Тёмный
No video :(

The Philosophy Of Ernst Jünger Storm Of Steel Review 

Chad A Haag Philosophy Channel
Подписаться 19 тыс.
Просмотров 4,4 тыс.
50% 1

Chad Haag lectures on Storm of Steel, total mobilization, the aestheticization of war, Nietzsche, and Evola's Metaphysics of War.
This video is for educational purposes alone. The purpose of this video is neither to promote nor refute any theories but rather to examine them from a strictly philosophical perspective. This is a response to a patron’s request within the School of Forbidden Texts. Remember, you can join us there for as little as just two dollars per month: / chadahaag

Опубликовано:

 

22 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 36   
@sadsackkvisling9694
@sadsackkvisling9694 3 года назад
Why is Junger important? Because as a man, he was both traditional and modern. He wasn't a monster, either, just a realist. His other works show a sensitivity to the fragility of life, the meaning of life in the face of extreme or destructive conditions, and questions of resistance or obedience to authority.
@lekal6247
@lekal6247 3 года назад
Copse 125 is the best followup from storm of steel! Go for it
@dannyiii146
@dannyiii146 3 года назад
That was a great review, thanks for posting! I recently read Junger's War as an Inner Experience, which he published 2 years after Storm of Steel. I found it to be on par with Evola's Metaphysics of War as far as warrior philosophy goes.
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329 3 года назад
Thanks I'll see if I can find a copy of this, sounds interesting
@sadsackkvisling9694
@sadsackkvisling9694 3 года назад
I could recommend "Frontsoldaten" by Steven G. Fritz or anything by Kurt Eggers
@jackfrank9257
@jackfrank9257 3 года назад
@Danny III Seconded.
@mostlydead3261
@mostlydead3261 3 года назад
Bataille admired that text of Jünger's. . called it a work of Mysticism..
@Timodj13
@Timodj13 3 года назад
Thank you so much for doing my request! This was an amazing insight and overview of my personal favorite thinker. Thanks Mr. Haag!
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329 3 года назад
Thanks sorry for the delay, more videos on junger etc coming soon
@naushadahmed8090
@naushadahmed8090 3 года назад
That Dragon Ball example was so excellent. Made me nostalgic.
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329 3 года назад
Yeah we all miss Toonami from 2001 (watching Gundam Wing, Dragon Ball Z, Outlaw Star etc. after school)
@Highlander_Red
@Highlander_Red Год назад
This was a great review man, I’ve read Storm of Steel and it is a great book. This video was all the more better because your voice sounded like the comic book guy from the Simpsons XD
@theflyingguillotine3788
@theflyingguillotine3788 2 года назад
Storm of steel reminded me alot of the illiad.
@anon2034
@anon2034 Год назад
Early Junger is better the late Junger. I think he got somewhat disheartened in his later years. Despite that all his work is good.
@panamahat5973
@panamahat5973 3 года назад
Big fan of yours, Chad. This is a seminal work of the reactionary canon, IMO. I hope things are going well in India, and that your wife is in good health. You two have a wonderful energy, and my own fiancée is also a fan. I will begin publishing my own books soon, and one of the places I'm considering moving to (life in the UK/US is no longer bearable) is India, like yourself. I will finish my philosophy degree next year, and want to embark on a similar path to you; what advice would you give, based on your own experiences? E.G. how did you manage to leave the west, re-settle and support yourself in a foreign country? Does your writing make up enough income for you? Keep up the good work!
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329 3 года назад
Thanks a lot, I would totally recommend relocating from the West if it's at all possible, as I am much better off financially, psychologically, and physically as a result of doing so. I think that moving abroad is much more complicated now due to travel restrictions but I think that there are still ways to do so out there, as honestly things were basically back to normal here in India just a few weeks ago. When I visited the southern tip of India in Tamil Nadu, I literally counted only one person wearing a mask in an enormous crowd of people there. My own way of leaving the West was through a spouse visa as my wife is a native of India; she applied for a visa to USA after we were married but it was rejected (honestly, they just want to blackmail people for tens of thousands of dollars, as my neighbor had to pay some 10 grand in legal bribes to bring a wife from the Philippines.) I can say that my writing makes a decent income here because the cost of living is so low compared to the West (i.e., 50 dollars per month to rent a small house etc.) Though even better than buying things for cheap has been just growing my own vegetables on the roof and raising my own chickens in the backyard for meat and eggs. I estimate about 80% of my vegetables are home grown and are of a far higher quality than the stuff on the Wal Mart shelf back in the USA. At any rate, I also encourage you to keep up the writing and I look forward to seeing the book when it's released.
