Тёмный

The HYRULE MAP Theory: The Missing Pieces of Zelda Lore 

GameSmiths
Подписаться 4,7 тыс.
Просмотров 299 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

14 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 475   
@nintendawesome
@nintendawesome Год назад
Lets not forget that in development, kakariko and lost woods swapped places. this could very well be a pre-alpha version of the BOTW map
@OdysseusOmega
@OdysseusOmega Год назад
Also remember that at some point in development, perhaps only in the concept phase, there were plans to include the Minish people.
@Gigawolf1
@Gigawolf1 Год назад
@@OdysseusOmega The furry long-eared people from the sky that made robots & gifted the Hylians with a bunch of powerful magic items, including ones that allow for changing sizes?
@botarakutabi1199
@botarakutabi1199 Год назад
@@Gigawolf1 wait, would that imply the minish and zonai are the same, or at least somehow related?
@iWhisperASMR
@iWhisperASMR Год назад
it IS a pre-alpha version of BOTW map, but BOTW was suppose to be TOTK but it was too good
@pancakes8670
@pancakes8670 Год назад
@@botarakutabi1199 They do share a lot of similar traits, yeah
@jasonzervos
@jasonzervos Год назад
The odd placemat of Kakariko Village and Lost Woods is explained by game development. I think some of the producers have said that they swapped places very late in BOTW's development. Probability because the game tells you to go to Impa at Kakariko Village and if it was at the original point it would be really difficult for new players to go there because the journey is full of guardians outside Hyrule Town.
@Celestiana06
@Celestiana06 Год назад
And it makes sense that they may have moved kakariko during the calamity events to keep away from the castle
@IsuKen
@IsuKen Год назад
Considering how much time passed between games, it makes sense that geographical locations would move around. Its interesting how the same location can feel familiar yet foreign at the same time.
@heroichitsuji
@heroichitsuji Год назад
It’s like coming home after a few years and all the furniture has been rearranged, replaced, or removed entirely.
@ΦίλιπποςΖαχόπουλος
@ΦίλιπποςΖαχόπουλος 6 месяцев назад
If I recall, Aonuma said that Twilight Princess is a century or two after Ocarina of Time, which means that differences in each map are there only to keep things fresh.
@novustalks7525
@novustalks7525 Месяц назад
​@@ΦίλιπποςΖαχόπουλοςexcept he's wrong. Because the temple of time has been dilapidated for thousands of years
@ΦίλιπποςΖαχόπουλος
@@novustalks7525 I doubt that a man-made structure can stand on the surface, and remain recognisable even, in the time it takes for the terrain around it to change. What makes you think it is so? I don't remember it being stated anywhere.
@hairball178
@hairball178 Год назад
Could the map have been an early reference point for BotW's development along with the extra content that would go on to be TotK? If that theory holds water, the Castor Wilds inclusion could have been due to the fact the Minish were originally going to be in BotW before being cut
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Indeed that’s my suggestion in terms of the plans for BOTW development which I think then extended to TOTK to realise the full vision of the skies and caves being too much in one iteration. Aonuma explains his disappointment at not achieving the vision for the skies for Skyward Sword in the “making of BOTW” series, so it adds more context for the mindset. Your point about the Minish is bang on, ironically featuring in the same series with Fujibayashi lamenting the decision. I had considered including this but I cut the initial script of 58 mins down to get this finalised, so that part was cut from this video. It’s a great call-out and I’d add the location of the memory near death mountain, where link and Zelda talk about the increasing monster threat atop a pile of defeated Lynels with blood moon music is significant to both titles and overlooks the “Minshi Woods” and “Picor Pond” - and is also the chasm entry point in TOTK to get to the Lost woods - critical story aspect and riffs the Minish references to a fault. Love your work 💚💫
@abdelwahedbenlmir7800
@abdelwahedbenlmir7800 8 месяцев назад
BOTW and TOTK are quite like the Oracle games , if that's the idea behind the games , then we might have a third game that connects both of them and ends them.
@CloutmasterPhluphyy
@CloutmasterPhluphyy 4 месяца назад
@@abdelwahedbenlmir7800 I'd love if they did a BoTW 3 and it could have a red motif. Idk what more they could do with it with ToTK having the defeat of ganondorf in it
@AllenMS828
@AllenMS828 Год назад
What I'm wondering is if the pieces of land torn from the surface during the Upheaval will ever settle back to the ground -- and if so, will they all go back where they originally came from? What if there have been previous Upheavals in Hyrule's history, and sometimes the land masses shift around in the sky before falling back down? That would be one way to explain how some pieces of the map stay fairly consistent, while others seem to move around randomly. (It also just hit me that the Upheaval represents the other kind of "tears" (as in torn apart) of the Kingdom. 😆)
@colin._..
@colin._.. Год назад
The sky islands do not originate from botws hyrule, but have been sitting in the skies above for hundreds of thousands of years ever since mineru and zelda together somehow got them up there somewhere between the imprisoning war and zeldas draconofication. Hyrule castle is the only thing that rose up, and most likely triggered the islands to start floating further down. They were not visible in botw because they were above a huge cloud barrier, which the light dragon breaks apart after you give the master sword to zelda behind the temple of time
@AllenMS828
@AllenMS828 Год назад
@@colin._.. Oh, I see. I haven't actually been able to play it for myself. I've only seen edited playthroughs, so I was clearly missing some context. Thanks for the additional info!
@dissect123
@dissect123 Год назад
In this day and age you cannot emphasize enough how well the Zelda franchise manages to captivate both old and new fans. So many new iterations of older franchises are disasterous disappointments.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Could not agree with you more. Wonderful comment and thank you 💚💫
@peanutbutter6720
@peanutbutter6720 Год назад
IMO it’s because Zelda has always been a volatile franchise, changing art styles and mechanics with every entry. Though they normally keep just enough consistency that it feels like the same franchise. And when they remove or change something that fans don’t like you can typically see them try to rectify it in the next game. TPs seriousness in response to the backlash about WWs art style, SS and the timeline in general to acknowledge popular fan theories, BotWs openness in response to SSs linearity, TotKs revamped dungeons and building system in response to both criticisms of and popular ways to play BotW. The list goes on and on. Most game franchises nowadays make a generic RPG slap an iconic song, logo, word, etc onto it and call it a day.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
A fair point for sure. In some ways that’s a point I was trying to make in its reiteration of the cycle. I had a whole piece of the script talking about how we as fans directly contributed to the split post WW as you mention, so I see the validity in what you are saying for sure 💚💫
@XxXAlexAutopsyXxX
@XxXAlexAutopsyXxX Год назад
They really did ruin majoras mask making spin skipping on water stop making certain spots significantly harder to skip on changing the way the Zora mask swam and changing the way the bosses attacked it was so dumb they did that
@mellomoose_
@mellomoose_ Год назад
nintendo is very good at keeping their franchises fresh
@korg3597
@korg3597 Год назад
IMAGINE a dlc where after the events of totk, a strange sound is heard from the lost woods. You are being guided by this voice to a huge log tunnel where the further you walk, it begins to warp and twist. Suddenly you see a large hole but without the gloom, and decide to jump down. When you fall, you see the rainbowlike colours of different masks and you hit the ground. You travel further into the depths where you hear a faint sound of a soothing piano, and the creaking of a wooden cog turning slowly. You see stairs and walk up to a large door, and just when you are about to open it, you hear a eerie voice from behind: " You’ve met with a terrible fate, haven’t you?"👹
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Words won't do my reply justice - but imagine emphatic applause - simply brilliant and I would absolutely be down for that reality 💚🌟
@strawberrymins
@strawberrymins Год назад
I would lose it if that would happen, that would just be way too cool
@sboinkthelegday3892
@sboinkthelegday3892 Год назад
I read some old interview long time ago, many years, where somebody suggested that Happy Mask Salesman is a parody of somebody on the staff, with a similar backstory as the Boo ghosts, sometimes flipping out at the developers. I think they mentioned a name I didn't recognize, so it never stuck with me who that was supposed to be, maybe Miyamoto or Koizumi. But doesn't he even look JUST like Fujibayashi? Funny thing is, that would be a year before his involvement in Zelda franchise starting 2001. But he was a director working across company borders, so he would be knwon as somebody who's a bit of an outsider like the way HMS is detached from both Link and Termina.
@spuriousgeorge7233
@spuriousgeorge7233 Год назад
Honestly I think that's a bad idea, as cool as it would be to see. Termina has too much thematic and symbolic importance to just put in a DLC. Majora's Mask told a mostly self-contained story, and I think revisiting it would only be a mistake. Besides, I'd personally rather see something newer and more fitting for Tears of the Kingdom.
@Tom-nv3mg
@Tom-nv3mg Год назад
No shot because I was literally just imagining they did something like this
@WeyounSix
@WeyounSix Год назад
I find it interesting that Fujibayashi worked on the oracle games, and that we got the Depths in TOTK, since subrosia was such a large part of the oracle games.
