The Truth About Tonewood: 52 Years of Experience | w. Roger Sadowsky

Подписаться 21 тыс.

Просмотров 15 тыс.

50% 1

Join Roger Sadowsky, founder of Sadowsky Guitars, as he explores the significant influence of wood on the sound of solidbody instruments. Drawing on his 52 years of experience, Roger argues against the common belief that wood has no effect on the sound of electric guitars and basses. He explains how different types of wood, particularly in the fretboard, affect the tonal quality and playability of an instrument. Whether you prefer the bright, tight sound of a maple fretboard or the warm, sweet tones of rosewood, Roger provides valuable insights to help you understand how wood choice shapes the voice of your instrument. Roger shares anecdotes from his extensive career, including how fingerboard materials have solved specific tonal problems for top session players. He emphasises that the differences are more about what the player feels and hears than what the audience perceives, and how this affects the player's touch and style. This video is a must for anyone interested in the nuances of guitar and bass construction. Tune in to explore the world of wood and sound with one of the most respected luthiers in the business.
Get your German made Sadowsky bass here:
Sadowsky Custom Shop - shop.warwick.de/en/instrument...
Sadowsky MasterBuilt - shop.warwick.de/en/instrument...
Sadowsky MetroLine - shop.warwick.de/en/instrument...
Find the Sadowsky MetroExpress models (made in Asia) here: shop.warwick.de/en/instrument...
Get your Sadowsky pickups here: shop.warwick.de/de/search?sSe...
Order your Sadowsky Preamp here: shop.warwick.de/en/pickups/ac...
Order your Warwick GNOME amps and cabs here: shop.warwick.de/de/search?sSe...
Or check your local dealer for availability.
www.sadowskybass.com
/ sadowskybasses
/ sadowskybassgermany
#SadowskyBass #bass #sadowsky #rogersadowsky #roger #tonewood #tonewooddebate #guitar

Видеоклипы

Опубликовано:

21 июн 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 136

@polarbear3427 14 дней назад

best insight: it doesn't matter for the audience, but esp. for the player.

@Themonist 6 дней назад

Then doesn't matter.

@maxsalasr 10 дней назад

I don't have 50yrs of experience, but what Roger kindly shares is what I can hear too. What matters the most is what the player hears, more than what others do. Great phrase and very true! The relationship with the instrument brings out emotions and indeed the player feels what is playing more deeply ❤

@gringogreen4719 11 дней назад

Thank you for sharing this with us.😎👍✨

@geekguitars 13 дней назад

Thank you Mr. Sadowsky!!

@Barry101er 14 дней назад

Thanks, Roger!

@fenderlead1 12 дней назад

At 4:10.. bingo! It doesn’t matter if the listener can’t tell the difference, if the player can and he’s not bonding with the instrument it can affect his playing. Thank you Mr. Sadowsky.

@stringtheoryx 11 дней назад

Very nicely presented, Roger! I've seen too many beginners that insist that they can't hear any differences in any type of bodies or fretboards. I believe that they can't. The problem arises when they flame anyone who actually has experience and good ears. I also agree with the point that the sonic differences and 'feel' of the instrument make a huge difference in touch, and how an experienced musician will play. Someone at the back of the room may not be able to distinguish alder from swamp ash, but they certainly should be able to tell differences in the players' approach.

@FrancisFurtak 11 дней назад

Finally a no nonsense video, no unboxing or a lot of BS. Roger just tells it like it is! Thanks Roger!

@mikegrosser8861 14 дней назад

thanks Roger good to see you, looking good!

@georgesims6484 14 дней назад

ROGER IS ABSOLUTELY CORRECT!

@BluesyKat 14 дней назад

Very informative, thanks Roger! 😍

@theNextProject 11 дней назад

Very interesting video, thank you for the presentation. I like your ending takeaway "it's what the player hears..." so true.

@477bus 14 дней назад

I started playing bass in '67 and have owned many brands and configurations. When I bought a Sadowsky in 2006 I stopped trying other brands and have picked up snippets from Roger over the years and in the Talkbass forum from him. Great to see the recent collection of videos where you can get all the true facts in one place. There's so much crap on RU-vid now. Trust this bloke.

