The Nightmares of Minecraft Horror 

Dev of A Craft Of Mine here! I do admit the game can be pretty goofy at times xdd, good thing about it is the story allows me to virtually add whatever I want. Infact A Craft Of Mine was initially an idea for a mod, but then made it a game to experiment with horror enemies which are more focused on a "minigame each" so I could maybe add that to my other game After The Curtain Call. However I may extend the game sometime if I'm bored or something idk As a spanish minecraft fan, I do know Killercreeper and being mentioned in a video where he is mentioned to has to be one of the highlights of my life xd, I loved his videos explaining how to do map stuff. That's all from me. Anyone check out my other horror games if you want to, many of them are of better quality than ACOM. Thanks a lot for mentioning my game ToadBup! I actually also watched a while ago the Mario games video and wondered if you were gonna make a Minecraft one :)

As a modded Minecraft player, I can confirm the scariest part is installing the version appropriate 'Too Many Items'.

14:10 AS THE MEXICAN I AM FORCED TO EXPLAIN THIS THIS IS THE "CHIPOTE CHIYON" THE SOUND IS NOT FROM CARTOONS BUT IT COMES FROM A TV SHOW CALLED "EL CHAPULIN COLORADO" AND IT IS ABSOLUTE PEAK, THE SOUND IT PLAYS IS THE SOUND EFFECT THEY USED IN THAT SHOW (AND OTHER SHOWS BY THE SAME CREATOR) EVERY TIME SOMEONE GOT HIT WITH ANYTHING, AND I MEAN ANYTHING FROM A PUNCH TO A BASEBALL BAT OR THIS WEAPON, IT WAS THIS SOUND ALWAYS. I SWEAR I HAD THIS VIDEO IN THE BACKGROUND AND THE WHIPLASH I GOT FROM THE SOUND BEING FROM THERE IS... FUCKING AWESOME, LITERALLY MEXICAN NOSTALGIA

"From The Fog" got me back into playing Minecraft on PC again, hands down my favorite mod.

The Squeaky Mallet did that hit noise because it's a reference to El Chapulin Colorado from Chespirito, the same person who made El Chavo del 8. His signature hammer was called "El Chipote Chillón" (the squeaky mallet) and in both El Chavo and his series everytime someone got hit by anything, that was the sound that played :)

A really good Herobrine mod to try is From The Fog. It adds effects that are very accurate to the original posts. Its for forge and fabric and even comes in datapack form if you dont want to use a loader for it.

I still remember the fact that, when I was younger, my mom and I gaslit my sister into thinking Herobrine was in our world. I'd wait for her to leave the game and go to her room and I'd edit the world with some stereotypical Herobrine stuff, you know, a summoner, stripped trees, lava pools, the works. My mom never said a word about what I did, so she really helped sell the illusion. God, I'm still proud of myself for that.

Minecraft's atmosphere is honestly so good for horror; I had always been focused on Herobrine-related Minecraft horror content, so this nice look at other fun maps and mods is awesome. :)

You forgot the S+ tier horror mod: Lycanite's Mobs. Remember all the terrifying creatures in RLCraft that were one of the main reasons people were scared to play? That was lycanite's mobs, a modpack that adds plenty of high-poly monsters with varying levels of scary to them as well as a plethora of new tool parts used in a unique crafting station to make some really interesting pieces of gear. Love the mod, can't believe you skipped it.

blood man had me dying with how you just took apart all the bodies and took blood man's head as a trophy

In terms of minecraft "horror" mods, you should check scape n run parasites and from the fog. Two of my favourite horror mods which can make game at least a little bit creepy

INSTEAD OF THINKING OF HEROBRINE WHEN HEARING SQUIDDO WHAT

"besides being ambushed by a gaggle of herobrines in a cave my holy water did do the trick in that instance" is my new favourite quote ever.

Every single video toadbup makes on a horror game just makes the horror game or subject so mucu more funny and non-scary than its supposed to be.

I love how the first think you do when attacked by a monster is skin it alive and steal it's identity.

16:18 actually theres an entirely different genre for these "modified cursed minecraft clients", most of them are modified versions of minecraft alpha

14:06 - 14:12 So, fun fact! The Squeaky Mallet might be a reference to the sitcom El Chapulín Colorado, with the main character named El Chapulín Colorado, created and starring the famous Mexican comedian: Roberto Gómez Bolaños, A.k.a Chespirito, who passed away at the age 85 years old, in November 28, 2014 (God bless his soul). He was famous in Mexico and Brazil, with many of his shows and characters, the most famous of them being El Chapulín Colorado, and the great and funny, El Chavo del Ocho. The Bell-like noise is because whenever someone was hit by whatever (like someone being slapped, or punched, or hit the Chipote Chillón [Which the Squeaky Mallet is a reference of]) that bell-like sound rang, as Comic Relief.

