Тёмный
No video :(

The Snell Helmet Standard is Meaningless 

FortNine
Подписаться 2 млн
Просмотров 638 тыс.
50% 1

Snell-certified motorbike helmets are a hallmark of safety. But last year, something sneaky happened. And it changes everything.
Support us by shopping motorcycle gear with this link:
frt9.co/aeu0mn
Or anything with this Amazon link:
frt9.co/30l4bi
Bike in the shop? Traveling? Rent your next ride with Riders Share: riders-share.c...
Connect with us:
/ fortnine
/ fortnine
/ fortninecanada
Directed and Edited by Luke McAdam

Опубликовано:

 

5 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,7 тыс.   
@techno_tuna
@techno_tuna 3 года назад
This is why you don't get invited to press events keep it up
@thepioneer6178
@thepioneer6178 3 года назад
That sounds like a threat, you work for Snell?
@rash500m
@rash500m 3 года назад
@@thepioneer6178 he said keep it up, so definetely not a treath ;)
@FadilKarim
@FadilKarim 3 года назад
That's when you know he's doing something right!
@motorcityoctane6713
@motorcityoctane6713 3 года назад
That's why they don't give Ryan lots of bikes to review as well. He doesn't BS the viewers with fake or paid reviews.
@Racer57
@Racer57 3 года назад
@@motorcityoctane6713 The hero we all needed.
@Choo-choo-chookcha
@Choo-choo-chookcha 3 года назад
I’ll say it first: Ryan F9 didn’t kill himself!
@billmcmeekin7909
@billmcmeekin7909 3 года назад
Don't think he's getting a Snell Xmas gift this year, lol
@mtdew992
@mtdew992 3 года назад
@@billmcmeekin7909 judging by the info he just provided, who would want one anyhow 😂
@creamydonk
@creamydonk 3 года назад
We're going to find him with two self-inflicted blunt force impacts to the same spot on the back of his head
@drp4783
@drp4783 3 года назад
@@creamydonk 😂
@nutriacubica
@nutriacubica 3 года назад
@@creamydonk They will not throw him off the moving vehicle after done tho because they be damned to partake in variable force impacts.
@miroslavmilan
@miroslavmilan 3 года назад
This isn’t even a RU-vid video anymore. It’s an art. It’s a masterpiece.
@stoneblue1795
@stoneblue1795 3 года назад
More like what should be accredited course study on the topic, but I'm feeling your vibe.
@metalheads-golf
@metalheads-golf 3 года назад
🤘🏻😎🤘🏻
@exothermal.sprocket
@exothermal.sprocket 3 года назад
But what did you learn?
@uniearesende
@uniearesende 3 года назад
Yes. It is a super production.
@theMightywooosh
@theMightywooosh 3 года назад
was going to add a like, but let's just leave it at 420
@kaptein1247
@kaptein1247 3 года назад
''If the name can mean 2 different things, does it mean anything?'' Thats a quote to remember
@Vcen7
@Vcen7 3 года назад
And the answer is always: "Yes. It means whatever is the worst version for you, will be the one you get. Always."
@workingguy6666
@workingguy6666 3 года назад
like the Ford Mustang, for example? Jesus, Ford fucked that up.
@-iIIiiiiiIiiiiIIIiiIi-
@-iIIiiiiiIiiiiIIIiiIi- 2 года назад
Yeah! Fuck the word "wound"! Lee: "Stop getting me wound up Brenda!" Brenda: "Wound up? I haven't stabbed you yet! How did you know I had a knife?"
@itsjustsid3502
@itsjustsid3502 2 года назад
Funny thing, reminds me of the word woman now....
@thehouseofcrumblingidols2694
What is a woman?
@jimhufford7328
@jimhufford7328 3 года назад
Read an article several years ago where an unnamed helmet seller said, "'First we make it Snell, then we make it safe."
@highball7347
@highball7347 4 месяца назад
Yeah that’s found nowhere on the internet. Need more detail.
@justcommenting4981
@justcommenting4981 3 месяца назад
​@@highball7347 not everything is on the internet. It's a random quote from an unnamed article.
@tomekhohn
@tomekhohn 3 года назад
Oh? Fortnine posted another video? It's the equivalence of a mini Christmas every time, quality content
@skillissue267
@skillissue267 3 года назад
True af
@JB4KE
@JB4KE 3 года назад
ESPECIALLY when you catch it on your lunch break 🤤😉
@cccpkingu
@cccpkingu 3 года назад
Yule. "Christmas" only emulates the European tradition, and nobody follows their additions.
@mooncake4511
@mooncake4511 3 года назад
True
@AJL15N
@AJL15N 3 года назад
Prancing moose? I spy a fellow Volvo driver 😂
@thomas316
@thomas316 3 года назад
It sounds like riders would be better off going for an ECE compliant helmet and ignoring Snell. 🤔
@DaemonViews
@DaemonViews 3 года назад
It always has been
@tisFrancesfault
@tisFrancesfault 3 года назад
They would be right to do so.
@noobasdfjkl
@noobasdfjkl 3 года назад
Not really. Most tracks in the US require helmets to have SNELL certification to be allowed to ride there. That makes this a very sticky situation.
@randombuilds8336
@randombuilds8336 3 года назад
ECE is actually safer than snell, has been for a while. DOT is kinda bare minimum.
@philipparana9225
@philipparana9225 3 года назад
I skip ece and go for fim. If it's good enough for MotoGP good for me
@simplemeow6887
@simplemeow6887 3 года назад
The Moviemaker is back to save our Brains.
@frednoble1833
@frednoble1833 3 года назад
O fuckin 💘.love this man. He is a fuckin jenious. And explains. Very specifically. Why. HE VERY FUCKIN KOOL. LOVE LOVE LOVE HIM NIGHTFENCER GATEKEEPER. FREDDY FROM.NOBLE FENCE. BRAINTREE MASSACHUSETTS. I HAVE SEBERAL SICK MACHINES ONE ID THE 199I KAWASAKI ZRC 1100 EITH NITROUS OXIDE AND MANY ENGINE UPGRADES. VALVES. PORTED POLISHED. BALANC3D AND BLUEPRINTED MOTOR CRANK. LOTS OF TITANIUM. L8fters roller rocker cams. Rc engineering. Keblar CLUTCH ETC. .HOLY FUCK .
@SuperDinomagic
@SuperDinomagic 3 года назад
Literally
@cesartapia610
@cesartapia610 3 года назад
Ralphthemoviemaker
@rishi-m
@rishi-m 3 года назад
@@frednoble1833 seems like a nice setup, cheers
@jimmorrison306
@jimmorrison306 3 года назад
Sounds like Snell is in the business of staying in business.
@LTVoyager
@LTVoyager 3 года назад
Ah, yeah, like every other business, organization and government.
@MK-hb3xc
@MK-hb3xc 3 года назад
Snell served a good purpose when they started, and still do with their automotive standards and possible some of their other standards. The fact is the ECE standard has just caught up and surpassed them in being relevant. Snell really should simply abandon the motorcycle helmet market, but that might cut a big chunk of revenue from their pockets.
