@@jetra_h Nope. The Ottomans were never at conflict with the main Jewish community in Israel. Even the Armenians in the early ages were the most loyal population. When Russia came, things got complicated. Even when the British, who had conquered Israel and the Middle East, came, the other Jewish community in the Ottoman Empire remained loyal.
All of them do. You’re not alone “Israel’s origins are in Istanbul, not Paris and Berlin, as much as people keep dreaming about Paris and Berlin.” - The Jerusalem Post (2016-09-04: TERRA INCOGNITA: The Turkish roots of Israel’s politics: Inside the deep state)
Muslims pay Zakat tax and non Muslims pay Dhimmi tax. Both pay tax to the state for its services,if Muslims had asked non Muslims to pay zakat they would have been accused of forcing their religion on other's
@@Tee-roniand King David marrying a 12 year old girl (according to Torah and many historians of Israel and America) was okay but in case of our prophet you got a problem.
We love Jews in Turkey greetings. In republic era ( 1930s ) along side Jews saved from Spanish inquisition we saved German Jews. Most of them were scientist's. Even Einstein got invitation from Atatürk. Today Turkey is medical tourism destination welcoming up to 1 million tourist's each year, thanks to those scientists. Turkey has best dentist, eye and plastic surgery technology.
uydurma şuan doktorların hepsi istifa edip kaçma derdinde ameliyat malzemelerinin çoğu tekrar tekrar sterile edilip kullanılıyor turistler buraya çok ucuz olduğu için geliyor yoksa iyi doktor iyi teknoloji lafları ful palavra
Jews were saved primarily for economic reasons. And they were allowed to coexist alongside of Muslims as long as they minded their place as inferiors. Also there were times and places in certain regions of the Ottoman empire where Jews were greatly mistreated by their Muslim neighbors many of their Muslim neighbors. So there's definitely a mixed history there.
This is a half-truth. The Turkish government didn't specifically save Jews from the holocaust, they instituted a policy to give passports to German scientists who had lost their citizenship because of political persecution. This was done to profit from their academic skills, and it just happened to be that a tenth(!) of the persecuted academics happened to be Jews. In the end up to a thousand emigres got these passports. However, if there hadn't been such a high proportion of Jewish academics in Germany, hardly any Jew would have gotten these passports. It wasn't a humanitarian policy, it was mainly designed to improve the Turkish university system. At the same time, the Turkish government denaturalized up to 5000 Jewish Turks during the Holocaust and therefore signed their death warrents. Also at the same time, Turkey instituted antisemitic laws such as a heavy tax on non-Muslims in 1942 including Armenians and Jews that was basically robbing minorities of their entire property. Modern Turkish politicians whitewash their history by pointing to a few hundred academics being lured into the country to profit from their skills.
“Israel’s origins are in Istanbul, not Paris and Berlin, as much as people keep dreaming about Paris and Berlin.” - The Jerusalem Post (2016-09-04: TERRA INCOGNITA: The Turkish roots of Israel’s politics: Inside the deep state)
@@talzzz1546 Go learn history. There was no oppression or malice against the Armenians, they even operated freely in many fields such as trade, jewelry and craftsman and lived their richest period until they side with Russians and formed gangs and massacred the local Turkish people. They paid the price for what they did and they have to continue their lives as a poor and pathetic landlocked country.
I know many Jews who were expelled first from Germany in the 1450s, and then from Spain and Portugal, and who still live in many cities in Turkey. There are many families who settled in Izmir after Thessaloniki. In addition to Istanbul, there are many Sephardic Jews who speak Ladino in the cities of Antalya and Mersin. Our ancestors were Fatih Sultan Mehmed and II. Bayezid entrusted them to us..
@@c.f.okonta8815 The reason is simple: The Ottomans never implemented a policy of colonization, assimilation and forced religious change. Each community lived their own language and religion comfortably. They learned Ottoman (Old Turkish) to communicate extra, just because they were within Ottoman territory.
@@c.f.okonta8815The dhimmi status also quotet in the video, creates the effect. Any nonmuslim is just accepted as their own beings, with regislations like giving extra tax, but not to enforced recruiting as soldiers like regular muslim, having no new worship places to build, but using the old ones freely. Every nonmuslim minority in Ottoman had their districts and villages respectedly in Ottoman cities.