@mortonwilson795 13 дней назад

Terrific, Roger - agree 100%. I know you're mainly addressing bass guitars but as a guitar player I came to the same conclusions many years ago. My '68 Custom Ebony board, FGN Roland '81 Strat w Maple board and my preference these last few years for Strats with Rosewood have made it all pretty clear to me in the studio. They all have a place - no 'favourites' per se - it comes down to the track, really. Thanks for the clear overview - I guess the debates will continue.

14 дней назад

Amen Roger!

@lronne 11 дней назад

Tell 'em, Roger! ❤

@haytguugle8656 11 дней назад

Thanks for your sage advice. Going back to '79, when I bought my very first real quality guitar, LP Gold Top (brand new '78), I chose it after playing it a while and listening to it - not having plugged it in AT ALL the whole time. Not kidding. Once I found one that felt good, I (uncomfortably) pressed my ear down on the shoulder and listened to the (wait for it) GUITAR. Not the pickups. not the tone knobs. The wood. The instrument. When I found one where all the notes rang even and true, and chords were clear and sounded all the notes together with sounding mushed or mixed, then I checked the neck (3-piece maple [loved it]) and made sure everything else was in order, I ended up with one of my favorite guitars I've ever owned. Great tone, Even note balance. Enjoyable sustain............. Every guitar or bass I've ever bought or built since then had to pass that test before I have ever considered anything about the electronics. The sparky stuff has massive affect on the output sound, for sure. But you have to start with the instrument first. IT has to be right first. I won't do it any other way. 🙂

@PaulChaney 12 дней назад

You are too humble, sir. As the proud owner of a Sadowsky Metroexpress, I take your words as gospel. And I 100% agree with your assertions about the fingerboard tones.

@robertthompson6302 14 дней назад

My sentiments exactly as a player

@truescotsman4103 6 дней назад

Seasoned guitarist that are musicians know this. People that deny it just want it to be false. The difference between maple and rosewood is very noticeable. Mahogany and Ash are completely different when used in a body. A maple stave compared to a mahogany stave will make the neck sound different. I like Maple, Ebony, Alder, Swamp Ash, and Mahogany. These are the woods that get the sounds that I like. Poplar is horrible. Some cuts of Mahogany used in a body will create a hollow sounding bloom in the body which I can't stand. I like a body that mutes the mids and the bottom and has a ton of mids and sustain. Thank you for making this video. Mahogany, Alder and Swamp ash all accomplish this to different degrees. Mahogany mutes the mids and overall resonance most it attenuates the sound best and sounds super sweet and balanced. Alder has a growl to it and is more open sounding with more volume than Mahogany. Swamp Ash cuts and has good balance across the frequencies and it's a little honky and has a lot of snap and attack.

@haytguugle8656 11 дней назад

Second comment; I remember the first time I heard the name; "Roger Sadowsky". It was in early '82. I was working as a tech for a (then) up-and-coming guitarist no one had yet heard of. He got connected with a similarly rising singer/songwriter. As part of the record deal, some new gear was purchased. One, a 50's gold top Les Paul. I remember being told it was a '52 but it was certainly a few years after that. I believe it was purchased at Styvesant Music on 48th St. (I could be not remembering that part correctly). It had humbuckers, and the bridge/tailpiece was original. Big, chunky neck and sounded great. But; it somehow had super-tiny frets! We joked they must be banjo frets! So it needed refretting and complete set-up. This is the part where Mr. Sadowsky comes into the picture. When we got the guitar back, it couldn't have been better. It really was a gem. And though I, personally, never had need of further business with Mr. Sadowsky, his was a name in the industry I never forgot, and mentioned often.

@basstor1 11 дней назад

I´ve had an Alembic Europa 5 for many years. Ebony fingerboard, multi laminate neck through of maple and purleheart, mahogany body wings with maple top. Lovely bass! Some years ago I bought another Alembic. Same pickups and electronics, same construction, and I was expecting it to sound the same as the Europa. But it didn´t. It had a much brighter sound. I found this strange since it was the same bass. But after some investigations I found out that it had maple body wings instead of mahogany. And it made a lot of difference! It must be said that the pickups on Alembic are a bit microphonic and are screwed tight to the body without any springs, and thus make a more solid connection with the body.

