Ik I am late to the party... but GOD DAYUUUUM BRO... I AM NOT EVEN JOKING... THIS IS ACTUALLY KIND OF BETTER THAN STRANGE MAN VIDEOS... AND I THOUGHT HE WAS TOP... The Editing hits harder than an Arabian Horse kick to the balls... keep it up... am pretty sure you got a plan... (I hope it ain't tahiti tho)
Arthur is a prisoner to loyalty. He can't stop being loyal to people, even if he know they are or were bad. His father was a bad person and he knew it. He'll talk shit about his father if he gets an opportunity to do so but he'll also keep a picture of him next to his bed and wear his hat.
I want rdr3 about him. Especially him trying to be a good father after being in a gang and trying to stop Arthur from joining Dutch and ultimately failing. Meaning, Arthur is wrong about his dad
Exactly what I thought! It would fit rdrs theme of the protagonist dying you could have him shot infront of Arthur or something and have the epilogue as Arthur young.
I think it should be a game where you play as both Arthur and Jack. Showing the parallels of their life. You play as Jack as a 1920s mobster while he flips through Arthur’s journal, as he’s reading Arthur’s entries, you play as young Arthur before the events of RDR2. Therefore RDR 3 allows us to move forward in time, but not lose the Wild West aspect fully.
I think it should be about Lyle Morgan and his struggle with a gang and the leader being an influencer like Dutch. It should be about Lyles struggle with knowing he should be taking care of his son, but this Dutch influencer type is making him have the gang come first. Then Lyles redemption at the end is the gang is about to get a huge score, so Lyle is going to take this money and leave with his son and the leader of the gang turns on Lyle for wanting to leave, so the gang gets Lyle caught and that's why he hangs. Arthur didn't know what happened, he just thinks he selfish. Then boom epilogue is Arthur getting into the gang with Dutch or somewhere around there.
In theory it sounds good, but in practice, how would that work really? We play as a character that we know will be hung at the end of the story? I could just see Rockstar shoehorning in some “twist” of having Dutch setting up Lyle to get caught/hung to get Arthur to himself. And I think that would be dumb as hell.
It doesn’t ruin it at all knowing what the end will be, that’s something that’s been done many times really well. It’s about how it ended up like that. I really couldn’t picture them putting Dutch in as a twist setting him up to get Arthur as a minion though, that’d be a bit ridiculous&would ruin it rofl. But then again, with so many movies, shows, &games trying to make “shocking” plot twists&tie things in way too hard, I also wouldn’t be completely surprised… I think it’d be a great game honestly if they stick to what makes Red Dead Redemption what it is. If it is about Lyle, it’d be sweet if it’s not gang oriented but instead has Lyle as a loner that sometimes falls in with a crew to do a big job or something. Besides that just him going through it on his own whether he just doesn’t like people or because he’s so withdrawn from Beatrice passing.
I they should do red dead 3 about this guy maybe meet Arthur’s son, whatever happens I don’t wanna see what happened in black water yet or play as jack
Arthur's son was killed as a baby with his son's mother. Also the west ended around 1915s, right when Jack was in his late teens early 20s the west was over. Rdr1 takes place in 1911 and Jack is 14 think then, close to that anyways.
I think it should be about Lyle Morgan and his struggle with a gang and the leader being an influencer like Dutch. It should be about Lyles struggle with knowing he should be taking care of his son, but this Dutch influencer type is making him have the gang come first. Then Lyles redemption at the end is the gang is about to get a huge score, so Lyle is going to take this money and leave with his son and the leader of the gang turns on Lyle for wanting to leave, so the gang gets Lyle caught and that's why he hangs. Arthur didn't know what happened, he just thinks he selfish. Then boom epilogue is Arthur getting into the gang with Dutch or somewhere around there.
I wonder if the hat Lyle Morgan wears was given to him by Arthur's mother and that is why he keeps it. Its seems to be a common hat from it appearing in the Valentine shop, so maybe Arthur's mother liked it while shopping and gave it to her husband Lyle.
You should make a video about what micah has been up to in the years between the red dead redemption mission and American venom and how he got this big of a gang that we saw when scaling mount hagen, btw if you remember me I've watched you both for a long time and congrats on all the success you deserve it❤️
A Red Dead Game in the 1860s through 70s. A time of reconstruction after the Civil war with the early stages of the Leymone Raiders to the struggle between the US army and the Wapiti people!? ROCKSTAR PLEASE!!! I’d pay good money for that!
