Тёмный

The True and the False Self 

The School of Life
Подписаться 9 млн
Просмотров 1,5 млн
50% 1

A good life is one in which we can dare to show our True Self and do not mind too much occasionally having to wear the mask of a False Self. But for this to be possible, we need a certain sort of childhood - as the masterful British psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott helped to explain in his theory of the true and the false self, outlined here.
Enjoying our RU-vid videos? Get full access to all our audio content, videos, and thousands of thought-provoking articles, conversation cards and more with The School of Life Subscription: t.ly/WBr_n
Be more mindful, present and inspired. Get the best of The School of Life delivered straight to your inbox: t.ly/fRltk
The School of Life runs a global online psychotherapy service that assists clients from over 40 countries. To find out more and book a session today, please visit our website: t.ly/xP3EL
FURTHER READING
“One of the most surprising but powerful explanations for why we may, as adults, be in trouble mentally is that we were, in our earliest years, denied the opportunity to be fully ourselves, that is, we were not allowed to be wilful and difficult, we could not be as demanding, aggressive, intolerant, and unrestrictedly selfish as we needed to be. Because our caregivers were preoccupied or fragile, we had to be preternaturally attuned to their demands, sensing that we had to comply in order to be loved and tolerated; we had to be false before we had the chance to feel properly alive. And as a result, many years later, without quite understanding the process, we risk feeling unanchored, inwardly dead and somehow not entirely present…”
You can read more on this and other subjects here: bit.ly/2qEJiJZ
MORE SCHOOL OF LIFE
Watch more films on SELF in our playlist:
bit.ly/TSOLself
SOCIAL MEDIA
Feel free to follow us at the links below:
Facebook: / theschooloflifelondon
X: / theschooloflife
Instagram: / theschooloflifelondon
CREDITS
Produced in collaboration with:
Katherine Blanchin
vimeo.com/katebalchin #TheSchoolOfLife

Опубликовано:

 

15 май 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,5 тыс.   
@theschooloflifetv
@theschooloflifetv 6 лет назад
What do you think of the relationship between the true and the false self? Let us know in the comments or we have a discussion going on right now our app available free here: bit.ly/2vsEzRk
@shawnlocotucker
@shawnlocotucker 6 лет назад
I'm not really comfortable with this binary, with this dichotomy. I take this as a useful fiction, this idea of a true and false self, but I think it leads down a rabbit hole of "am I being true right now?" or "am I being false right now?" I'm not fond of the fundamental idea that we are fundamentally true as anti-social creatures.
@mekman4
@mekman4 6 лет назад
The School of Life Maybe there’s something to this, kids who are angry may become meek as adults as they become more aware of their thoughts and it’s effects on others. I personally don’t believe that having no filter is healthy, it probably masks anti social behavior, the kind we see in celebrities and pundits often. It’s a sign of being out of touch, which is what the average celebrity happens to be. Edit: Sorry about that, I meant to say filter, I was lost in thought. Good stuff.
@gowthamg2081
@gowthamg2081 6 лет назад
This is so true. Only when you are self sufficient can you truly be there for others.
@billhoward532
@billhoward532 6 лет назад
"It's never too late to have a happy childhood" - Therapy may prove helpful but there are many many ways to help recover your lost childhood and your lost self... (shared to fb & G+)
@Leto85
@Leto85 6 лет назад
But doesn't the so called false self become the new true self eventually? Education is to learn after all, not to hide behind doctrines and politeness just because it's told to us, but because we have learned the values and deeper meanings of what us is learned during education and the consequences of staying in the old true self. I get it that therapy is needed in order to overcome the problems that come with if we never have gotten the change to be our 'child true self', as I so call it, but to stay in the end with a false and a true self is something I have my doubts about.
@morne.bester
@morne.bester 6 лет назад
These last few videos all had the same message - we don’t act like we want to - it’s because of our childhood - we need to see a therapist
@literallygaston2489
@literallygaston2489 5 лет назад
Morné Bester Well, they aren’t wrong
@uusrano
@uusrano 4 года назад
Freud approves. I don't.
@Princess_Lilly13
@Princess_Lilly13 4 года назад
@@uusrano Freud was a weirdo :/ ...
@FilipeMarcon
@FilipeMarcon 4 года назад
Fundamental. Sine Qua Non.
@blueberry7899
@blueberry7899 4 года назад
No not really. Its saying that if our childhood was bad we might be messed up and need to see a therapist to feel better. If our child hoods are okay - the video is saying we would probably be well adapted.
@xuanius
@xuanius 5 лет назад
I remember always being on edge at home because whenever I was relaxed, one of my parents would unexpectedly scold me. I would be sitting in my room smiling and enjoying the peace and they would say, "look at you being all lazy and worthless." or launch into a lecture projecting abject failure in my future. The only ways I could avoid confrontation were to be studying, doing chores, or looking visibly upset. Those were the times when I felt safe. Sometimes I would secretly enjoy being depressed because they spoke kinder to me and I didn't have to be as on guard all the time. I even looked forward to being sick and catching heavy fevers because my parents were really nice to me when I was sick. After moving away from home and working, I've slowly started enjoying life without pressure. I read for hours on weekends and just enjoy being in a cozy room, because I can :) Sometimes I sit there and just soak in the environment. These moments always bring me peace, and make me very grateful for being alone, because it means I can finally enjoy living in the moment. The downside of this is that I have a nearly psychotic aversion to being around other people. I have learned that being around others = being on edge, and that I can only be happy if I am completely alone.
@cheechchong3021
@cheechchong3021 3 года назад
I can totally relate to your upbringing - how have you made progress being social ?
@nicolhelbichova984
@nicolhelbichova984 3 года назад
wow thank u for ur words, it made me realize that I have the same experience.
@peacemekka
@peacemekka 3 года назад
The first two paragraphs is also my case. Hence I always behave like I'm studying despite the fact that I've totally lost interest in most of my subjects. I don't even know if I'll make it properly out of college.
@ohmcb
@ohmcb 3 года назад
I can relate to it.. Distancing myself from other people in order to be peacefully alone, yet craving social interaction because we are human after all.. I think the best silver lining to this is that we have to practice respecting our needs and create healthy boundaries between others.. Hope you have a greater life rn ^^
@souldancersbyjennifer
@souldancersbyjennifer 2 года назад
@@peacemekka I hope you are working through it and makes it through college
@whileimonmars
@whileimonmars 6 лет назад
Yup. I was never allowed to express myself growing up. I just had to listen, be quiet, and not bother anyone. I suffered through many years of neglect and I rebelled in some ways once I got into my teenage years. Now I have a certain contempt toward authority figures, although I still tolerate them if I have to, but I’m also more vocal about my feelings and opinions. In the end, I’m still learning about my “true self” since the person I was most of my life was shaped by trauma (I’m still fairly young though. I’m in my early 20s). It takes time and a lot of self-reflection to heal but it will happen.
@lloydnguyen3438
@lloydnguyen3438 6 лет назад
I hope u all the best !
@shayb8203
@shayb8203 5 лет назад
Damn you are gorgeous woman!!
@fatimasiddiqui1585
@fatimasiddiqui1585 5 лет назад
I am in the same boat as you, and I am 19.
@user-en2ed1kp5g
@user-en2ed1kp5g 4 года назад
Same af I felt this so hard
@Luna-ft8yh
@Luna-ft8yh 4 года назад
Good luck on that, you can do it 😇🙏💙
@shankarnarayanan835
@shankarnarayanan835 6 лет назад
This is soo relatable. I have never felt my true self and always felt like a slave to other people's demands and agendas.
@roger_isaksson
@roger_isaksson 3 года назад
It’s never too late to rebel against society and the tribulations of an upbringing in a humorous way. Heckle their pretentious ideals and superficiality. The OK boomer generation is the village idiots of (post) industrial civilization. Don’t let the disease spread to the next generation. Be an awesome savage.
@miepmaster25
@miepmaster25 3 года назад
If feel like a slave to the agenda of this human right now.
@miepmaster25
@miepmaster25 3 года назад
Roger Isaksson did you just tell Shankar to kill himself?
@sauravgupta4103
@sauravgupta4103 3 года назад
@@ajmeree I have poorly developed sense of self age 20. Will therapy help
@sauravgupta4103
@sauravgupta4103 3 года назад
@@roger_isaksson I have poorly developed sense of self age 20. Will therapy help
@moonvathna9817
@moonvathna9817 6 лет назад
This resonates with me so much. Sometimes I feel like the things I do aren’t run by my own wants and needs but just because of what those around me want me to act in a certain way like my parents. I feel like a different person around different people. I feel like I’m my true self when I’m with my friends because they like me for me but my parents told me that they care about me too little to criticize me. I feel like I need to find the balance in order to actually feel like I’m truly me.
@pattycake5643
@pattycake5643 6 лет назад
Kookie Cookie I kind of understand. I whent threw a bit of the same, my mom didn't like my friend, but in the end we were friends for years after until my friends death. But now because I hung out with my friend and avoided my mom I have neither and now am a people pleaser. I have a lot of love to give and am still missing who I truly am. I'm not to old to find me but I am to scared to go it alone. If I would have met people more like me eairlier in life my life would be so diffront, would I be happier, not always. But I would be me.
