Like my content? Want to support my work? Become a member and get early access to my videos as well as other perks! Support me on Ko - fi - ko-fi.com/travelingisrael
It's insane how many pro palestinian protesters there are. Since you are an Israeli, may I ask you, is this a terror attack on the west, or just a result of anti-semitism in the West? Why are black people, who we have stood shoulder to shoulder with in desiring equal rights, becoming anti-semitic in large numbers? Are they being targeted by islamist associations because of their poverty, ignorance, and feelings of being oppressed in America? I mean, it's not like black people were ever arab. Maybe my dad's distant long ago relatives were arab. I don't know. Are they organized by the west to show that they are split in a way to sneakily be for Israel while also supporting Arabs? If so, why? What skin is there in supporting arabs?
As an European Christian I really like the information you give on your channel. So many lies get debunked. I listen to both sides and I think the two state is the only solution if... The Palestinian Arabs choose to do coexist... But I don't see that happen. It could have happened for the sake of peace and a prosperous future for the children, but got rejected time and time again. Personally I believe the land is holy land that belongs to the Jews and not politics decide what happens, but God. I always love Isaiah 66. The church rejected the Jews for ages, which is a shame and a very sad history. I always point out that Israel is our 'big brother' and God's plan with Israel will happen. When WW2 happened all Christians in the area said that the Messiah would come quickly. My great grandfather pointed out that that would not happen yet, because the Jews would go back to their land. People laughed at him, but years later they saw it becoming fullfilled, like it is said in Isaiah 66. Greetings and God bless you and Israel.
I am an Indonesian who had always supported Palestine. But watching your videos has been an eye opener for me. I felt guilty for my support to one side of the conflict. Now, I just want peace for all. I hope the Arabs are ready for a peace agreement with Israel and both live peacefully and happily.
@@AH-gt8gv what? It shows how HIS side brainwash people Instead of saying “he brainwashed you” say how he brainwashed him and what he was lying? Because you are the one who look like doesn’t understanding a crap about this conflict
It's important to hear directly from some Israeli soldiers themselves, about what it is they do to Palestinian people ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-37MFa7ZKQWo.html
about the blank: what was the havara agreement aimed at? The Haavara Agreement was a 1933 deal between the Zionist movement, the German government, and the Anglo-Palestine Bank that aimed to facilitate the emigration of German Jews to Palestine. The key points are: •Under the agreement, German Jews had to surrender their possessions before leaving Germany, and the proceeds were used to purchase German goods for sale in Palestine. The emigrants would then receive the proceeds in Palestinian currency upon arrival. •However, the agreement did not imply that the Nazis were Zionists or shared the goal of establishing a Jewish state in Palestine. The Nazis' primary aim was to remove Jews from Germany, not to support Zionism.
Oren, I believe you were called for such a time as this, similar to Esther. You are like a lone voice calling out in the desert. Adonai bless you and keep you and yours safe and smile upon you.
I am Swiss, born in 1958. I was not familiar with that story you tell. However, even here in remote Switzerland, we experienced criminal acts carried out by Palestinian terrorists. I remember the shooting at an El Al plane at the airport in Zurich, as well as the hijacking of a Swissair plane, and the destruction of that plane in Jordan. I also remember the killing of 47 completely uninvolved people in a Swissair plane crashing near Zurich after the explosion of a PLO bomb. And I do remember the horrible PLO attack against Israels participants at the Olympic games in Munich, Germany. And up to this day I cannot understand how Arafat could become rewarded with the Nobel prize for peace for his horrendous crimes.
I'm an American and remember lots of terror attacks. However what I figured out at a young age is these attacks didn't happen because we eat apple pie and watch baseball. Do you think all that terrible stuff happened because you eat Toblerone and go Alpine Skiing?
They gave a peace nobel price to obbama that bombed the most out of all president and not to trump that DIDN'T start a war (highly unsual for USA president) and actually made peace plan possible like the Abrahams accords
I've followed this conflict since the early 2000s and can confirm that I have seen most of what you said documented, especially when reviewing Ottoman history and the records of the British Mandate. Please keep up the good work and keep the videos coming.
Our enemies called us terrorists ... People who were neither our friends nor our enemies ... also used this Latin name ... And yet, we were not terrorists ... The historical and linguistic origins of the political term "terror" prove that it cannot be applied to a revolutionary war ofliberation ... Fighters for freedom must arm; otherwise they would be crushed overnight ... What has a struggle for the dignity of man, against oppression and subjugation, to do with "terrorism"? One would automatically attribute this to an Islamic terrorist group and condemn it. However, the author of these words is none other than Menachem Begin in the years when the Haganah was fighting the British forces in Palestine. It is interesting to note how, in those years of the Jewish struggle against the British military in Palestine, the very term "terrorist" had a positive connotation. Here's another mental experiment: imagine reading in contemporary newspapers an open letter headed "Letter to the Terrorists of Palestine," containing these sentences: My Brave Friends. You may not believe what I write you, for there is a lot of fertilizer in the air at the moment. But on my word as an old reporter, what I write is true. The Palestinians of America are for you. You are their champions. You are the grin they wear. You are the feather in their hats. You are the first answer that makes sense-to the New World. Every time you blow up an Israeli arsenal, or wreck an Israeli jail, or send an Israeli railroad sky high, or rob an Israeli bank, or let go with your guns and bombs at the Israeli betrayers and invaders of your homeland, the Palestinians of America make a little holiday in their hearts. A very similar open letter was indeed published in the late 1940s in American newspapers. It was written by none other than Ben Hecht, the celebrated Hollywood scriptwriter. All I have done is to replace the word "Jews" with "Palestinians" and "British" with "Israeli." It is almost attractive to see the first-generation Israeli leaders openly confessing the fact that their claims to the land of Palestine cannot be grounded in universal justice, that we are dealing with a simple war of conquest between two groups between whom no mediation is possible. VIOLENCE- SLAVOJ ZIZEK page 119-120 www.imdb.com/title/tt16378034/?ref_=ext_shr_lnk
@@mohammedzbeidi6638 VOX may be looking for more content creators. Looks like you can follow their editorial guidelines. Let us know if they give you a gig.