@Flashy675
@Flashy675 Год назад
Another cool theory I saw is that the depths is the remnants of old Hyrule that was flooded in Wind waker
@WeyounSix
@WeyounSix Год назад
@@Flashy675 Not sure if I entirely buy that theory myself, but I do think it's likely we have seen parts of "The Depths" before in other titles. I do think that for some undisclosed reason, the Windwaker timeline merged and drained, leading to both rock salt everywhere and the Rito now existing alongside the zora. So you are right imho that the wind waker did leave some lasting effects on the world, I personally am just unsure if that equates to the depths. I would expect to see more hylian ruins down there.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Apologies - meant to comment on this days ago. It’s a great point and well put. Ironically the oracles appear to have been announced today on switch online, and I’d argue there’s some other callbacks in TOTK that make me wonder if we might see more referenced in what I suspect will be a DLC announcement within the next month. The timing is interesting 🤔
@WeyounSix
@WeyounSix Год назад
@@gamesmiths Wow, now I'm gonna have to use Switch Online. Lol
@buss1205
@buss1205 Месяц назад
@@WeyounSix the oot hylian soldier ghosts, the link outfits, and poes all being down there point to the depths being old hyrule imo. theres also wind waker where the koroks end goal was to create new land by spreading seeds all throughout hyrule. i dont think botw/totk being cell shaded like wind waker is pure coincidence.
@Quinooooo
@Quinooooo Год назад
Ive owned the poster of that map for almost 6 years now. i had no idea that the zelda community was so bamboozled by it
@WilliamHBart
@WilliamHBart Год назад
Speaking of the Song of Storms paradox, I think it's possible the original child the man in the windmill is referring to is Link after he returns from Termina. I'm basing this solely off of the fact that the composer brothers of Ikana Canyon originally came up with the song and we see Link learning it there and finishing his adventure in Termina and returning to Hyrule still a child. My idea is he came back and caused the psychological damage to the windmill guy with the song and thus, adult Link in OoT was able to learn it and then go back in time to become the child who taught it to the windmill guy. However, in order for Link to have been able to venture to Termina, he needed to know the song in the first place anyways so he could complete his adventure in Hyrule, so take the idea with a grain of salt. Alternatively, I think the song could just be fated to exist in the first place no matter where it came from. As if it is self-aware and choosing from where it originates, no matter what timeline. Where is Fox Mulder when you need him?
@captainhalcyonix9009
@captainhalcyonix9009 Год назад
Time travel and outsidership, zelda could have easily from any time come along and seed it into the world to allow the hero to complete his mission The plan of skywardsword and previous zelda/hylia likely stretches farther then we can imagine or know. We don't know where all she went outside of what was shown. Time travel is timeless.
@lucasstrople4767
@lucasstrople4767 Год назад
Everyone forgets the obvious thing with this one: the song on the organ box is programmed. The Windmill guy never needed to learn it. All he does is turn the crank.
@1800mexicano
@1800mexicano Год назад
The egg came first, laid by an animal that had generically diverged so far from its base lineage that it more closely started to resemble a chicken
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Nice
@rocknatex5013
@rocknatex5013 Год назад
For those who are curious or want to debate, I'm pretty sure that temple in the desert is the Temple of Time. Its architecture is literally one-to-one. And I think the structure in the top left is supposed to be the Tower of Hera, but I could be wrong about that. The village with the waterwheel is clearly Ordon, due to it being south of Faron Woods. One thing that I'm particularly curious about is the snowy village to the northeast. It never snows in Akkala, which is the region where the village seems to be located in. We can't say that it's Hebra due to the Hebra mountains being present in the northwest of the map. It's a very curious location. Moving on to the life forms on the map, the Stalchild is likely a reference to how Stalchildren appear in Hyrule Field at night in OoT. The scorpion might be a reference to Moldarach from Skyward Sword. The Link-like figure by the Great Deku Tree is likely just representing the Kokiri, but it might also be the Hero of Time himself. The two major mysteries for me are the dragon on the central mountain peak and the fish-like tail in Faron Woods. The dragon has wings, unlike the Draconified dragons from BotW and TotK, but it isn't a Gleeok due to it not having three or more heads. It also can't be an Aquamentus because those particular dragons have only one horn. The closest I can come to a conclusion is Valoo. As for the fishy tail, it could be in reference to the Water Dragon Faron, but I'm not sure on that. And if you've read all this, then I applaud you for being like me and having no life. Have a good day.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Consider me lifeless - read it, loved it. Another one with the boy near the Deku Tree - I think the Hero of Time is a great reference but also reminds me of the boy from ALTTP in the surrounded woods. Just has that vibe. Dragon wise Argorok springs to mind and Moldarach in the desert would team nicely with the SS references. Same with the water dragon. Nicely done sir, and love the discussion 💚💫
@thefourthfrank8814
@thefourthfrank8814 Год назад
I like how the series with all it's consistencies and inconsistencies lives up to it's title as a legend
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Couldn’t agree more, great way of wording it 💚💫
@victoralexandervinkenes9193
@victoralexandervinkenes9193 9 месяцев назад
People have a tendency to forget why it's called the LEGEND of Zelda. Sure, it's based on some truths, but some details and history are bound to be either misinterpreted, lost, or altered... After all, if it's called the Legend of Zelda, we need to ask this very simple set of questions... *When are the legends being told, and who is telling them?*
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths 9 месяцев назад
You wouldn’t believe me but I’m echoing that exact sentiment in audio recording of my current script. That concept is one worth raising in our exploration and a timely principle considering the respective sentiments that seem ( for me personally ) to miss the mark of the interactive nature and core of Zelda games - question, explore, uncover, and most important, craft your adventure with choice. Loved the comment 💚💫
@BeaglzRok1
@BeaglzRok1 Год назад
As a quick aside, my favorite solution to the Song of Storms is pretty simple: at some time before the paradox, Link was asked by Guru-Guru to play his song with him, and his magical ocarina made it start to rain. Somewhat similarly, the idea that BotW/TotK takes place after everything as a new beginning that acknowledges the past without adhering itself to it is great. Sure, there's a little bit of mental gymnastics in regards to figuring out if the Ooccoo turned into the Zonai, or why Hylia as a goddess has seen a resurgence after likely millennia of no one talking about her, but at this point in the timeline that's literally arguing over caveman sociology for how much temporal distance it has in regards to affecting the games and their story. Brush down the slate, still have a bit of those leftover markings there, continue from sense, a-okay.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
This was a blast to read, thanks for sharing 🌟💚 I think you are going to appreciate the commentary on the video I'm finalising at the moment on this topic. I very much agree that there is an element of elasticity to everything considering the incarnations matching the challenges of real world priorities, but the fun in piecing it together from a lore perspective is enjoying that challenge and finding ways to make sense of it all. In that degree, I'm still building on that theoretical approach and have more to add, so here's hoping it's at least enjoyable. All the best 👍
@yurisonovab3892
@yurisonovab3892 Год назад
Some Guy from twenty years ago: I made a neat map! Zelda Lore Nuts: BUT WHAT DOES IT MEEEEAAAAN!?
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Yep that sums me up nicely
@thajocoth
@thajocoth Год назад
Skyward Sword did not introduce the gliding mechanic to the series with the sailcloth. Wind Waker had the Deku Leaf and Link used it to glide in that game.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Sorry mate - poor choice of words. I’m aware of the gliding in WW - more meant to reference it in terms of that “sailcloth” handed from the Goddess ceremony as part of an ongoing in game item. But fair play - looking back, it sounds pretty stupid tbh without context. Thanks for picking me up on that, I try to be careful scripting so I’ll watch out for that next time. Have a good one mate, and thanks for the comment. All the best 💚💫
@RobotKitsune
@RobotKitsune Год назад
Brings to mind OoT's use of Cuccos to glide longer distances..I wonder if that's where our modern day Paraglider comes from, they have a bit of a similar feel in the glide itself, now that I think about it
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
@@RobotKitsune a really good point 💚💫
@pivotguydc1149
@pivotguydc1149 6 месяцев назад
@@gamesmiths To be completely fair - in BotW's beta the paraglider looked exactly like the sailcloth, so the comparison is warranted.
@ballachmona
@ballachmona Месяц назад
And in the Minish Cap, you could step into whirlwinds and glide around in some temples by using Ezlo as a parachute! This was also a Capcom collaboration!
@AbaddonEXE
@AbaddonEXE Год назад
Imaging that Gibdos were sentient all this time and not able to communicate due to Queen Gibdo’s curse/power/influence and they’re just trying to reach Link to seek for help so they can be free but we just slash them down since they look creepy and walk funny.
