The Infernal Veil: Lilith's Metamorphosis 

DOGMA WHAT COUNTRY IS ?

Hubo cambio de integrantes 🤫

Since 2022 they have changed 1 singer, 11 different guitarist 1 bass. The lineup has changed since 'father I Have Sinned' I don't want this lineup to change either. I think the nailed it and should stick with it. But also if one of the girls chooses to leave then we gotta deal with it. But hopefully not.

Glad to see I wasn't just going crazy lol Been thinking this for a while, especially after Father I Have Sinned. I feel like Lilith isn't the only one who has changed...

@@janabelle8456 Glad im not the only one noticing this. Yes maybe more, yet Lilith had the most obvious change or only. Tho I´d prefer her without the mask, but let´s see where this is going.

@@janabelle8456 from FIHS? the bassist is different, the guitar player is different, and no one cares about the drummer... although she plays like a demon in CL... now, I've been considering the possibility that Lilith has always been the same, it's just that she re-recorded the vocals on FIHS

Aww... If anyone knows the truth pls tell me! Who sang the My first peak ?? That singer is soooo cool! Where is she ? She is the original singer of Dogma ? And now who is the singer ? Idk o.o Thank you very much! 🤘🤘

@@belaradics6088 The singer has always been the same, not sure about the drummer, but the guitarist and the bassist changed in comparison to FIHS. It seems they are from Mexico.

With Ghost ? ...awww nah! Ghost is such a lame and booring band! Abs not similar to Dogma!

Nothing similar

​@@belaradics6088 they're obviously inspired by Ghost lol

The person is the same in Father I Have Sinned, My First Peak and Forbidden Zone. What they did was use her image (with different make-up, but if you look closely, it's the same as in Father I Have Sinned) and put in the voice of the actual singer, since she recorded the clips and then left the band, i.e. before releasing everything. My source is one of the producers of the clip.

​@@metalesvida666Do you have any information as to why the original singer left the band?

​@@metalesvida666So silly question, the vocals on the album are not the current singer?

​@@michaelbedsole970So the singer for the ,,father i have sinned" left the band?

@@alexandruacatrinei1032 From what I understand, the original singer left (don't know why) and that is why the vocals on the video for "Father I Have Sinned" are different from the single/album version. I've also heard that Lilith in the videos for "Forbidden Zone" and "My First Peak" is the same person as in the "Father I Have Sinned" video... that the new singer's vocals were substituted into those videos (accounting for the difference in vocals between the videos)... but I'm not sure about that. Apparently the two newest videos, "Carnal Liberation" and "Made Her Mine" feature the new Lilith. Not sure why she went with the mask concept. It's okay but I kind of preferred being able to see the singer's facial expressions.

I agree...im disapointed

changing members before the first album is not a good signal.. will they keep releasing only singles ?

Unfortunately yes, in early 2022 after they release 'Father I Have Sinned' and when they released 'My First Peak' the singer was different. The photos on the Spotify page and etc are from the first lineup. They didn't bother changing it. I don't think the girls have that much involvement with dogma, almost like employees. And that is not a good sign. But I would love to see this lineup continue cause they got potential to be huge.

Not a lot is known on this band, they are keeping it closed. Similar to ghost's musicians. They don't give names. Since the lineup has changed multiple times, we have not idea about this current lineup is. We know they don't originate from one country or if they worked with each other before... But it's intoxicating. & I do want more.

YES BUT DOGMA WHAT COUNTRY IS THE BAND ?

The voice in the album is from the new singer. She is Lilith in "Carnal Liberation" and "Mad her Mine". In the first three videoclips was the old singer. Sorry for my bad english :D

Me too. The mask is okay... but I hope it's a limited, artistically experimental thing. The make-up style is quite sufficient and allows for Lilith to add so much personality with her facial expressions.

Agree. She's so fun in Father I have Sinned, but the I'm not a fan of the expressionless mask in I made her mine.