What were the long-term effects of the Haavara Agreement on Jewish immigration policies between Nazi Germany and the Zionist movement? The Haavara Agreement, signed in 1933 between Nazi Germany and the Zionist movement, facilitated the emigration of around 60,000 German Jews to Palestine between 1933 and 1939. However, it did not have significant long-term effects on Jewish immigration policies: •The agreement was controversial and criticized by some Zionists, non-Zionist Jews, members of the Nazi Party, and the German public. •The agreement enabled Jews to retain some of their assets when emigrating, but most Jewish emigrants still had to surrender most of their property before leaving Germany. The agreement was a pragmatic deal that temporarily aligned the interests of the Zionist movement and Nazi Germany
Before we toured Israel in October 2022, my wife and I watched MANY of your videos. While we enjoyed them very much, we enjoy this series even MORE! Keep up the EXCELLENT work!!!
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rGVgjS98OsU.html 4':36 the Jewish population [to Palestine] more than doubled. The migration helped the Zionist movement gain steam. And a slogan took off. “A land without people for, a people without land.” And it sends a message to Western leaders... that the people who had been living in Palestine for generations... could just be easily moved elsewhere. The idea was that those inhabitants weren't a people with ties to that land. Palestine was, of course, a land with a people. In 1931, there were more than 850,000 Palestinian Arabs in the region, still the vast majority. But with the rise of Hitler and the Nazi Party in particular... “Hate became a rallying call.” Jewish flight from Europe became even more urgent. And Palestine started to see the biggest wave of Jewish emigration yet.
My wife, an Assyrian-Persian from Iran, always says the same things you shared. I think if anyone curious enough as my wife is, they will come to the same conclusion as you shared with us. Thank you.
Palestinian leaderships say the same things, but only among themselves, lest the world will know they lie. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-zp94XtO8gQQ.html&ab_channel=UncannyLizard
It's important to hear directly from some former Israeli IDF soldiers themselves, about what it is they do to Palestinian people ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-37MFa7ZKQWo.html
Current Panicky Israel propaganda machine spends $5B to pay people on-line to make pro-Israel comments pretending to be Arabs, Iranians, etc. as deceptive Zionist regime gets exposed. Great. You point out these liars. Put your comment directly not just Reply
My family is from Haifa. My father has always told me the same stories. One in particular. On the day of decleration of independence, trucks of the Jewish leadership of the city went through Arab neighborhoods, urging them to stay and live in peace. A lot of them did, and to date its a relatively successful coexistence.
@@romamak2367 a lot of people seem pretty "confused" at what "genocide" actually means... probably because they don't actually do much thinking and just keep parroting words they hear other people saying like "open air prison".
@@dhbhatta Are You sooo stupid that fact that NO Jews can live among arab-palestinians and fact that 25% arab-palestinians live in Israel you call GENOCIDE? It is but from arab-palestinians side they kill babxxies and elders
I am Indian Muslim and full support to Israel 🇮🇱 F Radical Islamists. They have destroyed our Islam. They have made Islam enemy of the West. But actually Islam is not the enemy of any civilisation. Islam is a peaceful message but radical Islamists destroyed it's essence. Islam needs to be reformed globally and only Muslims can do that. I would encourage to read books of Maulana Wahiduddin Khan where he debunked Syed Abul Ala Maududi's radical Islamist political interpretation of Islam.
وبعدين احنا لما بنيجي ندعي ربنا أو نشكره ما بنعملش كده 🙏 دي الصحيحة 🤲 وي كمان ما بنقولش كمان لك المجد دي خالص 😂 بطلوا اللعب مع بعقول الناس ونشر الباطل على الحق وي انشاء الله فلسطين المحتلة حره 🇵🇸♥️🇪🇬
@@abdalftah4693I think you are already free. It is just your mind who is imprisoning you. Your leaders and people have the capacity to have freedom unless you like fighting everyday and destroy your own place. Its in the mindset if you want to live in peace and progress and have a wonderful life.
Dear Lad, hello. I am 102. I was a surgical nurse in London during WW2 and in the 1980s I became a history teacher. I wanted to say I didn't know any of this history and I taught 3rd grade. I apologize. History is important weather it's good or bad, but we shouldn't repeat it when it's wicked. I don't get out anymore and I fell upon your site and I love it. You can tell you work very hard on your research. My husband was a German Jew, but not practicing. He was raised Catholic. He has long since passed. Thank you again for your informative information. God Bless you . Ann 👵
I certainly hope you are keeping well. I am a physician and an amateur historian who is very interested in the Second World War. You must have saved so many people. Please take care. ❤ from Calcutta, India.
