Тёмный

The Origin of the Israel/Palestine Conflict (Simplified) - Part 2 

Things I Care About
Подписаться 57 тыс.
Просмотров 107 тыс.
50% 1

Compare news coverage. Spot media bias. Avoid algorithms. Try Ground News
today and get 40% off the unlimited access Vantage subscription at ground.news/th...
Watch part 1 here: • The Origin of the Isra...
This video is the story of the origin of the conflict between Israel and Palestine that we see to this day. We cannot understand the war between Israel and Palestine, nor how Hamas came to be, without understanding the origin of Israel itself.
We will discuss Plan Dalet, Operation Nachschon, and how it lead to the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians, often referred to as "Nakba", in 1948 and 1948. This is crucial to understand the ongoing conflict in Gaza today!
Join our community!
/ discord
Animation by Nick Heumann (me) & Cameron Clack
Noticed that the animation quality has gone up significantly? You can thank my new Animation Director Cam for that!
If you enjoy our content, consider:
Following Nick (me) on :
/ ticanick
nickheumanns
Instagram: nicolasheumann
/ thingsicareabout
Make sure to follow Cam on twitter:x.com/Cam_Clack
Or on his RU-vid page: @Cam_AJR
This is his linkedin: / cameron-clack-881a461a8
These are some of my most used sources, and recommended readings:
Ilan Pappe - The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine
Rashid Khalidi - The Hundred Years War on Palestine
Benny Morris - The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited
Sami Adwan, Dan Bar-On, Eyal Naveh - Side by Side, Parallel Histories of Israel-Palestine
Nur Masalha - Expulsion of the Palestinians, The Concept of "Transfer" in Zionist Political Thought,
1882-1948
Thank you to my RU-vid Members:
501st CloneBoi
Leo'Pard
Slugbaby
Theo Ludwig
And Patreons:
Jeremy Cherian
Ben Drucker
David
JT96
SeanArki
LukB94
Songs used: (In order of appearance)
Kevin McLeod:
Lord of the Land
Americana
Sneaky Snitch
Sneaky Adventure
Covert Affair
Hard Boiled
Infados
Marty Gots a Plan
Accralate
Constance - The Descent
Desert City
Investigation
Minima
Infados
From Russia With Love
Exotic Battle
Crusade
Face Off
Darkest Child
Other Authors
Audionautix - The Voyage
Eminence Landscape - Ian Post
LMOP - The Whisper Man
This video was heavily inspired by Oversimplified and Bill Wurtz (Especially his history of the entire world, I guess)

Опубликовано:

 

6 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,8 тыс.   
@ThingsICareAbout
@ThingsICareAbout 3 месяца назад
See through media bias in coverage of Israel and Palestine. Try Ground News today and get 40% off your subscription: ground.news/thingsicareabout
@DruckerYTA
@DruckerYTA 2 месяца назад
Will there be a part 3?
@ThingsICareAbout
@ThingsICareAbout 2 месяца назад
@@DruckerYTA Not for the time being, maybe at some point
@DruckerYTA
@DruckerYTA 2 месяца назад
@@ThingsICareAbout 👍
@Tblackknight
@Tblackknight 2 месяца назад
why are you only making videos depending on only Palestinian propaganda? What about Israel side? They don't count?
@Tblackknight
@Tblackknight 2 месяца назад
It wasn't Soviet Union, it was Czechoslovakia, who gave weapons to Israel.
@Cam_AJR
@Cam_AJR 2 месяца назад
Animator here, Hope you guys enjoy part 2
@deimos5177
@deimos5177 2 месяца назад
Good Job Cam Excellent animations
@brianalexanderfrei1217
@brianalexanderfrei1217 2 месяца назад
Yeah man. thx for your hard work as well
@Cam_AJR
@Cam_AJR 2 месяца назад
@@brianalexanderfrei1217 Thank you
@Cam_AJR
@Cam_AJR 2 месяца назад
@@deimos5177 Thank you
@natigolden-l6s
@natigolden-l6s 2 месяца назад
@@Cam_AJR nice animation,not much adherence to the facts(12:58 qoute is wrongfully attributed to ben gurion when it was said by ezra danin) and of course omission of many attack by the arab sides against hebrew communities and pogroms against mizrahi communities across the muslim world prior to 1948.
@nathyboi21
@nathyboi21 2 месяца назад
oversimplified: "its impossible for an animated history channel to make a video every few months" Things I care About: *hold my beer*
@MidnightToker2011
@MidnightToker2011 2 месяца назад
This guy is not near the quality of oversimplified and has very clear and obvious biases.
@hugosenshida999
@hugosenshida999 2 месяца назад
"i disagree, so it's not as good" ​@@MidnightToker2011
@ericm.8110
@ericm.8110 2 месяца назад
​@@MidnightToker2011, oh no. TICA is not pro-Western. It's the end of the world, not.
@Javishxyz
@Javishxyz 2 месяца назад
Oversimplified works alone.
@libertatemadvocatus1797
@libertatemadvocatus1797 2 месяца назад
Well, Oversimplified is funnier, has better information, more historically accurate, and has less biases.
@Blazecfc
@Blazecfc 2 месяца назад
And people wonder why the Palestinians are pissed off. I hate this world.
@דמכי11
@דמכי11 2 месяца назад
what ? its their pronlem bru they lost
@wrxborg
@wrxborg 2 месяца назад
@@דמכי11 Fascho
@humanfrommars882
@humanfrommars882 2 месяца назад
their fault for losing
@swissspinodroid7572
@swissspinodroid7572 2 месяца назад
Well they’ve lost nearly every single major modern war with Israel, so it makes sense.
@JMTheGreat3000
@JMTheGreat3000 2 месяца назад
​@@humanfrommars882It isn't even a fair fight and they didn't loss they just don't have soldiers just militia u don't even know what u talking about so stfu and go cry to mommy
@tabe3263
@tabe3263 2 месяца назад
Oh boy, the sequel to the highly anticipated, controversial topic of Israel and Palestine. Seriously though, keep up the good work, because a lot of people avoid this subject quite often. 👍
@yonks8567
@yonks8567 2 месяца назад
Imagine being prosecuted in Europe for so long that you feel the need to do the same to another group that had absolutely nothing to do with it all.
@shachar9111
@shachar9111 2 месяца назад
Imagine beliving a biased video of someone that based his entire video of a book written by a radical anti-zionsit that his work was disproved XD
@tophat.commenter
@tophat.commenter 2 месяца назад
​@@shachar9111 How was it disproven when ITS A FACT. So youre saying al-nakba didnt happen?? How emotionless and racist can you be to say that?? You disgust me.
@TrojantoComet35
@TrojantoComet35 Месяц назад
It’s like Liberia. One of those, “we learned it from you dad” kind of things
@jeremytheimer7443
@jeremytheimer7443 Месяц назад
That'a not the reason. Also they had everything to do with it. Learn about Amin Al Husseini and perescution of Jews in Muslim countries.
@jachimikedenis
@jachimikedenis 27 дней назад
​@@jeremytheimer7443that doesn't disprove his point.
@BigSt1ngray
@BigSt1ngray 2 месяца назад
You fill the gaps oversimplified leaves for us 😅
@Doc_Beak
@Doc_Beak 2 месяца назад
Stop suking on OS he’s old news he’s way better not whitewashed no propaganda nothing
@AdzimHere
@AdzimHere 2 месяца назад
@@Doc_Beak chill, he isn't suking on OS. he was making clear that OS missed a few things that got cleared out in this video
@terminalimpact2771
@terminalimpact2771 2 месяца назад
@@Doc_BeakGeez, take it easy… It’s just a history animation
@RomanUrbanek
@RomanUrbanek 2 месяца назад
@@Doc_Beak This channel is clear propaganda for arabs but ok
@Anas_Sherif
@Anas_Sherif 2 месяца назад
​@@RomanUrbanek I mean if you want every content to be anti Arab, and if someone said Arabs were right for a sec then it's propaganda, you need to hold your racism a little
@vincevanhartingsveldt1801
@vincevanhartingsveldt1801 2 месяца назад
Moral of the story dont leave the brits with important lands.
