Тёмный

The Mangulam Inscriptions 

Storytrails
Подписаться 58 тыс.
Просмотров 44 тыс.
50% 1

The village of Mangulam near #Madurai is home to an ancient set of inscriptions that couldn’t be deciphered until the early 1900s. What story can these inscriptions tell about the evolution of scripts in India?
Transportation partner - www.savaari.com/
To experience more such stories of India, visit storytrails.in/
Become a Storytrails member:
www.youtube.co...
Storytrails is an award-winning organisation that showcases India through her stories, through story-based walking tours, audio tours, local experiences, videos, blogs, podcasts and online learning programmes.
Follow our work on social media: @storytrails
LinkedIn: / mycompany
#Brahmi #TamilBrahmi #Ashokapillar #Madurai #Mangulam #Indianlanguages #Tamil #TamilNadutourism #TamilNadutravel #Indianscripts #Jainism
Image Attributions -
Ashokan pillar - By ampersandyslexia - originally posted to Flickr as India, Day 15, CC BY-SA 2.0, commons.wikime...
Mangulam inscription - By Sodabottle - Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0, commons.wikime...

Опубликовано:

 

20 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 313   
@mrbiscuits915
@mrbiscuits915 Год назад
There is an account of a Maori tribe in new Zealand that cooked stew in a Tamil bell. According to the people of that tribe it was found under the roots of a huge old tree, so it had been there undiscovered for a long time. Tamil must be well travelled in the past 😊. It's on Wikipedia, there are even drawings of it. Apparently it was a ships bell. India has an amazing ancient history ❤
@Nt-nc9ps
@Nt-nc9ps Год назад
It is believed Newzealand was once connected to Tamilnadu and part of lost Tamil Kingdom called Kumari Kandam.
@drodro7672
@drodro7672 6 месяцев назад
Yes, but the Tamil inscription in the bell is written in Grantha or more latter scripts used for Tamil, not in Tamil Brahmi. So that bell is more probably a medieval era artefact.
@X-jn87ybt
@X-jn87ybt 4 месяца назад
​@@Nt-nc9ps Or tamils are travellors
@antiwokehuman
@antiwokehuman 3 месяца назад
@@Nt-nc9pspseudoscience alert😂
@ShizukanimeShorts
@ShizukanimeShorts 3 месяца назад
@@antiwokehuman "believed"
@sundars8638
@sundars8638 Год назад
Great, Thanks for sharing! Recently I visited the Yanaimalai samnar jain rock carvings of 9th century and the Keezhakuyilkudi Samanar jain hills rock carvings of 1st century(both in the vicinity of Mangulam)and were amazed to see the old scripts and precise carvings. These sites near Madurai brings us valuable historic facts and civilisation this area bears.
@xavier9476
@xavier9476 5 месяцев назад
Tamizhi is older than brahmi script....this is the solid evidence, as per the science.💯😍
@anograham9827
@anograham9827 2 месяца назад
Yes britishers kept the name brahmi. But now since we have evidence the name should be changed to Tamizhi.
@Hitmansharma_pullshot
@Hitmansharma_pullshot 25 дней назад
Rigveda written in Brahmi has been dated back to 20th century BCE as it mentions the river Saraswati which dried up in 1500 BCE therefore *Brahmi still stays older than Tamil Brahmi.*
@NaliniS-y2v
@NaliniS-y2v 25 дней назад
​@@Hitmansharma_pullshot why are you mixing myths with history 😂
@Hitmansharma_pullshot
@Hitmansharma_pullshot 24 дня назад
@@NaliniS-y2v *Rigveda* is a not a myth but an evident document found in 11th century Gupta rule; it was dated by scientists to be from 1500 BCE but more research revealed it's even older.
@Hitmansharma_pullshot
@Hitmansharma_pullshot 24 дня назад
@@NaliniS-y2v bunked history classes?
@ThunderFire03
@ThunderFire03 8 месяцев назад
Tamil brahmi is mentioned as damili in jain text Older jain saint used this language for writing epics and religion text in southern part About more than 95% of tamil brahmi inscription found in jain caves( in Tamil nadu, Kerala, and Karnataka, Andra Pradesh) That's why Jainism is referred as the original dravidan religion
@MSdfangirl
@MSdfangirl 8 месяцев назад
We called it thamili with a same pronounciation I don't know where the name brami came
@ThiruMSwamy
@ThiruMSwamy 7 месяцев назад
​@@MSdfangirlMay be, the Aryan migrants incert the word for all aboriginal languages of Indian States
@drodro7672
@drodro7672 6 месяцев назад
It was originally a script known as Brahmi before discovering its variant for Tamil language. That's why there is this appellation of "Tamil Brahmi". Why Tamilians are to such extant brainwashed with gross and academically uncompatible theories of Dravidianism or Tamil supremacism ?