@kurtjustiniani1354
@kurtjustiniani1354 3 года назад
That's what happens when you got hard headed people running an organization/company. They don't typically adjust to the times and trends and often than not, get left behind. In short complacency. (See Kodak, Nokia and other companies that were not relevant today)
@mike.thomas
@mike.thomas 3 года назад
@@kurtjustiniani1354 “Hard headed”. I see what you did there :-).
@quillmaurer6563
@quillmaurer6563 3 года назад
Would make sense for them to keep their standards as they are and state that it's intended for race car driving, not motorcycling. That would be of benefit to both motorcyclists and race car drivers. Problem with that, the reason they don't take that approach, is that far fewer helmets are sold for race car driving than for motorcycling. They'd rather have a meaningless standard on a lot of helmets than a relevant one on a few. Profit above mission, apparently.
@flarue3678
@flarue3678 Год назад
Your mention of the journalist that got fired prompted me into reading the whole story. Corporate values, economic interests, honest journalism, advertising dollars and personal vendettas aside, a really sad story for all of those involved.
@FortNine
@FortNine Год назад
"Sad" is the perfect way to describe it. No winners in the long run. ~RF9
@timtam929
@timtam929 3 года назад
FIM and ECE are taking in new data and adapting to the new conclusions on what is actually safe. Snell is sitting in its corner throwing a tantrum.
@Al.j.Vasquez
@Al.j.Vasquez 3 года назад
A very M'urican way to do it.
@ChrisLoew
@ChrisLoew 3 года назад
Bingo
@adamvanderploeg8270
@adamvanderploeg8270 3 года назад
this reminded me of a quote from Tim minchin's poem, Storm: "Science adjusts its views based on whats observed, faith is the denial of observation so that belief can be preserved"
@fartingfury
@fartingfury 3 года назад
@@helpfulcommenter In that case, go look at the animated video of the poem on RU-vid. It's full of lines like that one.
@kevinmoore4887
@kevinmoore4887 3 года назад
Evolve or die. SNELL was the go to standard when I bought my first helmet in 1974. I would expect data based science to push new standards. Looks like ECE is the alternative safety standard when helmet shopping.
@georgempouk
@georgempouk 3 года назад
i just love that he puts his sources everytime
@rhaynhillyard9772
@rhaynhillyard9772 3 года назад
As should be done, hate people that claim shit and can't back it up
@franklinlucaslima
@franklinlucaslima 3 года назад
Aka science
@Ughandi
@Ughandi 3 года назад
So does his science teacher.
@dankorolyk5917
@dankorolyk5917 3 года назад
Another brilliant episode telling like it is!
@Jnolet88
@Jnolet88 3 года назад
Crazy to see real investigative journalism
@ircsmith
@ircsmith 3 года назад
My last Snell helmet (Snell M2010) took two huge hits, with my head in it. The helmet looks great. You can see a little cracking on the right side of the chin bar but other than the face shield being scratched you'd never know it was in an accident. Never mind the two days I spent in the hospital for a concussion. I dont want my helmets to survive and accident. I want my brain to be protected. I now only race with ECE lids. bonus is the are lighter as well.
@LeoinFrance
@LeoinFrance 3 года назад
Wow man, that's some hard fact you just shared here. I'm happy that you keep racing champ!
@tobiaspieringer1653
@tobiaspieringer1653 3 года назад
Its the same ith crashing old cars with no crumplezones. The car looks fine, but everything inside it is mush.
@davidricci9894
@davidricci9894 3 года назад
This info is giving me anxiety about my own Snell helmet
@Bingomandingo
@Bingomandingo 3 года назад
Have you looked into 6d helmets? They were the first ones to tell me what a crock of shit Snell was years ago but their acessebility to a market suffered because they're a US brand and far too many people wouldn't look their way because of how they rejected snell (due to how it causes concussions) and stuck with ECE. They have a major focus on preventing concussions and after that crash you probably can't be affording any more dude
@tortron
@tortron 3 года назад
@@tobiaspieringer1653 I have a car with no seatbelts, My grandmother crashed an identical one years ago and was simply thrown through the windscreen to safety. It has a split windscreen so you only have to replace half of it too
@connergunnoe5576
@connergunnoe5576 3 года назад
I’m glad I watched this video and you are exactly correct Ryan! I just finished the riding academy at our local Harley Davidson and in the class they gave us a little Snell flyer that basically showed a graphic putting Snell’s standard way up and above what the ECE standard is. So Snell is still trying to trash on the European standards to keep those helmets out of our market here in the US and they’re doing it by targeting the least informed crowd of riders out there. Newbies like myself! I will be looking for an ece helmet for sure. Thanks for the great content!
@anthonysimoes7307
@anthonysimoes7307 2 года назад
But it was a class full of Harley riders so 95% I'm guessing we open face helmets anyways which are knowhere near as safe as almost every full face no matter what sticker is on it.
@emiloguechoons9030
@emiloguechoons9030 Год назад
American Capitalism at its finest, who cares if your brain gets turned into road grease, as long as we make our money! Absolutely revolting, non-profit my a*s
@NotJustAnotherAverageJoe
@NotJustAnotherAverageJoe 9 месяцев назад
@@anthonysimoes7307 helmets?
@tpilot_error404
@tpilot_error404 3 года назад
Fortnine : when endcredits are interesting to watch too.
@myz06rocks
@myz06rocks 3 года назад
For a current staffing level at Snell's offices, please refer to the dislike counter on this video.
@drew657
@drew657 3 года назад
If they spent half as much time worrying about safety instead of sales as they spent on watching and downvoting the video, the sticker might mean something.
@cyborgrat
@cyborgrat 3 года назад
and those who paid the full price tag for a bucket.
@PricedDoughnut
@PricedDoughnut 3 года назад
Good to see someone in the motorcycle journalism community talking about this. I never see much about it from other sources. And this is one of several videos Ryan has done to shed light on little known safety issues within motorcycling.
@SwainixFPV
@SwainixFPV 3 года назад
And he states all his sources, like I'd pay RF9 money to keep making videos if he ever gets dropped from fortnine (would be crazy because for me he's the guy I follow and not the website but idk how it's run) or wants to take a different direction
@GabrielEtsHokin
@GabrielEtsHokin 3 года назад
Um...I think Dexter Ford was "someone in the motorcycle journalism community."
@mrmark8603
@mrmark8603 3 года назад
The magazines get too much advertising cash to question this.
@peterjones2594
@peterjones2594 3 года назад
The research and quality of this film is incredible as ever.
@MK-hb3xc
@MK-hb3xc 3 года назад
It missed a few things, like the DOT duration of g force and a puncture test, neither of which are considered in the ECE standard. Still the ECE is better, not just because it is newer, it has been around since at least 2005 from what I've understood.