@7stormy334
@7stormy334 2 месяца назад
But we didn't, they left the land.
@vincevanhartingsveldt1801
@vincevanhartingsveldt1801 2 месяца назад
@@7stormy334 fair
@7stormy334
@7stormy334 2 месяца назад
@KnucklSandwich the Brits I just pointed out that the original comment implied that the British held important lands and that the reason they controlled it caused all the issues which is not entirely true. It certainly didn't help with all the issues.
@BiscuitisCool
@BiscuitisCool 2 месяца назад
@@7stormy334After messing everything up!
@7stormy334
@7stormy334 2 месяца назад
@KnucklSandwich then who was going to give it to the people who live there. Just keep it as a colony?
@averagenoob8867
@averagenoob8867 2 месяца назад
The pro Israelis are saying that this is one sided and is pro palestine , most of the sources were from jewish diaries and books , even the oppressors wrote about what happend and you say it is one sided ?
@callistoscali4344
@callistoscali4344 2 месяца назад
You have to use multiple sources of historical material and not assume Ilan Pappe's material to be accurate.
@averagenoob8867
@averagenoob8867 2 месяца назад
@@callistoscali4344 the point is that Israeli supporters state that the sources were pro Palestinians, which btw most of them were from Zionists as you can see from the video
@terralp2062
@terralp2062 2 месяца назад
@@callistoscali4344 Yeah that irritated me too. Just using this one book. If you did that in an essay, you would get an F.
@Wh0re_1234
@Wh0re_1234 2 месяца назад
The problem with this video that it uses Ilan Pappe as a source. Which he has been largely disproven in his work.
@thesilentpearl8575
@thesilentpearl8575 2 месяца назад
@@Wh0re_1234 by whom? don't give me a pro israel source because they disprove anybody who hates them
@ahmedjaisam2193
@ahmedjaisam2193 2 месяца назад
For the people claiming that this video is biased: 1: this video is not based on a single source. You can check the description 2: Two of the sources are by isreali historians.
@aridorot2371
@aridorot2371 2 месяца назад
Calling Ilan Pepe, the most anti Zionist anti Israeli “historian” an Israeli historian as a pretext for an unbiased view is worse than not using them at all. The narrative presented here is extremely biased and one sided
@nadavstein4471
@nadavstein4471 2 месяца назад
Yeah that’s not exactly correct. One major example is Ilan Pape that earned the unfortunate nickname of “the Israeli lord haw haw”. Whose book is unfortunately riddled with errors and lacking historical context. Now I don’t want to go rambling on about the politics of Israeli historians as it’s annoying and there are people far more knowledgeable about that subject than me. But what I can tell you for sure is that every single source mentioned is written from the Palestinian narrative, so you’re not seeing the full picture, only half of it.
@Ashad636
@Ashad636 2 месяца назад
​@@nadavstein4471 He literally took sources from the Virutal Jewish library. He took sources from both sides🙄
@andylopez6145
@andylopez6145 2 месяца назад
​@@Ashad636I dunno dude, I would know slot less then you but there was a out 4 times in this entire video where he said that it was based on Israeli testimony, none of it defending or justifying the Israeli actions
@reebozo3543
@reebozo3543 2 месяца назад
the only one saying it is biased are blatantly racist zionists who arent even hiding the fact that they are
@ericm.8110
@ericm.8110 2 месяца назад
Are we willing to bet that everyone who said „TICA is biased" wouldn't have complained if the video had been pro-Western?
@ticketthedog3781
@ticketthedog3781 2 месяца назад
my issue is the fact that things like the expulsion of the Jews of Jerusalem was left out, in the last video he completely got early Zionism wrong (Hertzl was only a figurehead not the ideological leader)
@zaidkapadia6824
@zaidkapadia6824 2 месяца назад
I bet my life on this
@humanfrommars882
@humanfrommars882 2 месяца назад
No
@Obri55
@Obri55 2 месяца назад
Exactly these people are only mad that they got their notions and beliefs challenged
@peterchung2262
@peterchung2262 2 месяца назад
Stop lying to yourself that you have an unpopular opinion. I live in a western country and it seems that a majority of people support Palestine (in public, not counting governments). Yes, maybe if this video was pro-western then some people wouldn't be complaining, but some people still would, and much more people (including YOU) who aren't complaining on this video would be complaining.
@makeroftoys
@makeroftoys 2 месяца назад
This doesn’t acknowledge that “Palestinian” included EVERYBODY who lived under the mandate (including Jews) until 1964.
@glaceo_o229
@glaceo_o229 2 месяца назад
Why does it matter? It’s not about race, it’s about the fact that one side is continuing to commit atrocities and another is trying to exist
@timc1604
@timc1604 2 месяца назад
They were Palestinians in the sense that they lived in that territory (and the region) of Palestine. When most people refer to Palestinians, including in this video, they refer to the Arab ethno-nationalist group residing primarily in the West Bank, the Gaza Strip, Israel, Jordan and parts of southern Lebanon and Syria. This distinct ethnicity developed before 1964, contrary to what some say. They often cite Golda Meir in making that argument. But the ADL has acknowledged that is mistaken and they believe she misspoke and actually was referring to the idea of Palestinians arguing for their own independent state.
@alexclems815
@alexclems815 2 месяца назад
That land has shifted hands for many years, jews do have a legitimate historical claim to the land. You loose the war territory is lost its been that way like forever.. am sure if the Arabs would have won the war with Israel 💯 there would be no jews and Israel would not exist
@TheCohenil
@TheCohenil 2 месяца назад
Yep and it's been like that from the start. If the Palestinias would just lay down their weapons they could actually form a country in Gaza.​@@glaceo_o229
@makeroftoys
@makeroftoys 2 месяца назад
@@glaceo_o229 The Arabs have been offered land to peacefully coexist five times. They don't want that. They want to exterminate the Jews... And the Jewish response is to defend themselves. Get used to it.
@_MJS_
@_MJS_ 2 месяца назад
Moral of the story: Free Palestine
@herrforesight-Satanisking
@herrforesight-Satanisking 2 месяца назад
Moral of the story: Put Palestine or Israel where England is now, and then give the other the area they claim
@WarshipMolester
@WarshipMolester 2 месяца назад
I am morally obligated not to pick a side in this shitshow.
@هايالقناةفقطتجربة
@هايالقناةفقطتجربة 2 месяца назад
thank you as a palestinian i really appreciate that thanks
@rajdipdas69
@rajdipdas69 2 месяца назад
Mortal of story: Muslims cannot peacefully live with other communities.
@guyvaiman1613
@guyvaiman1613 2 месяца назад
@@هايالقناةفقطتجربة as an israeli i have to humbly decline
@michelleanderson245
@michelleanderson245 2 месяца назад
I might like you a little more than Oversimplified, especially after your Vietnam video. Theres humor but you also dont take the tone/horrors of war completely out of it for the sake of humor. Not saying one is better than the other, youre both absolutely phenomenal to watch. Just my opinion
@kaltro_15567
@kaltro_15567 2 месяца назад
When you realise it's not the Jews or the Arabs who are the villains here, but it's actually the Europeans:
@datredhat
@datredhat 2 месяца назад
So true. If Britain never entered the region, this would not happened
@garyborg2345
@garyborg2345 2 месяца назад
british* leave the rest of us europeans out of it
@Anas_Sherif
@Anas_Sherif 2 месяца назад
​@@garyborg2345 The British attacked Arabs and other Europeans The rest of Europeans attacked Jews 💀
@sonicerby6496
@sonicerby6496 2 месяца назад
the jews where technically still Europeans back then. so racist
@aydenee558
@aydenee558 2 месяца назад
​@@datredhatif Rome never entered
@WalkerTheAmericanCircle
@WalkerTheAmericanCircle 2 месяца назад
another W from Oversimplified's heir
@triplem8573
@triplem8573 10 дней назад
Every time I revisit the history of Palestine, it makes my anti-Israeli spirit stronger.
