Thirdstory - Over (When We Said Goodbye) 

i’m so sad they aren’t a group anymore😢they were so underrated

what really makes their sound is the fact that they move together...intonation, rises and falls, pronunciations, volume...just everything they do is together and it lends such a cool sound that's so unpredictable. feels like an ocean's tide pushing and pulling

This song seems to find me again exactly when I need it. A hauntingly beautiful gem. Sad that it is so underrated.

My skin is clear , my grades are up , my weave is snatched

I was so obsessed with this song when it came out and it's utterly timeless. I hope they get back together at some point, their voices are so perfect together, and for them to hiatus so early is devastating to me.

I just MISS them man.

Still hits hard even after all these years 😭❤

That's what fresh air feels like

the acoustics in that location is unreal . beautiful arrangement with incredible voices . thank you for sharing your gift with us .

It's 2023, and I still love these 3. Much love. So much love 🇰🇪

I often come back and listen to all of the thirdstory covers, they just never get old.

Miss these harmonies

It blows my mind that while the lyrics don’t apply to my life, their harmonies are so powerful that I still have tears in my eyes because I can feel the emotion

Ben.....Elliot....Rich....guys.....y’all didn’t have to kill us like that 😩😭

Time heals, I've been told before Been Doing well Three years is enough to forget The love we felt But you called out of the blue And I'm pulled right back to you I forgot what you do to me How I wanted you desperately I've been fine, I haven't had you on my mind Thought it was over when we said goodbye Mouth dry All these butterflies Need to be strong Hands tied, do I cut you off Or Just play along But you called out of the blue And I'm pulled right back to you Why you keep me falling in love I forgot what you do to me How I wanted you desperately I've been fine, I haven't had you on my mind Thought it was over when we said goodbye Strugglin' to find a little peace of mind Don't you act like you had no idea You know full well how I far I fell Don't fool me Don't remind me I wanted you desperately I've been fine, I haven't had you on my mind Thought it was over when we said goodbye Thought it was over when we said goodbye Thought it was over when we said goodbye

This has to be one of my favorite videos of all time.... can't tell you how many times I've come back to this over the years...

the video can't even capture half of what their voices sound like in real life. it must have been a true blessing to be in that space!!

How is not a single soul mentioning that they split up? I would start crying if I wasn’t already crying from the beauty of this song

What did we do to deserve this flawlessness in our lives???

Still hurts me to this day that they parted ways #thirdstory .. I keep on coming back..

Anyone else notice the cough/sneeze in the background at 3:34? Someone must have caught a cold from how sick these boys were

Chills all over. I miss them. Come back.

Thirdstory was a group which I sadly discovered very late in their group’s career. A year after my friend showed them to me, they disbanded and went their separate ways. I listen to them to this day.. their own music as well as their covers are all timeless.

2:27 that falsetto tho...i cry

This sounded like how clean sheets on your bed feel. Warm and comforting.

I don't need medication when I can listen to this every day.

I’ve never clicked so quickly! This is absolutely gorgeous

Sigh. At least I got to see them live at one of their only london shows. I legit had tears in my eyes. I miss them lol

So sad that they aren't together as a group anymore :(

PLEASE RELEASE THIS ACOUSTIC VERSION ON SPOTIFY I BEG YOU

I wish this acoustic version had been on the album😭 Still love it but this just hits different🥺

0:48 just blown away at this part. so much emotion packed into Ben's voice there

Can’t believe they are no longer together

I will never get over this.

100% better than the album version. Love this so much

hits harder when the lyrics apply to your situation. the melodies and acoustic snatched my edges. thank you fellas for this gift

Maaaaan the world needed this tbh. I'm a Thirdstory stan at this point tbh.

And that's the beauty of being vulnerable together, expressing the heartache and turning it into art!

It's 2021 and I'm still obsessed with this song

please for the love of god never take this down

The Harmony 😩🙌🔥

2:38 when Rich starts singing and the guitar change...oh mylanta. I cannot even. #likebuttah

Please tell me this will be available on iTunes/Spotify!!

That “Don’t remind me” though😭😭😭

DROP THAT ALBUM!!!!