@MrSoull
@MrSoull 3 года назад
@@MK-hb3xc unreal… 🤦🏼‍♂️
@Razorshot-gk3dq
@Razorshot-gk3dq 2 года назад
This video was one of the biggest reasons i went for an ECE certified helmet for my first helmet when i started riding. Thanks Ryan
@pilkjaer
@pilkjaer 3 года назад
Damn, this production quality is off the charts. Great content!
@BackwardsMarathonPSU
@BackwardsMarathonPSU 3 года назад
The execs at Snell are NOT going to be having a good Monday once this video makes its way across their desk….probably any minute now. I am imagining several emergency PR meetings and a “task force” being created, lol.
@GrimYak
@GrimYak 3 года назад
Im sure right now there is an email with the subject URGENT
@anonym3017
@anonym3017 3 года назад
@@helpfulcommenter every foundation and company has someone in charge.
@MonstaFreak13
@MonstaFreak13 3 года назад
This information has been out for a while. Ryan has even made videos about different ratings.
@AshrakAhmed
@AshrakAhmed 3 года назад
@@helpfulcommenter that's what they would like to make you think about them. Getting a non profit tag is a good way to keep your income from taxing. They charge for their certification so they make money and they are fighting to keep their rating standard as the main one not ECE/FIM even if it saves lives. SO tax evasion, care less about saving lives and more about licensing fees, making a half ass standard so their certified makers can sell in another safer standards territory! Non profit my ass!
@atlas8rides
@atlas8rides 3 года назад
Ehh, those execs will probably discuss it and come up with 2 FortNine conclusions that justifies not making any smart changes
@Propulus
@Propulus 3 года назад
Every single video on this channel is absolutely fantastic, especially in the last 4-3 years, doesn't matter what topic it is, whether safety, reviews, tips,.. just keep on making them, best part of yt imo.
@JMsurYT
@JMsurYT 3 года назад
It's crazy, isn't it. Most channels would dream of hitting this quality level once, but they are doing it on a daily basis.
@blankv8057
@blankv8057 3 года назад
Dude kills it! Literally checks all boxes I’ve never even driven a motorcycle haha
@MaxwellAerialPhotography
@MaxwellAerialPhotography 3 года назад
Lord have mercy on the enemies of safe helmets, because Ryan sure won’t.
@thurney4343
@thurney4343 3 года назад
I love the 50"s film noire feel to this video. Nicely done Ryan! Hard to accept that Snell and DOT can't change and adapt to better and more realistic standards that save their customers. I guess they really don't care about improving, but are hard headed and care more about making money.
@RockandrollNegro
@RockandrollNegro 2 года назад
"Hardheaded..." I see what you did there.
@SeraphimCramer
@SeraphimCramer 2 года назад
Unfortunately, what else do you expect from America?
@darthnatas953
@darthnatas953 Год назад
@@SeraphimCramer Maybe to dominate the world like we have been doing for the last 78 years.
@SeraphimCramer
@SeraphimCramer Год назад
@@darthnatas953 Lol & there's the exact brand of American hard headedness & refusal to change I was talking about. We haven't dominated shit in the world in decades
@darthnatas953
@darthnatas953 Год назад
@@SeraphimCramer The US economy is the largest in the world. Our military is the largest in the world. We have the most personal freedom in the world (in most states). US citizens have the largest per capita assets in the world. Our government spends the most money on the stupidest, most wasteful shit in the world. All this with very detrimental demographics compared with countries like Denmark, Sweden, etc. And in spite of half of US citizens either not working at all, or working for the government (which is actually worse for production, because government workers not only have to be provided for by people who actually produce worthwhile products and services, but many also actively stand in the way of production.) The half of us that are working are so friggin productive that we can protect every country’s borders in the world except our own, with a military 10 times bigger than it needs to be, carry 25% of the people on our backs, all while swimming upstream against the other 25%. We drove Russia in to bankruptcy, managed to babysit Europe for the last 75 years, fought several useless wars with no point, and still are able to hand out free stuff to nearly every country in the world. All while doing equally worthless stuff like flying to the moon. China is next to get their butt kicked if we can get our fellow citizens to focus on what the actual problem is, instead of dreaming up fake problems to spend fake money on like the Earth possibly getting warmer or colder, or that medical care, education, or some other service that someone has to pay for is somehow a “right.”
@perlguiman
@perlguiman Год назад
Your entertaining writing saves lives. I'm grateful your team exists to educate and inform new riders.
@Not_Loading
@Not_Loading Год назад
Seriously, if I hadn't stumbled across his channel I would still be riding with a cheap dot helmet. It was still within the return window so I sent it back and ordered a proper ece certified helmet
@arijitRC7
@arijitRC7 3 года назад
I can see 10 snell employees marked their attendance..
@mickleblade
@mickleblade 3 года назад
Prob 1 guy with alt accounts
@amaymishra814
@amaymishra814 3 года назад
Make that 27
@CrawlTalkRun
@CrawlTalkRun 3 года назад
make that 29 plus the one alt.
@oscartobaroatmeal6734
@oscartobaroatmeal6734 3 года назад
71
@simonsjodin9268
@simonsjodin9268 3 года назад
*hits helmet once* No one: *hits helmet twice* Snell: Ah yes, safety
@chrisb.487
@chrisb.487 3 года назад
I keep asking myself "Why are these videos so short?" only to realize "Oh, it's actually 8 min long."
@geoffwatches
@geoffwatches 3 года назад
Because he doesn't stuff it with filler to make it past the 10 minute youtube preference algorithm. Though in this case he definintlry should - this is a PSA.
@chrisb.487
@chrisb.487 3 года назад
Aside from that, his videos are so damn good. I get so engrossed, I hardly notice time passing by
@debbiemilka2251
@debbiemilka2251 3 года назад
It is not so much the brevity, but the frequency of same. hate waiting a whole month between installments. The delivery has always been quite enjoyable and the touch of incredulity adds a strong factor of believable confidence. The entries from this year though by Ryan and even stronger and more powerful in presentation of vital topics. Very top sort and the industry should be paying close attention to this critical research. Well done Ryan . You are making our lives safer bit by bit. Probably not in the cards, but I for one would like bi-weekly or perhaps something every three weeks.
@garyadams187
@garyadams187 2 года назад
As always, very informative and entertaining content. Years ago I was involved in a low speed impact which caused a brain bleed. Head scan wasn't done since I had a 2010 SNELL rated helmet from a leading (high-end) brand. Since my recovery, I now recommend ECE over all others, because it is tested BEFORE getting a certification (sticker), and the fact that the testing if focused on low speed impacts as well as high. For the track, I now choose the FIM certified helmets. A few of us have been asked to tour the SNELL testing facility in the coming months; I suspect a lively discussion when the visit occurs. Your work is appreciated.
@scottcates
@scottcates 2 года назад
This video is very informative. I have been a Snell advocate for a long time without realizing the deficicts of the certification. Yet when I had my worst accident -- a 105 MPH getoff that put me tumbling through the Nevada desert, my Snell-certified Scorpion EXO700 helmet, was goughed, scaped, and scuffed on every square inch with a ripped-off shield, to boot. I ended up with a minor concussion, which I atttributed to being lucky enough not to strike anything solid while skimming the desert in low earth orbit. But after watching this report on the Snell certification, the helmet might have also contributed to my injuries by being just too damn hard.