@rain_drops2723
@rain_drops2723 2 месяца назад
Why is this so controversial. The Palestinians were literally colonized. I understand why the Jews were desperate for a safe haven. But Britain was just doing what they were doing best then and Israel continued it.
@theprincemonster7575
@theprincemonster7575 2 месяца назад
Some people in the comments are saying this is Palestinian Propaganda
@Franvvard
@Franvvard 2 месяца назад
People (pro Israel) just can’t accept that they’re the bad guy. Every argument for their case is bullshit or an exaggeration
@PopTop-df9mt
@PopTop-df9mt 2 месяца назад
@princemonster7575 No, not really. However people saying the opposite ARE part of the JDIF
@ihatetomatoo
@ihatetomatoo 2 месяца назад
Britain doing their best? wdym
@hypotheticalclit
@hypotheticalclit 2 месяца назад
Arabs are the original colonisers
@Shoeb._.248G
@Shoeb._.248G Месяц назад
Thank you for revealing the truth!
@naattxxnaattxx7055
@naattxxnaattxx7055 2 месяца назад
You know your unbiased when ground news sponsors you
@13Berzerker
@13Berzerker 26 дней назад
♥ Still there is one side who claims this is antiblablabla
@nbNJ90
@nbNJ90 2 месяца назад
UN guy casually ignoring that the lands he gave arabs were cities primarily populated by the arabs "70% of the land", while the areas granted to israel had much higher jewish concentrations of population. Disingenuous to assume "70% of the land should go to the 70% of the citizens", thereby forcing a population swap based off of the numbers, and not where people were actually located in that moment. It wasn't just to "make up for the guilt of the Holocaust". Although that was definitely part of it, that's very simplistic. It had something to also do with actual concentrations of citizens by ethnicity in the British territory in that moment.
@mrmason2342
@mrmason2342 2 месяца назад
Didn't the UN put major urban centers and territories with majority Arab population as part of Israel in their partition? I'd see that as a dishonest partition.
@someonewow7053
@someonewow7053 2 месяца назад
Bruh there were literally 1 mil arabs in the Jewish zone 💀
@Harv72b
@Harv72b 2 месяца назад
"Although that was definitely part of it, that's very simplistic." I mean...the title of the video literally says "(Simplified)".
@adamelghalmi9771
@adamelghalmi9771 2 месяца назад
i mean there were still about 800,000 Palestinians in the land, but a partition city-by-city was too much work for the UN ig
@atbing2425
@atbing2425 2 месяца назад
A lot of the land that was given to Israel was desert. The whole southern half of the region is essentially an uninhabited desert. This is just another common pro Palestinian talking point.
@هايالقناةفقطتجربة
@هايالقناةفقطتجربة 2 месяца назад
3 weeks ago israeli forces raided jenin (wich had nothing to do with the war by the way) and they went to the place where my mom works at she was at home thank god because they trashed the place computers chairs tables everything just broken oh yeah and they stole the money that was there *how is this self defence?*
@spiffygonzales5160
@spiffygonzales5160 2 месяца назад
Cuz brown
@אדירנצח
@אדירנצח 2 месяца назад
@user-cs2mx4lt3q because Jenin is the city where most terror attacks come from. It's not a "raid". It's as ridiculous as saying Iraqi forces "raided" mosul
@humanfrommars882
@humanfrommars882 2 месяца назад
Maybe because israel is at war with terrorists?
@Justaguyaroslav1234
@Justaguyaroslav1234 2 месяца назад
So you wanna justify self defence Alr ottomans invasion of kingdom of Jerusalem they had killed all the people of Jews and anyone who remained was turned into a slave or kicked out justify that lil bro
@Justaguyaroslav1234
@Justaguyaroslav1234 2 месяца назад
Fair is fair ottomans aka Palestines colonised the lands karma hits hard doesn’t it?
@bruhrewind9623
@bruhrewind9623 2 месяца назад
I was actually pretty neutral and want to see the Palestinians and jews (the ones that colonized palestine not the ones who have their ancestors living there) live together. But after watching part one and part two, i understand now how being neutral is just a way to say you know nothing about this conflict. You're doing gods work. Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸❤
@sebastienholmes548
@sebastienholmes548 2 месяца назад
This video is inaccurate.
@nodamage8011
@nodamage8011 2 месяца назад
@@sebastienholmes548 you are misinformed or just straight up lying
@MrBozny
@MrBozny 2 месяца назад
@@nodamage8011 no the video is highly inaccurate and biased. In part 1 it says the jews just harassed the Arabs to leave whilst a majority bought desert and swamp for highly inflated prices. Also when he talks about the UN partition plan it looks unfair because he doesn't mention that the Palestinians got the fertile land whilst the Jews got swamp and desert. It also seemingly uses the Haganah and Irgun as well as Lehi as interchangeable whilst they were all different and the Haganah was mostly filled with moderates since the Irgun and Lehi were extremists. It also shrugs off Arab attacks on Jewish settlements and even paints the supply couriers as only being military targets at 4:50
@nodamage8011
@nodamage8011 2 месяца назад
@@MrBozny you just point out things he said without refuting them. im getting serious "trust me bro vibes" from you. settlers didnt even deserve an inch of land they should go back home to Europe or elsewhere where they came from israel were like 200 years too late to the colonization party. maybe you could have gotten away with it back then but today we have technology to record every single one of your crimes. Israel has been exposed and nothing you say online will change that
@TaisonminMaxhama
@TaisonminMaxhama 2 месяца назад
The video is highly inaccurate and not neutral.
@armandolomeli2698
@armandolomeli2698 2 месяца назад
this whole vid is terrifying why can’t we all just get along 😢
@r7ahtesham885
@r7ahtesham885 2 месяца назад
Well decades of Anti-semitism made some racist Jews want protection from racism. So they did that, by going to a racist colonial state, and wanted their help to do that they do best.. Which is colonialism, on a land they may or may not have a connection to, but they themselves acknowledged the fact that the Arab Palestinians definitely did. And because of that, antisemites started to support racist Jews to undermine the Native Palestinians.. And they succeeded. So.. No, we can't get along, simply because the one that causes all the problems.. Basically, the western world, won't allow you to because it goes against their interests. So if you want to stop this, be defiant towards this system and be vocal with your support for the native Arab Palestinians. Because when it was Palestine, Jews, Muslims and Christians lived in peace and were coexisting despite Muslim Dominance. When israel came along, the Christians and the Muslims are being killed daily, but the Jews are helping commit those atrocities. And if any Jews recognise the vile nature of it and don't want to.. They themselves are imprisoned or physically assaulted by the police. Seriously. There's videos of Orthodox and Hasidic Jews being assaulted by the police. Context does matter but yeah remember, context of Pro-Palestinian Jews exists too
@superyass13
@superyass13 Месяц назад
Can you try to live with your aggressor forcefully?
@jeremytheimer7443
@jeremytheimer7443 Месяц назад
Delete the Quaran which teaches 1 billion people their ultimate goal is to be martyrs for allah (baal) and muhammed the caravan robber and child molestor. We tried to get along but the quran is by far the greatest obstacle.
@13Berzerker
@13Berzerker 26 дней назад
Hegemony of the USA. Share ? Not a bite ! They want all for themself´s. Boycott ✊ We stand with Palestine !