Bless your heart, Ann! I just came across your comment and found it amazing! You very much reminded me of my grandma in law who also completed the 100. She was a lovely english lady from Wirral and it was so joyful when my wife and I came to visit her. I'm sure my wife likes to send her love, too. So I'd like to say "Auf Wiedersehen" ❤
Great job.Clear concise truth. I'm a 68 yr old American woman. I have never read or listened to Vox. I have listened to history scholars and was aware of a lot of what you said. A good book on the subject is "From Time Immemorial" by Joan Peters. I don't have much of a social media presence but I will share your video with what I have. I certainly appreciate your work and time. 🇺🇲🇮🇱
Yes, she was a leftie who had bought the Palestinian ie Arab lie, and did her utmost to prove it true. Had to change her mind after learning the FACTS.
what was the havara agreement aimed at? its historical background? The Haavara Agreement was a 1933 deal between the Zionist movement, the German government, and the Anglo-Palestine Bank that aimed to facilitate the emigration of German Jews to Palestine. The key points are: •The agreement did not imply that the Nazis were Zionists or shared the goal of establishing a Jewish state in Palestine. The Nazis' primary aim was to remove Jews from Germany, not to support Zionism. •The Haavara Agreement marked the beginning of Nazi-organized Jewish relocation efforts, but these were driven by the Nazis' antisemitism and desire to "solve the Jewish question", not any support for Zionism. In summary, the Haavara Agreement was a pragmatic deal that temporarily aligned the interests of the Zionist movement and the Nazi government, but it did not reflect any shared ideology or goals between the two parties [at the expense of the local population composed of Palestinian Arans, Christians and local Jews+other minotities]
It is not a lesson. It is distorted, Israeli propaganda. Please go and check the claims made in the Vox video yourself, using independent sources instad of this “lesson” from a Zionist.
And like most children....they love to cheer for their underdog in their marvel superhero movies. Hope you grow out of you comic book phase and grow into reality.
Thank you, please keep making more 🙏 I'm not even Jewish and it's been so terrifying seeing all the hatred. I'd like to hope it's mostly the chaotic fury of mislead young people that can be tamed with accurate information and historical context
It's important to hear directly from some Israeli soldiers themselves, about what it is they do to Palestinian people ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-37MFa7ZKQWo.html
The problem is indoctrination, not misinformation. Equally true of the Arab far right, and insane lefties like queers for Palestine. Sadly, kids are raised on mental garbage and can't bother to think for themselves, or fear social banishment if they do.
Nigeria vs Boko Haram 350,000 dead Sudan vs JEM/Darfur 300,000 dead Yemen vs Houthis 233,000 dead Pakistan vs Islamists 50,000 dead Syria's civil war 400,000 dead South Sudan's civil war 400,000 dead Ethiopia and Eritrea vs Tigray 600,000 dead Do you remember demonstrations for all these dead?
@@ef2718those are rogue groups and sectarian violence. Israel is a supposed STATE.. one that is funded by America and supported by the EU. That’s why you are seeing demonstrations but you brain is more water logged than a cabbage so you couldn’t even notice the problem in your foolish analogy.
I always thought that Israel occupied Palestine land and displaced them but since oct 7 brutal attack by Hamas to Israel, I started researching more on this conflict from historical perspective and my perception completely changed now. Jews were the one who were displaced from their historical land over the centuries when this land was under different empire including ottoman empire. Watching you explaining the history makes more sense than others.
My grandma served in the Haganah in Jerusalem in the 1940s into the war of independence as a medic. There is no one that experienced pre-Israel Jerusalem like her. She knows every street corner, every curve and every turn in the old city. She also lived as a kid in the 1930s in petah tikva. She says: Arab attitude towards Jews was ALWAYS violent and Jews never felt safe, especially in jerusalem. This whole myth that violence started suddenly after 1948 and that Arabs are so peaceful, it’s a complete and total fabrication.
My grandma is an Iraqi jew and it's the same story there, again, way before the state of Israel was established. She was abducted twice, thrown off her own roof, and almost rap*d by a Muslim mob that specifically targeted jewish girl schools. She and her sister were saved by their own father, who was gravely injured and blinded for life. They were forced to leave all their belongings in Iraq and flee to Israel, where they lives in refuge camp's tents for ten years. Again, not something that is ever taught.
I will say it’s not 1940 anymore …and in the modern world we see Palestinians live in a concentration camp and have to endure constant bombardment and can’t leave because of Jim Crow laws.
I’m a none Jewish from the United Kingdom and I’m so worried and saddened for Israel and it’s people, I’m also very afraid what’s happening in the United Kingdom that our government and police are letting Hamas supporters protest on our streets inciting violence and hatred on Remembrance Sunday, my people fought and died in WW2 for all humanity. I’m absolutely devastated and disgusted .
You ‘silent’ majority cannot stay silent you also need to march for your values or you will lose your country, let the police and politicians know your disgust by protesting yourselves . Take back your country!