The people they terrorized is Africa. They aren't Jews they stole all of it from the bantu tribe. The Turks stole the identities of all the Israelites around the world. They did unspeakable inhuman things to my ancestors the Bantu. They are the Nazis!
05:56 Ottomans didn't banned only Jews they never allow a majority of community in one spot to cause civil war. Additional migration of one group would be putting oil into water.
We, the Turks, have never seen the Jews as enemies and have never exploited them. Even today, despite the widespread anti-Semitic propaganda in Turkey, there are millions of Turks who are friendly towards Israel and the Jews. (I am one of them)
Sektir lan Ortadoğu'da bize karşı ulusları savaştıran, İngilizlerle beraber askerlerimize pusu kurup şehit eden, esir askerlerimizi kimyasal havuzlara atıp gözlerini oyan türlü işkenceler yapan yahudi pchlerinden başkası degildi
Well we moslems always loved our Jewish and Christian brothers! We had a glorious past of being extremely tolerant and loving towards people of other faiths yet but in the past 100 years we have been shown as if we hate our brethren. I pray that May the God guide us all on the right path and keep all of us safe (ameen). I’m sorry for all the things that Jews have through in Europe and across rest of the world 🌎 . Love and respect to my lovely Jewish and Christian brothers 🙏 ❤😊
And we jews love our muslim and christian brothers and sisters. We have more than thousands of years of peacefully living together and cherishing each others cultures in the middle east. Without our muslim brothers and sisters, jewish life in cities like Bagdad, Istanbul, Beirut, … would never ever flourished, because we need each other, also in spiritual ways.
That has little truth, Muslims were not very tolerant towards Non Muslims. Discrimination, to the point were it resembled the apartheid laws in the US and South Africa, was widely common. Jews and Christians had to pay an enormous amount of money called the Jizya, had to sometimes wear distinct clothing which was often black with either a David star or giant Cross and a bell around their necks, had difficulties building churches, had barely any protection from the Islamic authorities etc.
@@eho6380 idk how this is comparable to apartheid. Apartheid is based on ethnicity not religion. Jizya is also small amount and varied under different rulers. But usually less than or same as what muslims paid (zakat)
@@Aksarallah The Jizya may have varied during different caliphs but it still was a very classic tactic to misuse it to increase the budget of the Caliphate. There were reports during the Umayyad Caliphate that the Egyptian Christians had to sell Church property because of this.
Correction: Jizya is a protection fee, Muslims pays More tax called Zakkat. Dhimma is not Umar Pact, It's set by Allah through Prophet Muhammad SAW, it also mentioned in the Quran.
Under Muslim rule, Muslims pay Zakat Tax and non-muslims pay Dhimmi/jiziya. Muslims have a duty to protect non Muslims. Non muslims are excempt from fighting wars.
It's odd. It seems like everything switched today. Now it's much safer to be a Jew in Europe than in the Islamic World, although we Muslims have nothing against Jews. I hope we can find peace and cooperation. We never hated each other before World War 1. It's sad that everything changed since.
Turkey is a secular country. Nothing will happen to you as a jew in turkey. Arguably You’re even more safe in turkey as a jew in the main cities than in europe because of islamic diversity, understanding and common irreligiousity among the turks, and turkish islamic community is also way more founded on personal and moral values along w culture while not so much in arabic countries. As for erdogan… he is the go to of the uneducated.
Turks have always accepted the Israelites as friends. (Because their respectful, honest and they are very friendly with Turkish peoples for sure) However, Israel's historical ties with the Israeli people are weakening due to operations that sometimes turn into massacres. Starting before the Second World War, the Republic of Turkey saved tens of thousands of Jews throughout the war. Turkish Embassies in Germany, France, Czechoslovakia and Greece distributed citizenship to tens of thousands of people. Those people also took refuge in Turkey safely, stating that they were Turkish citizens who wanted to return to Turkey. During the war, the Turkish state removed hundreds of people who were sent to Auschwitz and Dachou concentration camps and sent them to Turkey. Indeed, if all historical documents and archives are examined, they can see how unrealistic many of the slanders accused of the Turks are. The Turkish state can examine the Ottoman Archives and all records of the period with the states of the period such as the Russian Tsardom, France and the British Empire in Turkish, English, German, French, Russian and Spanish.
The Ottoman banned Jewish migration to Israel in 1891 and this began the narrative against Israel. The Ottoman narrative got amplified by the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem and this narrative still continues till today. The French anti-antisemitism and the Ottoman opposition to Jewish migration to Israel laid the foundation to the conflict seen today. This is often overlooked.