@TheElectricCherry
@TheElectricCherry 2 месяца назад
I love how Subway is used to represent poison😂
@xRlly
@xRlly 2 месяца назад
Historical background: Jews began purchasing land here when this was still the Ottoman Empire. At that time there was no cohesive Palestinian identity, but Arab nationalism began to emerge (as a response to the Young Turk movement), and they did object to the Turkish government about Jewish land purchase. But the government didn’t do much. When the Ottoman Empire broke up, the League of Nations decided what to do with the territory, and in the interim the British were given a mandate for control of the region that is Israel today. When the Mandate ended, the UN proposed to partition the land between the Jews and Arabs who lived here. The Jews agreed, even though the proposal involved a small strip along the coast and a lot of valueless arid desert. The Arabs refused, and launched a war. They lost. Many Palestinians fled or were thrown out, and their land was taken over by the new Jewish state. The Palestinians who remained are Israeli citizens today, they make up one fifth of the population, they had a party in the previous governing coalition, and are better off than any of their fellows in the region. In 1967 Jordan, Egypt and Syria went to war with Israel and after six days of fighting they lost. Israel then eventually made peace with some of them. Each time we made peace with one of the countries from which we took it, we returned the land, or offered to: Egypt took back the Sinai but did not take Gaza, and Jordan did not take the West Bank. There were negotiations with Syria (between Barak and Assad Sr.) and if we had made peace we’d have given back the Golan but the negotiations failed and we are still in a state of war with Syria. The West Bank at that time was full of Palestinians who had fled in 1948 and lived in “refugee camps” which became towns (slums, mostly). Anarchy reigned, there were gangs, and people were afraid to send their kids to school from what I read. Then in 1993 Israel signed the Oslo Accords with the Palestinians, and the West Bank was divided into areas under Palestinian control (A and B) and an area under Israeli control (C), and a Palestinian government authority was established, the Palestinian Authority (PA) with a police. The PA police instituted law and order, and the PA began to build a civil infrastructure, mainly facilitated by Salam Fayyad, a very capable Finance Minister and then Prime Minister. But the PA was corrupt and Fayyad eventually got sick of that and quit. Meantime there was a militant Islamist faction among the Palestinians, Hamas. Israel had established some settlements on the West Bank (and also in Gaza), and after the Israeli PM was murdered and a right wing government came to power the settlements were increased and entrenched, so that today there are nearly half a million Jews living there in Area C. In 2005 PM Ariel Sharon decided to withdraw all Israelis from Gaza, dismantle the settlements, pull out the army, and leave it to be controlled by the Palestinians. He explicitly declared that this was in order to preclude any similar pullout on the West Bank. After the withdrawal there were elections, and people voted for Hamas as the majority party in what was supposed to be a unity government. For various reasons Hamas and the PA couldn’t come to agreement (Israel also had a contribution to that), and in 2007 Hamas seized total power in a coup, and have been ruling with an iron hand ever since, and using all their resources to attack Israel ever since. As a result Gaza is on the border of humanitarian disaster, with 50% unemployment. Hamas is also gaining power on the West Bank, as the PA weakens. Israel keeps tight watch on the borders, but every time the attacks subside, they are loosened. The past few years they have been more open than any time since Hamas took over, with goods flowing through (even dual purpose materials) and thousands of Gazans coming into Israel to work every day. The conception was that Hamas cared about the economy and the welfare of the people and wouldn’t attack. This proved on October 7th to be incorrect.
@TanvirKabir-pl9gq
@TanvirKabir-pl9gq 2 месяца назад
The only reason isreal didn't try to settle in Gaza was because of Gaza armed resistance . even today Palestinian from west bank are being expelled.
@abdelrahmansalah8873
@abdelrahmansalah8873 2 месяца назад
There is only one thing you miss that during nakba there was a truce for a month with a American meditation in this truce no can buy weapons but Israel buy weapons from USA during this truce
@tdd1257
@tdd1257 2 месяца назад
There’s a bigger war in the comments of this video then in Palestine rn 😂
@qhawegraham826
@qhawegraham826 2 месяца назад
I wouldn’t say that
@LibertyforGreatness
@LibertyforGreatness 2 месяца назад
@@qhawegraham826 why
@softy_alt6596
@softy_alt6596 2 месяца назад
@@qhawegraham826I think he was making a joke
@jeckjeck3119
@jeckjeck3119 2 месяца назад
@@qhawegraham826 I would. Pal did it to iztzzelf.
@13Berzerker
@13Berzerker 26 дней назад
False balancing .. 10 loud trolls/bots don´t compare with 10.000 viewers (who don´t comment) Its clear : We stand with Palestine - not with the apartheid pariah state
@JohnOnChans
@JohnOnChans 2 месяца назад
I got a 5 on AP World. Without inspiring videos like yours, it wouldn't have happened!
@serganta8861
@serganta8861 2 месяца назад
Nice! Keep it up :)
@JohnOnChans
@JohnOnChans 2 месяца назад
@@serganta8861 Thanks man!
@notmanciv5016
@notmanciv5016 2 месяца назад
Got a 4 😭😭
@JohnOnChans
@JohnOnChans 2 месяца назад
@@notmanciv5016 Good luck next time!
@siukenken9950
@siukenken9950 2 месяца назад
20:46 templars? TEMPLARS? I did not see that coming
@GordonJordanGJ4797
@GordonJordanGJ4797 2 месяца назад
No offense Britain But you really fumbled over this one (And i wouldn’t blame you)
@yousefsawalha3902
@yousefsawalha3902 9 дней назад
The first unbiased history gj
@teze2284
@teze2284 2 месяца назад
bruh you cant say this is not biased when the source is "the ethnic cleansing of palestine"
2 месяца назад
its not biased, its known knowldege that isreal is ethinically cleansing them...
@teze2284
@teze2284 2 месяца назад
whatever you say buddy
@AlTata-v3t
@AlTata-v3t 2 месяца назад
​Its called facts ​@@teze2284
@Essa5225
@Essa5225 2 месяца назад
This is just the history whats biased? Do you think all those Palestinian exiles just left their homes out of their own goodwill or something?
@MrMask-mw5fd
@MrMask-mw5fd 2 месяца назад
He cited all the sources if you doubt it check yourself if it's biased or not then come back.
@aridorot2371
@aridorot2371 2 месяца назад
So, you basically animated Ilan Peppe’s pro Palestinian book
@someindokid
@someindokid 2 месяца назад
Well thats the truth. Its the real history on al-nakba.
@lewar_kurdi
@lewar_kurdi 2 месяца назад
When zionist history is fillied with horror, ofc by defult any historian and resource used as accurate as it get, the more chaios it will show and people will call it more biased. Escaping from hitler only to become hitlers
@pikemen3477
@pikemen3477 2 месяца назад
Because history doesn't support your agenda doesn't mean it's wrong.
@TheHunIL
@TheHunIL 2 месяца назад
​@@hatoosy he's a hamas supporter And he's not allowed to get into 27 european countries, and had an fbi investigation when he landed in the us. The first half had at least some sort of balanced pov, the second half shows nothing but jews massacre and kick palestinians out of their homes, with zero context. Every clash has some missing background info and missing evidences so he basically painted it the way he felt was right or to fit his own narrative.
@r7ahtesham885
@r7ahtesham885 2 месяца назад
You know his sources were from the israeli archives themselves? Because they were actually proud of it? Right??
@cadevo86
@cadevo86 2 месяца назад
Please do the Spanish American wars of independence!
@davidbakke9293
@davidbakke9293 2 месяца назад
YES! And then Pinochet, Castro, and other LA dictators
@cristinasalazar9293
@cristinasalazar9293 2 месяца назад
@@davidbakke9293 Castro was not a dictator. He defended his people against US Aggression. ✨💖🛠💖✨
@micahistory
@micahistory 2 месяца назад
Last time I was this early, it was British
@bennywark3103
@bennywark3103 Месяц назад
This conflict just makes me angry
@TheGamer14345
@TheGamer14345 Месяц назад
Great video. I like the fact that you're unbiased and you tell it the way it happened without cherry picking.
