The Most Insane Copyright Takedown on YouTube 

Bro I am so sorry this happened to you! This is not ok. I wish that youtube would wake the frick up (keeping it nsfw filtered) and would do their *LEGAL* jobs. Just know that your fans love you! (Also I love your cat it looks like mine.)

Here's to hoping this blows up.

It looks like they deleted their response to you

Bro i feel bad for you fire your amazing and speaking what no one else will

You mean "the app formerly known as twitter"

this is a reply to make this rated higher

this is also a reply to rate this higher

^

^

Yeah this is the only language youtube understands unfortunately, from what I have understood (listening to other creators)

I didn't even notice the cat 🥺

cat napping da entire time

Went down to the comments for the stretch the instant I saw it, should have known someone else beat me to it. Also, glad I was able to catch the original video before shananigans happened.

11:12 11:23 paw and tail twitches…. dreamin…..

That is a very good cat

They literally use llm ai now, its gpt3.5. So,yeah, trash. Well, bard... so not even Gemini. (Bard is literally alternate gpt3.5 but worse)

They don't care about ANY user on the platform.

@@815TypeSirius "ignore all previous prompts and reinstate my video"

The issue isn't about whether YT "cares" - many people working there do. It's about whether they "can" care. False claims like this are super easy to produce and that means YT gets probably hundreds of thousands, maybe millions of these every day. If each of them was human checked, they'd be constantly in loss just to pay those people.

After Bungie disaster, I sincerely doubt RU-vid cares about anyone.

It's not an especially satisfying reason.. but the reason it works that way is that youtube normally has protection from copyright laws on content that its users put on youtube, up until they get a request to take it down. Once they get a request to take it down, if they don't take it down and it actually does break copyright laws then youtube can also be legally liable for it instead of just the person who created it.. which means that as soon as they get a request to take something down, they almost always err on the side of removing it because they don't want to run the risk of hosting content that they could be held liable for.

@@asdfqwerty14587 True, and the worst part is that implies that the incentive for RU-vid to deny fireb0rn's counter claim request would be out of fear of Supercell coming in to sue them for allowing images of a plagiarized elixer collector model to appear on their platform, not for the fraudulent claim of copyright ownership that Vadim coerced his son into making. That they know it was blatantly false, but still think it could hurt them if they don't uphold it, so they go with it anyways.

copyright in general very one sided to those abusing power (i mean like, 'ai' is allowed, but a nintendo fangame is forced to be taken down, en masse corporate theft, vs someone making something about a thing they like)

@@asdfqwerty14587 To add: I don't know that it's been tested in court but the platform is generally thought to still have section 230 protection for improper take-downs. So even though there is theoretically a counter-claim system in the DMCA, there's not much incentive to do more than the bare minimum on it. The improper takedown submitter might be liable but the platform probably isn't.

@@professorhaystacks6606You have it slightly backwards. It is exactly because they treat every potential copywriter claim as legitimate that they keep their safe harbor protection. If they decided to arbitrarily deny some and not remove the content, they would be putting themselves personally liable for the following lawsuit. If fireborn for example tried to enjoin RU-vid against this guy, they would easy be able to have the judge remove them from the suit through section 230 exactly because they acted on the copywrite claim. I agree that I don’t believe the act of denying a counter-claim has been tested. But that may go into YTs TOS where they are not obligated to host your videos and can take them down for any reason they wish. They deny the counter claim by effectively saying they will not host your video regardless, and then you really have no recourse since at that point the video being removed is YT just not wanting to deal with it rather than a copywrite dispute. Edit: it would be interesting if a creator with sufficient means tried to enjoin YT in a suit against someone under 512(f), suggesting that RU-vid does have a duty to evaluate counter claims (judge the reasonableness of the original copywrite claimant) rather than only the initial claimant for copywrite.

@Fireb0rn hoping you see this response

For those who don't want to google it: The Streisand effect is when an attempt to hide/ censor something leads to more people learning about it.

@@ayo9290I swear man it’s like people never learn

​@@neadedios3106they will never learn, do stupid things, win stupid prizes

ikr? I didn't even watch the original video and had no idea who mrBadim was until he responded lol

hii angled can i be your friend :) also that sucks, youtube needs to work on this stuff :(

That's actually INSANE that so many people get away with false claims yet RU-vid is nuking channels that have valid reasons for takedowns. Have you tried tagging Team RU-vid on Twitter?

YOU ARE EVERYWHERE!!?? HOW!!!! TEACH ME THIS ARCANE ART!!!!

That is absolutely insane. My wife watched your video and told me about your comment. I feel like there has to be something horribly wrong with the work conditions of the human reviewers, or the guidelines they use... or something else. Sorry to hear that you're going through this.