@@cengizsogutlu this video mostly just propaganda Doesn't really tell about how muslims and jews fought together in the crusades against the Christians Or the jewish and christian slave owners that owned black slaves in the new world At the end of the day everyone just looks out for their own people Jews looked out for their own interests So did muslims and Christian's Nobody will feel pain for another only if he or she is an innocent baby
?? one side story lol, there's already a lot of Jew in Palestine, of course they're minority, after all Muslim soldiers is the one who freed Palestine from Christian rules, the restrictions imposed on jew by ottoman is a precaution to avoid unbalanced power and mass transfer in Palestine, to avoid civil war etc
In 1560 Grand Mufti of Ottoman Empire Ebu Suud Efendi is asked in a fatwa, "What is the meaning of the term the Holy Land?" His answer is that "various definitions of the term exist, among them the whole of Syria, to Aleppo and Urfa in the north. Others equate it with the area of Jerusalem (al-Quds); still others equate it with the term "Palestine."" In 1648 Kâtip Çelebi, in his book "Tuhfat al Kibar fi Asfar al Bihar/A Gift to the Great concerning Naval Expeditions" (printed by Ibrahim Muteferrika in 1729 in Istanbul, the book written in Turkish, but the title is Arabic); the first detailed Ottoman mapping of its Syrian provinces. Describes "Palestine" as the "noblest of the administrative divisions of Syria," comprising the two sanjaqs of Gaza and Jerusalem: "In the southwest the border goes from the Mediterranean and al Arish to the Wilderness of the Sinai. In the southeast it is the Dead Sea and the Jordan River. In the north it goes from the Jordan River to the borders of Urdun as far as Caesarea." 1649 Ottoman buerocrat, diplomat and traveller Evliya Çelebi in his Turkish language book Travels in Palestine wrote: "All chronicles call this country the Land of Palestine."
The way non Jews in Israel is similar treatment Jews faced. It's disgusting that people who have been victims of this treatment could could turn around and treat others the same way. Not very chosen behavior.
You jumped pretty quickly from the Muslim caliphs to the Ottoman sultans don't you think? You left out the whole story of the Mongols and their presence in the Levant. Just saying there's a lot more to the saga. But thx. anyway.
The turkic muslims see the Jjws as their cousins in faith. Even the historical Khazars, a Turkic people, were Jews. The Ottoman Empire was a refuge for fleeing Jews from Europe. The successor state of Türkiye under Atatürk, Jews had migrated from all over the world. The jews was an important asset for the young turkish state. Today, the turkish jews are one of the most patriotic citizens groups of turkiye. Turks are not arabs or persians ;)
Jews and Muslims have lived side by side since the time of Caliph Umar, when he took Palestine in 638 AD, that means before the Turks knew what Islam was. The Ottomans, who ruled much later, can be categorized as a "new" empire compared to the early Islamic caliphates. Muslim tolerance and acceptance of Jews has been a long-standing aspect of Islamic history, but, it has not always been perfect because we don't live in Disneyland. There were both periods of peace and conflict, which is reasonable given the complexity of history
@@juanjaimes1836 during world war the jews army of ottoman army consisting of 80k troops betrayed ottomans when british attacked levant region .... the commander of jewish army david ben later become the first pm of isreal .... after providing centuries of protection the ottomans came to know that they are actually feeding snakes
Everybody called the Holy Land as Palestine even in 16th century. In 1560 Grand Mufti of Ottoman Empire Ebu Suud Efendi is asked in a fatwa, "What is the meaning of the term the Holy Land?" His answer is that "various definitions of the term exist, among them the whole of Syria, to Aleppo and Urfa in the north. Others equate it with the area of Jerusalem (al-Quds); still others equate it with the term "Palestine."" In 1648 Kâtip Çelebi, in his book "Tuhfat al Kibar fi Asfar al Bihar" (printed by Ibrahim Muteferrika in 1729 in Istanbul); the first detailed Ottoman mapping of its Syrian provinces. Describes "Palestine" as the "noblest of the administrative divisions of Syria," comprising the two sanjaqs of Gaza and Jerusalem: "In the southwest the border goes from the Mediterranean and al Arish to the Wilderness of the Sinai. In the southeast it is the Dead Sea and the Jordan River. In the north it goes from the Jordan River to the borders of Urdun as far as Caesarea." 1649 Ottoman buerocrat, diplomat and traveller Evliya Çelebi in his book Travels in Palestine wrote: "All chronicles call this country the Land of Palestine."
