Reason Thomas changed after Season 2 in the TVS was cause he matured the whole fandom has agreed on this but i do like this theory *as* a theory but the canon where he just matured seems to fit more
I'd also like to mention the possibility of the story Thomas Comes to Breakfast could play a major role in changing Thomas' personality in the Railway Series and TVS. We could say Topham replaced the original Thomas with a different Thomas (in The Railway Series case, Awdry changed his design with a flat running board) and he gets into arguments with Percy on his first few days but soon gets over it overtime. In the TVS, it would be the time between Season 2 and 3 that changes his personality, while in the Railway Series, it takes quite a longer time for him and Percy to get along, as its timelime is different.
This is quite the interesting theory that Stories of Sodor is part of a multiverse and that The Standing Stones and Path of The Dead is all connected to one another. It does makes things a lot of sense though I do think with how you’ve explained it all, it definitely sounds like a conspiracy. A fun conspiracy though. The only thing I don’t fully agree on is that Mr. Star and Brian are from an alternate universe. That’s only because I’ve asked Victor about them and I had received information that, starting with Mr Star aka Godred. Mr Star is a time traveler who settle down on occasion. He found out about the Standing Stones a long while after Jack Bailey did and was more focused on travelling than being a king, which led to a rebellion in his time period. His death was retconned to say that he saw his future and he never got on James’ train, even though Victor did show that so there’s a loophole. And then with Brian, Victor mentioned that he did in fact die during the Blitz. He mentioned that his experience was similar to Station Master Jeffries. Since there is also an after life in universe (hence the scene where Alfred and Geoffrey makes amends and he says that the W&S trio says their hello), we can say that Brian was simply revived via The Path of The Dead, which is why there is a gap in his memory. That’s from my information I have from him directly. But don’t let it discredit from your theory. It still makes a lot of sense and I love the idea that there’s multiple versions of Jack Bailey. This is a wonderful theory video.
I could never think that stories of sodor would get This deep in lore its kinda funny tbh cause you never would know a series like it would turn up like this
No You Can't Sodor shorts are just funny skits that don't have any logic like a Zombie apocalypse on the island. Now try making sense of that in a universe that has logic obeys real safety and regulations on railways and treats crashes serious do you see how these shorts can't be used in a theory also was the scream needed it got someone kicked out of a restaurant ALSO Thomas comes to breakfast exists and Thomas got the flat running bored so NO there can't be another Thomas just because of That AND one line can't confirm EVERYTHING like HOW the f$!k can that a joke of a line just confirmed 100% EVERYTHING so this theory is 100% bull s$?t
Also Thomas has half his face. Half a face. The Half Engine... ...If Thomas was to come back, he'd probably be another Sidney. He's missing half his face, after all.
I still remember when Victor commented on your "Thomas isn't dead" video and all he debunked was that Sodor Shorts are not canon. He said nothing about anything else. I think he's currently leaving Thomas' ultimate fate in the air. He might decide to keep him dead permanently but he set things up so he could realistically bring him back later on should he want to
I have a simple theory, notice how some of the episodes from season 3 don't have a railway series origin. Thats because Thomas is still dead and they made this up as a memorial of that little blue cocky sh**head
I’ve also thought; Peter may not actually be dead and could still come back (though it’s not 100% guaranteed). With Thomas it’s been confirmed he’ll return. Mr. Hall has been the one stating what has been happening but Sir Topham Hatt and the other engines just really know what they’re hearing so it’s possible Mr. Hall could be planning something for him. With Peter, Mr. Hall’s been aware of his situation while again Sir Topham Hatt and the engines are just hearing what they’re told where he’s reported Peter’s been “killed” and that he was “breaking down Peter’s remains” but we never see it onscreen so for all we know Mr. Hall could be storing Peter, who could’ve also gotten knocked out, somewhere and could also have plans to restore him. And much like Thomas, Peter’s face didn’t disappear and in a Sodor Answer’s video it’s said an engine is fully dead when their faces disappear so for all we know Peter might still be alive just knocked out and stored somewhere else (I know there was workmen all around him at the scrapyards but being Trainz we can’t tell if they were taking him apart and could’ve just been adjusting things on him). In Geoffrey’s case we never saw the process of him being dismantled either but we saw it was just his tender left and as Neil was reporting what happened he most likely was legitimately cut up offscreen. With Alfred Colin Lily Adam Andreas and Mickey it's obvious they're dead and there's not coming back as they were just straight up destroyed or had black water put in them.
