The Scariest FNaF Characters You Don't Know - DMuted 

Fetch is scary, not because of endangering you, but you endangering everyone else. Fetch read Greg’s mind and killed the neighbor’s dog. Say you get in an argument with your friend, saying you hate them or something. Fetch will kill them, perceiving your friend as a nuisance to you.

I think one of the scariest things in all of FNAF is the story "Into the Flesh". The idea of an organic Springtrap creature popping out like a Xenomorph is terrifying. xD

I've never really known what these books were for the longest time, I had no idea they were a modern version of goosebumps, just very strange and sometimes terrifying concepts wrapped up in a book for kids, just with a fnaf coat of paint, very intereseting

Really do love the underrated FF characters, I really will always adore Pit Bonnie (sadly he was made into Eleanor which adds to my hatred for the character) and Fetch. I really love seeing a cool video like this shedding light on said characters.

Nothing beats being called wrong by mister deep muted FNAF himself.

Hearing you describe Into The Pit really sounds like a bad dream. Like if Michael had a dream about what his dad did and how it corrupted his childhood memories of Freddy's which (before he knew his dad's crimes) would have been nice. Doesn't mean the story is literally Michael's dream because the main character is Oswald but maybe it's a parallel to give us insight into Michael's mindset. Just a thought.

I like how fazbear frights has Danganronpa level over the top shit

SPRINGTRAP MPREG CANON?????? NOONE TELL KWITE

0:42 Pretty sure Scott said all of them are canon but they take place in different timelines, it’s kinda confusing. Basically everything thing that happened in the fright books can happen in the games but the stories never happened in the games but in alternate timelines.

I loved Fetch, he's so complex and unique, the ending scene actually frightened me. Absolute favorite.

I’m glad someone else is talking about these admittedly awesome additions to the Fnaf universe. Personally the most horrifying creature for me was the Julius Mech from the Breaking Wheel. I think how much the book builds it up makes you think it’s not going to be a thing until the story does a double twist and has this mangled kid in a metal suit actually happen. Then how he he kills the protagonist at the end is utterly disgusting in a way that I love. Great video

For me it’s gotta be into the pit springbonnie and count the ways Funtime Freddy. You have listed all of the ways into the pit springbonnie. Funtime Freddy how ever is a homicidal maniac he wants the main character to pick a death. Knows the French Revolution. But the worst thing that he did is he actually kills the main character

Great list! The Sea Bonnies are so dumb in concept, I agree, but they still creeped me out really bad. Mott's fate was horrible. I loved Blackbird, it's such a cool concept and was a really good story. Ralpho was cool and has a very memorable design, and I just loved the ending of Bunny Call. We really do need more games about the Fazbear Frights! The Stitchwraith stingers are very good, I wish they had been their own novel so they could have had more details and scenes. They explain the ball pit later as well.

ITP Spring bonnie is honestly my favourite character, he's so eerie, like a repaired uncanon springtrap with the body still inside. It's a shame that we only see him in one book, many of the book characters deffo deserves sequels.

tbf in the flesh is the only story thus far to make me feel uneased

Ik this isn’t Fazbear Frights related, but I think that Adult Charlie/Elizabeth has to be one of the creepiest fnaf animatronics to ever come out of the novels. I mean, come on, she punches Teen Charlie’s stomach so hard that fake blood comes oozing out and she rips out an Ella doll from her stomach.

I can't remember the story's name but one of my favorites is the one where the two girls end up in a pig animatronic, it's fnafy enough to makes sense but also does it's own thing. It's not weird either as the animatronic seems to simply possessed or controlled which calls back to a simpler time. I'd say it also makes William's death so much worse as it describes every detail of what the springlocks do to a person even more so than Dave's speech in silver eyes.