@Agnostic7773
@Agnostic7773 4 месяца назад
Dinosaurs also Dravidans
@Dreamer-i1z
@Dreamer-i1z 3 месяца назад
​@@ThiruMSwamy😂 aryan migrants Bro it's not proven yet
@rappuritappuri7082
@rappuritappuri7082 11 месяцев назад
The time when this inscription created sangam period. Chief poet of nedunchezian king was mangudi maruthanar. தலையாலங்கானத்துப் போர் was happened at that time. Tamil literacy was at peak at this time.
@munmunsarkar1726
@munmunsarkar1726 4 месяца назад
I am from west Bengal. I believe in whole heart that brahmi evolved from Tamil brahmi which has further evolved from Indus script. Some north Indians mainly from Bihar and up who are mainly illetrate about history thinks everything came from sanskrit. And some illetrate tamilians think everything came from Tamil. Both are wrong. Both belong to different language families. But I firmly believe Tamil is the first written language of india followed by pali and sanskrit.
@munmunsarkar1726
@munmunsarkar1726 3 месяца назад
@@Dreamer-i1z sanskrit and tamil belong to two different language family. How can they came from same language? Have I said Pali is older than Tamil or sanskrit. I said inscriptions of ashokan brahmi. Tamil inscriptions seeming to be older than ashokan brahmi as well from keezhadi. But in north oldest sanskrit inscription is newer than Pali. But Vedic sanskrit did exist before pali as an oral language.
@munmunsarkar1726
@munmunsarkar1726 3 месяца назад
@@Dreamer-i1z I said Pali and sanskrit didn't said Pali then sanskrit. Both these languages were spoken at some point on vedic culture. Tamil is completely different but both influenced each other.
@dreamsofadaffodil650
@dreamsofadaffodil650 3 месяца назад
The amount of destruction the northerner endured at the hands of the invaders leaves no place for speculation about what existed at one point of time, which could not survive the ravages to finally discovered by us today.
@ramananb
@ramananb 2 месяца назад
yes it's proved after Kezladi excavation, both Indus and kezladi script's are 80% the same
@anograham9827
@anograham9827 2 месяца назад
YES, and there are talks to change the name from Brahmi to Tamili. since they are the ones who founded and used the script first and probably taught the mauryans how to use it.
@dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569
@dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569 Год назад
Adbhut ❤
@VimalKumar-ms4tm
@VimalKumar-ms4tm 2 месяца назад
I am Telugu boy but I agree Tamil is oldest language in world, I am proud our has India as oldest tamil language in India.
@asura2000
@asura2000 2 месяца назад
😅 rey sanskrit oldest language
@speakandthink4601
@speakandthink4601 2 месяца назад
​@@asura2000 Hey do u know Thamizh history Thamizh cultural
@asura2000
@asura2000 2 месяца назад
@@speakandthink4601 yeah they're tribe's present tamil people not original tamils they mixed with andhra in pallava rule, originally tamils r black with high teeths so don't claim ur self as tamil
@asura2000
@asura2000 2 месяца назад
@@speakandthink4601 yeah tamils r from kumari kandam present Tamilnadu belongs to andhra, tamil is one of the oldest language we found that's it, in future we will find telugu Or sanskrit
@Hitmansharma_pullshot
@Hitmansharma_pullshot Месяц назад
​@@asura2000 Either Sanskrit or Tamil will be one because Kumari Kundum is a hypothesis and Saraswati river mentioned in Rigveda flowed 10,000 years ago
@lakshmikaandhangovindarajulu
Amazing!!!
@debabratamajumder2640
@debabratamajumder2640 9 месяцев назад
Excellent!
@scouterstu5856
@scouterstu5856 Год назад
I used a mediation cave in Sri Lanka with similiar letters scratched into the rock ceiling. Neither the locals or the forest monks knew the origin or what the script represented. I took a picture ofbthe cave ceiling and I think you have found the language it was written in. I shall send your video to friendsvin a nearby village who first showed the ancient "writing"
@amodmishra3030
@amodmishra3030 Год назад
This is a big news. Call archeological survey authority of your government.
@ChannaJayawardhana-h1o
@ChannaJayawardhana-h1o Год назад
Those kinds of scripts are allover sri lanka.. most of them beign early sinhalese.. the pakrit elu or ashoka brahmi.. there are no dravidian inscriptions like that in sri lanka..
@kalpadesilva438
@kalpadesilva438 11 месяцев назад
there are more than 70000 ancient inscriptions in Sri lankan not a new thing.. Lord Buddha also born in Sri Lanka.. British ruined our whole history.. there is no brahmi text or such thing. magadhi language.. spread from the sri lanka.. we have so many ancient palm manuscripts.. ahh so many Rawan's inscriptions also found...