@Ehal256
@Ehal256 Год назад
Over 100 in the desert, and I'd say you'd be lucky to not be seriously injured even with the best gear.
@GhostKing6790
@GhostKing6790 3 месяца назад
no that helmet probably saved your life
@scottcates
@scottcates 3 месяца назад
@@GhostKing6790 You're probably right.
@jawadulkarim9498
@jawadulkarim9498 3 года назад
So basically: SNELL ❌ ECE ✅
@andy_byrd
@andy_byrd 3 года назад
FIM is actually the checkmark here. But ECE is being pulled by them so it'll do
@mateojimenez5905
@mateojimenez5905 3 года назад
and FIM is best
@tisFrancesfault
@tisFrancesfault 3 года назад
@@andy_byrd FIM is for professional racers and offers the best protection at speed. However Its expensive. ECE is in General fine for most road users, and is cheaper to buy. But as far as min standards go; ECE is far more practical and superior than the Snell Standard,
@ciprianb4794
@ciprianb4794 3 года назад
@@mateojimenez5905 But you only get fim on at least 1000$ helmets
@cube1cze
@cube1cze 3 года назад
@@ciprianb4794 Take a look at Scorpion EXO R-1 thats 500$ lid and passed FIM standards.
@oaklecopel
@oaklecopel 3 года назад
Ryan, I’d love to see one of your good old fashioned reviews on the Pan America. I’ve heard some good things about the bike, but I’m interested to see what you think of it.
@randombuilds8336
@randombuilds8336 3 года назад
I've heard lots of great from magazines, but not much from actual owners yet. Still being a new engine design I'd wait a couple years before buying one. But I do love the comfort and practicality of ADV bikes.
@WPGKLR
@WPGKLR 3 года назад
@@randombuilds8336 The only "Owner" review I saw was some Harley bro who talked up how much dirt biking he used to do then proceeded to drive the Pan America like a geriatric down a relatively smooth road. I wont be taking his opinion on the bike, that's for sure.
@FortNine
@FortNine 3 года назад
Been trying to get a hold of one! It's at the top of our to-do list. ~RF9
@romgl4513
@romgl4513 3 года назад
@@WPGKLR Seems that bro has a realistic idea of 150hp elephant bike off-road capabilities. You want extreme? Harley did it in the commercial. Every fall on the Pan-am will cost like a slightly used Honda motocross bike.
@Vince_vanca
@Vince_vanca 3 года назад
@@FortNine you should ask revzilla :p
@lakshya8038
@lakshya8038 3 года назад
Damn people have the audacity to dislike this, its free quality content, What else do you want??
@miketran4289
@miketran4289 3 года назад
They work for Snell.
@christianstorms3950
@christianstorms3950 3 года назад
People very often don't seek information, but confirmation. Can't do anything against those who don't find it and are unhappy about that fact...
@IstasPumaNevada
@IstasPumaNevada 3 года назад
It's the internet, and it's youtube. It would be more surprising if there _weren't_ any dislikes. It would also be more surprising if there wasn't a comment amounting to 'how could there be dislikes'. As far as youtube videos go, this is a VERY low dislike ratio. Which is not surprising, because it's an F9 video.
@kidlikerizzle
@kidlikerizzle 3 года назад
Free pancakes
@justus4883
@justus4883 3 года назад
@@IstasPumaNevada yeah, even on rare live concert footage of an old musician with a view count just over 100, there will still be dislikes.. it's just how youtube works for some reason
@carlanderson6574
@carlanderson6574 3 года назад
Hey Ryan! Could we get a video honestly reviewing internet gear companies like Ruroc, skully, engine hawk, etc.????
@lofisgames7821
@lofisgames7821 3 года назад
I'd be really interested in his opinion on Ruroc.
@mowen8487
@mowen8487 3 года назад
Oh pleaseeee
@Jobin909
@Jobin909 3 года назад
We need this!!!
@8eewee
@8eewee 2 года назад
This. Ruroc seems nice at first glance ( and Enginehawk by extension) but there's something that feels off about the whole deal.
@BisZwo
@BisZwo 3 года назад
7:37 that conclusion scene ! 😍😍😍 Awesome job F9, as always!
@BTDTChino
@BTDTChino 3 года назад
I'll stick with my ECE rated helmets. They do more accurate testing for crashes motorcyclists actually get in to.
@STho205
@STho205 3 года назад
Almost every major international brand has them both, and almost all of them get a 4 or 5star SHARP aftermarket lab rating. You are unlikely to get a helmet that fails SHARP, even cheap China crap like HJC , Fuel or Scorpion.... Ride smart, don't duche ride and you most likely will never find out which is better.
@seb9940
@seb9940 3 года назад
@@STho205 You dont have to be a "duche rider" to get that kind of experience. Unfortunately someone i knew personally experienced it and that didnt end well...
@STho205
@STho205 3 года назад
@@seb9940 were they wearing a helmet?
@arsyadgafli8749
@arsyadgafli8749 3 года назад
@@STho205 HJC is definitely not cheap china crap
@STho205
@STho205 3 года назад
@@arsyadgafli8749 there is almost always a personal need to reinforce ones value by the product choices made in a branded consumer all basically the same market. You can't be a man cause you don't smoke the brand I do used to be the old joke fifty years ago. I have an HJC and it wore well. It was OK. It was a plastic outer shell, some igloo cooler extruded styrofoam, some laminate gray foam rubber with glue molded fabric. All the China buckets are that. They work for the purpose, but nothing to really cheer about. When it got over six years, i took it apart to see hie it was built. The unsupported shell would squish in half under pressure. I hit it with a sander snf it holed in under a second. The styrofoam was.. styrofoam... But the padding waa taped onto it with gaffers tape. No sewing. The tape was dry and powdery. It held together for six years, but probably any China "counterfeit" bucket would also. Since all China factories are controlled ultimately by ONE PARTY CORPORATION... is there really a difference. Last years revolutionary HJC is likely this years Alibaba/Amazon $80 special. I'm sure you're fine. I'm sure you're safe. They would hold together enough for a typical accident... However the five year rule is being pushed because cheap construction doesn't last long. Like Chinese Clark Shoes that are just trading on an old Western brand name.
@thedudewiththehair7535
@thedudewiththehair7535 3 года назад
A moment of silence to the one person that didn't like this quality content.
@nathanbossier2446
@nathanbossier2446 3 года назад
probebly someone who works at snell xd
@chrisb.487
@chrisb.487 3 года назад
There's two now so I'm guessing it's the president and vice president of Snell
@rottentom009
@rottentom009 3 года назад
1000% guaranteed it's the owner of a Snell approved helmet... that he just bought on fortnine 😂😂
@AndreiNeacsu
@AndreiNeacsu 3 года назад
@@nathanbossier2446 Most likely a bloke who suffered a crash wearing a Snell certified helmet. This raises the moral and philosophical question: "is someone who's brain-dead, but dislikes videos online, considered alive or deceased?"
