Тёмный

The REAL reason Hitler killed Ernst Röhm in the Night of the Long Knives 

TIKhistory
Подписаться 352 тыс.
Просмотров 237 тыс.
50% 1

Some still paint the clash between Hitler and Ernst Röhm as a clash between two distinct ideologies, whereas the reality is far more intriguing. So this video provides evidence for the reason Adolf Hitler initiated the Night of the Long Knives in 1934.
This video is discussing events or concepts that are academic, educational and historical in nature. This video is for informational purposes and was created so we may better understand the past and learn from the mistakes others have made.
Follow me on Instagram / tikhistory
The thumbnail for this video was created by Terri Young / tessdailyttv
⏲️ Videos on Mondays at 5pm GMT (depending on season, check for British Summer Time).
- - - - -
📚 BIBLIOGRAPHY / SOURCES 📚
Specific sources used in this video docs.google.com/spreadsheets/...
Full list of all my sources docs.google.com/spreadsheets/...
- - - - -
⭐ SUPPORT TIK ⭐
This video isn't sponsored. My income comes purely from my Patreons and SubscribeStars, and from RU-vid ad revenue. So, if you'd like to support this channel and make these videos possible, please consider becoming a Patreon or SubscribeStar. All supporters who pledge $1 or more will have their names listed in the videos. There are higher tiers too with additional perks, so check out the links below for more details.
/ tikhistory
www.subscribestar.com/tikhistory
Thank you to my current supporters! You're AWESOME!
- - - - -
ABOUT TIK 📝
History isn’t as boring as some people think, and my goal is to get people talking about it. I also want to dispel the myths and distortions that ruin our perception of the past by asking a simple question - “But is this really the case?”. I have a 2:1 Degree in History and a passion for early 20th Century conflicts (mainly WW2). I’m therefore approaching this like I would an academic essay. Lots of sources, quotes, references and so on. Only the truth will do.

Опубликовано:

 

7 апр 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,8 тыс.   
@trelard
@trelard Месяц назад
This is probably THE best overview concerning the Night of the Long Knives I've ever seen. Rational, logical, and backed up with historical receipts. This has been an awesome eclipse so far. On the other side of it now. Getting brighter.
@TheImperatorKnight
@TheImperatorKnight Месяц назад
Thank you! I'm glad you think so
@david7384
@david7384 Месяц назад
also check out zoomer historian
@nicholaswion846
@nicholaswion846 Месяц назад
@@TheImperatorKnight Yes, wonderful video, however, I have difficulty with the idea of referring to Hitler's concept of revolution being in any way, "Peaceful." I think it would be better to view the distinction as a clash between a chaotic vs ordered revolution, rather than a violent vs peaceful one.
@robertortiz-wilson1588
@robertortiz-wilson1588 Месяц назад
@@david7384 he makes some fair but debatable points about Norway, Churchill’s decisions, appeasement, etc. But he’s straight up lying or is just garbage at what he’s doing by constantly coping about what Hitler and the Nazis were planning to do in the east.
@robertortiz-wilson1588
@robertortiz-wilson1588 Месяц назад
@@nicholaswion846 well I did notice he kept finger quoting throughout the video for a reason.
@MadBroStudio
@MadBroStudio Месяц назад
He couldn't march on Rome so he marched on Rohm instead
@gbcb8853
@gbcb8853 Месяц назад
Nothing like a Homophone to get the point across
@keithad6485
@keithad6485 Месяц назад
very clever!
@stevem815
@stevem815 Месяц назад
Nice
@agstl
@agstl Месяц назад
😂
@patrickmiano7901
@patrickmiano7901 Месяц назад
Bad. Can I use it?
@dieterschonefeld7428
@dieterschonefeld7428 Месяц назад
My father was Army-officer in the Reich, i am 74 now and Your analysis is the only one covering what happened in those years as he told me - leaving me concluding that it developed quite exactly as You told it!
@johnlesesne1604
@johnlesesne1604 Месяц назад
Thanks for your post!
@dieterschonefeld7428
@dieterschonefeld7428 Месяц назад
@@erhardpostinger1326 Mein Vater hat mir Über "Die Nacht der langen Messer" genau so berichtet wie Sie den Hergang beschrieben haben. Alle anderen Beschreibungen, die ich bisher bekommen habe, waren nämlich anders!
@Grimskarr
@Grimskarr Месяц назад
Excellent video!!!
@urtyp6596
@urtyp6596 Месяц назад
Thanks so much Sir! Thats at the heart of the maximum confusioned state germany is in right now. Cheers from the fourth Reich Ps: it seems they are doing it all again. What a mess.
@aryanprivilege9651
@aryanprivilege9651 29 дней назад
He’s duped you merely with pejorative use of “socialism” today as contradictory to their meeting. If you don’t grasp freeing to bank for mafia of theft. He “greatest sin” was cutting off the profiteering from stealing labors wealth. AH absolutely grasping the cause of war, lie of WW1 war to end all wars drivel. As if greed would sublimate. He’s aiming to use “ stolen central bank” to serve the volk. Put them into labor not unemployment of the 6 million to zero fit men. He’s just using the Pharisees word trick in exactly way use go “ the animals brain if the goyman”insult. The banksters of USA declared war on 🇺🇸 to steal bank into privatization and financed the Russian Revolution Jacob Schiff, other wealth extracting criminals stealing majority of working persons wage and savings. If you believe Hitler could embrace any form of Comminism or Jewish Bolshevism yet fought them Frie Korps in almost magical victory where prevailed saw his Hess charge single-handedly a machine gun nest kill all inside and not be mortally wounded by bullets. Thought like many it showed Gott mit uns, old gods protected them. Of course they would destroy anyone who interferes with the salvation of Volk, Found these degenerates in beds with subverted young boys abused as if women was enough to enrage their vanguard. These are not the example we set, but what replace. That creep E.R. Was an irritant to all especially the leader referring to him on nicknames this hideous shirt fat pervert. Called Hitler “Addie” like some equal or foul persistence predator. There should be no threats from these homosexuals they force on the Volk. Books burning posters filthy degenerate ugly art the ghey theory and sexual abuse of children will never be acceptable to Volk. Abolition of age of consent this trans poison these vipers peddled. Never, you allow it and have learned nothing at all in these dark decades. Frankfurt school was booted to Southern California paradise itself. Ridiculous tragic depressing sad sacks of incel hatred and admitted smell of doom. If do not understand debt banking the debt windfall you must try or are condemned to folly of past. You’ll never understand the core principle, by this mama ideology the founding fathers are the socialists in exactly this manner. Or ole hickory Andrew Jackson. Good for them giving these cowards the option or course they were weak femme unworthy of redemption. He’s a mendacious double speaker, propaganda to undercut reality of the non stawart to selves. Get it it don’t I wish you you sell. You can find the truth in A history of central banking : The enslavement of mankind. - Goodson or Rum-ble. He’ll likely erase or broke and I have gold bars to earn. Hope see the wicked in his filthy channel see money. Book sources whom wouldn’t be published if not against the free bank free Volk. Of course the fallacious will cpntain much factual information sprinkled in deluting soup. Who care what Hitler’s for or violence on past none can be changed. We take the good and leave side effects or irrelevant. He allowed Jews even his friend in SS leadership role making him honorable Aryan. Part of Deutschland get its benefits , Mein kampf said convert and be saved could leave or ideny😮as German. Like dual citizenship oath to Israel today. Cannot have two masters or none and be free. Not good, your kindness is wasted on these cloaca vectors of illness.