@IndeedVancho
@IndeedVancho 6 лет назад
Kookie Cookie I understand how you feel. That's often how I look at my relationships. And believe me I wish I acted the same around Everyone but I don't/can't.
@IndeedVancho
@IndeedVancho 6 лет назад
Patty Cake I hope you're able to sort that out.
@suzanne893
@suzanne893 6 лет назад
Patty Cake It's never too late for anything, everything is possible, so do what you need to do. Get back with your mom and build up your relationship all over again. It takes time and practice, but don't get back to things that are long gone. Instead, let go off them and be yourself, don't care what anyone else thinks, just trust your intuition and your feelings. Do you believe in God? If so, ask for help and guidance, he'll show you the way. You will find new friends and the sun will come up again. Life is too short to hold yourself back all the time. Good luck and never loose hope.
@pattycake5643
@pattycake5643 6 лет назад
Austin Esquillin thank you...at this time I'm going with, no.
@kirstinstrand6292
@kirstinstrand6292 5 лет назад
In my opinion, it often takes a lifetime to become our True Self. Unless one had wonderful loving, communicative parenting, full of tenderness and empathy, most of us must first unwind the damage before we can begin to discover our True selves. Life is too short...let's face it!
@NokthulaMadondo
@NokthulaMadondo 4 года назад
So glad you mentioned undoing past or childhood foundations, as that is precisely what stops us from recovering our true selves.
@haiphamle3582
@haiphamle3582 9 месяцев назад
Agree. Going wrong then going right again, from the wrong place. I don't really agree that reversing back to a baby is the way. I think staying calm, listening to ourself, understanding our owned behaviors, then analyzing them properly, based on both feels and facts are the best method. Meeting the therapist is another one, faster and more effective maybe? Since they will guide us do exactly the same one above.
@noelj62
@noelj62 6 лет назад
Personally, I act my true self when I'm alone. I ignore all rules and taboos. I call into question the say and act of every person in my life, myself included. No one is off board. Then I go over my thoughts one by one with a magnifying glass.
@vanfernandes292
@vanfernandes292 4 года назад
Do you shit on yourself? 🤣🤣🤣
@chicxulub2947
@chicxulub2947 3 года назад
@Skarra Baines Exactly... You cannot feel shame of being yourself in front of anyone. Being yourself only with yourself is not enough. One's personality can never be fully developed if one does not allow it. This is all about it...
@chicxulub2947
@chicxulub2947 3 года назад
@@vanfernandes292 I use to pee... 😅😂
@kishanitaliya1408
@kishanitaliya1408 3 года назад
Paul it's much more deeper phycological than just acting conciously ...🙂
@noelj62
@noelj62 3 года назад
@@kishanitaliya1408 indeed. but changing my conscious thoughts seem to have a reflection on my unconscious mind. For example, my choice of answers or actions during my night dreams seemed to correspond to my new discovered self.
@RINX444
@RINX444 6 лет назад
I didn't know this concept existed. I thought I was the only one thinking this way. I was suffering from anxiety and depression for years but of course I didn't know about it. I sought the help of a therapist, but it didn't help me completely. I ended up doing a lot of journaling and thinking until one day an epiphany came to me. I was too pre-occupied with being the person people expected me to be. I would constantly sacrifice things I wanted to make others happy even though no sacrifice was expected of me. I told myself I need to be more self-ish in the truest sense. Do things I want to do regardless of what others perception/disapproval/comments would be. And you know what? It did help me. The more I did for myself the happier I became and led me to be more social and loving towards others. After watching this video, I see why that concept worked. And now I'm going to be more conscientious around my nieces and nephews. I'll give them the space to be themselves and lower my expectations to be completely civilized. Thanks!
@WILLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLU
@WILLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLU 5 лет назад
this is pretty spot on for my experience too. because of my childhood i became too much of a people pleaser and i was miserable. now i'm changing
@jbela
@jbela 4 года назад
Excellent,I just started journaling too. You're an inspiration.
@hnyii
@hnyii 4 года назад
Journalling has done me wonders too ..in just a couple of months at that.
@dzanegulles
@dzanegulles 3 года назад
Wowww thank youu for this
@everlasting_me
@everlasting_me 9 месяцев назад
Becoming your true self starts with putting yourself first, in whatever way that may be.
@zacharydchan417
@zacharydchan417 4 года назад
You need to know the darkness in order to appreciate light.
@SuperFaby27
@SuperFaby27 4 года назад
damn right
@hnyii
@hnyii 4 года назад
ugh, so painfully true, that is
@NOONE-iq3zt
@NOONE-iq3zt 3 года назад
similarly, you would need to know the light in order to fear the darkness
@bluebeka2458
@bluebeka2458 3 года назад
What light? **stands in pitch darkness and eats a bowl of cereals**
@veetee4826
@veetee4826 2 года назад
For how many years? How long?
@T333TN
@T333TN 3 года назад
My childhood- learning to walk on eggshells when I should be learning how to walk
@lucymcnamara4558
@lucymcnamara4558 3 года назад
Same.
@hannahnymous
@hannahnymous 6 лет назад
It was when my depression was at its worst that I've realized that the root of the problem was I was operating as my "fake self" and became a people pleaser. I'm an achiever in school till I graduated university, a student leader, had an active social life, and was always trying to be a good person. But I was also unhappy, depressed, and anxious of other people's expectations of me. The lies and the pressure was killing me. I wanted to give up a lot of times. That's why I completely agree with this video. It's now my mission to find my true self and to love myself unapologetically because I want to keep on living.
@abidemiadenle267
@abidemiadenle267 3 года назад
Quite relatable for me. I also became anorexic in college and I suffered from trich. When I got out of that really bad depression, I just stopped caring about what anyone thinks of me. Now I'm relatively happy and a bit fleshy too. People see me and say "wow... you're so fat now" then I say "Thank you" with a smile.
@hannahnymous
@hannahnymous 3 года назад
@@abidemiadenle267 Hiii there! ☺️👋 I'm so glad you're in a much better place now and you're able to relate to my comment 😊💗 Wow it's so nice to see this comment again from 2 years ago. It's incredible how much I have grown since then. I'm loving my true self now more and more each day and I'm on a self-growth journey. Who cares what the world says, what's important is we live and speak our truth. Hoping for more beautiful days for us 💗✨
@DaudZaidi
@DaudZaidi Год назад
@@hannahnymous How are you now ?
@kennethong1852
@kennethong1852 6 лет назад
*Discovering your true self is really a matter of exploration. Nothing achieves this more than educating (not schooling) oneself.*
@audelsalazar1962
@audelsalazar1962 6 лет назад
As a student and practitioner of Existentialism and Buddhism (which are sometimes at odds with each other and sometimes not) I will put forth two different responses to this idea of the True and the False Self from these perspectives: 1. From the perspective of the various Existentialist philosophers, all of whom agreed that the individual was responsible for their own life and had to accept and embrace this responsibility, the False Self is the inauthentic individual who follows the "herd" or mass society, rejecting or repressing their "passions" (what they love to do or being who they want to be) due to social pressure and conformity. This is what Jean-Paul Sartre would have called living in "Bad Faith" or a kind of willful self-deception as you would rather be doing and being something else. A famous (and often misunderstood) example of Sartre's was the Waiter who completely assumed the role of a waiter, which consequently subsumed his personal identity into the identity of the waiter, acting and doing whatever a waiter does, and more importantly, fulfilling society's expectations of what a waiter is supposed to do and be. In turn, the Waiter becomes more of a machine than a man, mechanically fulfilling the role of what a waiter is and relinquishing his freedom as an authentic individual. Tying in Winnicott's dichotomy of Self, the False Self would be the mask you wear while when interacting with others, while you only presented your genuine True Self when you were alone or among friends and family members that you trusted, which you learned the hard way to do as a child. The role the False Self plays in our daily lives as adults is that we fear our True Self will not be accepted by others and so we hide behind our inauthentic, socially-acceptable False Self. 2. In all Buddhist schools and traditions, the Self (or soul) is an illusion, an artificial image we create for ourselves of who we supposedly are. We falsely believe this Self (Winnicott's False Self) protects and comforts us but actually does us more harm than good, further separating us from reality, and more importantly, from others. Anatta, or No-Self, is the idea that by seeing through our creation of our Selves and realizing our impermanence, or more bluntly our mortality, and interdependence with others and the world around us, we will be closer to Nibbana (Nirvana) or liberation from dukkha (usually translated as suffering), allowing us to live a fuller, more satisfying life, strikingly similar to Winnicott's True Self and the authentic individual of Existentialism. While these two perspectives of the Self in Buddhism and Existentialism are extremely condensed and simplified, I hope they get the point across and that people realize the similarities, and not just the differences, of Eastern and Western thought. :)
@MariaMartinez-ts4vq
@MariaMartinez-ts4vq 6 лет назад
Audel Salazar wow, really interesting to read!!