@TheRainmanBachelor 14 дней назад

Roger do you find this difference to be less given our recent use of roasted woods?

@lostinpa-dadenduro7555 12 дней назад

I think everything adds up together. The wood, bridge type, pickups, strings, etc. If you play long enough you’ll find the combination you like that feels and sounds good to you.

@CardinalPhonics 10 дней назад

The sound of a string vibrating causing pressure waves in the air that we can hear is different from the sound that is produced by a conductive material creating eddy currents in an inductor (electromagnetic pickups) sent through a length of cable and then amplified, filtered, amplified again and finally transduced through a speaker. While both of these are sounds, they are derived from entirely different processes that don’t have very much at all to do with each other.

@mikedoolin9930 11 дней назад

I'm with ya Roger. I once built myself a solid body LP style with an ebony fretboard. I played one gig with it and absolutely hated it. Replaced it with Indian rosewood, loved it, played the guitar for years. Ever since I always use rosewood on electric guitars. On acoustic guitars I think it's too much, so there I use ebony or even better African blackwood. Anyway, I've been telling people for many years that it's pretty much all about the fretboard wood, and practically nobody believes me. Maybe if I tell them you said so too, they will!

@zachjones1716 13 дней назад

10/10 agree, I like the look of rosewood and that's what my first bass was, but after playing more basses I have grown to like the sound of maple. I've heard maple described as kinda scooped too

@r.l.rachel740 14 дней назад

Thank You for sharing your life long luthier experiences. The bass community values your insights & appreciates your dedication. ❤

@ib6903 12 дней назад

What’s the song on the outro?!

@joannalewis5279 14 дней назад

This really makes sense and it's very individual to the person and the instrument even though in general this is all right

@jerrymckenzie1858 13 дней назад

Well said sir!

@cd0u50c9 11 дней назад

This topic will never be settled. There could be two maple fingerboards out there that sound more different than a maple and a rosewood one by comparison; two exactly the same J basses by design might sound and feel completely different due to the properties of the wood. When we say wood makes a difference, I've for some time believed it's the material's density, moisture content and make-up, rather than the differences being due to species of wood. I do agree that the key factor that matters is how the player perceives the instrument!

@michaelmenkes7233 9 дней назад

Bass in particular is sensitive to tonewood. IMO the bass midrange is in the same resonant frequencies as are predominant in the woods. Roger's observations are very similar to my own. The better the bridge, as well, the better the relationship between strings and wood. This is why the Leo Kwan Badass bridge became the archetype replacement bridge. Heavy brass plate and heavy duty saddles. Don't overlook the composition of the saddles either. Brass seems to give me more of that growl from the wood than steel.

@milkovic07 13 дней назад

I'd say you can hear a bigger difference between body woods with a maple fretboard. Ash always sounds more firm and compressed to me than alder. Alder sounds like it has more lower mids and rounder bass and treble. I never could understand people saying it doesn't make a difference. To me it makes the most difference because the pickups no matter how they're wound will amplify natural frequencies of the bass. Also I think, with and without the graphite neck reinforcements, a huge difference in tone can be heard. There is a lot more of attack and faster response with a graphite rod, makes the bass sound much more modern. My favourite setup is swamp ash body and a rosewood neck, I feel it gives a nice tight tone and fits into most situations. Just my opinion.

@oldgoattheantichrist3468 13 дней назад

I believe the more important point is good guitars sound good acoustically and they resonate. From switching necks on Stratocaters I have also noticed that rosewood and maple boards have fairly significant impact on overall tone. Roasted Maple also brings more brightness to the table. I think any of us that have made partscasters can agree on these things, though I have a couple of 9lbs Strats from the 70's that sound amazing.The amplifier is still #1 as far as tone goes though. Even Stevie Ray couldnt make a Deluxe Reverb sound like a Marshall or a VOX or an Orange.

@fredeagle3912 11 дней назад

How does the guitar ring on or resonate? That will be reproduced by the pick up. I’ve played dead sounding guitars, they should be avoided. Otherwise the amp with all the buttons give you different sounds. Pickups are just magnets and wire. A magnet is just a magnet any way you look at it.