@@schoolofgrowthhacking This is one of the easiest claims to disprove, honestly. Judea was mostly a polity within Palestine/Philistia. Herodotus referred to it as Palestine in his histories in the 400s BCE, as did several Greek scholars after him prior to Roman conquest. Before Herodotus, various Semitic languages referred to the region and people as some version of Palestine with the consonant roots of P-L-S-T dating back to Egyptian pharaohs.
@@PaulMatthis The Merneptah Stele, also known as the Israel Stele or the Victory Stele of Merneptah, is an inscription by Merneptah, a pharaoh in ancient Egypt who reigned from 1213 to 1203 BCE The stele represents the earliest textual reference to Israel and the only reference from ancient Egypt.[4] It is one of four known inscriptions from the Iron Age that date to the time of and mention ancient Israel by name, with the others being the Mesha Stele, the Tel Dan Stele, and the Kurkh Monoliths
After that 1891 ban, Jews still made their way to Ottoman Palestine in non-trivial numbers (waves of pre- and post- Herzlian Zionist immigration) prior to the British victory, so I presume it wasn't energetically enforced. Maybe the Ottomans were just too busy otherwise trying to preserve the empire. Maybe the ban was declared primarily to appease certain political factions. Maybe the Ottomans received or anticipated financial benefits. I'm not so well read on this history so I'm only speculating.
They didn't take any money, but it was offered. A Jewish team, including a man who graduated from Istanbul University and was the first president of Israel, wanted an autonomous region in and around Jerusalem at that time, and in return they would pay all the debts of the Ottoman Empire. Abdulhamit refused this because they had an egalitarian approach, but then in the First World War, the Arabs betrayed the Ottoman Empire and massacred the Turks along with the British, and instead of an Ottoman autonomous jewish state, the British mandate of Palestine was established. The reason why the establishment of Israel was delayed by 50 years was probably because the Ottomans rejected the offer of autonomy in exchange for money, if they knew that the Arabs would stab the Ottomans in the back, they would probably have agreed with the Jews and expelled the betrayel Arabs from the region, and also cleared their debts.
Khazars are defenitly Turkic Khaganate it is the continuation of Gokturk Khaganate. The Khazar khanate was established after the collapse of the Gokturk khanate. The founding dynasty of Gokturks are ashine, later period same dynasty founded the Khazar Khaganate. The Gokturk khanate was Tengrist but the Khazar khan converted to Judaism, probably for political reasons, as it war with Umayyads arabs. Since the Khazars religion Judaism even if they were Turkic, most historians think that the massive amount of Jews migrate because Umayyads opression and settled in the Khazar Khaganate living peacefully and mixed with local people.
False. The Khagnate Empire was so evil they were surrounded and dissembled by the surrounding Empires. They were forced to adopt an Abrahamic religion. They chose to Pose as Judah under the religion of Judaism. They still worshipped with the Talmud and their old traditions but kept up the fake front of seeming righteous in the public's view. They are a people without a land, so they were known to use trickery and money tricks to extract wealth from the areas they immigrated to. Which is what happened to the Ottoman Empire. They accepted them into their territory and the Khagans killed, stole, bribed their way to the top of society while impoverishing everyday Ottomans. ... sounds familiar? Should. Germany tried kicking them out and you see how they tricked everybody into thinking it was Germans who were the provocateurs. Anne Frank.. fake..Kristallnacht was the German people trying to kick out the Bankers, Pawn Brokers, and Loan sharks. They put a star on them so they could be recognized as Judaism so the German people would know not to trust them. That's why Germany's military generals were full of Khagnates scientist using soldiers like science experiments. .. FF>> that's why they are in Israel but double citizen in another country that they extract wealth from and send it back to Israel. Even though the people of Israel were sold into slavery and prophecy says they wont be in their land until The Messiah comes back. Somehow the Khagnates parlayed their fake Judaism conversion into being a part of the actual Bloodline of Judah instead of the truth that they are Khagans from another way North of Israel. Smh.