@NokthulaMadondo
@NokthulaMadondo 4 года назад
Well put. Links for further info or reference would have been useful. But thanks nevertheless
@scrublord3376
@scrublord3376 4 года назад
Viete hel what long -pp- comment this is
@garretbrent1819
@garretbrent1819 5 лет назад
I respond deeply to this. Many times during a day, I question if I have ever just been myself. I've become so good at playing a False Self, because I've always had to adjust myself to the socio-political situation I'm in, since I was a child. I've often prided myself on being able to adapt to anyone and in so doing, manipulate any situation. Whenever I've made strides to become a more authentic version of myself, I've always felt guilty for it, and have found that my authenticity rarely gets me the attention and intimacy I crave. But the True Self is one who doesn't need the attention and intimacy from others in such a way that not having it will feel painful. The True Self is strong in its ability to care for itself, and that self-love is enough to weather the lonely periods of life, and attract to one the right attention and intimacy.
@crookedzebrarecords
@crookedzebrarecords 2 года назад
Take the meyers briggs personality test, you sound like an INFJ.
@ariaran1871
@ariaran1871 6 лет назад
Actually I think there is no a true self at all.We are all a flux of constantly changing ideas,memories,opinions,and prejudices.Like everything else,we are in constant process of construction and destruction within ourselves.I think it's comforting to know this fact.
@rosalilahimstergimst5148
@rosalilahimstergimst5148 5 лет назад
I'd suggest that honesty towards oneself and others about these constantly changing elements is what the true self consists of, and this honesty is sometimes compromised when the world around us is the higher priority, creating a need to be false at times, to 'handle things'.
@bubbly7137
@bubbly7137 5 лет назад
There are also no spaces at all
@Luna-ft8yh
@Luna-ft8yh 4 года назад
It is in deed :) however a false self will be stagnant. It will be the same as it was programmed to be, so we'll lack growth and change. Whereas the true self underneath longs for change. It is as you said ever changing. So what is underneath, the flow of ideas and concepts, can still not be shown in favour of an everlasting false face
@ManilMopas
@ManilMopas 4 года назад
basicly the self is your feeling of the self, saying that it's changing and therefor it doesnt exist doesn't make sence, if you 'true self' doesnt exist you wouldn't have a feeling of self at all, you would be a machine maybe that has no purpose, no interests, so on... the true self is all this things, its how your connection to the world is expressed and what are your desires, it changes but it exists with a small variation from how it existed the day before but generally speaking it would be mostly the same from day to day.
@ManilMopas
@ManilMopas 4 года назад
@Marianne haha like me most of the time, this whole video is about the development of a personality disorder and i happen to have one
@Horsie112
@Horsie112 4 года назад
I was raised not allowed to show personal emotions and I still haven't learn to be able to be angry to others because I was educated both in my family and at school that parents and school can never be incorrect or wrong, so being angry is unnecessary.
@themodernmeditator
@themodernmeditator 2 года назад
You have just helped me understand narcissism - the toddler that never grew up and is emotionally stunted around the age of 2. My dad used to go into rages, smash and throw objects around the room, be physically and emotionally abusive, manipulative etc. With the aim to destroy 'mummy' and to test if she would still love him unconditionally. As a child I attuned to his emotions for safety and survival and comforted him when he came home late drunk late at night. I have a memory of him getting into a fight and he got hit with a knuckle duster - it was me that got a flannel and was helping him mop the blood from his face (my mum use to 'ignore' him and stay in her room. I was only a teenager at the time! As a result, I had codependent/people pleaser patterns, and my trauma response was 'freeze' and 'fawn'. Thankfully I've had a couple of therapists to help me through the processs.
@Dierdre_Barlow
@Dierdre_Barlow 9 месяцев назад
That was like reading a description of my own childhood! 😱
@scaryhours2220
@scaryhours2220 3 года назад
This is one thing that I can praise my mother for, she always let me be who I wanted to be. She let me explore activities like karate football track weightlifting etc but was also so happy when I found my love for videogames. I was always a pretty good kid but I think its because she would tell me everyday that she loved me and heavens missing an angel and i was it. We had our problems but I was always loved to a galactic degree and because of that I can be myself and actually be content with who I am. School of Life is Legendary 😎.
@desisparta
@desisparta 6 лет назад
As a kid, my parents taught me to never hurt anyone and forgive no matter how huge the pain others would inflict on me. I took this literally and as a result I got constantly bullied at school. soon my grades began to drop because of them. I've changed schools 3 times and still I made bullies because forgiveness was a sign of weakness and a opportunity to get away with hurting me. now im 21 and I have an urge to hurt someone because I want the feeling that I can protect myself. I want to be capable of hurting someone so that I can know that I can protect myself from sadistic people.
@marieb5251
@marieb5251 6 лет назад
The girl's voice at the end always sounds like she's about to cry.
@ARKUENE
@ARKUENE 6 лет назад
Marie B, she might if you don't like and subscribe :)
@kevins7423
@kevins7423 6 лет назад
I like her voice.
@KMissPerfect
@KMissPerfect 6 лет назад
i thought its a guy
@Elivener
@Elivener 6 лет назад
maybe she is about to cry because she does not live her True Self))
@romantheroman98
@romantheroman98 5 лет назад
I hate this voice, it's so annoying
@alwaysbeeurself
@alwaysbeeurself 4 года назад
The true self is scared to be, the false self protects it. It is only when the true self understands that it is ok, that it becomes what it is intended to be, what it always has been, and now free.
@marek9081
@marek9081 6 лет назад
This makes perfect sense. I've never really been my true self and i merely adjusted to others, which of course made me anxious and depressed. Now thanks to therapy i'm trying to change it...
@mestherchung
@mestherchung 4 года назад
Are u seeing some progress ma friend
@sauravgupta4103
@sauravgupta4103 3 года назад
@@mestherchung I have poorly developed sense of self age 20. Will therapy help
@jbela
@jbela 4 года назад
I'm 48 years old and still struggling because of the bad childhood. It also affects my relationships with the authority. And was other random people, as well as friends. I've tried meditation, journaling, reading.I've also tried to see a therapist but I got turned down by three of them because they were booked. I feel like School of Life can only help me.and at this time I still feel like I'm doing this on a wing on a prayer.it's nice to know that there are other people on these comment boards that have gone through the same thing.
@98Blacklightning
@98Blacklightning 5 лет назад
This is the perfect explanation of what’s wrong with me. I’ve suffered depression for 8, suicidal thoughts for almost 5 years. And I just turned 20... Growing up I learned that I need to adapt to whatever the needs and feelings of people around me are. That showing extreme emotional behavior was rude and would be punished by emotional torment. My mother always compared to other kids, told me in which ways I’m worse than them and that she wished me to be more like them. And that I was a disappointment. Love was only shown when I was being a good boy, complying and nice to everyone. Expressing my true thoughts and feelings would often result in shock and rejection. Making me promise stuff and punishing for not meeting the expectations. Whatever my mother liked, was good for me. Whatever she disliked, was bad. Kinda fucked me up and killed my soul
@nicholasnopper6194
@nicholasnopper6194 Год назад
I can relate to you fully, my man. I've never heard about this, but I constantly question whether I am being authentic or not. I'm pretty sure a people-pleasing nature has been nurtured into me, and it has jacked up my sense of self. I've found this new girl who also deals with the same issue. She grew up too fast just like me, and has never been able to express her inner child. I hope that we can help each other through it, because I see myself going far with her (we’re both from broken homes) I hope you can find the help that you need, because you sound like such a splendid person. If only everybody could be their true awesome selves without any interruptions
@Maoam13
@Maoam13 Год назад
Same here. My family was so fucked up and everything my mother liked, i had to like to. She always told everybody I liked the color blue the most and I just liked white cocolate and nothing else. But they were her favorites, not mine. She knew I liked black and I liked chips. But she insisted I have other favorites. So fucked up.Now, as I am grown up I feel like I don’t know who I am and what to do. I feel so empty and my depressen just got worse. I hope you can overcome your struggles and live a happy life. all the best for you
@98Blacklightning
@98Blacklightning Год назад
Oh man this was three years ago, and I can say that my situation has somewhat improved. I now pay closer attention to my own needs and try to fulfill them, even when it goes so strongly against the shitty values and beliefs that have been ingrained into my innocent mind by violent force. I remember there was so much shouting, screaming, fighting and emotional abuse back when I was younger and especially as I went through puberty, which was when the demeaning treatment really started to grind me down and where I was unable to live out my true personality and discover life like a healthy teen should. I’ve been furiously insulted, ragingly demeaned, given a horrible conscience for minor things and intensely blamed for others suffering so many times it’s no wonder I ended up despising myself and my life and wanting to die. Not to forget the strict way I was expected to act compliant, responsible and mature and to excell in everything I did, even when I was pressured into doing it against my will. I remember wishing to have a normal family and to be able to enjoy life as excitedly and carefree as the other kids my age. I remember feeling so empty, abandoned and scared of the people around me. Damn that was really a bunch to go through and no doubt is has left deep scars gaping in my sense of self to this day. It becomes evident every day in the way I fear, avoid and distrust people, hide and hold back my honest thoughts and feelings, lie out of fear, constantly try to adapt and please, apologise and feel bad for everything I do to upset someone. And there’s so much more to list. However.. I’ve found that mentally going back and understanding the unmet needs enables me to purposely go out and catch up on the experiences I never had and thus continuously fill the gaping hole that has formed inside of me over the many years. For example I was often angrily pressured into wearing clothes I disliked and not allowed to discover and express my own personality through this, although finances were never a problem. I have come a long way making up for this by wearing what I like despite my grave fear of judgement and rejection which has been paralysing my authentic self for so long. There’s still a lot to make right and it’s hard but it pays off eventually.