@russellbyrnes7215
@russellbyrnes7215 3 года назад
It was quite eye opening reading my great grandfathers letters from WW1, in which he fought as a machine gunner in the ANZAC forces. The banality of it all jumps off the page, as well as the disregard for danger. He would often write of how they had been shot at or shelled and made it sound like it wasnt so bad, even relishing it as a bit of excitement to break up the long boring days. There are only sparse mentions of comrades who had died as sad but matter of fact footnotes. Similarly to Junger there is no hate of the enemy (called them all 'Fritz'), more of a sporting respect like they were engaged in a game of football. It's interesting how this changes for WW2 where there was so much more racialy motivated venom and atrocities committed amongst the soldiery, particularly in the Pacific theater and the Nazi/Soviet all time war scoreboard showdown on the eastern front.
@jarlnicholl1478
@jarlnicholl1478 3 года назад
I'm not if this is fair. Maybe early on but later in the war some of British propaganda was pretty brutal and dehumanizing, not too different from the WW2 material.
@samizdat8518
@samizdat8518 3 года назад
Thank you for all you do Chad.
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329 3 года назад
Thank you
@bobbyokeefe4285
@bobbyokeefe4285 5 месяцев назад
This text has aged like fine wine as they say,when you look at the current events unfolding in Gaza,where it's machine vs man essentially but one cannot help but ask two questions that come to mind,what is there to be done,I mean it's not like you can revert back to a state where an army can defy another army to meet up on some ground to duke it out with swords,shields and spears,secondly aren't swords,shields and spears a less complex form of technology(or what about the Elephants of Hannibal Barca,or the Byzantine's Greek Fire,or the Ottoman's cannons),hasn't technology always been part of humanity?and modern technology is just the logical step in our evolution,are modern men like Junger just whining about an idealised heroic(individualistic) past that never truly existed?in deed hasn't war always been about maximising your kills,with the least effort?
@rhysnichols8608
@rhysnichols8608 4 месяца назад
I can’t agree there, in the past technology was no where near as destructive and impersonal as it is today, human virtues mattered more, meeting an enemy spear to spear required skill, courage, athleticism etc, loading and firing a shell requires min of these virtues. To suggest that because humans have always utilised technology to varying degrees, that we’ve never been heroic is ridiculous. The destructive capacity of modern long range weapons is hundreds of times more deadly than a musket was, or a spear and sword were, and the virtues to fight using such weapons are much less than face to face with an enemy. There is something far more heroic about a cavalry charge or an open field battle with men testing their metal than modern war which is so industrialised it surpasses courage and virtue. While I agree the past is often over romanticised, it is true that warfare say under Napoleon offered more chance for heroism and glory than say ww1. Or ancient battles were no where near as impersonal and destructive as modern war, generally speaking.
@Cyclopsvision14
@Cyclopsvision14 3 года назад
Wow I just read this too. Going to bootcamp in a couple days. Synchronicity baby.
@iraklios5810
@iraklios5810 3 года назад
>that guy on /lit/ who keeps trying to force the meme Jünger was a liberal
@samizdat8518
@samizdat8518 2 года назад
Will you ever do Eumeswil?
@Evelyn-pe7kt
@Evelyn-pe7kt 3 года назад
>not reading the 1929 translation available now from Mystery Grove Publishing
@coolconfuzer
@coolconfuzer Год назад
Cover more about this book.
@bannerman3553
@bannerman3553 2 года назад
Great review, the book was great and every time I get a coffee I think of his love of that simple pleasure of coffee aroma in the morning and appreciate these things,,, watch 'Soylent Green' also to really appreciate the amazing pleasures we still have like water and nice dinner's.
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329 2 года назад
Thanks a lot for the comment, I'll keep this in mind the next time I drink a coffee
@gurjotsingh8934
@gurjotsingh8934 3 года назад
Waited for you Chad! When are you coming Punjab?
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329 3 года назад
