Тёмный

The Fields of Pickett’s Charge Part 1 | Gettysburg 161 

American Battlefield Trust
Подписаться 408 тыс.
Просмотров 26 тыс.
50% 1

Walking the fields of Pickett’s Charge with Wayne Motts, Doug Douds and the National Civil War Museum. Part 2 of our walk can be found here: ru-vid.comh7lMeTZqY7E?... #gettysburgtour
This video is part of our series commemorating the 161st Anniversary of the Battle of Gettysburg. View all of the videos here: • Gettysburg | 161st Ann...

Опубликовано:

 

2 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 72   
@AmericanBattlefieldTrust
@AmericanBattlefieldTrust 13 дней назад
We lost signal at the end, so this is officially Part 1 of our Pickett's Charge coverage. Part 2 is here: ru-vid.comh7lMeTZqY7E?feature=share and Part 3 is here: ru-vid.comwgQCAjETSKY?feature=share
@user-tv3id2nf5o
@user-tv3id2nf5o 12 дней назад
There's just something about Pickett’s Charge. I've done it 30 times. As you traverse the field, you just FEEL SOMETHING as you walk it!! Very unique.
@ncwoodworker
@ncwoodworker 12 дней назад
Just to see the scope of the field and how far they had to go to get to other side is chilling.
@sampsellmark
@sampsellmark 13 дней назад
I look forward to seeing these videos every year. thank you one and all who makes this posable
@johngetz8585
@johngetz8585 13 дней назад
Mornin' yourself..!!! Between the charge and the Cavalry charge on the backside..that was a hell of a day. Literally. A humbling spot ....
@blakebufford6239
@blakebufford6239 13 дней назад
A P. Hill's old Light Division was in Pickett's Charge although broken up into different divisions. Archer and Brockenbrough, Lane and Scales. I think the only one missing was Thomas's Ga. Bg.which was stuck in Long Lane. Archer and Brockenbrough were in the front. Brockenbrough broke, but Archer's (Fry) lost all their battle flags at or near The Angle except for the 7th Tn. which was torn off the staff and tucked into the coat of an officer. The 14th Tn was captured by the 14Th Conn. about 50 yds from their front. Great job folks!!!!
@kenttucson2830
@kenttucson2830 12 дней назад
Tucson Arizona here!
@kimfitzsimmons7408
@kimfitzsimmons7408 13 дней назад
Cant thank you enough for doing this every year. I so look forward to learning from you all.
@dragonflyhill5748
@dragonflyhill5748 12 дней назад
My great Uncle was a 17 year old sharp shooter, 42 Mississippi Vol , Gaston’s Regt at Gettysburg taken July 3 when lost in action and imprisoned at Ft. Delaware where he died March 64.
@MrBBaron
@MrBBaron 11 дней назад
In 1994 1995 and 1996, i stayed in Gettysburg and toured this battlefied. Stayed in the Cashtown inn , which was claimed to be haunted. I can vouch for that . In 1996 I walked the exact trail from where my NC men started their attack. I was dressed in full Confederate gear. Upon reaching mid field, i stopped and pondered about those young men in grey.I looked skyward and then gave a heartfelt prayer and salute to those brave souls. Would i have gone with them? ..Yes! When I reached the union line i was greeted by applause from those that saw me walking the distance. Some wanted to take pictures with me. It was a very emotional moment and a highlight of my life as I wanted to be there since I was i boy when learning that my ancestors served in NC Confederate units.
@grahamhill2267
@grahamhill2267 13 дней назад
Hi again from the UK! Before I got interested in the Battle of Gettysburg and the American Civil War, the only thing I knew about Confederates was what I’d seen in Hollywood movies. They always portrayed Confederates as illiterate, murderous cut-throats and vagabonds. Have seen a couple of times now the written artefacts like the Confederate Privates diary in this video, what beautiful handwriting it is and dispels the Hollywood interpretation of the Confederate troops! Wonderful!
@johnturner2664
@johnturner2664 12 дней назад
Hellow from Eugene Oregon. Thank you so much for all of your time and effort put into your videos. I can't wait to come and see everything in person.