@raybarry4307
@raybarry4307 Месяц назад
Dude you may refer to this as "only a video" but I've learned more watching You than most of the books on this subject. You produce the equivalent of short well written books every other week. Don't sell yourself short.
@mikeoz4803
@mikeoz4803 26 дней назад
Rohm knew of Hitler's homosexuality & deep perverse practices. The Generals despised Rohms sexual immorality & threats to take over the Army. Thats about it.
@shukuffxi
@shukuffxi Месяц назад
Saw this pop up on my lock screen. Saw the title. Was like "Welp, some people are about to be pissed and not like historical facts and citations." I guess some part of Reddit is going to get really frustrated lol.
@erloriel
@erloriel Месяц назад
Reddit seethes knowing that TIK posts!
@kikastra
@kikastra Месяц назад
They hate Tik videos the most because he actually backs it up with sources. Is it all 100% correct? Impossible, but no one can claim that he's just making crap up (they do, but they are 100% wrong about that.)
@MaconMedia
@MaconMedia Месяц назад
I was banned from r/Libertarian for posting something similar. LOL
@shukuffxi
@shukuffxi Месяц назад
@@MaconMedia Badge of honor lol. I didn't know r/Libertarian was that bad.
@jelstone20
@jelstone20 Месяц назад
@@kikastra If you don't believe he makes things up you haven't been concentrating on his replies in community posts.
@KarlButIWishIWasntMarx
@KarlButIWishIWasntMarx Месяц назад
Leaving work early, an eclipse over the US, an hour long TIK video, and its only Monday. Today is a good day.
@DaveSCameron
@DaveSCameron Месяц назад
I have a decent copy of Konrad Biography and I encourage everyone who enjoys history to checkout the book. 😮😅 📚
@JorgeCruz-mi5gc
@JorgeCruz-mi5gc Месяц назад
I am sitting outside listening to Tik History while watching the phases of the eclipse. It is definitely a great day.
@regu6582
@regu6582 Месяц назад
And the week/year goes on. What other goodies to come ? I do appreciate the viewpoint of reality from TiK.
@nathanielcowan3971
@nathanielcowan3971 Месяц назад
​@@DaveSCameron😊😊😊
@bjorntorlarsson
@bjorntorlarsson Месяц назад
Leaving work because of a solar eclipse?? Please kill my curiosity and let me know what kind of job you have! A photo model tanning himself on the beach? ;-)
@mothman2514
@mothman2514 Месяц назад
"Why did Lenin kill the Mensheviks?'" After 5 minutes of browsing Reddit, you will understand.
@samsonsoturian6013
@samsonsoturian6013 Месяц назад
Yeah, there are no virtually no historians on the history subs. I think it's a combination of the zero entry barrier, popularity contest, and anonymity that allows a tens of thousands teenagers and socialists to spam weird stuff and harass. There's at least one mod on r/askhistorians that will remove anything and everything except their own posts.
@LethalBubbles
@LethalBubbles Месяц назад
that the most fascistic thing he ever did and your reddit comment makes me think youre no better
@keithad6485
@keithad6485 Месяц назад
Why did Stalin have Lenin done away with?
@mothman2514
@mothman2514 Месяц назад
@@LethalBubbles And cue people clutching their pearls over an obvious joke.
@johnkelly4237
@johnkelly4237 Месяц назад
This is a fascinating analysis of Nazi history. I have read The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich by Shirer. As we now know, it has some historical flaws, but it is fabulously well written and is a good foundational text. I also read the three-book trilogy on the Third Reich by Evans and it is well worth purchasing and lingering over. This was a GREAT video! Thank you for all your hard work to bring it to us!
@NakedOwl501
@NakedOwl501 Месяц назад
I wish we were more nuanced with our education regarding the "bad guys of WWII". Not to nuture sympathetic ideas towards them, but to *understand* them and how they came about. To realize that this wasn't just "some guys decided to be evil", but there was a very real (and very repeatable) series of events and human reasons behind it.
@sydmccreath4554
@sydmccreath4554 Месяц назад
That precisely became my own personal approach which came about due to my eventually noticing I was experiencing disappointment and dissatisfaction at a blasé easy acceptance of the Historical WW2/Hitler/National Socialism status quo as it is.
@johnsmith5215
@johnsmith5215 Месяц назад
I thinks it probably completely understandable to regard them as evil people while still having nuance, only true monsters could have carried out something like the t4 program in the modern era
@NakedOwl501
@NakedOwl501 Месяц назад
@@johnsmith5215 The T4 program has eerie connections to modern Canada, ironically enough.
@johnsmith5215
@johnsmith5215 Месяц назад
@@NakedOwl501 no idea about that, I just know the Germans were taking mentally disabled kids from there parents telling them that they were going to take care of them and make sure they were safe and well, only to sterile and murder them and all during peace time It was a sick regime even before the war
@khorps4756
@khorps4756 Месяц назад
@@johnsmith5215 But this is the problem: We are all monsters. Everyone thinks they are reasonable good guys, just as the Nazis did.
@veeli1106
@veeli1106 Месяц назад
Last time I was this early Hitler was rejected from art school…
@gg_rider
@gg_rider Месяц назад
According to another historian, Hitler was an artist who lived in the gay section of Berlin, with a gay roommate, and hung out at the known gay park ... but he wasn't gay. Ernst Rohm was homosexual, into military chic. Hitler? Gay? NO WAY! HOW DARE YOU!
@hafizihilmibinabdulhalim1004
@hafizihilmibinabdulhalim1004 Месяц назад
​@@gg_riderAnother theory is that Hitler also had a relationship with a French woman even though he always claimed that he despised French people
@robert48044
@robert48044 Месяц назад
somebody has to make the joke right?
@Acolyte_of_Cthulhu
@Acolyte_of_Cthulhu Месяц назад
and still better than todays progressive junk art, darn
@patrickmiano7901
@patrickmiano7901 Месяц назад
Did you know that the school 🏫 officials that rejected 🙅‍♂️ him admitted that he was not totally without talent and recommended he apply to architecture school 🏫? He should have followed their advice, even if he had to go back to technical school.
@tokencivilian8507
@tokencivilian8507 Месяц назад
An hour and 8 minutes very well spent. Great stuff TIK.
@ivanmonahhov2314
@ivanmonahhov2314 Месяц назад
yeah I am 5 minutes in and this is already funny. TIK quotes historian criticisng communism which is really weird , ends with dates 1920, 1921. Russian civil war ended in 1923.
@bastait
@bastait Месяц назад
@@ivanmonahhov2314 its funny cause you try your absolute hardest to pick it apart and cant
@sextuspompeius1266
@sextuspompeius1266 Месяц назад
⁠@@ivanmonahhov2314vast majority of the fighting was over by the end of 1920 and certainly by the end of 1921
@DiogoSilva-qn8qo
@DiogoSilva-qn8qo Месяц назад
@@ivanmonahhov2314 Wow, almost like people can criticize something that's actively going on, instead of just when it ends. Are all the people against the Ukraine-Russia war or Israel-Palestine war non-existant?
@mikeoz4803
@mikeoz4803 26 дней назад
Rohm knew of Hitler's homosexuality & deep perverse practices.
@larsrons7937
@larsrons7937 Месяц назад
The moment I logged in, long past my bedtime, and saw the notification I knew that "I ain't gonna get much sleep tonight!" Thanks, TIK. Stay awesome.
@gagamba9198
@gagamba9198 Месяц назад
Your video was not 'way too long'. It was excellent. Thank you for doing the work and bringing the receipts.
@InvestmentJoy
@InvestmentJoy Месяц назад
For quite some time, youtube punished long form, now they're much more friendly to it.