The very first vocalist was named Isa Rhody. Since the change nobody except the inner circle knows the now lilith name.

Mira, yo también lo veo plausible

From what I understand and have heard others say, Lilith in the past three videos has been the same person... but the singer changed after the first video and the new vocalist's voice was added to the videos "Forbidden Zone" and "My First Peak". That is supposedly why the vocals sound different than on the video for "Father I Have Sinned". Maybe "Carnal Liberation" is the first video in which the new singer appears in person... but this is just stuff that I've heard on social media. Don't know if it's true or not.

Exactly! I've heard that too. And even the reasons why she, the first drummer and guitarist left the band.

@@metalesvida666 I haven't heard anything about the reasons. What happened?

Yeah the make up change looked better in first vid. New guitarist always look like she's in pain doing solos. Original guitarist was tiny and cute.

Just IMHO, Lilith in FHIS looks and sounds different than in "My First Peak" and "Forbidden Zone." She sounds the same in "Carnal Liberation" as in "MFP" and "FZ," but absolutely the person in the vid is different. @@michaelbedsole970

Sí, y aparte de que utilizaron su imagen, sólo que con diferente maquillaje, en los vídeos de My First Peak y Forbidden Zone, y pusieron otra voz, puesto que ella ya había abandonado la banda cuando los publicaron.

😂😂😂 ¿De verdad no lo veías venir? Al instante de ver los video, que priorizan mas el aspecto erótico que musical, con malas actuaciones y vestuarios provocadores, como dando la sensación que vas a ver una porno ¿No notaste que algo no cuadraba?

Same, makes me feel like it won't last.

Colombia

​@@MetalProfessor65don't think all of them for this lineup now? Aren't Lilith & Rasalka American? But I have not met them. You have. What is your theory?

@@helheimforge I'm confident that Lilith is American. Rusalka's accent sounded American to me, but I'm less certain. The other musicians didn't say enough for me to get as good a read on their accents, but I'd go with Latin American for (alphabetically because I don't want to seem like I'm "ranking") Abrahel, Lamia, and Nixe. Thanks for watching and joining the conversation! 🤘

@@MetalProfessor65 how much time did you spend talking to them?

@@helheimforge I honestly don't recall because I was in such a daze, but I'd guess 10 minutes.

Lilith paints her face for the concerts, I think the mask is a symbol type of thing.

You know this is fake right? This was like a movie backstory for a fictional character.

Not a new singer. Just a mask. They’re telling a story

Is it? They’re still showing the original photos from when the band first started. Can’t be someone new or they wouldn’t be able to use the original stuff. Couldn’t use someone’s likeness or voice without their permission.

@@jesterboykins2899 I think you're wrong, it's stupid but as beautiful as the nose of the first singer is, under no circumstances will it fit into this disgusting and narrow mask...and her voice isnt the same

@@fredericcarriere7657you’re right, the 4 initial members are no longer part of the band, they changed the 4 members from FIHS video

@@josedavidvf07 sad...

Creo que nos pasó lo mismo 🤣🤣🤣 Se tratará de una nueva cantante? La bajista la cambiaron

Yo creo que este es el inicio de lilith, esto es antes de father i have sinned, creo que aquí ella inició el dogma y las otras tres ya estaban dentro, y si son diferentes cantantes creo que ella es la de father i have sinned, tiene el mismo timbre de voz.

Es una explicación del inicio de lilith y su liberación carnal

@@rhellion66 lilith sigue siendo lilith pero mutando jajajja, en cuanto a Nixe yo creo que es la misma 🙃...

@@florenciacordobez1302 Nixe no es la misma, yo sé por qué lo digo 😉

La etimología judía, Satanás hace referencia a una persona traidora, embustera, por eso en el infierno de Dante, esos condenados están en el último círculo y Yahve fue el ángel que ayudo a la creación de la humanidad, por eso su nombre escrito en hebreo representa masculino y femenino cuando se separa, haciendo alusion al principio que lo puede crear todo.