@konanLerehcob
@konanLerehcob 3 года назад
That's me. F9 is only telling half of the story and this was very dishonest of him to do so. See, contrary to what he imply there are serious people working for motorbikers safety and doing their job with great care at Snell. And as you guessed, I am one of these people. I work as a HOST (Helmet Operator Special Tester) for Snell and we try our helmets in EVERY condition. The standard of quality is only making sure we reach the specific hardness or softness desired for either market. Nonetheless, I test those helmets myself in real conditions and I have crashed head first over a thousand times in testing already and see how I am not mentally impaired at all ? Snell quality for sure.
@emmettturner9452
@emmettturner9452 3 года назад
I started riding in 2008 and the wisdom then was “Snell, Snell, Snell, Snell!” Little did I know it would get so much more complicated only the next year.
@cgmoog
@cgmoog 3 года назад
When I bought a new helmet in ~2008 I went for the British Standard. Now I go for with ECE. Snell has not been relevant for years. Motorcyclist published an article ripping Snell in 2005 (same journalist who was fired from Motorcyclist for writing about Snell in the NYT).
@rapid13
@rapid13 3 года назад
@@cgmoog The article you mention is titled “Blowing the Lid Off” by Dexter Ford. It’s brilliant.
@kevinmoore4887
@kevinmoore4887 3 года назад
I started riding in 1972. Pretty much get a Bell helmet with a Snell sticker or risk your head to an unknown. Almost 50 years later, I would expect changes. For road bikes, I want a shell that smashes and absorbs energy when my head hits the flat area called pavement. Off-road, keeping pointy rocks out of my skull and impact absorption are 2 considerations.
@jstn9914
@jstn9914 3 года назад
You guys really nailed the noire film aesthetic with this one! The bungie cords linking all the evidence together made me snort.
@mayanksingh0044
@mayanksingh0044 3 года назад
I'm in India there is no ECE no Snell here yet I clicked, liked and watched ur video. Quality content as always
@JaiSaldi
@JaiSaldi 3 года назад
only ISI standard as per new rules, rest all certified helmets illegal 🤡
@mayanksingh0044
@mayanksingh0044 3 года назад
@@JaiSaldi yessss
@nekil_s
@nekil_s 3 года назад
actually there are many helmets company provide ECE 22.05 with DOT and ISI in India. to name a few royal Enfield, TVS, MT etc..
@mithunnaidu0816
@mithunnaidu0816 3 года назад
Snell : we are best certification Ryan : I'm about end this man's whole career 😂
@jokumukamikalie
@jokumukamikalie 3 года назад
"If the name can mean two different things, does it mean anything?" This honestly sent chills down my spine. Snell is completely neglecting the very purpose of a helmet to keep their name on the European market.
@vinvenus4581
@vinvenus4581 3 года назад
Honestly, living in Europe, I haven't even heard of SNELL before watching this channel. My German Schuberth helmet is as an EU certificat.
@jokumukamikalie
@jokumukamikalie 3 года назад
@@vinvenus4581 I have a Schuberth too, so it's not my personal issue, but having unsafe helmets on the market is a real issue in general.
@ntdscherer
@ntdscherer 3 года назад
Business disregards safety in favor of greater profit. More news at 11.
@jokumukamikalie
@jokumukamikalie 3 года назад
@@ntdscherer Wouldn't be odd if it wasn't a company testing _mandatory_ safety equipment.
@stevee8318
@stevee8318 3 года назад
The Snell foundation is a non-profit
@reaper8887
@reaper8887 3 года назад
Ryan should check out India's revised ISI standards. That's even more messed up than this Snell situation.
@stoneblue1795
@stoneblue1795 3 года назад
Does it come with a BBQ GRILL bolted to one side like their motorcycles?
@reaper8887
@reaper8887 3 года назад
@@stoneblue1795luckily no !! Well, atleast for now anyway. And that BBQ grill thingie is mandatory for the registration of any motorcycle.
@Lex4122
@Lex4122 3 года назад
And who is surprised that in India safety standards are borked?
@RiloElton
@RiloElton 3 года назад
@@reaper8887 yeah I'm curious about that bbq grill thingy in India. What purpose does it serve? Can you get rid of it after you've registered it?
@reaper8887
@reaper8887 3 года назад
@@RiloEltonThat contraption is called a "saree guard", it's designed to keep pillion riders "saree" or any other bulky clothing from getting caught in the sprockets or wheels and lead onto any accidents. Even though that thing is mandatory for the road bikes here, most will get rid of it after the registration process is over.
@68404
@68404 3 года назад
Love the production values and Ryan F9 himself. This channel is so classy
@torquer9669
@torquer9669 Год назад
Good video/info, and holy crap, what an awesome production. Bravo!
@PerfectlyUselessComment
@PerfectlyUselessComment 3 года назад
I would never seek out this video topic but once again, your amazing production quality keeps me coming back for more no matter what you choose to do.
@jiafengli7648
@jiafengli7648 3 года назад
When the DOT video out years ago, I was like "well, my helmet is not DOT only." Me now: "crap..."
@Hazardxv
@Hazardxv 3 года назад
Yeah now I'm out here looking at new helmets. Shit.
@quillmaurer6563
@quillmaurer6563 3 года назад
I got my helmet after watching the DOT video, went ECE as the sense I had at the time was Snell was for racing while ECE was more suitable for street riding. Now I hope he doesn't come out with one saying ECE is crap too... Even if he does, I'm guessing it's best of the three, and we all know crashing a motorcycle with any helmet isn't going to be fun.
@ThatSoddingGamer
@ThatSoddingGamer 3 года назад
@@quillmaurer6563 Well, ECE 22/06 (and some with 05 stickers) are basically the balance between budget and variety, versus top protection but limited options that FIM offers. However, in another 5 or so years (5 is probably optimistic, I admit) we might start seeing more budget friendly FIM helmets as manufacturers get a better handle on it and start larger production runs. Of course, then we'll have to contend with the grades of FIM, as there are multiple grades of the FIM standard. ECE will become the bare minimum for informed, sane riders, and the lowest rank of FIM will be be what most riders will actually look to get. Snell will probably start being phased out from motorcycles by then, I hope. They never really should have been used as a standard for motorcycle helmets, as the video illustrates. DOT? That'll probably exist for quite some time as the legal bare minimum. The helmet equivalent of slapping on a barely functional part to a device to ensure the whole technically qualifies as legal to use.
@alexsavastru8125
@alexsavastru8125 2 года назад
@@ThatSoddingGamer I found myself thinking "What a valuable footnote for the video this is" while reading this comment. Good stuff, bro. Thanks for the intel ;)
@ThatSoddingGamer
@ThatSoddingGamer 2 года назад
@@alexsavastru8125 No problem dood, at least someone found it useful ^_^
@markbaum9615
@markbaum9615 3 года назад
Ryan should be the modern twilight zone narrator...
