurious lives. It all depends on whims & fancies of rulers. Thank heavens, our world class tech czars who have made more investors super rich when compared to govt, have nothing to do netas or else they never would reach top levels. Rajneeti may koi bhi Pativrata nahi hota 🙏

Our Govt. Is totally KADKA

Then, when everything is sold off, what about next year?

Government should not think in terms of Return on Investment. Profit is the moto of private sector, but the public sector is promoted only for economical and social inclusion and social security which will be totally ditached. Ours is a socio-economic country with population more 135 crores inclusive of educated masses from deprived class. The PSB are providing huge employment oppertunities to the educated masses. Selling of PSE/PSB one by one is a big blow to the social sector and financial inclusion. If government is thought of reforming the financial sector, well, government may think of any viable method without affecting the core structure of public sector charactor.

If government invest in anything, it is public money. It doesn't come from the pockets of cheap politicians we have. If government invest on infrastructure items like hospitals, schools collage etc.. they should not expect any monetary profits from it. These are the prime responsibility of any government. Similarly, if any road or flyover is made it is an asset created for the nation. Returns expected out of it should be for only maintaining it , not for making profits. Enough taxes are being colleted for essential like defense etc. Balance should go to welfare of the society. If government ignores the basic purpose of it's existence, as what is happening today , it will result in the total destruction of this nation. I don't think that we are far from it. Almost there perhaps.

Dear Sujit & Akhilesh excellent piece 👍....but the billion $ question is which indian conglomerate has the where with all to run such behemoths , forget buy them ? Does a Reliance or a Tata or a Birla or a Mahindra has such deep pockets ?

Good discussion , not much jargon, any person can follow with minimum knowledge can understand. I think this pair should dicusd Demonetsation , it's pros and cons, for general public.

Waiting for episode on mismanagement of psu.

Love the way you say 'goverrrment'! With emphasis on the 'rrrrrrrr'!!! That's exactly the way we feel about this farce. Btw, Akhilesh and you are superb together.

The govt should be cutting the expenses by 40 percent of all government employees including leaders defense. By this inflation is curtailed but jobs are retained

there will be no takers / buyers for any of the public sector units , including the profitable ones . Basically no one likes to invest in a PSU mainly because of its bad , corrupt and lethargic work culture , which they do not want to inherit along with the physical assets. While offering the PSUs for sale , the Govt. inadvertently says that that they would protect the interests of the employees which sends a terrifying signal to the private investor that the culture of PSU is also forcibly transferred to the investor , which drives them away as in the case of Airindia. Govt should keep quiet and leave the employees issue to the new management , otherwise the millstones around the neck of the Govt will never be removed pushing the whole nation into economic disaster soon..

How the Government will pay back the money it will take from the Private Sector after 4 years or will it extend the lease for ever? This is giving away to the Private sector at a highly discounted price. Money will not come from the pockets of Private sector owners but from the banks. When these will be NPAs, all these Modis and Choksis will run away to London.

Big chunk of land is involved

Lets say you privatize road making. What incentive private sector has to build road to remote villages/towns? Its not right to say govt. should stay in strategic sectors. Govt. need to be there for people’s benefit and social good is one good aspect which is why we all agree to pay little more tax as our income grows. Private businesses by their very nature are not for pooling money for social cause, they are for pooling money to make more money.

This format is way better u should have started with this . Ist time I was able to listen to ur complete video

If government is unable to handle some companies then how it will handle the whole country.... simply by selling to the businessmans 😁😁

Even Kanhaiyya kumar made a similar statement didnt he..🤔?

India success is in Mix Economy even Russian now feel they should have gone with Mix Economy

SIR.. what about taking some advice from Ambani and Adani..

First thing first,, why RSS government don't have money to invest in infrastructure. Where are those money, ManMohan government left before leaving.. What are those policies of RSS government that put India is such grave condition of shortage of money ?? Talk about those policies. Point them out.

Both of you are jemm 👍

Thank u so much ❤️

Insurance companies became sick...

Ajit does not understand the reasoning for running these PSUs in the first place. Fix them, that is thir job, they broke it, now fix it, not sell public assets for crumbs.

They are selling stuff as they have no money but they have all the money to spend on private planes and exotic parliament! Wah

Government could have sold Airindia with some loss so that we do not keep on making more loss. But govt. Will not sell Air india as they need to take care of PM's special A1 plane

Sir's . I have no idea as to how much business negotiations you'll have done. EVERYTHING has a price and terms. Your price my terms and conversely my price your terms. Within those boundries IF the PARTIES are flexable any and everything has a price and can be disposed ( sold ) off.

Wonderful excellent discussion, please do more of such discussion s👍🙏

I think Akhilesh understanding about PSUs is not reaching ground reality. PSUs work in a lot more restrictions compared to pvt players. Everybody compares development in Telecom sector but it may not b same in every industry. In addition telecom is a milking cow for big pvt players..

When we are privatizing our PSU units to Private companies, which are family run and managed, the next CEO is the son of the present CEO. It is hierarchy that decides on the top post and not competence. We should make it obligatory on Private sectors taking over important PSU units to run these organizations with professionals and not family members.

Modi sarkaar has money to buy Pegasus🤔😩

Too many add breaks 😒

Modi sarkaar has money to buy Pegasus 🤔

How you're going to change the mindset of the burocrats who know how to get financially well individually not doing anything good for the country?

👍

IPS Academy - Indian political services academy or equivalent with specializations should be mandatory for becoming a minister. Will that ever happen? If so it will bring out the true India and make India to hold top rankings in most areas of activities in the world. A democratic super power.

You selling PSU not issue with that .. But with respect to that government should build up new PSU .. For future purpose .. On one hand you just selling off without building anything to counter that ... Well just waiting for that day when government will say " Citizen of india, now you all are privatized. This is been done for your own definite .. Be a Nationalist and agree with government..."

And no one dares to suggest about those who went shopping for air India planes and got kickbacks. And sold cheap some of the flying assets.

Air India can't be sold forever 😄😄😄

It would be wonderful if you could name and shame.

1st Permanent employment should be retracted from the public sector, 2nd top management of these PSU's should be on a contractual basis, they met a target in predefined period they get everything, gets to be the hero and handed over another PSU's also else should be sacked.

Extremly contradictory your explanation which already Duped by most Private Planters what easy to seen mind blowing amount of Bánk NPA and Tax exemption to Corporates. So, Why you are Not suggesting to this Government that, Look Mr. you are unable to handleiding the Country and failed all corners, so, without further any JUMLA, you better to step down and offers to fittest person's who can safe the Boat & can confidently DRIVE.

Govt should sell off air india assets instead of selling it off as a package..break it up and sell it