The question is NOT answered: Why would Allah create a human knowing that human will go to the fire (and Allah knows about it before that human is produced)? Allah brought that human to life to fail and be eternally tortured. Allah did that with the intention to torture that human after he dies because Allah knows the future results even before we are born.
@@electro639 The choice is still there. Even he knows before producing that human in particular,Allah gives a opportunity this human to be a good person and go to janna eternally. We have the examples of the enemies of the prophets ,they had everything in this life and even the prophet has been in their lives and still they choose the wrong way.
@@mahama998no the choice is not there. Only what Allah wills happens. So these people who reject never had a choice to accept because them rejecting was ultimately Allah's will.
Well I wrote a page on this when I was thinking about it and I’ll put down my core ideas. Firstly what changes us from being straight up destined to go to heaven or hell is the ability to make conscious thought out decisions, free will. All of us are able to make decisions that will take us to heaven. You also must consider how far the question expands. Basically when you boil it down to its core, the fact that you were created at all- regardless of gods knowledge,the question claims all the events that lead you here could not have been changed, it’s all pre determined. It expands to atheism. Lastly, to stick true to this idea of the question would be to say everyones deeds are to be blamed on god. When you see a child rapist, instead of thinking “this person is disgusting and deserves no mercy” you must think “it’s unfortunate god made him that way” Ultimately, the best answer I can give you is that only god truely knows. I think it’s called Quroon or something, all I can do is differentiate between the idea that you were created to go to heaven or hell from how it actually is. It isn’t like 1+1=2.
سبحان الله عدد ماخلق سبحان الله ملء ماخلق سبحان الله عدد مافي السموات والارض سبحان الله ملء مافي السموات والارض سبحان الله عدد ما أحصى كتابه سبحان الله ملء ما أحصى كتابه سبحان الله عدد كل شيء سبحان الله ملء كل شيء الحمد الله عدد ماخلق الحمد الله ملء ماخلق الحمد الله عدد مافي السموات والارض الحمد الله ملء مافي السموات والارض الحمد الله عدد ما أحصى كتابه الحمد الله ملئ ما أحصى كتابه الحمد الله عدد كل شيء الحمد الله ملء كل شيء الله أكبر عدد ماخلق الله أكبر ملء ماخلق الله أكبر عدد مافي السموات والارض الله أكبر ملء مافي السموات والارض الله أكبر عدد ما أحصى كتابه الله أكبر ملء ما أحصى كتابه الله أكبر عدد كل شيء الله أكبر ملء كل شيء لا إله إلا الله عدد ما خلق لا إله إلا الله ملء ما خلق لا إله إلا الله عدد مافي السموات والأرض لا إله إلا الله ملء مافي السموات والأرض لا إله إلا الله عدد ما أحصى كتابه لا إله إلا الله ملء ما أحصى كتابه لا إله إلا الله عدد كل شيء لا إله إلا الله ملء كل شيء استغفر الله عدد ماخلق استغفر الله ملءماخلق استغفر الله عدد مافي السموات والارض استغفر الله ملء مافي السموات والارض استغفر الله عدد ما احصى كتابه استغفر الله ملء ما احصى كتابه استغفر الله عدد كل شيء استغفر الله ملءكل شيء لاحول ولاقوة إلا بالله عدد ماخلق لاحول ولاقوة إلا بالله ملءماخلق لاحول ولاقوة إلا بالله عدد مافي السموات والأرض لاحول ولاقوة إلا بالله ملء مافي السموات والأرض لاحول ولاقوة إلا بالله عدد ماأحصى كتابه لاحول ولاقوة إلا بالله ملء ماأحصى كتابه لاحول ولاقوة إلا بالله عدد كل شيء لاحول ولاقوة إلا بالله ملء كل شيء
I dont get it, i mean, my question is that if somethimg goes wrong in my life, am i to blame myself and the choices made? or put it all on predestination?
Asslamwalekum but then there is a group which says that we don't have choice it Allah who decides everything.... Now there is a possibility of this opinion as well as some are created to be prophets some are created to be martyrs and so on so forth so where is the choice... It's really very confusing... Anyways....la hawla quwata illah billah...
The speaker answer is contradicting their own teaching that Gods will precedes mans will..zakir naik because of his lack of proper knowledge in Aqidah many times said(he chooses it he decide to do it pertaining to man NOt Gods will..speakees should focus on dawah and stay away from islamic sciences(fiq(
This is not all true.Everything was written by Allah 50,000 years before anything was ever created.Quran 57:22 No evil falls on the Earth or in one's own soul,but it is in a book before we bring it into existence so that you may not grieve for what has escaped you.
The question is NOT answered: Why would Allah create a human knowing that human will go to the fire (and Allah knows about it before that human is produced)? Allah brought that human to life to fail and be eternally tortured. Allah did that with the intention to torture that human after he dies because Allah knows the future results even before we are born.
very nicely Explained, but this is just a lil bit idea that how Allah thinks. We Can't even comprehend. May Allah bless us all, And may Allah spread this channel's msg to all human kind so that it give hidaya to the wrong doing people
❤This can clearly understand if we apply physics to it. This world working according to the Time. In other universe (example: in heaven), there may be dimension which not depend upon time,may be other things like gravity or something which Only Allah knows. Soo my logic says, that may be the reason that people in heaven having a constant age of 33 & ISAA (عليه سلام) will come in age of 33(because the time not be a part for them). Also can compare with Miraj journey of Muhammad(pbuh). If we travel at speed of light or more than that and reach some other dimensions,we can see our past or we will be a person having future knowledge. When we say, ' Allah knows in Advance', Allah is in the Future with all knowledge in an another dimension which is not affected by time. Also we can see this science in the Movie 'Interstellar' . Think with logic & with science. We have limitations to think, Only Allah(The Creator) knows the Best❤🤗
Alhamdulillah,Alhmadulillah,Alhamdulillah. i really can't stop thanking Allah for everything.This video has really made things that were unclear vivid to me.May Allah continue to bless us the people that posted this video.Ameen
I am watching this video because there is a man I wanted to marry who walked away from me but I wanted to marry him. his name is Mahmood. for all of you reading this please pray for us. if it's not good for me may Allah keep it away.
This is a very difficult question! Perhaps the only answer is: Say: He is Allah, the One and Only; Allah, the Eternal, Absolute; He begetteth not, nor is He begotten; And there is none like unto Him. (Surah Al-Ikhlas)
Allah has ILm of Gaib. Allah already knows what is going to happen in future.He has the knowledge of the past , the present and the future, that is beyond human imagination and comprehension.
yeah i just thought the same, because what he said, it's like Allah is not doing any thing and just watching us, and it's only us doing things and get the results. i'm not agree with that, because Allah is not idle, not just watching us, if we doing things and get the results it's still all of it because of Allah grant us to do that and get that result
Thus video confuses 'knowledge of Allah' with 'qadr' - they are separate and distinct concepts. Qadr relates to Allah's 'active involvement' in our world and lives.
This is what I don't get about people. They try to think like God. They try to understand God. Just because of their limited human thinking using verbs, vowels, expert in both Arabic and English, they think they figure it all. We will never have the knowledge Allah has.
I can't read Arabic, but all the English translations of Quran I have read strongly imply that Allah has pre-decided everything, without defining the word predestination definitively. All I know is the concept is crazy and therefore could not have come from Allah.
How is it an issue? Qadr before creation like in sura Al kalam, them manifestation of creation, then day of resurrection, hell or heaven and we humans are here to testify qadrullah! Imagine you create something with end a to b, you now everything about it, the beings in it have a sense, feeling of free will or not, that's all. Isn't that not easy to comprehend?