@archangelapache2953
@archangelapache2953 Месяц назад
You know the actual narrative for why National Socialism came about is far more nuanced and interesting than any traditional or Marxist narrative that dominate the current sphere of media. Imagine a TV series that accurately depicts the events as they really happened. I think it would capture the interest of many. Not making Hitler and his Nazis the cartoonish evil bad guy that we must always look at from the outside, but looking at the organization from within and showing it for what it was. Also the idea of a scene in which Hitler walks into Röhm’s hotel room with a whip would be pretty funny.
@JR-sq2of
@JR-sq2of Месяц назад
If you want to look at the organization from the inside, then watch Filmmakers For The Prosecution. The Nazis were very organized and actually filmed what they did on the inside. They played it back at the Nuremberg trials. Oops l😮
@bastait
@bastait Месяц назад
they were evil all socialism is that is the issue. the real problem is we cant compare it too modern socialist movement the clutching of pearls fore stalls such acts.
@TheIndignation
@TheIndignation Месяц назад
HBO pick this up, Nazi game of thrones
@JR-sq2of
@JR-sq2of Месяц назад
​@@TheIndignation Thanks Mr Indignation. 😊
@TheBlackfall234
@TheBlackfall234 Месяц назад
@@bastait The Socialism from the Third Reich has nothing to do with your understanding of Socialism. Oswald Spengler wrote a book called "Preußentum und Sozialismus", wich was a very important foundation to the ideas of Nationalsocialism and explains why the Nationalist Idea of "Socialism" has nothing to do with the marxist and democratic socialism.
@lod689
@lod689 Месяц назад
I know you have more detailed videos of the Reich, but the foundation you lay before describing the conflict with the SA here is perfect. You have presented a very clear and easy to follow comparison of Marxism and National Socialism.
@TheImperatorKnight
@TheImperatorKnight Месяц назад
Awesome, I'm glad to hear it! It's difficult to know if I have made something clear or not, and sometimes people say I've said stuff that they don't understand, so it is good to know this video was understandable.
@user-ih8fn1uz6y
@user-ih8fn1uz6y Месяц назад
Slapnut
@yaroslavdanilchenko3722
@yaroslavdanilchenko3722 Месяц назад
Hey TIK, I've watched alot of your videos and it's shocking to me the amount of detail you put in them. You've been an inspiration for me to look deeper into history beyond what the historians say. Thank you for your work.
@lonjohnson5161
@lonjohnson5161 Месяц назад
TIK, on Sunday, Viva Frei and Robert Barnes briefly discussed inviting you to their show. Both are lawyers who discuss law and politics. As a subscriber to both RU-vid channels, I would love to see what comes from a conversation among the three of you.
@philnorris3507
@philnorris3507 15 дней назад
You are undoubtably the best RU-vid_Historian of the political and economic ideas in this fraught time period. Thanks for reading all the books I don't have time to read and study. Thanks for publishing such fulsome and balanced videos, explaining in terms any educated person can readily appreciate. I'm so glad I re-subscribed after rage quitting for something you said a long time ago (I forget what it was and I'm embarrassed to admit I was so wrong). Please keep up the good work educating me and the rest of the public interested in these topics (WW2 and related issues) you are worth 1000 books and 10,000 hours.
@SepticFuddy
@SepticFuddy Месяц назад
All this talk about "peaceful revolution" over "violent revolution" only reminds me of Fabian Socialism and its counterpart, American Progressivism. I think it would be worth going into that topic, because that's really the missing link between the evils of Axis ideologies and the similar evils of Allied governance both pre- and post-war.
@awakeandwatching953
@awakeandwatching953 Месяц назад
and our current predicament in the anglo sphere
@snagletoothscott3729
@snagletoothscott3729 Месяц назад
Because they are related. There should still be the video available in RU-vid of Goebbels in the mid 30's giving an interview (to the BBC, I believe) where he states that, when the Nazi Party came to power it was almost unexpected even by them. They quickly realized that, while having ideology, they didn't have the first idea how to manage and run an actual government. They looked around for a bureaucratic system that could fit into their ideology allow them to implement their goals and they came across American Progressivism...particularly that as practiced by FDR. This interview added fuel to the fire in the US media that was increasingly seeing FDR as a burgeoning Fascist (Yes, I know Nazi's weren't Fascist, but, you know, media and their simple minded readers). Geobboles went on to say he himself was personally impressed with FDR's use of propaganda and manipulation of the press in the creation of the White House Press Corps.
@samsonsoturian6013
@samsonsoturian6013 Месяц назад
Progressives only like to pretend they know anything about that
@Web720
@Web720 Месяц назад
@@snagletoothscott3729 Link to the video?
@snagletoothscott3729
@snagletoothscott3729 Месяц назад
@@Web720 You tube doeskin like crosslinking that much especially videos and people they try and smother. Now I found a portion of the video , but it's not containing the part of the interview I was mentioning. Even at that, the poster has had to reupload it since RU-vid has taken them down. As such, the full version might not be available. Goebbels interview 1933 (re-upload) post by Karin.K Since RU-vid likes to nuke these things, here's a partial. You can figure out the rest of link watch?v=KroMulABm1E The full interview that I saw was about 12 minutes or so, but this is part of that interview. Edit: I did find a tiny bit more at US Holocaust museum website, but again, only a 2 minute spot and not the part I'm referencing, but it does have a timer and shows the interview with Ward Price to be over 57 minutes long. trying to find full version, or even that exact section, will be really hard, considering the current political situation in the US with the government's stranglehold on on places like RU-vid. I cant imagine anyone posting that would stay up for very long.
@steveclarke6257
@steveclarke6257 Месяц назад
TiK thank you for more of the Interwar political analysis ...... The problem as I see it is there is no view of the "opposition" viewpoint- The view of other politicians in Germany as a counterpoint for why you have the melting pot of German politics, with the additional points of view in Germany. That would give other viewers an all-round view of the political spectrum in Germany.
@TheImperatorKnight
@TheImperatorKnight Месяц назад
Good point. I guess a video on the various different factions would be useful in the future
@mikeoz4803
@mikeoz4803 26 дней назад
Rohm knew of Hitler's homosexuality & deep perverse practices. The Generals despised Rohms sexual immorality & threats to take over the Army. Thats about it.
@VikSkiKat
@VikSkiKat Месяц назад
This is a very difficult subject to talk about without coming across as being "One of them". I think you do a good job. Thanks for the brilliant videos. Some excellent work.
@kenhoganson9481
@kenhoganson9481 Месяц назад
Thank you Tik! Amazing how convoluted this all was, and thanks for being so clear and understandable!
@AbeGreenleaf
@AbeGreenleaf Месяц назад
It bears mentioning that gradualist socialism is not purely a reaction to the failures of the Bolsheviks. For instance the Fabian Society in the UK whose whole purpose was to bring about a peaceful socialist revolution through gradual legal means was founded in the 1880s.
@marioarguello6989
@marioarguello6989 18 дней назад
What was/is peaceful about it?