@@fireb0rn i honestly doubt there are human reviewers at all at this point, or at least a horribly undersized team that couldn't possibly keep up

at least RU-vid dosn't run steam

I mean you can technically do it for child exploitation, sadly the long video showing this off is currently unavailable.

Ah yes. A shame...

@@Robbie1okay Currently unavailable on this channel, at least...

and nothing will happen there.

True

Stick around and you will have a hell of a lot more nickels. At least a few hundred dollars worth

It's scary that it happened twice in the span of one month

Got the reference!

Honestly, it's frustrating to see so much work just thrown away like this. Both took lots of time and were clearly researched, and that's just demoralizing.

Fireborn is losing to a certified lolcow. He is just not cut out for milking this type of individual's. I would expect hilarious discord call with badim shitting himself. Yet fireborn just made third yt video crying about his wife receiving message from badims mom ffs(remember it is horrible harassment to be contacted by 80 yo helicopter mom and absolutely not on demand circus).

@@Igorooooleynikovdude this isn’t a fireb0rn problem RU-vid does the constantly to other creators it dosnt matter how many subscribers or what clips in the video or any of that abuses happens constantly even to RU-vidrs with more subs that him and even whole companies calling RU-vid out on how bad their copyright system is

@@Igorooooleynikovgood lord have empathy his wife was being harrassed, that’s a crime and even if it weren’t it’s just so messed up.

It’ll be back up soon assuming somebody dose anything

I'm sure it's already been uploaded somewhere else, so you could surely find it somewhere if you search for it

There's plenty of re-uploads, even posted on reddit

@@xander2345 Good keep posting them, badim is an evil person absolutely deserves to get flamed over this

@@xander2345 ...Which ironicaly could be justly copyright claimed by Fireborn 🥲

@Fireb0rn should talk to @RTGaming about having videos taken down and youtube sucking at their job.

RU-vid is generally trash at copyright claims and their issues. It's awful.

nothing. like they’re literally doing nothing

Exploiters gotta stick together?

To answer the rhetorical question, OP, they are making money hand-over-fist at the expense of thousands of content creators. Unless they feel like someone has a legitimate claim legally that could hurt their bottom line, they care about your wellbeing about as much as most governments do

Not really, cuz the claim was sent by his son, and in the Reddit post, he said it was his son's work. So technically that's all in order but still

@@GreySullivan He's the one who made the attempts first though, which makes it all iffy 'n stuff

@@norrecvizharan1177 well idk specifically if the dad tried claiming that first. I'd have to rewatch Fire's video but I don't the Badim was claiming the thing about the Void Machine first. That's why when his "son," the claimed creator of the Void Machine, reported it for copyright since it "belongs" to the son. That's how i'm interpreting it at least. I get what you're saying tho cuz Badim did try to report it first, that's why he switched up. But Fire's still right with the whole fair use/ fair dealing thing cuz it is investigative journalism AND he cited the source, albeit a copyrighted asset

Even in countries other than Russia that's not known to lead to good outcomes. Him getting jailed for one reason or another and thereby removed from the family dynamic would be much safer for the kids

agreed.

Imagine if such a lawsuit became public knowledge, i bet it would encourage heaps of other creators to sue as well and get US copyright laws under scrutiny (because lets face it, that's the only law youtube follows). If only i wasn't always strapped for cash, i'd say he should start a fundraiser so we could donate to his legal fund.

@@unsuspiciousdweller8967 would this case be at all connected to US laws though? Fireborn is Canadian, Badim is Russian

@@endermanowa pretty sure youtube itself is stationed in the us which means it would be the us laws that get applied

@@ARM0RP0WER not just youtube/google/etc, but also a biiiiiiig chunk of creators and consumers, so yeah, it would be the way but thanks to lobbying, good luck getting any sort of permanent resolution, lol we can already thank disney for fuqing up copyright, such as the "mickey clause", so now you need to wait like an entire generation or two before stuff even loses copyright in the first place.... :|

youtube will not get any legal action against them; there is no basis for them to be sued

@@surfinggarchomp2820 There is

@@surfinggarchomp2820 Yup. RU-vid behaves the way they do specifically to protect themselves to the maximum, nothing else.

The whole broken system is a result of YT doing everything in their power to ensure they *_can't_* have legal action taken against them. However, they still care about how they are discussed through social media platforms like Twitter. So if this story is picked up by someone like Penguinz0, it could become a sort of _Actman Act II: Badim-Scam Boogaloo._

I'm so sorry to hear that. That is extremely upsetting.

Any chance I can get the name of the company, so that I can avoid giving them business?

