The Kulture Study: ASTRO MOONBIN&SANHA 'Madness' MV REACTION & REVIEW 

I'm glad Sanha will get to do his concept now, but I'm also sad. I LOVE the dark and sexy concept, both music-wise and visual-wise, and these two pull it off so well. I never paid much attention to Sanha until Bad Idea came out. I was just thinking, "Has he always been this attractive and sexy?" He suprised me with how well this type of concept suits him. He really shines. Of course he can pull off other concepts, and I'm sure whatever song they release next will be great, but I'm really going to miss this concept from them.

i feel like Moonbin is probably a better creative director than Sanha and I'm a little worried about what it'll be like if they go down Sanha's preferences

@@igniculusquartz1827 why don’t you just see, if anything the sub-unit has given us the opportunity to see them both in different light. Hey I’m sure no one thought Sanha can match and keep up with Bin’s stage presence but here we are getting 2 incredible performers working in synergy. So you never know. Just like Bin got the opportunity to try first and got better, same will be his case. He just needs to try, plus it’ll be good to diverse the concepts. Sanha is Sanha, Bin is Bin so the concepts will be different for sure

@@theunbiasedone i mean sure but he could also flop, like you said you never know. also i think moonbins concepts have really cultivated this cool dark theme and sanha seems to prefer more acoustic and soft kinds of things and i don't think that would make a good title track. it could go either way like you said i don't know but i'm just saying what i'm thinking

@@igniculusquartz1827 You seem to think Bin is a better creative director than Sanha when the latter hasn’t even tried yet. Let me ask you a question, Astro main sound was soft/bright etc but they did they flop when they switched suddenly released “All yours” with the title “One”? I mean that was different from Astro’s cultivated soft/bright theme. So again one doesn’t know if a soft acoustic music might perform or not on the first try, it might not be to your preference/taste which is fine. As I said before, diversity is good or the unit sound might soon feel stale for some. Plus I’m not sure Sh would go the acoustic route for the unit, that will be reserved for solo work. However Bin has expressed desire no pun intended to sing a Sanha ballad kind of sound one day even with the entire grp. It’s within your right to think/worry but considering this isn’t the first time I’m replying to you about your Bin/Sanha thoughts it’s really hard not to also think within my rights as well that you’re just against one of them. You know Bin also said he wanted a different concept which wasn’t dark can’t remember the interview tho so let’s just see again. Just as the rap part wasn’t “giving” to you but some also liked it, it might just be the same case.

❤

❤

I feel every word you said. I actually feel so regretful I came too late.

I hope you are feeling better lately. I just want to say we did deserve his beautiful soul and he was very deeply loved. Moonbin most likely suffered from Major Depressive Disorder, which is usually genetically inherited. This cannot end well without proper treatment and psychological therapy. I’m sure he knew how much he was loved and I can assure you he loved us back just as much. Hugs to you

I hope you're doing ok

ngl i wasn't a fan of the rap part. what i liked about the subunit was that despite both being men they didn't have a rap part which is really refreshing in boy groups since they usually alwayssss have rap and this kinda hampers my opinion of the song a bit. also, i know it's kinda pointless to critique english lyrics in kpop but i just cannot get over the "i'm giving" part at the end of the rap verse because it's such a funny line that it actually distracts me

me too 😁

yup, sanha wrecked me HARD this comeback. even the other members say he's like a sponge so he's got the best of *all* worlds thanks to his hyungs

SANHA has always been my son-shine. He has grown up so much from when l first got introduced to ASTRO in 2017. I still want to see more of them as l, too am OT6.

This is somehow the first members-centered praise of Sanha I’ve seen that actually does praise SanHa if you get me. Most of the time it’s just brag and share him among the members and that’s that nothing about his individuality/ as tho Mj, Rocky, Bin, JinJin, Nunu opened him up and placed those traits there without his own raw talent/skills/hard work. So thank you❤💫

14:18 exactly, it's such an iconic move

Sanha is so underated it hurts (⁠ノ⁠ಥ⁠,⁠_⁠｣⁠ಥ⁠)⁠ノ⁠彡⁠┻⁠━⁠┻

I'm back again and still love the way you noticing their detail, thank you, xx

😢