@lesstalkmoreaction_1
@lesstalkmoreaction_1 Год назад
Sorry this happened to you. I hope you find a way to heal and understand that your mother was also probably unaware of how that would affect you so try not to take it personally but I'm learning that we are all a work in progress I hope this helps
@4Him4u2
@4Him4u2 9 месяцев назад
It will get better as you grow and establish your own life. Just be careful not to repeat that relationship in your life partner. It’s easy to do and is painful all over again. Take care of yourself.
@bluegoblin2.026
@bluegoblin2.026 6 лет назад
My true -self has many great things to say, however my false-self has restricted my comment, because in the back of my mind, getting no likes on this comment will damage my ego 🤔
@a0um
@a0um 6 лет назад
I disliked your false self comment. What now?
@niafly159
@niafly159 6 лет назад
SnottyLottie ayyyy snotgirl!
@bluegoblin2.026
@bluegoblin2.026 6 лет назад
All in one I have subbed to you. 😁
@774Rob
@774Rob 6 лет назад
Both your true-self and false-self have failed to make a comment of any value and you still got ninety-five likes. What does that say about your ideology?
@bluegoblin2.026
@bluegoblin2.026 6 лет назад
I'm glad to see my comment offended so many people, when it's purpose was the opposite. I'm afraid it's too late for us as a species yo evolve
@dashamai1163
@dashamai1163 5 лет назад
There is a Chinese saying about the image of self: There are three mirrors that form a person's reflection; the first is how you see yourself, the second is how others see you and the third reflects the truth. What do you think about that?
@ta3970
@ta3970 3 года назад
I think you have to be highly evolved to recognize that 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
@kubix426
@kubix426 3 года назад
Just go into TV and you will meet your True Self
@shocktones9704
@shocktones9704 Год назад
I must be boiled down to how I was raised, a loving Mother and Father who sacrificed much to feed, shelter and clothe me. I felt loved and unafraid to approach them, they would listen and support and I knew they loved me unconditionally .Most my memories are fond. I've never felt as I haven't been my true self
@eduardochavacano
@eduardochavacano Год назад
you are so lucky then... But love is not always good. Only an uncle or an aunt can really love a child.
@augijyotbali2131
@augijyotbali2131 3 года назад
I think childhood plays a HUGE roll in building personality of an adult there by affecting an entire person .
@Dr.JudeAEMasonMD
@Dr.JudeAEMasonMD 2 года назад
This is pure gold, I believe that the dark night of the soul that proceeds the spiritual awakening into the true self, the shattering of the illusion of the false self into an integrated authentic self IS the salvation experience, the regeneration of the soul in the recognition of the Word as the truth, the way, and the life.
@lizp5449
@lizp5449 2 года назад
I agree,the dark night can last no the as we!l,but a truer version of self arises.Painful indeed,but it seems to be a metamorphosis
@mechakumquat9426
@mechakumquat9426 6 лет назад
This was the most relevant thing I've ever watched at exactly the most relevant moment.
@alanavendano8254
@alanavendano8254 4 года назад
Same
@sebenzilemaseko5749
@sebenzilemaseko5749 6 лет назад
That’s not your true self. That’s your mind and personality. Your true self is pure consciousness, it’s always been and will continue continue to exist.
@kikaa6091
@kikaa6091 3 года назад
I feel so sad rn because I'm slowly finding out that in my childhood i was neglected and told who I am and who I should be so often that now I can't recognize who I truly am. It's shocking for me to recognize that my parents weren't good to me and that our family is dysfunctional. I am still in my teen years and it hurts me to know that i may not free myself from my FALSE ME until I will be an andult. I found out that when I'm completely alone or when I'm drunk I feel sorta happy and satisfied. I don't overthink what I do and it's just so easier to do things I want to do when I'm not being judged by me or others. Yes this is kind of a self pity comment, but please don't judge me. I will be grateful to whoever was willing to read this. It means much to me that you were willing to listen to me, thank you. :)
@An1MuS
@An1MuS 3 года назад
Know it will take some time for you to change but it is possible, I've been where you are right now. The most important advice I would give you is "Be your own best friend." Be kind, compassionate, understanding, and accepting to yourself. Imagine a perfect parent. Now imagine that you could be that parent for yourself in a way that it would feel like you're being your own best friend. How will it be? You will pay attention to the way you talk to yourself, and change it to a way that is more loving. In fact, you will love yourself unconditionally. See what that word *_really_* means and what it implies. Whatever mistakes you do, you won't beat yourself down for them. You will be supportive instead. If you're feeling sad, upset, unmotivated, depressed or *_anything else_* you won't numb those feelings and distract yourself from them, you'll try to understand what's behind them. You'll be with those feelings, all of them, you will listen to them, until you feel better. You'd do this self-loving little by little, every day, here and there, make it a habit, take a few minutes each day to ponder about it and to connect with yourself in a more loving way. Only when our true self feels safe enough to express itself within the walls of our own skulls, can it really come out unafraid to others. If our own head is a bad neighborhood, how else can we feel roaming in there but not in defense/attack mode? How can a person be their true selves with others, if they can't even be it with themselves? If I have a feeling and I'm the first to judge myself for it, how could I even expect to express that feelings to others? As they say, "All you need is love" :) Good luck
@kikaa6091
@kikaa6091 3 года назад
@@An1MuS thank you so much🥺
@riolawrance7080
@riolawrance7080 6 лет назад
It's so true. Our life back then, really determine our future. Darkness and unwanted experiences need to be solve to unlock someone's soul to his/her nature. Thanks for making this video, makes me heal myself and if I can, I will heal another who feel the same
@ibrahimchaudhry9024
@ibrahimchaudhry9024 6 лет назад
Wow.... so incisive.... & penetrating. For our growth & healing.... we really need to give ourselves... & others... the LOVING space to be unpleasant, broken & difficult. So we can process & purge it out of our system... & move on happier, calmer & lighter... .... baggage free. Thank you... heartily! Much Love, 🙏❤🙏❤🙏
@nickthenoob4968
@nickthenoob4968 6 лет назад
Amazed at how this channel seems to pull pages from my very own life's experiences.
@waspenterprise1
@waspenterprise1 6 лет назад
a false self is what you're left with after growing up with an emotionally self-absorbed narcissistic mother
@sauravgupta4103
@sauravgupta4103 3 года назад
I have poorly developed sense of self age 20. Will therapy help
@carsonchan5102
@carsonchan5102 2 года назад
@@sauravgupta4103 Yes. Forgiveness, Respect, Acceptance of others and yourself. Its never too late!
@gogo311
@gogo311 6 лет назад
I think all of this boils down to letting out your true emotions from time to time.
@velvet_moon_
@velvet_moon_ 3 года назад
This explains so much. I’m 30 and about to start therapy for the first time in my life. I can’t wait to get started on finding my true self.
@schwelly8052
@schwelly8052 2 года назад
turning 30 and i need it
@yaminishah2629
@yaminishah2629 2 года назад
Hi, how it has been in therapy so far? I'm asking this, because, I have been wanting to go for so long, but I don't earn yet, and I can't bother my parents, they believe this is all an overreaction. And I want to know, if it really has helped. My anxious brain keeps telling me nothing will get me out of the depressed state, I am currently in.
@mountainjay
@mountainjay Год назад
@@yaminishah2629 if you are in a depressed state, in addition to looking for a therapist, you should also look for God.
@Vargolis
@Vargolis Год назад
hows it going Brittany? how are you getting on since this message? much love
@cmwenda92
@cmwenda92 5 лет назад
The best thing about this channel is that it gives quite an unorthodox way of viewing concepts we or as humans generally think we know. The true self and expressing him/her vs the false conformist self is something I hadn't quite thought of along those lines. Thank you for yet another eye-opening video and something else to contemplate
@lydiatownsend7789
@lydiatownsend7789 3 года назад
I had a parent with severe depression when I was a young child. I walked on egg shells to make them happy or comfort them, so I learned to put on a good face and not complain. Even when I saw a therapist I struggled to actually say how I felt.
@ryanliberty
@ryanliberty 6 лет назад
This was a beautiful and clear explanation of an important concept. ❤
@6699Jackie
@6699Jackie Год назад
This video really does speak to me, i am having therapy once a week and i struggle with who i really am and talking about what has hurt me growing up. Thankyou so much for sharing
@kabisceral
@kabisceral 6 лет назад
As a clinical psychologist, i keep learning and remembering thanks to you guys. You are awesome.
@creativitycave9374
@creativitycave9374 6 лет назад
The thing is people and those around don't accept me and who I am. I know the opinion of others don't matter that much but where ever I am my true self the only one that likes me is myself. 😌
@Luketaylor9729
@Luketaylor9729 6 лет назад
Screw them. Sometimes, it's better to have you're own company rather than that of others.