@TheDaveBloom
@TheDaveBloom Год назад
No unfortunately I’ve tried to be nice to them but they just swing at me regardless
@majora5651
@majora5651 11 месяцев назад
I see I wasn't the only one that got a deep burn in their soul after *that* moment in Majoras Mask
@smilesfordays
@smilesfordays Год назад
I DO have this puzzle in my home! It’s in the wrap still, next to the one they did of the windwaker stain glass! Very cool! I think my dad bought them both for me for Christmas, and I might be mistaken, but I think he got it at a big chain bookstore that sells many licensed items. I’ll have to ask him.
@Ashura_yt2
@Ashura_yt2 Год назад
0:00 Start 0:43 Chapter 1 6:18 Chapter 2 12:33 Chapter 3 23:13 Chapter 4 28:39 Outro
@TetrisAddiction
@TetrisAddiction Год назад
I have the 2014 puzzle- I won it at an arcade years ago. I realized it wasn’t the map, but never thought that deeply about it.
@MonsterMaze
@MonsterMaze Год назад
Good stuff man!
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thanks heaps mate 💚💫
@marissabulso6439
@marissabulso6439 Год назад
This is my first time coming across a video of yours, and I just wanted to say thank you! This is a beautifully done video essay and I very much enjoyed it. I’ll be sticking around for more!
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thank you kindly and appreciate both the kind words and ongoing support. I’m working on the next theory as we speak, part of a set of theories actually and you’ll find a callback in there to an Easter egg of sorts I left in this one. They take me a while, doing them outside of work etc, but I hope they will continue to keep you entertained and worth your time. All the best, and have a great day 💚💫
@dudenintendo605
@dudenintendo605 Год назад
Great video! Finally someone who see the worth behind this evolution of an almost real legend! With TotK they landed such a masterpiece! Everything is coming together that was established over years! A lot of people were criticizing the not existing tools from the old Zelda games, but for example what's better than a "Hook Shot", the Ascend function! And all the tools had disadvantages to them, that were eradicated in BotW and TotK! Back to the "Hook Shot"; you had to follow the level structures to be able to use it, for its time their tools were genius, but in an open world concept you can not use old paths! I love this trilogy of the latest Zelda games, it was a perfect way to say goodbye to the old world and welcome the new into our lives!
@dekoldrick
@dekoldrick Год назад
Now I wonder if the events of what happened to Zelda in TotK might have changed the timeline of previous entries. That would put BotW and TotK on a timeline disconnected from the previous. A genius move that would allow for future games to be created without constraints to past events.
@zelda_ray6757
@zelda_ray6757 Год назад
I personally think that it is a different timeline from the others, occurring after Skyward Sword. Since the Zonai are not present in any other games, it would make sense if there was a timeline split where the Zonai didn't come down (the other three timelines) v. Botw & Totk, where the Zonai did come down and contributed to Hyrule. That would wrap up how mummy Ganondorf being sealed under the castle for that long doesn't conflict with other Ganondorf's of the other timelines.
@thenanomon6908
@thenanomon6908 Год назад
I've needed a video like this. I got the puzzle for christmas last year and I was always wondering about which iteration of Hyrule it's showing.
@THEREALmethebat
@THEREALmethebat Год назад
"Those who forget the past are doomed to repeat it..." I am going to be sad if BOTW and TOTK are just placed at the bottom of the timeline as a reboot. The continuing lore is one of the best parts of the game and community.
@THEREALmethebat
@THEREALmethebat Год назад
Thanks so much for the video!!
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thanks for the comment. I can only suggest that I don’t expect that to be the case. My interpretation so far is more a launching point for taking those stories into a different iteration or dimension. One where the existing history remains but indeed can be iterated differently in a new cycle. Similar to how each day you begin by waking, cohesive to all days prior but your day plays out differently as a result of the events transpiring from the day prior. Maybe you go to work like always but events never play out the same. Probably not the best explanation but I’d like to think Nintendo are actively engaging the past to open up the possibilities of moving the series forward but retaining those stories to revisit or possibly reiterate without retcon. Just my view of course, but it’s a possibility that covers all bases, it’s what I would do in their position 💚💫
@thajocoth
@thajocoth Год назад
We know the version we see of the Song of Storms loop, but if you unwind it backwards, it's possible that a version of Link simply played the song that the windmill guy was playing, since he plays that same song even before Link plays it to him. This causes him to get mad, so adult Link gets the song before he goes back in time, changing the reason (and likely the timing) of young Link playing the song to him. It goes around, goes around, like a windmill, but a windmill starts somewhere when it's built. This wouldn't be a real paradox, because time has no reason to care about consistency. Matter is effected by physics at every point. That's all that matters. This world's physics happens to include magic. Nayru created the laws of the realm, what the rules of this world's physics would be. It only makes sense for the universe would carry these out _blindly._ The fact that multiple timelines were created by the time travel in OoT proves this.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Interesting. Being fair, paradox is an oversimplification of a much more complicated discussion but I’m never likely to please everyone with terminology decisions so although I can say definitively I know bringing up this topic is a minefield where I won’t be able to phrase it to please all, I certainly appreciate your perspective and largely agree with you. Albeit what I consider to be the multi dimensional aspects at play behind the iterative nature of the franchise v scientific endeavours compared to fictional world building I guess that’s my reference in terms of the statement about interpretation. What is really the great thing is heading these opinions and understanding how others view the matter. I enjoyed this perspective, particularly the consideration of how it began with when the windmill was built. I don’t disagree. But that was the point - not to debate the point of beginning but to appreciate the iteration of it from one perspective to another. However, that line - it starts where it’s built - chefs kiss - loved it 💚💫
@CC-df3pn
@CC-df3pn Год назад
The reason the Windmill guy and song of storms in OOT is known as a bootstrap paradox is because if Link never learns the SOS from windmill guy, he can never play the song to the man which is then the cause for him originally learning it. This is the literal definition of a bootstrap paradox or causal loop. The information creates itself out of necessity. We can take it further in that we know SOS doesn't originate in Hyrule, the Hyrulean Sharp brother composed the songs of the sun and moon which became one song, the sun's song, their graves are found on either side of the royal tomb in Kakariko. SOS was created by the Terminian Sharp brothers in Ikana. Link can only learn that if he survives the events of OOT, which to do so he has to complete the shadow temple, to do that he needs to get through the bottom of the well, to do that he needs SOS. So, the song does exist but Link learns it out of time, again, due to the paradox necessitating it to be so.
@thajocoth
@thajocoth Год назад
@@CC-df3pn The Bootstrap Paradox isn't really a paradox at all. A thing can originate from a prior iteration of said universe. With multiple trips through time, it can land on a version that fully obscures where something originated the first time. This is especially true in multiverses that branch off new timelines when time travel occurs, which we know the Zelda multiverse does. Also, the windmill guy plays the same exact song BEFORE Link ever plays it to empty the well. Every time you enter the windmill, including the first time you ever visit Kakariko Village, he's playing the song. In Termina, it was composed by one of the Sharp brothers... But Romani & Malon managed to have the same song for different reasons. I see no reason the Song of Storms in Hyrule couldn't've been originally composed by Hyrule's Sharp Brothers. That's not an uncommon trope for multiverses... Different versions of the same people creating the same things despite having different circumstances... They were still royal composers, after all. They composed the Sun's Song.
@CC-df3pn
@CC-df3pn Год назад
@@thajocoth again, it is the LITERAL DEFINITION of a bootstrap paradox. Yes the song plays as we enter the windmill, that is a limit of the original game. We are told directly that the song is first learned by the windmill guy, and played, by a boy with an ocarina which ruined the windmill. The canon overwrites the gameplay and system limitations of the original game. The canon also says that the Hyrulean Sharp brothers only composed the Sun's song not SOS. I know what you are trying to say but using the limits of the game in the face of what the game and all other media surrounding it state as the actual events and canon is reductive
@thajocoth
@thajocoth Год назад
@@CC-df3pn Assuming that all multiversal events in the series are shown to us, and that nothing else ever happens seems more like limiting yourself for no reason. They were royal composers. Why would they only compose one song in their entire lifespans? That makes no sense. I'd be surprised if they didn't also compose OoT's warp songs & Song of Time. The Sun's Song would be, like, their final song that they were in the middle of composing when they died, like their version of Beethoven's 10th symphony, which is why you can only get it in their crypt. We know that time travel in the Zelda multiverse creates alternate timelines. With all the time travel that occurs, we're only told about three of these timelines. It's super naive to think there wouldn't be more. These three are simply the timelines with games in them. Maybe the timeline that has a version of Link learning the song in a more straightforward way is simply otherwise uninteresting, so it has no games after that? Or maybe that time branch gets pruned from existence after it happens, which is more logically how time travel would really work if it was possible? There are so many gaps where things happen in the Zelda multiverse that we never see. I wouldn't assume that just because we only see the carpenters building Kakariko village and then trapped by the Gerudo that they immediately left for Gerudo Valley the moment Kakariko was done being built. Other things could've happened in their lives between those events that were simply not important to the story. We can't really know what those things were. Time travel paradoxes make certain assumptions about how time travel works (and those assumptions never actually make any logical sense). This is a multiverse in which we *know* how time travel works because we can see that it splits into separate timelines. Since it's not a causal loop universe (one in which time cannot be changed, so if you go back in time, you always went back in time), none of the traditional "time travel paradoxes" are valid in it, because there are now a billion different possible explanations that work to fill in the blanks. We can't know that any one of them is true unless Nintendo adds one of them to the series canon, but it doesn't matter which one is true because it's unimportant to the story. We have enough information to know that it's possible. It could easily be that if Link doesn't play the Song of Storms, and therefore doesn't get into the well to get the Lens of Truth, that after a while Link learns the song from another source at some point in the next few years (which could be in Hyrule or Termina, who knows?) Link then happens to play it in the Windmill. In this version of events, 7 years after child Link failed to enter the well, the guy is angry about the song being played, but it happened more recently than 7 years ago. This causes Link to learn the song earlier because of his time travel forward 7 years before. As a result, he can play the song sooner, getting into the well, and the guy's anger changes from "5 years ago" to "7 years ago" in the future. That's one of a million perfectly logical possibilities. It would make no sense from a narrative perspective to show us all that, and it's very clear that Nintendo cares more about narrative than canon consistency. There's no reason to show us the pieces that are irrelevant to the story.