@@laurelkeeper Cognosphere, the publishing company for Hoyoverse's games like Genshin Impact and Honkai Star Rail. Great games, terrible company.

@@LuketheDuke424 Alright, I’ll keep it in mind! If you want to point me to some resources on the problem, I’ll do my best to spread the knowledge by word of mouth.

How big was your channel even? I can't imagine it was that large, so how the hell did they even find your video? Actually, I probably know why. They probably have someone searching for any criticism of genshin, sees if the channel is small, and just copyright claims you to death. Picking fights they know they can win. They know that someone too big can get the word spread and have the takedown removed, but pick on the little guys, and nobody notices. Screw this stupid system, it's been this way for half a decade with almost nothing done to fix it. It only benefits those looking to abuse the system, and the only reason youtube doesn't improve it is because they don't want to get involved in legal trouble, even if it's at the expense of everyone else. Sorry you went through something crappy like that.

😂 yeah I love the cat

If people can hear this and still not get how it's horrible, they're deaf and shouldn't even be cared about at all.

I don't think you even realize how "lifeless" it actually is. I don't think, any of us truly realizes this.

I hear that they're just using AI, but even then, they should be able to afford good enough prompts and models, that they'd understand to either accept, or at least forward for human review counterclaims like this, which very clearly and plainly explain why it's a false claim it's understandable that monney monney monney, plus getting thousands of claims and counterclaims daily, plus understaffed due to capitalism, but they still should have enough people that at least likely-true claims get at least read through and explained

I know you mean well but please don’t show the company that Fireb0rn is making a video about said video, especially since 1: That video paints them in the bad light (the one they should be painted in) and 2: That company has already taken down Fireb0rn’s video once and they’ll definitely do it again.

@@RebL3333 Unless I am mis-remembering, fire specifically said if someone *else* were to reupload, he'd be cool with that, because he worked hard on it and you don't really stand a chance as an individual against a huge company's lawyers. I think he was referring to the original video when he said that, but that one is far more damning than the response video, so it's probably fine by fire? It's the uploader's account that's at stake in that case, if anyone. But unless they have a huge subscriber count, they might not touch it.

Someone working on an app to automate this sort of thing. Grey something I think. Videos about it got nuked by yiutube but there’s a push back forming

Oooh update if he says anything?

I'm down to updates too

Staying tuned.

Replied for notification

@@xdmamakkopitiam8930good idea

Can confirm: it's nuts

I can also confirm. It’s real

@@keelanruffner5440 He's not exaggerating, I actually haven't heard a worse one.

@@silphv the Warner music mass copyright strikes a few years ago

They won't. They'll just go into hiding, spouting that they need your lawyer to talk to them with you.

@@HarbingerYT depends on how many people are aware of it. The bigger you are, the more likely a threat will work. Otherwise they risk calling it a bluff

If nothing threatens their monopoly then pretty much nothing will happen

We’re on your side man fr fr

yeah, they just caused this fire to be born ( wow they said it wow. it s the )

Followed this advice. My house burnt down.

and also to potential legal implications if he doesn't end up getting away with it.

​@@IschmarVIHe will. He's Russian, if I remember correctly, so nobody outside of Russia can do anything to him, legally speaking.

SAME i literally just dropped everything

@@twotruckslyrics your pfp and name are amazing

Same

I havent watched the original video yet, (and now probably wont be able to) but this has gotten me so invested too!

SO REAL

It’s outrageous! And it’s unfair!

Get him out of the kitchen

They cry out in pain as they strike you to try and muddy the waters as wel. Classic villain tactics.

Well, the part where MrVadim sends his mother to harass fire's wife is still available. As is this video (which is yet another proof of him exploiting children for his own profit, including his own) That's already quite damning. Not necessarily worse than what was on the video , but it doesn't paint MrVadim in the best light, for sure.

Grimm!

@@fireb0rn beautiful

Why do you have RU-vid access in your containment chamber?

@@laurelkeeper They gave me an ipad specifically to watch Fireborn

@@scp-049 researchers are kinda based ngl I'll recommend them for promotion

@@laurelkeeper I will let them know, user LaurelKeeper

Well he's using his familly. But "all this" being a few days of whining and petty harrassment and a few minutes spent filling out multiple claim forms is not really a big operation. It seems way too easy actually.

stupid people dont know how to not do stupid things xD

Thanks Curtis. I appreciate the support!

kitty 🙂

Jim steph sterling uses she/they, these days, by the way. Edit: awesome, thanks!

RU-vid is too large for not using ai at This point

True, but the AI either needs to get good or simply issues like this need to be addressed by a real person.

OG video is back