Would like to see the channel touch upon how General Erich von Falkenhayn (despite having a low opinion of Jewish people) and other German officers were said to have thwarted a plan by Djemal Pasha during WW1 to do to the Jewish community within the land of Israel what was done to the Armenians, Assyrians and Greeks within the Ottoman Empire during that period prior to the arrival of the British.
@@magnumopus1628 Battle in Fez mentioned in the screen happened when a moroccan Sultan fought his rival nephew over the throne with the support of Ottoman troops. The battle was between two muslim factions and jews have nothing to do with it. as of the massacre of fez It happened even before Ottoman state was even founded. After the Idrisid Dynasty fell in Morocco the country fell into a state of anarchy with a bunch of Berber tribes fighting and raiding each other. leading to a berber tribe "maghrawa" sacking the city of Fez and massacring It's citizens. mainly from the Jewish minority in the city.
What has never changed has never changed. Baruch Hashem His People thrive and multiply everywhere they go and their enemies seize to exist. It has never changed.
The 1891 ban was never enforced. German and Eastern European Jews continued to settle in Palestine until and during WWI, after which the Ottaman Empire collapsed.
Türklerin yahudi düşmanlığı yoktur. Osmanli döneminde bu kadar çok milleti bir arada tutmanin tek yolu adaletle yönetmekti ve Türkler yüzlerce yıl bunu yapmaya gayret etti.
@@cankirsehirli They spoke Ladino and Tutkish after the big wave of Spaniards, who changed the community's culture from the local Greek to more Spanish. Before that wave the Jews spoke Romaniotic - Jewish Greek, and they were called Romaniotes, not Romanian as she told. Romanian Jews are the Jews of Romania, not the Jews of Eastern Rome/ Byzantium (Rome).
You miss so many importants events: The proclamation of the first jewish Rishon Letzion around 1880 as a Jewish gobernor of Jerualsem , the first was Abraham Hai Gagin…..the development of the economic activities in Ottoman Palestine by the help of Moises Montefiore, the first jewish Hospital, the first jewish press in Jerusalem. You miss the Burn of Smyrna in 1922 and the protection of the Jews by Ottoman soldiers…..
Factually wrong! The laws of the thimma are directly from the prophet عليه السلام himself! They are allowed to follow their own legal systems and courts!
@@UNPACKED But they didn't settle there. They settled in Bosnia and Herzegovina. And your graphic shows them doing what I described. The parts of Ottoman Empire than were Muslim had a lot of fun. The others, catastrophe.
The Berber Muslims liberated the remnants of Israel from Visigoth rule over Spain in 711. The reconquista, inquisition and edict of expulsion of Israelites from “Spain” on the 31st of March 1492. Forced the Israelites to convert to Catholicism, and/or leave. Many could not afford passage out of Spain so they converted in fear for their lives and of their loved ones . Many who did not convert and could afford passage. Left to various parts of the known world. Specifically Africa. Then there the masses who couldn’t afford passage and did not convert to catholicism. On the very last day of the edict. It was the Ottomans who came for them. For over 900 years they lived amicably. In Spain and in the Ottoman Empire. For 900 years Muslims protected them and gave them liberty to live as they wished, to practice what they wished, to be fruitful, and to grow prosperously. It’s sad to see the relationships between the two this day and age. How can two groups of people live together prosperously and amicably for 900 years and today be at extreme odds? The answer is worth investigating.
The jizya was a tax on non-Muslims collected by the State and distributed to Muslims so they had a passive income and did not need to work - or, at least, that's how it was envisioned. They did not want Jews and Christians to convert because they lost income with every convert - no more jizya coming in plus there was one more Muslim the State had to pay. That model wasn't sustainable so the converts were the first Muslims required to pay the jizya. That said, in many ways, it was a much better life than a Jew could expect in Europe but imagine what life would be like if you had to supply the income of the dominant group in your society while they didn't have to work though they did fill many government and military roles. The Jews were particularly valuable when it came to trade because they had established personal networks that stretched from Palestine to England, Morocco to Poland, and everywhere in between. They could get anything - weapons, ammunition, experts - anything at all and they filled the role of ambassadors rather effectively.
Do you think the tax collected from the jews was enough even enough to feeding a city of muslims? Pls check the income, economy and infrastructure of the empire before you speculate. You should be thankful to the ottomans that they just used their money and not their body as slaves and warriors in wars. What a terrible comment damn
Your way understanding the history and interpreting on it is shameful. I see a comment of a 10 year old child learning history from the movie Dracula lol
Is it known roughly what proportion of expelled Sephardic Jews made their way to the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth and Eastern Europe in general rather than the Ottoman Empire/MENA and Americas/etc?