@WordsInProgress
@WordsInProgress Год назад
Perhaps BOTW was originally meant to literally unite the timelines and they decided to push that back to a later game. It seems very intentional to include features from previous games in the puzzle map, and they may have decided they had too much material to put into two games (especially considering exactly how much there is to both games already). It would be very interesting to me if this became a trilogy but it seems unlikely
@WordsInProgress
@WordsInProgress Год назад
Obviously these games technically take place in all timelines, I'm implying that it seems they intended to do a lot more and there's likely a lot already planned for the future with the amount of content they've had to cut from botw and totk throughout development
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
I think that’s a pretty good call-out and I’d agree that what we know is only part of the roadmap at any given point in time. It’s interesting to consider based on where we are now and what potential the series has to expand the story 💚💫
@noradosmith
@noradosmith Год назад
I like how this dude comes out of nowhere and casually drops one of the best zelda videos ever
@jackdaw4986
@jackdaw4986 Год назад
Personally I thought the castor wilds connection also had something to do with the ancient columns which is right below Rito village but I fully understand where you're coming from when referring to Rito Village's connection and the Tabantha Wilds
@Fuzzypaws
@Fuzzypaws Год назад
That connection still fits, because the ancient columns bears a lot of resemblance to the Wind Tribe Ruins in MC, which you access via Castor Wilds.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
You’re actually bang on and I agree with you. There were a few locations in BOTW for the ancient columns etc, one being west of Illumeni Plateau/south of Rito and another near Akalla stables, inland from the coastal features nth east. Your connection makes sense to me for sure 👍💚💫
@stuffz1757
@stuffz1757 Год назад
I mean I think the memories are just before OOT. The games still happened after and Skyward Sword and the Era of Chaos both still happened before, TotK just only cares about TotKdorf and to a lesser extent Skyward Sword.
@cato3277
@cato3277 Год назад
Could be the Era of Prosperity
@amirhosseinmaghsoodi388
@amirhosseinmaghsoodi388 Год назад
I myself put a bit more padding in between the imprisoning war and OOT and consider the civil war a different conflict from the imprisoning war. I think the Rauru from OOT is a descendant of the one in TOTK; inheriting the power of light and maybe time too. Perhaps OOT Rauru rediscovered both the Triforce and the Master sword, put the former behind the door of time, sealed by the latter. And perhaps with the aid of his fellow sages too since there is a chamber of the sages.
@Splatakv
@Splatakv Год назад
So glad that RU-vid recommended your channel! I love the correlations you brought up between the mech (I still have that puzzle, I have yet to do it 😅) and the interviews/games. I think botw/ totk game map struck such a beautiful balance between classic Zelda landmarks while keeping it new to explore. I don’t expect places to stay the same from game to game, in fact, it’s better for their main theme of exploration that they don’t. But as a lore buff it’s great that they are keeping it a stable and in mind while designing. Great video and thanks for sharing!
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thank you kindly Splatakv - couldn't ask for a better comment and couldn't agree more with your take on things. It's a tough line to tread with the lengthy history the series has, but I'm very greatful to enjoy it so much and share that passion with others like yourself. Thanks for taking the time to share this, and keep being amazing - you made my day with this one, so I hope this puts a smile on your face too 💚🌟
@Splatakv
@Splatakv Год назад
@@gamesmiths right back at cha! Now excuse me while I binge the rest of your theories 🤓🍿
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
@Splatakv legend! Hope they hold up ok - I’m still pretty rough at this whole YT thing 😂
@Splatakv
@Splatakv Год назад
@@gamesmiths I know how you feel! But honestly your production quality is excellent, and so is your narration. I would have assumed you’ve been doing this for much longer so go easy on yourself! You deserve it 😊
@garrettrinquest1605
@garrettrinquest1605 Год назад
It's great to see another classic theory video from you! This is what I'm here for.
@bigz4829
@bigz4829 Год назад
I just went and read the transcript of that Iwata asks interview. It is SO fascinating to me that the design philosophy of BotW, whose praises have been sung by nearly ever RU-vid essayist, was present in-house as far back as even then.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Agree BigZ - that interview was mind blowing and felt like a treat to read now with the privilege of hindsight. I’m glad someone else appreciated as much as I did 💫💚
@bigz4829
@bigz4829 Год назад
@@gamesmiths Iwata seems to have a strong link to the malaise of Nintendo properties from 2010-his passing, which is likely put on him just by the western community of fans. I don't know what he was doing at Nintendo aside from PR and these interviews, but the man knew how to carry an audience and tell them exactly what they're looking for. A legend.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Honestly the video from Gaming Historian gets me every time. From embodying hard work, kindness, passion, humility and unity, his stewardship through adversity showed true courage and symbolically brought about the rebirth of Nintendo in modern gaming - a fitting understanding of the principles discussed in that interview - finding universal appeal through a sense of feeling. I know very little myself, but my experiences in leadership have always been about a mantra that you work for your team, not the other way around. I can’t help but feel this approach was something similar in how he connected with people. He remains an icon to me, always will. Making games fun for everyone - indeed a legend in every sense of the word. 💚💫
@Silails
@Silails Год назад
I have the "cleaning cloth" version of the map, bundled in the leather like 3ds zelda carring case (that I use for my switch) and since then always wondered what's up with that weird map
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Wow another reference of a source I haven’t heard. Thanks for sharing - this map gets around 💚💫
@deathnights-bane3301
@deathnights-bane3301 Месяц назад
I used to have this on a mug, it was a triforce that when heated revealed the bigger image, the mug began showing up around the same time the anniversary Amiibo's started releasing.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths 12 дней назад
That’s a new one - awesome thanks for sharing. It’s interesting how many places this turns up 💚💫
@SenketsuFi
@SenketsuFi Год назад
i literally have this map as a reusable sticky sided cleaning cloth stuck to the side of my PC next to me RIGHT NOW..
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
OMG! That might actually take the cake for the most odd version of the map in circulation since I put out the video which is saying something. A reusable cleaning cloth...honestly...speechless. I was toying with the idea for a while about following up on this video purely based on the volume of random items it now seems to be associated with because I'm kinda intrigued as to who is making all this stuff - what's licensed v knock off...and get more behind how it's managed to proliferateso much. There's something about the sheer variety and weird randomness of it that has me more curious than when I went to make the video. Thanks for sharing this and blowing my mind. A reusable cleaning cloth...so random its perfect. Legend effort 💚💚🌟🌟
@dantheman15
@dantheman15 Год назад
YES! The return of the king! I know that this has been a long running, highly contested idea for you. I am glad that you finally were able to get it out. The concept of this map being a rough draft of breath of the wild made sense but now with tears of the kingdom we finally receive answers in a well-done video thanks to you. I can't wait to continue building these paradoxical puzzle that are the zelda theories with you and the community.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Dan - Thank you for everything including the inspiration for this video. I truly could not hope for a greater friend - and indeed, we have a lot more ahead. Luckily we have a great team and awesome community to share it with. I’ll be right there with you, picking apples and planting seeds. 🌟♾️💚💫
@daymoid356
@daymoid356 2 месяца назад
I have had this map on my wall for a while no and i had no idea it had this much history,but i knew it was official zelda merch so youve essentially put together a comprehensive video of the scattered thoughts i had when totk first came out. Ive never felt so validated in my life
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths 2 месяца назад
Honestly, this comment made my day, thank you! And you are most welcome, the thing had been curious for me for the longest time as well, so its been interesting to see the reaction from everyone has really reinforced how mysterious the piece is amongst the fandom, which validates your thoughts even more 💚🌟
@_Mingus_
@_Mingus_ Год назад
4:25 I HAVE THAT NOTEBOOK I GOT IT FROM THE BOOK FAIR AT SCHOOL YEARS AGO LET'S GOOOOOO
@ЧуднойЛинк
@ЧуднойЛинк Год назад
You know, this video made me think of something different. Zelda series has an odd place in my mind, as if it's recreating my childhood memories. I've never played any Zelda game as a child, due to them being unavailable in my country. I only got to know this series in about 2016. But games like Ocarina of Time seem... familiar to me, as if I knew them way in the past.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
I adore this comment. So poetic 💚💫
@170skeith
@170skeith Год назад
I have just assumed that the timeline didn't matter and that's why it's so confusing and the main goal is to reboot the series to tell a long form story while not isolating older fans so the timeline was made but the only current timeline that Nintendo is working from is Skyward sword, the flashbacks from Tears of the kingdom, breath of the wild, and the current day events of tears of the kingdom.