@byronmarsh1352 12 дней назад

What the player *feels* is what matters. I don't think you'll ever hear a difference playing with a band or on a recording that you couldn't do with EQ. Feeling is everything to the player and their performance.

@hotdotdog 13 дней назад

Yes Roger. All of those things can make a difference. I think the biggest reason for the disparity in this argument is the individual human ear. We are not born knowing the difference between the sound of a plate hitting the floor and a set of keys hitting the floor. We had to learn that. 52 years of listening has educated your ear to a much higher level than musician who has been playing for a comparatively short while. My musical mantra is "All you hear is not all there is to hear". When someone tells tells me they can't hear the difference, I tell them "You mean you can't hear the difference yet."

@roberttower8059 12 дней назад

I am blown away by your mantra! That is great! I am going to remember that one.

@crucifixgym 12 дней назад

It’s true, the ear is just the transducer of the ear-brain system. When the brain is lacking, the hearing has more learning to do. This is the entire fundamental concept behind audio engineering, to name just one extremely critical field within the music industry.

@TheAquabatix 14 дней назад

Great explanation. Thanks for what you have done for the bass community.

@danielbarbieri8199 13 дней назад

This is simply a physical phenomenon, called sympathetic resonance. This is how acoustic guitars work, but it also applies to electric guitars. To a certainly smaller extent, but not insignificant.

@becketcolon9013 13 дней назад

It's all about the wood, Each piece has natural frequencies that either excite the strings via sympathetic vibration, amplifying and prolonging the strings vibrations or the wood dampens the vibrations and mutes the strings. This is what Paul Reed Smith refers to when he says a good guitar rings for 45 seconds and a bad guitar for 15. Wood of the same species varies from tree to tree. You need to test each piece acoustically.

@finintuk 14 дней назад

What is being described sounds like it could be easily tested with an oscilloscope. I'm more inclined to think wood has an effect on bass than guitar because the lower frequencies are closer to the natural resonance of the woods. That said, an EQ can sculpt the sound way more than having multiple basses so maybe only the sustain is the relevant quality here?

@jomamma1750 13 дней назад

The lower frequencies travel much more slowly through the wood than higher frequencies. This is why bassists are all about the woods, and guitarists are all about the signal processing.

@mikedoolin9930 11 дней назад

The best electronic measurement tools can't detect the subtleties the human ear and brain can. That's why this will always be a subjective discussion.

@doctor_mav8 10 дней назад

Tl;dr: Tonewood isn't perceived with your ears, it's perceived with your heart.

@LairdDavidson 12 дней назад

Interesting and what is said might be correct. However a demonstration using measuring tools and sound samples is what is needed to convince me. Demonstrate how an alder body sounds different to a poplar one, a maple fingerboard sounds different to a rosewood one all other things being equal for example.

@jonathonmcmillan9410 11 дней назад

Do your own work. It's not hard.

@Rory-co4vm 11 дней назад

@@jonathonmcmillan9410it costs money and time. I think it’s much more appropriate for the salesman to prove their wares right?

@migueltrapezaris6437 9 дней назад

If I listen carefully I can tell the difference between my alder and my swamp ash bass. It makes no difference however when I have 3 layers of distortion on, in a dodgy venue with a crappy PA and a crackhead behind the console, which is all I seem to play these days it seems (shocking for crust punk/hardcore, I know)

@fredgonzalez6619 14 дней назад

Man, I love this video Mr. Sadowsky!!!

@robwebber1217 14 дней назад

I've yet to see anyone pick them out in a blind test.

@Mikey__R 13 дней назад

In my experience, tone is really for the player, not necessarily for the listener. I've played some basses that "feel" laid back, some that "feel" more alive and immediate. I've no doubt the physical properties of the materials are a big part of the difference. Saying that, I honestly don't know if I could pick out a maple board from a rosewood board if I was playing blindfolded.

@hansemannluchter643 13 дней назад

"Blind tests are flawed"!!! Anyone can see, sorry hear, that gold-cables sound "warmer" than silver-cables!!