@research007
@research007 Месяц назад
Christa Schroeder, who had been Hitler's secretary since June 1933, examines the question of whether Röhm had been planning a coup in her memoirs, "After 30 June 1934 people puzzled a lot over whether Röhm really had been planning a coup. Purely subjectively, in my opinion he had not, but after Himmler had inveigled his SS people into the police, Röhm probably wanted at least the status of a people's militia for his uneasy and temporarily unemployed SA force. That would have been a breach of the political accord with France. Hitler wished to avoid difficulties in that direction and feared that Röhm had a private political agenda. Judging by the files to which I had access later, and Röhm's order to the SA of 10 June 1934, it cannot be ruled out however that it was his intention. The last paragraph of his order reads: _I expect that on 1 August the SA will be ready, fully rested and invigorated, to fulfil those honourable and onerous duties which Volk and Fatherland expect of them. If the enemies of the SA are hopeful that the SA will not become involved after their leave, or only partially, then we shall allow them this short, joyful respite. At the time and in the manner which appears necessary afterwards they will receive the appropriate answer. The SA is and remains the destiny of Germany._ This means that chief of staff Röhm had sent his 4.5 million SA men on leave, but as he did so threatened to strike out with a hefty paw. He spoke of 'enemies of the SA'. According to this order by Röhm, the SA 'fully rested' would serve not 'Führer and Reich' as it was then the practice to say, but be at the disposal of 'Volk und Vaterland'. What also struck me in this order was the absence of the usual salute 'Heil Hitler!' with which it was customary to conclude all official correspondence." Schroeder, C. "He Was My Chief: The Memoirs of Adolf Hitler's Secretary." Frontline Books, 2009, p. 30.
@TeaParty1776
@TeaParty1776 Месяц назад
Hitler worried about Rohms potential political power, whatever Rohm may have been planning. And, of course, he hated the homosexuality of Rohm's, SA.
@nobodysbusiness610
@nobodysbusiness610 Месяц назад
Got to say you nailed it on this one. One of your best videos for sure. Definitely helped connecting some dots previously unconnected in my mind. Great job!
@foxpedro001
@foxpedro001 Месяц назад
Hi TIK. Notifications are always on for great videos like yours. Keep up with the great work.
@Triplitz
@Triplitz 15 дней назад
My god the parallels with what is going on here in the US is shocking. The "march through the institutions" mirrors the "synchronization" you speak of almost action per action. As a German Americans we have already seen this play before and have no desire to repeat it. This is a sort of mirror of the Kronstadt sailors and should be mandatory in US education as a warning to would-be revolutionaries. Anybody dangerous enough to topple a regime is a danger to the regime that replaces it.
@jaytheconqueror2
@jaytheconqueror2 Месяц назад
This is a wonderful video. Great presentation, and it even included things which are not widely known about the purge. Salute.
@ConversionCenters
@ConversionCenters Месяц назад
I wasn't aware that Hitler had laser beam eyes. This fact actually explains a lot about his behavior...Thanks for the vid, Tik!
@LordBruuh
@LordBruuh Месяц назад
I absolutely admire the hardwork you put into these videos. The amount of reading and knowledge you have to absorb, then properly convey to an audience is incredible! Thanks!
@in39484
@in39484 Месяц назад
According to historian Thomas Weber, it shows a lot of information about how Hitler in 1919 sympathized with social democracy, in fact, he tried to join an ethno-nationalist party called the "German Socialist Party", this party were leftists who embraced nationalism. .
@robert48044
@robert48044 Месяц назад
the dude needed a party to gain power, get in where you fit it, fake it till you make it
@Despiser25
@Despiser25 Месяц назад
Funny how the "Nationalists" want to rule the World... Nationalism isnt the problem until you put the word SOCIALIST next to it.
@felipeguerrero1508
@felipeguerrero1508 Месяц назад
He mentions that in Mein Kampf. He went delussioned.
@theywouldnthavetocensormei9231
@theywouldnthavetocensormei9231 Месяц назад
I've never understood how someone can be a leftist and *not* a nationalist, if you want taxes to pay for everything, it only makes sense that you would be very rigid about everyone in your country paying taxes. Leftism doesn't really work at all, but it would work a lot better in a closed system than trying to have some idealistic global socialism.
@Paciat
@Paciat Месяц назад
Didnt Hitler say: "everyone was once a socialist" when someone asked about his early political career?
@jorgevespucci9878
@jorgevespucci9878 Месяц назад
This dude is an absolute boss. Love the unedited takes on factual history.
@TheImperatorKnight
@TheImperatorKnight Месяц назад
Thank you, but the videos are edited!
@user-ch7wn5fk8d
@user-ch7wn5fk8d Месяц назад
ya, no detail left out. It's kind of amazing.
@jorgevespucci9878
@jorgevespucci9878 Месяц назад
@TheImperatorKnight Haha ahh man that's why I love ya. Yeah, I guess I meant in the context of revising history to better fit an agenda. Not that the videos themselves are a one take delivery of excellence.
@datboi7893
@datboi7893 Месяц назад
@@TheImperatorKnight I think he meant unedited, as in unbiased, but yeah, there's some splendind work you've done over the years. I'm looking forward to every weekly upload of yours.
@ianstoneman4843
@ianstoneman4843 Месяц назад
Again. Thanks for the enlightenment! Keep up the good work. As a trained scientist. I like my references and loved your comparison to other authors and their lack of and use of crap references. Keep it up TIK.
@boreopithecus
@boreopithecus Месяц назад
It’s interesting how both the Soviets and the Nazis seem to avoid calling each other “socialists” or any derivation of the word. The Nazis unusually often refer to the Russians as “Bolsheviks” and when I was in St Petersburg 25 years ago what struck me was all the war memorials I saw referred to the Germans as “fascists” and never as “Nazis”.
@Blackdeathgaming-yv1kk
@Blackdeathgaming-yv1kk Месяц назад
That's because both are socialists but have an entire different philosophy behind it and have a different idea of what it means to be socialist. One promotes class cooperation, Nationalism, a form of market economics, is a meritocracy, allows private property etc while the other is internationalist, seeks the destruction of class, promotes equality of outcome, is anti religious , controls the economy through central planning etc. Only similarity is that both oppose capitalism and consumerism and rampant materialism.
@sorenh.2216
@sorenh.2216 Месяц назад
@@Blackdeathgaming-yv1kk I´m German, born ´79. One of my Grandfathers fight from ´41- ´mid ´44 eastern in Armouref SS-Div. till he lost both legs witch hat to that time cut of more times because of no Antibiotics WITHOUT Morphine- just "Moonshine". It´s very important to different betwen SS ; Waffen-SS ; SS-Polizei ; Einsatzgruppen. He told me Bastards was most of Einsatzgruppen and ESPECIALLY "Kettenhunde" (MP) which behave like Superman but most killing helpless without Weapons in the "Etappe" (Area between Germany and HKL (Frontline) why the fighting Units call them "Etappenhengste" and ALL Fighters in Waffem-SS and Wehrmacht hated and disrespect them! But like the "Politkommisare" redside they was able to kill the Squads by will without serious Consequences by say "Feigheit vor dem Feind" In Stalingrad for Example Paulus and the Organisationmembers of that Groups had allmost till End more than enough "zum Fressen" (Food) while the Fighters Eat their died Comrades. The Kettenhunde killed till End now not anymore following Soldiers to Blackmail them running nearly without food, Weapons or Ammo into Death "obwohl" they had before heard the Speech from Germany the whole Army Already Died. Today many Germans know Adolf learns like Anjelica Kazmierski to hate the REAL Germans at Tavistock Institute and loved like many of his faqr Left Socialists till end the "Bariloche" County in Patagonia like Hotel Eden!
@useodyseeorbitchute9450
@useodyseeorbitchute9450 Месяц назад
@@Blackdeathgaming-yv1kk Soviets went full nationalist in aftermath of Barabarossa, while Germans were running central planning. The differences were more not that big in practice...
@johnmcdonald9295
@johnmcdonald9295 Месяц назад
@@sorenh.2216The British should never have declared war on Germany,and Churchill should have been tried for war crimes,he won the kalergi award in 1955
@reddeadsniper1263
@reddeadsniper1263 Месяц назад
​@@johnmcdonald9295Germany shouldn't have declared war on Poland.