@@REALFeltysCoinsAndTrainsBut again we didn’t see him fully dismantled, it was just claimed by Robert Hall but just because it was said doesn’t mean we know it happened. And plus that’s just a theory, a train theory (I forgot who came up with that).
Personally, I think there’s going to be two timelines, in the start of SCP’s of sodor, Edward says you can take these stories as true or false, I think it’s BOTH, you can collect the pieces and get the timeline with magic and what not, and the one where you just take the weird things as what’s said it is, universe and multiverse timelines
Yes, however Edward mentions the whole "Historical Inconsistencies" Part and that's when it hit me. These Inconsistencies add up to something, and they've been building up ever since then.
There is an exception to the twin thing. Peter and the other black five were both killed. What I mean by the black five being dead is that in the Johnny Cuba scps of sodor episode, the black five gets pushed off a bridge and dies in a river due to rapid temp change. And Peter was shot dead. Soooo yeah.
Yeah I don’t think Thomas wouldn’t get revived because his already dead and I think that they might replace Thomas with a Jinty like the one with saw in the intro of s5 stories of sodor plus I think Thomas might fade away at the end of the intro
Or option 2 theory is that after thomas im season 5 of the stories of sodor Thomas is dead but not his soul maybe that the ghost of Thomas reconstruction himself into another tank engine a different basis I think in season 6 or 7 of the stories of sodor but let’s just wait and see
I still believe that Thomas is still alive in the stories of sodor but who knows maybe he’s gone forever or maybe he’s still alive we’ll just have to wait and see in season six or maybe even in season seven
There is only ONE Henry. But did Henry in this universe have two bodies? Maybe. Also, everything else feels like you've gone batshit insane. Theories lead to Conspiracies, Conspiracies lead to Insanity. I mean, come on. Another Henry, Brain & Arthur came from another universe and a Thomas is yet to enter our universe.
@TobyOliverHenryFan The evidence was literally shown in Rescued, I'm kinda bewildered that I even have to say this, but there are technically Two Henry's within Stroies of Sodor. The shell is literal proof, also I only used this as an example of the parallels, one being alive and one being dead. This doesn't mean that there are two sentient Henry's, just two Body's. I also used the Rev's Book to show that this is a thing in the main RWS timeline that Victor Pulled, thus supporting the twin concept. Also how on Earth could this even be debunked when it literally is shown to be the case in the SCP's Of Sodor? How do you explain the Nartwin wiping out everything in a single timeline? Simple. You can't.
I think you might be slightly off. Because there is an afterlife in the series and I think what happens is the body just rematerialized and the soul comes with it. With their memory intact which is why geoffreys is confused when he does. Why Brian doesn't have his memory is probably just the scp foundation giving him amnestics after he came back.
Thomas’s dead face looks too much like Thomas’s mutation in Sodor Fallout. The episode is titled Fallout’. Try something from that deadass AU and see what you could find from there.
Sodor Fallout has no value in my eyes when it comes to SOS. Also, no, the face does not look the same as in Sodor Fallout, to compare the two is laughable.
The only thing I'm wondering is if Flying Scotsman will be going to America Hol up wait a min Thomas could have been killed during the war but at the same time a man entered the tunnel of death in Culdees Mountain and thomas was automatically brought back to life but was off the rails and thought he got knocked out and the wreckage he sees he thought and the others was a german DB80 but IT WAS HID OLD BODY that is my theory its the same thing that happen to the W&S brake van cant remember the name maybe one day we will se micky back
that and I can easily be proven wrong if someone answers me this is the scps of sodor canon to stories of sodor,I saw it in the same light as the sodor shorts as just fictional stories Edward told
there aren´t two Henrys, it´s just how Awdry referred to Henry´s old and new shape respectively you just have to use a common misinterpretation to justify Thomas´ return in a theory that makes no sense
Also I hate when people forget that scps of Sodor is not officially canon. We don’t know if anyone of the five episodes in that mini series is canon or not.
This theory is so dark like holy loligaggers if this isn’t dark and and brain destroying I don’t know what is this is so bonkers like…. I have no words no literally I don’t know what to say surely you’re done with these dark theories? Right?
Actually about when you talk about about the two Henry’s is probably false because in Sodor Answers Henry stated that He’s the only one with his twin brother so ur wrong but your theory is a bit worng
Two Henry's are implied to exist within Victor's Universe, but not directly, the only part that matters isn't even that they're two Henry's, but rather how the scrap engine looks like Henry.
Schrödinger's Thomas toy! Britt Allcroft comes up with her own ideas. That's how. Also, I think, maybe Thomas is the Schrödinger's not-an-E2-tank-engine that is both dead and alive?