@Jersey2tall86
@Jersey2tall86 12 дней назад
Doug, as a veteran (USMC) artillery officer (1st Bn 11th Marines, 1st Bn 14th Marines, and once-14th Marines XO), I fully agree with your analysis (from 6:08 to 6:54) regarding the so-called "overshoots" in this cannonade. Was glad to hear someone like yourself finally articulate it in a quasi-official public video setting like this. I would also add that the objective of the Union artillery here is different from the Confederates, which would be that the Union's objective would be 1. counter-battery fire to lessen the effects of the Confederate guns and 2. in anticipation of an infantry assault (and no commander on the battlefield would ever not think that an infantry assault wasn't going to follow an artillery bombardment--it was a standard military tactic for several centuries) to pin down and degrade the assaulting force. Using correct artillery terminology, you can say here that the Confederates' was a bombardment, while the Union's was a barrage.
@bigstevesnostalgiadragraci4240
@bigstevesnostalgiadragraci4240 12 дней назад
Spot on assessment. As a former Army artilleryman, your comments are well taken. It's a little "inside baseball" for many, but absolutely yrue.
@Gitarzan66
@Gitarzan66 8 дней назад
@Jersey2tall86 My dad was a Navy Corpsman in the 11th Artillery, Companies H&k. He landed in Korea with the 1st I.D in 1050. He was there for a year and was present at Chosin. He received a Commendation from the Corp for his work at battalion aid during the battle.
@michaeldouglas1243
@michaeldouglas1243 13 дней назад
Always a great pleasure to listen to Mr Douds speak. I'd love to get him to give me a guided tour sometime.
@geralddixon4705
@geralddixon4705 13 дней назад
Hi guys I from south Carolina but originally from n.y. I 😘 be theses guys I watch you guys all the time Jerry Dixon from sc
@delnunley7026
@delnunley7026 8 дней назад
Thank you for posting these! Love them in Wyoming
@user-yn7bj2mt1g
@user-yn7bj2mt1g 12 дней назад
Lee was supposed to be such a great leader. He dropped the ball on this charge. It was basically insane to attack across such open ground and to attack such high ground
@michaelhoffman5348
@michaelhoffman5348 6 дней назад
A little harsh, don't you think? Ewell was supposed to attack Culp's Hill at the same time to coordinate from both ends of the field, but the Union beat him to the punch. That lost, had the bombardment been successful, we may be looking at a whole different outcome. Lee's weakness was that he was NOT a micro-manager, while many of his generals needed close attention. Lee was also suffering the first stages of heart disease, so he definitely was not on his A game at Gettysburg.
@kw19193
@kw19193 4 дня назад
@@michaelhoffman5348 Not in the least bit harsh. Instead of making excuses for Lee the bigger picture reveals that as an offensive general Lee was at best over-the-moon slack, and not just here at Gettysburg. Lee's reputation rests as much upon incompetent and intimidated leadership of the AoP as it did his supposed genius. Lee's whole handling of this battle was pathetic. Had it been Grant, Sheridan, and Sherman on the other side the defeat would have catastrophic. Cheers!
@michaelhoffman5348
@michaelhoffman5348 3 дня назад
@@kw19193 Could not disagree with you more, as would any soldier that fought for or against Robert E. Lee's ANV. When Commander-in-Chief Winfield Scott told Abraham Lincoln that his overwhelming recommendation to lead Union forces was Robert E. Lee, it was because of a well deserved reputation, not some "over the moon" slack. Lee took long chances because he HAD to take long chances with the limited resources he had. When you get the chance to actually spend 5 minutes on the battlefield on July 1st or 2nd or 3rd in 1863, and see the actual events unfold in real time, then you can tell us all exactly where Lee showed his insanity. Cheers yourself...
@kw19193
@kw19193 2 дня назад
@@michaelhoffman5348 I have indeed been to the battlefield mate and it actually solidifies the terrible decisions that Lee made not only on the 3rd but the 2cd and 1st also. But really, what sort of 'genius' sends his army hither, thither, and yon and then chooses to fight upon ground not to the advantage of the AoNV. Add to this his slack directions to officers new to command and his unwillingness (or inability) to control his general of calvary, Stuart, and you have a heady little cocktail of disaster waiting to happen. Finally, the infantry assault across an open field of almost a mile and a half into the maws of a prepared defensive position was lunacy, there was simply no way it was going to succeed. Again, Lee's so called reputation rests more upon the thoroughly incompetent leaders of the AoP than any demonstrated genius. Cheers!