@jstogdill
@jstogdill 3 года назад
In addition to being glad to see you drawing attention to this issue, I’m thoroughly impressed that a company that sells SNELL tagged helmets has the righteous fortitude to fund this video. Many thumbs up. Edit: p.s. It’s well past time for every helmet retailer to make it easy to search helmets by certification and for the certifications and their meaning to be readily visible in every product listing. This is probably the most important thing to know about a helmet but it is usually the least obvious part of the product listing.
@RiderXp
@RiderXp 3 года назад
This channel is one of the best in automotive space! Delivering useful information in the most creative and artistic way imaginable. I can only hope to get to close to this level some day!
@kiler2death
@kiler2death 3 года назад
Ryan just absolutely blasting us with well researched and sourced videos in amazing quality. Seriously my favorite youtuber.
@t.walker3101
@t.walker3101 3 года назад
i’ve been binge watching fortnine videos glad to see i’ve got another to add to the list
@Curtis.Carpenter
@Curtis.Carpenter 3 года назад
fortnine videos..always happy to see new uploads!!!
@pcphilanthropy
@pcphilanthropy 3 года назад
Best motorcycle content and production quality on YT… change my mind.
@jamesdaple9951
@jamesdaple9951 3 года назад
Incredible journalism!!! I hope you guys have loads of awards!!! for Excellence!!!
@Kobe29261
@Kobe29261 3 года назад
Thank you for pointing out the real crucial value of this video - the journalism, sure the editing is top-notch but what Fort-9 has done is really draw attention to the politics of motorcycle helmets. Sure hope we don't miss this, as we congratulate the videography. Again the adage proves true - do anything well enough and you end up in philosophy[at least in ontology]
@KienDo111
@KienDo111 3 года назад
Somebody please give this man more money to spread his videos all around the world. 200k views don’t do him justice.
@devme20
@devme20 3 года назад
Ok, as someone that stays in the other side of the world.. this is the first time hearing about snell XD
@gwot
@gwot 3 года назад
I had no idea snell isn't in the other side. A lot of tracks in my area (Canada) mandate SNELL rated helmets. DOT alone is not enough, ECE is yes or no depending on track.
@benclimo461
@benclimo461 3 года назад
Where you from? Here in EU shell is still very well known as well
@devme20
@devme20 3 года назад
@@benclimo461 SEA(south east asia)
@devme20
@devme20 3 года назад
@@gwot SEA(south east asia)
@BDA84
@BDA84 3 года назад
@@benclimo461 Never seen it in any west europe store but to be honest I only check the CE sticker or maybe I only take brands that don't care about it, don't know.
@seansamurai1981
@seansamurai1981 3 года назад
No point in arguing with FIM, they are literally the authority on helmet safety
@johnb8440
@johnb8440 3 года назад
I'd agree, but Snell used to be the authority. Always question everything. They are only the authority because the data points to their standard being better right now, but lobotomies used to be a standard because they were better than what came before. Question everything.
@mmaaddict78
@mmaaddict78 3 года назад
Until someone comes along with a better standard and FIM stubbornly sticks to their own formula. Seems like a common occurrence over the history of safety standards lol
@johnb8440
@johnb8440 3 года назад
@@mmaaddict78 legit, yeah. Standards don't change until someone calls out a different standard is bullshit. It becomes a money-making game eventually. Always starts out great.
@raycodv267
@raycodv267 3 года назад
@@johnb8440 except that the FIM standard isn’t there because they want to get their stickers onto helmets. Only a few helmets in the world actually are FIM certified. The FIM rating is there because the FIM wants and NEEDS to protect their most important assets… MotoGP riders. The FIM is the motorcycle equivalent of the FIA. They’re the organisers of premier-class motorsport. They don’t make their money from certifying equipment, they get their money from organising championships. Without the riders/drivers those championships are doomed, so they have to protect their riders to the best of their ability in order for them to protect their revenue.
@lemonbrothers3462
@lemonbrothers3462 3 года назад
@@johnb8440 except it wasn't really the authority, it seemed so because it was a requirement to enter a track but for long ECE has been considered better by a lot of people (until FIM showed up). Previous F9 videos showed just that, with SNELL being recomended if you wanted to go to a track, otherwise ECE.
@bytesandbikes
@bytesandbikes 3 года назад
I've never seen a Snell sticker outside the US. I think the battle is long lost.
@gwot
@gwot 3 года назад
I have! they're in Canada too
@MrDudeRose
@MrDudeRose 3 года назад
A big thank you to Ryan and the whole F9 crew, another great video, fll of information that I would have to dig through loads of paperwork to acquire. Also hats off to the lovely Film Noir styling. I really enjoyed this so thank you once again.
@svenkund234
@svenkund234 3 года назад
Once had a discussion about this with a motorcycle supplier who believed I was in big danger because I'm riding with a ECE helmet and not a snell helmet. Thanks for the great video.
@rik8508
@rik8508 3 года назад
Ah. Happy to know this. Good thing I live in Europe so I can completely ignore Snell and only look for ECE and FIM.
@STho205
@STho205 3 года назад
Everybody can ignore Snell. It is not a street legal standard anywhere but racetracks that impose it privately. This video is important to the helmet marketing industry, like Ryan, Revzilla, etc... But not on the street.
@lemonbrothers3462
@lemonbrothers3462 3 года назад
@@STho205 it's still better than DOT so could be the better option for US folks that can't source an ECE bucket easily enough, altough there's little reason for that to be true with shops like fortnine and revzilla around
@STho205
@STho205 3 года назад
@@lemonbrothers3462 you know, a Ryan F9 video five years ago called "5 Safest Helmets" half of them had neither a Snell or ECE sticker.. And he said it didn't matter as they were safe. He was falling back on SHARP. His highest recommended one was the high viz Scorpion 490 which at that time had no ECE but a Snell 2015 (which is years after this video's stated controversy) and the HJC which only had a DOT sticker because it couldn't pass Snell and had never paid to get ECE. Both were China Buckets with flexible cheaper polycarb shells. 4 years ago he did the video Best Snell helmets where he sang the praises of Snell. Followed up a few weeks later with the horrible dangers of DOT. When it finally comes down to it, these guys are entertainers and product salesmen. Ryan produces a nice polished video. He filled a week. Ride safe... Your helmet is as good as you need...and I hope you never need it.
@rameylewis7730
@rameylewis7730 3 года назад
@@STho205 I have to agree with you. As much as I enjoy some of Ryan's videos, he's starting to sound more and more like a used car salesman.
@ws8080
@ws8080 3 года назад
@@STho205 That's not what I saw in those older videos. He correctly pointed out same thing in different way - how Snell was about a firm shell, and competing standard is about a flexible one, i.e. the harder vs. softer adjectives used in this current video. As I recall, he said neither is perfect (nothing is), but Snell's hard shells are a liability if not padded and fit correctly, and the softer standards are great for absorbing but not for point impact, etc. Too much absorb without a shape doesn't match our hard heads. Anyway, this science is changing with more testing - notice the football helmet changes in just the last few years.