@AlbertComelles1970
@AlbertComelles1970 Месяц назад
Congratulations TIK, what a masterpiece! Another one, by the way, in a long row. And on a fundamental subject. Crystal clear but still open to debate. Thank you.
@vincentperiolat4610
@vincentperiolat4610 17 дней назад
This is spot on what I needed, I am not alone! There ARE some people out there w/ the capacity to think, reason, and question deeper than 2mm when an authority, academia, or organization 'informs us' on anything. Great work! Sub.
@casparcoaster1936
@casparcoaster1936 Месяц назад
really feel lucky to have found this channel in 2018, been really facinating, and absorbing videos, very grateful
@johnroberts8093
@johnroberts8093 Месяц назад
Love your videos, super impressed with the level of research and therefore, the level of detail within the videos. Love the way you represent the map movements and how you show which units are engaging which units. Love this political stuff as well. Realised I was a bit dim when it came to political history so I'm happily learning here. I appreciate all you do on here. 🙏🇬🇧🙏
@realitycheckreally8412
@realitycheckreally8412 Месяц назад
Top quality as always. Thanks TIK...
@rogerparkhurst5796
@rogerparkhurst5796 Месяц назад
Great job as usual. Insight I had not read in the biographies I had read.
@jangelbrich7056
@jangelbrich7056 Месяц назад
Small tiny detail: Germany _signed_ the Peace Treaty of Versailles on June 28, and _ratified_ it on July 9. That said, it does not alter anything of the events, but the Socialdemocrats were frowned upon as traitors by German nationalists (of any kind), and as hopeless loosers by the Allied powers, as the signing Germans had zero say whatsoever, being reduced to "rubber stamp diplomats". I could be said it is remarkable that the Socialdemocrats still continued to win elections after this in the Weimar Republic - not as majority, only as largest among so many others.
@aleksazunjic9672
@aleksazunjic9672 Месяц назад
SD had a large and traditional working class base . Situation in Germany soon became chaotic (hyper-inflation and all that stuff), so people were trying to find safety in something they could belong. Average worker was not swayed by traditional national parties run by affluent aristocrats, nor was he interested in restoration of monarchy which led him to war. Only party that could make balance between national and social had a chance, and such party appeared. Rest was history.
@kenon6968
@kenon6968 Месяц назад
It was the largest party in Germany, and one of the best organized in the world. Party had a much more encompassing definition then in the sense that they had all sorts of ancillary organizations attached to them and were much more a part of people's lives than they are today. That support was won over a half century of organization, it wouldn't likely be lost so easily.
@bjorntorlarsson
@bjorntorlarsson Месяц назад
​@@kenon6968 Social democrat Tage Erlander 1946-1969 led a peaceful revolution in Sweden, which totally changed every single aspect of our society. Division of power abolished for totalitarian centralization of everything, families crushed by oppressive taxes, all children indoctrinated in governement kindergarten, schools, universities, everyone dependent on government handouts including all media, regulations preventing founding of new companies or any kind of independence from the government, and on and on. Since 1969 there has been no political reforms in Sweden except for those directly driven by foreign interests: The re-regulation of financial markets in the 1980s, the membership of the EU in the 1990s. And now DCA, a military deal one-sidedly giving the US unlimited access to Swedish territory and resources with even the families of US soldiers stationed here having full diplomatic immunity from following Swedish laws. The government doesn't even have the right to inspect the (to begin with) 17 US military bases here. Suddenly Sweden is the LEAST neutral country in the world! (This bilateral deal is completely unrelated to NATO).
@robertsettle2590
@robertsettle2590 Месяц назад
​@@bjorntorlarsson.....When and where in Sweden, did the USA establish these military installations?
@bjorntorlarsson
@bjorntorlarsson Месяц назад
​@@robertsettle2590 Signed by Sweden's government on December 6th, 2023. Just google "Defence Cooperation Agreement" to read the full text. (RU-vid shadowing doesn't allow me to post any kind of links) Completely one-sided! A skilled US lawyer verses uneducated cheap to bribe Swedish prime minister. No defence guarantees or anything in return, so it does not qualify as an alliance. Germany 1918 was not an unconditional surrender. This was!
@akacurmurdar1
@akacurmurdar1 Месяц назад
Enrst Rohm: "I want a second revolution" Hitler: "OK" Rohm: "No not like this!"
@pointlesspublishing5351
@pointlesspublishing5351 25 дней назад
Good tldr😂
@jhlasound
@jhlasound Месяц назад
This guy is the absolute best of the best for history and accuracy , and the fact he adds tons of legitimate sources just makes it all the better
@alexb882
@alexb882 Месяц назад
Oddly enough, I saw this as a recommendation on another WW2 documentary video here on YT that featured Richard Evans, I wonder if that is a coincidence haha. Subscribed, nicely put together sir
@TheL1034
@TheL1034 Месяц назад
Glad you did this, I've always been fascinated by the rise and catastrophic fall of the SA. Daniel Siemens book Stormtroopers was a very enlightening read, especially for pointing out the "Beefsteaks", socialists who joined the NSDAP, named for being brown on the outside and red on the inside. But unlike most discussions on the SA, it also talks about what happened to the organization after Rohm and his allies got "life expired".
@markgrissom
@markgrissom Месяц назад
Love TIK's book recommendations of late. Won't miss this one either.
@cristibrad6742
@cristibrad6742 Месяц назад
another golden piece of debunking distorting naratives. p.s in case there was a human error, on the patreon/subscriber black bar roll credits, there is Ralph Cox times 2. Keep up the great work!
@seththomas9105
@seththomas9105 Месяц назад
TIK hits another home run! Love the historical discussion and breakdown of the timeline and facts.
@davidconnellan6875
@davidconnellan6875 Месяц назад
Love your videos great work. You really should get/deserve a publishing deal
@charlesnunno8377
@charlesnunno8377 Месяц назад
Knowing this actually makes Hitler seem completely consistent.
@user-js2xn9jv9l
@user-js2xn9jv9l Месяц назад
So many hours of watching TIK videos throughout the years and I still crack a laugh every time he impersonates Hitler with an "evil voice"
@oldfella3919
@oldfella3919 Месяц назад
Great vid TIK ... love these analyses. 👍
@adrienne0711
@adrienne0711 26 дней назад
Your “just a RU-vid video” (quoting you) is outstanding, thank you! I really enjoyed it.
@dougm2745
@dougm2745 Месяц назад
Fascinating and educational. Keep it up!
@Axisjampa
@Axisjampa Месяц назад
Great video TIK. This level of analysis has no match in RU-vid.
@TheImperatorKnight
@TheImperatorKnight Месяц назад
I do wonder if I'm overdoing it some times with the level of detail
@Axisjampa
@Axisjampa Месяц назад
@@TheImperatorKnight I think many people will be a little scared to see an hour plus video of a topic, but I also think the majority of your fans tend to like the long format. And I think sometimes is necessary to make the Message really hit home. For me, you make excellent content as it is.
@nomdeguerre7265
@nomdeguerre7265 Месяц назад
@@TheImperatorKnight Not at all. If one argues against what some people badly want, or need, to believe, it's obligatory. People will never believe anything they don't want to believe unless you can make your case forcefully. It's far better to do that with facts and research, if one seeks an audience of those who actually think for themselves. In the long run perhaps those willing and able to observe, learn and decide for themselves are the opinions that matter. 'Useful idiots' are useful, but they're still idiots, and hence ultimately uncreative and unproductive. Credibility is essential, unless one simply wants to 'preach to the choir'. All credible argument depends on solid research, facts, contemporary sources and citation. @Axisjampa says your citation and research "has no match on RU-vid". As you point out very effectively, your credibility is above the level of even much published literature. One need not sacrifice quality to the medium. It separates the 'wheat from the chaff'.