@mrjokeyvolg524
@mrjokeyvolg524 10 месяцев назад
Sinhala brahmi with Sinhala parkit
@scouterstu5856
@scouterstu5856 10 месяцев назад
@@kalpadesilva438 I think if you check you will find the Buddha was born in India. BtW, I know Sri Lanka very well and you blaming the Brits for the economic and environmental disaster the Sri LanKan people have created since Independence is total nonsence. The Singapore President visiting Lanka shortly after independence expressed his wish the Brits had left Singapore in such good financial health, infrastructure etc and hoped his country could become as prosperous and administratively stable Sri Lanka. The Singapore people did prosper and created a magnificent nation state. Sri Lanka did the exact opposite, taking a magnicent country and turned it Into an environmental and economic disastor. We can blame the Brits and their bloody Empire for a lot but the horrible mess the people of Sri Lanka have created for themselves is solely of their own making.
@venkatbabu2071
@venkatbabu2071 Год назад
Awesome, best wishes
@SaravananSaravanan-ox8br
@SaravananSaravanan-ox8br 4 месяца назад
Super super 👍👍
@spkutty
@spkutty 8 месяцев назад
For strange reasons, this site is not an ASI site, but is protected by State Department
@anaesthete5592
@anaesthete5592 4 месяца назад
Why's that
@G..V
@G..V 4 месяца назад
​@@anaesthete5592Coz CG don't want Tamil to prove it's evidence
@agentK1896
@agentK1896 3 месяца назад
​@anaesthete5592 because that would give supprtt to the theory that there was more than one dominant civilisation in India. They decided that everything came from sanskrit. If you close your mind you'll look for no further evidence. Why does ASI not dedicate more resources to keeladi?
@Artic_Asteroid
@Artic_Asteroid 2 месяца назад
​@@agentK1896Because they are simply scared
@Artic_Asteroid
@Artic_Asteroid 3 месяца назад
Thanks for the info❤❤❤
@Ramu_ab
@Ramu_ab День назад
You're writing is good
@ThunderFire03
@ThunderFire03 Год назад
😢 once whole South india follow Jainism till 7-10th century Then everything get changed Very few tamil jain are surviving there in South india in very extreme poverty condition Jainam Jaytu Shashanam
@soulful2665
@soulful2665 Год назад
True, once Jain's was at it peak in whole india Jainism is older than anything
@Agnostic7773
@Agnostic7773 Год назад
Without warrior class Religion cant sustain Both Buddhism and Jainsism against to warrior class
@soulful2665
@soulful2665 Год назад
@@Agnostic7773 the concept of king is originated in Jainism
@esotericwanderer6473
@esotericwanderer6473 Год назад
@@Agnostic7773 do you know, who were jain kings??, no right!!!! Then dont write non-sense, Pandya, hoysala, chedi, ganga, amoghavarsha, mahameghavahaa kharavela, samprati and many more were born jains Even chandragupta later became jain Do you even know how powerful they were😂😂 Ahimsa is the main principle of jain dharm but is only limited to jain munis, Jain shravaks like me only follow vegetarianism, like others we can also blow anyone who troubles is (virodhi hinsa) is also main principle of jain dharm
@Agnostic7773
@Agnostic7773 Год назад
@@esotericwanderer6473 Dont confuse Jains rejected varna system or not ?
@rvee_filmophile
@rvee_filmophile Месяц назад
Tamizhi documentary series is there in youtube, which explores Why Tamizhi is different from others and how Tamizhi evolved into modern Tamizh. It is featured by the Archaeological department officers.
@rajanaravind2069
@rajanaravind2069 4 месяца назад
Good work and great effort 🎉
@eliotanderson6554
@eliotanderson6554 Год назад
@kalairubinvenkat8333
@kalairubinvenkat8333 3 месяца назад
Good to hear. Don't call it Tamil brahmi. It's Tamizhi. Brahmi got it's name after Ashoka who is said to have created the script, Yet tamizhi has presence as early as 7th century bc, But brahmi came out around at 3rd century bc. Thankyou!
@shivasubramanian1959
@shivasubramanian1959 4 месяца назад
People have a misconception regarding Shramana/Samanam, they think samanam is jainism its not. Samanam also included Ajivikas, Budhhism, Charvakas, Jainism & Kabalism. The monks name carved in the rocks Kani-Nanthaasiriyan-Iyakkan was not a jain monk, he was from Ajivikas/Aaseevakam
@tamiltsairam2191
@tamiltsairam2191 2 месяца назад
South India Sri Lanka full Tamilnadu 💪🎏🐯🏹🦁🚩🚩🙏🙏🙏
@ŇØ_ØŇĚ-lu6mi
@ŇØ_ØŇĚ-lu6mi 3 месяца назад
Pandian king pride 🫅
@HariKrishna-lo4xi
@HariKrishna-lo4xi 3 месяца назад
There were 8 ancient languages in India. Historicans did research on 2-3 languages according to their scripts and period.