@markironside9818
@markironside9818 2 месяца назад
I’m going to cook some popcorn over these comments
@501stcloneboi2
@501stcloneboi2 3 месяца назад
Amazing😊
@beast-kw5zf
@beast-kw5zf 7 дней назад
I respect how much time you put into your vids. We need more ppl like u and oversimplified
@naattxxnaattxx7055
@naattxxnaattxx7055 2 месяца назад
This whole conflict is basically. "He hit me, so I hit him back" over and over and over. I REALLY hope we can live here like human beings and break the cycle.
@tophat.commenter
@tophat.commenter 2 месяца назад
Its impossible tho. Slightly possible but mostly impossible. Each side has a want. And theyre not stopping until they get what they want. And if one side gets their want then the other side doesnt get their want. So its an endless cycle.
@reebozo3543
@reebozo3543 2 месяца назад
yeah. refugees come in, u welcome them. They rob you, you retaliate, some other person defends the robber, and so on.
@disabledmechanic5316
@disabledmechanic5316 2 месяца назад
easy to see it as a endless cycle of violence but its a cycle of violence started by the colonization of palestine by zionists
@ammarmohamed3583
@ammarmohamed3583 2 месяца назад
Well thank god this is a traceable human conflict and not ancient history, we can easily identify who was the one that started this whole conflict.
@naattxxnaattxx7055
@naattxxnaattxx7055 2 месяца назад
@@ammarmohamed3583 my point is that it doesn't matter who hit first. Just stop freaking hitting each other. We are basically playing here the prisoners dilemma and no one trusts each other anymore.
@NikosVillasenor
@NikosVillasenor 2 месяца назад
Me lookin in the comments to see if anyone translated the Spanish: 👁️👁️
@archangeldo913
@archangeldo913 2 месяца назад
7:23 The British guy said he impregnated the other guy’s sister, I think.
@rouwd4wn649
@rouwd4wn649 2 месяца назад
"I don't speak English, I'm sorry I do not understand, where is the library, I'm pregnant from your sister"
@user-us7el6ss2l
@user-us7el6ss2l Месяц назад
@@rouwd4wn649 LOL
@yassin2687
@yassin2687 2 месяца назад
do a video about the Lebanon civil war
@pozdrav423
@pozdrav423 2 месяца назад
20:45 they mentioned Bosnia 🎉
@Aniket-fl8qk
@Aniket-fl8qk 2 месяца назад
Can you make video on Bangladeshi genocide of 1971 in future Also love your videos
@humanfrommars882
@humanfrommars882 2 месяца назад
He wouldn't.
@Aniket-fl8qk
@Aniket-fl8qk 2 месяца назад
@@humanfrommars882 why ?
@MuhammadAhmedMubashir
@MuhammadAhmedMubashir 2 месяца назад
@@Aniket-fl8qk He should make it. Absolutely no pakistani other than jahils defend or support it. Pakistan carried out a genocide the exact way the zionists carried out a genocide.
@fives5555arc
@fives5555arc 2 месяца назад
As a Bengali, I would like to see that. I feel like it’s a pretty unknown event by a lot of people, and should be given some attention.
@kalslavo
@kalslavo 2 месяца назад
Would love to See that. Absolutely no clue about this. 😟
@OkHutJunior
@OkHutJunior 22 дня назад
Oversimplified but with a better upload schedule
@ThePredoCatcher
@ThePredoCatcher 2 месяца назад
2:06 Can you please provide the source to that? googled about Dayr Ayyub and that wasn't mentioned once
@rominagad2502
@rominagad2502 2 месяца назад
I think he meant dayr yasin
@gun_toting_lefty
@gun_toting_lefty 18 дней назад
I feel nothing for people trying to steal land. I feel disgust for people laughing and cheering it on.
@beatzbyreefah
@beatzbyreefah Месяц назад
Wow these were really good videos very informative. The level of shock that I am in right now is unimaginable. They literally just went in the middle of the night and started kicking people out blowing up houses with people in them they didn't care about life. It makes you ashamed to be a human being
@empire6732
@empire6732 Месяц назад
And about that Arab-Israeli war, Israel won ONLY because of foreign support, and the statement about arabs being outnumbered is also false.
@daniellang1182
@daniellang1182 Месяц назад
And yet the Palestinians here, with opened arms to have a country. They just need to take it. What was happening if the Palestinians were winning? We win because litterly every man that stand just fought. The other option was death. We do what we need to do to survive, like always. Our brutality came from your brutality. He just forgot to mention for example, the rapes from the 1929 riots by Arabs. He missed a lot of parts of the Palestinians brutality. How about. How the Muslims initially conquered this land.
@Nikolailjo
@Nikolailjo 2 месяца назад
Israels proposed territory is like 80% desert 20% fertile land
@GordonJordanGJ4797
@GordonJordanGJ4797 2 месяца назад
We’re there actual templars at the siege of jaffa? Since im curious
@mustafaaalmosawi
@mustafaaalmosawi 3 месяца назад
Yes, part 2💪🏼
@HellStr82
@HellStr82 2 дня назад
I still don't understand why Palestinians are upset about.
@Ardito3709
@Ardito3709 2 месяца назад
Origins of Russia vs Ukraine next?
@remysadventures-official8357
@remysadventures-official8357 2 месяца назад
Awesome :D Breakfast will have something interesting to watch Thanks for the vid TICA (and Cam, animator) Funny start btw (have not watched the rest of it))
@יובלרוט
@יובלרוט 2 месяца назад
Speaking about how the UN were making up for the holocaust while ignoring how all the arab countries were practically saying they are going to clear out all the Jews from their lands, Jews might have gotten more land, but arabs both didn't need to leave that land and it was expected the Jewish population will rise significantly (because the arabs will ethnically cleanse them), tried to watch prior video, tried to watch this video, left both early because it is pretty blatantly favouring Palestinians by hiding facts.
@mohammed44_
@mohammed44_ 2 месяца назад
The problems the arab have is not with the jews, because they dont think israelis are jews, jews originally are middle eastern group who are close to arabs by language, religion, geography, and appearance, but modern israelis are athiests, and white, they are not middle easterns, but rather europeans
@nodamage8011
@nodamage8011 2 месяца назад
are you getting paid to lie?
@יובלרוט
@יובלרוט 2 месяца назад
@@nodamage8011 what is a lie here?
@nodamage8011
@nodamage8011 2 месяца назад
@@יובלרוט first of all jews has been running to Arabs and Muslims for protection from christians all throughout history and you are trying to paint it as if arabs hate jews and wanted to ethnically cleanse them. secondly Israel's own agents bombed jews in arab countries to force them to emigrate to "israel". but u probably never heard of this
@nodamage8011
@nodamage8011 2 месяца назад
@@יובלרוט literally everything you wrote is false and made up.
@ehabl8816
@ehabl8816 2 месяца назад
You did an amazing job on this one
@LabidRahat
@LabidRahat 2 месяца назад
Great channel! Best of luck broo! ❤️
@jasporflex1976
@jasporflex1976 2 месяца назад
Great for using Ilan Pappé as the only source for this video. Ilan Pappé is known to have a strong anti-zionist narrative and many opinionated and sketchy claims throughout his works. It's not me saying it, but all historians from the "New Historians" group who read the same archived Pappé did.