I’d love to give Lyle his own game but I’d rather have us play as Mac and start the story off with him and his brother joining Dutch’s game. We can than get more Arthur and John when they were younger and probably the golden years of the gang. End it with the botched ferry job in blackwater so we can see what really went down, we can even see Micah and Charles joining the game near the end. We can do time skips of course. And end it with a epilogue playing as Mac escaping after getting badly injured, Milton says they caught up with him and ended him mercifully but I bet Milton lied to piss off Arthur to draw his gun or get Dutch to do some revenge mission against the pinkertons and Milton. But I can see Mac surviving and turning a new leaf since he nearly died and lost his brother. I hope we get Mac’s game honestly since Uncle described him as a badass, Ruthless but at the same time had a good heart. So perfect for a protagonist to play as since we can choose to do low honor or high. Lyle seems like he’s just low honor with no high honor about him at all. So would be weird to do high honor stuff with Lyle and we already know how he dies. No way getting around getting hanged in front of town square
Hey man, I know you prob don’t remember me, but I was one of the first subscribers on this channel, anyways I just wanted to apologize for not watching any of your vids for a while. And congrats on the channel growth
My belief is that Arthur kept Lyles Hat for the following reasons, he kept it to mock him in a way, like "im better then you ever will be you bastard" and the second reason he just liked the hat
Arthur has a strong sense of loyalty&misplaced affection it seems. He always tried seeing people in the best light, barring very few people that really didn’t have any good.
I don't know what I feel about a game that takes place in the height of Wild West. Red Dead Redemption has been about the fall of the Wild West so it feels odd to have the next game at the peak of Wild West times.
Some people say if a rdr3 comes out is about how the gang met or jack story but now I saw arthur father and remembered him on arthur wagon as a pic, but I think if a rdr3 would be the story of arthur father but still with honor ranking the low one should be the hang one which it's at the town and gettin humiliated and the high one getting shoot at the stomach or chest and looking at young arthur until his last breath and he gives his hat for continuing the morgan legacy even if arthur hated him he still had a spot for his father
Long story but it is relevant to you`re comments. One day i was visiting one of my elemantry school teachers beacause at the elemantry school beacause my high school is done earlier and i was takling with her about rdr2 and the final mission with Arthur and she said that she doesn`t play video games bit if that was a book she would read it so i am currently working on a red dead revolver book a rdr1 book and a rdr2 book that i will mail to her beacause she works at a different school now. I don`t know how yet but i could try to give you for free copies of the book when its done if you`re intrested.
I heard rumors of a deeper story for Jack Marston joining the military, and then he raises a son? I honestly don't want to see either than or a story about Lyle Morgan. I would like to see a story of a Buffalo soldier with PTSD, creating a gang or bounty hunting squad with his former fellow soldiers.
That game sits well with my childhood because of all the bullshit I had to go through with my family members. I understand why he keeps that he keeps the hat to remind himself of where he came from, even if he does lose himself and his dad’s ways
for the rdr3 lye idea I say section 1 be as we play through a small section with Lyle, rob a train, kill some lawmen, maybe top off the end with robbing the bank of a alive prospering town of Tumbleweed. Then we shift to young arthur, as the bank robbery went poor on the escape and Lyle gets hung within our first mission with young Arthur. Shortly after we fall in with Dutch and then we get a new timeskip to when Arthur is around 28. We miss out on characters like Sadie, Charles, Lenny, and Micah. But we can be introduced properly to characters like Mac, Davey, and maybe even that one unnamed rat gang member Arthur mentions to tilly in an optional dominos game. End it off with how the Van Der Linde gang robbed banks when they were succesful with the gang robbing and securing the money from the same bank Lyle tried to rob with his small gang around 15 years ago. Then for the epilogue you could just swap through playing as Lyle before he had arthur or arthur after the bank robbery
What if Dutch knew Lyle and was a good friend of his. Before Lyle dies he makes Dutch promises to take care of his boy. We play as Dutch in the epilogue and he finally finds Arthur(Arthur ran away during his father’s hanging) and takes Arthur in. Depending on how close they make Lyle and Dutch, it would make Dutch’s betrayal of Arthur hit even more since he would also be betraying Lyle also. To those who say why Arthur never mentioned Dutch knowing Lyle it’s because Dutch never told Arthur. It’s not out of character for Dutch to keep a secret.