@blastmanutz7798 11 дней назад

As I always say, people who think wood doesn't matter fall into one of these two categories: 1. Lacking experience 2. Simply cannot hear the difference (again lack of experience with sound analysis, or just simply lacking an ear or hearing skills)

@ileutur6863 13 дней назад

Some random everyday person on youtube: does blind soundtests, swaps parts, gives frequency charts Gutar brands with big budgets: umm believe us cause we say so

@cooljp1531 13 дней назад

I used to change strings every 3 days because they would start to sound dull after playing them for 3 days ( only an hour a day ). So WTF are you people talking about. Just some sweat on the strings makes a difference after a few days. Even that Glen dude in string tests said how bad some expensive strings sounded then in the following video proceeds to say how nothing on a guitar makes a difference ( WTF ). Everything makes some difference. The problem is most of you are deaf and in the mix some things make a lot of difference and some very little, but everything makes a difference. Just changing picks while playing will produce different sounds which anybody can hear while playing, but probably not in the mix. In order of importance, sure just work it backwards, speakers, amp, guitar, guitar parts, etc.... which usually makes the most difference And by the way Sadowsky has swapped probably a 1000+ body parts more than some stupid youtuber hunting for clicks

@deanallen927 13 дней назад

He hand makes some of the fines instruments in the world - you don't. Unlike you, he does and has done more than just "say so".

@ileutur6863 11 дней назад

@@cooljp1531 still just word of mouth

@ileutur6863 11 дней назад

@@deanallen927 You don't have to be a chef to know when the eggs are overcooked

@deanallen927 11 дней назад

@@ileutur6863 Fine - go eat your guitar.

@hakanaxlund4316 13 дней назад

Thank you for a humble and balanced opinion shared.

@NelsonMontana1234 13 дней назад

Of course.

@LysanderLH 14 дней назад

Okay, so do the thing that nobody has yet done and measure the tonal differences of the woods and show them. Then do the other thing that nobody has yet done and blindfold test several independant players and listeners

@italoop7850 13 дней назад

YOU should do that...

@LysanderLH 13 дней назад

@@italoop7850 Am I the person making claims about the effects of different woods on what anyone can hear, especially when a solid bodied guitar with pickups is amplified? So who is responsible for proving that it even exists?

@lordgraga 13 дней назад

Warmoth has tons of videos along these lines.

@t23c56 13 дней назад

Jim Lill

@LysanderLH 13 дней назад

@@lordgraga guessing they proved themselves right. shock!

@Calbertone 14 дней назад

I wonder if the material of the neck in addition to the fingerboard also makes a difference

@SadowskyGuitars 13 дней назад

Of course it does

@jcsk8 14 дней назад

That´s what we need. Experience! I´m tired of people saying wood won´t matter but it does. And 4:00 is the most important point!

@jomamma1750 13 дней назад

I agree in part. In my opinion you're 100% right about the boards. However, it's been my experience as a player/builder that the bodywood has a significant effect on the sound as well. While I hear a tremendous difference between bodywood species, I've always felt that the single most important characteristic of a body is its overall resonance. For example: as much as I love the sound of Alder or Mahogany, I'd pick a highly resonant piece of Ash over a more "normally" resonant piece of the other two. Anyway, that's what my ears tell me after 35 or 40 years of playing. P.S. your basses ROCK!! They're awesome axes, thanks.

@stevepelham9010 13 дней назад

Yes there are differences.after about 40 guitars "Mahogany" Is my choice of wood and a Rosewood fretboard. But hey as to talk about such things with an nay sayer will be all the same as to talk food and drink with an Hill Billy.

@hannovor 14 дней назад

👍👍👏👏🙏🙏

@katfishrick1600 13 дней назад

I'm convinced that anyone who really believes that fretboard wood doesn't make a difference in tone and feel is probably suffering from significant hearing loss. Or is just a contrarian.

@alittlebitgone 12 дней назад

Cool, listen to them blindfolded and pick which is which. I'll wait.

@katfishrick1600 11 дней назад

@@alittlebitgonethat has been done many times, troll.

@hansemannluchter643 13 дней назад

"I feel very strongly....". OK, that proves it, case closed.

@fretbuzz59 13 дней назад

But you left off: "... after 52 years of experience (I feel very strongly) ..." This isn't a gut feeling.