@texmexfla
@texmexfla 11 дней назад
San Antonio Texas is here!
@4673103
@4673103 13 дней назад
From NewBedford been There four times and learn more every time I watch😎
@mikekellum6238
@mikekellum6238 13 дней назад
Direct descendant of William Kellum, 55 th Virginia, extreme left flank of Picketts charge.
@gilllawson2214
@gilllawson2214 13 дней назад
Thanks to everyone again for this video and work
@rayparker7496
@rayparker7496 13 дней назад
Love this videos
@intpete
@intpete 10 дней назад
Kudos to Sarah! A very moving story.
@garys.4789
@garys.4789 13 дней назад
Great job as usual guys 😎👍
@cindylodestro5788
@cindylodestro5788 13 дней назад
NC here!!!
@jef5537
@jef5537 12 дней назад
Great job Sarah and co.!
@johngibbons2858
@johngibbons2858 12 дней назад
Love these videos. Thanks for all the hard work.
@bobbennett7195
@bobbennett7195 12 дней назад
I can't Imagin what they were all going through.
@heynowls3058
@heynowls3058 13 дней назад
Palm Springs CA! I woke up Garry! Thanks folks.
@WayneFielder
@WayneFielder 12 дней назад
WHAT a damn cliff hanger! AMAZING WORK EDITOR!
@bigsarge2085
@bigsarge2085 9 дней назад
👍👍
@chieffamilygenealogyoffice621
@chieffamilygenealogyoffice621 12 дней назад
Wyoming here! Been to Gettysburg twice….
@HighVelocityRips
@HighVelocityRips 12 дней назад
Damn, I’m addicted, my history teacher is probably rolling in his grave 😂
@johnzajac9849
@johnzajac9849 12 дней назад
For Federal observations about the lethal accuracy of rebel artillery, read the well-researched books by Hennessy, ‘Return to Bull Run’, and by Hartwig, 'I Dread the Thought of the Place’.
@WayneFielder
@WayneFielder 12 дней назад
@21:42 - I'd bet those folks in East Tennessee, right at the edge of the upright part of the monument? yeah...those folks were ready to take the fight to middle and west TN in 1861 so I'm kinda sure those ancestors of East Tennesseans would have a problem with that so small portion of the monument! OKAY, Okay okay...I get it and EVERYTHING about how and why this monument was placed. For DAMN sure Tennesseans should be honored at Gettysburg and I do love the monument.
@InVinoVeritas.
@InVinoVeritas. 13 дней назад
Oh no, livestream interrupted/ended. They changed the title to Part 1 so hopefully they're getting ready to livestream Part 2.
@dragonflyhill5748
@dragonflyhill5748 12 дней назад
😊
@edwardyost915
@edwardyost915 13 дней назад
Thanks!
@AmericanBattlefieldTrust
@AmericanBattlefieldTrust 12 дней назад
Thanks so much!
@KenKen-jt6lh
@KenKen-jt6lh 13 дней назад
From Scotland. Tactically if Lee did not instigate pickets charge what options did he have
@padraicfarrell188
@padraicfarrell188 12 дней назад
What options did Lee have? That is one of the greatest "what ifs" of civil war discussion. Some say he could have moved his army south , get between the ARmy of the Potomac and Washington DC. That would have forced Meade to attack him. Lee might have gone north and threatened Harrisburg and possibly Philadelphia or Possibly NYC. The issue with either option is Lee's supply lines. He really couldn't do either from a logistics pov. A lack of options doesn't make the decision any better though. Withdrawing would have saved a lot of his soldiers. Not that that would go well either. Lee couldn't have known any of that on July 3rd though. And that is the drama that transfixed so many to this epic drama
@billfries1077
@billfries1077 11 дней назад
Bill in Belvidere Il. Here
@Spinonemaster
@Spinonemaster 13 дней назад
More great analysis of the final day .... I've always had great respect for Gen Lee .... but Lee failed horribly at Gettysburg on day 3 .... either delusional, or his foolish pride would not allow him to rethink his strength and lack of a good tactical ground for an attack ...
@ga6381
@ga6381 8 дней назад
Just got back from the 161st Gettysburg reenactment. Went down Seminary ridge, took pictures with my 12 year old son. Left my binoculars there, by the NC monument. Went back 3 times around from 2:10 - 3:15. Could not find them. If anyone finds them, could you let me know. It would have been before the Porta John's up to the the NC monument, on the stone wall by one of the cannons. They were Baraska binoculars. Appreciate it, if anyone finds them. Thank you.