@creativitycave9374
@creativitycave9374 6 лет назад
Luke Taylor I sure did. 😁
@BigHenFor
@BigHenFor 6 лет назад
Find your own tribe. How? Start doing things that you love that you can share with others. This will lead you to meet more people like you.
@birichinaxox9937
@birichinaxox9937 4 года назад
It does matter for me. The wrong environment is soul crushing
@lusuzy2106
@lusuzy2106 6 лет назад
I don’t fully agree with this theory. When we were young, we express our emotions so we can ask our parents to fulfils our needs. But as we slowly grow up we need to learn how to properly interpret our emotions and express our need. The parents need to discipline us exactly that. If they are extremely tolerant, like the ideal parents this video mentioned, then we will think expressing all of our feelings, even sometimes it’s hurtful to others, is okay. Then we either encounter socially rejecting situation because our behaviours so we learn to communicate from that, or we become psychopaths- to do extreme behaviours to get what we need. The alternative I think is this- let the kid know that all his feelings are justified, but teach him the right way to think about his feelings(why he feels this way, what he needs), and the right way to communicate to his surroundings(first parents then society). So the kid will live knowing all his feelings are justified, but not forcing other people to tolerate everything he does, and still successfully communicating what he needs from others. Adults often feel depressed or stuck because they can’t accept how they feel especially if it’s socially unacceptable, so they need someone to accept first(therapist) so they can accept themselves. So I agree the inexpressive adults need therapist. But the parenting part, no no no, please don’t be overly permissive of your child.
@BigHenFor
@BigHenFor 6 лет назад
Lu Suzy Permissive? Winnacott was not being permissive at all. Often you can't tell people things, you have to show them. If a child is having a tantrum through frustration or fear that they cannot express or articulate in any other way, because their motivations are a mystery to them, then their parents must teach by example. Putting a frustrated child on the naughty step calmly but firmly, until they calm down teaches by example. This doesn't work with dysfunctional adults or children. These act out their bad behaviour because it gets them a pay off that they have learned to expect - attention even if it's bad like shouting or corporal punishment. Winnacott by not giving them the expected drama, and quietly sitting them down and talking to them about what they did and why they shouldn't do it again was being anything but permissive. Learning how to set boundaries without bullying or traumatising the child is something every parent is not necessarily good at. It's easy to have children, but it's not easy to be a parent. Why? People tend to do what they are used to. If they have been aggressively parented with shouting and slapping or, if they had too much freedom with few boundaries, they are not going to be effective adults, nevermind parents. Boundaries are needed not only to keep the child safe, but to give it the skills to get what it needs in life, i.e. to be an effective adult in the world. Therefore, they have to learn the right strategies by example. Most parents try to be good parents, but tend to only do what they think works. It's a fine and subtle line between browbeating a child into submission or raising a tyrant.
@dumper926
@dumper926 5 лет назад
I think you are not interpreting the information correctly. Some parents - such as mine - dont allow their kids to express normal emotions. For example, one time I was crying because I couldnt go to my friends house (I was maybe 7 and crying about what kids cry about, pretty normal and not a big deal) and my dad's reaction was explosive anger, and then manipulative guilt trips that involved him crying and telling me we are a weak family because of my behavior. THIS is what the video is talking about. I had to learn to pretty much sit in silence and hide my feelings or else I'd go through that shit for HOURS at a time. I could never show emotions because my parents were so emotional and damaged. That is what this video is addressing. It's okay for kids to be upset and to feel angry. The video didnt say to just do nothing about it lol they just claim that shutting it down all or most of the time in negative ways can create issues when that kid becomes an adult. CASE IN POINT ME
@dumper926
@dumper926 5 лет назад
Also, they say psychopaths are born while sociopaths are made. So you cant allegedly make your kid be a psychopath.
@elizabethschwartz3619
@elizabethschwartz3619 4 года назад
Lu Suzy You are wrong. They do not grow up feeling entitled. Do you know how I know? Because I was raised exactly how it was described in this video. I was tolerated as a child. When I was younger, I was extremely polite, did all my homework, and was just the nicest person, but at the same time, I didn’t stress over school. I truly was. However, I was a total ass to my parents. I would scream in my mother’s face and threw a chair once. A few years ago, I called them a narcissist. They never changed their demeanor. They talked to me softly and babied me... I am babied to this day lol. But I am not a jerk. You missed a very important detail. Even though they tolerated my badness, they taught me to be thoughtful of other people. They didn’t tell me to be good or respect them. They taught me to be thoughtful of OTHERS... they never directly said I should respect them. I was never told, “You don’t take toys from other children” or “You hurt his feelings. That makes you a burden.” I was told, “I know you don’t realize it, but you really hurt his feelings when you took his toy. Why don’t you go apologize to him?” And I said, “okay.” I wasn’t a bad person. I just made a simple mistake. In a way, as a child, I completely differentiated between the public and my parents. Be respectful to the public. Be whoever you want to your parents. You know what? I turned out okay. I’m 17 now and am beginning to mature more and more. My parents and I have a fantastic relationship. I really need to repay them once I get older.
@coolboy-ty8kf
@coolboy-ty8kf 4 года назад
Elizabeth Schwartz You don't owe your parents anything. Cherish them♥️
@Mike-fx4wk
@Mike-fx4wk 5 лет назад
Blew my mind. I found this channel today and I'm thankful. U just clarified something I Instinctively knew was going on inside me but I couldn't work it out. Perfect.
@9grillo
@9grillo 4 года назад
this resonate with me this is how feel, when i was growing up i wasn't alow to be my true myself and now im go to therapy to find myself. Now im a rebel but im learning how to be my true self instead of being what mother wanted me to be. Thank for making this video it helps alot to derstand what im going through and how i felt all those years and how i feel now.
@Sprinterification
@Sprinterification 6 лет назад
If anything this scares me. My mum was depressed when I was young, she had four children under 5 and I was the youngest. My dad would get angry at little things. He would grit his teeth, raise his voice and his movements became wild. I feel uneasy even remembering it now
@britneychelle87
@britneychelle87 6 лет назад
Feeling a bit shook cause this describes exactly where I’m at in my life rn. The therapy has been hard but this is very validating that I need to keep on this path.
@isarfr
@isarfr 3 года назад
How are you now?
@arthippie333
@arthippie333 3 года назад
There are so much researches out there. Winnicot was an amazing doctor. Thank you school of life for making this video and enlightening me. I am a doctor. I was suffering from depression and anxiety in my life. Your videos has always helped me in analysing, accepting and correcting myself. Thank you. Keep up the good work. 😊
@serenevalor
@serenevalor 3 года назад
At some point...we have to stop blaming our childhood, past, caregivers and others for our wrongs... I'm glad psychotherapy allows and helps people to move forward from the blame and onward with their life.
@36summers
@36summers 2 года назад
Looking back at my Childhood and reflection on Adults years, I've always wondered why I always felt I needed to please others first before actually just being myself and doing whatever came natural to me. My mother was very strict and all of us, Siblings, felt quite scared of our mother. She ultimately drilled into us that our welfare came second to our neighbours for example, because somehow it Brough shame on us if we stuck up for ourselfs. If say we were being bullied. I can remember clearly a day when me and my friend were fishing. Some older lads were throwing stones at us. My friend, got up, challenged them and actually ran them off! I sat there at took the bullying. He was amazed at my non action, but I was more afraid of bringing a negative situation back home, so at the time, I was actually more fearful of my mum not the bullies. I was very impressed and quite Jealous of his bravery. Fast forwarding into Emotional relationships with the opposite sex, Some, not all, but most, have being built on pity, and feeling sorry for the other. Or taking on the role to fix them while giving them everything and then regretting it which fuels bitterness ??
@spiritedrenee9895
@spiritedrenee9895 6 лет назад
I was thinking about this earlier today. It's like you guys read my mind.
@charmedprince
@charmedprince 6 лет назад
Description Untitled me too. I was busy self diagnosing myself yesterday if i have Asperger's syndrome and then this vid popped up
@mikgol81
@mikgol81 6 лет назад
Synchronicity = the universe communicating with you
@philosothink
@philosothink Год назад
these videos make me cry while simultaneously feeling hopeful. ty
@popopier
@popopier 6 лет назад
This video helps me a lot. It explains why I have been difficult with any social relations, and how I should do with my 5 years old child. It gives me the courage to go on my everyday life. Thank you very much.
@smilleur
@smilleur 4 года назад
I really needed to hear this today. My intake appointment for therapy is in a few weeks. This makes me feel a lot better about it
@SFVetNeph
@SFVetNeph 6 лет назад
I wish I could be my true self but even I don’t know what it is anymore. 😢
@henrydaquipel8700
@henrydaquipel8700 6 лет назад
Mr. 'Grey' Rodgers Sighs. Same here.