I had been considering making a trip to Delhi, Punjab, and the Himalayas this April but of course the travel restrictions just happened to come back when my wife got summer vacation from teaching. She told me though that Punjab is pleasant to visit in the winter as she had went to see her aunt and uncle who live there some ten years ago, so I hope that I could make a trip there this December. I visited Assam and Shillong in December 2018 and actually really enjoyed that cold weather since I have live in this extreme heat in Kerala.
@gurjotsingh8934
@gurjotsingh8934 3 года назад
@@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329 yeah, it's very hot in summer. But anyhow things are getting crazy with the ongoing trajectory of events unfolding here. What do you think about this thing called "New world order", a conspiracy theory yeah, Is there any relation between the upcoming collapse and how the elites are getting more desperate than ever before in their endeavours to not let things get out of their hands. Third world and even the most rural villages of Punjab are developing, "growing" more than ever, Here groundwater is on an alarming level, this is a curse especially on a land who got its name by waters (five rivers- punj+aab), 3 of which are dead because of this dam that was considered the "temple of modern India", Bhakhra, which destroyed ecology and arctic species of rivers, and the rest two are no longer here cause it was the Punjab that got partitioned in 47. Apart from that, after the construction of the dam there came this "Green Revolution" thing, which destroyed basically traditional farming, destroyed villages, family structures and traditional values, as for example: it was considered a sin as great to sell milk as to sell ones own son, If you would visit any rural village, it was common for people to give a litre of milk to you. The indigenous dialects of the rural language are long lost. Many of the species of birds, as common as sparrows, and animals went extinct, thanks to the expansion. Main thing that happened with this Green Revolution was the natural seed of plants and crops got horrifically changed, which is now causing Cancer and many allergies and now the crops require artificial fertilisers, which disturbs the natural fertility of land and also of humans. In a nutshell, the traditional system got insidiously changed with the parasitical modern one and Now an entire generation of younger children are migrating to West, as "they don't see any future here", a lot things also get added onto it if you take account of the religion, if you account what happened in 47, in 84, after 84 military attack on highest temporal authority of Sikhism and how an entire generation was massacred and wiped out. And now, with the artificial drugs coming in, natural ones like opium, bhang, which were grown in ones own houses by the ancestors, being banned, rest of people dying from fentanyl, morphine etc doses. Modern India has been a disaster for tradition and nature basically. And now it's getting out of control, with this covid thing, more and more people getting "vaccinated", controlled, house arrested, forced to modernize, migrate to cities, forced to equip with gadgets that monitor you, be technologized. What do you think about the future?
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329 3 года назад
@@gurjotsingh8934 It's unfortunate to hear about all this, I just hope for the best but I suspect that much of this could be a temporary phenomenon and that things fueled (quite literally) by a fossil fuel surplus which won't last. For example, all the artificial pesticides, fertilizers etc. are derived directly from that, and without them people will have no choice except to revert to more traditional methods. Of course, the Midwest in the USA has been so badly mismanaged that it has been predicted it will become something of a North American Sahara which is quite scary
@devilspalm16
@devilspalm16 3 года назад
Which edition of storm of steel did you read? The Mystery Grove Press edition is an earlier English translation/publication from 1929. The Penguin press editions are from the 1960s and even Junger edited a number of passages to downplay the nationalism and glorification of war.
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329
@chadahaagphilosophychannel7329 3 года назад
I read the same edition as I used as the cover image, a Penguin edition that was cheaply available in India. I am sorry for not specifying this at the beginning of the video. I think doing another video comparing this to the 1929 translation would be good in the future.
Далее
Ernst Jünger - Storm of Steel BOOK REVIEW
32:50
Просмотров 25 тыс.
Pythagoras & His Weird Religious Cult
22:48
Просмотров 1 млн
E366 Navigating the Bible: Revelation
43:52
Просмотров 80 тыс.
Chariots and Changing Warfare in the Bronze Age
29:08
Aleksandr Dugin Fourth Political Theory Lecture
52:38
Просмотров 107 тыс.