@microhistoria
@microhistoria Месяц назад
My hopes that he may continue the wermar republic series is alive, thank god. btw TIK, I know you read those. Do you have a method of writing for making your videos engaging? I find myself glued to the subject the moment you start talking but I can't replicate it in my own videos. How do you do it? (I recently lost my job and all help is welcome in this regard)
@nolanmacdonald8350
@nolanmacdonald8350 Месяц назад
Of course tik is never in my feed, rarely getting an update about new videos once a month I remember to come here and mingle with my fellow historians!!
@torbjornkvist
@torbjornkvist Месяц назад
Good and necessary stuff, as usual. Thank You!
@stevenread1676
@stevenread1676 Месяц назад
3:40 They still don't know what 'real' socialism is TIK! Everytime you ask a socialist for an example of a socialist state that hasn't failed and they always state "It's not real socialism!" Sooo... I don't think they really know either :D
@mnk9073
@mnk9073 Месяц назад
Democracy has been around for three millenia and we still only have barely functioning light-versions of it. I suggest you sit down until you find a true democracy or a version of capitalism neither built on the exploitation of third parties nor locked in a eternal constantly accelerating boom-bust cycle or one that isn't just a straight line to a monopolist running literally everything.
@stevej71393
@stevej71393 Месяц назад
At least in the US, they'll probably say Sweden, which isn't really socialist.
@smtandearthboundsuck8400
@smtandearthboundsuck8400 Месяц назад
I know what it is. A bourgeois dictatorship that still produces commodities, promotes nationalism, commits imperialism and worker abuse is the furthest thing from socialism. The USSR was a social democracy ruled by Socdems (liberals) the same type of people that used the freikorps to kill actual communists, in fact they killed even the most communists in history probably. The first page of Capital is enough to disqualify any "AES" that edgy leftists worship as socialist. The "not real socialism" is just true. The USSR and China are as Socialist as North Korea is democratic.
@The_13th_to_awaken
@The_13th_to_awaken Месяц назад
ah the no true socialist fallacy
@Paciat
@Paciat Месяц назад
And they have the definition. Its when the workers (by central planning, cause it cant be done otherwise) are in control of the means of production. So every "workers party" that claims it is representing the interests of working people is by definition socialist. EDIT: as the video sais 1:04:24 😋 I disagree with TIK that socialists arent dumb.
@rossbryant1280
@rossbryant1280 Месяц назад
Excellent video, as a History teacher, I will be incorporating some of the sources you have used in this video into my lessons when I teach the NOLK to students from now on! Thank you TIK!
@phann860
@phann860 Месяц назад
Good luck with that, trying to explain Hitler was a socialist and therefore the idea there is a left and right wing is nonsense, the Nazis and Communists were both left wing as by the way Mussolini was.
@rossbryant1280
@rossbryant1280 Месяц назад
@@phann860 It’s hard enough trying to explain it to adults, let alone school children!
@jackwistos458
@jackwistos458 Месяц назад
7 58:56 ​@@phann860
@jackwistos458
@jackwistos458 Месяц назад
​@rossbr 58:56 yant1280
@rossbryant1280
@rossbryant1280 Месяц назад
@@jackwistos458 TIK coming for the Guardian 😂
@Beastius24
@Beastius24 Месяц назад
Absolutely love your videos and work. Thank you 😊
@charlesnunno8377
@charlesnunno8377 Месяц назад
You do excellent history work on this.
@debbiestyer453
@debbiestyer453 Месяц назад
I absolutely love your arguments ( logical) against all the ideobabble of poorly cited Marxist takes on Hitler as right wing ...thank you very much.
@darbyheavey406
@darbyheavey406 Месяц назад
Fascism is a left wing phenomenon. Capitalism is right wing.
@etiennepilorget8777
@etiennepilorget8777 Месяц назад
Congratulation Tik! Great work as usual. I wish I could talk with you in person (I have a master degree in modern history).
@tylerwright6380
@tylerwright6380 Месяц назад
Kudos and congratulations! This is the best in-depth analysis of the intricacies of the early Nazi movement, the changes in policy that occurred after the party's coming to power in 1933, and the rivalry between Hitler and Roehm of which I am aware. This is great stuff!!! Keep it coming!
@brianbrady4496
@brianbrady4496 Месяц назад
Another great video tik. As always
@dIRECTOR259
@dIRECTOR259 Месяц назад
Excellent topic choice.
@bute6838
@bute6838 6 дней назад
Very detailed and documented history channel on yt. Great work TIK.
@robertmontgomery6811
@robertmontgomery6811 Месяц назад
I was watching this on a tablet in bed and my wife came into the bedroom. She commented that you had a wonderful way of presenting the subject and a great and interesting voice. To the extent that she had become engrossed in listening to a subject she wouldn't have had any interest in normally. As for myself, well I'm on my third viewing of the Stalingrad series and each time I pickup more fascinating detail. As I'm quite disabled now your history presentations help pass what was previously quite boring days. Having read several older histories of the war in the eastern front or indeed the western desert I can't believe how much you have enlightened me. I've never believed that Hitler was a madman, evil very much so but not mad. I can imagine towards the end that he went of the rails as he watched on helplessly as all his dreams were crushed. I was an avid reader of Manstein. Raus and Mellenthin and cherish their books but you've helped me to be careful regarding their memoirs. Many thanks for your hard work.
@MrFancyTrex
@MrFancyTrex Месяц назад
Just curious, but how fast do you read? Judging by how much content you are able to give us I would assume you are quite quick. I am dyslexic and it causes my time to comprehend books to skyrocket, do you have any tips to improve my reading speed/comprehension?
@speggeri90
@speggeri90 Месяц назад
I’m no TIK nor dyslexic, but I heard some dyslexics use much of audiobooks or at least some text-to-audio program. Hope you can find it helpful.
@wimmeraparanormal6581
@wimmeraparanormal6581 Месяц назад
Lewis, you've pronounced Goering's name correct and Rohm's name also has an Umlaut and therefore its pronounced the same way. Rohm's name is pronounced RERM. Same way as GER-ING. Just sounds better when the Germanic name is pronounced correctly. As always, brilliantly researched and presented. Kudos to you
@johkupohkuxd1697
@johkupohkuxd1697 Месяц назад
No, its pronounced "Göring" & "Röm". The vovel is similar to the one vovel in "heard". TIK's pronounciation is frankly lousy.
@wimmeraparanormal6581
@wimmeraparanormal6581 Месяц назад
@@johkupohkuxd1697 Thanks, you're actually agreeing with me so the first word in your above phrase is 'YES', not 'NO'. Plus there are 2 vowels in 'Heard'. And yes, Lewis's pronunciations in ALL of his videos are terrible, but the historic content is absolutely first rate. Wish I could find the Umlaut on my keyboard too :-)
@johnking6252
@johnking6252 Месяц назад
Excellent breakdown of the episode, cleared up a few questions, thx. 👍
@fsaldan1
@fsaldan1 Месяц назад
This is a thrilling video. Stunning insights that clarify many issues. Kudosto Mr. Tik.
@dekyras
@dekyras Месяц назад
Another great video. Clear, informative and engaging.