@ariyanghadei6462
@ariyanghadei6462 2 месяца назад
This proof to our puranas which say india is populated from South
@iamthefutureofindia
@iamthefutureofindia 3 месяца назад
Bramins Are Comes From North Side India Then They Settled In Tamil Nadu , Native Tamil Bramins Are Nott There
@suriyakumarp
@suriyakumarp Год назад
Ashoka's script should be termed as Dhamma Lipi as it been referred to in the past than 'brahmi' the term coined much lately!
@aniruddhbahuguna5462
@aniruddhbahuguna5462 Год назад
Brahmi term available much earlier in dhamlipi. Buddu
@suriyakumarp
@suriyakumarp Год назад
@@aniruddhbahuguna5462 so what's the time period for the "brahmi"s presence as first, before Ashoka's script or after?
@aniruddhbahuguna5462
@aniruddhbahuguna5462 Год назад
@@suriyakumarp Hold it book and read it According to a popular Jain legend, Rishabhanatha is believed to have taught eighteen writing scripts to Brahmi, one of which came to be known as the Brahmi script.
@suriyakumarp
@suriyakumarp Год назад
@@aniruddhbahuguna5462 that's a new information for me. Thanks for the same. As per recent research, Ashoka's script was termed as Dhamma Lipi rather than the Brahmi.
@aniruddhbahuguna5462
@aniruddhbahuguna5462 Год назад
@@suriyakumarp No dude Radhakumud Mukherjee first pointed word Dhamalipi and he even justified why It should it call brahmi.
@Gimma-z3v
@Gimma-z3v 3 месяца назад
I don't understand why they say Tamil Brahmi. Why do you mix Brahmi with Tamil language which runs alone.
@karthiksubramanianlakshmi
@karthiksubramanianlakshmi Месяц назад
SAMANA SAMAYAM( Jainism Religion), there is a belief that gaja Lakshmi goddess, ( goddess Lakshmi with elephant symbol on either side ) was inherited from old jainism.
@Gowrisankar__gs
@Gowrisankar__gs 2 месяца назад
தமிழ்
@chalapathinaidu7934
@chalapathinaidu7934 2 месяца назад
Great Tamil is oldest language of world
@Shubh_jain3124
@Shubh_jain3124 Год назад
Jain religion is supreme❤️💪jai mahaveer swami
@rohannova8268
@rohannova8268 Год назад
Superior is not your religion but the most civilized Tamil rulers who were so broad minded to welcome and provide shelter to Aryan Jain monks...
@Shubh_jain3124
@Shubh_jain3124 Год назад
@@rohannova8268 they are itself jain so they have to example hoysala dynasty ganga dynasty and even some rulers of cholas and pandyas even workship jain gods so pls there is no sense pf your comment 🙏
@Melody--uc2ce
@Melody--uc2ce Год назад
Every indian religion is supreme Respect every religion. Not only own religion
@esotericwanderer6473
@esotericwanderer6473 Год назад
@@rohannova8268 lol, there were many original jain kings like:- pandya, chedi, ganda, hoysala, mahamegavahana kharavela, samprati mourya and later maurya dynasty. jain dharm is thousands of years older than brahmanism
@rohannova8268
@rohannova8268 Год назад
@@esotericwanderer6473 Pandya seriously, I'm from a Pandya clan man, I'm not a Jain, how shamelessly you can say that Pandya kingdom is part of Jain, Pandyas are Shatriyas not a lower caste as Jain you are Vaishyas, understand that.
@jaganneethi6551
@jaganneethi6551 2 месяца назад
According to magulam it was miisunderstood as tamil brahmi deerived from brahhmi but according to keezhadi & theni nadukkal inscriptions were totally different from brahmi.and so it was mentioned as "tamizhi" which was unique on its origin.
@vaishnavmorye5789
@vaishnavmorye5789 Год назад
What if the script is a version of greek as a lot of greek travelers used to come to india Same are seen in karla caves and elephanta in mumbai
@anograham9827
@anograham9827 2 месяца назад
both tamilnad and kerala was called tamilakam and spoke the same language. which explains why the tamizhi script is used to write tamil. they are the ones who found it and taught the mauryans.
@elangiyanjb5203
@elangiyanjb5203 2 месяца назад
It's not Tamil Brahmi ,it's Tamizhi
@Sudhirkumar-xv8cy
@Sudhirkumar-xv8cy 5 месяцев назад
If it is in devnagari lipi we ask to nepali ..Nepali is written in the Devanagari script, which is similar to Hindi. It is the official language of Nepal and the mother tongue of over half of the population. Nepali is also spoken in India, Bhutan, and parts of Burma.