@Mercenaries3
@Mercenaries3 12 дней назад
Is that Gary trying to get something going by saying “Chris did you say Doug is wrong.”
@blakebufford6239
@blakebufford6239 13 дней назад
I've never heard the theory of deliberate over shots. Interesting,! Every thing I've read puts a rubber stamp on over shots being due to the obscuring smoke. Very good idea Col. Doud!!
@philipwolf3619
@philipwolf3619 12 дней назад
Bad timing fuses - new factory
@burrellbikes4969
@burrellbikes4969 8 дней назад
Hmmm…I honestly am not trying to throw shade at the Vet’s - but I wonder how many of the survivors claimed to have gotten all the way to the wall or even past the wall? It would seem that given the utter destruction of those attacking units - if you got to the wall, you were most likely a casualty in some fashion. So it just makes me wonder if they are pumping up their own actions from that day to be a bit more than it really was.
@1rwjwith
@1rwjwith 13 дней назад
In the book Killer Angels LEE is portrayed as being somewhat ill and suffering Angina pain . Was that factual? Any evidence to that ?
@Raymond-dn3su
@Raymond-dn3su 12 дней назад
I had also read that Lee was suffering from a virus or from eating spoiled rations. Causing him to be extremely dehydrated, thus interfering with his mental state. And it was recorded by several Confederate adjutants, many of the Confederate officers did not want this frontal assault to proceed.
@Raymond-dn3su
@Raymond-dn3su 12 дней назад
I left a reply about Lee being sick that day. I had also read that he was dehydrated from eating bad food.
@MrFrostings
@MrFrostings 13 дней назад
What's the date, Wayne?
@Clare-qo5jv
@Clare-qo5jv 12 дней назад
Did he say "girly excitement"? It's called 'enthusiasm" sir. There's a difference. What grade are you in?
@michaelhoffman5348
@michaelhoffman5348 6 дней назад
Longstreet's Assault... plain and simple.
@Jersey2tall86
@Jersey2tall86 12 дней назад
Hmmm... 63+75 = 150+ ??? 🤣😂
@philipwolf3619
@philipwolf3619 12 дней назад
“WE” had a failure !!??? Da-huh? So you are a slaver ?
@davidpitchford6510
@davidpitchford6510 13 дней назад
Please don't keep saying "stuff"; Geez! Also: more somber facts vs. girly excitement. Finally, complete your sentences without going off on tangents and please ensure that sentences follow from the last one and lead to the next.
@vinceo1058
@vinceo1058 13 дней назад
I think you'd be happier reading a book than watching a live presentation, especially if you believe that excitement is "girly." You should demand a refund *and* insist on speaking to the manager.
@blakebufford6239
@blakebufford6239 13 дней назад
I like their " girly excitement"! 😂
@AmericanBattlefieldTrust
@AmericanBattlefieldTrust 12 дней назад
We can do whatever we want, it's our production. Feel free not to watch.
@padraicfarrell188
@padraicfarrell188 12 дней назад
Fans of the ABT think of those things as features not bugs.
@RandomOccurrences
@RandomOccurrences 9 дней назад
@@AmericanBattlefieldTrust Please don't stop what you're doing or how you do it. I look forward to these anniversary specials every year and block out whole afternoons to watch the coverage. Everyone involved with the production and presentation is great and I never fail to learn something (usually many somethings) I didn't know before.
@gilllawson2214
@gilllawson2214 13 дней назад
Is it gone? 👀
Далее
Дьявол - ТРЕШ ОБЗОР на фильм
19:10
Jubal Early & Barlow's Knoll - Day 1 | Gettysburg 161
43:20
Top 10 Gettysburg Myths
8:54
Просмотров 11 тыс.
Gettysburg: Animated Battle Map
16:51
Просмотров 4 млн
July 2nd Line of Battle | Gettysburg 161
45:01
Просмотров 17 тыс.
Most Evil Actors in Hollywood History
20:45
Devil's Den - Ranger Matt Atkinson
1:03:41
Просмотров 642 тыс.
Дьявол - ТРЕШ ОБЗОР на фильм
19:10