@ZESAUCEBOSS
@ZESAUCEBOSS Месяц назад
Another rock solid video sir. Keep em comin
@dunkirchen1940
@dunkirchen1940 28 дней назад
Great channel! You just gained a new subscriber!
@gintautassickus6390
@gintautassickus6390 Месяц назад
I hope the hyperinflation series will continue in a few years.
@veeli1106
@veeli1106 Месяц назад
By that time we may actually *have* hyperinflation for ourselves!
@SepticFuddy
@SepticFuddy Месяц назад
@@veeli1106 Already there in Argentina. VLLC
@TheImperatorKnight
@TheImperatorKnight Месяц назад
@@SepticFuddy How are things over there? I've heard 70,000 state employees were sacked?
@DAVIDMcDonald-uf2ep
@DAVIDMcDonald-uf2ep Месяц назад
@@TheImperatorKnightApparently their head political figure is working at trying to cut down the government to near-nothing to get rid of corruption on a populist basis. Something about a chainsaw, it’s really interesting. Also apparently, leftists are trying to compare their guy with Trump and the dude over in El Salvador.
@NullParadigm
@NullParadigm Месяц назад
@@TheImperatorKnight Yes, Milei managed to over-deliver on his promise on his government cuts, and Argentina has a surplus budget the first time in 12 years. Many if not all price controls were also removed, which in turn means prices have gone up and since inflation numbers don't actually track inflation but price increases it seems his policy has been "inflationary", so media states "inflation has gone up by 12%", but it's simply true scarcities meeting their true demands finally taking place. I'd link but YT hates us sharing links.
@Triumph2024.
@Triumph2024. 24 дня назад
Tik and the Zoomer Historian=A+ work.
@Jean-rg4sp
@Jean-rg4sp 4 дня назад
*This video is a **_tour de force._** You acquired such a command of the subject which bears testimony to your intelligence and I am grateful that you shared your knowledge here on RU-vid where some of us are getting all our education nowadays.*
@jts0221
@jts0221 8 дней назад
Amazing videos, been loving listening to this on my commute
@saintclarus
@saintclarus Месяц назад
In secondary school in Year 10, just 5 years ago, I was taught that the reason was because 1) Hitler wanted to get rid of the SA and kill Rohm as they didn't swear loyalty to Hitler and 2) because Hitler hated gay people. Not once in my GCSE History course was it mentioned that Rohm wanted a second revolution -- or even that there was a first revolution, a peaceful one. I was even taught he was far-right and hated communists and communism under any circumstances, which I thought was strange since socialism is very much a left-wing ideology. I love your channel. It's surprising how much isn't taught and how much of what is taught is actually taught wrongly.
@neilreynolds3858
@neilreynolds3858 Месяц назад
It's surprising to me that they taught anything and anything even that close to the truth but I'm in the US.
@varvarith3090
@varvarith3090 Месяц назад
1:04:00 I'll do one better: Hitler was Hitler. Hitler killed Hitler, so Hitler wasn't Hitler.
@donallan6396
@donallan6396 Месяц назад
Excellent and comprehensive background leading up to the purge. Thanks ans I subscribed.
@mickcraven980
@mickcraven980 Месяц назад
Good stuff, TIK. BTW: Constitutional lawyer, Robert Barnes, gave you a HUGE shoutout on his recent podcast with Viva Frei. He would like to have you as a guest on one of his shows. Go for it, TIK! Your voice needs a bigger audience.
@TheImperatorKnight
@TheImperatorKnight Месяц назад
Thank you for informing me! The only thing is that I think my strength lies in crafting solid videos backed by sources, rather than interviews.
@mickcraven980
@mickcraven980 Месяц назад
@TheImperatorKnight Thanks for your reply. Your strength is in your carefully prepared presentations, so I understand your hesitation to engage a new format. Barnes might like to hear about your process, histiography, upcoming projects, areas of interest, etc. I hope you find an option that works for you. I appreciate the hard work you put into your final products.
@liubei3058
@liubei3058 Месяц назад
​@@TheImperatorKnightI liked hearing you talk regularly in that one video you did. These might be a strength, but podcasts wouldn't be a weakness. I listen to any podcast with Razorfist in it. I'd listen to most podcasts as long as it said *Featuring TIK history
@quintustheophilus9550
@quintustheophilus9550 Месяц назад
Wohooo! New video! Thank you, Tik :)
@Hillbilly001
@Hillbilly001 Месяц назад
Although, I'm more of a tanks over banks. TiK, you absolutely make the banks interesting. Well done. Thanks. Cheers from Tennessee
@neilreynolds3858
@neilreynolds3858 Месяц назад
War is expensive. Our own warmongers here in the US forget that. To build a tank, you have to have the money and industry and workers to build a tank. That takes time.
@Hillbilly001
@Hillbilly001 Месяц назад
@@neilreynolds3858 You must be new to TiKs channel because over a year ago he asked whether viewers were more interested in banks or tanks. Meaning the business of war or the war of business. As one that's had to fill out a statement of charges on a piece of lost equipment, I know personally how expensive sh*t can be. Only took you 7 days to spout your nonsense about something not even related to my comment. Well done. LoL.
@idleshinobi3980
@idleshinobi3980 19 дней назад
I really appreciate the contant listing of sources.
@ronschramm9163
@ronschramm9163 Месяц назад
Your information is always excellent and on point. One minor error: The "American Browning" described as being given to Rhoem, in place of the Michael Hans Lippert photo, appears to be a Belgian-made Browning 1935 Hi-Power. First, since John Browning died prior to the completion, but held the patent it was known in the US and worldwide as the "Browning High Power." However, the Belgian Fabrique Nationale (FN) Arms manufacturers called it the "Haute Puissance" (HP) or alternately the "Grande Puissance" (GP) (Ian Hogg, 1978, 1970). Sources: Hogg, Ian (1978). "The Complete Illustrated Encyclopedia of the World's Firearms". A & W Publishers. New York, New York. Hogg, Ian (1970). "Military Pistols and Revolvers". Arco Publishing. New York, New York.
@stansirlmkhope2312
@stansirlmkhope2312 Месяц назад
I feel like we’re living in late 32
@stug41
@stug41 Месяц назад
The pattern of riding a wave of revolution, only to attempt to stem it once the crest has taken those leaders to their goals, and either successfully suppressing those more extreme or crashing on the other side due to not delivering what was promised, is frequently shown in revolutionary histories. Very interesting to see the specific motivations on which these figures acted here. You mention napoleon and the national guard, but even before him the various and tumultuous revolutionary committees attempted to balance their own interests, those of the factions that supported them, and the war, frequently leading to extraordinary measures for so many purposes. In sure Papen had this in mind when he wrote his speech. The fact that Hitler and other revolutionaries posed their movements in contrast to what they saw as the failures of previous or ongoing revolutions like that of the soviets is a great way to contextualize these efforts. A fascinating drama, the way these characters use one another to gain, and betray when they advance enough that their goals become exclusive to one another.
@phann860
@phann860 Месяц назад
It is almost always the way, once a revolution occurs the nut jobs are taken care of, except Lenin kept the nut jobs and ended up by almost destroying Russia.
@mojewjewjew4420
@mojewjewjew4420 Месяц назад
​@@phann860No worries stalin dealt with all the nut jobs, including lenin.
@gipsoneight
@gipsoneight Месяц назад
Great video as always btw.
@NikhilSingh-007
@NikhilSingh-007 Месяц назад
Unfathomably based thumbnail.
@jasonharryphotog
@jasonharryphotog Месяц назад
I watched every minute, this was excellent , enjoyed watching it;
@TheCruxy
@TheCruxy Месяц назад
"Lies must be repeated, Truth requires to be heard"
@mojewjewjew4420
@mojewjewjew4420 Месяц назад
Where is this from?