@kalkuttadrop6371
@kalkuttadrop6371 2 месяца назад
I’d personally love to see a semi-sequel semi-continuation semi-moreindepthlook of your German Revolution videos looking at the last year or two of the Weimar Republic. More specifically, the period from January 1933-August 1934 where the Weimar Republic still sort of existed and possibly could have been saved, everything after Hitler became chancellor in January 1933 to Summer of 1934 when the last remaining checks collapsed. There's sort of 5 distinct phases to it, the January-March period where everything was more or less the same it had been under prior degree governments(Hitler was chancellor, Hindenburg ruled by decree, same old), the March-July period where the Reichstag fire and Enabling act gutted what little protections existed and democracy ended (March was the communists and vocal extremists, by July even the moderate conservative parties or other right wing nationalist parties were banned), the August 33-January 34 period where the main players were all generally happy with the direction things were going(Von Papen, Hidenburg, Schleicher, and of course Hilter himself), the period from February 1934-June 1934 where Papen and Hindenburg realized things had gotten out of control and started trying to reign him in, and the final two months where the Weimar Republic went from being gutted to completely destroyed. Those final few months were utterly chaotic. It was discovered in May Hindenburg was dying. Von Papen's marburg speech intended to reign in Hitler in June failed and lead to him losing his job. The Night of the Long Knives in July killed most of the remaining dangerous opposition, including Kurt Schleicher one of the few remaining moderates with any influence, and most of Von Papen's staff including his right hand leaving him powerless. It also wiped out the SA, the threat of which had been the main thing the Moderate faction was using to weaken Hilter(talking about the violent street thugs causing trouble to the citizens and scaring the army into thinking they were losing their jobs), now suddenly the people viewed the NSDAP as protecting them from the street violence and the Army was suddenly swinging to their side. Then finally in August Hindenburg(the only person with any power outside of the party at this point and the only guy with enough credit to keep the army on their side) died, the positions of Chancellor and President were merged destroying any hope of ousting Hilter, and Von Papen was exiled to Austria under threat of death. Some say if Hindenburg had lived a little longer and stayed a little sharper, or if the Night of the Long Knives had failed and Röhm was able to cause significant internal issues in the NSDAP, or if Papen hadn't given Goeballs full control of Prussia's police force(thus gutting his own power base and giving the NSDAP full reign over the largest province) they MIGHT just have been able to claw back control. If you really wanted to you could extend it to August 1932-August 1934. (August 1st 1932 was the first date the NSDAP had the majority seats, that's a sort of power even if they were refused chancellor ship. Goring was also made Leader of the Reichstag as a compromise which was one of the highest positions in the government in August 1932), as long as the latter period isn't neglected. Oh and during the January 1933 onward period they actually changed the national flag to the old imperial tricolor one, it was only changed to the infamous red one after Hindenburg died
@omarshebli3208
@omarshebli3208 Месяц назад
Great video
@nme232
@nme232 2 месяца назад
Thanks so much for filing in for oversimplified. This is also very educative.
@jedimasterbones
@jedimasterbones 3 дня назад
Dude made a whole 25-min vid of him not being able to cope 🤣
@tossboy2643
@tossboy2643 2 месяца назад
Dude you can’t just use one book for your source that is so blatantly one sided. I’m not a Zionist, I’m anti Israel, but it’s not possible to get a realistic image of anything if you only read one book about it from one perspective. That’s just bad history
@avishaidavis6038
@avishaidavis6038 2 месяца назад
The worst part is that a lot of the "history" the author wrote in that book has been debunked
@Levascus
@Levascus 9 дней назад
First of all, he used 7 sources, that proves you didnt even read the description and just took this out of your a**
@tossboy2643
@tossboy2643 8 дней назад
@@Levascus almost every quote in the video is from the same book, and the information he is saying is basically exactly what that book says. Considering that large parts of that book have been outright proven to be not true, it’s a bad sign sign so much of his video uses it as foundational text. I’m not a Zionist, I am pro Palestine, but that doesn’t mean I can’t also recognize bad history when I see it
@AdamCarles
@AdamCarles 3 дня назад
FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
@Darkgeran7
@Darkgeran7 2 месяца назад
I’m am late to comment but great work on this series and from now on I will do a better job at using your videos as an entry point like you said.
@newguy8288
@newguy8288 2 месяца назад
To the people saying it’s a biased video with only one source, it legit takes 1 second to look at the description and see here’s several sources.
@maxscameraguy
@maxscameraguy 2 месяца назад
Iian Pappé is a sloppy historian at best and his book is nothing more then politico-moral garbage. The book is largely accepted as dishonest.
@fahimishrak2731
@fahimishrak2731 2 месяца назад
says the butthurt internet troll with his trust me bro rethoric
@Anas_Sherif
@Anas_Sherif 2 месяца назад
He wrote it using declassified documents from the Israeli government, which no one can access today for obvious reasons, and for sure if anyone was Israeli and someone spread all that they'd have to make a little propaganda to prevent people from reading it
@maxscameraguy
@maxscameraguy 2 месяца назад
@@fahimishrak2731 maybe do your own research before commenting such idiotic things.
@fahimishrak2731
@fahimishrak2731 2 месяца назад
@@maxscameraguy I did little kid and every single resource including israeli media like haaretz talks about the Nakba and how zionist militias terrorized and expelled 750k palestanians. That''s a stone cold fact and ethnic cleansing deniers and genocide deniers like you are part of the problem who would've denied the holocaust too if you were alive back in 1945.
@mrmason2342
@mrmason2342 2 месяца назад
@@maxscameraguy Hey buddy, instead of trying to act like a smartass why not show us some of your own sources to disprove lian Pappe? Or are you just another butt-hurt Zionist in this comment section throwing accusations left and right with no structure or evidence?
@moultage
@moultage Месяц назад
Loving your videos! I'd love to see a video about The Troubles in Ireland or Cuban Revolution
@kimberlylewistyner2070
@kimberlylewistyner2070 2 месяца назад
I LOVE THE NEW ART STYLE!!
@natigolden-l6s
@natigolden-l6s 2 месяца назад
art style is important,what about historical accuracy and neutral coverage? . they use the unreliable source of illan pappe who ,just for example , in 12:58 attributed a qoute by ezra danin to ben gurion... in the previous episode he said the 1929 pogroms ended up with 200 arabs dead without mentionning most of them died by british police while attacking hebrew civilians .he doesnt mention how the "unarmed arabs" caused from 1936 to 1939 292 security personnel and 400 hebrew deaths, he left out in this video 1947 mamila attack before the haifa oil refinery massacre,he left out the fact the brits enabled the neighboring arab countries to create modern armies while raiding hebrew militas military cahces till 1948(And in the case of jordan-they even had a british general known as jhon bagot), he leaves out the expulsion of hebron gaza and nablus hebrew community in 1929 and silwan and pekiein communities in 1938. he leaves out pogroms across the muslim world against the mizrahi communities from 1903 to 1948,he left out the fact the head of the arab higher committee- haj amin el husseini-was a nazi ss officer and brought here bosnian mujahideen units from his disbanded ss units,he left out fabuary 1948 ben yehuda street bombing and jerusalem post building bombing,he left out deir yassin stopped its neutrality before the attack on it and that 5 hebrew militants died catching the "unarmed" village,he left out all the druze arab villages and abu gush who didnt participate in any violent attack against us were not harmed. why ? because he has an agenda.
@zaidkapadia6824
@zaidkapadia6824 2 месяца назад
​@@natigolden-l6s Chill ADL bot
@jasporflex1976
@jasporflex1976 2 месяца назад
​@@natigolden-l6sGreat comment. Please post this in the main comment section for more people to see.
@kimberlylewistyner2070
@kimberlylewistyner2070 2 месяца назад
@@natigolden-l6s a long paragraph!?!?
@natigolden-l6s
@natigolden-l6s 2 месяца назад
@@kimberlylewistyner2070 you have all the elaboration you need to see why i say he has an agenda and he is far from accurate.