@haruhisuzumiya6650
@haruhisuzumiya6650 Год назад
Definitely unique the 550 P and the 1000 P are the exact same map This map was made slightly independent of BOTW map as Wii U development was 2012 which would predate the map but remember that it was published in 2014 ZU was definitely still in development then. With a teaser in 2014
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thanks and appreciate the comment. Interesting to note, and something I left out of the video so as not to overly elaborate, but different versions either feature or remove the World Atals banner from the bottom portion, depending on the source of the map. It's another fact that makes it more intriguing - underneath that banner is a reference to a peahat from OoT, but is covered when the banner is in place, that being the more common representation. Thought you might find that interesting as well noting the timelines mentioned and considered in respect of the dialect of Ancient Hylian Script - that being the more modern version from ALBW onwards, as opposed to the initial type from SS. 💚🌟
@bruhbruh885
@bruhbruh885 6 дней назад
I just got this puzzle and now this videos on my feed? Crazy coincidence, I love this map and this theory
@NintenDobs
@NintenDobs Год назад
I bought this puzzle for $10 at EB Games nearly 10 years ago, never actually put it together for one reason or another until earlier this year and turns out it's missing one single piece: the smoke ring on Death Mountain. In terms of Zelda related content; something that I've always really enjoyed completing every last quest, bottle, item, heart container, armor upgrade, etc., I can't express just how unsatisfying this puzzle was lol
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Oh wow - I feel that one and hard. It makes something in my eyeball itch and honestly my OCD nature is in full gear just reading this. My heart goes out to you 💚💫
@NintenDobs
@NintenDobs Год назад
@@gamesmiths Well something I hadn't thought of until watching this video was seeing if they are still available to buy, thanks to you I now know I can just get another one from Amazon. Fingers crossed this next one isn't missing the peak of Hyrule Castle 🤞
@Hylianmonkeys
@Hylianmonkeys Год назад
Ive been wondering about this for years. I havent thought about in a while though. I never thought we would get answers.
@wizcatcheslightning
@wizcatcheslightning Год назад
Excellently said here, GS! Definitely curious to see what the next game brings us!
@DonutSwordsman
@DonutSwordsman Год назад
the flower monuments in the sky translate to talking about before the zonai showed up and met sonia, she told them that the green shrines from TOTK were popping up everywhere.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Nice call - thanks for that and appreciate the input 💫💚
@EpicFireMaster1230
@EpicFireMaster1230 Год назад
I’ve had this puzzle framed on my wall for years! So cool.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
That's awesome EpicFireMaster1230 - glad this made that a little more cool for you 💚🌟
@ghoulie11
@ghoulie11 Год назад
The Music Man always reminded me of the Happy Mask Salesman.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Very much so 💚💚🌟🌟
@DaylightRobbie
@DaylightRobbie Год назад
So. One thing I’ve always been curious about is the Great Plateau. It’s always seemed out of place as if it was just placed there. Coincidently. It’s also in the place where you’d expect the kokori forest would be. It’s also roughly the same size. Its also home to the first temple of time. Was it maybe a floating island that wondered hyrule? Did it rise out of the ground?
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
A great pondering. Supposedly it was moved during development, but keeping it in world, considering it as built around the Kokiri forest is an intriguing proposition
@DarkMirria1
@DarkMirria1 Год назад
That Hyrule map on that puzzle is also featured on a fuzzy blanket that was sold at GameStop. I’ve seen them there in the past and own one myself which is how I know.
@ericmarroquin8980
@ericmarroquin8980 Год назад
I have the exact same blanket hanging up on my room wall😁
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Sweet - that’s awesome 💚💫
@GaryJuuce
@GaryJuuce Год назад
3:13 So theres like parallel timelines or something? like A split before or during Skyward sword? Era of Myth could all be similiar to the games we have
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thanks for the comment/question GaryJuuce and I guess that's part of the larger mystery and depends on your take. For me, I continue to find more evidence of the games and lore being planned out well before most think, and the connections add to what I believe was a planned change or addition to the timelines published in Zelda Encyclopedia, but courses were changed I think based on the feedback from play-testing which identified that fans were having so much fun trying to understand where it fit that ultimately the devs decided to leave it more of a mystery and allow the fanbase to come to their own conclusions. Summarily for me though, there is definite threads from Skyward Sword through the major console releases (OoT, MM, TP, WW, Zelda 1 & 2) and what eventuates in BOTW and TOTK. What I do believe though is we have a cyclical iteration on what's happened in the past, meaning they exist in parralel to an extent, albeit within a different reality. It's a little tough for me to explain it and I'm breaking that down in the last video I released a few weeks ago and more on the way, but needless to say it's an interpretation that some might not agree with which is fine, but for my mind, we have more coming to piece this mystery together. Will be very interested to see what happens with the DLC 💚🌟
@stevendorries
@stevendorries Год назад
6:16 I just realized I have the map in the form of a tiny screen wipe that came with my Zelda 3ds case from the release of A Link Between Worlds
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thanks Steven - yet another variation I hadn’t heard yet. Man this keeps getting more interesting over time. Appreciate the input. Have a great day 💚💫
@Markcrazeer
@Markcrazeer Год назад
if tabantha is castor wilds then could minish cap be set after? the rito being the wind tribe and the wind ruins the remains of rito village?
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Absolutely and ties in with another interesting take on things where it could be considered almost a mythical prequel of sorts before Skyward Sword which is really cool to ponder. Great call 👍💚💫
@Markcrazeer
@Markcrazeer Год назад
@@gamesmiths mythical. that is one important thing to remeber in all of this. no zelda game is canon. it is all the legend of zelda. events happened but the only thing we can ever take as fact in any given zelda game is what we see in the given game. chances are a lot of zelda games are retellings of same or similar events. or, the general events of the game are history but everything we play is myth.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
@@Markcrazeer indeed my friend agree. Though I’m putting together a theory at the minute that will throw a slight spin on perspectives considering the viewpoint of course. Fascinating materials I’ve been going through provide an opportunity to put some scientific rigour behind the fictional backdrop with some surprising evidence to make it worth considering so keep an eye out for that soon. As always it’s only one possibility…or should I say more like a myriad of possibilities 😉
@cajunking5987
@cajunking5987 Год назад
I got a tiny map from the 3DS case too, still have it in great condition
@Ferovu
@Ferovu Год назад
Cool. It’s really nice to see Nintendo hunting at future games when, Me when they show TOTK teaser in 2018: “What the f*ck is this?”
@catgckool428
@catgckool428 Год назад
Can anyone tell me the name of the song that plays about 8:10 in. It's good and I having trouble finding it even with the source of the music used in the video being in the description.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Hi there - that track is "Fi's Theme", with this version being from the Skyward Sword OST - beautiful song 💚💚🌟🌟
@spudsbuchlaw
@spudsbuchlaw 2 месяца назад
I've always believed each map of Hyrule is like Skyrim: an interpretation. Its not literally changing but permutations showing us different interpretations of the same thing. The "True Hyrule" is likely either LTTP+Zelda 2, since they were first and didnt need to be remixed, or is completely unseen to this day
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths 2 месяца назад
A fair enough call and I quite liked the references made, thanks for sharing your thoughts 💚🌟
@WildflowersCreations
@WildflowersCreations Год назад
Very interesting take on this map, thank you!
@pivotguydc1149
@pivotguydc1149 6 месяцев назад
From a music nerd standpoint, Guru-Guru has a music box. It's pre-programmed to only play the Song of Storms, forever, by whomever built it. All Guru-Guru does is turn the handle, no music knowledge required. All Link would have to do to learn the Song of Storms is to listen to it long enough to transcribe it, which is something he could do at any age, technically.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths 5 месяцев назад
Interesting take on a conundrem factoring in causation. Makes me then wonder...who made the box? 💚🌟
@BioAlpha5
@BioAlpha5 Год назад
i love this series so much. great video! I theorized something similar but SS, BOTW And TOTK all exist in another timeline (and the OG Timeline but). The Era of Myth is a alternate reality version of the older games. And ganondorf in the era of myth that is similar in our OG timeline (the n64 games and other games etc) all exist or may not exist. Like a dragon break but like you said, doesn't necessarily end. So BOTW and TOTK somehow exist possibly in a way that well never experience? But use what we know from SS, Era of Myth, BotW and TotK in the "Fujibiyoshi Parallel Timeline" to help answer the questions of the old OG Timeline. Or something completely different. Some people say that BotW and TotK are contradictory to each other. AND some people are saying the games are a ll one timeline. But the best part? All of us coming together to try to figure it out. I love it. Great video and ill def be watching more!