@ThePassionateBiker
@ThePassionateBiker 3 года назад
Ryan working so hard to investigate which standard for helmet is safer. Meanwhile in India - Helmet must comply with Indian ISI standard which is basically low end version of ECE , Otherwise no matter how safe your helmet is, it's illegal.
@rightwingsafetysquad9872
@rightwingsafetysquad9872 3 года назад
That’s how it is almost everywhere, you must psd the local standard. In America all helmets must pass DOT. Thankfully almost all helmets that pass ECE also pass DOT.
@mrrashu77
@mrrashu77 3 года назад
Also the ECE certified helmets which are undoubtedly superior, are considered ILLEGAL, as if it was contraband. ffs
@krabha9681
@krabha9681 3 года назад
Go for Royal Enfield helmets, they are ISI DOT certified and ECE approved. Affordable too.
@humannature4327
@humannature4327 3 года назад
Its funny that we indian start using helmet only recently...few years before people used to say to people who use to wear helmets *that are you going to space..if not then why are you wearing that urn on your head* ..🙄 PS: ECE helmetes are more relevant in today's India because now the bike are getting faster so the chance of you rolling on the road and hitting your head on the multiple side has increased But before the story was different
@mayorofnow
@mayorofnow 3 года назад
Do the police actually enforce it?
@ApodyktycznyCzlek
@ApodyktycznyCzlek 3 года назад
oh come on, Ryan, you're about to kill another safety standard?
@UpstateDS
@UpstateDS 3 года назад
Worthless safety standards should be killed off.
@kilianortmann9979
@kilianortmann9979 3 года назад
@@UpstateDS No, they go to a farm upstate.
@darkiee69
@darkiee69 3 года назад
You mean unsafety standard, right?
@ApodyktycznyCzlek
@ApodyktycznyCzlek 3 года назад
I mean, yeah, Ryan's totally right, but bruh, he's on the killing spree
@l0pher
@l0pher 3 года назад
"Safety" standard
@mxmlbll9590
@mxmlbll9590 3 года назад
Thank you F9 team for your service
@francescovultaggio2540
@francescovultaggio2540 3 года назад
God, this is one of the best channels since every frame a painting shut down
@SolamenteVees
@SolamenteVees 3 года назад
Best motorcycle-centric channel on YT. And I don’t even ride anymore…
@B1ueStryk3r
@B1ueStryk3r 3 года назад
Note to self : DO NOT buy Snell helmet.
@redsquarejay
@redsquarejay 3 года назад
I regret my purchase. Luckily I have to buy a new helmet next year anyway. ECE it is
@luckify3046
@luckify3046 3 года назад
I bought a snell helmet about two months ago... R.I.P.
@SooHighFashion
@SooHighFashion 3 года назад
@@luckify3046 yeah I got a bell race star rip hbu
@seniorrider9337
@seniorrider9337 3 года назад
A very good reason to take another safety course and practice safety at every chance. YOU are the best safety device available. Ride safe, ride long!
@SooHighFashion
@SooHighFashion 3 года назад
@@Bagration421oh I didn't know that, every website I've seen says the safety of the race star is very good. I think the pro star is even better
@sepg5084
@sepg5084 3 года назад
In asia, Shoei helmets are the thing to get. Imagine thinking that hard helmets are safer on the day and age of crumple zones and shock absorption devices like airbags.
@husseltoo
@husseltoo 3 года назад
Any brand that races on FIM events has to be certified, there are lots of other brands that will follow the new ECE R22-06 .
@reason2gether
@reason2gether 3 года назад
In the limited space between the outside of the helmet and your head, where do you think the hard surface should be? I still want the exterior to be as hard and as impenetrable as possible , while having the most cushioning possible inside. Is there a part of your head that you would consider to be a safe "crumple zone"? The best improvement I feel has been made through the years and can further be made is in the overall weight of the helmet. Keep the hard shell exterior and soft interior, while reducing inertial load/strain on the neck as much as possible. Other areas I feel should be improved if possible are: outward visibility, hearing ability and ventilation comfort.
@RoonMian
@RoonMian 3 года назад
The only downside is that you can mess up your helmet when it just slips out of your hand from a 2 feet height and you wouldn't even know by looking at it :(
@9inchpp
@9inchpp 3 года назад
I'm more of a GIVI guy myself
@mhordijk0871
@mhordijk0871 3 года назад
@@reason2gether The harder the shell, the more likely it is to shatter on impact. A hard shell transmits more energy to the inside. A softer shell absorbes energy by deforming. Like a crumple zone.
@CaptainCraigKWMRZ
@CaptainCraigKWMRZ 3 года назад
Do they have RU-vid Production Awards? This channel definitely deserves them all!
@stevelarson6992
@stevelarson6992 3 года назад
Don’t know how you do it but your channel just gets better and better! Keep it up !
@peterjensen6844
@peterjensen6844 3 года назад
Love the "bring the receipts" sources list at the end.
@hyr079
@hyr079 3 года назад
Long-time watcher, first time commenter. This is a really important story, thanks for bring it to light to well.
@IstasPumaNevada
@IstasPumaNevada 3 года назад
@Huo Shing I vouch for Jon Madden, so you can trust it's important.
@Bina69
@Bina69 3 года назад
three cheers for the editor, amazing job.
@motordemic
@motordemic 3 года назад
Anish, the man behind the edits 🤩
@nevilles.5066
@nevilles.5066 3 года назад
Honestly Ryan is the best in the business and no one comes close! So much effort, attention to detail, research and execution in all his videos. Big up to you mate👏👏👏
@thejohnnerparty
@thejohnnerparty 3 года назад
I'm only 34 seconds into this video and I'm ready to heap high praise. This is a vlog on the motor cycle industry, but already I see a production that is on par with with the best the move industry can must. .... Okay, back to the vlog .... This production deserves multiple academy awards: Story, information, ACTING, B&W, lighting. It is all so good. .... To sum it up - really good production. Really.
@thepcguy007
@thepcguy007 3 года назад
We now have all the clues. It was Ryan, in the garage, with the ECE standard...
@weifeng5958
@weifeng5958 3 года назад
I wish that someone would make a FIM Adventure / Dual Sport helmet I’d be all over it in a heartbeat
@MK-hb3xc
@MK-hb3xc 3 года назад
With the level the FIM is considering for velocity of impact be glad you don't have one. They are looking at rate of acceleration that is so high it is not a survivable situation and, in turn, will make the helmet transmit more shock because the helmet/liner need to be made harder/stiffer to meet that unsurvivable standard. Dual sport helmets are dealing with rates of acceleration at 1/2-1/3 that of the FIM and done right will have a more flexible giving shell and liner to suit, transmitting less shock to the brain. Go to 10:50 in this video to understand what they are doing ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-QmMa32byIJA.html And yes I realize the video is about 50% promotion of 6D, but the other 50% is dealing with the standards. Even includes what is good in the DOT standard and missing in others. See 2:55 in the video, understand what is missing from ECE and should be added.