🕉. When Jews had been kicked out of Ottoman Empire, they could not get good treatment anywhere. Only in India 🇮🇳 they got love and dignity. The Mumbai Jews (Bombay, India) narrate it with great pride. Why don't you mention it in the Description. Publicize the Jews's love towards India. 🇮🇳.
@@pardes7342 India was never under Ottoman Empire. It waw turks of central Asia who invaded India,but they never able to penetrate deep in South-India and Jews only live in Hindu Kingdom so they were treated with humanity.
@@abbakovner1861 in 1917 around 80,000 jews in ottoman army betrayed the ottomans and shifted their sides to british right in the middle of battle resulting in biggest ottoman defeat in levant region ..
@@haroonshahid5545 Well, obviously, in 1916 the Arabs themselves were the ones who made a rebellion to destroy that empire that was already falling apart from before.
@@mahlina1220 though we shouldn't forget after ww1 the Ottoman Empire broke in pieces, and during the 1929 British Palestine riots the Arabs attacked Jews who did nothing wrong such as causing the Hebron massacre for example (remember before that they legally and fairly bought land or property)
It is the biggest mistake of the Ottoman Turks. The Ottomans saved the Jews who were being subjected to genocide in Spain. he placed it in 3 large cities. These Jews hid inside the Turkish nation. They looked like Turks and carved the inside of the Ottoman. When the time comes, sultan 2. They overthrew Abdulhamid and broke up the Ottoman Empire. Westerners were aware of the Jewish danger. Turks and Muslims treated Jews with compassion. We understand very well that they made a big mistake.
We, the Turks, have never seen the Jews as enemies and have never exploited them. Even today, despite the widespread anti-Semitic propaganda in Turkey, there are millions of Turks who are friendly towards Israel and the Jews. (I am one of them)
Yahudilere bir Türkün düşman olması büyük bir aptallıktır.1. si 2.Abdülhamidi tahttan indiren yahudiler değil kendi yaptığı hatalardır. Örneğin 1877-1878 Osmanlı Rus savaşı gibi.Yahudiler Türk Tarihinde bir kez bile Türklere isyan etmemiş ve Türk Askerine kurşun sıkmamışlarıdır.Ama Araplar binlerce Türkü katletmiş ve binlerce Osmanlı Askerini şehit etmişlerdir. Hatta bugün Filistin bayrağı bile Osmanlıya isyan eden aşiretlere ait isyan bayrağıdır.
Caliphate or Khaleefeh is a Farsi word " خرابها - kharabeha " which means Ruins, abandoned properties or properties of dead owners with no heir. Hashem (zionism) and Commonwealth are partnered up as the khaleefa of the world, secretly and deceptively. Caliphate organization needs to be a public, transparent and not for power or profit. Caliphate shall use the entire assets to help women, children and old people who do not have the ability or opportunity to compete for food and shelter. Iran is the only nation who has a separate charity organization to manage this assets "Bonyad Mostazafan" which is the largest charity organization in the world which has virtually eliminated income tax.
I wish religion or ideologies never played a part in this if only all cultures would have lived in peace with each other instead of forcing an so-called non-Muslim tax on jews christians and zoroastrians at the time and the ottoman empire would have been a much better and greater country instead of benefiting on slavery and conquests
We paid as much as Dhimmis did so they could avoid Army service that mandatory, 2.1% more is what we have to pay than Dhmmis. I still think if it weren’t Religions it would still be racism some what.
That tax you mentioned about was because Non-Muslims weren’t allowed to serve in the military. Muslims didn’t pay it since they had to join the military. After all, it would be awkward to make serving in military mandatory for non-Muslims in an Islamic Empire.
Jizya and zakat just tax nomenclature, similar thing, and actually jizya quite easy as it fixed number in few classes...zakat can be so much much higher as it not fixed pay
Are you sure about that? In the first half of the 20th century, many Arabs were displaced as Jews bought the lands they had been working on. And as for what happened in 1947-48, it’s more complicated than you might think (as wars tend to be) ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-jB6IhmHYzWs.html
It’s hard to track exactly - estimates are that 1.5 million dunams, which was 75% of Jewish land pre-1948, was purchased from Arabs. Although estimates are that some 3,000 became landless, as much of the land was held by a few foreign owners. Many (50-100k) Arabs were also arriving from neighboring Arab countries during this time to work on Jewish lands, so it’s hard to define percentages exactly.