The protests in western world is concerning. It's one thing to protest and another for to call for "Jihad" or "Intifada". People who came as refugees from war ridden countries (the hypocrisy not to protest against a Muslim country that fought your country, but only when it is Israel), are calling for war on their refuge city. It's also scary how misinformed they are, out of ignorance.. I saw sign that says "75 years of occupation and raping".. I mean, not only you are completely factualy wrong about 75 years of occupation (unless you don't acknowledge Israel as a state, but then again, why are expecting Israel to stop the war if you don't acknowledge it ?).. but RAPING ?!?!?!?!? where did that came from lol.. they really don't want me to get into statistics about Arabs raping Jewish women vs Jews raping Arab women..
@@gal2659there should be a simple rule: if you live in a democracy, you don't spread dictatorships' propaganda, you live in a secular country, you don't prefer religious laws to the ones you are supposed to abide. If you breed much and intend to become a majority and to impose the rules of the lovely country they come from, should go to where that rules exist - their lovely country. And because I was born and live in Eastern Europe, when I talk to people from Asia and the Middle East, I don't buy into the colonialism blame game, it's been many decades, it's time to take responsibility for their fate
I am spanish living in Uk and I am in shock for what is happening on the streets. I love this country, it has given me everything. Me and my kids have integrated in this culture, we participate in all celebrations and events. It is scaring that people do not respect the country they have opened the arms for them.
I often here about the Nakba from my Arab friends but have never heard it from this point of view. This was really eye opening. I appreciate you providing a wider perspective so respectfully!
Thank you for this educational video!!! ❤ I `m from Germany and stand with Israel and the Jewish people. This kind of information helps me in challenging conversations with pro palestinians. Be blessed!
Why did you let millions of muslims into your country? have you studied their history of hate against Christians and Jews? this religion has been at war with Europe since the 8th Century! I am Just being honest
its fake educational video. the 6 day war was alos fake. Zionist cant even invade a open air prison in 30 days. they need 100 billion from the U.S. you is a moron if that make sense to you.
I stand with humanity. I wouldn't commit '7 October'. I wouldn't bomb innocent women and children in Gaza. I stand with the Jewish and Palestinian people. If it was up to me all Palestinians could return to their homes and live in peace with the Jews. The human species is a tragic one. There will never be peace in Israel. That is almost a fact that everybody will agree on, I'm afraid.😪
It's an offshoot of the muslim brotherhood created by Hasan al-Banna YS, but was indeed supported by the oh-so-clever secular Israeli government in an effort to undermine Fatah. That effort worked to some extent, but ultimately backfired and led to October 7. The Torah instructs how to neutralise Amalek properly. @@halimaakbar5530
Thanks for making this video, I've encountered your videos before but couldn't get over the historical tragedy happened to Palestinians and how could Israelis kick out Palestinians, so I really appreciate that you talk about this. What I like the most is that you try to support your argument with details instead of quick glossing-overs. Respect. Please keep making more videos, you are making a difference.
When the 1948 War broke out, the Israeli government published a front page article in the local paper calling on the Arabs to stay & promising them equal rights as citizens. The fact is they left on their own for various reasons, some because they were scared & some because they were told to evacuate temporarily by he Arab leadership.
Thank you a lot for your videos! I am an Arab and an Ex-Muslim and can only confirm the hate that "my people" have towards the Jews. Never understood it and never will. 99% of them never opened a book to read history. In my home country in the 1940s jews were followed and forced to leave their home and houses and everything, yet no mainstream media talks about that. The Arabs and the lefties try very hard to re-write the history to make it as such, as if the arabs/muslims are alway the innocent, helpless ones. I salute you and hope one day I can visit israel.
You have a good heart. Thank you. Everyone needs to shake the past and create a multiethnic society in which each culture and spiritual beliefs thrive. We are all made from the same material.
The Institute for Palestine Studies, an Arab organization based in Beirut stated, *68% of Arabs left their villages without ever seeing a Jewish man with a gun or a soldier* Search, *_"How we really became refugees, 13 Palestinians tell their personal stories"_* Mamoud Abbas and 12 others from all over Israel, tell the truth about why and how they left the villages and houses and it wasn't because of the Jews.
The problem is however they weren't allowed to return home after the war, when they came back settlers had moved into their houses. It's not nice fleeing an area when a war breaks out, and then after the war ends when you return to your home someone else is living there.
They were allowed "home." Name any villages where people were forbidden for returning. The majority of those 68% were immigrants from neighboring countries (the majority of the population of both Israel and Palestine is consisted of immigrant families who moved because they were promised economic opportunities by the British), so most of them were just going back to where they lived a few decades ago. It'd be as if Jews moved to Israel, then went back to Europe when the war started, and decided to stay -- that's not being kicked out.@@randomhuman2595
Never seen attitude of Israel to conquer "historically our" land. They always were ok with status quo, as long as neighbours don't wage war. They also never waged war first. They developed by themselves, and built better standards of living, rather than focusing on their neighbours. Arguments like "Gaza is prison" are ridiculous, and have nothing to do with Israel. Blaming other people for your failures and waging war because of it is enough for me to pick side.
It's simple, as with all things made by man (or managed and interpreted) some cultures are bound to be inferior. The Medina Muslim bound gaged and killed the Mecca Muslim. He did it so long ago that the Mecca Muslim never existed.
oren, thank you very much for addressing this heinous video from VOX. I know it might not make much sense, but Americans love graphic arts. When I saw this video for the first time, I almost lost my mind. I lived in Israel for almost a year while studying history at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. I am so grateful you made this.