@TheCruxy
@TheCruxy Месяц назад
@@mojewjewjew4420 it's a paraphrase of something I've heard Ryan Dawson say before
@mojewjewjew4420
@mojewjewjew4420 Месяц назад
@@TheCruxy I googled him and he appears to be a nobody, not even a wiki page, anyhow I heard something similar, like Hitler saying if you say a lie enough times it will be believed.
@ForestryService.
@ForestryService. 27 дней назад
This is why leftist memes require so many words and context making...lies require effort
@leesnyder9144
@leesnyder9144 20 дней назад
@@ForestryService. that does not make any sense. The more a liar says the easier it is to understand the motive. History is about context.
@patricksullivan4329
@patricksullivan4329 Месяц назад
One would think that, since Hitler led a political party named 'National Socialist, it's a pretty strong clue that he was himself a socialist.
@strategicperson95
@strategicperson95 Месяц назад
But you get those that deflect it by pointing out how North Korea's full name has "Democratic" in it, and by the Wests own obsession and worship of democracy. What they don't realize is North Korea does view itself as "democratic" since they view it as a people's movement. Which for many communists is the "purest form of democracy." As a US citizen relearning and having a better understanding of our founding fathers, we really shouldn't hold "democracy" in such high regards as we do. Democracy itself leads to another form of tyranny, the tyranny of the majority. And in the State level, especially in my home state of Commifirnia, it truly shows how we are lead by a bunch of urbanit tyrants. Out of 55 counties, we are dictated by 3: San Francisco, Sacramento, and LA. And with all the population Jerry meandering CA and NY does just to increase their numbers of representatives; someone tell me how "democracy" is such a good when it can easily be so evil.
@nomdeguerre7265
@nomdeguerre7265 Месяц назад
@@strategicperson95 But it IS Democratic. It has elections every four to five years. It just had one for its Legislature with 8 parties 'winning' seats. The '3rd' largest is the 'Green' party. So what's not 'democratic'? Democracy isn't at all incompatible with totalitarianism. In fact unrestrained Democracy is inherently totalitarian.
@thomasshelby1922
@thomasshelby1922 Месяц назад
@@strategicperson95We aren’t a Democracy… We are a Constitutional Republic. It is deliberate that the term “democracy” is used over and over and over. A Democracy is 51% Rule, in a Democracy if you get Majority that want to ban guns then guns are banned. In a Democracy if you get Majority to vote to censor speech then you get Censored speech. The U.S is now a Oligarchy. It’s not even difficult to prove this anymore. Requirement for ID to vote is not a political issue it’s something like 80% agree which you can’t get 80% to agree on anything. If we were the Democracy that is claimed (not even the Republic) then we would have Voter ID Laws… this is actual proof that we are a Oligarchy. Iv spent the last 5 years looking at Politics to try and just understand and I didn’t care about anything but understanding and I wish I hadn’t.
@sydmccreath4554
@sydmccreath4554 Месяц назад
@@thomasshelby1922 You have elections. US population votes for who they want in power. This is the VERY DEFINITION OF A FUNCTIONING DEMOCRACY YOU MASSIVE IDIOT!!!
@karatos
@karatos Месяц назад
@@strategicperson95 Democratic Socialism is the notion that if we all vote on who the slaves will be then it makes slavery ok. I certainly don't like the notion that only those in power should be allowed to decide who may vote but the only thing more terrifying than restricted democracy is unrestricted democracy. Walking that line has been the tricky bit for all of time. Pretty sure no one has it exactly correct yet.
@chrisdjernaes9658
@chrisdjernaes9658 Месяц назад
Thank you for clarifying a complex period of history that is completely missing from American public schools and Universities. As always, the Truth is far more interesting than Hollywood and Academia portray. Cheers 🍻
@NullParadigm
@NullParadigm Месяц назад
I'm happy to see you revisting the Weimar Era again going over the political parties of the time, cause I struggle to find interesting and condensed information on the topic. Some people today (especially socialists) think the SPD wasn't socialist, and I found things only made sense (like the SPD's rhetoric) once I discovered that. Keep up the good work Lewis!
@robertortiz-wilson1588
@robertortiz-wilson1588 Месяц назад
Absolutely phenomenal work! Seriously, you’re indispensable.
@wildukind442
@wildukind442 Месяц назад
Röhm was in the secret military guild called "die schwarze Schar" (the plack passel) this was a big problem for the movement
@hardrightturn7502
@hardrightturn7502 Месяц назад
die schwarze Schar translates to 'The Black Flock'
@wildukind442
@wildukind442 Месяц назад
@@hardrightturn7502 and sounds better. thanks
@hardrightturn7502
@hardrightturn7502 Месяц назад
@@wildukind442 No prob! The word 'schar' can actually be translated as 'group', 'company', 'flock', 'crowd', 'club', almost anything like that, so you could use whatever word sounds best there. I know that 'Die Schwarze sonne' translates to 'The Black Sun'....thats how I knew, I just had to look up 'schar'
@mojewjewjew4420
@mojewjewjew4420 Месяц назад
And what did this secret military guild do?
@wildukind442
@wildukind442 Месяц назад
@@mojewjewjew4420 this guild comes out of a 4000 years old tradition of gay elite fighters. the original was called the golden flock. 150 couples out of 300 men. they were a longtime succesful elite force in the ancient greek army. sounds strange but one example: a man who watches enemies attacking his beloved partner is fighting multiple times harder than anyone you can imagine. Röhm tried to fullfill his ancient dream of a perfect warrior. hitler knew his stories since their munich days... more next time
@ricardokowalski1579
@ricardokowalski1579 Месяц назад
"non violence" and "H1t\er" are only acceptable in the context of comparing against Stalinism.
@RedRabbitEntertainment
@RedRabbitEntertainment 17 дней назад
Stalin was too based for this world
@gerritenjasper135
@gerritenjasper135 Месяц назад
I am in the last 50 pages of Peikoff’s ‘The Cause of Hitler’s Germany’ and now, the ‘status quo’ explanations of Hitler’s rise to power, right wing extremism, etc. Feel so weird to me. It’s like people don’t want to take off their blindfold and just blame everything on ‘the right’ for the sake of convenience. Also Hitler’s own writings look utterly rediculous to me now.
@browngreen933
@browngreen933 Месяц назад
Wanting Germany to be a world power like the USA was hardly ridiculous.
@NullParadigm
@NullParadigm Месяц назад
@@browngreen933 But thinking you should start wars simply because other nations have more land and less people is idiotic.
@phann860
@phann860 Месяц назад
Except Hitler was left wing, just tried a different approach.
@MK-rw1on
@MK-rw1on Месяц назад
@@phann860 hitler wasnt leftwing. nationalist never can be leftwing.
@somenon-human0267
@somenon-human0267 Месяц назад
​@@MK-rw1on you are talking about leftwingers today. leftwingers in past were nationalist.
Далее
The Death of Himmler - The Complete Series
1:32:29
Просмотров 1,2 млн
WALL OR FALL 🙈
00:10
Просмотров 11 млн
Hitler's Socialism: The Evidence is Overwhelming
43:00
Просмотров 418 тыс.
Warsaw Ghettograd - The 1943 Uprising
42:16
Просмотров 239 тыс.
Churchill was an idiot
28:05
Просмотров 442 тыс.
How World War 2 Began
1:50:40
Просмотров 1 млн
World War 1 (All Parts)
1:04:50
Просмотров 12 млн
The Night of the Long Knives | The Nazis in Power
52:12