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Man this was a pleasure to read - you got it @BioAlpha5! For my mind, I have my take on things, and that's certainly something I'm building on with the current run of theory videos and as part of what I've been exploring for some time. I really do believe the devs have a longer term plan in operation, and the more I delve into the lore and aspects, the more alignment I seem to find that suggests this is indeed where we are heading. That said, I'll be the first to say that I could be completely wrong, and it's my best interpretation based off what I'm finding, and sharing it with fellow fans is the best part of making these videos. To date, I'm convinced I've actually learned more about why Nintendo are approaching things the way they are - for me doing a theory is very much about putting up facts and observations, suggesting what I think it could mean, but ultimately leaving it up to you as the viewer to interpret and decide - it just makes sense to me as the best way to do things. I might have my own version, but I keep getting input from others I like more than my own take, so leaving things open to a collaborative discussion ensures I get to see things from so many different perspectives I never would have, and honestly I'm richer for it. It's a real privelage to do these videos and read comments like this, and thanks for being awesome, and being part of that discussion. I really like your take on it too, and to be honest, I have noticed a few things that could support that viewpoint as well. Expect me to touch on at least one of those in the next theory video or two, but suffice it to say, there's always been an open thread for me with Skyward Sword that raises a question about what I've deemed "The Forgotten Timeline" in my own theory notes, so I can totally see where you are coming from there. Whether that's the way the Big N goes is anyones guess, but it sure is fun to talk about. Have a great day, and thanks again 💚🌟
@BioAlpha5
@BioAlpha5 Год назад
Thank you! feels great that a big Zelda RU-vidr thinks my theory has weight. And its def a benefit to be open to all ways the game and its info can be interpreted. Cant wait to see your next video. Thanks again! @@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
@@BioAlpha5 Very kind my friend, but we are all fans and trust me when I say that the best theories come from everyone, not just someone on YT, and we are all as important when it comes to being heard in the Zelda theory community as each other. That's one of the main reaons I love doing this and I'm still stoked that anyone listens to my theories just the same as you. Looking forward to bringing some new content ideas soon that will hopefully get that message out even stronger 💚💚🌟🌟
@infernal7901
@infernal7901 Год назад
The idea of this actually seems really cool and interesting
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thank you 💚💫
@TheNerdyHomestead
@TheNerdyHomestead 4 месяца назад
This was a great video to listen to mildly blazed. Thanks for the cool vid
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths 4 месяца назад
Glad you enjoyed it! 💚💫
@minty9959
@minty9959 Год назад
i literally have that puzzle it was in my room for years
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
lol! Thanks for that, literally one of the reasons I wanted to do this theory. It's kinda cool to think we all had this map laying around in some form, and I'd thought it would be important with TOTK. When my "guesses" about the Gibdos and the pirate ship actually came to pass I was really excited to share it 💚🌟
@MarshallTheArtist
@MarshallTheArtist Год назад
Link learned the Song of Storms in Flat's tomb in Ikana Graveyard in the imaginary land of Termina. It's magic.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Love it 💫💚
@paperpopper2586
@paperpopper2586 Год назад
Fantastic video, i have nothing to add i just really love zelda and all the discussion like this about it
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thanks for taking the time to comment and glad you enjoyed it 💚💫
@demonwolf8024
@demonwolf8024 7 месяцев назад
Which came first? They both did, it's just a matter of perspective. However, the better question to ask is where did the song come from? Neither of the Links nor the windmill guy created the song as they heard it from each other but how did the song come into existence? That's the actual paradox. Edit: As The Doctor put it, who composed Beethoven's 5th symphony?
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths 5 месяцев назад
Sorry for the late reply - no idea why this comment held back on my feed, but thanks for your input and couldn’t agree more - perspective always changes the narrative and enjoyed the reference there 💚💫
@ryanwatts7817
@ryanwatts7817 Год назад
Will have to give this video a round 2. I loved what I heard but I used it as something to zone out to, to get rid of a raging headache and it worked so thx. Also I got the map as a poster that I bought In a shop
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thanks Ryan - 2 birds with 1 stone - couldn't be happier and possibly one of the best pieces of feedback I've ever heard - you've achieved legend status! Appreciate the input and humour, champion and welcome here anytime mate 💚💚🌟🌟
@noahRibeye
@noahRibeye Год назад
Colgera fight music is the best boss fight music in totk 👇
@noahRibeye
@noahRibeye Год назад
0:44
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Absolutely🌟💚
@rocknatex5013
@rocknatex5013 Год назад
I beg to differ. Ganondorf's boss themes were all legendary. Especially when it started riffing off Ocarina of Time's Ganondorf battle theme.
@sus-gibble4721
@sus-gibble4721 2 месяца назад
Best Boss in most of the franchise. IT WAS SICK!!
@ogOAFgaming
@ogOAFgaming Год назад
Mrs. Oaf and I have this exact puzzle!! Absolutely brilliant GS!!❤
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thanks Oaf, always appreciate the support brother
@PenneySounds
@PenneySounds Год назад
Who is this Aiji Aiyanuma people keep mentioning in these videos? Is he connected in some way to the other one that keeps getting mentioned, Eijia Aoanuma? Or Aijia Eiyaonuma? Or Aiji Anuma? Who are all these people?
@Insertbadnamegot
@Insertbadnamegot Год назад
Keep it up! This amazing
@MysteryTheMysterious
@MysteryTheMysterious Год назад
I haven't watched the whole video but congrats on 13,000 views on this video!
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thanks Mystery much appreciated buddy 💚💫
@hermancharlesserrano1489
@hermancharlesserrano1489 Год назад
What we need next is a meta time loop that sends us back to the most iconic events across all the games…Ganondorf using Zelda(‘s power) in order to change the outcomes of his greatest defeats…so Link has to make it back to pivotal moments, to save his prior selves, re-defeat Ganon(s), save all the versions of Zelda…a mad race across all the timelines as he solves the present in order to achieve the past
@Big_Dai
@Big_Dai Год назад
Zelda has always had a very simplistic story structure.. filled with "details" by the Player's interactions with the world (in some cases, they aren't as noteworthy). Nintendo's approach, and more of a distaste, to keeping a timeline is rather interesting. It's one that allows them to basically redo the same game/story over and over without changing anything other than the systems and mechanics. It's also smart, because people like Zelda for what it is.. and TotK being basically BotW version 2, as well as a remake of Skyward Swords, it allows them to iterate on that freshly. It's also kind of sad from a storytelling point of view.. as they aren't really interested in moving it forward. Special cases like Majora's and Link's Awakenings were born from desires to make something else (while being pushed for time) and don't really help their case.. I'm afraid Zelda will never really be anything more than it is. Not until these geezers leave, and new generations either ruin it or make it better (the first option being the most likely outcome).
@jslaughter95
@jslaughter95 Год назад
One thing I would absolutely LOVE to see is the next few Zelda games taking place in the same world as BOTW/Totk but outside of the borders of Hyrule, give us a new Majoras Mask like adventure outside of the comfort zone of Hyrule
@Iffondrel
@Iffondrel Год назад
This is all very true. That being said, the very loose story structure and vague understanding of the timeline has led to some truly marvelous fan content of the series, and that's something that's been really interesting to explore.
@Big_Dai
@Big_Dai Год назад
@@Iffondrel That is very true! But there's something to be said about your community of fans wanting more and letting their creativity push these stories collectively into places they have no business being in (according to Nintendo's standards). I'm one to think people shouldn't need to do "homework" and find little tidbits of improvement on the darkest places of the internet when they are incapable of constructing them themselves. Although, it worked for Bloodborne! Giving me extra HOURS of more content from a game I ultimately still love.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thanks. I’m very lucky to have a great community and I guess the viewpoint comes from seeing things from different perspectives. I love the detail but I know plenty of others who prefer a simplistic approach or only know things from one title. I could imagine it being hard to cater for that, but I think Nintendo ultimately walk that balance very well. Thanks for the comment and appreciate the input 💚💫
@Big_Dai
@Big_Dai Год назад
@@gamesmiths 🤗
@dishman4694
@dishman4694 3 месяца назад
Exactly how many tombs, or groups of books, must I purchase for to be able to know everything there is to know about Hyrule, Lorule, and all of its surrounding history?