It is so wild how much propaganda is out there, especially on alternative media. There is always some grey area to consider - but i can't wrap my head around the Hamas support ... maybe i am too German. This video however seems quite objective with one little qualm i have: It is always the Arabs starting the conflict.
@@HansWurst-gm2rx The support is for the Palestinians, not Hamas, but there is a general recognition that Hamas is a symptom of the way the Gaza Palestinians have been treated since 2006, and the Palestinians in general since 1948.
@@nickfish8345unfotunatly I heard meny ppl in the pro-Palastinian protests also support Hamas 'actions of resistance'. It seams most of the world forgot, or regected what Hamas has been doing (to both sides) ever since it took over Gaza...
@@nickfish8345 I think many people want to support the idea of peace and liberty and so they are on the free Palestine bandwagon which often leads to inadvertently or directly supporting Hamas. Hamas is not Palestine. But Hamas is in control of the strip and the governing body of it at the moment... Any support to that region goes through them and therefore goes to them. One of Israel's biggest problems in this war is propaganda, Israel knows it, they are very careful. We need to educate those people, ask if they know what they are supporting and have they listened to Hamas? Hamas at least say very clearly what they want. The history has been done and cannot be changed, we can only find a solution when we go forward.
@@HansWurst-gm2rx There are always rogue agents on a) sides of conflicts. I understand from this video that starting conflicts was never the policy of the leadership of the Jews.
The video is a rehash of a commonly employed false counter narrative that has been repeatedly debunked by Israeli historians themselves. If you want to see a contemporary direct response referencing material far better than this video does, lonerbox on RU-vid just did one.
A RU-vidr(not historian) that goes by Lonerbox has made a very well researched response. He seems to have found the sources Oren is using and they seem Questionable to say the least. Definitely worth checking out
I'm Australian with a Turkish background and have seen much negativity at the hands of my "fellow" Arabs and Muslims. I was abused mentally, verbally, physically, and sexually all at the hands of my own people. We are our own worst enemies. I hope somewhere down the line we can break free from these ideological shackles and live in peace but I fear this won't be possible for centuries to come. To my Jewish brothers and sisters let us not give up on each other, there are people out there who know the truth and want peace and progression!
I’m sorry you’ve had to go through those things🤍 I hope you find healing. Thank you for your support, as an Israeli Jewish, you have really warmed my heart. May we find peace🌎🕊️ amen🙏✨
I appreciate the high caliber style and integrity in the way you address these emotionally charged issues. My heart is filled with gratitude because I am now able to clearly see and understand how easy it is to be manipulated by others as well as the media to think, feel, and behave in predictable ways by “spinning” out of context information & creating a heart wrenching emotionally charged story around it. I support you and your work 100%.
He do Zionist propaganda and you are ignorant of the truth , right now Isrrael do revenge over the terrorist doing terrorist act , is not justice but revenge, starving people man women and children is genocide and a war crime , Israel is no better than the terrorist.
@featherweldon3632 That's not how that works. What's wrong with you? Lol, you need to cite your sources. That's why in academia, I can't write a paper and tell reviewers to just Google it! He's making all sorts of claims that are controversial. You should be more curious about exactly how he came to his conclusion. In college, we call this critical thinking.
You literally just google what he has said and look up the actual incidences in things like the encyclopedia brittanica. I have an undergraduate degree, I understand that you need to cite your sources, but it’s also not that hard to look any of this up. Also what’s wrong with me? What’s wrong with you? You’re the one who can’t seem to figure out how to google and then search this information from there. He gave dates and names for everything he said, so follow up and do the research yourself.
Not every progressive thinks that way, some of us actually learn history. You’ve done a great job here just laying out facts without emotional attachment. In the end emotions fade but the facts remain.
Knowing liberals, they love to jump to the defense of a supposed victim. Look how gullible they are when it comes to false accusations without really wanting evidence or even digging deeper or even care to following up on a story. They hear Palestinians are being bullied by the bigger Israel, they hear "free Palestine" and "genocide", but if you dig even a little bit it's very apparent Palestinians are the ones who wish for genocide.
Dude you might be the best channel on this platform. I absolutely love how you destroy people with facts and you don’t get emotional. People get upset and attack you but never offer any actual counter argument thus proving your point.
"I absolutely love how you destroy people with facts and you don’t get emotional." I really admire your choice of words here. Fits in the current situation. "Destroy people"... hmmm you really nailed it there.
שיתפתי, כמובן. כל כך חשוב. תמשיך בבקשה לעושת כאלה סרטים, ופשוט כל הכבוד לך שאתה משקיע כל כך הרבה. חייבת לומר, שמעולם לא התעמקתי בהיסטוריה של ישראל, והיות אני משלימה את ההשכלה, אפילו במעט, בעזרת תוכניות כמו שלך. הרבה מאוד ידע לא נכון האכילו אותי כל השני, אבל זו הייתה בעיקר אשמתי, כי אני צרכתי. אז זהו..תודה
Wow, thank you. I used to be more on the pro Palestinian side but as I’ve been doing more research I definitely can’t help but stand by Israel now. Thank you and others for speaking the truth. Keep doing the good work no matter how hard it is. There is hope for some.
@@isaacneumannhaving a PhD doesn't mean someone is not going to lie. Everything the guy has stated in this clip is historically verified and true. If your guy says otherwise, he's lying...