I know I already said this before, will you be interested on making a video on the 3rd meteorite. That no one found yet, Rockstar noted that there is some spots on the map on where no one explored yet. You all make good Red Dead videos, I think you can make an interesting one
This is my personal favorite theory for RDR2. We’d get a game set while the wild west was still crazy, we’d get a unique story that still ties and shows how things repeat themselves. We’d see the rise, decline and ultimate fall of the van der linde gang. The only thing is they might need to do a time skip from epilogue 1 to 2 so the player wont have to play as a literal child
I have a theory that arthur and dutch met at the same age ig and shared a similar story and then dutch made arthur his new family member and then they shared their story with other people who eventually became their friends and then lead to the gang.
what if: Red Dead Redemption 3 3 stories Part 1: Lyle Morgan Part 2: Arthur Morgan's early days with the Van der Linde gang up until they reach Colter after the failed robbery Part 3: Jack Marston
Any Red Dead 3 would need to include Red Harlow. Maybe Lyle Morgan ran with Harlow and Uncle in the 1860's, before he met Arthur's mother. This would really bring the story full circle. Just an idea.
Kieran lost his parents too and suffered abuse by others but didn't let it make him mean. He stayed a soft boi and unfortunately that's what got him killed.
I the the third game will be you playing as arthur morgan pre blackwater than blackwater than we can also see what Dutch did by like a dynamic camera would show Dutch than after he kills the lady you see the gang run and you play the blackwater event than it ends or maybe you play as Kenny or Lenny whoever died during the mission and witness it than die than you play as arthur but you play as him in between chapter 2 and 1
Rdr3 should be 3 MAIN chapters. every main chapter contains their own ''chapters''. *First Main Chapter: You start off as Lyle Morgan and i imagine the length of this main chapter would be 4-5 chapters long. *second Main Chapter* You begin as either Hosea or Dutch and after a while you meet young Arthur and you'll be able to switch between the three with the gta 5 character switch. This chapter would be the longest one, lasting much longer than rdr2 did since you have to cover 20+ years. I imagine the ''best minor chapter'' in the game would be where you play as Arthur and seek revenge for your son Isaac and Eliza. This would also be the moment where Dutch uses the famous line ''Revenge is a fools game'' after Arthur's grief and anger remained after taking revenge. There's a lot of story that rockstar ever so kindly mentioned in rdr2 in rdr2's ''Chapter 2'' *Third Main Chapter* would be marked with the entrance of Micah Bell and the last mission being the infamous blackwater massacre/blackwater ferry job. anyways, there's no way in hell rdr3 wont be a prequel to rdr2 since they introduced characters and gave them a personality who died due to prior events.. prior events being the blackwater massacre WHICH WE HAVENT SEEN
In the next game, they need to connect Revolver to Redemption and explain how some of those stories were exaggerated and that's why Revolver was so cartoonish as far as presentation. I want Red to return, so bad 🤗 Marston favors him enough, I'm js 😆 Something. Fan service man 😌
Hear me out Zonkers what if in RDR3 we play as Lyle Morgan and you can switch characters between Lyle, Arthur, and Arthur’s mother. But then when Arthur’s mom dies we only play as Lyle and Arthur but then When Lyle dies we play as Arthur in a epilogue that is way longer then we play as Dutch, Arthur, John, and Hosea. Then we play thru that very long epilogue that we play as the gang grows then it leads into the last mission of the game the blackwater massacre. So anyways wanna do a Collab about this Zonkers
story time! one day, lyle morgan met a woman named beatrice, they loved each other very much. but one day, a child was born. lyle was so mad at this he drank to cope, wishing the child was never born, and annoying the mother about it to. he was so irretated at the mother for the birth, when she became sick he never even bothered to help. stuck at the bottom of the bottle and continuing a life of crime, the mother passed leaving a sad child and a whiskey bent father. the father was very mad at this point. abusing arthur, blaming him for beatrice's death and hating him ever since. leading to the derogatory words in arthurs journal. following the events, lyle was tried and found guilty of larceny, ending in a hanging. following lyle's example, arthur turned to a life of crime, running with dutch van der linde. later, arthurs attachment to family left him caring for the gang members. dutch not having that sense, instead aided micah in the end, due to him sharing the same ideologies. that is story time about the storyline of rdr2 served fresh by a 10yr old. enjoy
red dead revolver is red dead revolver, red dead redemption is red dead redemption, red dead redemption 2 is red dead redemption 2 because it’s the second red dead redemption game
For some reason, I don't think he was abused.I think he was just neglected. I mean, he could have been abused, but for some reason, I just don't think he was.
Arthur has a lot of self-hatred over who he is for his crimes, so I feel he wears his dad’s hat as personal reinforcement that he’s no different from his father.