@BigHenFor
@BigHenFor 6 лет назад
Then start to get reacquainted with yourself. How? By doing something new and different each week, and keep a journal about these new experiences. Expand your horizons. "You are not a tree - if you don't like where you are, then move"
@birdontheinternet
@birdontheinternet 3 года назад
Big ass mood
@SFVetNeph
@SFVetNeph 3 года назад
Well things are way better now. The bully at work is long gone. I’m a key worker officially which helped me get over my burnout. I’ve rediscovered myself during lockdown with my old hobbies. Even passed my exams without even taking them! I am a caring, responsible, creative, and intelligent member of society. ✊
@gemilangsibarani4310
@gemilangsibarani4310 3 года назад
@@SFVetNeph glad to hear that, hope your life will get better
@ampz1466
@ampz1466 6 лет назад
I think people seem to be making a wrong assumption. As I understand it, it's not about raising a spoilt brat and letting them do whatever they want. It's about not putting adult pressure on a child so that the child isn't afraid of themselves and their emotions. I think. I think I've been through what the video talks about. I relate so much to it!! (Sorry for the length) When I was 6 my dad lost his job, and when I had just turned 13 he died. My mom had so much pressure on her that I knew I couldn't rebel. I had to be perfect - great grades, good manners, dress discreetly, no dating, Do nothing even slightly risky. Even when I got flu I felt guilty because I knew I was giving her more to worry about. I wanted to save my mom from any more stress. I grew up to be very obedient, quiet and anxious adult. When my mom passed away it devastated me. But now that it's a year and a half later, I'm slowly finding who I actually am as an adult. Could say I'm rebelling. . . Sort of. I'm a 25 year old woman who drank and played pool with a friend for the first time a month ago. I have a friend who's like an awesome therapist. She lets me go wild, but still protects me enough. My personality hasn't truly changed I just feel free to be myself a lot more, even if myself is kind of an idiot who screws up a lot and gets angry at my loved ones sometimes. Someone who loves drinking with friends and swears and puts fun colours on the ends of my hair just cos I can. I love singing even though I'm so so very bad at it and I'm studying Visual Arts at University. TL:DR: mom was stressed when I was growing up. I had to be near perfect. Now at 25 I'm finding my true self, which involves purple hair and playing pool.
@s4oren2
@s4oren2 4 года назад
God, every time I watch any of your videos, I feel so understood I'm always moved to tears.
@thesupergreenjudy
@thesupergreenjudy Год назад
I think there is a difference between helping your child manage their emotions (after all, screaming and shouting and throwing things all over the place because you are in a rage is not what I would call a positive way of expressing your true self) and denying your child the opportunity to explore different activities. The latter is what often leads people to develop a different persona. Over the last few years I reduced my consumption of media that keeps reminding me of my less than ideal childhood and that I need a therapist and focused more on information about how I can improve my relationship with my parents. I have learned so much more from that than watching self-pity inducing videos which turn our to be a self-fulfilling prophecy for me. There is, of course, a balance to be had but I think being told over and over again that your childhood sucked and you are not responsible for your maladaptive behaviour isn't really conducive to improving your situation.
@SciencewithKatie
@SciencewithKatie 6 лет назад
Very well done and as interesting as always. 💛
@alonbechor1842
@alonbechor1842 6 лет назад
This video completely emphasizes what regularly goes through my mind. Before watching it,I would never have thought that this phenomenon of faking the self identity while near my caregivers does really exist somewhere else.
@jamiem5504
@jamiem5504 5 лет назад
it is like you just went into my brain and understood the root of all my psychological problems and explained it to me and now im crying
@emilyb7867
@emilyb7867 6 лет назад
Another helpful and eye-opening video. Thank you for uploading such good content!
@paulmetdebbie447
@paulmetdebbie447 6 лет назад
Both selves described here are false. The real true self is not agressive, inconsiderate, asocial or insensitive. It is curious, outlooking, loving and accepting. Yes, a wrong upbringing can spoil a lot. But a right upbringing is not that which tolerates everything passively, but guides with strong love. Other than this video suggests, Winnicott did not have a negative image of the child's true self at all. I quote : "a well cared-for baby usually feel(s) confident, calm and curious and (is) able to learn without having to invest a lot of energy into defences". Please, School of Life, be accurate in the use of the ideas of others.
@crisissocoylike
@crisissocoylike 5 лет назад
Alain does put his bias in a lot of these videos, tbh. I think the School of Life videos are good introductions to general ideals in philosophy and psychology, but there's still a lot more digging to do within these subjects beyond a ~5 minute introductory video.
@hanna_swede
@hanna_swede 5 лет назад
Agreed. From my personal experience, I remember specifically and strongly how selfless, or whatever the word is, I sometimes wanted to be as a toddler. For example, I remember on my 3rd birthday that I wanted to give my mom the bigger of two toys because she was bigger than me I said. I proudly said this because I wanted to make her feel better and to be a good person. Only dared this if the people were kind/not mean to me of course.
@MissRenesmeePretty
@MissRenesmeePretty 5 лет назад
Hanna Sofia Maybe there are people who are born with selfishness and other bad traits, I remember not wanting to share with certain people just because their presence annoyed me but I liked sharing anything I ate with my dog so I’m not sure anymore what the true self could be.
@gabbieannie8025
@gabbieannie8025 5 лет назад
Id have to agree on this, getting all wild and not held accountable can be problematic. As I was watching the clip cant help but ask "so how should we differ psychopaths?" Are they allowed to be wild at young age cause they're supposed to? I believe not.
@user-np6tf8zx1u
@user-np6tf8zx1u 5 лет назад
100% agree with you. I think School of Life is missing the mark lately with videos suggesting terrible behavior is OK. Terrible emotions are OK but acting out your aggression on other people is not. The goal should be to channel those emotions into a productive pursuit, i.e. expressing them in a tranformative way that generates self-empowerment.
@PurpleCloud619
@PurpleCloud619 6 лет назад
Your videos are Therapy of their very own. This channel & my recent introduction to Alan Watts is all I need through this “Bad Way” that I’m currently going through.
@angeldemon5926
@angeldemon5926 4 года назад
I need to be true about my personality... About myself... I do love myself... But making other people avoiding me just because of my REAL self... Making me to hate myself... But no more! I want to be healthy! Physically and MENTALLY! Me avoiding those fake feelings is better than me being insecure forever... LOVE MYSELF💜
@Alireza-zc3kc
@Alireza-zc3kc 4 года назад
Wonderful video , there is only one big issue, not all therapists are skillful and great at what they do. I do absolutely agree with the contents of this video, but finding a good therapist almost requires a good luck otherwise you end up spending 1000s of bucks for no reason. That's according to my previous experiences with therapists. And it almost makes you think there is no way out of this
@yoyobuddie757
@yoyobuddie757 3 года назад
I fake my personality in everything religon, love,smile, friendship, my dreams and ect................... I don't know what too do. I feel hurt. I want to know who I am I hope I can be myself In the future.
@luisurena9876
@luisurena9876 3 года назад
Try to do the things that make you feel good and peaceful inside; do them as much as you can. I think a psychologist can help too, yoga and meditation, journaling, and other tools. We're in this together.
@nehaantony3751
@nehaantony3751 3 года назад
See...sometimes its better not to be you.......nobody is born perfectly .we all have something wrong...if we kept that negativity with us by being ourself its more dangerous ...be the one you love to be....for that you need to throw out many thoughts and habits...... so by sacrificing the bad you be the best you whom you really wanted to be... Dont try to love the one whom you are.....be the person you love you to be.....it will make. U happy...trust
@tomato4300
@tomato4300 3 года назад
But I don't to want to be like a kid too .-. So...what now?
@nehaantony3751
@nehaantony3751 3 года назад
@@tomato4300 then be the one you wanted to be.....its you who finally decide where your thoughts must go and what your mind must tellll......fins it ..
@nehaantony3751
@nehaantony3751 3 года назад
@@tomato4300 then be the one you wanted to be.....its you who finally decide where your thoughts must go and what your mind must tellll......fins it ..
@NGH99999
@NGH99999 6 лет назад
Growing up, my father was a good, hard working man, and he tried mightily to be "there" for my siblings and I, but he had a neurotic, emotionally reactive side to him, and he would blow up and yell at me if I did something he disapproved of. Since this felt like certain death coming over me, I of course learned very early on, and very quickly, that I had better STOP BEING ME and figure out (fast!) how to be a good little boy that father would approve of. So, yeah, I'm 49, and I've still got the fake thing down. Watching this video, I totally relate and agree with its message, and it emphasizes, in my mind, just how arduous it is to responsibly and effectively parent a child. What a huge, immensely important proposition! I am entirely convinced our modern world would be orders of magnitude better / more positive / more harmonious if children were allowed to fully develop their proper sense of self. Think of the adults they'd grow into, and the families they'd create. If enacted on a worldwide scale, we'd see massive improvements, on a humanitarian level, within a generation. That's the blink of an eye!
@dianawitherspoonrivera4756
@dianawitherspoonrivera4756 5 лет назад
These are some of the healthiest, most constructive videos of all time. Bless you for sharing them!!!
@drogoscg1
@drogoscg1 6 лет назад
How free is healthy? What if a child is allowed to live more instinctually, but is secretly murderous, violent, and not just amoral, but immoral? It seems to me that some social constraints and norms have to be imposed on the young individual no matter what. Such impositions might cost the young individual some freedom to find true self, but for the sake of the group such constraints have to be taught and imposed from birth. I don't think as long as there is another person who may suffer from the actions of the individual can we truly be free in self and call ourselves functioning. We have to always have some minimum of empathy, sympathy, and compassion.