@@isaacneumann Could not have said this better. I watch Oren’s videos to gain an understanding of how others view this conflict, but that is very different from factual reality. What we choose to believe is very important. Theres a quote from a dystopian fiction book that reads “One generation to change the text. One generation chooses to teach that text. The next grows, and the lie becomes history.”
@@isaacneumann Sadly alot of the comments are written by fake accounts made from the hesbara. To push pro Israel's propaganda and help with the algorthims to spread misinformation. Sadly, they have the money to push any narative to uneducated people's minds. A very dark moment of history of man kind. I hope palestinians will have their justice upon their barbaric oppressors.
As someone who studied 'international studies' with a major in middle east, I always find your videos not only absolutely on point but I think you you present history in a way that is very clear that holds channels like VOX accountable. I hope you and your family are safe. I'm in Bat Yam and things are challenging right now but I have faith in our IDF. Stay well.
It's important to hear directly from some former Israeli IDF soldiers themselves, about what it is they do to Palestinian people ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-37MFa7ZKQWo.html
I appreciate your insights and knowledge on Israel, your country and culture is INCREDIBLE, and I am grateful to have found you on RU-vid. The next time I am in Israel, I hope to have you lead our team. Praying for you and your country ❤
To what he said in 7:54 / 25:07 there is no concrete evidence or proof "Atlas aimed at establishing an intelligence-gathering base in Mandatory Palestine, radioing information back to Germany, and recruiting and arming anti-British Palestinians by buying their support with gold." "Historian Wolfgang G. Schwanitz has cast doubts on the story: The claim that the mufti got "ten containers with poison" to kill a quarter of a million people via the water system of Tel Aviv in exchange for the five Palestinian paratroopers in late 1944 (61) is not substantiated in British or German sources. If the authors can now show really hard proof, this would be a discovery, since the British police report of 1944 on file is very detailed." "Historian Christian Destremau points out that the cargo contained no such quantities of toxic material, but only poison capsules, probably to be of service in attempts to liquidate locals believed to be collaborating with the Mandatory Authorities.[12] According to MI5 files, the parachutists brought three types of poison to Palestine: some suicide pills for themselves, six tubes of powder to put tracking dogs off their scent (they didn't realise this was poisonous and kept it with their food) and an envelope of "arseneous oxide". Regarding these latest, Wieland said that the mufti insisted it be brought for the purpose of eliminating Arab traitors but Latif denied it was the mufti's idea. The 400-page files do not mention any intention to poison population or enough quantities for such a plan." This hoax originated from the book "The Quest for the Red Prince" This why I find the Israel-Palestine situation so difficult because it's hard to find many non biased and accurate sources
funnily enough it's from that same wikipedia article he showed i find it funny that people called him nuanced or not biased when he does something like this
Thank you for addressing the misinformation on Vox point by point. As usual your clarity is enlightening. You have only to look at what they say in their charters and to the Arab violence throughout history, not only to Israel, but to others such as Christians and to each other to see the difference in life values. Being a perpetual, multi-generational refugee is very profitable. Keep up your most excellent work!
Thank you very much for everything! It was precisely because of this video that I wrote to you on Instagram and I even received the video. Vox also made a video about the Gaza Strip, which is also completely out of context. I really like Israel and the only way I can at least somehow help is to talk to people and you help me a lot to show people everything in context. I can't wait to see Israel again. I wish you all the best from Prague.
This guy is lying through his teeth. I'm not even 4 minutes into the video and almost everything he said is a very sly twisting of the narrative and all kinds of tricks and even pure lying. Go at least read the Deir Yassin Wikipedia page for yourself to see how much this dude is lying. For starters, I'll refute 2 points he made about Deir Yassin: 1) "the casualties were low". They were between 18% (the lowest estimate by pro-Israeli sources) and 41% (the highest estimate by pro-palestinian sources) of the population in the event. 2) "they talk about Deir Yassin because there is no other examples, it's like saying Deir Yassin, etc etc, when you have nothing else to say". No, the reason everyone mentions Deir Yassin is because it was THE START of the nakba and because it was absolutely heinous act, where Israeli military unit attacked a village near Jerusalem which specifically was in peace with Jews, they had peace agreements with them, they had no intention of fighting vs Jews, and they had no militants or anyone to defend them, and also because the plan for the attack on Deir Yassin wasn't simply "taking over power centers/buildings and occupying it", but instead "forcing all people out of the village, and if anyone refused, whether women or old people or children, doesn't matter, then kill those". So yeah, it was a pure ethnic cleansing and terror attack on specifically a village who had friendly relations to jews. The whole village (600 people) were either killed (107-250 of them) or kicked out of the village. There are disagreements whether there was also raping in Deir Yassin, but even without it it was absolutely the most heinous act and also there WERE raping overall in the nakba, even IF it didn't happen in Deir Yassin.
I'm not sure that's really happening on a massive scale, at least not with Vox. Western media is still overwhelmingly lenient to Israel, but I would say luckily an increasing amount of people can see through that and realize Israel isn't as innocent as the sugarcoated Western narrative makes it out to be. Really the truth is always more complex than any media outlet paints it as.