The fact that I just found your channel today and this comes out after I’ve just finished watching some videos of yours makes me happy

I've only read two Fazbear Frights books and I don't plan on quitting but 1:35 am wasn't my favorite story by a long shot but I only felt super bad for the main character the entire time. Same thing with Lonely Freddy. They weren't scary at all but they just made me feel bad. Anyway Out of Stock was genuinely such a blast to read and I can't wait to see more

The agony reminds me of Randy Cunningham's 9th Grade Ninja's corruption system, except it's misery.

Say what you will about Faz-goo but the concept itself is very disturbing. Honestly I kinda like how weird and crazy these stories get on occasion, it's just neat to see FNaF stories taken in all kinds of directions, which is one reason why I really like both Frights and Tales.

I’d love to see you cover some more of these stories!

Super awesome video. I’m really glad you’re giving these characters a moment to shine in this video.

Okay "The Real Jake" could be a Silent Hill monster backstory.

I don’t see fetch as a villain or evil, but neutral, it’s just following instructions

The fact that Luigi’s Mansion music is playing in the background in the beginning: 👏🏼

Its awesome to watch a youtuber who talks about the books.

'in the flesh' to me felt the most like, realistically tragic in a way. sure it's got that fnaf charm but it's a man away from his ill son trying to make him feel better with what he can. there's no actual antagonist we can point a pitchfork at, even the brain cancer- it's a faceless unceasing cell growth in the most unfortunate place. not even whoever planted that ied that took out jake's dad, we don't even know all that. everyone in that story were just people, plain and simple.

Nice video! You seriously have a lot of potential my friend! I wish you great amounts of happiness and success! :)

I personally theorize that Ralpho might just be a random serial killer, not William Afton but some escaped mental patient or maybe a spree killer on the news as some background lore that we're not privy to. I mean it bled red blood not agony so it (in theory should be human) and besides a lot these books seem to be takes on established horror movies, tropes and scary stories, for example: Blackbird: The Raven By: Edgar Allen Poe Step Closer: John Carpenter's They Live To be Beautiful: I personally interpret as a retelling of the legend of Faust, but focusing on the "Deal with the Devil" trope that the story bought in but through the lens of a twisted retelling of Cinderella Out of Stock, Fetch and Sea Bonnies: Take your pic on which killer doll , terrifying toy and small monster movies movie they could be paying a homage to, Child's Play, Puppet Master, Annabelle, Talky Tina, Gremlins, Ghoulies, The Pit, The Gate. I could go on. Fazgoo and Lonely Freddy: Invasion of the Body Snatchers, anyone? So I feel like if we applied Ralpho's story to this formula I've made up it would probably be a Fazbear Fright's take on a few things: 1. 80s slasher flicks such as Friday the 13th, due to be set in a camp in the woods with a masked killer stalking an unsuspecting group of people just looking to get away. 2. Home invasion thrillers such as Us, You're Next and The Purge, due to said masked killer wanting nothing more than to get in. 3. The trope of the situation of the story happening due to a prank gone wrong, look at Slaughter High and Terror Train. Although this was more like trying to abort the prank if anything, so that may or may not count. So, I believe that this story is basically at its core a suspenseful 80s style slasher film in the form of the written word. Or I may be overthinking it, but either way I had fun theorizing and sharing.

Honestly, I think Scott Cawthon should take The Real Jake and turn it into an official FNAF game with Steel Wool or some other game company, or even an element of the movie. Unlike every other thing in FNAF, the topics covered in The Real Jake is depressing and super realistic. If Scott does that, then he'd reach a new level of horror for the franchise that, much to one's discomfort, we'd see play out to the very end. Quite literally.

Imo, the breaking wheel, count the ways and together forever are probably the scariest fnaf stories. I guess stuff like gumdrop angel and kids at play are also scary but not nearly as scary as the beginning few.

If someone asked me this I would either answer William Afton in every form even when his memories became the agony or the one and only. Golden Freddy.

Great video!!!