@Sudhirkumar-xv8cy
@Sudhirkumar-xv8cy 5 месяцев назад
Other languages are also in Nepal
@anaesthete5592
@anaesthete5592 4 месяца назад
​@@Sudhirkumar-xv8cy even Latin is from Nepali
@gangadharhiremath7306
@gangadharhiremath7306 11 месяцев назад
Can someone tell us the basic difference btn Tamil Brahmi and Asokan Brahmi?
@YoutubeBank-bp5js
@YoutubeBank-bp5js 9 месяцев назад
see let me explain u in detail brahmi ,usually they refer is the asokan brahmi and there is a script which different in grammar and syllabel but somewhat similar to brahmi ,and more close to cureent tamil interms of grammar,syllabus,structure,writing so they called it as tamil brahmi before once believed brahmi is older than tamil brahmi.. but now... many proofs had given tamil brahmi is older than brahmi..from which brahmi is evolved eg: only ka in tamil no extra syllabel from ka ... for our convience can ka,kha,ga ,gha.. we use this sound but had no letter for this.. so... from ka.. ka kha ga gha letters evolved so conclusion tamil brahmi is older than brahmi from tamilbrahmi is current version is tamil brahmi or asokan brahmi current version is prakrit by mix of tamil brahmi and asokan brahmi evolved southern brahmi(which pallavas improved it) so southern brahmi now become telugu and kannanda.. by mix of percentage of words from tamil brahmi... is current tamil and malayalam.. at some point malayalam mixed with sanskrit thats it tamil brahmi(old tamil) brahmi,asokan brahmi prakrit dont ask about sanskrit pls... because sanskrit is of hotha script which is of modern day iran and syria in india ,the oldest sanskrit script we have is of 100 AD not older than that...
@gangadharhiremath7306
@gangadharhiremath7306 9 месяцев назад
@@RU-vidBank-bp5js Thank you.But what is the connection btn Grammer and a script? A script should be capable of bringing the sounds and speech forms specific to that language in to writing. (Tamil script is OK for Tamil but becomes inadequate to write sanskrit)
@YoutubeBank-bp5js
@YoutubeBank-bp5js 9 месяцев назад
@@gangadharhiremath7306 Grammar and script is evidence to proof,that this script belongs to that particular language For example Language have some characteristic feature Like In sanskrit and indo european language ,words usually use prefix words and not suffix words Similary some other group of language use infix words Tamil and dravidian language use suffix words Tamil brahmi uses suffix words If it is non known..indian aracheo some group claimed it as north indian family of languages like pali.. After find outing this difference only we came to know this is tamil Or else... They will disguise it as pali.. Important to note. Whenever ,for tamil ,we have to show proper proof,evidence to claim that it is ours.. Even for that ,they wont accept the fact But on other hand..sanskrit and other north langugae.. Without any evidence they claim it as theirs.. But govt accepts these.. and printing in ncert book This is somewhat... Blind games or cheat play played towards tamil language from the period of post british era... But how hard they try... Truth speaks with hard core facts.. Example For tamil to claim oldest language we need to show proof..even after proof they wont accept But for sanskrit to be old.. no proof Oldest sanskrit manuscript is about 100 AD... Not more than that.. And they usually claim 1500bc which is not in current sanskrit script..rather in hotha script which is syria,syriac origin(iran)etc.. And.. horse mentioned in rigveda hymns ,those burials are found in syria.. If sanskrit is 1500 bc old,then accept sanskrit is from out of india( non indian) Or if sanskrit is indian( then it is only 100 AD only) They some group will Come nd bark..before that we used oral language.. Then we can also claim we also used oral langugae + At the time of sanskrit is in oral format Tamil is in its grammatical peak in written format How script is connected with grammar. Now lets talk about it In jain caves tamil brahmi is wriiten along with prakrit For example- writing RAM( in tamil) by grammar we write it as (iiram) According to tamil grammar Words in tamil wont start with ra but always start with iiraa.. I think u got the point.. Similarly.. Another tamil brahmi script which we got that is older than asokan brahmi script Uses the word aaa-gol This word is not even used in sangam literature also.. It is pure form of tamil word Mentioned in tamil grammar book (tholkaapiyam) So we easilg found that this tamil brahmi,we found is tamil) And it is pure non mix tamil Written by pot makers at that time Where people around tamilakam dont have any script for their languages
@Dreamer-i1z
@Dreamer-i1z 3 месяца назад
​@@RU-vidBank-bp5js noy agree The words of ancient sanskrit can be found in iranian texts which is 800 year older than the evidences of tamil script
@ChannaJayawardhana-h1o
@ChannaJayawardhana-h1o 3 месяца назад
​@@Dreamer-i1z and it is 100% possible brahmi script is from aramaic which is a foreign script.. so no this is not a tamil born script but a borrowed one which evolvetp become the modern tamil script.. same with devanagari and most of the indic scripts..