@natigolden-l6s
@natigolden-l6s 2 месяца назад
12:58- what is attributed to ben gurion- was actually said by ezra denin according to norman finklestein and other historians(Shows how sloppy illan pappe was). palestinians were not armed ? is that so ? how did they rebel against the brits in 1936-1939 rebellion killing 292 british forces and over 500 members of the hebrew community? again with "they were using only stones" ? kaukji forces and haj amin el husseini forces(including a component of bosnian mujahideen volunteers,many served in the muslim ss units) were armed by neighboring arab countries . why? you have an agenda. in fact the british forces were arming the arab nations surrounding israel while all the way leading to their departure from the land of israel- they have raided hebrew weapons caches(while helping to create modern arab armies and even having british personnel in the arab armies-see jhon baggot). in the previous video you depicted 1929 hebron and safed pogroms as "clashes" and talked about "palestinian casualties"(british police stopping the lynchers) and then you skipped 1936 jaffa pogroms and 1938 tiberias pogroms and banishment of hebron,gaza,silwan and pekiein communities. arabs have targeted hebrew civilian communities all through that time,including sniping the yemenite grapevine neighbourhood in tel aviv and raid of mamila before the haifa distillation plant lynching .you dont mention the arab leaders calls for killing and exterminating the hebrew population(especially the ones by the nazi ss officer husseini ,head of the arab higher committee,or by leaders of neighboring arab countries,not the pogroms against mizrahi communities before 1948 all across the muslim world),and the arab high committee have officially rejected the partition plan,so where were the arab people supporting the partition?. you dont mention ben gurion peaceful coexistence plans before 1929 hebron and safed pogroms,and you qoute illan pappe rather than benny morris.
@professord2807
@professord2807 2 дня назад
Thank you. This guy is clearly agenda driven. Doesn’t mention any of the numerous terrorist organizations by Palestinians. Conveniently leaves out they refused to comply with international law.
@rexmon2592
@rexmon2592 2 месяца назад
I can’t imagine watching this two part series and still thinking Israel is in the right.
@hellohithere9192
@hellohithere9192 2 месяца назад
Cause its a entirely biased video using little to no unbiased information which seeing the sponsor makes it very laughable
@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0
@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0 2 месяца назад
​@hellohithere9192 Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0
@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0 2 месяца назад
​@@hellohithere9192.I guess they're biased too
@HorizonMakes
@HorizonMakes 2 месяца назад
Nobody is in the right. This conflict isn't right Vs wrong, it's grey Vs grey. This is the reason the discourse around it is so asinine - everyone acts like it's simple, when there could hardly be a more complex topic.
@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0
@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0 2 месяца назад
@HorizonMakes Even david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine Zeev Jabotinsky said in 1921: "I don't know of a single example in history where a country was colonised with the courteous consent of the population".
@PleasantPark-StarrySuburbs
@PleasantPark-StarrySuburbs 2 месяца назад
Moral: Never let the british or the un make borders
@mesoiq
@mesoiq 2 месяца назад
One of the best videos on the matter ... thank u for the hard work
@earlLXIX
@earlLXIX 2 месяца назад
We got Oversimplified 2 before GTA 6!
@mounirhafsa6193
@mounirhafsa6193 2 месяца назад
Thank you for such great work ! been watching all your videos lately, great work and good luck for the rest !
@Ex0dus111
@Ex0dus111 День назад
Part 2 and we're barely at 1949...
@motasemsalameh1521
@motasemsalameh1521 2 месяца назад
very informative and eye openning, kerep going!
@aohps7063
@aohps7063 2 месяца назад
I’m sure that this comment section will be very calm and peaceful
@tyronecomblast1078
@tyronecomblast1078 2 месяца назад
I Appreciate you. You earned this sub.
@brendonbonner3309
@brendonbonner3309 Месяц назад
This 'Long Seminar' (starting 31 December 1947) mentioned at 8:40 seems to bear a chilling similarity to the the Wannsee Conference (20 January 1942) chaired by Rheinhard Heydrich to ensure the Final Solution to the Jewish Question, in that it seems to have been chaired by Ben Gurion to ensure the Final Solution to the Palestinian Question. If you were on the receiving end of either you may have found the difference between them largely academic. Both seem insanely inhumane!
@YassineAchmourk
@YassineAchmourk 2 месяца назад
after seeing this video it suprises me how many cilivians where killed instead of resisting arabs and thats just awful after all it looks like the jews are taking revenge on the arabs instead of the germans
@Ko_tada
@Ko_tada 2 месяца назад
Just like how the naxis took revenge on the Jews instead of the British and the French , it's always the weak who face the consequences of what they didn't do , but was done by the stronger side who never face consequences of their own actions
@homersimpson6585
@homersimpson6585 2 месяца назад
Sad thing is when the Jews were being prosecuted in Europe for the killing of Jesus it was the Arabs and amazeighs that welcomed them in their homes in Al andalus and Morocco and they were usually not prosecuted in the Middle East There’s a book by David Wasserstein a Jewish historian called “How Islam saved Judaism”
@BiscuitisCool
@BiscuitisCool 2 месяца назад
The Israelis did he just dosen’t focus on it😊
@thesilentpearl8575
@thesilentpearl8575 2 месяца назад
@@Ko_tada thats ignoring the fact that there were some original jews who lived in under ottoman rule in peace. they were treated more or less fairly as they only had to pay a tax versus the prosecution that jews in other european countries faced. zionism changed everything.
@Ko_tada
@Ko_tada 2 месяца назад
@@thesilentpearl8575 but Palestineians still have to pay for Europe's sins (not all European countrys but a large portion of them) why didn't the UN give Germany to the Jews it was already cut in half they might have just gave Jews half of Germany because they were the ones who carried the h0l0caust after all , if displacing innocent civilians because other people suffered then maybe they should have made the people who supported the suffering pay for it and not people form the other side of the planet (collective punishment is still f*ckd but why do Palestineians have to face it ) after all the allies controlled half of Germany and supported the creation of israel and still support it to this day with the same passion , the Soviets controled the other half and also heavily supported the zionist project , why did non of them offer the Jews a piece of Germany ???? Why should Palestineians give up their land because the Jews didn't like Europe anymore ????
@janetwebster5099
@janetwebster5099 Месяц назад
Great Job! 👍 Thanks for putting this 2 part seris out! The short format/cartoons make it more accessible for those who dont want to watch live reports, or dont understand the conflict. Prior to October 7th many people, including myself knew very little about the situation in Palestine, and even less about the asymmetrical nature of the conflict. Its high time the truth about Israel and their genocidal ways was publicized!
@russianbear6517
@russianbear6517 2 месяца назад
Do we get part 3 or is this series done now?
@daniellang1182
@daniellang1182 Месяц назад
For what? That he will twist what happened in Oslo agreements?
@JamesMcPillar
@JamesMcPillar Месяц назад
So I was right. Israel is the villain of this story. I have avoided this but; "Free Palestine"
@wanderduck3
@wanderduck3 2 месяца назад
The book you used for this is not only noted for its poor scholarship but also for its really bad translation of quotes (many of which you used) and its taking many things from their contexts. For example many of the Ben Gurion quotes you used are from his journal and aren't known to be actual goals or plans, but rather the private rants of someone. It's honestly sad how complex and convoluted this conflict is that no body does an honest explanation of it.
@arunramani1724
@arunramani1724 2 месяца назад
History gives modern ideas and ideals a different light.... It can be either good or bad. Great video Dude 🎉
@jasporflex1976
@jasporflex1976 2 месяца назад
You realize that this video only uses Ilan Pappé's work as a source. This is not a factual telling of history. Only the promotion of Ilan Pappé's work. If you don't know who Ilan Pappé is and what the "New Historians" group is. I recommend you do some research about it. Ilan Pappé is not for nothing known as a sloppy historian.
