I appreciate ustadh allows himself to be challenged. Its good to see that he is happy to do so its these types of questions that help to break things down in bitesize pieces for everyday muslims including myself
Some people are missing the point of the role the host (pakistani brother) is playing in this podcast. He is playing devils advocate i.e taking the worse side of the argument on the behalf of the people who aren't present to question the points ustadh abdul rahman is making. This allows for a deeper understanding and meaning to be extracted from proofs ustadh brings.
Asala mualaikum brother. Barakallah feek sheikh for the video. Akhi, please do not stop this program it is very beneficial for me and I am sure same many other brothers&sisters.
These podcasts are so BENEFITING. I love how the brother challanges the statements of the guest. Exactly what we need, not to blind follow and accept everything/anything just because someone said it without daleel. Barak Allahu feekom for making this possible. Alhamdulillahi rabbi alAlameen.
i love these podcasts. Its very academic and I love how the host challenges Ust Abdul Rahman Hassan positions and statements. I also love how Ust Abdul Rahman Hassan isn't egoistic and is patient when he answers the questions and challenges. May Allah reward all of you.
Regarding the point of the Companion saying "Rabbana wala kal hamd"- It has a basis. Abu Huraira reported: The Messenger of Allah (Peace be upon him) said: When the Imam says:" Allah listens to him who praises Him." you should say:" O Allah, our Lord for Thee is the praise." for if what anyone says synchronises with what the angels say, his past sins will be forgiven. Sahih Muslim, Book 4- 809
He did mention it when he said about the conditions "The Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wa sallam 1.Could do it. 2. Needed to do it. 3. Chose not to do it. Microphone's something that comes in the thing that he couldn't do it.
Microphones do not fall under the definition of bid'ah that was mentioned in the beginning. It would fall under the linguistic definition, not the technical one, and the technical one is the purpose of this discussion. We do not use microphones to seek nearness to Allah, it is simply a means to fulfill a Shar'ī objective (there are 5) which is aiding the religion, specifically by making the Adhān heard. If someone was to believe or claim that using the microphone is virtuous and pleases Allah, then it would be considered a Bid'ah which has no basis.
mplsridah The host and Ustadh are upon the same beliefs lol, he's just grilling Ustadh with arguments Ahl ul-Bidah might use if Ustadh was just explaining this topic like in a lecture - he's playing devils advocate, so Ahl ul-Bid'ah can't say Ustadh missed this and that, because the host made sure he didn't.
![The Hot Seat Podcast || Misconceptions of Bidah in Muslim Society [Ep 3]](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