@vickymech6414
@vickymech6414 3 месяца назад
Why put name from discover first
@eswarapandi9358
@eswarapandi9358 Месяц назад
This is not tamil brahmi is just tamili
@Legendudaa
@Legendudaa 4 месяца назад
brami is nothing it mean nothing just thamizhi or thamizh
@NileshKumar-nr2vj
@NileshKumar-nr2vj 10 месяцев назад
There isn't anywhere mention of any script called Brahmi. These were brahmins thi se were asked by foreign archeologists and they said this is Brahmi script. But the word Dhamma script is mentioned 36 times, popular during Buddha period..
@MSdfangirl
@MSdfangirl 8 месяцев назад
Dhammili pi we called it tamili. some one create name brami for it for changing history😕
@anograham9827
@anograham9827 2 месяца назад
britishers kept this name when they found ashoka's inscription. but recent evidence has shows that tamil is written way before in this script and they have called it thamizhi.
@TheKakamuka
@TheKakamuka Год назад
Arrumai
@stormshadow5283
@stormshadow5283 11 месяцев назад
Fascinating how far Vedic rishis travelled South!
@anograham9827
@anograham9827 2 месяца назад
Hi. This was written by tamils. And they called the script as tamizhi. They are the ones who taught mauryans how to write.
@isaipithanrapz2882
@isaipithanrapz2882 День назад
No Vedic it's Jain saints
@investmentmentortamil
@investmentmentortamil Год назад
Ofcourse it's older than brahmi Scientist proved Tamil is the oldest language in the world
@BlackSakura33
@BlackSakura33 Год назад
Lol
@amodmishra3030
@amodmishra3030 Год назад
Why do you people have so much ego?
@investmentmentortamil
@investmentmentortamil Год назад
@@amodmishra3030 it's not ego It's truth Speaking truth is very important to spread knowledge
@amodmishra3030
@amodmishra3030 Год назад
@@investmentmentortamil Do you know where homo spaiens originated? Modern humans arose around 3 lakh years ago. Look, I agree that Tamil is a beautiful language and one of the oldest language in the world but you can't name it as oldest ever! Anyways, proof of oldest written language is of Sumerian language. Let's wait for more excavation for Tamil to dethrone that. Bro, there is a difference between spoken and written language.
@petergreg352
@petergreg352 11 месяцев назад
@investmentmentortamil Indha bandha dhaan namla alikutha podhu Tamil pazhamaiyana mozhi dhaan But adhoda 33 older languages iruku first being sumerian and egyptian. Example ku indha tamil brahmi 300 bce, egypt la first pyramid 2480 bce la build pannanga
@anirudh2704
@anirudh2704 10 месяцев назад
U can clearly see the transition from vertical brahmi writing to horizontal tamil brahmi writing. How the "क" all changed to tamil ka
@anograham9827
@anograham9827 2 месяца назад
bro the ashoka inscription is way after this. so that's not possible.
@Gowrisankar__gs
@Gowrisankar__gs 24 дня назад
Bro you dropped this 🧠
@anirudh2704
@anirudh2704 23 дня назад
@anograham9827 no one agrees this are origin of Tamil scripts.
@isaipithanrapz2882
@isaipithanrapz2882 День назад
And you people want to note one thing very clearly ... Ashoka script used for kings and statement of government only but in tamil nadu everyone wrote tamili ( tamil letters ) in there home meterials ... Tamil is oldest spoken language and oldest written language ... And all over south east asian languages from tamil only
@shivendrapratapmandavi8998
@shivendrapratapmandavi8998 Месяц назад
I think tamil and pali prakarit are older than sanskrit
@okay9906
@okay9906 7 месяцев назад
*Tamizhi @ Tamili, not Tamil brahmi.* Please don't fool the world with you crooked history.
@mukundhsmart3615
@mukundhsmart3615 4 дня назад
not jains it's samanas both are different
@aathawan450
@aathawan450 2 месяца назад
It's not thamil pirami. It is Nagari. The oldest people now called tamil are not tamil. They are nagas. Lord shiwa muruga karuppasamy - Krishna are nagas saints.. The first cultural creaters of the world. Human relationship mother father ungle anty etc. and transformed hunting to farming.
@prajwalkannadiga8737
@prajwalkannadiga8737 2 месяца назад
Lol😂😂😂 Father of all indian scripts are Ashoka. Because of him only we can all write our scripts in brahmi.
