I see it as Allah exists outside of time. So HE can perceive what will happen and what has happened and what could have happened at the same time. Moreover, when we look through a telescope into space we look at what WAS. We see what WAS there 100s or 1000s of years ago. Allah can see what we WILL do as time differs where Allah is and HE is outside of this and HE is able to see just as we can see what WAS. So where Allah is HE can perceive what WAS and what IS and what WILL BE. The future for us as we live it has already been seen due to Allah's position and majesty. So in that sense time has already finished but for us it is still happening at the same time.
Islam is hard-determinism, making choice an illusion,which means no free will. That all 5 muslim guys ignore/dismiss logic and reason is mind-boggling.
free will paradox in da deen -- alla wrote in book - al kitab everything a human will do before he creates the rooh (soul), then rooh (soul) is created and placed on earth --- the individual now follows the pre set program alla wrote down in book (kitab) - just like a robot would -- so if a person apostates , alla wrote that in the book before he even creates the apostate soul. so the said apostate never had any choice
Hey , yeah like banging your head against the wall to make then see this. You also get hadith like this sunnah.com/muslim/46/47 *"'A'isha, the mother of the believers, said that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) was called to lead the funeral prayer of a child of the Ansar. I said: Allah's Messenger, there is happiness for this child who is a bird from the birds of Paradise for it committed no sin nor has he reached the age when one can commit sin. He said: 'A'isha, per adventure, it may be otherwise, because God created for Paradise those who are fit for it while they were yet in their father's loins and created for Hell those who are to go to Hell. He created them for Hell while they were yet in their father's loins."*
This makes no sense and I will explain why. A teacher makes predictions (high probabilities based on previous facts) but his predictions do not always happen the way the teacher predicts (some students surprise their teachers). Allah KNOWS before someone is born that he is going to the fire (nothing surprises him because he knows beforehand); why the need to play games with that human when Allah knows that he will be terrorized in hell by Allah after he dies? For humans, we have a choice; for Allah we follow a program (he is omniscient). Allah KNEW Adam and Eve would eat the forbidden fruit BEFORE he created them. He created them and put the forbidden fruit there to troll them because he knew they would eat from it. Allah plays more by telling them not to eat from it or they will be punished. After they ate it, they got PUNISHED. They got punished because they follow Allah’s program before they were born. It is totally nonsensical; more like a human-made story. Before God created an entity who was called Satan (shaytan), Allah knew Satan would fail at a certain hour, minute and second. Why to create an entity to be hated by Allah, the angels, human beings and that entity will be forever terrorized by Allah after the Second Coming? Is that a god of love? If you knew the future and you see that your son will rape your mother, torture little girls and boys in your community and make many people unhappy; will you bring that son to this world or would you choose not to get your wife pregnant? Allah did it on purpose and he made a big hell of fire to threaten all those who would dare have critical thinking. WAKE UP AND STOP TRYING TO COVER THE SUN WITH ONE FINGER.