If you’re gonna do a part two, you should include a map called scary blocks lab. It has a lot of good story building and it is a horror map, but it’s one of the tamer ones. Also, it includes actual gameplay instead of just being relied on horror elements.

So something i've noticed about indie horror games from new creators are that they don't quite get how to do backtracking. A lot of the time, it feels like it's just there to extend the game's run time. Something you should always strive to do is make areas you have to backtrack to feel different in some way. For example, a hallway that was once safe now has some kind of entitly starting back at you from the end of the hall. Sure, there might be something new behind a locked door that can be opened, but that doesn't mean that the trek to the locked door has to be empty. Switch it up a bit! add a new complication that wasn't there before

Aw come on man. There are plenty of scary mods! Cave Dweller, Scape and Run Parasites, From the Fog, From Another World. They are all fun and spooky.

I really miss this old modded horror server called TerrorCraft. It was so good, and it shut down and I don’t know what happened:/ it’s on technic launcher but the server doesn’t work

I rememberd watching these horror maps especially with herobrine and thinking he was gonna poses me and or kill me.

The random fires in the caves of Alpha were amusing, especially when no sources were around to cause the fire.

There are horror mods, but most are underrated. Alas.

one interesting horror mod is from the fog it attempts to recreate the erie feeling of being watched

A Craft Of Mine is basically (good) mascot horror elements with Minecraft textures, it looks really neat

If you want a more subtle version of Error 422 but equally terrifying, check out the mod From The Fog. Honestly the only mod or anything Minecraft related that was able to creep me out

Finally some good horror games, like "The Blood Man" still waiting on that sequel.

Thank you again for showing me joy, Toadbup.

From the fog by Calving is one of the best horror modded series ive seen

Im sure at least someone has mentioned it, but if youre looking fir a truly EXCELLENT horror mod, you should check out 'From the Fog' Its yet another Herobrine focused mod but its imo one of the better ones made, perhaps even the best!

great video toadbup!!

all hail chain chomp

19:57 it’s never a good sign when a character calls them self a god

Want pretty ultimate and realistic to story Herobrine experience? “From the fog” is the far best choice.

Man, the moment you mentioned adventure maps, my mind immediately went to the Slenderman Mansion map(s? Can'R remember if there were more than one). I spent so much time as a kid watching my favorite youtubers play through it... In hindsight having Slenderman just be an Enderman with a different texture pack was slightly silly, but I was like 9 so that shit was terrifying to me lmao

I can relate to Thomas, as having a cult *revolving* around doors myself. I understand it's hard to *handle* that kind of business and I respect this guy

I love playing Minecraft horror maps. Some of them feel like whole brand new games.

Oh let’s go I love surprises - famous last words 1:11

This video autoplayed when I was working on stuff in the background. I was wondering why Wendigoon was talking about Minecraft.

Killercreeper55 being mentioned took me off guard, I absolutely loved watching his videos and people playing his maps when I was younger

Great video finally a new video Minecraft horror mods are terrified

Beware is an awesome Polish horror map with FULL VOICE ACTING that you should really check out! There’s an official English version which is translated pretty well, although the voice acting is significantly worse (due to the creators’ nationality). The first part is pretty basic, but Beware 2 Enchanted Edition is one of the best!

Err422 has a fin concept, but executed too...bluntly? Like sure downloading it you already know its gonna be a horror game, but imagine the first few days in the game or hours of playtime are normal. Then it adds subtle things, moving inventory slots or forcing you to drop an item, randomly opening/cloaing doors (somewhat like Into the Fog) and the longer you play the worse it gets. Slow burn, imho, works better then upfront 'horror'

Dude, Killercreeper55 was one of the reasons i bought Minecraft, so happy to see him mentioned

"click this lever for a surprise?" "Oh boy I love surprises!!" *Proceeds to get sent to Hell by elder Guardians*

then he turned himself into a crafting table! funniest thing I've ever seen

I downloaded the herobrine mod as a kid and it left me horrified to the point that I only played on my Wii for months out of fear, but now I’m not super scared of him but the idea of a mysterious entity existing in your game and stalking you in the shadows is a bit unsettling.