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths 3 месяца назад
Technically none tbh - you only need to know as much as you want, that’s the beauty of it. That and Google always helps 😉. Seriously though, I find Zelda Encyclopaedia and Creating a Champion to give most of the info you might not get in game and definitely recommend GDC presentations and dev interviews for good info without someone else “interpreting” it. All the best 💚💫
@baltakatei
@baltakatei Месяц назад
The gibdos look alien because the Hylian body plan probably is alien. Hylians only look like us because we're supposed to empathize with them for marketability of the game. Much like how despite Star Wars took place “A long time ago in a galaxy far far away” it has “humans”.
@very_generic_name
@very_generic_name Год назад
I figured out that piece that puts it all together. The officially licensed, legend of zelda calendar.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
💚💫
@bobbyjackson797
@bobbyjackson797 Год назад
I had a cloth map of hyrule that came with my strategy guide for twilight princess back in ‘06, did that one not count?
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Wait wait - did you get that map back in 2006? I can’t find any references before 2014 of that iteration and no comments either. And with Twilight Princess - that would be pretty awesome 💫💚
@Cyclingismywholelife
@Cyclingismywholelife Год назад
Great work, fun watch.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Glad you enjoyed it - thanks for the kind words 💚💫
@silenceoflink5880
@silenceoflink5880 Год назад
I have a blanket with this map on it, and I always just assumed it was a generalization of the maps of Hyrule so when someone asked for a map of Hyrule, Nintendo didn't have to ask from which game. They would just give this map. Basically, it's the map of marketing lol.
@nanabobo567
@nanabobo567 Год назад
That's certainly a good way to label it. "The map of marketing."
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Yeh fair call. I can see where you’re coming from - it is a business after all
@doomsdayrabbit4398
@doomsdayrabbit4398 4 месяца назад
Well, we know the next title's name, then - The Legend of Zelda: The Marketing Map.
@theganjician9272
@theganjician9272 Год назад
I really wish that they would have added all of the temple dungeons from SS, OoT, TP and ALTTP to the game could legit be copy and pasted and I wouldn’t care or just change up mechanics slightly. They could be side content like Skyrim dungeons or something. Other people exploring them or bandits there. If there is 3 Separate Temple of Times still standing then all of the other places should be too even if some are in disrepair. Plus having old iconic places remade in ToTK’s engine would be amazing! Kakariko needs the giant windmill and graveyard leading to the shadow temple and being able to access under the well. Gerudo’s spirit temple bandit hideout. Things I wish they would have added in tho. Guardian armor should still be a thing and weapons with Guardians being enemies. Maybe have the Shieka have special tests for link in combat you could complete for rewards? Where are The Deku Scrubs??? They should have included Poe’s as actual enemies for us to fight. More flying enemies in the sky/ sky islands and mini bosses flying around. New leviathans in the sky islands not just dragons. Helmasaurs, dodongos, wolfos, Deku babas, tektites. The huge rideable boars that the moblins rode, stal hydra iron knuckles and dark nuts Skull Kids! And a ruined forest Haven leading to the Forest Temple would have been awesome with the original Phantom Ganon there with his old model Why can’t we pet any dogs when that was brought up they wanted to add? Why remove Hearty fruit( forgot the name) Why is BoTW and ToTK the only Zelda games that don’t have a dedicated fishing spot? And regardless why are there no fishing rods at all in these games? Bombing and swimming works but, Nintendo has always had a soft spot for fishing(adding a brand new fishing spot in MM Remake) that idk why they wouldn’t add it. More realistic with the systems present or as an alternative. You could buy supplies or make them to get a bigger better catch
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
OMG - that would be ultimate - shut up and take my money 💚💚💫💫 seriously though a great idea and could be like wave expansion packs almost like MarioKart if need be because I think a lot of us would be down for that
@Zacian2.0
@Zacian2.0 Год назад
So has anyone else put together that the Depths is only under Hyrule and not extending past, which might just mean it is man made. Very sus. also it never goes under any water (leakage worries?)
@nunull6427
@nunull6427 Год назад
Mine of the shieka battery ingredient?
@noahsmethers9339
@noahsmethers9339 Год назад
Having explored the depths a lot, it's interesting that the higher elevation=lower depths. Also, the walls of the depths end slightly before the overworlds edge. And every place there is water on the overworld there are walls in the depths, so I don't see leakages being a problem (Besides the hot springs I guess, but those get lava instead). I don't know what it means, and I'd love to see a small section of the map without gloom, roots, or any of that over time wear-down, that way we can see if it looks natural or not
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
It’s a great observation and I’ve got a running theory on the depths planned for a future video post completion of my playthrough. One thing you might notice is how the landscape is completely wrought - almost like it’s had any richness long since drained as well as extensive mining operations. Both features connect extremely well with events surrounding the Lanayru region in Skyward Sword - lands once fertile undergone a desertification of sorts with the suggestion of time shift stones mining contributing to the environmental degradation. 💫💚
@rocknatex5013
@rocknatex5013 Год назад
I have a theory that the Depths are where the Underworld of Zelda NES was located. I mean, the statues in those dungeons kinda resemble Zonai statues, and there are rooms too dark to see without lighting a candle. Plus, it served as Ganon's lair and a hotspot for monsters. If nothing else, it feels like a reference to the NES Underworld.
@eboroni
@eboroni Год назад
I would love to see an actual game using this map
@JPBrooksLive
@JPBrooksLive Год назад
I have a journal and a blanket with this map on it!
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
That's interesting - the blanket is one I've never seen, but sounds AWESOME, so might have to look that up - thanks for sharing this 💚🌟
@cd31000
@cd31000 Месяц назад
The Song of Storms has an easy solution if you consider that the Fallen timeline is true. My current solution for it is that in the fallen timeline Link begins his journey as normal up until he enters the Temple of Time, but instead of being sealed away he is ambushed by Ganondorf, and the recently acquired triforce of courage stolen, despite still having the master sword he is forced to carry out his journey to the best of his ability however he is not able to retrieve the medallions and is forced to look elsewhere. This is where he ends up making his way to Termina, learning the song of storms, but is unable to stop majora and in a last ditch effort uses the Giants Mask to help the Giants push the moon away from termina. He returns from his journey and teaches the song of storms to the windmill man to gain access to the well, but is still unable to acquire the medallions, meanwhile Ganondorf begins his assault on Hyrule bringing destruction in his wake Even going so far as to kill most of the sages, but as it's hero link who is still a child at this time tries to fight the king of evil and fails, Zelda still in the sheik disguise retrieves the Ocarina of Time and uses it to send herself back in time thus starting the child timeline, meaning that the person who teaches the windmill man the song of storms in the Child Timeline originally, is not link but Zelda disguised as sheik, this is also why Link is sealed away is simply because It's necessary for him not to be involved in the battle so that way he doesn't die again.