I have blocked all media with a pi-hole and WireGuard tunnel. That world does not exist to me. And neither does the truth. I can find plenty of great scholars who present the case for Palestinians. I can find plenty for the case of Israel. And many who fit in between. This is not a problem of "media".
just imagine that until 1965 they didn't even have an anthem. The overwhelming majority didn't even recognize itself as Palestinians. Palestinian nationalism only sparked after the 6 day war when they realized they are David now in the David vs Goliath story
Companies like Vox are teaching *revisionist* history since the people there are left ‘liberals’ who were taught the same disinformation at their prestigious universities by their left ‘liberal’ professors. The Ayn Rand Institute did a good video explaining why the left hates Israel.
My dad's best friend fought at Deir Yassin as part of the Lehi. He was not above admitting to other acts of terror he had performed as part of that group - but always insisted that Deir Yassin was a battle, not a massacre. In fact, they warned the people of Deir Yassin to leave multiple times before the battle started. My dad, who was 5 years old and lived very close to the village, remembers hearing the trucks driving around and calling out with loudspeakers, for hours before the attack.
Definitely a battle. That town wasn’t neutral as claimed, it overlooked the TelAviv-Jerusalem road & some attacks against aid convoys on their way to relieve the besieged jews in Jerusalem came from Dayr Yassin. There were militants there from other Arab nations, like Iraq. The Israeli militias involved took casualties and 5 KIA’s. 5/6ths of the villagers took the loudspeaker warnings seriously and fled and the Israelis took 200 prisoners they later released. Never heard of a village massacre where most the population survived. But Palestinian authorities lied about Dayr Yassin so hard that they must maintain that lie, because the rumors were a driving force in sending thousands of arabs fleeing the region.
@@ShakaCthulu It was not only the Arabs lying about it. The Haganah had a vested interest in sabotaging both the Etzel and the Lehi - they parroted the narrative as hard as the Arabs did. Also, from my understanding there was at least a company of Iraqis camped at Deir Yassin that day, with several machine guns.
Your dads best friend fought at Deir Yassin and your dad was 5 when it happened. So child soldiers for Zionists were normal during that time? What a convincing story...
I have to say, I had my doubts on this conflict and who was in the right. After watching all your videos multiple time and fact checking them with plenty of other resources I feel like I have a pretty decent picture of the situation. It’s a shame how much people fall for palestinian propaganda about the partition and the whole conflict. I respect you Oren, and I hope that your family and your community make it out of this war safely. Support from Italy
Same 🙌🏼 I was so curious why all the fuss over this conflict and learned Israel is absolutely right in its claims and palestinians are nothing but liars and whiners
I respect you for taking time to study and form an opinion. More than 99% that watch a 10 seconds news excerpt or TikTok video. People like you are the hope in this world.
Oren, you are an eloquent teacher. I am piecing together the gaps not taught in popular history to understand modern conflicts. You are giving perspective to the narratives I'm fed in the west. I'm an atheist with a muslim name.... British born, but critical of the post colonial chaos across the world. Keep up the good work.
American Jew age 68. I learned the Zionist version of this history in Hebrew School, learned the Palestinian "correction" as an adult. Thank you for this detailed and nuanced explanation of historical fact - I'm relieved, frankly, that reality lands closer to the former than the latter. עם ישראל חי
If you encounter jews that support palestine at America, they are blatantly lying and are just against the state of Israel and trying to side with Palestinians which is a way that benefits them and they know if Palestinians get the support they want, that would mean the destruction of the state which is their goal
the Zionist is 2 face snakes every thing they say is fake. victim mentality always make shit up. dont make fake story up. just say White jews want to kill people and steal they land. stop playing the victim card every one starting to see right true this fake shit
"If I were an Arab leader, I would never sign a treaty with Israel. It's normal; we took their land. It's true that it was promised to us by God, but how should they care? Our God is not their God. There were anti-Semites, the Nazis, Hitler, Auschwitz, but was it their fault? They only see one thing: We came and stole their land. Why should they accept that?" in Le Parade (The Jewish Par 121 -BEN GURION-
"When we say that the Arabs are the aggressors and we defend ourselves - this is only half the truth. As regards our security and life we defend ourselves and our moral and physical position is not bad. We can face the gangs... and were we allowed to mobilize all our forces we would have no doubts about the outcome... But the fighting is only one aspect of the conflict which is in its essence a political one. And politically we are the aggressors and they defend themselves. Militarily, it is we who are on the defensive who have the upper hand but in the political sphere they are superior." ~DAVID BEN-GURION
As a Russian, I support Israeli struggle against Hamas. I found myself in situation similar in a lot of ways to Palestinians in February last year. I was locked in a country that is ruled by criminal regime, with extremely powerful propaganda, with the entire world hating us etc. And even though I might not agree with everything that west and Ukraine are doing, I can still think for myself and realize that Russia is at fault here. And neither I, nor any thinking person in Russia complain about Ukraine bombing Russian cities in retaliation to aggression. And I wouldn’t complain if the US came and bombed Moscow in order to overthrow Putin’s regime. Of course, a lot of people in Russia think otherwise and prefer to trust propaganda instead of common sense but it’s their choice, they are not victims of circumstance, they choose not to think because it’s easier. You cannot present sheer human stupidity and intellectual laziness as “the other side of the story”. My heart goes to those people in Palestine who realize that Hamas are criminals, who condemn their actions and either actively or passively resist them. Hope Israel frees Gaza!