@juliannahikaru9912
@juliannahikaru9912 2 месяца назад
Yeah ok the first part was fine but this was incredibly biased, disappointing
@merubmalik8299
@merubmalik8299 2 месяца назад
Cope
@unspoken7841
@unspoken7841 2 месяца назад
Pov: you don't hear what you want to hear in a video about HISTORY
@amnont8724
@amnont8724 2 месяца назад
Unpopular opinion: both were really biased
@blimlimlim2479
@blimlimlim2479 Месяц назад
It should be noted that Ben-Gurion despised the Irgun, he authorized the use of fire for the Haganah upon an Irgun ship.
@SaharMaorLevy
@SaharMaorLevy 2 месяца назад
This is no longer history contest. This is a Hamas propeganda. I was expecting more
@PakPilot999
@PakPilot999 Месяц назад
I would rather have that than zion propaganda
@Filan.Fistekuuu
@Filan.Fistekuuu 11 дней назад
can't handle the truth
@supermanmnb5754
@supermanmnb5754 2 месяца назад
This is the best thing to watch while playing hoi
@r7ahtesham885
@r7ahtesham885 2 месяца назад
Bro there's literal stories of civilians being murdered and brutally oppressed. If it were Jews, you'd get cancelled so fast
@lLooN3y
@lLooN3y 2 месяца назад
Yeah I’m Korean and I have no bias to either side. I’m just a big history buff. TICA videos has always been biased to essentially the traditionally “adversary” side with Vietnam, Korea and completing glossing over any atrocities the other side did while empathizing on the atrocities that the western powers or western backed ally did without REAL context. This man just put the modern borders of Israel right after 1950s and glossing over multiple wars essentially started by the Arab nation to also ethnically cleanse the Jewish population. lol this isn’t oversimplified. This is a joke at this point. A parody that shouldn’t be taken seriously. I didn’t mind his somewhat bias take in his earlier videos, at times it was completely wrong or taken out of context but it was a refreshing. But this one is straight lazy, misinformation and click bait to get views. This dude needs to do a better job, yeah those flash split second captions don’t count. TICA knows what they’re doing. Entertaining propaganda parody videos at this point. Like almost TICA thinks it gives him clout to just go against western nations. Like a rebelling child. Unbiased videos would probably make this channel a success.
@natigolden-l6s
@natigolden-l6s 2 месяца назад
glad you recognize the bias too. they use the unreliable source of illan pappe who ,just for example , in 12:58 attributed a qoute by ezra danin to ben gurion... in the previous episode he said the 1929 pogroms ended up with 200 arabs dead without mentionning most of them died by british police while attacking hebrew civilians .he doesnt mention how the "unarmed arabs" caused from 1936 to 1939 292 security personnel and 400 hebrew deaths, he left out in this video 1947 mamila attack before the haifa oil refinery massacre,he left out the fact the brits enabled the neighboring arab countries to create modern armies while raiding hebrew militas military cahces till 1948(And in the case of jordan-they even had a british general known as jhon bagot), he leaves out the expulsion of hebron gaza and nablus hebrew community in 1929 and silwan and pekiein communities in 1938. he leaves out pogroms across the muslim world against the mizrahi communities from 1903 to 1948,he left out the fact the head of the arab higher committee- haj amin el husseini-was a nazi ss officer and brought here bosnian mujahideen units from his disbanded ss units,he left out fabuary 1948 ben yehuda street bombing and jerusalem post building bombing,he left out deir yassin stopped its neutrality before the attack on it and that 5 hebrew militants died catching the "unarmed" village,he left out all the druze arab villages and abu gush who didnt participate in any violent attack against us were not harmed. why ? because he has an agenda.
@luvitluvitbaby
@luvitluvitbaby 2 месяца назад
This video is clearly very pro-Israel.
@humanfrommars882
@humanfrommars882 2 месяца назад
​@@luvitluvitbabyhow?
@lLooN3y
@lLooN3y 2 месяца назад
@@humanfrommars882 lol he’s being sarcastic
@humanfrommars882
@humanfrommars882 2 месяца назад
​@@lLooN3yoh aight mb
@daxeckenberg
@daxeckenberg Месяц назад
Don't mention that the Jews were given the swamp & malaria infested lands, and the large southern desert. Also, a large body of land was given to the Arabs namely Jordan ( also Palestinians , as Jordan never existed preciously).
@daxeckenberg
@daxeckenberg Месяц назад
also, the Palestinians who didn't fight and agreed to not fight are now Arab Israeli citizens
@Epic_Memer_Man
@Epic_Memer_Man Месяц назад
Jordan was never part of judea
@kraevorn7483
@kraevorn7483 2 месяца назад
So Ben Gurion is in hell?
@someonewow7053
@someonewow7053 2 месяца назад
He will be punished so hard he will wish that he was just sand
@AdamNoes
@AdamNoes 2 месяца назад
Most def
@kraevorn7483
@kraevorn7483 2 месяца назад
@@someonewow7053 well this is a little awkward because he’s actually a character in the book the ambassador Where Israel became a state in 1938 and it’s about the Israeli ambassador to Nazi Germany securing Jewish immigration, and Ben actually meets with Adolf Hitler in one of the chapters
@MikeJoe-jy5kp
@MikeJoe-jy5kp 2 месяца назад
Yes
@reaper2579
@reaper2579 2 месяца назад
Obviously yes, i mean hes an atheist tho and doesn't care about the Torah nor the ten commandments so yeah...
@ShelleyLevyMusic
@ShelleyLevyMusic Месяц назад
Simplified for the Palestinian narrative that’s for sure
@Qoboiboi
@Qoboiboi 2 месяца назад
Just like the first part, its full of inaccuracies, misquotes, and everything possible to push his own bias on this supposedly "educational" video, at the obvious expense of quality and objectiveness. I have been studying this conflict for a while now, including watching some videos about it to compare perspectives from all sides and study and understand how videos push a narrative or a bias, and I usually don't mind. BUT what really infuriates me about this one particularly is that its aimed at people who are just beginning to understand this complex conflict (that usually takes actual effort to understanding it properly without being biased to any side) and preserving it as an educational "Oversimplified" style video, and the people watching this and learning about the conflict for the first time dont know that you are decieving them into a narrative. Your use of outdated philosophies and concepts, that for an unbiased person who knows more than surface level will immediately flag it as a biased video, will fly right over the heads of people newer to this conflict. You are allowed to push your narrative, but to disguise it as education is just evil.
@jawad2685
@jawad2685 2 месяца назад
What are some of those inaccuracies and misquotes?
@vodoxthefirst8776
@vodoxthefirst8776 2 месяца назад
Quit yapping
@disabledmechanic5316
@disabledmechanic5316 2 месяца назад
jesus christ i expected a actual refutal, you literally said one sentence that goes bad video lol, cant prove why that is so
@hmodealtherwi6842
@hmodealtherwi6842 2 месяца назад
Holy shit imagine writing two entire paragraphs to deliver the message "umm you are wrong and I disagree"
@bruhrewind9623
@bruhrewind9623 2 месяца назад
Nah you guys are cooking this man 💀
@mroejacobs
@mroejacobs Месяц назад
Zion Israel≠biblical Israel ok ✝️🇵🇸🙏
@Doc_Beak
@Doc_Beak 2 месяца назад
UN 😂😂😂😂😂😂 Things I care about -: FREE PALESTINE
@Muhammedkmal
@Muhammedkmal 2 месяца назад
تحية لكل احرار العالم ولصاحب القناة الذي قدم لنا محتوي حقيقي يدعم قضيه شعب مظلوم
Далее
The Russian Revolution - OverSimplified (Part 1)
21:04
Beautiful Military 🏅
00:10
Просмотров 1,2 млн
Israel Hamas war: how Oct 7 changed the Middle East
37:32
The American Civil War - OverSimplified (Part 1)
29:53
Israel and Palestine Origins with Dr. Benny Morris
1:39:27
Beautiful Military 🏅
00:10
Просмотров 1,2 млн