0:35 Great, now i feel old. 13 years ago

wtf the editing on this is so cool ahaha. you're so underrated man :)

Creepypasta Minecraft!!! Creepypasta Minecraft!!! 😂😂😂 I recommend "That Thing" the noise it makes is bone chilling

6:14 Blindfool wouldnt be even worse when you cant see and you hear a loud jumpscare

When I saw the DHMIS tv shirt I was really excited. Such a great series, I didn’t know you also enjoyed it!

The squeaky hammer's sound effect appears in Latin America's tv show "el chavo del ocho" whenever someone got hit by a punch or something

The 1st one really needs a sequel

Man, I’ll always remember how weird it was to hear my name in the first horror map. I had the same name as one of the kids

herobrine being so popular is funny if you know the old original story where its revealed he's notch's dead brother

there is a crazy horror map called "grief", dantdm played it before. true childhood :)

rip lumps 😭😭😭

14:07 WAS THAT A CHAPULIN COLORADO REFERENCE!?

The scariest part about Back to School is going back to school.

Minecraft horror maps are very nostalgic for me

the Herobrine mod is so nostalgic to me, i remember seeing a brazilian youtuber named "Venom Extreme" playing it and couldnt make it into the end

I love your channel so much. The ending was seriously funny

I’m surprised that you didn’t cover the cave dweller or the night dweller

17:12 i guess Steve is a “no brainer”

I am surprised there wasn't a mention of the cave Dweller or from the fog, or the now upgraded version of the cave dweller who is Uncanny, spoopy ang gives the poopy.

Try Horrorcraft Reimagined Nightmares, it's scarier then hell

Combine “from the fog”, “weeping angels” and get some resource packs that make the game feel creepy to make a scary experience. Especially when playing in VR

7:20 is that Rihanna?? LMFAOO

16:38 THANK YOU FOR THE WARNING!!

My favorite Minecraft horror map will always be The Orphanage

0:30 just gonna leave a mark for a meme I saw cuz whynot

Toadbup is basically GrayStillPlays but for horror content

my fav map was the orphanage one it scared the hell outta me when i was younger

I need to know where that clip of the kid flicking the lever is from it's too damn funny

To this day my favorite Minecraft horror map has got to be “The Orphanage” it’s just so good and probably a little less confusing than other maps

Hey, I don't know if you'll check this video again, but if you see this comment I just want to let you know about PSX Minecraft. It's a similar idea to the corrupted minecraft version, but one that - and as a ToadBup fan I know you're perceptive so you may have spotted this - imagines Minecraft as an OG Playstation game, some kind of "lost prototype" type beat. It seems up your alley, and I think it would make for a cool video!

If you really want to reach peak SEO-uhh I mean peak horror minecraft, it'd probably be a good idea to make a video on the "dweller" craze spawned by Gargin's Cave Dweller mod

"not to many horror mods" that aged like milk....

The true horrors of minecraft are the mobs votes

The jump scare in Bloodmen looks like they took a picture of a K-Pop singer and edited it in photoshop

try "From The Fog", it's THE BEST Herobrine mod.

I’d love to see you review some minecraft horror arg’s/analog horror! I know there’s some on youtube

Does anyone else remember staying up late watching youtubers do a playthrough of the Orphanage horror map on their ipod touch? Just me? Ok

THE CAVE MONSTERS, BUP! *THEY MAKE THE NOISES*

nobody tell him about From the Fog he'll shit his pants

the school one just got me remembering the doll house one

14:10 the hammer is actually from el chapulin colorado

5:55 isn’t that a picture of Rihanna but made all demonic? *LMAO*

Was the jumpscare for bloodman just Halle Bailey?

Clay soldiers, my childhood

honestly surprised the parasite mod is not mentioned anywhere in this video. If you ever make a follow up please include it

I'm surprised you didn't cover the classics like The Orphanage and Saint Judes (junes?) Hospital (asylum? i forget its name)

The scariest minecraft mod was made horror on accident, BREG

heroin minecraft is too scary to exist

You feel old?, I was there when the arcade business was just starting, I was there when et the extraterrestrial for the 2600 was released

Minecraft and horror xan go together really well...espi3cally the herobrine mod recently

The scariest thing in minecraft, is what The 'Monster School' series turned into.

bro forgot the cave dweller, from the fog, night dweller and scape and run parasites mods, all of wich are pant shittingly scary