@lkunitypictures6085
@lkunitypictures6085 Год назад
Why they add brahmi?? Just old tamil is better
@sohamshinde7978
@sohamshinde7978 Год назад
coz its a variant of brahmi .
@chithambararajanr219
@chithambararajanr219 Год назад
​@@sohamshinde7978 you are wrong. Actually in 18th and 19th century they thought it was a variant of ashoka's bhrami but later in 20 and 21th century they found graffiti in keezhadi and palani with old tamil script and this concluded that tamil script tamizhi is older than ashoka's because their was no evidence found in north india how that perfect script was evolved but in south india particularly in madurai their are alot of pot with graffiti, caves script etc to show the evidence for the evolving for a complete script.
@sohamshinde7978
@sohamshinde7978 Год назад
@@chithambararajanr219 the keeladi one which is dated to 6th century bce hasnt been proved by evidence . No detail of its strata is given so this remains a question . For grafitti i would say harappan people came from Indus valley to south india . If keeladi dating proof is given then it could be 6th century bce .
@chithambararajanr219
@chithambararajanr219 Год назад
@@sohamshinde7978 lol, Keezhadi excavation remains were carbon dated at beta analytic center USA. Don't spread fails statement you pro-ariyan outfit buddy.
@pussybell2883
@pussybell2883 Год назад
MUST GIVE SPACE TO BARBARIANS OUR OWN HALF BASTARDS WON,T LET,LIVE TO SEE IT..UNFORTUNATELY IT,S A MONEY EARNER..IF NOT ALL WILL BE IN RUMBLES LIKE LORD RAM IN AYOTAYA..
@Gowrisankar__gs
@Gowrisankar__gs 2 месяца назад
Its Tamili, Damili not Brahmi😂
@sarathdassanaike2807
@sarathdassanaike2807 Год назад
Supreme Buddha preached his Dhamma in Magada Language and Pali Sanskrit 2570 Yr ago Emperor Asoka the greatest introduced Buddha Dahamma to Sri Lanka It's part of writing history of Sri Lanka
@Agnostic7773
@Agnostic7773 Год назад
Jains brought new script for Tamil
@xavier9476
@xavier9476 5 месяцев назад
Tamil had a own script before Jainism came into being...thats called #Thamizhi
@Agnostic7773
@Agnostic7773 5 месяцев назад
@@xavier9476 Tamil grammar writer was Jain .. Jain gave script to Tamils
@xavier9476
@xavier9476 4 месяца назад
@@Agnostic7773 Which script was given by the Jains? because Tamil language has so many scripts system. Thamizhi script Thamil brahmi Vattezhutthu Pallava script Grandha Kolezhuththu Modern tamil....
@Agnostic7773
@Agnostic7773 4 месяца назад
@@xavier9476 When you created this Dhamizhi or Thamizhi script ? Sounds like Ashokan Dhammi script !! Tamil Brahmi script introduced by Jain saints Even Tamil Grammar created by Jain saint Thiruvallavar A language only need one script to get progress and to wide spread knowledge Why you have different scripts with only minimal knowledge that too only useless poems and songs Not anything on science !!
@xavier9476
@xavier9476 4 месяца назад
@@Agnostic7773 One point is correct thiruvalluvar is jain monk... but how did you know thiruvalluvar 😱
@thevip-unemployed3010
@thevip-unemployed3010 3 дня назад
Not Tamil Brahmi. Its TAMIZHI
@FriendForever86
@FriendForever86 4 месяца назад
Jainism is the oldest religion
@shrinivasnimbalagundi1770
@shrinivasnimbalagundi1770 3 месяца назад
Tamil is oldest rest of the country people were like bla bla bla ... 😂😂😂😂 Any logic in this at all?..
@SMCGPRA
@SMCGPRA Год назад
If Tamil brahmi is older than brahmi then what is the origin of Tamil Brahmi as for brahmi most scholars agree Aramaic as origin
@ChannaJayawardhana-h1o
@ChannaJayawardhana-h1o 3 месяца назад
Exactly..
@rallyworld3417
@rallyworld3417 Год назад
Impossible 250 bc is not old enought to draw conclusions that Tamil brahmi is older
@sohamshinde7978
@sohamshinde7978 Год назад
no one is claiming that.
@rallyworld3417
@rallyworld3417 Год назад
@@sohamshinde7978 yes he is in the video
@sohamshinde7978
@sohamshinde7978 Год назад
@@rallyworld3417 oh yeah he first said variant of tamil brahmi and then says it maybe older than ashokan brahmi , contradicted his own statement .