I don't think you'll catch this but, could you do a video on TheDarkLordK's Mangle video? The voice acting in that video is spot on and I love how the characters acknowledge that the animatronics can actually be dangerous. NGL the almost constant thought process that because they aren't human means they aren't dangerous despite being much bigger and heavier than you is kinda annoying.

Out of Stock is my fav story EVER

Got curious, looked up ied explosions, and then I clicked images, IDK even know why but those images are horrific

What about that one story in Felix the Shark? The scoop I think it was called. That was the saddest story with a nice ending :,)

I think Funtime Freddy is the books is the scariest. A large animatronics that can fit a TEEN and won't let her out even after begging and saying she didn't want to ACTUALLY die is scary. And how many ways he lists off isn't even all

the scariest part of this video was the music changing volume when i had loudness equalization off

We need an out of stock game

"And it was jakes dad who was a soldier over-seas talking to jake" Awhhhh "And then he died to an IED explosion" JESUS CHRIST.

so greg didnt say "Man jack...i really wish i had Kim Jung Uns heart rn"

gotta be fnaf 1 bonnie. he hit that perfect uncanny valley when he cooked that thing up

I really want to make a 3d fazbear frights fangame but I don't really know what stories to create a minigame of (except out of stock and bunny call, these are pretty obvious). Can you give me some suggestions?

maybe ralfo was not an animatronic or possesed but an actual murderer or serial killer idk

the pig animatronic from i think friendly face is one of the scariest in fazbear frights

Bro Under Construction isn't weird, that world ending thing was a whole simulation in Vr, it's implied that the girl got shocked leaving the booth and probably her soul got trapped there inside the simulation, that's why when she dies in the simulation, everything becomes darkness but she is not dead.

The only exposure I'va had to Fazbear frights before is a Quandale Dingle-style montage in a russian youtuber's video.

Yeahhhhh babbbyy!!!! New upload!!!!

I REALLY like that 3d model

My personal scariest animatronics are nightmarionne,fetch and baby from the books

8:00 so he just injects pure agony into you? If he does, then it seems like agony is a wierd thing in the universe

Yeah cancer and grief probably are some of the worst monsters to exist.

....so its Oswald and the Unlucky Rabbit. Seems legit

If I were to encounter them In person, the scariest animatronic, in my opinion, would be mangle, hanging from the ceiling

Honestly I find the design of the blackbird to be very creepy lol

As much as it's a meme to hate on faz-goo, He Told Me Everything was one of the only FF stories that honestly creeped me out.

misread tge thumbnail as sexiest monsters i was so confused

lol persona soundtrack in the background

Why is the books remind me of the goosebumps book

Lash bird trap

Bro I want a personal fetch

No demuted we can't beat any animatronics

Into the pit spring bonnie is terrifying to me

These are scary animatronics/monsters but they don't beat the Julius exoskeleton

Just wondering is 6am night for you chat. for me its day

Yknow as dumb as Sea Bonnie’s are I actually really enjoy them as a concept. Granted I may be biased bc I love body horror in fiction though lol

what about the agony,lonely freddys,faz-goo

its music man for me

"Jeffrey's Revenge" 😭

Could Ralph all be the mimic

Fetch is litterally M3GAN

If someone asked me who the scariest animatronic was, my default answer would be Ballora. I’ve always found her the most unsettling out of anyone in the series.

me: *thinks of Plushtrap as the scariest* yeah right

fyi first one is called ITP Bonnie or Into The Pit Bonnie

The more hear about the bools the more fanfictiony they sound

Neat

what game are you playing?

3rd comment: Dark-skinned cheetos.

12:55 tell Evan?

great video! what is the game in the gameplay called

Honestly, I think the scariest monster from the books is Julius's Exoskeleton. I mean the story itself doesn't even have anything to do with fnaf at all. It's literally a fleshy exoskeleton who crawls on walls and is very fast.