@danielc6440
@danielc6440 Год назад
Brilliant video 👍🏻👍🏻 I agree 100% with your analysis
@SilentVinyl
@SilentVinyl Год назад
That is pretty cool
@celestedoodles
@celestedoodles Год назад
The moment the map popped out I had to pull out my LoZ Notebook I bought years ago and amazed its the same one shown here XD
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Nice thanks for sharing. Another one coming from a notebook. This map really found its way into so many homes in different ways over the years. All the best 💫💚
@Rugbi_15
@Rugbi_15 Месяц назад
I’m blanking on the track around 26:28. Can anyone help me out? It sounds Skyward Sword-esque but I have no idea.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Месяц назад
Bamboo Island is the track you’re looking for and is from the Skyward Sword OST
@Rugbi_15
@Rugbi_15 Месяц назад
@@gamesmiths oh wow! Hi! 😳 Thank you for letting me know! 💜
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Месяц назад
No problems. Great track and a worthy addition to any playlist. Enjoy ☺️
@Rugbi_15
@Rugbi_15 Месяц назад
@@gamesmiths P.S. Love your videos! Recently discovered your channel and I’m loving the theory crafting and discussion! 💜
@pizzashop314
@pizzashop314 Год назад
I have the map on a blanket... and the books but the blanket is the first thing I owned with it
@SPEEPSHighway
@SPEEPSHighway Год назад
8:42 Audio: Iwata Asks CC: a water ass
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
😂😂
@_shinyrinn
@_shinyrinn Год назад
what is the title of the music that begins at 26:20? I have been trying to find it for too long. what is the song title
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Bamboo Island - Skyward Sword
@_shinyrinn
@_shinyrinn Год назад
@@gamesmiths thank you so much omg it's been driving me up the wall for months
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
You are most welcome. It’s a tough one in that most collections or albums don’t feature it. If you search specifically though, there’s some nice renditions from the OST to individual takes with flair. Glad to help out
@maartenvandenberge7116
@maartenvandenberge7116 Год назад
totk was origionaly ment to be dlc to the botw game, until it grew out of proportion, so this would make a lot of sense as the final map design in the concept stage where the ganandorf fight was still meant as DLC as well as the sky islands and the pirate attacks
@sodajesus8128
@sodajesus8128 Год назад
I'm sitting here thinking while I listen, how did Pinnacle Rock that had been Northeast in Death Mountain ended up going Southwest as a border to the Gerudo Desert. Like the Goddess Statue from Skyward Sword, it should of been in Faron Wood's to the Southeast and then it is somehow Northwest hmm. So it'd make sense if there is a sword stool in Faron right? Sadly can't find one it's only if you go to Central Hyrule and go southwest to a set of ruins that is overran by water that had been said to originally hold the Master Sword before it had been moved to the Lost Woods as a stone slab tells you when you go underground.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Really good points all-round. Putting aside the mechanics aspect, the movement of the Pedastal is something covered with depth in Zelda Encyclopedia (pg 27). What's interesting is the location of the Pedastal of Time in Twilight Princess is in the "Sacred Grove", located SW and would be smack bang around the comparative Faron Region, give or take. Symbology reigns similar to the Temple of Time and Temple of Light, but is also home to the Dominion Rod. I'm interested in that whole scenario, particularly considering the pale blue/green aura of control placed on objects from the Dominion Rod and with technology similar to those closest to the Hylians of Ancient Times, when closest with the Divine. If you can get past the weirdness of the Ooca, the location rings much closer to where you are pointing, and makes me wonder about the changes in that locale over time. I've covered in the past the whole Rubber Helm and materials - the helm very much looking like a Jabu Jabu reference and considering the Zora's penchant for avoiding lightning, it looks like their creation. I hypothesised this as their location prior to moving to the current Zora's Domain circa 10,000 years ago based on the monuments around Zora's Domain. The build being a joined effort with the King of Hyrule and initial concept art shows similar caverns to the trailer with luminous stones about. If this version of Hyrule is an alternate of sorts, the pieces almost have a tracking that can be applied. Love your work here and has me thinking. More to consider for sure. Thanks for sharing the comment sodajesus - really enjoyed thinking about this, and will continue to ponder...🌟💚🤔
@sodajesus8128
@sodajesus8128 Год назад
@@gamesmiths It's one of those that when you start thinking of the landscape for BotW's and TotK's it doesn't quite match ya know? If it really is all timeline's put together then... Which Hyrule is it? Is it a much more built on land where it's just dozen's and dozen's of building's had been rebuilt multiple times or is it a certain Hyrule that had expanded more when considering each Hyrule is built different... It's like the Master Sword it's basically a blade that can purify evil and travel through time itself, just there is only ever one blade? I don't believe it to be that, in Skyward Sword the "Goddess Blade" becomes the Master Sword but loses it power in different timeline's. Sometimes you can slash and do a blade beam or it's just a hack and slash blade, did it become stretch thin that in each timeline it's power became so small that TotK's Ganon could destroy it? Like in Wind Waker when meeting Ganondorf it sounded like that Master Sword had been recreated as the other had been lost. Is it a copy that after tampering it became the real thing? Cause if it is all timelines together wouldn't there be several different places where the Master Sword had been placed and the Master Sword in each area? What if the real Master Sword is still buried deeply within the land where it had Originally been placed? Could there... Be more than one? Also the fact Fi talked to Zelda and never says a word to Link, cause they have to be Mentally linked right? It's only in BotW and TotK where we actually see the Master Sword glow to show Fi is talking. Could it also be that Skyward Sword Link is connected to Princess Zelda rather than other Link's or had it been the Triforce Fi sensed in Zelda and told her what to do to get the best chance. Hmm makes one wonder.
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
@@sodajesus8128 I think you are going to appreciate the new theory I’m finalising now. It doesn’t go full blown into where I think things are heading but it does an important thing in asking the same kind of questions you are with more evidence to suggest to me anyways that it’s not just coincidental. For what it’s worth- same page my friend. If you check out the realms diagram on p28 of Zelda Encyclopedia you’ll notice that it doesn’t make sense. The depiction of the realms is impossibly depicted on a 2d plane. But if you reconsider it adding a 3rd dimension (like a cube for example) you get closer. But 1 main issue remains - there are 2 Kingdoms of Hyrule on that diagram pointing to the same heavens. Easy to dismiss as post WW /PHANTOM /Spirit tracks except this diagram has no timelines…so consider it 4 dimensionally - and now it makes a lot more sense. I believe the answer is there but there’s much more to it. I’m trying to get these theories out to get up to speed where I want to discuss with others but it’s taking me ages. But I think I’ve got a Clanger or two yet to come that could suggest the Big N are holding back on longer term plans
@sodajesus8128
@sodajesus8128 Год назад
@@gamesmiths Hmm it does make you think a bit more when it had been explained more. Yes there is Old Hyrule we know from most of the series and then New Hyrule which came in the timeline of the Hero who isn't there, I always pondered how did Hyrule get flooded cause at some point there had been a Wind Waker as they mention time and time again when the Link of that era does finally appear, but who was before him? They mention it plenty of times, cause if the timelines Converge into one wouldn't it mean there is a Hyrule out there buried deep within the ocean or did the ocean get lowered at some point spreading all the land of Old Hyrule and somehow connected to New Hyrule and the folk's of that timeline either tore down the castle or maybe it got rebuilt within the center. Looking at the map it could be possible with how gigantic Hyrule kingdom is in BotW and TotK, maybe just maybe they went back to the original land, and the land you see due north could be another part since you really don't see anything south as a border (I could be wrong about it.) It's one of those great mysteries I mean think about it... Sure it could of been land shifting and volcano's erupting but there would be a castle in the depth's in ruins if that is the case. It's like thinking of where the Zonai came from did they evolve from the Skyloftian's or were they blessed by the Goddess regardless? I'm not 100% on it but imagine Link of the Skies building Hyrule with that Zelda, it'd mostly be the younger generation who could have been the one's to leave leaving the older generation up in the sky so instead of a whole new race suddenly popping up those who stayed may of gained more favor by the Goddess transforming them. What if the Aspect of the Hero's garb had been that Zonai? Link? Whoever he is being thrown into that timeline, they don't say he's Zonai or Hyrulian just the Hero who put the first Calamity down, unlike Rauru's and his sister's form it's different it looks more Wolf like as if Link from Twilight had been caught in a middle form a hybrid form.... Lol what if that Link is Twili and Hyrulian put together? Since the Triforce of Courage would of protected him from being changed so regardless of the realm the Child is from his form stayed the same. It's just a thought that maybe that Hero of Aspect is Midna's son since she has red hair, it'd be crazy if it was. As for the Map... I'm sure if certain plates shifted and Volcano's erupting underwater or on land had sat for a very long time, many island's could of been pushed together to form BotW's and TotK's land. Also makes me curious where the Master Sword had been during Rauru's and Sonia's time, has it been waiting for someone to pull it somewhere hidden or is it one of these "It wasn't there yet" situations.
@RowanSkie
@RowanSkie Месяц назад
Hi, a year late, but the chapter names seem to be broken? Chapter 1 has the "A Puzzling Mystery" chapter title and so forth.
@Mamma1999
@Mamma1999 Год назад
I have 999 bokoblin fangs, and 404 bokoblin guts
@Mamma1999
@Mamma1999 Год назад
Help
@SalamiSelimbo
@SalamiSelimbo Год назад
Really cool video, I like the hyrule map belonging to no game and all the understanding we can have of it, Id love a new game keeping the botw engine but changing the map before Aonuma decide to make new game graphics design, My dream is getting a reboot of Majora's mask but with a map the size of botw and more amazing sidequest and mask (rito mask and return of the deku scrubs) then I wouldn't complain if there is only 4 or 5 dungeons, Stone tower could have it's lore deepening with the other world and the moon could be bloody, anyway hoping next zelda won't take too long to come.
@bennydave4160
@bennydave4160 Год назад
How about a remake of alttp with assets from the depths used to create the dark world
@SalamiSelimbo
@SalamiSelimbo Год назад
@@bennydave4160 Would be awesome too ^^
@elloisefarrow7769
@elloisefarrow7769 Год назад
i have this map on a blanket that was bundled with an acrylic statue of the hylian shield lmao... just got it earlier this year from Walmart LOL
@gamesmiths
@gamesmiths Год назад
Thanks elloisefarrow7769 - another new one to me - bundled with the shield is wicked curious! This map gets around for sure, and btw - congrats on getting the shield - awesome stuff 💚🌟
Далее
ТИПИЧНОЕ ПОВЕДЕНИЕ МАМЫ
00:21
Просмотров 1,3 млн
10 Lore Secrets in Tears of the Kingdom
20:19
Просмотров 1 млн
Are There TWO Master Swords? (Zelda Theory)
13:36
Просмотров 1,1 млн
Where Do Hyrule's Rivers Go?
30:45
Просмотров 2,2 млн
How Tears of the Kingdom HACKS the Zelda Timeline
29:13
A Big Fat Review of Breath of the Wild
3:20:42
Просмотров 10 млн