@chithambararajanr219
@chithambararajanr219 Год назад
Nope, in 18th and 19th century they thought that it was a variant of ashoka bhrami but later they found it is older than ashoka's because in madurai and surrounding you can find the earlier structure of scripts like graffiti in pots, caves etc which were belongs to 6BC to 9th 9BC.
@pussybell2883
@pussybell2883 Год назад
TAMILLI..WHAT,S THAT BRAMAY..?
@narenselva4538
@narenselva4538 Год назад
It's not jainism! It's different and called samanam! Also asivakam
@sohamshinde7978
@sohamshinde7978 Год назад
no
@Wackadoodle
@Wackadoodle Год назад
Samanam is a tamil word of Jainism 😅
@sohamshinde7978
@sohamshinde7978 Год назад
@@Wackadoodle but you said it was not jainism but rather it is samanam so thatswhy i said no .
@Wackadoodle
@Wackadoodle Год назад
@@sohamshinde7978 sorry my reply was for Naren Selva who initiated this conversation.
@narenselva4538
@narenselva4538 Год назад
@@Wackadoodle nope. It's a completely different religion. Even I thought the same
@tamilarasan6567
@tamilarasan6567 2 месяца назад
Its not brami word ,it should be called s tamili word change it or delete the video
@YoutubeBank-bp5js
@YoutubeBank-bp5js 9 месяцев назад
yes it is true ,tamil brahmi is older than brahmi proof Evolution of letters theory + u showed the inscription of jain caves even that contains mix of prakrit but another inscription found in pulimakombai.. which follows exact grammar of current tamil(thokaapiyam) which pure tamil brahmi without any mix of language which older than the brahmi
@aniruddhbahuguna5462
@aniruddhbahuguna5462 Год назад
It is brahmi pat
@exmuslimhumaid786
@exmuslimhumaid786 Год назад
Wrong information... It is pali Or prakriti language..
@kalpadesilva438
@kalpadesilva438 11 месяцев назад
lol there is no language named pali.. english people made this language.. only magadhi language..
@exmuslimhumaid786
@exmuslimhumaid786 11 месяцев назад
@@kalpadesilva438 pali & prakritik language... Check ancient history book... Ncert Rs sharma book will be good ... I dont trust RU-vidr for information...i always relay on books.. I think u should check once then comment here... More specifically check for jain and buddist text ...
@vat513
@vat513 6 месяцев назад
Tamil is also spoken by Ancient North Indians, your ancestors spoke Tamil. Sadly today you people speak Hindi.
@Dreamer-i1z
@Dreamer-i1z 3 месяца назад
​@@vat513that was not tamil That was mother of tamil and sankrit
@Dreamer-i1z
@Dreamer-i1z 3 месяца назад
​@@exmuslimhumaid786wait,did u write RS sharma and ncert Lmao 😂 We can not debate with legends like u
@multiversescriptutes8400
@multiversescriptutes8400 6 месяцев назад
Vedic Sanskrit is the oldest language. NOT Tamizh. So cope.
@southtechie
@southtechie 5 месяцев назад
Vedic sanskrit is derived from other languages.
@southtechie
@southtechie 3 месяца назад
@@Dreamer-i1z Sanskrit means refined one. Refined from what? Obviously it is an artificial language developed from other languages.
@user-dostiBaniRaheBus
@user-dostiBaniRaheBus 8 месяцев назад
learn Hindi
@vat513
@vat513 6 месяцев назад
What's the use of learning a dirty language like Hindi?
@kumaran907
@kumaran907 4 месяца назад
No learning that over cooked language
@rockythebranDon
@rockythebranDon 3 месяца назад
Learn Tamil
@VandeBarath
@VandeBarath 4 месяца назад
Bullshit
@Thatchur.Devanesan
@Thatchur.Devanesan 2 месяца назад
Never Jain but Samana = Aseevagam. It is a Tamil Religion.
@daviddenson599
@daviddenson599 Месяц назад
Its not Brahmi, it is thamili.
Далее
The story of the lost ancient fabric
8:37
Просмотров 593 тыс.
What’s your height?🩷🙀💚
00:59
Просмотров 3,1 млн
1 Subscriber = 1 Penny
00:17
Просмотров 46 млн
The Most Underrated Ancient Projectile
14:49
Просмотров 772 тыс.
Similarities Between Sanskrit and Lithuanian
22:01
Просмотров 1,9 млн
What date is it, really? The Hindu Calendar
9:46
Просмотров 145 тыс.
Viral Video of a Man's Crazy Job Interview
16:02
Просмотров 1,4 млн
The Baghdad Battery? Archaeologist Reacts!
33:03
Просмотров 197 тыс.
Secrets of a Medieval Castle | Chepstow Castle
31:45
Просмотров 3,7 млн
What’s your height?🩷🙀💚
00:59
Просмотров 3,1 млн