"thinking person" Thinking person means people brainwashed by Western propaganda? "And I wouldn’t complain if the US came and bombed Moscow in order to overthrow Putin’s regime." You probably would have sided with the Nazis during World War II, like the Ukrainian fascists you hero-worship. You are a traitor to your own country.
Thank you for this , you really make me think about the innocent people caught up in these wars. Being Bulgarian myself I can thoroughly sympathise with the position of Russian people like yourself stuck in Russia.
More people should talk about this subject! The reason why the current repporting is so scewed in favour of Hamas is because ppl don't understand the origin of Israel. Please, keep making videos like this one❤ much support from Poland 🇵🇱 ❤
Contemporary Jew hating mainly from two groups. The largest ofcourse is Muslims. No comments needed, Islam is their motivation. The second one is from those so called "less fortunate" the jealous one on the Left who paint Jews as rich Capitalist controlling and oppressing the world with their bunkers 💰 Well... I Have to mention another peculiar group.... The Conspiracy Theorists they are not politically or religiously motivated just a garden verity losers who needs to blame someone else for their laziness and incompetence....
belive me most Polish people do not support Israel. Funny how many hotels in Poland banned Israeli turists as they behave like animals. I never heard about hotel banning Arabs
I'm in the UK and have been shocked by two things - firstly, the utterly despicable terrorist attacks on Israel, and, secondly, the almost immediate cheering by pro-Palestinians. How can anyone celebrate this? In the face of these football chants of 'free Palestine', I decided to learn more about the issues, not least because I want to be able to give the balanced and proportinate story to my children. Oren, what you have put together here is first class. I've learned more from you about Israel in half an hour than I learned from years working in all of your neighbouring countries! Hats off to you and keep these coming!
It's basically zionist propaganda look up the video on tantura where the jews, veterans of 1948 talk about thr massacre of that town and how there was a plan to intimidate the arabs into leaving. The plan was to use violence so that the next town up the road heard about it and fled if they didn't they'd be killed. The documentary features mainly Jewish people and the few arabs who lived there. They give a completely different side to this simpletons account
I never thought I would want to make a RU-vid video, but when i watched the Vox video and how selectively it was presented I was starting to gather information to refute it on RU-vid. Thank you for obviating the need for me to do so.
Can't thank you enough for taking the time to make these videos. You are doing a service countering the propaganda that is really overwhelming right now.
Oren, I cannot begin to tell you how important it is what you are doing. Your training and experience as a tour guide has made it so that you can explain these parts of history in a way that is easy to understand, and with a calm demeanor that makes people listen. I have children who go to American universities, and I am sharing your videos with them and their friends to spread your lessons. The abhorrent lies are unfortunately becoming accepted facts, and too many young people don't know the truth. And it makes them either cower in silence and fear, or at worst, join the anti-Israel mobs. We are just too close to reaching a point in history where the relationship between the far left and the Arab world may gain the upper hand in an ongoing war against the Jews, by disseminating such vicious contortions of history.
You realize he's arguing with things that he made up? He's playing a part of a video, then twists their words and then refutes those things that he made up himself, and then acts as if he refuted what was said in the video. He's openly lying and twisting thee narrative and nobody is even checking his wild claims. Go at least read the Deir Yassin wikipedia to see the truth. It was absolutely heinous act and it wasn't a single time, the reason why it's talked about is because it was the most inhuman act, attacking the peaceful population, who had a peace agreement with the Jewish forces, had no intention to participate in the any anti-jewish actions. Despite all those peace agreements, the Jewish military forced the whole village out and killing anyone who refused to leave, whether it's old folks or women or children. It was absolutely heinous plan that even some commanders in the Jewish military forces opposed it, and it was the start of nakba, that's why it's talked about the most. The reason why there were "so little casualties" is because it's a small village where only 600 people lived. Death estimates are 107-250. So it's between 18 to 40% of all residents killed.
It's important to hear directly from some former Israeli IDF soldiers themselves, about what it is they do to Palestinian people ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-37MFa7ZKQWo.html
It's important to hear directly from some former Israeli IDF soldiers themselves, about what it is they do to Palestinian people ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-37MFa7ZKQWo.html
US Questioned Over Israel's Use Of "Human Shields" in Gaza and the West Bank ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-oNWKggupwrc.htmlsi=sxdybscB3uEwNV7o
there's an interview with Golda Meir from 1967 where she was asked about the Palestinian people's right to have the entire region of 'Palestine', her answer was: "I'm a Palestinian, from 1941 to 1948 I walked around with a Palestinian passport", issued to her by the British empire that ruled the region of 'Palestine', which was inhabited by arabs (for centuries) and jews (for millennia). so yeah, by that definition, I, an Israeli jew, am also a 'Palestinian'. the difference is that jews actually have an ancient identity so we don't need to identify ourselves using arbitrary regional names assigned by an empire that conquered our region at some random point in history.
That would be the same as someone in Austria saying: 'at some point in time bohemia (part of the czech rep.) was part of my country, so we are entitled to that land'.....
Zuheir Mohsen of the PLO himself stated that there were "no differences between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians, and Lebanese", though Palestinian identity would be emphasised for political reasons. In a March 1977 interview with the Dutch newspaper Trouw he stated that "between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese there are no differences. We are all part of one people, the Arab nation [...] Just for political reasons we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity. Because it is of national interest for the Arabs to advocate the existence of Palestinians to balance Zionism. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons"