OH MY GOD SOMETHING NEW

THEE BEST HARMONIC VOICES ON THE PLANET 🌎🎶💯🔥🙌🏾

My 1st time listening to this group and my my my going thru every song I love yall voice so touching to the soul idk wya or wyd please come back to the world as a group 😩 ❤

It just kept on getting better. Even though the lyrics almost make me feel like crying this is absolutely amazing ✨✨✨😭🥺

Still one of the most greatest songs out there

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW. I LOVE THIS. SAAAAANGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG.

How am I only finding out about this NOW.. wtf. So Beautiful

very rarely do i find amazing male vocalists. so talented

The guitar. This never gets old

This is one of the most gorgeous pieces of music I've ever heard...

Shut up and take my money.

Miss you guys.

This song is realllllllly good on the new album, but there is just something so heartfelt and incredibly special about this version.

I JUST DISCOVERED THIS BAND. WHERE HAVE THEY BEEN ALL MY LIFE OMGHAKSND I'M IN LOVE ❤

Where have I been that I have never heard this before? My life.... my soul is in complete sync with this song. Absolutely beautiful.

this is easily one of the most beautiful things i've ever heard

Can I get some more. This is pure and real talent. No gimmicks n auto tune just real talent

I think I have single handedly contributed half of this videos view count. I have to listen to this at least 20 times a day it's sensational and I can't get enough

put this on Spotify pleasee. MISS YOU GUYSSS

THIS IS EVERYTHING

I always find myself going back to this song, no matter my mood. If I'm happy? Play it, sad? Play it, its just THAT song in my life right now. And I'm totally okay with that.

idk how many times I watch this in a day I have written a poetry cover to it and everything

Everything about this is so professional, these guys never stop impressing me!!!! Like what heckk

The sheer vocal talent of these singers is amazing in itself...then add beautiful lyrics, amazing acoustics, classy outfits, amazing harmonies, shall i go on lmao

0:48 his voice pierced through my soul 😢

They were so amazing!!!

It’s still on repeat today! 💯🔥

BEAUTIFUL!!!! FINALLY ANOTHER SONG!!!!

Pls come back you have inspired so many 🥺♥️ love u.

I need this to be available on Spotify so I can put it on repeat and be in my feels

COME THRU HARMONIES

been a huge fan the last 2 years and I'm SO READY for new stuff

Back for more because this was too good.

This song is so heartwrenching lyrically, yet so warm and soulful sonically. It's perfect for fall. Thanks for sharing guys!

Actual angels are singing to us

This song is PURE PERFECTION!!! 🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️Every rift, run, harmony is SICKENING!!!!😭😭😭😭

How does this not a billion views?!?! Just breath taking. Honestly. Those harmonies. I'm melting.

I literally can't get enough of this song

I always come back to this song

someone please do a ultimate guitar tab for this please please please

Idk how y’all never fail to make the most magical harmonies

When living in your feelings is wholly acceptable 🖤👌🏽

This is my 7th time playing this vid. Sooooo Goooood!

i just found this song this week, and i found out today that y’all broke up a few months ago🥺😪🤧 anyways, y’all are so talented, have such amazing vocal and lyrical abilities, and your melodies and harmonies oh my- i wish i could’ve seen you perform live !!! good luck with all your individual endeavors❤️❤️❤️

I've been waiting my whole life for this !!!

I️ have had this on repeat since I’ve discovered it today. I️ just need it to rain as this plays and the fire place to burn and I’ll literally be in heaven

I need a gospel album, Christmas album and world tour!

I haven’t listened to this in over a year and wow 🥺🥺 I remember it being amazing but... WOWWW GUYS

That ”but you called out of the blue and I’m pulled right back to you” solo part just killed me.. it just hit me like a truck

My ears... haven't been blessed like this in a while.

still just keeps you warm on the inside

hell yeah, i love this song, still, after years

A fitting location for the voices of angels...

sighhh their voices just make me close my eyes and listen to beauty. if beauty was a sound. it would be them

FINALLY. I AM SO HAPPY! THIS IS BEAUTIFUL!