@late2647
@late2647 6 лет назад
i Granot Thank you. I was waiting the whole video for a small caviat, a nuance, a simple acknowledgement that our unconstrained, self centered "true self" is an impediment to society. You can certainly raise your child to discover himself, explore and become a unique individual, but I don't think refreining from punishing good behavior and rewarding positive ones, for the sake of both your own kid and people around him, is really what we should be doing. Other than that, it's not like it has never been done before. People I know who were clearly free to be their "true self" because their parent didn't give a shit, are self centered assholes, for the most part. Of course, I do not have a perfect assement of all of them and their childhoods, and that's only particular cases, so I'm open to being proven wrong here.
@olgrandpapdiabeetus9551
@olgrandpapdiabeetus9551 6 лет назад
It seems implied. Firstly, due to it being common knowledge to know never to let your kids do extremely wild and crazy things. They already know that and they expect you to already know that. And secondly, it is hinted at that those sorts of bad and extreme behaviors won't go without being addressed or even punished if needed be. The mother's scowl is a nod to it, and more directly, how the mom is drawn, telling her child to stop when they kick the other kid ( 2:39 ). The goal is to inform people about parts they don't know, not to re-iterate common sense. Every video essay is expected to be taken with a grain of salt and reality to cut out anything that's already understood in the grand scheme. Of course there has to be a minimum. The point is to allow more freedom to get closer to minimum.
@Nitephall
@Nitephall 6 лет назад
i Granot What the video is saying is that during our early years we need to be able to be who we are without being made to feel guilty or shameful about it. We need to learn that it is okay to express our true thoughts and feelings and do the things we want to do. If we don't get this validation, if our parents don't send the message that it is okay to be who we are, a message become deeply ingrained in us that says I, as I truly am, am bad, irrelevant, unacceptable. We learn that we are merely playthings for our caregiver's neuroses, and only in that does our worth lie. Certainly, as the child grows, it has to learn to conform to certain norms of society and standards of behavior, but we must first receive the message that I am okay, just as I am.
@BigHenFor
@BigHenFor 6 лет назад
i Granot I think you misunderstand the point that the video is making. Firstly, every adult has to balance their own needs with those with those of society. To do that successfully and effectively requires a childhood that allows the child to learn that their needs of safety and security can be met by them being to negotiate with the adult world. Part of that process is learning that is learning that one doesn't control the world AND one doesn't have to try to do so to get what one needs. This essential step takes place in childhood where the child develops and learns how to behave with others through developing its Ego. The Ego is the problem solving part of the psyche that works out how to meet our instinctual needs (the Id) whilst following the rules and structure from outside that is internalised (the Superego). Good parenting - boundaries imposed in a calm but firm and consistent manner, structure, safety, and reassurance - leads to a well-defined and secure personality that can meet its own needs whilst functioning in the world. This personality is two-dimensional as it is the Persona - our social selves managing our interactions with others, and our Id, ideally working well together. Where parenting has been dysfunctional - violent, unstructured, or lacking, the child's personality doesn't work properly. They learn dysfunctional ways of relating to others and meeting their own needs, which can persist into adulthood. Such people don't recognise that they are unconsciously repeating patterns that no longer serve them. Part of that is acting out these patterns in order to get responses from others they more familiar with such as anger, rejection, and punishment. That's what Winnacott saw, and by subverting his patients' expectations of punishment and rejection, and reinforcing good behaviour, he taught them that they could change their behaviour, and get what they needed. The secret true self is the child-like part of ourselves that never goes away. It needs a distinct awareness of autonomy and a sense of agency and capacity in the world to not act out.
@Hesnotoneofus
@Hesnotoneofus 6 лет назад
Not that I don't empathise with your perspective but I think more often than not, we are good without social norms pushing us away from being these instincts. Education, knowledge, and wisdom change our true behaviours. Social norms are only that, what is visible socially. So many of our choices are free from this pressure so we must learn them elsewhere, if we are to become true and whole persons.
@contr4dixion
@contr4dixion 4 года назад
Interesting. I feel like I've put myself through one such process where i become quite an unbearable ass to my family. I feel better now and more willing to give and take, but also more assertive of things I truly want.
@me0101001000
@me0101001000 6 лет назад
This video is not immediately relevant to me right now, but when I decide to have children, I'll definitely come back to this again. Once again, well done.
@janaalabin6826
@janaalabin6826 3 года назад
Watching videos like these make me really happy. I am healed through this video. Thank you for this video.
@bryanvasquez6388
@bryanvasquez6388 6 лет назад
I wish I knew who my true self is, I'm dying slowly feeling fake and unhappy. I'm so scared to let my guard down.
@kp2kpx
@kp2kpx 6 лет назад
Best channel on youtube.. Hands down..
@sebastianelytron8450
@sebastianelytron8450 6 лет назад
I searched for the "Hands down" channel, couldn't find it. Care to send me a link?
@kp2kpx
@kp2kpx 6 лет назад
ru-vid.com/show-UCssqLB2qVDmP-DvI5hIndfw
@AfterschoolPsychology
@AfterschoolPsychology 6 лет назад
Sebastian Elytron Looks like I'm gonna have to change my channel title
@Hans-tr6dx
@Hans-tr6dx 6 лет назад
yep I agree. together with Stefan Molyneux
@sebastianelytron8450
@sebastianelytron8450 6 лет назад
KP Singh Come on! Even TSOL is better than that channel. You seriously think that's the best?
@mariannaackerman6093
@mariannaackerman6093 5 лет назад
Another beautiful video by School of LIfe. I think these videos should be broadcast as public service announcements--I'm almost serious. As a practicing psychotherapist I see these as messages we need. Thank you!
@jasminehouston-burns1691
@jasminehouston-burns1691 4 года назад
I never had people to interact with. My mother was on drugs and my father was distant, angry, uninvolved. Recently I started AA and moved into a sober house. While I don't have a therapist, the work is extremely therapeutic. I believe I over-promise myself emotionally in some situations. While I can be very kind, and give people who need it really intense and intimate attention, I naturally find that I have my limits, and because I am unacustomed to taking my own space I find that when I need to close down I can snap shut and become mean or socially disoriented in other ways. I need to step back and really assess how much I can give, and also how I truly feel about how I'm being treated in the moment because I find that sometimes I actually feel disrespected, even if slightly, but respond by laughing or some form of approval. In trying to assess how I "truly" feel so that I can bring that to every conversation, I'm allowing myself to sulk, overreact, not care and just feel whatever those feelings are. This however does make me think of my deeper moments of meditation where I felt like I wanted to cocoon, to hold myself after sitting in the awareness of my fears. I might really allow myself to do that next time.
@19abhishekbanerjee
@19abhishekbanerjee 6 лет назад
School of life is very insightful indeed.
@lokisfriend
@lokisfriend 6 лет назад
While there are many good points here, boundaries must be put in place, lovingly but firmly. Allowing all these 'true self' actions many times violates others, for instance, screaming, biting, etc to another little one is not healthy for either. We live in a world with many other species and must be taught how to get along and not run roughshod over others. We see many children today brought up with this mentality of letting them do anything and they are beasts, pardon me, but we all have to learn that the world does not revolve around us and can be done so lovingly and before it finally dawns on us eventually.
@thierryhenryboudewijn6087
@thierryhenryboudewijn6087 Год назад
Beautiful! I immediately reverted back to my true self. Thank you, SOL.
@chriscorona1317
@chriscorona1317 6 лет назад
Best channel on youtube, hands down. Bless you all.
@jillbosonetto8230
@jillbosonetto8230 6 лет назад
How do we raise children with freedom to be and emote, but also teach them manners and boundaries? As in, you cannot hit others when you feel angry...
@Esbro
@Esbro 6 лет назад
Jill Bosonetto How it is said in this video there has to be a phase where he is allowed to do anything, it musnt have to be his entire childhood that would be spoiling. The kid must explore different feelings and emotions and it needs the help of the parents. There are people who couldnt be really angry and aggressive in their entire childhood. They learned that that was absolutely forbidden so they soaked that all in and made them unhappy in their adult life. Always keeping everything in and in makes you so unhappy ... Thats why kids must learn what it means to be aggressive, destructive and wild while its still possible. After you let them explore it you can teach them things like manners. First emotional education, than intellectual.
@jillbosonetto8230
@jillbosonetto8230 6 лет назад
Esbro, I understand. At what age or point does one switch from allowing the destructive and wild to teaching respect of others and boundaries do you think? I ask because I have little wild ones that SEEM perfectly spoiled. I'm trying to find boundaries myself, lol.
@Esbro
@Esbro 6 лет назад
Jill Bosonetto Well i guess there is a reason why therr wasnt an age named in this video too. I think it really depends on the child, the parents (that means you @_@) and the circumstances. Maybe it is the duty of the parents to observe the children and think for them while they cannot do it for themselves. It should be your duty and right to raise your child properly and that means you have to decide when you think the child is old or mature enough to be prepared for adulthood, thats what manners basically is.