Noice

honestly fetch doesn't sound that bad, like yeah he kills people but he isn't inherently evil or anything, he's just trying to be helpful to his owner in any way it can.

i didnt watch the vid. but mine is nightmarionne

The music is a little too loud

8:00

10:05 There was literally no reason for you to be salty

What about Funtime Freddy?

2:14 you mean 6

Y'know, maybe I'm just missing something, but I couldn't stand the Fazbear Frights books. I only got up to Gumdrop Angel before giving up. The main characters are always unlikable assholes, the books spend way to long describing details that really don't matter, the storylines are easily predictable once you get past the first few pages, and the storylines themselves are just kinda awful. To Be Beautiful sexualizes a 15 year old, In The Flesh is just actual impreg fanfiction, and Lonely Freddy is so ungodly boring that I'm still not sure how I got through it. One big problem is the plots are so cartoonish that they just don't fit into FNAF. Some stories, like Into The Pit, are so batshit insane that they can benefit from it. But for the most part, the Walmart brand Goosebumps style the books take on kinda flies in the face of the horror of the FNAF series. The whole point is that the animatronics are cartoon like, and yet realistic in an uncanny way, similarly to the Chuck E Cheese animatronics they spoof. When you take away the realism and just make them run of the mill horror story boogiemen and it really doesn't work. It also doesn't help how poorly the animatronics are implemented into the stories. In Come Closer, Foxy, the main antagonist and cover of the fucking book, appears twice. One of said instances being the start of the story and the other being a dream sequence. There are some exceptions to this, thankfully. Scenes like the Ralpho fight from Bunny Call or the Plushtrap chase from the Plushtrap story from book 2 I can't remember the name of are stand out examples, and genuinely feel like something from the games. However these kinds of scenes are the exception and not the rule. And about what I said about the main characters, you know the opening scenes in slasher movies? You know, the ones where a couple of unnamed throwaway characters go into a spooky place to do some form of delinquent behavior only to get brutalized by the big bad to show off how cool and scary he is? They're usually one note and unlikable so the audience knows not to care about them. Imagine that, but if the throwaway characters where the main characters of the movie. Take Angel from Gumdrop Angel, for example. She's in a shitty situation, sure. But one of the first things she does in the story is slap the shit out of her younger stepsister because said younger sister offered her a slice of pizza. Or Milly from Count The Ways. She spends the entire story being a dick to her cool ass, murder robot hoarding, cookie baking grampa for basically no reason. There's also Mat from In The Flesh, who's awful to basically everyone who interacts with him, and tries to steal his roommate's date after getting drunk. If you want a horror story to be suspenseful, you have to make the audience care about the main characters. If not, then the audience has no investment of if they die or not. I won't pretend The Silver Eyes trilogy had top tier human characters, but at least I couldn't say I hated a majority of the cast. When Charlie was in danger, I was actually decently invested. On the topic, the original trilogy also had objectively better scenes with the animatronics. The Foxy arcade chase, the Balloon Boy lights section, the Funtime Freddy mirror maze, all of them were fun sections and, like I said, felt like something from the games. That kind of formula could have worked well in Fazbear's Fights. Set up an animatronic and end the story with a climactic fight with said animatronics. Instead, we just kinda get an unsatisfying anticlimax for most stories. The finale of Come Closer gets cut off by the main character getting hit by a truck and dying. To Be Beautiful just kinda has the lead decompose into garbage. I feel like these are trying to be more horror based endings, which can work, but the issue is that they don't. Like the third books ending, where the main character just kinda goes coocoo and hides in a pipe because an alarm clock was bothering her, kinda like that one SpongeBob episode with the boots but worse. If you like the Fazbear Frights books, fine by me, but honestly I just don't like them.

*lip smack*

Uhh No, you cant say which characters are scary and which ones aren't. hardly any one the characters you said where "scary" actually scared me

Me who already read the Fazbear Frights.

I think glamrock Ferddy is scary