@underbudgee9522
@underbudgee9522 3 года назад
I’m telling you, with this level of production quality motovlogs and camping trips would be top notch. Plus it would bring in a larger crowd. 👍
@Blexy91
@Blexy91 3 года назад
I'm simply impressed by how creative and enjoyable all of his videos are. It looks like he's having so much filming these. Love from France man, keep up the quality content !
@True96red
@True96red 2 года назад
FortNine is the only channel I have to full screen the videos because it's like a movie, love it
@dheeraj3945
@dheeraj3945 3 года назад
Only detective Ryan can make helmets exciting and interesting 😂
@tonybrett7974
@tonybrett7974 3 года назад
For really thorough testing have a look at the UK's Sharp helmet safety scheme.
@ONEly-uc4et
@ONEly-uc4et 3 года назад
That is a good point and was not brought up here - sharp.dft.gov.uk/sharp-testing/. Some of the impact speeds are lower than ECE/FIP 6.0m/s - 8.5m/. That said always cross compare with other testing. Arai has not always gotten top marks on some of their helmets at Sharp. This lead to the lowering of the visor hinge on newer models to improve side impact testing (at least that is my understanding).
@Gofr5
@Gofr5 3 года назад
Sharp was the reason I bought my HJC IS-17 as my first helmet. Don't always have to pay the big bucks to get the good stuff. shame that model is now discontinued.
@redbynight
@redbynight 3 года назад
Sharp never seems to get enough love, it seems.
@syntheticXstasy
@syntheticXstasy 3 года назад
So what's the takeaway here? That ECE is the sticker to look for now, not Snell?
@kilianortmann9979
@kilianortmann9979 3 года назад
If you buy a Snell helmet you don't know on first glance if you get the hard Snell D, or just a worse ECE. Whether Snell D or ECE is right, Snell R is certainly wrong.
@syntheticXstasy
@syntheticXstasy 3 года назад
@@kilianortmann9979 gotcha that makes a lot of sense. Thanks!
@tisFrancesfault
@tisFrancesfault 3 года назад
More or less. I mean Snell is great if you hit a curb or hit a bollard with your head; but the reality is you gonna be bouncing on the road. In such a case snell standards lack the durability. Great for massive single impact damage, but anyone whose had a tumble knows thats rarely the case. ECE standards are just better for realistic crashes.
@mateojimenez5905
@mateojimenez5905 3 года назад
yup FIM is still the safest but those helmets are expensive and rare, so ECE is the way to go
@Cromell
@Cromell 3 года назад
@MINISTER MOTOVLOGS HOL' UP
@peterlovett5841
@peterlovett5841 3 года назад
This really highlights the issue of what are you going to have your crash in? A race car or coming off a motorcycle (race or road).
@afineandpleasantmisery8500
@afineandpleasantmisery8500 3 года назад
I don't have a motorcycle but yet I have watched every on of your videos. some of the best content on RU-vid.
@rodneypearce6113
@rodneypearce6113 3 года назад
I have been watching for a while on your channel, you make some of the best presented and most thoroughly researched content for motorcycling out there. Really, really appreciate your channel and thanks to the whole crew.
@javi3_14
@javi3_14 3 года назад
man this is so important i had no idea how the testing was done… no more snell for me
@spencerlivvy1090
@spencerlivvy1090 2 года назад
The production quality of this video on top of being hugely informative makes it absolutely exemplary. Earned a sub from me!
@dewai
@dewai 3 года назад
Remember when the news used to report on stuff that mattered? Yeah me neither. Thank you, FortNine!
@ooorannn
@ooorannn 2 года назад
I usually don't comment on videos but this video is a masterpiece i keep finding myself going back to rewatch this video
@geoffblake2748
@geoffblake2748 3 года назад
Brilliant content as usual. Having looked at the FIM requirements and reasoning behind them, I strongly believe that the European ECE standards offer better protection for road and race riders.
@Sunesen
@Sunesen 3 года назад
Now I feel like wearing a trench coat and smoking a cigaret in a dimly lit office....And I don't even smoke.
@tjey379
@tjey379 3 года назад
Now that's an education, love the packaging , it really makes getting the point better than easier.
@MOTO809
@MOTO809 3 года назад
Thank you for this. I grew up with the notion that Snell was tip top, and never questioned why. I'll be passing this along to my piers.
@RockandrollNegro
@RockandrollNegro 2 года назад
While you guys are hanging out at the piers, pass this info along to your peers.
@chesy-headshoxx
@chesy-headshoxx 3 года назад
I watched quite a few Videos (20+ I'd say) of this Channel over the past few Days. Don't know why I just found it like a week ago.. But I am really astounded how well these Videos are made. The Scripts, the Stories, the Texts. On Point and straight forward. Really refreshing without any "Bullsh*t". Plus, I love when Ryan makes use of that Blackboard and hits us with his Knowledge in Physics. Big Fan of this Channel. Keep up the amazing work! (Greetings from Germany)
@klaseronen7535
@klaseronen7535 3 года назад
After having worn Snell certified helmets myself, I consider that the most important point is that whether the Snell standard would be considered obsolete or not, Pete Snell's tragic death was not in vain. As we say in Finland, having your head in one piece is the main thing, or in other words in Finnish, the "pääasia" (="head thing").
@MK-hb3xc
@MK-hb3xc 3 года назад
It is obsolete for motorcycles. The ECE and DOT are actually better for the street rider for sure. That was proven out back in 2005 by Dr. David Thom in the Motorcyclist commissioned testing leading to the Blowing The Lid Off Helmets article. Interesting enough, the ECE standard was ECE r 22.05 at that time too. So no real revision has been done with any but Snell. Snell is still behind though.
@Jacob-oe5zr
@Jacob-oe5zr 3 года назад
Well if Ryan disappears, I think we know who to go after 😬
@legallyfree2955
@legallyfree2955 3 года назад
Disappears? Or do you mean commits suicide by shooting himself in the back of the head with a suppressed 9mm?
@gwot
@gwot 3 года назад
@@legallyfree2955 yeah, got suicided, is what I call those.
@IWantYourNachos
@IWantYourNachos 3 года назад
FIM for the win, Snell is out and ECE is playing catch up
@Nick-hm9rh
@Nick-hm9rh 3 года назад
The video quality never dissapoints
@oledokka
@oledokka 3 года назад
I never comment on RU-vid, but this channel is something special. Quality all the way, from ideas to form and execution. Every time. Bravo!
Далее
What's Inside the Best Motorcycle Helmets of 2021?
9:57
Fake Motorcycle Gear and How to Spot It
11:43
Просмотров 1 млн
Motorcycle Smart Helmets (HUDs) are a Scam
7:59
Просмотров 1,4 млн
Motorcycle Riders: This Graph is Your Skill Level
9:51
Motorcycle Thief vs. Bike Locks - Which is Best?
8:49
The Worst Motorcycle of the 1980s - Honda Ascot Review
10:34
Why Democracy Is Mathematically Impossible
23:34
Просмотров 3,5 млн
NEVER install these programs on your PC... EVER!!!
19:26