@jillbosonetto8230
@jillbosonetto8230 6 лет назад
Esbro, thanks! Parenting sucks. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
@Esbro
@Esbro 6 лет назад
Jill Bosonetto Yeah but its better for the long term if you do :D You get happy when they are happy, you are proud for their first day at primary school, their first girlfriend, Graduation and job and so on.. If you dont make kids youre pretty alone with your money :( I read somewhere that money only makes happy if you spend it for other people (you love).
@theocruex
@theocruex 5 лет назад
"inwardly dead" nice. I just subscribed
@shelleywinters6763
@shelleywinters6763 3 года назад
Society doesn't allow us to be ourselves. Mostly at work I feel the most suppressed. They try to take advantage of that, then I have to do something without losing my temper. What ever I say I'm always the bad guy, even when they are doing something against the law.
@martin-3726
@martin-3726 6 лет назад
I love this channel it's so spot on and has helped me and my friends to understand and seek a better life for ourselves...
@jiminssmolhands5493
@jiminssmolhands5493 4 года назад
I just want to be feel loved and belonged I always get bullied for having a poor family:(
@preronabaruah4503
@preronabaruah4503 3 года назад
I'm sorry, love. You do belong in this world because you take up space in it everyday. Poverty has nothing to do with you but everything to do with robbers who are glorified in our society as CEOs. I hope you understand the strengths of the background you come from and look down on those who try to tell you otherwise.
@sophiapinkomg6343
@sophiapinkomg6343 4 года назад
I literally started crying while watching this because I relate to it so much. I feel like I have to be perfect and it's destroying me. And it really doesn't help when my mom praises me for being such a great child because that puts more pressure on me. So then when I do slip she thinks I've become a different person and gets way more upset at me than say my brother who has always been more of a trouble maker. I'm still a teenager, Can I turn this around?
@kalmarlajos7301
@kalmarlajos7301 Год назад
Girls are normally expected to be more compliant than boys, by society and parents. So, the chances are small that your mother will change her ways. Instead, you need to rely more heavily on yourself and summoning your own powers in this game we call call life and family : ) My two cents...
@leefart9690
@leefart9690 4 года назад
My moms been terminally ill my whole life. She blames me because she got worse from birthing me. When i would be unpleasant in any way as a kid, abuse would always follow. Not i have extreme trust issues. I feel like if i dont act how everyone else does ill litterally never be loved. Its lead me to be very erratic and wild with a bad crowd, and then minutes later quietly reading in a library.When im alone i find myself lull or as it put it "ineardly dead". I dont even trust my therapist. Ive been without emotional care for my whole life....I hope i can get better one day.
@snjmriguy1
@snjmriguy1 5 лет назад
Only mom was allowed to be the monster a child is supposed to be. She was a monster. It sucked the life out of me. This video makes so much sense. Thank you.
@flowmotion_2
@flowmotion_2 4 года назад
I don’t think anyone had the perfect childhood
@birdontheinternet
@birdontheinternet 3 года назад
Because the perfect person doesn't exist, so neither can the perfect parent
@sevenstoneplace7200
@sevenstoneplace7200 6 лет назад
So many of your videos end with therapy as the recommended course of action - but what about those of us who can't afford therapy, who don't have insurance and don't live in countries which support our mental health? what are we supposed to do? it was a good video but it makes me feel hopeless when the solutions presented to these problems I identify with are beyond my reach.
@BigHenFor
@BigHenFor 6 лет назад
Seven Stone Place Do your own therapy: 1) Practice staying present in the moment by practicing meditation or mindfulness techniques; 2) learn how to take care of yourself by acquiring habits that promote mental health and have other benefits too: regular exercise, eating healthily, sleeping enough, self-compassion, and journaling about your feelings in tandem with 1) will give you added capacity to withstand stress. 3) be discerning about what company you keep - sometimes the fear of loneliness can lead us to tolerate people who are simply not good for us. Avoid people who are narcissistic and don't have the patience or kindness to be good friends. If they disturb your peace of mind, make you feel anxious, or uncomfortable, stay away from them. 4) remember to have some fun regularly - reward yourself for hard work and goals you have achieved by doing something that makes you smile. This doesn't have to be expensive in time or money, but it should make you smile. Moreover, you'll be more relaxed and less stressed; 5) give up trying to control others or events - you can only control yourself. 6) Be grateful - even the poorest of us has things they can be grateful for, but sometimes we forget our blessings. A daily gratitude list in your journal will pay dividends. 7) Curate your exposure to the media - the TV and social media can waste a lot of time and expose you to people and ideas that aren't healthy for you. The news especially can present a distorted view of the world in order to get people watching it. Avoid or limit your consumption by being very selective about what you watch. There's a reason why Silicon Valley CEOs denied their children use of social media, and the scandals around it suggest that it should be treated with caution. 8) Don't be afraid to ask for help. If you can, develop a network of people you can trust to talk to. A good listener is worth their weight in gold. 9) Read self-help and motivational books. Programme your mind for success. We all stand on the shoulders of giants, and it is sensible to learn the habits of successful people. These are some of the things you can do. Take your own life into your hands and learn to live a good life.
@VictorYamaykin
@VictorYamaykin 6 лет назад
I second the importance of finding a trusted, active listener (anyone even a bartender or barber maybe?) who reflect back what they heard and help you sort out your own thoughts, feelings, desires, goals, dreams, etc. by hearing you out. Writing helps sometimes but talking it out with someone over coffee can too
@KimberlyLetsGo
@KimberlyLetsGo 5 лет назад
That has to be a very difficult position to be in and would make most feel helpless. Have you considered seeking out books that may provide you with insightful thoughts? That's what I did a lot of when I was much younger and couldn't afford counseling. Hopefully there is a library close to you so the investment would be practically nothing. Books by John Bradshaw may be a good place to start. I learned a lot from them.
@crisissocoylike
@crisissocoylike 5 лет назад
Hey-o, spagetti-o! If you're in the USA, usually you can get a therapist via Medicaid if you currently have low monthly income. www.betterhelp.com/ is also a good low cost alternative, for therapy, if you have to pay for it.
@mariannaackerman6093
@mariannaackerman6093 5 лет назад
I think you raise a very valid point and I don't know the answer. There's something called "Co-counselling" in some countries which is free and done within a context of emotional safety, but it's not the same as having psychotherapy. I guess School of Life isn't there to address all the problems--their mission seems to be in part to educate people about the need for therapy, but you raise a really significant problem, which is that it's often only available to those with money. I'm sorry it's a problem for you, truly.
@renzmariongavino2454
@renzmariongavino2454 2 года назад
Thank you School of Life for making easy for people to understand these concepts!
@Prabash_Prabhu
@Prabash_Prabhu 6 лет назад
I go to therapy every week and get everything off my chest. It has helped a lot. Before therapy I would keep everything bottled in and refuse to cry and remain stoic. Now I see that my emotions are trying to tell me something and that I should "feel" me emotions which allows me to then analyse them with clarity and rational. It's hard being your true self as an adult so the therapists office helps alot
@AFord1981
@AFord1981 6 лет назад
So 'Hell is other people', essentially?
@pattycake5643
@pattycake5643 6 лет назад
Adam Ford hell is what you say your life is by letting others be the director. I like the saying "life is a stage and we all think we are the stars." we make people the stars like the astanouts or our favorite singers. You are the star, now go out and shine bright, you shinning star.
@pattycake5643
@pattycake5643 6 лет назад
number1mumisme that was interesting.
@kateshungi8945
@kateshungi8945 6 лет назад
Yeah no exit
@sometime.somewhere
@sometime.somewhere 6 лет назад
And in that way I guess we can all contribute to other people's heaven...or hell. Hell is also the absence of people too... In that way can there be a heVen?
@BigHenFor
@BigHenFor 6 лет назад
Adam Ford No, hell is our perception of what is outside of us and our control. We often see the world as we are, not how it is. A change of attitude through reframing our situation, can bring change and kickstart progress.
@snsmystic
@snsmystic 2 года назад
I don't believe this video suggests that children should be pampered and run wild, and should be taught and learn self-discipline. However, I do believe this deals with "parentification" where the children learn to suppress their valid needs in order to help manage the stress and anxiety of their caregivers. They become people-pleasers or covert or overt narcissists.
@miamina2235
@miamina2235 5 лет назад
Therapy would ideally be like that but the mental health system we live in trains therapists to diagnose every patient they have, and prescribe them medicine or send them to a psychiatrist to get medicine when they no longer feel they are able to handle their patient. Very few therapists are actually willingly to allow the patient be their true self.
Далее
Becoming Your True Self - The Psychology of Carl Jung
15:20
where is the ball to play this?😳⚽
00:13
Просмотров 8 млн
The Role of the False Self in Narcissism
13:27
Просмотров 23 тыс.
The Terror of Being Alone
11:13
Просмотров 512 тыс.
12 signs you might be suffering from PTSD
8:14
Просмотров 6 млн
Who Am I?
7:47
Просмотров 3,9 млн
On Being Out of Touch With One's Feelings
7:21
Просмотров 1 млн
A Test to Judge How Good Your Parents Were
7:37
Просмотров 6 млн
How Repressed Emotions Make Us Sick
4:20
Просмотров 1 млн