@toliskoskinas 13 дней назад

after 52 years making great guitars seems that his feeling is way more important than your comment.

@wildersparks9161 13 дней назад

@@toliskoskinasnah, he has too much at stake in the myth of tonewood.

@deanallen927 13 дней назад

He makes some of the world's finest instruments by hand. You're right, case closed.

@3rdmm 13 дней назад

Every other company agrees with him. So, yes.

@Gk2003m 13 дней назад

I don’t think anyone is claiming outright that wood in solidbody instruments has zero effect on sound. I think the claim is that the effect is negligible compared to that of the strings and the electronics. Where wood, and/or build method, can most affect the sound is in sustain and ‘aliveness’. For example, a neck joint that is less than top-notch will reduce both of those qualities. And a hard maple neck will preserve a brighter tone than a neck made of more absorbent wood. Body wood is probably the least important part of the overall tone of the instrument.

@DoodlezMusic 11 дней назад

Correct, tone wood has barely any meaning for solid bodies as almost 95% of the tone comes from electronics, even more so for active instruments and electric guitars with distortion. The biggest difference in tone you'll get is from Pots, pickups, and especially pickup placement (example, 60s vs 70s jazz basses)

@paultraynorbsc627 14 дней назад

Thanks for Sharing 🎶🎵🎸

@johncat8347 13 дней назад

I was A scension player for 52 years I agree with you young people have to trust the gray hair

@humblegeorge 14 дней назад

I agree !

@sinakaedwards2009 13 дней назад

I am really impressed with Roger's ability to explain with his knowledge the differences. I am now a subscriber. Was wondering if the Precision style body sounds different than the Jazz style body if pickups and wood are the same? Only difference is the shape of the body.

@avital2166 14 дней назад

❤👌👌👌

@vodekz1534 13 дней назад

Great words, I have one of your sweet basses. Great quality

@hushpuppykl 14 дней назад

It does not affect the tone? Guess they never played a '78 Jazz Bass with rosewood and maple fingerboards. 😂

@lucmichel7588 14 дней назад

👍👌

@DaveyDeSade 13 дней назад

Feelings vs. science

@erikkrogen335 14 дней назад

👍👌😎

@Themonist 6 дней назад

So, if no one can feel it it doesn't matter. Let's be honest.

@4stringsloneliness 3 дня назад

You forgot about players should can play. There is no difference between wood if you can't play bass.

@thorugs2816 14 дней назад

Yep

@mollirodhaet7224 7 дней назад

100% Rosewood oils dampen most.

@AgentDaleCooper482 13 дней назад

Just compare an aluminium guitar with a wooden guitar and you'll here a very stark difference. The strings interact with the vibration of the body and that has an effect on the signal the pickups "pick up"... Is this something to fetishize about? No, but this man is still right.

@apPLAUd113 13 дней назад

of course different woods affect the tone of the bass! and we all also know that different woods has no effect on the tone of electric guitars!

@richardmetzler7909 12 дней назад

Blind test or it didn't happen 🙄

@jhref 11 дней назад

Blind test it

@jari04 14 дней назад

In my opinion, this video is the end of that discussion.

@mortonwilson795 13 дней назад

Amen to that! 😀

@jason.braatz 13 дней назад

The video that ended this discussion was Jim Lill's.

@wildersparks9161 13 дней назад

Lmfao no

@lumberlikwidator8863 12 дней назад

Audiologists will tell you that no one has ever heard the sound of their own voice, because the sound is colored by the bones of the skull. If you listen to a recording of your voice the sound is distorted and colored by the recording and playback equipment. So the tonewood debate is settled. The reason some people can’t hear the difference between maple and mahogany is the very thick bones of their skull.

@howheels 13 дней назад

Tone is stored in the balls

@WowIndescribable 13 дней назад

Cognitive bias, for the win.

@escargotomy 13 дней назад

It's funny to sift through a decade of know-it-alls with their home-brewed sham science experiments and pronouncements. They usually all end their videos by insulting the viewers intelligence, "if you don't believe me you're stupid". And here's the real deal guy saying "here's what I've heard with my ears, but make your own decision". Well, give me the real deal 24/7 over the low life RU-vid influencer. Thank sir, for sharing your expertise.