Dhimmis mean obligation or a responsibility. Non Muslims are supposed to be more protected in a Muslim state as their welfare and security is direct responsibility of the state. For this they pay a Taz named Jaziya and are exempt from Zakat tax which only Muslims pay. They're supposed to be equal citizens of state except for a few discriminations related to religious ideology. But in the real world, sadly it doesn't happen. Secondly how come Jews fled to Israel when Israel was not even created as said in the video? It is a very one sided video, only showing a Jewish point of view.
It would be beneficial to describe the relationship between the Jews and Muslims in the Middle East today. I lived in the Middle East. Jews and Muslims got along fine. However, most Arabs (principally Muslim) disliked Israels racist policies.
@@RUBIKS.R. Then please explain this… “Do not take the Jews and the Christians for friends; they are friends of each other; and whoever amongst you takes them for a friend, then surely he is one of them; surely Allah does not guide the unjust people.” -Quran 5:51
Well, everything was better for everyone. 400 years of relative prosperity in the Middle East and it all ended when the Turkish state lost its Arab possessions. Turkey should get its lands back and we would have freedom again. No terror no quarrel.
I'm sick of people claiming everything as a conspiracy theory. Face the facts that some of your people have done wrong instead of denying and defending their wrong doing.
Jews' economic success is the reason. They are smart, hard-working, shrewd businesspeople who take care of their own. Love them or hate them, there's no denying that. Don't get me wrong, I have great friends from both Jewish and Arabic descent.
@@levand3673 ''powerless people, don't you forgot that''? This is exactly the kind of thing I'm referring too. Pretending that jews were never in position of power/influence and then creating a stigma that you ''must not forget that''. It's the ultimate victimhood and then have the audacity to claim success. It's disingenuous and embarrassing.
@@sergiosaunier you'll always hear of the ''success'' but never the failures. Taking responsibility seem very difficult for some to do. Other groups have no problem in calling some of their own if they find them to be immoral. They literally have organisations and espionage preventing them from criticism and facing responsibility. When you highlight these simple facts, you're called a conspiracy theorist..
This video has missinformation Muslim nerver treat non Muslim 2nd class citizen. Under ISLAMIC law Muslim has many social service & responsibility what nonmuslim dosent has.If non Muslim has zizya Muslim has jakha,fitra & other social serrvice.also Muslim can't trede in relagious fair what is big business back than
You force us to hate you the amount of deception is sickening what you mean by 2nd class citizen call it gezia or call it taxes potato pata . Judges, doctors, ministers, and scholars had freedom of worship, and even the judiciary had an independent judiciary
This video distorts the facts that Jews found safety and protection in the arms of Muslims in North Africa and the Ottoman State and lived their best times among Muslims. THey were not discreminated against and were treated by the Justice provided in Islam for non-Muslims especially Jews and CHristians.
Sassoon family escaped from Turkey from death threats from Caliph. They came to Bombay and British gave him protection. Sassoons were successful business family and constructed many iconic buildings that Stand proudly even today.
Poor Greeks(!) did not give back the property of Jews to their remaining family members. How many billions dolars would it cost? All the real estate in Thessaloniki which were owned by Jews. It is a must I think. Poor Greeks(!) should compensate som how.
@@cankirsehirli Poor Jews that live in Greece and they don't pay taxes to Greece but their taxes go to Israel How many billions of dollars would it cost?
Finally an explanation that tells it like it is without all of the geographical beating around the bush when it come to the relationship between the Jews and Muslims, it was that whole; I like you better but you’re number “two”. I can only speculate that this was a bit of a pill for the Jewish people to swallow knowing that, if they had a difficult time in Christian Europe the Muslims could just forget about it; infect the only thing between the Muslim people and Eastern Europe were the Jews but two is better then zero so they played along. I can only speculate that the Muslims saw the arrival of Eastern European Jews as a possible threat as they must have been very metropolitan and could be viewed as the new number one going forwarded in the Ottoman Empire. Now there is a whole lot I don’t know and I’m sure it’s not that simple, but old wounds and animosities stem from simple things like someone telling you you’re number two just before they get there asses handed to them by the other number one you had to deal with in the past.
